News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Monday May 16, 2022 @12:48PM (#31400102)
Tell me, what assets exactly are backing BTC which stop it from crashing just like Luna?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:00PM (#31400271)
LUNA minted trillions of brand new tokens within the span of a day or so rendering the token worthless. This is due to the way LUNA was tied to the algorithmic stablecoin UST. It was a true ponzi.

BTC's max supply is capped and the release schedule of new coins is fixed and predictable. There is no possible way that trillions of new bitcoins could suddenly be created.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:20PM (#31401376)
Luna crashed because people lost trust in it. The only reason people have trust in BTC is because other people have trust in it. If that ever changed, there is no actual use for a BTC, and they are thus intrinsically worthless.

Fiat currency has the backing of a government. The government demands certain payments of this currency in order to own land, and also for some extra rights like mineral extraction, fishing licenses etc. Thus, as long as the government is viable and can confiscate the land of those who don't pay, there will be demand for the currency, and it will be proportional to the value the government assigns to the property and the rate of tax.

Thus, the currency is stable, because you know at the end of the day, there will always be a buyer who needs to pay their taxes.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by peyton on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:39PM (#31402887)
I don’t understand your argument. What happens during hyperinflationary periods or other currency collapses? The government stops demanding payments?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:39PM (#31413192)
Monetary supply outstrips the government's ability to collect on it. It is usually done on purpose to benefit some ruling individuals or for strategic reasons to zero the value of a country's debt. But I challenge you to find any example where the hyperinflation didn't make sense to pursue to the people in charge of the money supply.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by rubyfan on Monday May 16, 2022 @06:47PM (#31404005)
A better argument might be fiat currency is stable because governments hold a monopoly on violence.

But governments can be poorly run so I suppose “stable” is not the right word.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by chii on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:24PM (#31404244)
> But governments can be poorly run so I suppose “stable” is not the right word.

no, but the currency belonging to a particular gov't is as stable as the gov't itself, so your statement is still true; vis a vis the Zimbabwe currency vs the US dollar.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by cma on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:28PM (#31404272)
An ad-hoc system of local warlords who take power isn't more stable, even with a blockchain.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by imtringued on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:08AM (#31408257)
What people refuse to believe is that a currency is actually a reflection of the real world. Yes there is some filtering going on and time lags can be huge but any well managed currency is only going to perform as well as the real economy.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by whatshisface on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:44PM (#31404375)
Fiat currency does not actually have the backing of a government. What could the UK do when the pound peg broke? Nothing but lose enormous amounts of money trying to hold it.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @10:02AM (#31410806)
Fiat currency isn't pegged to a specific value, but it does have government backing that gives it a baseline value.

Want to own a house? Even if you buy it with bitcoin, you're going to need fiat to pay for the property tax bill.

Get paid wages? Even if you get paid in bitcoin, you still need fiat to pay the income tax bill.

Sell something? Even if you sold it for bitcoin, you still need fiat to pay the sales tax.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by derangedHorse on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @10:33AM (#31411280)
The government doesn’t give it a baseline value, it just has the power to force people to use the national currency when doing business involving legal affairs and the like (which may help bring up its value). Even then, I know of 3rd world countries that prefer the US dollar for all day to day (peer to peer) transactions even when the local government has their own currency established.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by neltnerb on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:29PM (#31405003)
What scenario involves the UK losing an enormous amount of money would be one where they are attempting to "hold a peg"?

I'm confused. Countries manipulate their currency supply in various ways in order to make their money cheaper or more expensive, I get that. But I thought the main goal was to keep exports or imports to a good balance to avoid wrecking a real economy. Like, actual people's lifestyles and jobs and well-being, beyond just the value of an investment instrument

I'm not sure I see the metaphor holding up here, isn't the issue that came up an arbitrage opportunity caused by a peg that in the real world doesn't really exist or which is easy for actual human beings to intervene in?

