News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by exdsq on Thursday June 02, 2022 @02:47PM (#31598984)
We don’t have a written constitution, so if you remove all the pomp and tradition it’s highly likely some things do actually go wrong as people forget they’re meant to happen.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by simonh on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:04PM (#31599206)
The US constitution is a handful of pages, and only a few lines actually specify how the government should function on a day to day basis. If they forgot everything but the constitution and worked out everything else again from scratch, the result would likely be completely unrecognisable.

Furthermore there's an argument to be made that the UK system of government is considerably more modern that that of the US. After all, their system is essentially a direct copy of the UK system of the time, with a few minor tweaks. The house is parliament, the Senate is the House of Lords, and the President is an elected King George V. Signing laws is Royal Assent, dissolving the House is Prorogation, he can even pardon criminals. I say George V specifically because the powers of the crown have been massively reformed since, really from Queen Anne onwards, but the US system has remained frozen in time.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by exdsq on Thursday June 02, 2022 @07:11PM (#31601756)
That’s true of the US but ignores the fact only 3 countries in the world don’t have written constitutions - the UK, New Zealand, and Israel. I’m not being sarcastic when I say a lot of this is managed in the form of strange old traditions that, if stopped, would render the country fairly useless till they’re all codified somewhere.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by PeterisP on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:18PM (#31603028)
"would render the country fairly useless till they’re all codified somewhere"

Not really, almost all of the things done by government for the daily management of the country are not related to the constitution and are already codified.

You would need to figure out, agree and codify a mechanism for changing power, but you can arrange it so that you have years to do it and codifying that small part is not that huge of a task; USA had long conventions but that was more because of the need to actually create a country; and many other countries post-revolutions have functioned quite reasonably while codifying the constitutions, because it really doesn't affect the daily things, and you can run on interim rules (in UK's case, continuing as before for a limited time) until it's done.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by lambertsimnel on Friday June 03, 2022 @03:12AM (#31605165)
Don't Canada and Sweden also lack written constitutions?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by dane-pgp on Friday June 03, 2022 @05:23PM (#31613815)
"According to ... the Constitution Act, 1982, the Canadian Constitution consists of the Canada Act 1982 (which includes the Constitution Act, 1982), acts and orders referred to in its schedule (including in particular the Constitution Act, 1867...), and any amendments to these documents."[0]

"The Basic Laws of Sweden (Swedish: Sveriges grundlagar) are the four constitutional laws of the Kingdom of Sweden that regulate the Swedish political system, acting in a similar manner to the constitutions of most countries. ... Together, they constitute a basic framework that stands above other laws and regulation, and also define which agreements are themselves above normal Swedish law."[1]

You're right, though, that sounds a lot like the arrangement that Israel has, and the Wikipedia article for the "Basic Laws of Israel"[2] says (without citation):

"Israel is one of 6 countries (along with Canada, New Zealand, San Marino, Saudi Arabia and the United Kingdom) that operates entirely or in part according to an uncodified constitution..."

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Canada

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Laws_of_Sweden

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Laws_of_Israel

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:18PM (#31599340)
Living in the US, and looking at how (for example) their second amendment has ruined their society, but it's considered heresy to countenance change to the holy document, I really don't want the UK to go down that path.

There are places with written constitutions that have turned out better than the US one, but if you look at parallels between the UK and other nations, the US is the most likely one for the UK to follow. That way lies ruin.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by engineer_22 on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:38PM (#31599573)
The US Constitution has been regularly amended since the beginning. Your claim that it would be heresy falls flat here.

2nd amendment ruined society, exactly how? The US still enjoys the largest economy and military in the world respectively. Religious and personal freedoms are codified in law. What is in ruins?

Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:58PM (#31599788)
I didn't claim that amending the constitution was heresy. I claimed that removing the second amendment is heresy. And I stand by that.

[edit: on re-reading, the above is not true. I meant to claim that removing the 2A was heresy. My bad]

Look, this is just an opinion, but from the outside looking in, your society is frankly awful at looking after its people, and the everyone-gets-a-gun made sense a few hundred years ago with frontier justice, but certainly doesn't today. The gun culture doesn't create (as claimed) a "polite society", it creates a society based on fear, where everything is much more dangerous because guns are, at least potentially, involved.

I've been stopped by the police twice in my lifetime for speeding - once when I was a kid just passed his test, once a decade or so ago driving up the 280 to SF Airport and running late. The one in the US was a far more fraught affair - I suddenly remembered advice to keep your hands visible, don't make any sudden moves, etc. etc.

