News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by vhiremath4 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:39AM (#32746768)
If my tax dollars go anywhere, I would rather encourage students study multiple high-demand majors than provide loan forgiveness to societally unproductive majors (gender studies, literature, etc.). I don’t see why we should use tax money to prop up anything other than proven productive fields of study. Society should get something back, and I’d rather get back a smart physics/econ double major.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by hackerlight on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:08AM (#32747421)
> societally unproductive majors (gender studies, literature, etc.). I don’t see why we should use tax money to prop up anything other than proven productive fields of study.

Some majors are actually unproductive and a waste of both the student's and taxpayer's money, and should not be subsidized.

But many humanities that often get binned this way are actually civically productive, and they're only economically unproductive because of significant market failure. The benefits to society aren't priced properly. Such majors, and that is the social sciences, should arguably be subsidized by the government, because they are technically public goods.

What the last few years has taught us is how much damage an electorate can do who isn't educated. If they don't understand anything about economic systems, political systems, sociology, history, psychology, then their mind can be taken over too easily by propaganda, which can have catastrophic consequences, all the way up to the death of democracy.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by sabas123 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:53AM (#32746856)
Especially when it comes to fundamental research a lot of work is "useless" until it isn't. This idea of picking winners before people even start at a college is not the way to go.

Many people would argue that linguistics is one of those useless studies compared to comp sci, but it shares deep connections to research in logic and by extension type theory (see handbook for logic and languages)

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by jimbob45 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:15AM (#32747481)
Gender Studies and Literature will never not be useless professionally. That said, there is immense value in having some number of scholars study those fields in great detail and we would suffer as a species if we let our knowledge in those fields rot.

Would it perhaps be prudent to cap the number of participants in those departments to match the number of real-world vacancies available?

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by Der_Einzige on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:43AM (#32747718)
"Every time I fire a linguist, the performance of the speech recognizer goes up"

-https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Jelinek

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by visarga on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:26AM (#32747113)
You're right, the search space is deceptive and going directly towards the goal might lead to a dead end. Only in hindsight we can tell which stepping stones were essential. Immediate results are the best, but in the meantime we need to focus on novelty and interestingness.

A great video about open-endedness (warning - very long) with Kenneth Stanley, author of the book "Why Greatness Cannot be Planned"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhYGXYeMq_E&t=350s

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by IG_Semmelweiss on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:02AM (#32746915)
what I understood parent to be saying is that the picked winners were picked by students, not some central arbiter of what should be studied.

unless youn disagree with the laws of supply and demand, it seems the market consensus at this moment is that compsci majors are far more useful than any fundamental research (which still remains undefined).

Even if the market was wrong and fundamental research could somehow be valuable, why would you not trust the primary beneficiaries oj making that decision, vs some bureaucrat that has no stake in the outcome?

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by mint2 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @11:07AM (#32751624)
Law of supply and demand has no direct relevance on what benefits society as a whole
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by trs8080 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:54AM (#32746865)
People are really out here thinking that arts and critical theory haven't advanced human civilization... and that science and technology exist in a cultural vacuum.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by nightski on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:16AM (#32747031)
Most people aren't going to college for academic research, which is a big part of the problem. They are going for careers unfortunately.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by Balgair on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @09:59AM (#32750737)
In California it's a bit different.

According to 'The Master Plan', UCs are designed for research and post-grad work and some professional careers. Only the UCs give out PhDs (with a few exceptions). CSUs are designed for professional and teacher education and cannot give out PhDs (with a few exceptions). So, as an undergrad thinking of grad school, a UC is a better place to go to as they have the grad labs and classes on campus, while the CSUs mostly do not. Your chances of getting into grad school are a bit higher.

Berkeley, being a UC, is more geared toward research than Chico, a CSU. I mean, Cal even has a nobel prize parking lot.

https://www.ucop.edu/institutional-research-academic-plannin...

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by greatpostman on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:22AM (#32747079)
Middle iq people have no business taking on huge debt to study critical theory
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by rafram on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @08:30AM (#32749715)
> Middle iq people

What a sad way to categorize people.

[dead]
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by wwweston on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:54AM (#32747329)
I'd like to make sure I understand your position here.