Are you describing what Russia did? Did they "lose money" with the actions they actually took? It seemed more about adding rules and changing contracts than by spending money on anything in particular, I'm not sure how one would calculate how much money they lost doing it. Or if that's a useful way to think about it really even, nations just have so many other priorities and their money policy is not at all algorithmic...

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by rntksi on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:37PM (#31405076)
GP is probably referring to this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Wednesday
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by neltnerb on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:47PM (#31405141)
Ah, thanks, very interesting.

So it sounds like this "ERM" is algorithmic enough that it broke things. It did get stopped due to human intervention though, so it feels like a weak metaphor.

I hope international currency markets aren't quite so fast... hopefully we won't find out.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by whatshisface on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:05PM (#31405285)
The very concept of a currency peg is that you sell things in exchange for the currency when it is not valued highly enough, and buy things in exchange for it when it is valued too highly. It wasn't the implementation that is algorithmic, it was the idea of a pegged currency itself that made Black Wednesday inevitable.

If a national government can't maintain the value of their currency, they aren't backing it, and if they have so much gold that they can maintain the peg no matter what happens, it isn't fiat (the gold standard is where the government will sell and buy gold at a fixed price, printing or destroying currency in the process). So I would conclude that fiat currencies aren't backed by anything.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by imtringued on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:11AM (#31408276)
Well pegs are stupid ideas. Just let the interest rate "float" into the negative range. That way your currency will remain stable while every other country inflated their currency to represent the same negative yield.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by squidbeak on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:12PM (#31404878)
It could leave the Exchange Rate Mechanism which created the conditions for the run. And it did. Fiat currency always has the backing of a government, as 'fiat' suggests.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by whatshisface on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:09PM (#31405312)
When the UK ended the ERM, they stopped backing the currency. The UK does not back the pound, the pound does whatever the market wants it to do.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by lottin on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:47AM (#31406144)
Not entirely. Central banks try to ensure price stability via monetary policy.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by samatman on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:46PM (#31402942)
To be perfectly clear, you're claiming with a straight face that government issued currencies are stable because there will always be a buyer who needs to pay taxes?

Any reasonable definition of stability precludes hyperinflation, we agree on that right?

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by iaw on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:19PM (#31404593)
Historically government backed currencies are are stable because they have two underlying components: an economy denominated in the currency and an implicit threat of force (e.g. standing militaries). It's one of the reasons the US dollar is the chief reserve currency around the world as well as the denomination in which oil is traded in.

You need dollars not because people have faith in them but because people have faith in the underlying institutions they represent. It's fine to claim you back bitcoin because you don't have faith in the traditional institutions but pretending that those institutions don't support dollars in a way that crypto/bitcoin isn't seems a little near-sighted.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by imtringued on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:16AM (#31408310)
Yes it would preclude hyperinflation. Of course, now we should ask ourselves what kind of situation results in the government having to spend more money into the economy than it is receiving back. Oh right, by not taxing those who have money. Money that doesn't circulate doesn't pay taxes. If you keep money in your bank account forever that money will never be taxed, the government will never see that money again. It must run a deficit, not because it is stupid, it must run a deficit because it is actively subsidizing an influential part of the economy and any refusal to pay the subsidy is harshly rejected not just by the rich but also by the poor.

The fact that inflation is the escape hatch for loss aversion psychology tells you that everyone on this planet is actively choosing for there to be inflation or even hyperinflation instead of a negative interest rate.

People will argue how immoral it is for a bank to tell you that your physical capital is slowly depreciating and thus even a 0% interest rate would be too high to offer to you. No, that would violate the principle of private property, private property of coupons that represent the time of other people, who are slowly aging and paying opportunity costs. People think they deserve to own the time of other people as if they were cattle or slaves. After all, their freedom to not be a debt slave violates your right to private property which is a far more pressing matter, after all the psychological bias of loss aversion justifies any hideous act (note how I didn't refer to immoral acts, as many hideous acts are considered moral).

