News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by ben_w on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:51PM (#32198057)
A global grid was my favourite solution until recently. The problem is that it needs the combined cables to have cross section in the order of a few (3?) square meters (at 640 kV), and that in turn is in the order of 52 years of global copper production (we make more aluminium than copper but Al is a worse conductor).

Using even higher voltages makes everything much easier, and the cables’ combined cross sections may need to be less (depending on how much lower the maximum demand at night is) or more (depending on future increases in daytime demand).

Downside is that’s still order-of a few trillion dollars, close to the same as the cost of 36 TWh of batteries (i.e. global overnight only), and we’re likely to make those batteries anyway for the electric cars and when their condition deteriorates enough to be taken out of the cars they're still good enough for grid storage.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by zbrozek on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:45PM (#32198526)
While your house wiring is typically copper, transmission and distribution wiring isn't. That's very-often aluminum. And as you point out, we make a huge amount of the stuff.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by ben_w on Saturday July 23, 2022 @02:32AM (#32200935)
20.6 MT copper/year vs 64 MT aluminium/year, even using both that's still equivalent to about 17 years of current global production (which is a big but not impossible change over the timescales desired), but the price is still painful.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by zbrozek on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:43AM (#32203768)
Aluminum has higher specific conductivity than copper by mass. So if you think you need 1 MT of copper conductivity, you can do the job with 0.5 MT of aluminum.

Aluminum is also quite abundant. Rate limits will be political rather than production. That's not to say this is a realistic idea or that it's worth doing, just that it isn't unthinkable on a resource basis.

https://www.anixter.com/en_us/resources/literature/wire-wisd...

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by kortex on Saturday July 23, 2022 @11:43AM (#32204358)
Aluminum production is also tightly coupled to electricity production, so cheaper power could lead to cheaper aluminum in a positive feedback loop.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by walrus01 on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:57PM (#32198109)
I don't know of any long distance HV AC or DC transmission lines that use copper. It's all aluminum already.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by tclancy on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:29PM (#32198371)
I’ve heard it’s all ball bearings but that may be outdated.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by dotancohen on Saturday July 23, 2022 @01:14AM (#32200604)
Meaning that coal transported by train is still a major energy source? Globally that is still accurate unfortunately.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by adrianmonk on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:35PM (#32233260)
It's a reference to the movie Fletch. The main character is an investigative reporter. In one scene, he poses as an airplane mechanic. The real airplane mechanics are not very convinced, and he tries playing it off by saying, "It's all ball bearings nowadays."

https://youtu.be/SjJYNZirQCU

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by eternityforest on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:31PM (#32198889)
I doubt copper would be used in that kind of thing. It's worse, but not that much worse.

Energy storage might not be an issue in a decade or so. There's no law of physics saying they can't make batteries without conflict metals. Eventually someone's going to invent a battery made of some cheap hydrocarbon you make by the tanker car, or that compressed Co2 turbine system will turn out to be the real deal, or they'll figure out magnesium air, etc.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pfdietz on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:15AM (#32202624)
Copper is used in applications where the conductor is volume constrained. Transmission lines are not volume constrained, they are mass constrained. Aluminum is superior there: its electrical conductivity divided by density is higher than copper.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by ncmncm on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:42AM (#32201269)
A clear majority of utility storage will not be batteries, just because cheaper methods will be favored.

The cheapest will rely on E = Fx, where F is air pressure, or gravity, or buoyancy. But liquified anhydrous ammonia, despite being more costly to make, will be extremely popular because it is easy to transport and store, and is fantastically useful for many purposes.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by eternityforest on Sunday July 24, 2022 @04:11AM (#32211410)
I think that depends on battery tech. If they get magnesium air or metal free organic flow working I would imagine it would probably be chosen over mechanical methods.

Ideally I suspect you don't really want utility storage anyway, you want something so cheap, small, and renewable you can do point of load storage and have a bit of grid independence, and not need as much transmission infrastructure.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by ncmncm on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:25PM (#32243509)
Point of use storage costs a lot more.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by nine_k on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:52PM (#32199432)
Superconducting power transmission was first implemented back in 2014 [1]. Some progress has been made since then [2].