You seem to be saying there is a body of ideas that has gained such a widespread foothold that they hold a significant place in the culture such that they can unfavorably affect social dynamics at civilization-wide levels.

If this is true, it would imply that we should be carefully -- some might even say critically -- be examining civilization at all levels from ideas (and their implications and consequences) through practices so we can understand those dynamics and perhaps help civilizations be more healthy.

Does that sound about right?

Because it also sounds like some kind of critical theory...

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by tsol on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:08AM (#32749036)
Your argument appears to be circular. He said he believes critical theory to have done social harm. You observe that he says there are ideas present in society that cause social harm. Then you say this means we need critical theory to examine such damage(as OP said is the result of critical theory).
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by wwweston on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:52PM (#32753817)
That's actually not what I said, unless any socially critical examination does in fact meet the definition of "critical theory"...

And in fact, no one here knows what the commentor means by that phrase, much less how it's ostensibly done damage, which would be necessary in order to change their mind as invited.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by badpun on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:12AM (#32749069)
> Because it also sounds like some kind of critical theory...

What's the "theory" exactly? It just sounds like common sense.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by saagarjha on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:47AM (#32747287)
Are we really going to rehash the same, tired argument that only STEM majors are useful to society? Having the narrow view of social benefits being solely centered around money is incredibly short-sighted, and I’m not even sure I want to respond to physics/Econ majors being “smart”.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by a4a4a4a4 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:31AM (#32748451)
> Are we really going to rehash the same, tired argument that only STEM majors are useful to society?

It seems so, since it's hard for people to admit that an average STEM graduate is much more useful than an average humanities graduate. It's not that the humanities aren't useful, they are, but to succeed and actually have an impact on society, you need to be one of the best humanities graduates.

We don't need more psych bachelors grads who took on 10-20x their future annual income in student loans, only to file paperwork in an office for the rest of their lives. There are much better ways for them and for society to spend that money than subsidizing/bailing them out.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by gnz11 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:38AM (#32748868)
> It's not that the humanities aren't useful, they are, but to succeed and actually have an impact on society, you need to be one of the best humanities graduates.

Your average STEM grad is not having the impact on society like what you describe here.

We also don’t need more CS bachelor grads churning out CRUD apps for adtech companies.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by mint2 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @11:12AM (#32751710)
Or “democratizing” finance with coin base or “democratizing” housing via REITs
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by amanaplanacanal on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:49AM (#32748925)
Perhaps if we were better at funding mental health in the US all those psych degrees might turn out to be useful.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by a4a4a4a4 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:18PM (#32753404)
It doesn’t really matter because most of those psych grads aren’t and would never be capable of administering mental healthcare beyond what any of us can already find on Google.
[dead]
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by saagarjha on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:15AM (#32747474)
Dumb, or courageous? Do you not benefit from the people around you who studied liberal arts? Who is going to make the Netflix shows you watch after you get home from work after spending 8 hours slinging JSON around and making bank? No, seriously, these people are going into fields that we benefit from and yet refuse to pay for, and if they didn’t our society would be worse off. Why do you consider this a dumb decision rather than a sacrifice they shouldn’t have to make?
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by nequo on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:30AM (#32747593)
I was going to post something similar but parent got flagged and I couldn't.

Gender studies is important. I have to think about non-gender issues for a living and this means that I don't have the time to think about the thousand ways in which women are disadvantaged in society.[1] But gender studies majors do, and I am better off for reading the arguments written or summarized by them than not learning about many of these issues at all.

[1] And possibly men too. Not gender studies but an example: https://home.uchicago.edu/~bursztyn/Misperceived_Norms_2020_...

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by cultofmetatron on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:54AM (#32747801)
I doubt the people making shows for netflix are not being paid well. Even the ones pouring out absolute junk lately are being paid bank. a Better example would be english teachers who absolutely are being underpaid while providing value to society.

gender studies is still bullshit. I took a few mandated classes back in university. 90% of getting an A is just knowing what the teacher wants to hear. I have a hard time believing any of them can understand critical thinking giving how much of their doing well in that major is just going with groupthink.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by astrange on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:03AM (#32746930)
This is already happening; all humanities majors except for philosophy are collapsing in the US.

https://twitter.com/benmschmidt/status/1562212497272279041

(Weird that psychology is growing, all the psych degree people I know work in HR and I don't think that's what they dreamed of.)