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by BurningFrog on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:37PM (#31404696)
There are plenty of fiat currencies, backed by stable governments, that have become completely worthless. The Zimbabwean Dollar is the most famous one this century. There are plenty others.

This fully disproves your argument, as far as I can see.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:23PM (#31401410)
> Luna crashed because people lost trust in it.

No. It crashed because trillions of tokens were created rendering each token worthless.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by seoaeu on Monday May 16, 2022 @03:14PM (#31401997)
You have it backwards. The trillions of tokens were created because people lost trust in it. Specifically, the loss of trust instigated the price drop from $1 to ~98¢. That's what started the collapse. Only afterwards did the "death spiral" of minting of more tokens, which degraded trust, which decreased the price, which drove more minting, etc. happen
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by stickfigure on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:20PM (#31402705)
There were two coins involved; the overprinting of Luna corresponded with lost confidence in UST. The obvious conclusion is that "algorithmic" stablecoins are bullshit.

Whatever fate lies ahead for Bitcoin, it doesn't have this particular weakness. It's not "leveraged" in the same way as Luna/UST.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nwiswell on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:15PM (#31403213)
It's chicken and egg.

People lost trust because they knew people losing trust would cause a death spiral, and they wanted to get out before everyone else.

It was a fire in a crowded theater. Bitcoin depends on trust, yes, but there's no Damoclean sword like there was for Luna. Some people losing confidence does not necessarily lead to others losing confidence.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by _carbyau_ on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:11PM (#31405659)
Like toilet paper in a COVID pandemic... people were acting not because of the item itself, but because they knew how "the crowd" would react - a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by namdnay on Monday May 16, 2022 @03:09PM (#31401945)
You have the chronology wrong. The tokens were created because the price kept slipping, and the more the price slipped the more tokens were printed, the more people panicked etc
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:29PM (#31401485)
Then why did the total Luna market cap go down? Surely if people still had trust it should have just diluted the token values?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by orangepurple on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:42PM (#31401644)
Both can be true
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by kristopolous on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:35PM (#31402844)
That's not the point here. It's behaviorist.

Prices stay changed because the beliefs change.

If people had thought this was a sane and reasonable move that didn't really affect things the price would quickly return despite the quantity increasing.

The believed durability of the token changed

No matter what strategy is to be used to try to repeg it, it will only work if there's faith in the price.

Price isn't a thing it's a relationship between people about a thing

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by orangepurple on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:43AM (#31408072)
Price is the expected resale value of a good or service
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by asimjalis on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:51PM (#31405844)
Why were these trillions of tokens created? Wouldn’t that naturally lead to the token’s devaluation?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Strom on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:40PM (#31402898)
Bitcoin also has the backing of a government - El Salvador.

I would rather argue though that even government backed currencies are fully dependant on trust, not government usage of it. Just check out any government currency hyperinflation event.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:13PM (#31404171)
> Bitcoin also has the backing of a government - El Salvador.

A government backed currency means the government can issue that currency (for better or worse).

Bitcoin is legal tender in El Salvador, as is the US Dollar[1]. The US dollar is also legal tender in Zimbabwe and other countries.

We don't say the US dollar is backed by El Salvador or Zimbabwe. Instead it is backed by the "full faith and credit of the United States".

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/forex/040915/countries...

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nradov on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:41PM (#31403476)
El Salvador is a failed state about to default on its national debt. It's not a real "government" in the way that most of us would define the term.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by minsc_and_boo on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:01PM (#31415644)
El Salvador also doesn't use Bitcoin.

91% of El Salvadoreans prefer to use USD, and most stopped using Chivo (the privately-owned, government controlled wallet) after withdrawing their initial deposit.

https://www.elsalvador.com/noticias/negocios/el-salvador-bit...

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by el-salvador on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:52PM (#31405545)
> El Salvador is a failed state about to default on its national debt. It's not a real "government" in the way that most of us would define the term.

