News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:12PM (#31597689)
Here in the UK we're one day into a two day extra 'bank holiday' for the Queen's jubilee (70 years).

Seems a good time to remind people of great sites like these, places that take the time to gather the evidence that reveals the truth behind royalty - descendants of thieves and murderers still profiting off the proceeds of their ancestral crimes, with their only 'qualification' being an accident of birth.

We've never been a democracy. And we never will be as long as we have an aristocracy and a royalty with priviledges and titles both unearned and undeserved.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by simonh on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:23PM (#31597841)
We could get rid of the monarchy tomorrow and ordinary britons would notice zero change in our political and democratic freedoms. They are politically irrelevant, a few completely peripheral procedural and technical issues aside that make no real difference in the grand scheme of things.

I'm not sure if that's an argument for or against keeping the monarchy to be honest. They're a historical vestigial appendage of the state, but the idea that we're any less of a democracy because they're there is kind of silly.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:49PM (#31598211)
> They are politically irrelevant, a few completely peripheral procedural and technical issues aside that make no real difference in the grand scheme of things.

At the very least they own huge parts of the country, and the Queen has (and exercises as per recent Guardian stories) vetos and opt-outs of the laws the rest of us must follow.

Regardless of that, even as a basic principle our country reeks of deference and class.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by p10jkle on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:55PM (#31598294)
They get 25% of crown estate profits, but I’m not sure they really ‘own’ that land per se. And in general, the elite own a huge amount of the UK (most notably Oxbridge colleges with incredible land ownership). We can make a case to take ‘back’ the Queen’s private or crown estate land, but why just them? IMO, casting judgement on what historic ownership is ‘rightful’ is really hard.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:22PM (#31598642)
We'd struggle to fairly take it back; probably not even worth trying. And whilst I never said so specifically I presumed it apparent that I never meant just the Queen. I accept I could have been clearer (sorry).

The first steps might be:

- An end to the honours system (entirely - even though many 'commoners' get them now it perpetuates the class concepts)

- Fair and universal application of inheritance tax to reduce the inequalities over the generations

- The taxation of assets (beyond a certain point so that people don't need to sell their home) and not just income

All those have arguments for/against, but it would be good for them to be honestly discussed and considered by those with the power to effect change.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by barry-cotter on Thursday June 02, 2022 @08:11PM (#31602354)
> The taxation of assets (beyond a certain point so that people don't need to sell their home) and not just income.

That’s a great way to discourage investment and capital formation and encourage emigration. There’s a reason wealth taxes are not popular in OECD countries.

https://taxfoundation.org/wealth-taxes-in-the-oecd/

Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Friday June 03, 2022 @03:17AM (#31605221)
That rather assumes that untaxed wealth (as opposed to income) is productive wealth, which is not necessarily the case. And that even if it were, there's an assumption that the (perhaps valid) concerns are the priority and not the introduction of a fairer system.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Friday June 03, 2022 @04:50PM (#31613447)
> There’s a reason wealth taxes are not popular in OECD countries.

Well, there are two reasons: the Prisoner's Dilemma, and good old fashioned bribery (or "campaign financing" as we euphemistically call it).

Fortunately, however, the recent agreement for a global minimum corporation tax rate[0] shows that major economies can sometimes solve the coordination problem needed to avoid the "race to the bottom" that capitalists try to impose on nation states.

A modest proposal would be that the top 1% of wealth holders in the world would have to pay a 1% annual tax to their country of residence. The WTO could be tasked with determining the true wealth of any multi-millionaires who bribe national officials into under-reporting their holdings. Any country that defects from this agreement, and any multi-millionaire who hides in one of those countries, would be met with sanctions and treated like the corrupt oligarch that they are.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_minimum_corporate_tax_r...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:11PM (#31599280)
shrug and it riles some people up, which at least is entertaining. Most of us don't care.

Tbh, if you look at the performance of the queen compared to the performance of recent prime ministers, well, let's just say it's not a shining example of democracy at it's best.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:30PM (#31599486)
By that logic we should make Charles the Prime Minister and shut down parliament.

Maybe the reason the Queen is so respected is that she doesn't (visibly) exercise much power, and the lesson there is actually that Prime Ministers should be more limited in what they can do of their own volition (without broad consent from the public, in the form of a truly representative parliament and an independent judiciary enforcing a codified constitution).