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by topkai22 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:37AM (#32747212)
Bachelor level psych degrees also pay worse than most humanities.

https://www.hamiltonproject.org/charts/interactive_embed/car...

My personal take is that humanities departments should be aggressively courting 2nd majors (somewhat egotistical, I was a double major). As much as we might want to believe that the purpose of education is to give person a fuller life, increased earnings potential is an undeniable part of there reason people go to university. Selling a line like “the CS department will teach you how to make money. We’ll help you live the rest of your life” or “engineering got me in on the ground floor. Clarity of thought and speech got me to the top floor” seems like it could open up more demand than trying to go it alone.

My N of one experience suggests it might be effective. I thought I was just getting a vanity politics degree on top of my CS degree because I liked it. After 10 years in career I think I refer to lessons and skills learned in those humanities classes as much as the ones in my CS classes.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:25AM (#32747106)
Psych is an "easy A" batchelors program for people who don't know what they want to study. It's a useless degree without moving on to the severely placement limited graduate programs.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by dagw on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:48AM (#32748580)
all the psych degree people I know work in HR

I would figure that the whole point of getting a psychology degree (as opposed to taking some psychology courses as part of your main degree) is to work as a psychologist? Why are all these people failing to get their psychologist qualifications?

Where I live, I've never met or heard of anyone who went for a psychology degree without the intention of becoming a psychologist. Sure, not everybody makes it to the end, and few end up doing research instead, but the whole goal of the degree is to produce qualified psychologists.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by wheelinsupial on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:27PM (#32753501)
Where I live, there just aren't enough spots in psychologist training programs. There are 8 spots for clinical psychology grad programs where I graduated from with 1200-1300 psych undergrads. Psych enrollment increased by 20% in the last 5 years and the clinical psych program's training capacity stayed flat. Of those 8 spots, between 1 and 6 spots are filled by people from outside of the province including international students.

(I'm oversimplifying a little. There are 6 accredited programs, but there are 10 undergrad universities that produce psych majors, so the numbers probably look worse overall.)

You're right that the goal is to become a qualified psychologist, but the training pipeline doesn't match that goal. Crudely, there are training spots for less than 1% of psych undergrads (maybe 2% if you include research psychologists). There are alternative programs for counseling, but it's not the same license. The cost of these counseling programs is also astronomical for Canada. I know people who went that route and have $150k loans to pay back. If you're competitive enough to get into one of the clinical programs, they are funded (with students given stipends ranging from $30-$40k/year), but even if they aren't tuition is under $7k/year.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by christkv on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:14AM (#32749085)
Because in some countries there are different branches of psychology studies. Clinical psychology that will earn you a license to practice and psychology which is really just I’m interested in psychology.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by wwweston on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:46AM (#32747272)
I have a math undergrad. I imagine someone who values physics & econ wouldn't think a math degree is "societally unproductive", but the decided majority of people I meet including other college graduates have absolutely no idea what I studied/learned in the course of doing that.

What reason do you have to believe that you aren't doing the same thing with the majors you're judging societally unproductive?

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by trentgreene on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:50AM (#32746837)
The strange thing is I as a SWE interviewer generally find an engineering degree to not be indicative of engineering talent, over say, a masters in underwater basket weaving. I’m not sure dumping money into stem education does anything, or if any field of study is “proven productive.”
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by jetru on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:53AM (#32746858)
Dumping money in STEM probably does do something, we're all just biased over the CS portion of things - which yea, is a mess.

But for subjects like Civil, Electrical, sciences like Physics, Biology, I suspect the story is quite different.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by trentgreene on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:09AM (#32746978)
Re: the “hard” stems, maybe? They have a clearer function as a certificate pipeline, but in terms of prep I find it difficult to quantify. There’s also limited positions at the end of this pipeline (medicines a killer example, academia, research). Are we creating better candidates or more positions with stem programs? Or just more candidates who 1) don’t find positions or 2) don’t end up with relevant skills for the roles they take.