At least for now, El Salvador has enough cash on hand to pay the $800 million bond payable in February 2023. Current cash foreign reserves are about $3000 million.

I'd like to clarify though, that I'm not an economist, and that the processes required and implications of using those funds to pay the upcoming bonds due are outside my scope of knowledge.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Strom on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:06PM (#31404119)
What criteria of the definition doesn't El Salvador fulfill?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by filoleg on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:43PM (#31405502)
> What criteria of the definition doesn't El Salvador fulfill?

The one that is actually important when it comes to currencies, having something valuable (whether it is a resource, power, political influence, military, finances, etc.) to back the currency up with.

But on the most technical level, you are correct, El Salvador has the ability to back up BTC in the same capacity as a country like Zimbabwe can back up Z$.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by lottin on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:53AM (#31406176)
It doesn't have the resources nor a policy of "backing" bitcoin. By contrast, countries that issue their own currency have a central bank that is typically tasked with maintaining price stability, hence "backing" the currency.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by dmitrygr on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:36PM (#31403426)
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by jimmydorry on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:25PM (#31404251)
From the article, El Salvador has been cut off from financial markets by two of the ratings agencies that played a pivotal role in the corruption that caused the 2008 GFC to happen. Their reason for cutting El Salvador off is because their debt to GDP is approaching 87% (a fraction of what other countries have run up, especially due to COVID).

The IMF (International Monetary Fund) which typically steps in to offer predatory financing terms, already outlined their demands: drop Bitcoin support.

So El Salvador really must have gone all into Bitcoin, right? Yes, somewhere between 25million to 73million dollars worth (in contrast to their 800million dollar bond or the ~6billion dollars they raise in taxes each year [1]).

Oh the horror. There is definitely no geopolitical maneuverings here. /s

[1] Government Revenues in El Salvador increased to 6037.70 USD Million in 2021 from 4894.30 USD Million in 2020 https://tradingeconomics.com/el-salvador/government-revenues....

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:17PM (#31404584)
if bitcoin constitutes an insignificant portion of their activities, why would they oppose such a term?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by jimmydorry on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:52PM (#31405852)
One of their largest industries (up there with tourism) is remittance processing (mostly for out of the US) denominated in US dollars. Most of their local economy operates on US dolar too, which means accepting Bitcoin everywhere offers some significant advantages:

1. Not being beholden to the whims of American banks and the American government

2. Less administrative overhead would mean being able to offer more competitive services with lower fees [1]

3. Being Bitcoin friendly would attract more crypto oriented industries to be based out of their country: offering a wider market to tap into (global remittances)

[1] "Last year, they collectively transferred nearly $6 billion, or roughly 23% of the country’s gross domestic product, and a chunk of that went to the middlemen facilitating these international transfers." https://www.cnbc.com/2021/09/09/el-salvador-bitcoin-move-cou...

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by lottin on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:55AM (#31406190)
> One of their largest industries (up there with tourism) is remittance processing

What percentage of El Salvador's GDP does remittance processing represent?

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by jimmydorry on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:39PM (#31417110)
As I mentioned in my comment above (from the article) ~23%.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by lottin on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @12:35AM (#31419264)
Sorry, I didn't see it. 23% of GDP is the value of the remittances that enter the country. This does not mean that remittance processing (which is an economic activity) represents 23% of GDP. Remittance processing is likely a tiny fraction of GDP, since it's a low value added activity.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by romeros on Monday May 16, 2022 @06:45PM (#31403992)
Polycat finance only had 3 Million Tokens. That's the max supply. There will never be more than 3 Million Tokens. And yet the price tanked and will never ever recover. It traded at $60 a piece. Now it is trading in cents.

Quant has only 12 Million Tokens. No new tokens will ever be created. It topped at $400 a piece. Now it is trading at $72. It could go down all the way to fractions of cents.