Re:Who owns Parliament? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday June 02, 2022 @07:39PM (#31602046)
The only reason for the Queen to prorogue parliament when Boris was clearly lying about it --he was avoiding democratic dissent against him-- is to avoid making a kerfuffle that risked setting Tories against Royalists (these groups being largely coterminous). Basically, I felt she might be a person of upright morals and firm beliefs right up until that point; then she proved she's just doing everything to keep the money flowing for her family and didn't really care about 'her subjects' and so does not deserve our respect, not in the least.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dTal on Thursday June 02, 2022 @10:01PM (#31603342)
One wonders who the Queen's "advisors" are. They surely hold enormous power for how unknown they are.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:01PM (#31613567)
The "deep state" nature of the Queen's advisers[0] is the second dirtiest secret of the British monarchical system, after Queen's/Prince's Consent.[1]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privy_Council_of_the_United_Ki...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queen's_Consent#Vetting_of_bil...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:39PM (#31599589)
> By that logic we should make Charles the Prime Minister and shut down parliament

Uh huh. I think reductio ad absurdum wants to have a word.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by arlort on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:25PM (#31598679)
> they own huge parts of the country

And they would keep owning them if they were made to abdicate

Re:Who owns Parliament? by basisword on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:33PM (#31598804)
Only if we let them.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by simonh on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:38PM (#31598879)
We could always confiscate your property while we're at it. Every little helps. After all there can be few on this forum that aren't in the upper decile of wealth globally. Property is theft!

(er, kidding in case that wasn't obvious)

Re:Who owns Parliament? by nicoburns on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:50PM (#31599012)
The more pressing issue with land ownership in the UK is that we don't even know who owns large chunks of it.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by MockObject on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:04PM (#31599201)
American here. How is that a pressing issue?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:19PM (#31599363)
It makes it harder to introduce a land value tax, I guess?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by eadmund on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:27PM (#31599451)
Does it? Seems like if the State doesn't know who owns a piece of land, it can just auction it off.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:39PM (#31599594)
If the state were so keen to serve the interests of the public, it would have auctioned off this land already, regardless of whether a land value tax had popular support.

I suppose I'm hoping that if people knew who really owned the country, and who would be the winners and losers of a LVT, there would be such strong support for one that it would be politically untenable to oppose it.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by MockObject on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:44PM (#31599648)
If the state really doesn't know who owns a piece of land, what's stopping someone from squatting? Wouldn't the owner have to prove ownership to the state, to activate law enforcement?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by simonh on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:36PM (#31598841)
As I said, peripheral procedural and technical issues aside that make no real difference.

The idea that these mean we have no democracy is absurd, and does no credit to the reasonable arguments for disestablishmentarianism.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:34PM (#31599523)
I believe that disestablishmentarianism is usually understood to refer solely to the question of whether the Church of England should be the Established (i.e. state) church.

There are probably some antidisestablishmentarianists who disagree with that definition, though.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:29PM (#31599473)
Unfortunately not politically irrelevant at all. The Queen has directly interfered in legislation, and she also has a weekly chat with the PM every week.

It's unlikely they talk about tea and biscuits.

But the real issue is that the Queen legitimises hierarchy and privilege. Instead of modelling democratic authority and meritocracy, she models the opposite - vast inherited wealth and land ownership, without accountability.

She is also the head of the armed forces, who swear an oath of loyalty to her personally - not to Parliament, and certainly not to the people of the UK.

In the UK she has Sovereign Immunity, which means she literally cannot be convicted of any crime. She can't even interviewed.

None of this would be a problem if she was in any way outstanding, but unfortunately the Royal Family have made some exceptionally poor choices. The Prince Andrew trial - and his $12m bailout - is just the most recent scandal in a long series of shady events and associations.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dTal on Thursday June 02, 2022 @10:06PM (#31603382)
>a weekly chat with the PM every week.

To be fair, a weekly chat at any other frequency would be quite eccentric!

Re:Who owns Parliament? by EliRivers on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:56AM (#31606291)
"She is also the head of the armed forces, who swear an oath of loyalty to her personally - not to Parliament, and certainly not to the people of the UK."

