News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mdasen on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:20PM (#32243437)
To hit 250TB in a month, the person would need to do 809Mbps (assuming a 30 day month). I personally would assume that "unlimited 1Gbps" wouldn't include using 80% of the link's capacity, but I also agree that stated limits are better.

That would be $16,691 worth of transfer from AWS (US East pricing for 250TB to the internet). I'm not arguing that AWS isn't overcharging, just putting up a comparison. Even at $0.01/GB, that would be $2,560.

They should probably just say 50TB with overages at $0.005/GB or something like that. They are offering 20TB on their cloud servers so 50TB on the dedicated seems reasonable and $0.005/GB for overages is less than you'll get almost anywhere else while still probably enough for Hetzner to make a profit.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by yjftsjthsd-h on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:50PM (#32243799)
> I personally would assume that "unlimited 1Gbps" wouldn't include using 80% of the link's capacity

Why ever not? If you sell someone something but only let them use less than 80% of it, that feels like fraud.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by teej on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:17PM (#32244159)
That’s not how anything in the consumer world works. If you want guaranteed volume and throughput, sign a contract for it.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by lazide on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:19PM (#32244191)
And yet, that’s not how data center bandwidth is typically sold. Weird huh?

It’s total bait and switch, and probably false advertising/fraud.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by foobiekr on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:29PM (#32244312)
A lot of colo and DC bandwidth is sold as port speed for the connection with no guarantees at all as to sustained bitrate to any other port including egress.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by romwell on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:39PM (#32244420)
Yeah, and that's better than lying about the guarantees.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by lazide on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:00PM (#32244631)
Which is very different than caps and throttles!
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by krn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:29PM (#32244320)
Exactly. In my country, an "Unlimited 4G LTE" data plan costs 12 EUR. But without any "fair usage" policy that would be simply impossible. Nobody would expect to use tens of TBs per month without ever being contacted or heavily throttled.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mort96 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:37PM (#32244397)
Why would it be a bad thing for it to be illegal to lie? Just don't call the plan "unlimited", and have clearly stated limits.

Obviously that's not as good marketing. Products usually look better if you lie about them to make them look better. But lying in marketing shouldn't be legal. And this shouldn't be controversial.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by krn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:43PM (#32244460)
> Why would it be a bad thing for it to be illegal to lie? Just don't call the plan "unlimited", and have clearly stated limits.

Maybe because the limits are not fixed and completely depend on the spending of the customer? If a customer is among the top 1% of the biggest users and – at the same time – among the top 1% of the smallest spenders, that simply raises the costs of the service for everyone else. There are only three choices here: a) get rid of the customer; b) make them pay more, or c) raise the prices of unlimited plans for everyone.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mort96 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:46PM (#32244491)
What does this have to do with anything? If the user if paying for a service, they should be getting that service. If the operator is offering a service which they can't afford to offer, that's not the user's problem.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by dale_glass on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:14PM (#32244775)
The argument is that there are no easily determinable limits.

Let's say the provider has a 100 Gpbs upstream, 1000 clients, and offers a cheap plan where you pay for 1 Gbps with no limit. The provider obviously can't provide a sustained 1 Gbps to every client 24/7.

Now, how do you honestly advertise that? Because you can give people 1 Gbps service so long not too many clients do that at the same time. And you can tolerate people downloading 24/7 so long they don't all do it at the same time.

How much you have to crack down will depend on how close to capacity you are, and what your clients are doing.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mort96 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:35PM (#32244955)
That's a cool story. It sounds like something the marketing and sales departments should probably think pretty hard about. It's not an easy problem.

But a service with a cap also isn't unlimited.

Making a pricing structure which works for the company and is easy to understand for the customer isn't easy. Nobody said it was easy. But I don't understand how you go from that, to arguing in favor of lying to the customer.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by KronisLV on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:24AM (#32247758)
> The argument is that there are no easily determinable limits.

But the fact that there is a limit at all, means that you can definitely display it somewhere.

Suppose you have two users, John and Jane, John is in the 1% of most valuable customers, Jane signed up last month. The data center has plenty of free capacity in June, but is closer to capacity in July.

Now suppose that each user has their own dashboard for resources.

  John:
    June - Your bandwidth limit is 200 TB. Please contact customer support if you need to increase it.
    July - Your bandwidth limit is 160 TB. Please contact customer support if you need to increase it.
  
  Jane:
    June - Your bandwidth limit is 40 TB. Options to increase this limit will become available after X$ in total spend.
    July - Your bandwidth limit is 30 TB. Options to increase this limit will become available after X$ in total spend.
As a matter of fact, Hetzner already has something like that under their "Limits" section:

  Limits
  Limits are set per customer and are counted across all projects that you created. If you need more resources, just send us a request, and we are happy to adjust them for you.
  Outgoing traffic to ports 25 and 465 are blocked by default on all Cloud Servers. Send a request for unblocking these ports. Please note that we generally do not answer questions regarding limit increase on the telephone.
You don't necessarily have to advertise the fact that your limits will be dependent on lots of variables and will change (though you should disclose it). What you shouldn't do is say that there are no limits, which is clearly lying. Even if the lie only becomes relevant to a very small part of the clientele who'll be affected by this, it's still lying.

