News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by astrange on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:03AM (#32746930)
This is already happening; all humanities majors except for philosophy are collapsing in the US.

https://twitter.com/benmschmidt/status/1562212497272279041

(Weird that psychology is growing, all the psych degree people I know work in HR and I don't think that's what they dreamed of.)

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by topkai22 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:37AM (#32747212)
Bachelor level psych degrees also pay worse than most humanities.

https://www.hamiltonproject.org/charts/interactive_embed/car...

My personal take is that humanities departments should be aggressively courting 2nd majors (somewhat egotistical, I was a double major). As much as we might want to believe that the purpose of education is to give person a fuller life, increased earnings potential is an undeniable part of there reason people go to university. Selling a line like “the CS department will teach you how to make money. We’ll help you live the rest of your life” or “engineering got me in on the ground floor. Clarity of thought and speech got me to the top floor” seems like it could open up more demand than trying to go it alone.

My N of one experience suggests it might be effective. I thought I was just getting a vanity politics degree on top of my CS degree because I liked it. After 10 years in career I think I refer to lessons and skills learned in those humanities classes as much as the ones in my CS classes.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:25AM (#32747106)
Psych is an "easy A" batchelors program for people who don't know what they want to study. It's a useless degree without moving on to the severely placement limited graduate programs.
Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by dagw on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:48AM (#32748580)
all the psych degree people I know work in HR

I would figure that the whole point of getting a psychology degree (as opposed to taking some psychology courses as part of your main degree) is to work as a psychologist? Why are all these people failing to get their psychologist qualifications?

Where I live, I've never met or heard of anyone who went for a psychology degree without the intention of becoming a psychologist. Sure, not everybody makes it to the end, and few end up doing research instead, but the whole goal of the degree is to produce qualified psychologists.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by wheelinsupial on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:27PM (#32753501)
Where I live, there just aren't enough spots in psychologist training programs. There are 8 spots for clinical psychology grad programs where I graduated from with 1200-1300 psych undergrads. Psych enrollment increased by 20% in the last 5 years and the clinical psych program's training capacity stayed flat. Of those 8 spots, between 1 and 6 spots are filled by people from outside of the province including international students.

(I'm oversimplifying a little. There are 6 accredited programs, but there are 10 undergrad universities that produce psych majors, so the numbers probably look worse overall.)

You're right that the goal is to become a qualified psychologist, but the training pipeline doesn't match that goal. Crudely, there are training spots for less than 1% of psych undergrads (maybe 2% if you include research psychologists). There are alternative programs for counseling, but it's not the same license. The cost of these counseling programs is also astronomical for Canada. I know people who went that route and have $150k loans to pay back. If you're competitive enough to get into one of the clinical programs, they are funded (with students given stipends ranging from $30-$40k/year), but even if they aren't tuition is under $7k/year.

Re:Campus College of Letters and Science plans to limit high... by christkv on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:14AM (#32749085)
Because in some countries there are different branches of psychology studies. Clinical psychology that will earn you a license to practice and psychology which is really just I’m interested in psychology.