Reality doesn't matter. Perception of reality is all that matters. Likewise, Bitcoin could only ever have a 21 M supply cap and it could end up trading in fractions of cents just like the above two coins in the future.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by pirate787 on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:22PM (#31401398)
No assets though-- the only thing backing bitcoin are "greater fools"
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by JKCalhoun on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:07PM (#31404128)
That actually sounds pretty sound then. I wouldn't have said/thought that a decade ago but of late I've begun to think that's a pretty good bet.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:24PM (#31401420)
Same fiat paper currency.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:32PM (#31401512)
As I said on the other thread, there is a government with a police force backing fiat. They also guarantee they will buy the fiat currency and in exchange give you the continued use of the land you own. This is why it is called 'fiat', which means backed by law or authority.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by vageli on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:34PM (#31402836)
Governments have demonstrated that they do not have to accept their own currency [0] and have demonstrated a willingness to drive the value of their currency down. [1]

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Indian_banknote_demonetis... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018%E2%80%932022_Turkish_curr...

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by throwanem on Monday May 16, 2022 @06:31PM (#31403897)
Fortunately, one side effect of being long BTC is that the owner of the position becomes immune to bullets, batons, laws, liens, and civil actions.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by thehappypm on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:37PM (#31401579)
Not really. You get to keep your property if you pay fiat to your local government every year. That is backstopping its value.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by mejutoco on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:54PM (#31401772)
You can pay your taxes with it at the very least.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by moistly on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:26PM (#31402771)
Wow. Talk about destroying any credibility you’d hoped to hold onto. Total foot-gun action.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by overtonwhy on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:01PM (#31402532)
If a majority of the miner pool decides to make a change the change is made. That's how decentralized concensus works right?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by meowkit on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:36PM (#31402857)
Well, not quite.

If a majority of miners fork their clients away from the bitcoin code repo by removing the coin cap, they would be creating a "new bitcoin". If the inter-subjective consensus of users also decide to use this new bitcoin it will be the defacto. Otherwise it will just be another fork (call it Bitcoin NoCap) like bitcoin cash, bitcoin diamond, bitcoin gold, etc.

The original "bitcoin" network (before the cap removal) would still propagate by whoever has the chain history.

The reality is that any attempts to split the chain to a state without a cap, at least with the current cultural consensus at this time, will result in a dead chain after a short period as people sell off the coins on the new fork.

https://www.investopedia.com/tech/history-bitcoin-hard-forks...

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by lottin on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:06AM (#31406254)
It does seem to me that bitcoin holders are highly impressionable by a small number of influencers. They could easily be convinced of anything.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by jtaft on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:10PM (#31400425)
Do you think the value of Bitcoin will go to zero due to lost private keys?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:23PM (#31400593)
I think it would sooner be rendered obsolete for another reason before this scenario.

It would take a long, long time for this to play out.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by wallacoloo on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:17PM (#31404581)
one usually hears the opposite argument: Bitcoin becomes more scarce as users lose their private keys. lost keys => smaller supply => higher price per unit. i can see the opposite argument though: lost keys => less desire to interact with bitcoin => lower demand => lower price per unit. so it might just be a wash.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:21PM (#31404608)
The former relationship wouldn't play out IRL, since there's no authoritative "lost bitcoin registry" to signal to buyers that the supply has effectively decreased
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by netheril96 on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:47PM (#31405146)
The buyers do not need to know about that. The effect of supply and demand on price doesn’t depend on anyone knowing supply and demand.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @12:10PM (#31424498)
the effect of supply on demand does indeed require that buyers know something about the supply

I mean, just think about it for a moment: how many bitcoins were "lost" today? Was it 0 or 100,000? Perhaps it's -100,000, because somebody gained access to 100,000 that were previously lost.

If it doesn't make a difference, then the supply isn't affecting demand

If it DOES make a difference, then demand can't be affected, because nobody knows whether it was 0 or 100,000 or -100,000

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by netheril96 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:46AM (#31432199)
The effect of supply and demand on price come from people bidding on the free market, not from anyone on the market knowing the global supply and demand.