Of course, that's not the world that we live in and "unlimited" offerings will be a mainstay of marketing in the industry, for the better or worse. Probably better for the org and worse for the clients. Kind of why I also hate mobile carriers being dishonest with their data plans. It's like nobody even knows what "unlimited" means.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by iam-TJ on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:50PM (#32245079)
Maybe like ADSL was originally advertised in some markets, with the contention ratio?

In your scenario, 10:1 contention ratio, "up-to" 1Gbps throughput, 1Gbps link-speed.

In the UK British Telecom originally offered 'consumer' ADSL at 50:1 and 'business' (more expensive) at 20:1 contention ratio specifically to deal with the backhaul limitations.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by stonemetal12 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:06PM (#32245188)
Probably the way they do processors, say you get N Mhz as a min that is boostable up to M Mhz.

If they advertised "you get a min of 200kbps, that could boost up to 1Gbps" that would be acceptable, as long as you actually got that 200kbps. The problem is they claim it is 1Gbps, then look at you funny if you expect 70% of what they claim.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by redeeman on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @07:12AM (#32249072)
how about saying "limit: XGB/gbit/whatever, but IF we feel like it, you might be allowed more"
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by krn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:00PM (#32244634)
A private operator can choose to stop providing any service to any customer at any time. Especially, if it finds it to be economically unsustainable for their business.

For instance, OVH has previously terminated accounts of paying customers simply because it didn't want to do any business with people from an occupied territory[1].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29680251

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mort96 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:11PM (#32244745)
But what does that have to do with anything? Why can't operators just not lie to their customers?

Just don't call the plan "unlimited". Have well-defined limits. They don't have to be hard limits, they can be a gradual speed reduction after some amount of data per month. Just don't lie. I don't understand why you think this is a difficult concept.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by krn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:13PM (#32245250)
Again, the limits are not fixed, and therefore cannot be clearly defined. If a customer is spending $5K / month on dedicated servers, Hetzner might earn enough from renting hardware to cover truly unlimited usage of bandwidth. If a customer is spending only $50 / month, that's a completely different case. Such a customer might simply be not valuable enough to keep.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by wumpus on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:11PM (#32245234)
That case possibly looks like obeying sanctions, although they have failed to explain why they think this customer is in Crimea. For example, OVH may have discovered that the Russian ISP involved was putting fake data into geoip, and if you're aware you can't just pretend you don't know.

BTW, if it was just "we don't want to do business with you any more", that depends on what your contract says. Most consumer ISP contracts allow an ISP to drop a customer for any reason without explanation.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by stonemetal12 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:59PM (#32245133)
So I buy a gallon of milk, but depending on how much I pay for the gallon of milk, I get some percentage of it?
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by kyriakos on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:22PM (#32271260)
It's not illegal because they don't cut you off but after you go above a threshold they throttle your speed instead.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by woojoo666 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:03PM (#32244658)
It's not "unlimited", its "unlimited*". There are additional constraints that are enumerated afterwards. But for the vast majority of users, it will feel like unlimited, so it's not necessary for them to read those additional constraints
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mort96 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:13PM (#32244763)
Limited shouldn't be called unlimited. That's just straightforward false advertising. But it sounds like Hertzner doesn't even have the asterisk with additional constraints.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by brandon272 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:56PM (#32245111)
The "asterisk" is the Terms and Conditions that you agree to when signing up for the service.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mort96 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:59PM (#32245139)
Can you enumerate these bandwidth usage constraints then?
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by romwell on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:38PM (#32244406)
Well that's nonsense.

Words have meanings for a reason.

The meaning of the word "unlimited" is not, in fact, "limited, but we won't tell you what the limit is — you'll get to find it out the hard way".

Whatever the terms of the "fair usage" policy are, that's what should be in the description.

Otherwise, is plain old lying and misreading — which for some reason you are OK with.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by randunel on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:37PM (#32244402)
I've got unlimited 4G/LTE/5G for €2/mo with reduced bandwidth after 55GB but still unlimited, and true unlimited for €5/mo without any bandwidth restrictions.

I'm proxying traffic through mobile proxies and expect nothing less than unlimited.

What herzer do amounts to false advertising when compared to the mobile traffic examples.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by gzer0 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:02PM (#32244654)
Where are you getting these prices?
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by kytazo on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:46PM (#32245048)
yes please share any info possible, this will help a lot
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by Handytinge on Monday August 08, 2022 @10:47PM (#32393758)
You appear to be projecting your experiences in your country as "the consumer world".