Speaking as someone who was just such a person (although at the time I did it, in the service I was in, there was no loyalty oath at all), while I can see the issue with this, I would really not have felt comfortable going on record as loyal to parliament or the the people of the UK. We should just bin it entirely; it's a job, with legal conditions and requirements. No need for any weird oaths.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:35PM (#31598020)
> ordinary britons would notice zero change

But that only proves that what we have now is an elective dictatorship where the Prime Minister of the day effectively exercises all the powers of the sovereign, without any real accountability or separation of powers.

Removing powers from the Queen (or even just codifying them in a written constitution) would be the first step towards fixing this democratic deficit and allowing the people to choose someone more suitable to hold those powers, with a proper mandate to support them.

The particular reform I propose is introducing a "Governor General" role for the UK, who has the power to veto laws, treaties, and wars, but remains nominally answerable to the Queen just as the Prime Minister pretends to be. To be eligible for the role, candidates would need to be nominated by 20% of MPs, and they would be elected in a national election using the Supplementary Vote method.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by waylandsmithers on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:26PM (#31598701)
> elective dictatorship where the Prime Minister of the day effectively exercises all the powers of the sovereign, without any real accountability or separation of powers

(As an American) this is a more pessimistic view of how it appears to me. Maybe I'm being naive but the voice of the people does appear to provide accountability. The idea that David Cameron felt the need to resign after the Brexit vote because he no longer had the support of the public seems like a big deal to me. We're not really big on admitting defeat over here.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by pmyteh on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:08PM (#31599250)
It's complex. There's nothing really to stop a British prime minister going full dictator if they want, as long as they can get Parliament to pass an Enabling Act. And that's not an entirely fanciful proposition: they have the support of a majority of the House of Commons pretty much by definition and the Lords have very little power in practice.

Our constitution is built on the so-called 'good chap theory of governance', which is that power is in the hands of people 'like us', and therefore reasonable. If the PM loses a vote of no confidence he's obliged to resign. What makes him? Nothing. But that's the convention and it's been followed until now.

It's also a constitutional convention to resign from ministerial office if caught lying to Parliament. (Yes, really!) That one, though, looks defunct: Boris Johnson is a serial liar, and has managed to get himself referred to the Privileges Committee of the Commons for lying over his lockdown breaches despite his majority in the Commons. Will he resign? Will he hell. He doesn't want to, and all the Commons can do is bring the whole government down (and even then only if he is prepared to resign then). He's made it clear he doesn't care, and the Conservative Party in the Commons has made clear they're not willing to face an election over it, so that's that.

A similar thing happened over the Prorogation of the House just before Brexit. That was fairly straightforwardly a contempt of Parliament, and the advice to prorogue was found to be unlawful by the Supreme Court. But nothing of consequence happened to those in charge as a result.

I'm grateful our political culture isn't quite as buggered as that of the US at this point, but I'd be grateful for slightly stronger guardrails against misconduct than simply hoping it doesn't happen.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by PeterisP on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:11PM (#31602962)
"as long as they can get Parliament to pass an Enabling Act" is a huge qualifier - if the elected representatives are agreeing to it, that's not a dictatorship, and in UK no act of parliament can't bind itself or a future parliament from changing its mind at any point of time, so that dictatorship would last from an Enabling Act until a Disabling Act.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by pmyteh on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:06AM (#31606756)
It is a big qualifier, but not entirely that big. Yes, it would mean that the decision to start the dictatorship was democratic, but you could definitely arrange it so there is no Disabling Act. Don't forget that to pass such an Act would need the Royal Assent, which the government is now in a position to refuse. Yes, that's a breach of constitutional convention, but we'd be well past that point.

So the plan goes something like this: pass the Statute of Proclamations[0], optionally repeal by proclamation section 4 of the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022[1] to keep your complaisant Parliament in place indefinitely, optionally make a proclamation preventing them from meeting, definitely refuse Royal Assent to a Disabling Act, and then govern by decree as you please.

Obviously this isn't failsafe in any way. Dictatorships aren't stable just because they've got legal cover, and the politics would need to be carefully managed. But there's nothing in our constitution that would prevent it.

[0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proclamation_by_the_Crown_Ac...