I bet we'll eventually see more of that, with superconducting materials steadily becoming more pliable and affordable, and liquid nitrogen being pretty cheap. Maybe we'll see hundreds of miles of such lines. It looks to me more realistic than land in Western Europe becoming cheap enough to install a gigawatt of solar panels here and there.

[1]: https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/182278-the-worlds-first-...

[2]: https://energycentral.com/news/shanghai-opens-world-leading-...

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by ben_w on Saturday July 23, 2022 @02:44AM (#32200986)
I like superconductors, and I certainly hope they'll become viable, but "hundreds of miles" is a factor of at least 120 short of what's needed, and land for a GW of PV isn't that expensive even in western Europe, especially as PV can be present in pastureland at the same time as the animals.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by lotharcable on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:43PM (#32198503)
Money != Wealth

You can go ahead and force every billionaire to sell off everything they own and hand it to the government and all you end up with is a one time boost to government tax receipts.

That's it. One time boost. Next year those billionaires will be gone. There won't be new ones.

And it won't create any more food. It won't solve shortages. It won't create more solar panels. It won't create 1 mile of copper lines.

Because when the government goes and says "I need 40 million acres of solar panels"... Who is going to do that? Where is that going to come from?

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by walrus01 on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:46PM (#32199002)
>Because when the government goes and says "I need 40 million acres of solar panels"... Who is going to do that? Where is that going to come from?

1) the empty arid land where we would put 40 million acres of solar panels is for the most part already owned by a state or national level government. go look at a map of how much of nevada is controlled by the BLM for instance.

2) governments already pay for electrical generation through nuclear power plants, building hydroelectric dams, etc. the question would be to apply that same money to building giant ground mount PV instead.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by ncmncm on Saturday July 23, 2022 @03:44AM (#32201277)
Arid land will soon be recognized as the worst place to put solar farms.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by otikik on Saturday July 23, 2022 @07:47AM (#32202453)
Those billionaires will no longer be buying politicians in the following years either. Perhaps it’s worth doing just for that effect alone.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by distances on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:48AM (#32201551)
How is this related to the parent comment? I don't get what you are talking about here.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:12PM (#32198727)
The communists have repeatedly done the equivalent, which is nationalizing industries. It never, ever produced better results.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by toomuchtodo on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:46PM (#32199405)
France is buying out the remainder of EDF (France’s commercial nuclear fleet operator) for €10 billion, so we’re going to get another chance to observe the experiment.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jul/19/france-to-p...

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by spaniard89277 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:32AM (#32201486)
It's not going to be any different. They're buying EDF because the current situation of their nuclear capacity is a shitshow.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by walrus01 on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:25PM (#32198842)
Government owned, government built, government run regional monopoly electricity generators in North America are already the absolute cheapest dollars per kilowatt hour in the continent.

It's not communism.

I am referring to hydro quebec, and to the hydroelectric dams in central Washington State.

Would you claim that if we had let the free market build those hydroelectric dams using private capital instead, that we would have better results right now?

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by Aeolun on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:58PM (#32199076)
> that we would have better results right now?

Think of the shareholders!

All that lost value could have gone to line their pockets, but instead it’s being used for the good of society (to be fair, probably to those same shareholders through different companies at exorbitant rates).

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:00PM (#32199101)
> All that lost value could have gone to line their pockets, but instead it’s being used for the good of society

That is indeed the pitch the communists make. How is that working out for them?

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by cycomanic on Saturday July 23, 2022 @01:31AM (#32200660)
Show me any large scale infrastructure project that has been realized by private enterprises without massive government subsidies. How is your privately funded highway or rail system working out for you?
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by Aeolun on Saturday July 23, 2022 @02:16AM (#32200866)
> How is your privately funded highway or rail system working out for you?