For example, Australia:

https://www.gizmodo.com.au/2022/06/spintel-acma-unlimited-si...

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by 0xy on Monday August 08, 2022 @11:01PM (#32393826)
ISPs in Australia regularly sell 'unlimited' connections that aren't unlimited, and ACMA allows it. [1]

I'm surprised my own residential grade connection hasn't been flagged, given I consume over 10TB a month.

[1] https://old.reddit.com/r/nbn/comments/hwz7l4/abb_cancels_ser...

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by KronisLV on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:13AM (#32247699)
> If you want guaranteed volume and throughput, sign a contract for it.

I think that what a lot of people have problems with, is the fact that Hetzner doesn't actually tell you what is okay and what isn't. Would using 70% of the link's capacity be okay? What about 60%? Or maybe 50% is where they draw the line?

Here's another host that I use, Time4VPS, which have more clear terms: https://www.time4vps.com/?affid=5294 (remove affid for non-affiliate link if you don't want me to get a kickback in case anyone buys the services; I also host my blog with them)

Their servers include a guaranteed amount of bandwidth, either at 100 Mbps or 1 Gbps. And should you exceed that limit, they're also clear about what will happen:

> What happens if I run out of bandwidth?

> We reduce your VPS server’s port speed 10 times until the new month starts. No worries, we won’t charge any extra fees or suspend your services.

So if I'd exceed the amount that's given to me with any of their services, my 1 Gbps link would become a 100 Mbps link, or my 100 Mbps link would become a 10 Mbps link. On a technical level, it's obviously worse than Hetzner's offering (speaking of how much data you can actually move), but the transparency is nice and I wouldn't ever have to worry about my services being suspended because they don't automatically enforce any limitations just so they'd get to claim "unlimited" in their marketing materials.

Disclaimer: I still use Hetzner personally, they're one of the more affordable platforms (pretty much the same pricing tier as Time4VPS) out there. Though it's also nice when service providers have some provisions in place to automatically introduce limits for those things that could cause problems, like the amount of bandwidth that's available to you. Or just charge you for it outright, so there are fewer unknown variables.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by worldofmatthew on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:33AM (#32246867)
Hetzner sell dedicated server with Unlimited and Guaranteed traffic at a 1Gbit port (As per the product pages).
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by encryptluks2 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:04PM (#32244673)
Imagine going to a unlimited buffet restaurant per customer and paying an extra $15 and then being told after it is capped at one plate from the salad bar.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by colejohnson66 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:28PM (#32245344)
Except buffets do do that. Not that extreme, but if you go into a one and continue to eat for multiple hours, you’ll be kicked out despite having “unlimited food”.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by hansvm on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:11AM (#32250593)
And when it goes to court they usually lose. They can ban you in the future if they want, but they sold an "all you can eat" meal and are expected to provide that meal even if you're extra hungry.

Much like the Hetzner article, there's an obvious physical cap that can't be exceeded, and they're supposedly selling up to that cap.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by Spooky23 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:39PM (#32244415)
Gigabit Ethernet usually lands around 80% fully utilized due to overheads and such. That’s not fraud.

Even in a private data center, you’d typically move a workload like that to avoid disruption to neighbors.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mhh__ on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:20PM (#32244209)
We live in the real world. You're right but that's not worth basing strategy on.

"We had a good team on paper. Unfortunately, the game was played on grass"

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by mdasen on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:02PM (#32244655)
It's hard to respond to stuff like this. I get the attitude: "I'm due what I paid for!"

There are so many ways in our society where there's unwritten expectations. In this case, the unwritten expectation was that they weren't going to meter you and you didn't have to worry about overage charges, but that the 1Gbps should be thought of more as a burst rate than a 24/7 sustained rate. Likewise, I'd interpret it to mean that if I had a heavy month, I'd be fine.

If I'm a student paying for a dorm in college, should I be allowed to set up a mining rig pulling 10 kW and costing around $720/mo to run? Electricity is included in my dorm fee! I'm paying for it and I'm going to use it!

This is kinda why AWS nickle-and-dimes customers for every little thing - they had people who would find any area of weakness in their pricing model and go after it. I'm not even saying that people did it maliciously. Jungle Disk was a really cool idea: a mountable disk that used S3 to store the files. The problem was that it started doing loads of S3 operations. At the time, AWS didn't charge for operations and now there's this popular program doing a lot of operations compared to its storage and transfer charges.

As someone that has created SaaS software, some customer always comes along and finds an interesting use of your software. Sometimes it's a customer not really understanding the product. Other times a customer has found a weakness in the pricing model and they want to exploit it.