[1]: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2022/11/enacted

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:14PM (#31599309)
> But that only proves that what we have now is an elective dictatorship where the Prime Minister of the day effectively exercises all the powers of the sovereign, without any real accountability or separation of powers

No it doesn't. It just means it's irrelevant to ordinary life.

What they have has no bearing on how I live. Zero. Nada. Zilch.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by vasco on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:27PM (#31597897)
They are not irrelevant in the sense that they are a declaration of the nation that there are special people by birth. In a society so worried about equality, it is appaling that multiple countries in europe not only have populations that leave under monarchy, but that they seem to be in favor.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by hef19898 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:15PM (#31598546)
None of that monarchs is involved in actual legislative, executive or judicative activities. Sure, they are heads of state, but that's where it stops. European monarchs don't write laws, don't sign laws, are not part of the elected government.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by karencarits on Thursday June 02, 2022 @05:23PM (#31600682)
> European monarchs [...] don't sign laws [...]

At least in Norway, laws have to be signed by the King and the prime minister (with a few exceptions); for example, in 1975 the King did not sign a law passed by Parliament/Stortinget and the law did not become effective (this was, however, a special occation related to a strike where the two parts found an aggreement after the law was passed by Parliament but before it was signed by the King and the prime minister, so the government recommended the King not to sign). See https://lovdata-no.translate.goog/artikkel/vil_kongen_nekte_...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by hef19898 on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:01AM (#31605891)
We have a similar situation with German President, our head of state. The president has to sign laws once they are passed by both chambers of parliament. Usually Presidents sign, almost, whatever is put in front of them. Quite some time ago government had a phase when they tried to pass laws that were later struck down by the constitutional court. That prompted the then President to do some due dilligence and return proposed laws to parliament. Needless to say politians were not amused.

That being said, our Presidents have not real power in the legislative process, pretty much like most Monarchs do.

Playing this process, like in your example, is fair game if doesn't happen all the time.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday June 02, 2022 @07:46PM (#31602120)
In the UK laws are signed into being by the monarch, formally they're like writs from the monarch about what they wish. Parliament and the legislature are just advisors. It's a bad look for a country claiming to be democratic.

The monarch chooses the PM, it's 'her majesty's government' according to law and tradition; she refused Australia's choice of PM in the past IIRC.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by karencarits on Thursday June 02, 2022 @08:26PM (#31602464)
> It's a bad look for a country claiming to be democratic.

Perhaps, but rather bad looking than bad functioning; I'm not intimate with how the Stuart Restoration worked, but the monarchy in Norway was introduced in 1905 by vote and has been widely popular since. If the monarchy and its role in the constitution and the sosicety have continuous support by a majority of the population, then it is a good look for a country claiming to be democratic?

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:53PM (#31599740)
> European monarchs don't ... sign laws

That may be technically correct (the best kind of correct), but the details are more interesting:

"Since the sixteenth century no [British] monarch has actually signed a Bill themselves. Instead, the monarch signs what are known as Letters Patent which announce that an assent has been given."

https://www.open.edu/openlearn/society-politics-law/law/what...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by plonk on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:38PM (#31598079)
Seems like their special status is more of a burden today.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by krona on Thursday June 02, 2022 @04:56PM (#31600406)
If I were prime minister I think having to have a private in-person chat with the monarch every week would probably have a profound impact on how I went about running the country on her behalf.

It's like a schoolchild having to explain themselves to the headmaster.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:14PM (#31613696)
The relevant observation here is that you, and most schoolchildren, and most prime ministers, have a capacity for self-awareness and a sense of shame.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by teknopaul on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:58PM (#31599130)
If you got rid of the monarchy tomorrow you could bet your life that Tory government would be immediately selling of assets to buy voters.

There is little other reason to keep the monarchy, but that's enough.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dTal on Thursday June 02, 2022 @10:11PM (#31603412)
The foxes are in charge of the henhouse. Tory party members and the monarchy - two intimately related groups characterized by extravagant and unearned privilege. There is little point in reforming just one.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by exdsq on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:47PM (#31598984)
We don’t have a written constitution, so if you remove all the pomp and tradition it’s highly likely some things do actually go wrong as people forget they’re meant to happen.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by simonh on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:04PM (#31599206)
The US constitution is a handful of pages, and only a few lines actually specify how the government should function on a day to day basis. If they forgot everything but the constitution and worked out everything else again from scratch, the result would likely be completely unrecognisable.

