News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:49PM (#31598211)
> They are politically irrelevant, a few completely peripheral procedural and technical issues aside that make no real difference in the grand scheme of things.

At the very least they own huge parts of the country, and the Queen has (and exercises as per recent Guardian stories) vetos and opt-outs of the laws the rest of us must follow.

Regardless of that, even as a basic principle our country reeks of deference and class.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by p10jkle on Thursday June 02, 2022 @01:55PM (#31598294)
They get 25% of crown estate profits, but I’m not sure they really ‘own’ that land per se. And in general, the elite own a huge amount of the UK (most notably Oxbridge colleges with incredible land ownership). We can make a case to take ‘back’ the Queen’s private or crown estate land, but why just them? IMO, casting judgement on what historic ownership is ‘rightful’ is really hard.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:22PM (#31598642)
We'd struggle to fairly take it back; probably not even worth trying. And whilst I never said so specifically I presumed it apparent that I never meant just the Queen. I accept I could have been clearer (sorry).

The first steps might be:

- An end to the honours system (entirely - even though many 'commoners' get them now it perpetuates the class concepts)

- Fair and universal application of inheritance tax to reduce the inequalities over the generations

- The taxation of assets (beyond a certain point so that people don't need to sell their home) and not just income

All those have arguments for/against, but it would be good for them to be honestly discussed and considered by those with the power to effect change.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by barry-cotter on Thursday June 02, 2022 @08:11PM (#31602354)
> The taxation of assets (beyond a certain point so that people don't need to sell their home) and not just income.

That’s a great way to discourage investment and capital formation and encourage emigration. There’s a reason wealth taxes are not popular in OECD countries.

https://taxfoundation.org/wealth-taxes-in-the-oecd/

Re:Who owns Parliament? by kcartlidge on Friday June 03, 2022 @03:17AM (#31605221)
That rather assumes that untaxed wealth (as opposed to income) is productive wealth, which is not necessarily the case. And that even if it were, there's an assumption that the (perhaps valid) concerns are the priority and not the introduction of a fairer system.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Friday June 03, 2022 @04:50PM (#31613447)
> There’s a reason wealth taxes are not popular in OECD countries.

Well, there are two reasons: the Prisoner's Dilemma, and good old fashioned bribery (or "campaign financing" as we euphemistically call it).

Fortunately, however, the recent agreement for a global minimum corporation tax rate[0] shows that major economies can sometimes solve the coordination problem needed to avoid the "race to the bottom" that capitalists try to impose on nation states.

A modest proposal would be that the top 1% of wealth holders in the world would have to pay a 1% annual tax to their country of residence. The WTO could be tasked with determining the true wealth of any multi-millionaires who bribe national officials into under-reporting their holdings. Any country that defects from this agreement, and any multi-millionaire who hides in one of those countries, would be met with sanctions and treated like the corrupt oligarch that they are.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_minimum_corporate_tax_r...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:11PM (#31599280)
shrug and it riles some people up, which at least is entertaining. Most of us don't care.

Tbh, if you look at the performance of the queen compared to the performance of recent prime ministers, well, let's just say it's not a shining example of democracy at it's best.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:30PM (#31599486)
By that logic we should make Charles the Prime Minister and shut down parliament.

Maybe the reason the Queen is so respected is that she doesn't (visibly) exercise much power, and the lesson there is actually that Prime Ministers should be more limited in what they can do of their own volition (without broad consent from the public, in the form of a truly representative parliament and an independent judiciary enforcing a codified constitution).

Re:Who owns Parliament? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday June 02, 2022 @07:39PM (#31602046)
The only reason for the Queen to prorogue parliament when Boris was clearly lying about it --he was avoiding democratic dissent against him-- is to avoid making a kerfuffle that risked setting Tories against Royalists (these groups being largely coterminous). Basically, I felt she might be a person of upright morals and firm beliefs right up until that point; then she proved she's just doing everything to keep the money flowing for her family and didn't really care about 'her subjects' and so does not deserve our respect, not in the least.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dTal on Thursday June 02, 2022 @10:01PM (#31603342)
One wonders who the Queen's "advisors" are. They surely hold enormous power for how unknown they are.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:01PM (#31613567)
The "deep state" nature of the Queen's advisers[0] is the second dirtiest secret of the British monarchical system, after Queen's/Prince's Consent.[1]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privy_Council_of_the_United_Ki...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queen's_Consent#Vetting_of_bil...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:39PM (#31599589)
> By that logic we should make Charles the Prime Minister and shut down parliament

Uh huh. I think reductio ad absurdum wants to have a word.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by arlort on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:25PM (#31598679)
> they own huge parts of the country

And they would keep owning them if they were made to abdicate

Re:Who owns Parliament? by basisword on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:33PM (#31598804)
Only if we let them.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by simonh on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:38PM (#31598879)
We could always confiscate your property while we're at it. Every little helps. After all there can be few on this forum that aren't in the upper decile of wealth globally. Property is theft!

(er, kidding in case that wasn't obvious)

Re:Who owns Parliament? by nicoburns on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:50PM (#31599012)
The more pressing issue with land ownership in the UK is that we don't even know who owns large chunks of it.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by MockObject on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:04PM (#31599201)
American here. How is that a pressing issue?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:19PM (#31599363)
It makes it harder to introduce a land value tax, I guess?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by eadmund on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:27PM (#31599451)
Does it? Seems like if the State doesn't know who owns a piece of land, it can just auction it off.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:39PM (#31599594)
If the state were so keen to serve the interests of the public, it would have auctioned off this land already, regardless of whether a land value tax had popular support.

I suppose I'm hoping that if people knew who really owned the country, and who would be the winners and losers of a LVT, there would be such strong support for one that it would be politically untenable to oppose it.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by MockObject on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:44PM (#31599648)
If the state really doesn't know who owns a piece of land, what's stopping someone from squatting? Wouldn't the owner have to prove ownership to the state, to activate law enforcement?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by simonh on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:36PM (#31598841)
As I said, peripheral procedural and technical issues aside that make no real difference.

The idea that these mean we have no democracy is absurd, and does no credit to the reasonable arguments for disestablishmentarianism.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:34PM (#31599523)
I believe that disestablishmentarianism is usually understood to refer solely to the question of whether the Church of England should be the Established (i.e. state) church.

There are probably some antidisestablishmentarianists who disagree with that definition, though.