I get it the attitude. It's a war between you the buyer and the company selling a product to you. Personally, I'd rather have a more amicable relationship in my dealings. Yes, that means having realistic expectations about offerings including what might be marketing "puffery" (whether it meets the legal definition of puffery or not; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffery). I'm not going to say that you're wrong to want 100% of the link 24/7, but then you're just talking about being in a situation where the company exercises their right to terminate your account (which you would have agreed to when signing up). Looking at Hetzner a bit more, it looks like they charge €1 per TB or $0.001/GB on their plans that have overages - 10x better than cheap places like Digital Ocean.

Yea, there's lots of places in this world where you can cause headaches for other people by using something in a way it wasn't intended that you're entitled to do - but you're going to have an unhappy time fighting for what you're due all the time. Instead, I'd rather focus on using things the way they were intended such that I don't create adversarial relationships with those I work with. Yes, in this case it would mean that I'd probably buy a few servers or just offer to pay them €200 for the extra bandwidth. Or I could fight, they could give me 30-day notice, and I could find another "unlimited" provider until they see me as a toxic customer and I start it all over again. Again, you're not wrong. You're just going to have an unhappy time trying to enforce your rights and get something better than the company expected to be giving you.

And of all the scummy things out there, Hetzner seems to be pretty decent. €0.001/GB overage on their limited plans is really cheap even compared to good deals like Linode and Digital Ocean (which charge 10x that). Their servers are really cheap. Their pricing is mostly very straightforward - maybe with this being an exception. I'll take a nebulous "it's unlimited, but don't push your luck" over what most hosting providers are offering. I could probably do 250TB for a month and they'd ignore it if it wasn't consistent. I can transfer way more than I get Linode or Digital Ocean and they'd ignore it. Maybe you just want me to say that you're right and that Hetzner is being evil and the person is due their 250TB of transfer every month, but I'd rather go through the world thinking that things are run by humans who want to do the right thing and sometimes don't anticipate all the consequences and then something like this happens - especially when the company doesn't seem to be doing evil stuff. Like, we've all seen surprise AWS bills in the tens of thousands without enormous usage. In this case, we're talking about a pretty small bill compared to the usage.

Yep, that person has the right to use that bandwidth - and Hetzner has the right to terminate a customer for any reason with 30 days notice. I'd just rather try and work with a company in a reasonable fashion if they're willing to work with me in a reasonable fashion. The alternative is becoming the customer that the company hates.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by Handytinge on Monday August 08, 2022 @10:51PM (#32393781)
> In this case, the unwritten expectation was that they weren't going to meter you and you didn't have to worry about overage charges, but that the 1Gbps should be thought of more as a burst rate than a 24/7 sustained rate.

Actually the written expectation was "unlimited" - without limitation. These so called "unwritten limitations" exist solely in your head, and are not suitable for companies to assume users inherently know.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by deadbunny on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:50PM (#32245073)
> but that the 1Gbps should be thought of more as a burst rate than a 24/7 sustained rate

They do not state that anywhere in their advertising or terms of service.

They are advertising 1gbps/24/7/month as implied by their "Unlimited" terminology this is a perfectly measurable value and then cutting people off if they use 80% of that limit.

While I wholeheartedly understand that they can't offer that level of service for all customers and they expect most user to not use the full rate 24/7 and price their products as such.

If I'm being sold 1tb of transfer and am cut off that 800gb that is unacceptable, that is what's happening here (give or take some gigabytes).

If this is a problem for them then they need to change their advertising or terms orservice to state their Fair Use or AUP to list these limits.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by fl0id on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @08:19AM (#32249568)
This so much.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by arghwhat on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:42PM (#32244452)
It is only fraud if it is intentional deception.

In this case I suspect they assumed reasonable interpretation and customer interest: No realistic hosting provider can have the capacity to have every server utilize network 100%, but despite this the customer still benefits from increasing the uplink speed.

In my opinion, their limits are perfectly reasonable, the configuration is in the interest of the customer, and what is provided seems to be a reasonable interpretation fitting with existing definitions. It is only lacking documentation or unclear policy (one rarely plans for the unlikely, and I don't think they expected this), and something that should just be resolved by their customer service department.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by whatshisface on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:49PM (#32244522)
So what you're saying is, if I offer 10,000 gallons of ice cream for $100, but deliver an ice cream cone, I can defend myself by saying that what I delivered was more in line with what a typical customer would want?
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by woojoo666 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:08PM (#32244720)
> So what you're saying is, if I offer 10,000 gallons of ice cream for $100, but deliver an ice cream cone, I can defend myself by saying that what I delivered was more in line with what a typical customer would want?