Furthermore there's an argument to be made that the UK system of government is considerably more modern that that of the US. After all, their system is essentially a direct copy of the UK system of the time, with a few minor tweaks. The house is parliament, the Senate is the House of Lords, and the President is an elected King George V. Signing laws is Royal Assent, dissolving the House is Prorogation, he can even pardon criminals. I say George V specifically because the powers of the crown have been massively reformed since, really from Queen Anne onwards, but the US system has remained frozen in time.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by exdsq on Thursday June 02, 2022 @07:11PM (#31601756)
That’s true of the US but ignores the fact only 3 countries in the world don’t have written constitutions - the UK, New Zealand, and Israel. I’m not being sarcastic when I say a lot of this is managed in the form of strange old traditions that, if stopped, would render the country fairly useless till they’re all codified somewhere.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by PeterisP on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:18PM (#31603028)
"would render the country fairly useless till they’re all codified somewhere"

Not really, almost all of the things done by government for the daily management of the country are not related to the constitution and are already codified.

You would need to figure out, agree and codify a mechanism for changing power, but you can arrange it so that you have years to do it and codifying that small part is not that huge of a task; USA had long conventions but that was more because of the need to actually create a country; and many other countries post-revolutions have functioned quite reasonably while codifying the constitutions, because it really doesn't affect the daily things, and you can run on interim rules (in UK's case, continuing as before for a limited time) until it's done.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by lambertsimnel on Friday June 03, 2022 @03:12AM (#31605165)
Don't Canada and Sweden also lack written constitutions?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:23PM (#31613815)
"According to ... the Constitution Act, 1982, the Canadian Constitution consists of the Canada Act 1982 (which includes the Constitution Act, 1982), acts and orders referred to in its schedule (including in particular the Constitution Act, 1867...), and any amendments to these documents."[0]

"The Basic Laws of Sweden (Swedish: Sveriges grundlagar) are the four constitutional laws of the Kingdom of Sweden that regulate the Swedish political system, acting in a similar manner to the constitutions of most countries. ... Together, they constitute a basic framework that stands above other laws and regulation, and also define which agreements are themselves above normal Swedish law."[1]

You're right, though, that sounds a lot like the arrangement that Israel has, and the Wikipedia article for the "Basic Laws of Israel"[2] says (without citation):

"Israel is one of 6 countries (along with Canada, New Zealand, San Marino, Saudi Arabia and the United Kingdom) that operates entirely or in part according to an uncodified constitution..."

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Canada

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Laws_of_Sweden

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Laws_of_Israel

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:18PM (#31599340)
Living in the US, and looking at how (for example) their second amendment has ruined their society, but it's considered heresy to countenance change to the holy document, I really don't want the UK to go down that path.

There are places with written constitutions that have turned out better than the US one, but if you look at parallels between the UK and other nations, the US is the most likely one for the UK to follow. That way lies ruin.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by engineer_22 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:38PM (#31599573)
The US Constitution has been regularly amended since the beginning. Your claim that it would be heresy falls flat here.

2nd amendment ruined society, exactly how? The US still enjoys the largest economy and military in the world respectively. Religious and personal freedoms are codified in law. What is in ruins?

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:58PM (#31599788)
I didn't claim that amending the constitution was heresy. I claimed that removing the second amendment is heresy. And I stand by that.

[edit: on re-reading, the above is not true. I meant to claim that removing the 2A was heresy. My bad]

Look, this is just an opinion, but from the outside looking in, your society is frankly awful at looking after its people, and the everyone-gets-a-gun made sense a few hundred years ago with frontier justice, but certainly doesn't today. The gun culture doesn't create (as claimed) a "polite society", it creates a society based on fear, where everything is much more dangerous because guns are, at least potentially, involved.

I've been stopped by the police twice in my lifetime for speeding - once when I was a kid just passed his test, once a decade or so ago driving up the 280 to SF Airport and running late. The one in the US was a far more fraught affair - I suddenly remembered advice to keep your hands visible, don't make any sudden moves, etc. etc.

In contrast the UK one was a walk in the park. Got the ticket, the policeman even cracked a joke to reduce the tension, and the worst part was telling my mother (I was still driving on her insurance).