Well, we get lovely toll gates about every 10 miles. Happily they’ve been automated so you can more or less just cruise on, but the constant “that’ll be $3, that’ll be $4, that’ll be $3.50” while you are driving can get on your nerves.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by rfrey on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:32AM (#32203676)
The notion that government supplied infrastructure, which enables private industry to flourish, is somehow communist, would probably make even Ayn Rand pause for a second. From roads to electricity to clean water, government infrastructure has been part of the American success story since the 18th century.

It's only the radical "right wing" (scare quotes because they bear no resemblance to "right wing" thought from before the 90s) that have challenged the government role in giving American industry the tools they need for success.

To call government funded infrastructure "communist" is the clearest illustration of the Overton Window I think I've ever seen.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by zapataband1 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @02:49AM (#32201007)
You mean like china who has 10,000 high speed rails running every day producing the cheapest PV cells and lifted their population out of poverty? Let's just let Elon Musk get richer at the 3 trillion dollar mark he might let us have ONE tunnel.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by jprd on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:50PM (#32199810)
It isn't, not when there is a better _commercial_ system in the world. If the "invisible hand" was real, great. As it has been a constantly manipulated and managed construct within the world of global finance from the moment Adam Smith shared it with anyone, it completely ceased to have any meaning going forward other than license to savage.

Economics isn't science or maths when you get past the micro level. It is psychology.

If there is a Capitalist society that also has a deep respect for mental health, I say it only exists in Science Fiction from the 50s and 60s.

The goals of communism are pure and true, but insanely unrealistic considering we're talking about humans who still instinctually believe in a reality where scarcity is anything other than a human construct.

On the other hand, naturally, barely restrained capitalism is just going to be a giant cancer where the rich feast off the poor until it all goes down in flames.

What's needed is a shared sense of morality, community and survival across our species.

History says we're fucked.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by rfrey on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:02PM (#32199480)
It's working out great for the communist governments of Quebec and Washington State. The communists in Norway also seem to be doing ok.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:18PM (#32199589)
The communists in Norway, like Russia, benefit enormously from pumping oil out of the ground, which goes to the government. In Norway's case, it's 20% of the GDP. Probably much more today with all the oil price increases.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by Teever on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:41PM (#32199748)
Can you comment on the communists of Quebec? As a Canadian, this is what I find lacking in debate on American sites like Reddit or HN.

Canada is very similar to the United States, another way of saying that is that Canada does things slightly different yet the results seem to be profoundly different than the States.

Why is that, and what are we as Canadians doing that Americans and others around the world should attempt to copy and improve upon?

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Saturday July 23, 2022 @01:13AM (#32200601)
I know next to nothing about Quebec, and so cannot contribute anything there.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by vasco on Saturday July 23, 2022 @05:08AM (#32201654)
Quebec has a communist government? Wikipedia tells me liberal / constitutional monarchy.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by danaris on Saturday July 23, 2022 @12:28PM (#32204810)
'Twas a bit of sarcasm in response to WalterBright's overly broad characterization of "communism".
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:02PM (#32199481)
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by defrost on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:13PM (#32199549)
"never ever" is both a strong claim and ridiculous.

I'll take the Australian Snowy River Hydro scheme over the mess in Texas any day.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:16PM (#32199578)
How about the California power system?
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by the_why_of_y on Saturday July 23, 2022 @05:43AM (#32201816)
I find the one in Texas much more impressive.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/09/preliminary-report-l...

While Texans froze and natural gas-fired power plants tripped offline during a February cold snap, natural gas traders and pipeline companies made up to $11 billion in just nine days.

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/07/11-billion-in-9-...

“I will say we understand that it would be unacceptable to just have customers bear the cost on their monthly bill and as if anybody could pay for that,” Gold-Williams said. “So we are working diligently - the financial services team is working diligently, trying to figure out ways to truly spread that cost, potentially maybe, you know 15 - I mean, 10 years or longer to try to make it affordable. We don’t have that fully assessed.”

https://www.ksat.com/news/local/2021/02/19/skyrocketing-pric...

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by defrost on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:54PM (#32220077)
I'm Australian and as a nation we're considerably more "communist" than can be found in the US .. with many major public funded infrastructure projects historically established, a global AAA credit rating, a minimum living wage since 1900, national health, functioning democracy, etc.