Yes, if that's truly what the typical customer would want. But I doubt a typical customer would want only an ice cream cone after seeing that offer. However, if you offer "unlimited* ice cream", adding in the terms and conditions that it can't exceed 1 gallon per day, and 99.9% of users don't eat over 1 gallon per day, then I think it's fair to serve only 1 gallon per day.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by teraflop on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:21PM (#32244838)
The actual situation here is more like: you're told you can have up to a gallon per day, but if you actually try to take a gallon every day, you're told that doing so is harming their operations, because you're taking up too much of the workers' time and forcing them to buy ingredients too frequently.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by redeeman on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @07:20AM (#32249134)
that argument doesnt hold, I will give you a realworld example of why.

Some years ago I purchased a (what I thought to be) huge backpack from an ebay store. it said 200 liters. What I got, I estimate to generously be around 75 liters. (by measuring the outer dimensions)

I complained, and they refused to budge, even after I showed them photos of the measurements, and they responded with "we have sold 3597 of these backpacks and nobody else complained about the volume, you must be wrong!!!" (i dont recall exactly if it was 3597, but it was thousands, and a specific number).

Clearly most people got what they expected, a reasonably large backpack, but not a HUUGGEE backpack. Was this okay? Was it acceptable I had to argue countless times and in the end contact paypal to get my money back?

Why is it okay because its hosting services?

edit: and it wasnt just misprint on the listing, the 200L was embroided into the backpack itself, and similarly on their smaller models, with the smaller number

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by olyjohn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:57PM (#32245117)
1 gallon per day is not unlimited ice cream!! It's limited to one fucking gallon per day. "English motherfucker! Do you speak it?"
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by arghwhat on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:39AM (#32247857)
That's an absurd strawman.

If you really want to use this analogue, then the provider is getting upset after continuously providing 8000 gallons of ice cream every month to an individual who bought a single ice cream cone with "unlimited refills".

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by tshaddox on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:04PM (#32244683)
No, but if you offer an “unlimited ice cream” ticket but then refuse to deliver me 100 solar masses of ice cream, I think that’s okay.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by deadbunny on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:41PM (#32245006)
What nonsense. A 1gbps connection has a limit of traffic it can push in a month, that is the limit of their "unlimited" offer.

They are advertising that you can use 100% of your 1gbps link in a month then cutting TFA OP off at 80%.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by tshaddox on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:50PM (#32245070)
> A 1gbps connection has a limit of traffic it can push in a month, that is the limit of their "unlimited" offer.

If your interpretation of basic words is so wildly different from the norm that you already consider "1Gbps unlimited" a contradiction then surely you would never find yourself in a contract where subtler terms are in question.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by deadbunny on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:51PM (#32245477)
How else would you interpret "Unlimited bandwidth @1gbps"?

1gbps maxed out for a month (you know, unlimited usage of a 1gbps line) equals 330TB (give or take depending on the length of the month).

If you signed up for a service which offered 50TB of upload then they cut you off at 35TB then you would be rightly annoyed.

If you have caps on your sevrvice? Cool. Don't use the word unlimited and inform customers of those limits.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by teraflop on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:15PM (#32244782)
What if I offer "unlimited ice cream, up to 1 cone per day for a month", and then after you pay for a month and ask for an ice cream cone every day for three consecutive weeks, I refuse and say your demands are excessive?

Sure, I might be within my legal rights to drop you as a customer the next month, but isn't it still a scummy and misleading way to advertise my service?

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by tadfisher on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:37AM (#32247206)
This is pretty much how MoviePass went bankrupt. The unifying gist is, the business model depends on acquiring customers that don't use the advertised service. But customers are smart and want to maximize the value they receive for their money.

Eventually, you either get an ISP-like situation where everyone has caps on their "unlimited" service and there is no room to disrupt the market, or you get MoviePass.

There is not going to be a free-market solution to this problem, because no service with defined limits will be able to compete with the "unlimited" service at the same price point, and there are no consequences to simply dropping the expensive customers.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by bobkazamakis on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:48PM (#32244507)
> It is only fraud if it is intentional deception.

Are you implying that this unintentional? That things like this are marketed without the full knowledge that such a service is impossible?

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by gernb on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:40PM (#32244426)
You should try that at your local fast food place that has free unlimited refills. Drive up a tanker trunk and trying filling it up with unlimited soda.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by cthalupa on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:51PM (#32244551)
This is a horrible analogy.

At a fast food places they advertise unlimited refills on the cup they sold you as part of the meal.

Here you are being advertised unlimited traffic on the port they sold you as part of the server.

Trying to liken using the port you are being sold as part of the server to driving up a tanker trunk to a fast food place is silly.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by woojoo666 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:14PM (#32244772)
They are both transfer services. You either take your cup and refill at their drink fountain, or use your server to transfer data through their network. Seems like a fine analogy to me
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by eropple on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:24PM (#32244864)
Then presuppose that you walk up with a garbage bag, fill your cup, and dump it into the garbage bag. Rinse and repeat.