That's an anecdote, not data, but it's a microcosm of any interaction with the police. Over here every tinpot town has military hardware and SWAT teams because the criminals might have guns, the police are poorly trained in general, SWAT teams included, and the interaction between police and policed is far more tense, controlling and authoritative as a result. Because of guns being so prolific, the Peelian principles of policing are pretty much impossible to apply, and so US police do their job with overwhelming force for the given situation and employ fear as a standard tactic...

Every shopkeeper is more alert for guns; Another anecdote: I was being driven from McCarrean airport to a hotel in Vegas for a trade show before I started living here, and my cab driver pulled out in front of someone, who chased him, got alongside and pulled a gun (!!!). My cab driver pulled one right back at him (!!!!!!). They yelled at each other and went their different ways. Could have gone a lot differently. This sort of thing doesn't happen in civilized society.

> The US still enjoys the largest economy and military in the world respectively. Religious and personal freedoms are codified in law

Well, great ? It doesn't change how American society interacts. And the abuse of "religious freedoms" to oppress people is another huge problem in American society in general. I wouldn't go claiming that one, personally.

To be clear, I didn't mean that the 2A was the only reason American society is ruined, but it's more along the lines of (with apologies to EI, this is from memory):

"The gun doesn't kill people, people kill people"

"Well, yes, but the gun helps, doesn't it? I mean, if I walked up behind someone and yelled BANG! they're not very likely to drop dead, are they ? They'd have to be pretty dodgy on the old ticker for that to kill them"

In the same way, the 2A hasn't killed American society, but it helps.

Feel free to disagree :) I don't really care about fake internet points, and I realize this isn't a popular opinion in America, but from the outside looking in - y'all are nuts.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by mmcdermott on Friday June 03, 2022 @11:43AM (#31609856)
The Second Amendment isn't well represented, by either side of the political aisle. The original intent wasn't for frontier justice, recreational hunting or self-defense. The second amendment was a check on government power, no different than the checks and balances between different branches. An armed populace was always a potential risk, the idea was that freedom was worth that risk.

The core societal question is do we still believe that?

If one believes that it isn't, then the constitution should be amended to reflect the tradeoff between safety and security the populace is willing to accept.

If one believes it is, then one must look for other ways to moderate risk and accept that any group that has power will sometimes abuse it.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by engineer_22 on Sunday June 12, 2022 @07:53AM (#31713812)
You claimed American society was in ruins. You have failed to support that claim.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by mijkal on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:55PM (#31603305)
I'm American. And I agree with everything you've said.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by jaywalk on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:45PM (#31599658)
You live in the US, but refer to "their" society as if you're not a part of it. So if "their" society is in ruins, why do you choose to continue living there? Surely you can head off to any number of countries that would suit you much better, and allow you to be a part of their society.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @04:01PM (#31599820)
Ah, the old "if you don't like it, leave" advice.

Well, in life, you might come across some situations where running away isn't really an option. I've got an (American) wife who likes it here, and a kid whose schooling I don't want to interrupt.

Yes. If it were just me, I'd leave. I've made enough millions that I could live quite happily back in my home country, but, you know... Life. Not just your own opinion counts...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by jaywalk on Thursday June 02, 2022 @04:32PM (#31600159)
So then maybe "society is in ruins because people are allowed to own things I don't think they should be allowed to own" is a bit hyperbolic, yes?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @05:14PM (#31600585)
shrug you have your opinion, am I not entitled to my own ? And since when did not liking something mean you weren't entitled to criticise it ?

American society is screwed up, IMHO. A large part of that is due to the policy of fear used by authorities, due to guns, and another large part is due to the wide "independent" streak within the society - I put it in quotes because it's really just selfishness, and guns are the poster-child for that attitude.

shrug Nothing I say can matter, I can't even vote, but it doesn't mean I don't have eyes to see.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by exdsq on Thursday June 02, 2022 @07:09PM (#31601741)
Do you know how many countries have unwritten constitutions? Hint: it’s the same number of countries that will use the Metric system after Boris has his way.