There are numerous counter examples to your overly broad "never ever" claims here.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:55PM (#32199056)
I read recently that Mexico was nationalizing part of its electric grid and user prices were expected to rise as a result.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:08AM (#32201379)
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pclmulqdq on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:32PM (#32199297)
I would claim that, yes, private capital would generate power more cheaply with those dams, but that isn't the only reason those dams are there. They serve several alternative functions (ie preventing flooding, keeping lakes full) that a free marketeer would not do.

However, dams are cheap enough for power generation that even with government inefficiency involved in their construction and operation, the power is so cheap that it doesn't matter.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by NikolaNovak on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:43PM (#32199382)
I thought that question got empathically answered when Ontario hydro was privatized and split and went to hell together with our electricity prices.

Same with Ontario vs Manitoba or Quebec car insurance etc. Some things just suck when they're privatized - they focus on short term gain and end up with lousy infra and long term preparedness. I think HN has a pretty solid consensus on private telecom monopolies vs municipal fiber as well.

Back to topic, I thought most of usa private power monopolies are basically in dire straits from infra upkeep and maintenance and grid - there's a lot of bright knowledgeable folks on HN so I would genuinely appreciate comment if I'm way off base in my ignorant ways.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by 8note on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:36PM (#32199716)
As a limiting case, a private system can't do it cheaper than a public one. A private system needs to skim profits off the top, which will always limit how cheap it can go
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by Consultant32452 on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:44PM (#32199769)
"Your margin is my opportunity." ~Jeff Bezos

Private is cheaper if there is competition. Monopolies are always more costly, public or private.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by ben_w on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:23AM (#32201444)
Private is not always cheaper — the NHS comes to mind as a counter-example, and is cheaper in part because the British government gets to act as a monopsony.

While competition can indeed help illuminate new solutions, competition can also come in the form of different political parties and international comparisons.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by formerkrogemp on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:39PM (#32208265)
"You cheap, underpaid labor is my wealth. Thanks for the trip to space, nerds." - Jeff Bezos
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by 8note on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:34PM (#32199692)
Aramco has done great though
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by Aeolun on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:51PM (#32199034)
We don’t need to shift all necessary electricity from one end of the earth to the other right? Just the shortfall that a large number of batteries cannot deal with overnight.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by elihu on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:33PM (#32198896)
I'm curious if anyone knows the cost/benefit analysis of HVDC over aluminum cables versus using high-temperature superconductors like ReBCO tape. Maybe supply of yttrium is a bottleneck preventing large-scale use of ReBCO?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare-earth_barium_copper_oxide

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pclmulqdq on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:29PM (#32199277)
High voltage solves a lot of materials problems for wires. I assume that almost everything about superconductors is expensive to do, not just the raw materials, which makes it too costly (in both energy and money) to use them as wires.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by elihu on Saturday July 23, 2022 @12:04AM (#32200243)
I assume there's a really high fixed cost involved in creating a cable installation that's insulated and continuously chilled to liquid nitrogen temperatures, but maybe there's a break even point if the amount of current you're moving is large enough? I mean, if you're comparing with an aluminum or copper cable with a cross section measured in meters, that isn't cheap either.

There might not be a break-even point. Maybe ReBCO tape is just more expensive per amp it can transport than ordinary conductive metals like aluminum. Maybe HVDC lines can be boosted to arbitrarily high voltages such that you never need huge cables in the first place.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by lazide on Saturday July 23, 2022 @01:14AM (#32200605)
The issue as well is catastrophic failures.

Superconductors get VERY exciting VERY quickly if they ever quench, and that is a property of the current and superconductor. You can't carry infinite current.