You will probably not stay in the establishment very long.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by cthalupa on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @09:43PM (#32246096)
Why do we keep coming up with these bizarre ways to try and make this work?

It is the normal operating mode of an internet connected server to send traffic to the internet - often even 100% of the time! It is the normal operating mode of drinks at a restaurant to be drank by the person while there, and maybe one refill for the road.

Trying to liken "Using the 'Unlimited' 1gbps port that was advertised "to "Refilling a cup and dumping it into a garbage bag" is ludicrous.

I don't understand why people are doing mental gymnastics to defend a bad advertising practice.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by Volundr on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:07PM (#32246200)
> It is the normal operating mode of an internet connected server to send traffic to the internet - often even 100% of the time!

It is? I've been admining servers for a long time and I've never run one using 100% of it's upload bandwidth 100% of the time. I've never even run one at 80%. Being that near capacity means your service is about to fall over. Frankly for most services it's probably flagging.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by cthalupa on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:25PM (#32246574)
There are plenty of workloads where 20% slack in the workload would result in massive (both relative and in absolute terms) additional costs. In these sorts of workloads, it's incredibly common to run any individual server in the fleet very close to maximum capacity. And even if any individual workload isn't, virtualization and containers letting you bin-pack servers makes it even more common.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by Volundr on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @08:45AM (#32249768)
Such as? Sure if you are operating on massive scale or have a remarkably steady load that 20% margin might be feasible, but that's the exception not the rule. Especially for a lone piece of physical hardware that can't scale up/down.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by eropple on Sunday July 31, 2022 @12:33PM (#32296683)
I'd be interested in an example of this, too, because I've been doing this for a while and I can't think of many--particularly in a modern, scalable environment (because Hetzner's APIs aren't great but you absolutely can scale automatically in their environment if you want to).
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by 13415 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:59PM (#32243930)
That's more than a feeling. It's literally bait and switch.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by labster on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:15PM (#32245262)
I see my Marianne walking away from this deal.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by londons_explore on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:54PM (#32244580)
A better way to do it is to simply prioritize traffic in order of whoever has used least traffic this month.

So if a link is congested and a packet has to be dropped, then it is dropped from whichever user has sent the most packets in the last 30 days.

The end result is light users will get great service. Heavy users will start to see congestion at busy times, but will still be able to download as much as they like, contending with other heavy users at busy times.

Actual implementation can consist of say 10 QOS queues, where each customer is assigned a queue based on their decile of traffic sent in the last 30 days. Ideally you'd do strict priority on the queues, but I actually find it works better to say each queue has 2 packets delivered for each one of the queue below. That ensures that if a low use customer has a big burst of traffic, other clients still get a few packets delivered, which helps flow control adapt better. Also, rather than just ranking on 30 day traffic volumes, it works better to rank on 30 day traffic, plus 7 day traffic, plus 24 hour traffic, plus 1 hour traffic. That effectively means traffic sent in the last hour is counted 4x. That means users get faster feedback.

Do this and your company gets better utilization of network hardware too - every link will be 95+% full all the time. Thats better than the traditional model of building for peak usage and having links sit idle at 3am. There are plenty of customers who would love to use that cheap 3am capacity!

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by itsthecourier on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:38PM (#32244986)
Do I love your answer, nice weighting bro
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by bb88 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:58PM (#32243919)
> Even at $0.01/GB, that would be $2,560.

That's still overpriced by a factor of 10. Hetzner overage price for the 10G link is 1 euro / TB or about $0.001/GB. That seems pretty reasonable.

So we're really looking at something more like $250/month.

https://docs.hetzner.com/robot/general/traffic

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by prvit on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:55PM (#32245106)
Hetzner still makes a good profit on that $0.001/GB.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by bb88 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:47PM (#32254792)
I'm guessing a lot of that money is being reinvested into the network. At the point in time their business levels off, they can take profit.

Likely in this case, they can't upgrade their network fast enough, I'm guessing. And they don't have the funds to do it.

This would be a different story than my local cableco say. They will sell you 5TB of data for $100/mo. Or about $0.02/GB. But that money isn't going into network upgrades. And won't until they're forced to, since that's the cable company business model and has been for decades.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by dvfjsdhgfv on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:26PM (#32243517)
> They should probably just say 50TB with overages at $0.005/GB or something like that.