If people have to know supply and demand to determine prices, how can free market work for thousands of years before the basic principle of economics is established?

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by wallacoloo on Thursday May 19, 2022 @07:55AM (#31433331)
say BTC rises from $30,000 to $300,000. two scenarios:

1. 10% of all BTC holders want to cash out. nobody lost their keys, so 2M BTC hit the “supply side” of the market.

2. 10% of all BTC holders want to cash out. half of them lost their keys, so only 1M BTC hit the supply side of the market.

this is the way it makes a difference. in the latter scenario, BTC spot price would likely reach a higher value.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by tw600040 on Monday May 16, 2022 @08:39PM (#31404703)
//BTC's max supply is capped and the release schedule of new coins is fixed and predictable

That doesn't mean it's not a Ponzi. One can run Ponzis with a cap and fixed/predictable supply increases..

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:12PM (#31400452)
> There is no possible way that trillions of new bitcoins could suddenly be created.

There absolutely is: fractional reserve banking. Exchanges are already operating that way. They offer loans, savings accounts and everything.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by chaostheory on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:33PM (#31400761)
Not a fan of Bitcoin, but you’re confusing Robinhood synthetic IOUs with Bitcoin. They are not the same thing.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:17PM (#31400512)
> There absolutely is

Banks and/or exchanges cannot create more bitcoin.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:20PM (#31400545)
Sure they can. You deposit 1 BTC, they loan it out to someone else. Boom, 2 BTC.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:25PM (#31400626)
No. There is still 1 BTC in this scenerio. When you choose to deposit your 1 BTC you've lost custody of it and somebody else has gained possession of it. All you have is a promise that you'll get it back - which is not === BTC.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:35PM (#31400781)
You said what happened to Luna can't happen to BTC because the BTC supply is capped. It's not. The inability to mine new BTC doesn't actually matter. The pseudobanks we call exchanges are still able to introduce numberless BTC into circulation through loans. The result is inflation and possibly market crashes in case of defaults. Really no different from what Tether and every other bank is doing.

I've written more detailed posts about this:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31375366

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:46PM (#31400953)
> BTC supply is capped. It's not.

Yes, it is. They are not introducing BTC into circulation. This is verifiable via the blockchain.

Banks creating IOU's or derivatives or whatever other abstraction they can come up with never generates new BTC. You'd hope that people foolish enough to work with such financial institutions would know the risk of possessing nothing but an instrument created by the bank. If you're unwilling to take custody of your own bitcoin, you better damn well do some good research on third party custodians.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:57PM (#31401107)
How much BTC exists in the blockchain is ultimately irrelevant. What matters is the amount of BTC actively circulating.

If you deposit 1 BTC on Binance, then I can get your BTC in the form of a loan. I can even withdraw your BTC. Meanwhile, Binance records still say you have 1 BTC, they even allow you to trade with it. So there's really 2 BTC in circulation. That BTC is duplicated, it's in multiple places simultaneously.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by warkdarrior on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:36PM (#31402853)
That is correct. And, fundamentally, this is possible because the Bitcoin chain is not the only ledger out there tracking BTC. Each (centralized) exchange has its own internal ledger, tracking how much BTC its customers have.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:33PM (#31401536)
And of course, the music keeps playing as long as Binance has liquidity.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by codehalo on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:12PM (#31402631)
Still doesn't have anything to do with Bitcoin, or the bitcoin supply.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Firmwarrior on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:31PM (#31405430)
They're explaining that your algorithmic science money is susceptible to the same forces that Crypto Faithful say turn USD into Fiat Clown Coins
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:29PM (#31404274)
In the non-blockchain space this is called "credit creation" and it absolutely is something that happens there.

But this doesn't happen with Bitcoin.

It's true that there are a number of DeFi apps that will loan BTC.