They may be more efficient, but they come with a whole host of challenges that make them difficult to use over long distances or in uncontrolled environments, which is pretty much what you'll have to deal with for long distance utility level power transfer.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by Emma_Goldman on Saturday July 23, 2022 @02:58AM (#32201057)
A lovely idea, but it will not happen anytime soon because states consider energy independence to be of existential geopolitical importance.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by rocqua on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:09AM (#32202971)
Did you take into account that transmission cables are usually hollow? Due to the skin effect, most current runs through the edge of a cable, so by hollowing out the cable you can remove a part that doesn't carry much current.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by adaml_623 on Friday July 22, 2022 @06:58PM (#32198126)
The good news is that humanity has saved up a few trillion for emergencies. The bad news is that it's been saved up and hidden in tax havens. Pity
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by kortilla on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:25PM (#32198338)
What a bad take. The US alone effectively created that much money out of thin air during the pandemic. All of the countries combined printed far more.

Doing the same for an energy project that might actually pay back (unlike the covid losses) is far less disruptive.

Finally, the amount of money hidden away in tax havens by the rich is nothing compared to this. Don’t drag down something as important as the climate crisis with some smooth brained class warfare.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by Aeolun on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:53PM (#32199048)
> The US alone effectively created that much money out of thin air during the pandemic. All of the countries combined printed far more.

The difference being that most of that money ended up in rich people’s pockets, and are now causing a global economic crisis.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by anu7df on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:27PM (#32199271)
I am not sure of that. If all that money ended up in rich people's pocket, never to see the light of day again we won't be having the inflation crisis. The money through various investments is now out in the open, driving up inflation. It is still unequally distributed and that is causing issues. If there was a magical way to distribute that money equally between everyone inflation won't be an issue. Unfortunately magic isn't real.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by ben_w on Saturday July 23, 2022 @04:26AM (#32201454)
I don't claim to know the full causes of the current inflation issues, but inflation can also be caused by a reduction in productivity, not just by an increase in money supply.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by kortilla on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:18PM (#32209634)
There needs to be a reduction in productivity while everyone magically staying at the same income levels though to keep demand high.

The rapid increase in just human labor prices seems to indicate that money is making it to people somehow because COVID didn’t kill enough of the labor force to have that kind of effect.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by adrianN on Saturday July 23, 2022 @01:08AM (#32200578)
Rich people don't keep their money under the mattress. It's invested in assets that make it available to the economy.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by adrianN on Saturday July 23, 2022 @01:07AM (#32200576)
If you used the money to build renewable infrastructure, most of the money would still end up in rich people's pockets, because typically it's rich people who own the means of producing infrastructure.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by kortilla on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:14PM (#32209615)
No it didn’t. If it all just ended up in rich people’s pockets it wouldn’t have caused this kind of inflation and supply shortages for all of these every day items.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by 8note on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:37PM (#32199724)
Haven't the covid losses already paid back? We aren't in absolute catastrophe
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by kortilla on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:26PM (#32209689)
No. They won’t be paid back until the government gets an excess of at least that much in tax revenue.

Something mitigating an ongoing can be expensive, have the intended positive effect immediately, but not be paid back for a long time (or sometimes ever).

Federally subsidized flood insurance is a much smaller scale example. There are many places in Florida and the gulf in general where houses get destroyed by hurricanes and have to be rebuild for $X every 20 years when we only collect maybe 25% of $X in premiums.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by InvertedRhodium on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:37PM (#32198446)
What a one sided take - there's no reason that both can't be real problems.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by billiam on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:37PM (#32198443)
People that charge class warfare just don't want anything to change. Wealth accumulated by the rich mostly by burning dinosaurs is just as fictitious as any QE from the Fed.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pydry on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:45PM (#32198528)
It's only fictitious if Jeff Bezos is comparing his wealth to your wealth.

Try to tax it away and use it for something that would benefit everyone and suddenly it becomes a lot less abstract to him.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pclmulqdq on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:35PM (#32199331)
It would become a lot less real too. The wealth of people who mostly get it from stock ownership is a complete fiction, driven by the scarcity of shares on the open market. If Jeff Bezos dumped his entire holding in AMZN shares, the whole company would be worth a lot less. Not due to any sort of magical effect of Jeff Bezos, but due to the market being flooded with supply.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pydry on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:43PM (#32199385)
I guess this means if a hypothetical Bill Gates sold off the vast majority of the 45% of Microsoft stock he owned then the company would then be worth a lot less?