I fully agree. People use more and more bandwidth. It was just a question of time before someone started to use a petabyte a month. "Unlimited" makes no sense unless they are really ready to allow 100% usage of 1Gbps uplink all the time.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by cgriswald on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:58PM (#32243915)
I think "unlimited" should just stop being used as a marketing term. Even if they were actually offering the ability to fully saturate the link indefinitely, the data is still limited by the link speed. In my opinion, the marketing is way out of alignment with the actual contracts on offer.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by 3np on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:45PM (#32245038)
> It was just a question of time before someone started to use a petabyte a month

Nah, even with fully saturating the link you won't get there.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by beaugunderson on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:50PM (#32244533)
I used to work for a visual effects studio in Los Angeles, we setup a Canadian office and wanted to do offsite backups from Canada to LA and from LA to Canada for redundancy. We found a provider who would give us dedicated unmetered 1gbps and then setup a simple rsync. It worked great, we hit 800mbps (the theoretical maximum with TCP overhead) and then 5 days later we got a call from the provider who was absolutely floored that we wanted to actually use the bandwidth we had paid for. Since we had signed a contract they were f'ed but we did come to some agreement in the end. They told us we were affecting all of their other customers.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by walrus01 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:33PM (#32244939)
Now that is a shitty hosting company, since you told them what you were going to do in advance and wrote a bandwidth commitment into the sales order.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by beaugunderson on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:29PM (#32245347)
I think it was a classic case of "sales person will do anything to get the deal done, including things that are harmful to their employer"!
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by walrus01 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:06PM (#32252228)
assuming this person is paying at least $200 a month (not $40-50 like for a hetzner server) it's probably not even harmful economically.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by beaugunderson on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:09PM (#32252293)
Not sure if you mean me or the OP; for us this was a LONG time ago so if memory serves (and it might not) I think we were paying $2,000+/month.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by crooked-v on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:16PM (#32244152)
> I personally would assume that "unlimited 1Gbps" wouldn't include using 80% of the link's capacity

I would personally assume that it would include 100% 24/7 (barring reasonable service outages). That's what "unlimited" means.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by romwell on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:47PM (#32253797)
People in this thread: unlimited means what I want it to mean, and today, it means "limited". Why, that's just how the world works!

People who own dictionaries: this is a completely idiotic line of thinking. By which I mean "reasonable". Why, is there a problem?

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by worldofmatthew on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:22PM (#32243466)
AWS pricing is a rip-off.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by contingencies on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:29PM (#32243558)
... and their systems are designed to make controlling it difficult to impossible while locking people in to their ecosystem.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by booi on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:47PM (#32243767)
How are their systems designed to make controlling cost difficult? I've found it exceptionally easy to find places where things are suboptimal and it's always quite clear to me how much something will cost before I do it.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by vorpalhex on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:52PM (#32243846)
I had an engineer run up a $5k sagemaker bill because they didn't realize "stopped" was different from "terminated".

You also can't set a max billing limit (or a soft limit).

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by Spivak on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:57PM (#32243895)
If you rent a car and it’s still in your possession but turned off they don’t stop charging you.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by pixl97 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:00PM (#32243942)
Well luckily it's very obvious when I still have a car in my driveway.

It's not obvious that a script got caught in a loop and decided to write up a $5000 bill overnight.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by zdragnar on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:21PM (#32244213)
The previous post didn't say a script got caught in a loop overnight, it was that the engineer didn't understand the difference between stopped and terminated.

Even so, I don't think it is AWS's fault that buggy code was left to run unattended overnight in the example you give.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by pixl97 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:45PM (#32244479)
Right, it's not AWS's fault that buggy code ran overnight.

It is absolutely 100% Amazon's decision to give you little to no tooling to prevent this in many scenarios other than going to their billing department and beg for a correction.

I do not use any service that can proceed to bankrupt me for personal use for what could be considered a normal use case. At work I'd pass the issue off to my manager who'd pass it off to a rep and deal with it that way, but there is no way I want to take that responsibility on myself to correct.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by whatshisface on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:51PM (#32244542)
AWS has a reasonable defense for charging for that - it costs them money whether you meant to run it or not.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by zdragnar on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:57PM (#32246700)
To be fair, it'd be fantastic if there were an option to put an automatic hard stop on services once a billing threshold is reached. I seem to recall AWS explaining how to rube-goldberg something together yourself with lambdas and alerts, but if they're capable of telling me to how cobble together the feature myself with their services, surely they could offer it as a turnkey option.

That aside, I also understand that they can't actually put a hard cap, since usage is measured after the fact occurs, and by the time the system triggers a halt, more usage has likely occurred. At the very least, I'd be fine with paying $X + 1 when I set an auto-shutdown threshold to $X if that was what they had to do to implement it.

Outside of that quibble, I find the other complaints to be less reasonable.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by amluto on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:25PM (#32244271)
If I rent a car, I see the pricing up front. And the pricing does not depend on how often I open the trunk or how far I turn the steering wheel.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by ctvo on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:48PM (#32244510)
You do see up front pricing. Please look harder, it’s there for every dimension they charge you for (instance type, network traffic, disk size, etc.).