(Incidentally, I think CS is a very good place to invest, precisely because there’s a lot of demand, start up cost for self employment is low, and applicability is super broad)

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by Melting_Harps on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:57AM (#32746893)
> But for subjects like Civil, Electrical, sciences like Physics, Biology, I suspect the story is quite different.

I can speak to Biology; most undergrads are left with little opportunity as most roles require a graduate degree to do anything meaningful when the economy is actually favorable, and often seek roles outside of their field when it's not. As a undergrad that was lucky enough to enter the field in the wake of the GFC long enough to just pay off my student debt I've met so many biologists/biochemists who either couldn't find anything in their field, or simply gave up trying and sought the highest paid and somewhat stable role they could get 'that required a degree.' It's quite clear that the system has failed, and the system is designed to onboard more STEM grads as it sounds as their are ever-growing holders of degrees chasing so n amount of open roles.

Tech in unique in that it is one of those few Industries where the barrier of entry is rather low, but the attrition and competence level vets for viable candidates almost entirely on it's own--the gatekeeping interview process is still an unnecessary hurdle.

Personally, for all the controversy Eric Weinstein has made directly and indirectly of his own actions, the concept of Embedded Growth Obligations was incredibly well researched and consistent with what we have seen as outlined since 2005 and then solidified itself in the financial collapse of 2008 [0]:

> Embedded Growth Obligations are the way in which institutions plan their future predicated on legacies of growth. And since the period between the end of World War II in 1945 and the early 70s had such an unusually beautiful growth regime, many of our institutions became predicated upon low-variance technology-led, stable, broadly distributed growth. Now, this is a world we have not seen in an organic way since the early 1970s, and yet, because it was embedded in our institutions, what we have is a world in which the expectation is still present in the form of an embedded growth obligation. That is, the pension plans, the corporate ladders, are all still built very much around a world that has long since vanished.

We have effectively become a Growth Cargo Cult. That is, once upon a time, planes used to land in the Pacific, let's say, during World War II, and Indigenous people looked at the air strips and the behavior of the air traffic controllers, and they've been mimicking those behaviors in the years since as ritual, but the planes no longer land. Well, in large measure, our institutions are built for a world in which growth doesn't happen in the same way anymore.

0: https://theportal.wiki/wiki/Embedded_Growth_Obligations

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by resist_futility on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:38AM (#32747680)
The only problem that's cropped up is the decline of the education system due to continued undervaluing of our countries bedrock of teachers. With an increase of business majors during a continuing recession.

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/05/09/310114739/what...

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by standyro on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:49AM (#32746829)
Regardless of your feelings about tax dollars, I hate to break it to you, but the UC system hasn’t being subsidized by California in decades. Something like 15-20% comes from the state.

Maybe that’s part of the problem.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by topkai22 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:09AM (#32746976)
From the UC system budget doc: student tuition and fees are 39% of “core budget”, state general funds are 46%.

https://www.ucop.edu/operating-budget/_files/rbudget/2022-23...

The overall budget gets weird with medical centers and something called “Sales and Support”, but in any case California tax payers put in more money then students. I don’t think that’s a problem, but it’s definitely subsidized.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by marcushill on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:54AM (#32746862)
15-20% of what comes from the state? If you are talking about funding, wouldn't that count as the state subsidizing it?
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by enumjorge on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:05AM (#32746943)
We do get something back. Having economically unstable individuals and families affects us all even if indirectly.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by cma on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:34AM (#32747628)
> physics/econ double major

Who probably proceeds to go into zero or negative-sum trading, or negative sum ad targeting intelligence.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by dc-programmer on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @09:29AM (#32750304)
I think it’s more of a matching problem. There are lots of students who get nothing out of CS classes. Ideally we would match the available slots with the students with the highest analytical aptitude.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by pevey on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:42AM (#32746787)
Agreed. This is the worst possible way to address whatever problem the university thinks they have.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by systemvoltage on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:18AM (#32747046)
I want none of this. I want a whole bunch of apprenticeships and tradesmen from our colleges. Technicians and specialists. Subject matter experts. Manufacturing engineers.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by fmajid on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:25AM (#32748028)
Psychology is massively popular but with too many graduates for available jobs. Same with Law.