(Answer is 3, albeit they’re different sets apart from the UK)

Re:Who owns Parliament? by throw2597 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:32PM (#31597988)
There are very real issues that would be solved, not abstract ones like in the article above. See, for example, https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/series/queens-consent
Re:Who owns Parliament? by bsedlm on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:17PM (#31597746)
I'd argue that while the current generation of nobles may in fact have done nothing much to earn them, they do have ancestors that fought bitterly, and in some cases quite sleazily, to earn and keep their privilege.

the idea that "all men are equal" is not really true in Europe. And it's only supposedly true in America

Re:Who owns Parliament? by eadmund on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:32PM (#31599498)
> the idea that "all men are equal" is not really true in Europe.

It's not really true in reality. Some folks are stronger, some faster, some more intelligent, some have more social connections, some are more charismatic. Even if we lived in a Harrison Bergeron dystopia there would be some inequality somewhere.

I kind of admire an idealised British system which recognises inequality and attempts to channel it to good ends. I think the House of Lords as it was prior to 1911 made a lot of sense; I think that the honours system makes a lot of sense. I think that there's a lot to be said for having a monarch who is powerful in theory but weak in practice and a prime minister who is weak in theory although powerful in practice.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by keybored on Thursday June 02, 2022 @04:22PM (#31600045)
Some people are also more wicked, less empathetic, more manipulative, and more opportunistic.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by bsedlm on Thursday June 02, 2022 @05:46PM (#31600918)
it's supposed to be equal before the law... which it's not real in practice anywhere either. Usually one's networth changes the law, at least in Europe they're upfront about it.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by keybored on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:42PM (#31598918)
I can’t tell if this is supposed to be even more of a scathing condemnation compared to what OP said.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by Mikeb85 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:20PM (#31597791)
There are some republics in Europe that did indeed overthrow their royalty/aristocracy...
Re:Who owns Parliament? by goatcode on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:23PM (#31597845)
And others that thought they did, only to find that they were the arms and legs of an even more brutal and incomprehensible regime.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by Mikeb85 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:52PM (#31598257)
And eventually those nations got rid of those too.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by keybored on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:42PM (#31598910)
Really? Which ones?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by goatcode on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:20PM (#31597790)
The longer you live, the more you realize Thrasymachus was right. There is no order except for what the generations forget that their ancestors pretended was order, alongside the peace you build and maintain with your next-door neighbors.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dan-robertson on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:21PM (#31597826)
> We've never been a democracy

I’ve definitely heard it argued that the brief commonwealth between Charles I and II was the first modern democracy, where ‘modern’ means a system somewhat like current democracies rather than ‘after 1500’.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by notahacker on Thursday June 02, 2022 @08:40PM (#31602606)
That's a stretch. England was technically a republic, and had technically become a republic over the issue of Parliamentary privilege.

But in practice what happened is that a Parliament purged of royalist sympathisers got little done before being dissolved at gunpoint by a general and replaced it with a council of "holy men" picked by the Army, then that council decreed that the general should have all the powers the king had previously enjoyed bar the title (which he later turned down) and then he ruled much like the previous king, convening Parliaments only when he saw fit, before his powers were inherited by his son despite his son's lack of aptitude for using them or support. Arguably the most democratic bit of the lot was ironically the restoration of the monarchy (passed by a less-restricted Parliament, due to a shift in the balance of military power, and generally considered to have been popular with the wider public). The UK already had the tradition of Parliaments elected by a narrow franchise passing legislation, the only difference is that it became senior military figures convening them and shutting them down. And whilst Parliamentary and military factions clashed over many things, they all agreed that movements raising crazy notions like non-landowning classes having voting rights needed to be suppressed

First modern military coup d'etat might be closer to the mark.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by olivermarks on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:50PM (#31598225)
May be of interest in relation to the opaque nature of British history -

The City of London’s strange history Lord Glasman on what the Romans did for the Square Mile

https://www.ft.com/content/7c8f24fa-3aa5-11e4-bd08-00144feab...

Alway interesting to try to read the tea leaves on the relationship between the two UK entities who run the two sovereign states - the palace and the city of London

Re:Who owns Parliament? by euroderf on Friday June 03, 2022 @11:32AM (#31609704)
Amen to that. The more you know about the City of London (which is NOT the city of London), the fishier the whole setup sounds.

"An ancient, semi-alien entity lodged inside the British nation state." "The last of England's rotten boroughs."