Back to your analogy. You get charge for these other dimensions that vary when you rent a car:

- make, model

- miles driven

- toll usage

- driver’s age

- duration of rental

The more accurate analogy here for the GP is the person returned a rental car to the wrong lot and was charged additional days until they discovered their error.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by cratermoon on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:05PM (#32244008)
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by comprev on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:45PM (#32243735)
Free/cheap to get in, expensive to get out. Your data is held at ransom to some degree.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by nimbius on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:58PM (#32243917)
IMO hetzner is missing a golden opportunity to offer a dedicated or more powerful colocated data center solution to this client. being able to service the tenants needs should be their only concern. throttling just leaves sour grapes for everyone, and might mask hetzner having capacity issues supporting their workload..cost clearly isn't the problem here.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by foobiekr on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:30PM (#32244327)
Combining statistical multiplexing, fixed WAN bandwidth and SLAs with penalties are basically a recipe for massive losses.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by thexa4 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:21PM (#32243456)
They did have traffic caps a while back but explicitly abolished them.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by thegeekpirate on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:24PM (#32243495)
Yep, it was 20TB from what I recall.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by iancarroll on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:47PM (#32243758)
Hetzner is probably paying ~$300/mo/Gbps for their transit capacity. While I’m sure this particular account isn’t profitable for them, they’re not losing a boatload of money from it either. Hard to blame the user if they advertise it as unlimited.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by walrus01 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:57PM (#32243898)
at the size and scale of hetzner an individual 100Gbps IP transit circuit is considerably less costly than $30k a month.

more like 5-6k max at a major IX point.

this also ignores how much of their traffic is settlement free peering to other adjacent ISPs.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by worldofmatthew on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:59PM (#32243924)
From what I remember; FDC has 100Gbit/s for $4,999/month.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by walrus01 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:31PM (#32244330)
fdc is not a transit provider specialist with POPs in every major global city (as measured by CAIDA ASrank size) similar to Cogent or Telia or level3, which a hosting company like hetzner might become a customer of, rather, it's a hosting company
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by worldofmatthew on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:41AM (#32246910)
Its their resold transit product (their 100G Dedicated Bandwidth Servers are often cheaper).
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by repox on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:10PM (#32244066)
"Unlimited 1 Gbps" should be unlimited. Otherwise it's downright fraud to label it "unlimited".
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by tomjen3 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:26PM (#32244273)
AWS is overcharging badly. I wouldn't even take them seriously if you want to do something with e.g video. Charging per GB is a joke in a world where my (expensive) ISP doesn't even offer anything less than 30/30mb.

IMHO Hertzer is the only hosting company that get what business it is in. AWS makes a ton of sense if you need to rent serious iron to do OCR on 100+ GB of scans of corporate documents, you need GPU power to train your AI model, or you are a startup that needs to grow 50% a month.

If you are an established company with a normal demand model, AWS will rip you alive.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by NavinF on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:53PM (#32244572)
> AWS makes a ton of sense if […] you need GPU power to train your AI model,

Breakeven time between paying for GPUs, servers, and colo vs GCP was 3 months when I last checked. AWS was even worse. For training, cloud GPUs only make sense if you don’t have anyone on your team that’s familiar with physical infra or if you have a ton of free credits which is fairly common for startups with VC funding.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by tomjen3 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:04PM (#32244681)
I was assuming that you only needed to train your AI once.

AWS is like a hotel. Great if you need it for a couple days, but you are mad if you want to live there indefinitely.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by themitigating on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:17PM (#32244175)
If some large American ISP did this people would be at pitchforks. Hetzner gets a defense
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by nottorp on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:10AM (#32250583)
Actually all cheap "unlimited" hosting is like that. Someone just noticed it on Hetzner. Next month someone else will notice it on $LARGE_AMERICAN_ISP.

Although I bet $LARGE_AMERICAN_ISP will not warn you, but just shut down your site and lock you out of your data.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by _tomcat_ on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:40PM (#32244425)
So you basically read that as nobody would actually mean "unlimited" or "1Gbps".

Do you live your day-to-day telling people lies or what?

None of that behavior sounds rational to me.

I can only imagine 'what? you thought I was going to paint the ENTIRE house!'

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by NavinF on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:44PM (#32244474)
That says more about AWS than anything. It’s not hard to get wholesale transit under $0.1/mbps 95%ile.

809Mbps costs $81/mo for a small provider.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by rowanG077 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:01PM (#32243950)
> I personally would assume that "unlimited 1Gbps" wouldn't include using 80% of the link's capacity, but I also agree that stated limits are better.

There is in fact a very clearly stated limit. It's unlimited.

Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by jwlake on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:16PM (#32244786)
The correct thing is to just token throttle to the max you're willing to offer for the fixed price. Then when a small minority figure out 1Gbps really is like 100Mbps, then whatever.
Re:Hetzner appears to impose unlisted “fair use” on traffic by Akronymus on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:06PM (#32244016)
If you set some kinda limit, people will be trying to get close to it. Thus actually increasing overall traffic.