If you do that on your own, it's your (legal) responsibility. If Copilot does it for you, it's GitHub's/Microsoft's responsibility.
Is this true? It hasn't been tried yet I assume?
GitHub/Microsoft says that it's still your responsibility.
>You should take the same precautions as you would with any code you write that uses material you did not independently originate. These include rigorous testing, IP scanning, and checking for security vulnerabilities. You should make sure your IDE or editor does not automatically compile or run generated code before you review it.
I'm not really sure how am I supposed to go about validating that I can in fact use this code that the magical black box barfed into my IDE using a bunch of different weights.
If Copilot is fair use, and has no restrictive license, than how is it anyone's responsibility?
If Copilot isn't fair use, it's Microsoft's responsibility.
(For copyright; for patent that's another issue, but you can violate patents by similarity without exposure or copying, anyway.)
Give us your money but you are responsible for the code that OUR tool generates.
If I use grammarly, are they responsible for what am I aiming to write?
You can no more claim ignorance of where the github copilot code comes from than where the Amazon's low, low prices come from.
Whether you care is totally on you regardless of whether you pay ir not. You pay for product or service not moral absolution.
At the same time when fast fashion companies sell T-shirts made with slave labour, its not the company's responsebility to check what their suppliers are doing.
And if tesla autopilot kills you and your family its not their fault either.
Neoliberal morality - companies are never accountable for anything, it's heresy to suggest they should do their job properly.
Zara's clothes sometimes have notes in their pockets from people being held as slaves, pleading for help. I havent heard of anyone going to jail
most of our electronic waste end up illegally exported to poor countries, again when was the last tomw someone faced the music for that?
This whole thing would be fine if GitHub hadn't just used all public code on their platform, ignoring all involved licenses.
It's like saying GPT-3 created text is copyright infringement, because some author used the same sentence in a book before.
I could ask you the same thing.
> But if you do the second thing you are not a great dev, and would have probably ended up copy pasting it anyway.
How would I know that the boiler plate I ask copilot to write for me is copied verbertim from a codebase, that neither I nor Microsoft has licensed to use?
If you are using it to write whole complex functions thatare the same as other people's, I guess that is copying.
But if you do the second thing you are not a great dev, and would have probably ended up copy pasting it anyway.
I think the first use case is far more common, and creating boilerplate that is so generic you could never really attribute it anyway.