In contrast the UK one was a walk in the park. Got the ticket, the policeman even cracked a joke to reduce the tension, and the worst part was telling my mother (I was still driving on her insurance).

That's an anecdote, not data, but it's a microcosm of any interaction with the police. Over here every tinpot town has military hardware and SWAT teams because the criminals might have guns, the police are poorly trained in general, SWAT teams included, and the interaction between police and policed is far more tense, controlling and authoritative as a result. Because of guns being so prolific, the Peelian principles of policing are pretty much impossible to apply, and so US police do their job with overwhelming force for the given situation and employ fear as a standard tactic...

Every shopkeeper is more alert for guns; Another anecdote: I was being driven from McCarrean airport to a hotel in Vegas for a trade show before I started living here, and my cab driver pulled out in front of someone, who chased him, got alongside and pulled a gun (!!!). My cab driver pulled one right back at him (!!!!!!). They yelled at each other and went their different ways. Could have gone a lot differently. This sort of thing doesn't happen in civilized society.

> The US still enjoys the largest economy and military in the world respectively. Religious and personal freedoms are codified in law

Well, great ? It doesn't change how American society interacts. And the abuse of "religious freedoms" to oppress people is another huge problem in American society in general. I wouldn't go claiming that one, personally.

To be clear, I didn't mean that the 2A was the only reason American society is ruined, but it's more along the lines of (with apologies to EI, this is from memory):

"The gun doesn't kill people, people kill people"

"Well, yes, but the gun helps, doesn't it? I mean, if I walked up behind someone and yelled BANG! they're not very likely to drop dead, are they ? They'd have to be pretty dodgy on the old ticker for that to kill them"

In the same way, the 2A hasn't killed American society, but it helps.

Feel free to disagree :) I don't really care about fake internet points, and I realize this isn't a popular opinion in America, but from the outside looking in - y'all are nuts.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by mmcdermott on Friday June 03, 2022 @11:43AM (#31609856)
The Second Amendment isn't well represented, by either side of the political aisle. The original intent wasn't for frontier justice, recreational hunting or self-defense. The second amendment was a check on government power, no different than the checks and balances between different branches. An armed populace was always a potential risk, the idea was that freedom was worth that risk.

The core societal question is do we still believe that?

If one believes that it isn't, then the constitution should be amended to reflect the tradeoff between safety and security the populace is willing to accept.

If one believes it is, then one must look for other ways to moderate risk and accept that any group that has power will sometimes abuse it.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by engineer_22 on Sunday June 12, 2022 @07:53AM (#31713812)
You claimed American society was in ruins. You have failed to support that claim.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by mijkal on Thursday June 02, 2022 @09:55PM (#31603305)
I'm American. And I agree with everything you've said.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by jaywalk on Thursday June 02, 2022 @03:45PM (#31599658)
You live in the US, but refer to "their" society as if you're not a part of it. So if "their" society is in ruins, why do you choose to continue living there? Surely you can head off to any number of countries that would suit you much better, and allow you to be a part of their society.
Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @04:01PM (#31599820)
Ah, the old "if you don't like it, leave" advice.

Well, in life, you might come across some situations where running away isn't really an option. I've got an (American) wife who likes it here, and a kid whose schooling I don't want to interrupt.

Yes. If it were just me, I'd leave. I've made enough millions that I could live quite happily back in my home country, but, you know... Life. Not just your own opinion counts...

Re:Who owns Parliament? by jaywalk on Thursday June 02, 2022 @04:32PM (#31600159)
So then maybe "society is in ruins because people are allowed to own things I don't think they should be allowed to own" is a bit hyperbolic, yes?
Re:Who owns Parliament? by spacedcowboy on Thursday June 02, 2022 @05:14PM (#31600585)
shrug you have your opinion, am I not entitled to my own ? And since when did not liking something mean you weren't entitled to criticise it ?

American society is screwed up, IMHO. A large part of that is due to the policy of fear used by authorities, due to guns, and another large part is due to the wide "independent" streak within the society - I put it in quotes because it's really just selfishness, and guns are the poster-child for that attitude.

shrug Nothing I say can matter, I can't even vote, but it doesn't mean I don't have eyes to see.

Re:Who owns Parliament? by exdsq on Thursday June 02, 2022 @07:09PM (#31601741)
Do you know how many countries have unwritten constitutions? Hint: it’s the same number of countries that will use the Metric system after Boris has his way.

(Answer is 3, albeit they’re different sets apart from the UK)