It really is weird how frequently I see the view you espouse and how nobody who repeats it seems to consider the clearest, most obvious counterexample that so completely disproves it.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by tsimionescu on Saturday July 23, 2022 @12:09AM (#32200262)
So you think that Microsoft stock price wouldn't go down significantly if Bill Gates put 45% of the company up for sale?
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by coob on Saturday July 23, 2022 @01:52AM (#32200745)
He sold most of his MSFT in 2020 when stepping down from the board.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pclmulqdq on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:08AM (#32201944)
By that time, he had sold almost all of MSFT. He was a ~2% owner. That sale was a lot more similar in scale to a hedge fund selling a large block of shares than to Jeff Bezos liquidating his holdings.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pydry on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:23AM (#32202020)
IIRC put 44% of the company up for sale over a period of many years and the price of microsoft stock did indeed go up during that time.

So yes, I think what would happen is what did happen.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by tsimionescu on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:32AM (#32202717)
The hypothetical was about selling them all at once, or a very short period of time.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pydry on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:04AM (#32202931)
A) The OP did not mention this.

B) even if he did it would be kind of like saying that your 500k house isnt really worth 500k because if you walked out on to the street and and asked passers by for offers for a maximum of one hour you would almost certainly not get 500k.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by tsimionescu on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:33PM (#32208222)
> A) The OP did not mention this.

The OP said "If Jeff Bezos dumped his entire holding [...]". I find it very hard to equate "dump" with "still over the course of a decade".

> B) even if he did it would be kind of like saying that your 500k house isnt really worth 500k because if you walked out on to the street and and asked passers by for offers for a maximum of one hour you would almost certainly not get 500k.

Now you're exaggerating in the other direction. The point is that if these people whose fortune is entirely stock of a massive company wanted to sell all of that stock for cold hard cash on the stock exchange in the same way you or I might sell our stock for a big purchase, they would actually only get a fraction of the nominal value ascribed to them.

Sure, if they do it slowly over the course of a decade, and if the business avruay survives that long at its current valuation (which Amazon might, but Tesla won't), then they can eventually actually get the fortunes they theoretically own.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pydry on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:13AM (#32213166)
>Now you're exaggerating in the other direction.

Im just illustrating the difference between liquidity and wealth.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by kortilla on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:29PM (#32209708)
Well what you stated never happened, so not sure what there is to disprove. It took Gates a significant amount of time to wind down his ownership stake in Microsoft.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pclmulqdq on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:03AM (#32201914)
In 2020, as I understand it, Bill gates sold less than 1% of MSFT on the open market there: his holding went from a bit over 2% to a bit over 1%. He had been steadily selling over the last two decades.

Contrast that with Jeff Bezos, who owns 10% of Amazon, or Elon Musk who owns over 20% of Tesla. Half of Gates's holding is nothing in comparison to half of Bezos's.

When you sell large share blocks like Gates did, you do it very slowly to avoid market impact. Elon Musk couldn't sell slowly enough to avoid an impact when he sold shares to buy Twitter.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pydry on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:09AM (#32201952)
Overall he sold about 44% of the company. He had about 45%.

The guy above was telling me this would drive the price down. You know what actually happened though. The share price went up.

The "billionaire shares are imaginary meme" is just a rhetorical trick designed to confuse the economically illiterate.

The only interesting thing about this meme is figuring out where it came from and how it was so efficiently pumped into the public consciousness.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pclmulqdq on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:16AM (#32203046)
Oh yeah, he sold it very, very slowly, over 20 years. The hypothetical I was responding to is suggesting that these billionaires' fortunes be liquidated within a year.

Even so, you don't know how much higher the price of MSFT would be if not for Gates's selling. Other factors just drove the price up faster than he drove it down.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pydry on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:27AM (#32203145)
Yeah, fair point.

Either way the meme of bezos's wealth being a fiction is comprehensively disproved.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pclmulqdq on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:30AM (#32212399)
I think too many people equate fiction and lies. Stock prices and market caps are not complete lies (the company is still worth something) but they are fictions. I like to think of fiction as "a lie that tells a truth that cannot be told any other way" (adapted from Albert Camus).