Predating Parliament and not subject to it. Kinda makes ya wonder if the entire purpose of Brexit was to resist any hint of financial regulation by the EU.

Over the years The Guardian has had a number of interesting articles about the City, such as [1].

[1]https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2011/oct/31/corpor...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dan-robertson on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:19PM (#31597779)
Today is a regular bank holiday. Only the Friday bank holiday is extra.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday June 02, 2022 @07:50PM (#31602153)
Isn't Thursday the BH Monday but moved, so not quite the regular BH either.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:55PM (#31598293)
I thank you for the correction.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by B1FF_PSUVM on Thursday June 02, 2022 @06:01PM (#31601066)
There in the UK you've had a republic for some six or seven centuries, your kings are mere entertainers hired and fired at will, as Charles I found out.

You do have a ruling class, but monarchy is not your problem. The Roman senators hated the Caesars with good reason, they gave the people too good a deal.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by pyuser583 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @08:24PM (#31602442)
England has had a de facto republic for about 350 years - since the end of the English Civil War.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by B1FF_PSUVM on Friday June 03, 2022 @07:34PM (#31615149)
Meh, I'd set it at the Magna Carta, but OK, sold, I know when I'm getting a good deal ;-)

This "constitutional monarchy" thingie has to be the most bare-faced ... ah, "truth" since comrade Augustus informed the Senate that the Republic was working normally.

Must be "turn-about is fair play" at work.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by etothepii on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:49PM (#31598208)
Of course it's underserved. But the person of the sovereign in the British system can be a unifying figure impossible with an elected Head of State.

Don't agree? Just look at how the red half of the US talk about Obama and the Blue half talk about Trump.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by joaonmatos on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:22PM (#31598636)
As long as you keep the Head of Government away from the sovereign, presidents can be harmless enough to avoid this kind of polarisation.

Maybe look at Ireland or Portugal as examples of republics where the president keeps the constitutional safeguards (dissolving parliament, vetoing laws, and what not), and you'll see that they are not exactly polarizing figures. Instead, the prime ministers are, as they should (they head partisan politics).

Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:53PM (#31598262)
I really don't care about that.

I also don't care about how dutiful the Queen is and what she's sacrificed to the role - though to be clear I do believe both those things at a personal level.

It doesn't matter what incidental good it accomplishes if it goes against the fundamental principles of equality.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by annyeonghada on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:54PM (#31599066)
Equality is not "a fundamental principle", this is a modern conception of how society should be run while fundamental principles are absolute and eternal.

Even going back to only 100 years ago the idea that "we are all equal" would have sounded ridiculous. As an example, we could take the accounts about the role of schools in various educational systems in Europe: it was widespread belief that the function of such institutions was to select the ἄριστοι - àristoi, from which it derives aristocracy - the best among the best. School was intentionally set up as an exclusionary institution, opposed to our "inclusive" endeavor: it was considered obvious, a "fundamental principle" even, that some people were better, in some sense or in another, than others.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:33PM (#31599509)
> Equality is not "a fundamental principle", this is a modern conception of how society should be run while fundamental principles are absolute and eternal.

Fundamental means foundational. But regardless of whether or not the definition you choose to follow (and they do vary) adds more nuance, it's pretty obvious what was meant by the phrase fundamental principle. And pretty obvious from the context that it was in fact referring to, as you put it, the "modern conception".

It really feels like you've picked up on a trivial phrasing at the cost of ignoring the intent, probably as a means of introducing some eloquent but irrelevant knowledge on etymology and derivation which adds nothing to the discussion.

It doesn't matter what it was like 100 years ago. We live now. And equality is fundamental to our current conceptions of an ideal democracy. Or foundational if you're still offended by the word choice.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by closewith on Friday June 03, 2022 @01:02AM (#31604484)
> The Republic guarantees religious and civil liberty, equal rights and equal opportunities to all its citizens, and declares its resolve to pursue the happiness and prosperity of the whole nation and of all its parts, cherishing all the children of the nation equally and oblivious of the differences carefully fostered by an alien government, which have divided a minority from the majority in the past.

From the Proclamation of the Irish Republic, 106 years ago.

> Even going back to only 100 years ago the idea that "we are all equal" would have sounded ridiculous.