Market caps and startup valuations are fictions. That doesn't mean that they don't say something important - they convey information about who has market power, political power, technological progress, etc. All of those things are worth a lot. Fictions can affect reality. They are frequently more powerful than truths. Theranos, Nikola, and Tesla have all moved billions of dollars of real money on the back of fictional product descriptions.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by kortilla on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:32PM (#32209731)
Nobody said it’s a fiction. What is a fiction is pretending the current share price * number of shares is what the value is. That’s completely detached from how the stock market works.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by pas on Friday July 22, 2022 @07:22PM (#32198317)
the problem is the allocation of the resources in the real economy. the copper production goes somewhere currently. if half of that suddenly would go to making these super long distance cables that would cause brutal inflation for a lot of things that depend on copper. (sure, eventually it would increase supply too.)
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by eternityforest on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:41PM (#32198960)
A lot of copper goes to nonelectrical uses that could probably go away.

Whenever I see something mechanical made of bronze or something it always looks like a real waste. New finishes and coatings look pretty good and composites are strong and corrosion resistant, and steel is cheaper.

Not everything can be replaced but some can.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by dranudin on Saturday July 23, 2022 @06:21AM (#32202012)
You should try a copper pan. They are great! Copper is also a very effective conductor of heat.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:05PM (#32198676)
High taxes always drive capital away into unproductive tax havens.

Reagan's achievement was to eliminate tax shelters in exchange for lower tax rates. This pulled the investment out of those unproductive shelters into productive activities, leading to the prosperity of the 80s.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by Hammershaft on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:20PM (#32199239)
Reagan created and governed on unprecedented peacetime deficits caused by his military spending and tax changes. If his policy had any meaningful influence over the economy of the 80s it's likely the massive deficit spending.

That said, the link between presidential policy & short term economic changes is universally overstated. The government can cut down basic research funding and the effects won't be felt for a half century.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:09PM (#32199528)
My point was his policies caused a shift in investment capital away from unproductive tax shelters and into productive investments. Eliminating the tax shelters was part of the deal he made with Democrats to get the budget passed.

That can't help but produce positive economic changes.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by 8note on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:39PM (#32199733)
The investment shift being into military contracting though?
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by andrepd on Friday July 22, 2022 @08:17PM (#32198763)
Prosperity of the 80s? You mean the era that signalled the end of the post-war golden age of capitalism and brought about hyper-financialisation (which led us to the 2008 catastrophe from which we still haven't recovered) and the decline of tax progressiveness and public services (which supercharged wealth inequality back to gilded age levels)?

Many of our current problems can be traced back to changes which occurred in the 70s and 80s.

Yes, prosperity on GDP numbers, blessed be Its name. Unfortunately not everything is reduced to making line go up.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by WalterBright on Friday July 22, 2022 @09:02PM (#32199123)
Decline of public services? Government social spending has increased enormously since the 80s.

I'm amused you're blaming 2008 on Reagan.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by badpun on Saturday July 23, 2022 @05:31AM (#32201765)
When you deregulate stuff, the catastrophic results usually don't come immediately. If they were to come immediately, it would be blatantly obvious to everyone that it's a bad idea, and hence deregulation wouldn't happen. So, in practice, most of deregulation happens in areas where it's good for short-term and bad/catastrophic for long-term.
Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by cycomanic on Saturday July 23, 2022 @01:50AM (#32200737)
> High taxes always drive capital away into unproductive tax havens.

Citation needed. Show me data that demonstrates that use of tax havens is correlated to tax rates. The data over the last 30-40 years at least at first glance seems to disagree. Tax rates (in particular top income bracket, capital gains and corporate taxes) have continously reduced, while the amount of money in tax havens has increased.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by specialist on Saturday July 23, 2022 @12:04AM (#32200245)
The revenue corollary of PAYGO.

I support tax cuts being tightly coupled with much reduced tax avoidance. Retroactively.

Re:We're going to need a lot of solar panels by robocat on Saturday July 23, 2022 @02:42AM (#32200976)
Money is a river, not a lake.