However if you look at the loan mechanism it is different to how it is done in traditional finance.

A BTC loan is done in one of two ways:

1) The original owner of the BTC is given an IOU in the form of a different token (lets call it "Wrapped BTC" or wBTC) and the original BTC token is given to the person taking the loan, OR

2) The person taking the loan is given another token ("wBTC"). This is more common.

In both these cases no new BTC is actually created. It's possible to create more of this other token though. In the specific case of wBTC[1] they say it is 1:1 backed with BTC, but other tokens might not have the same backing.

I don't have a strong opinion on the utility of BTC, but I think it is worth being accurate in our discussion.

[1] https://wbtc.network/

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Nursie on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:31AM (#31406056)
> But this doesn't happen with Bitcoin.

It doesn't happen on the bitcoin blockchain. Exchanges are black boxes though, we don't always know what's going on in there.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:06PM (#31416855)
No, that makes no difference.

If you think otherwise explain the mechanism you think is happening.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Nursie on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @09:50PM (#31418403)
Exchange has all customer deposits intermingled. Exchange offers crypto loans. Exchange shows positive balances across all users that exceed deposits (though may or may not balance out with negative balances).

Everything keeps functioning because the exchange is a black box and not everyone wants to move their BTC at the same time. More people can 'own' BTC on paper than there is BTC in existence on the blockchain.

In the same way that most BTC transactions don't involve the blockchain either, they take place entirely within exchanges.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @06:15AM (#31420992)
It's true this is how it would work if you are treating BTC as a traditional asset and creating dollars by loaning the same deposits out multiple times.

But for BTC you can't do this. If they have 100 BTC deposited from all their users and then try to loan out 101 that 101st transaction is impossible because the bitcoin isn't there.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Nursie on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:30PM (#31429669)
I'm sorry this is just nonsense, as has been pointed out many times, exchanges are not constrained by the blockchain of any particular cryptocurrency, most of their transactions don't take place on a blockchain and their customer balances are not stored on the various blockchains.

You may as well talk about this being impossible with paper money, the bank can't give out more than it has! There are only so many notes! But it doesn't need to. People can trade within the bank and between banks so long as the reserves cover the activities.

Quadriga CX worked this way, until it didn't and everyone discovered their cryptocurrency was fictional.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:11AM (#31431018)
> I'm sorry this is just nonsense, as has been pointed out many times, exchanges are not constrained by the blockchain of any particular cryptocurrency, most of their transactions don't take place on a blockchain and their customer balances are not stored on the various blockchains.

Sure, within the exchange that's true. The instance the BTC leaves the exchange as a loan or withdrawl it is no longer possible for that BTC.

> Quadriga CX worked this way, until it didn't and everyone discovered their cryptocurrency was fictional.

I don't think this was the case, unless you can show me otherwise.

In particular, they had "BTC ATMs" where people could withdraw cash. Note that this is not loaning BTC.

And when the CEO died, the BTC could not be retrieved. There was no magic second exchange-issued BTC around - it was gone because there is only one copy.

Notably there is a precise accounting of the BTC that was lost because there is a public ledger of it. Quadriga CX didn't produce any more BTC - they just lost their customer's BTC.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Nursie on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:20AM (#31443315)
> I don't think this was the case, unless you can show me otherwise.

Quadriga CX showed their users having BTC in their accounts.

In reality, the guy running the show had already gambled those away on other exchanges.

It all held together, ish, until he died and the music stopped.

> In particular, they had "BTC ATMs" where people could withdraw cash.

This is news to me and hasn't featured in any write-up of QCX I've ever seen.

> And when the CEO died, the BTC could not be retrieved. There was no magic second exchange-issued BTC around - it was gone because there is only one copy.

Yes, this is exactly what we're talking about - we have no real idea how much BTC is in peoples accounts on exchanges, because they are a black box and may be creating it out of thin air. While they don't try to move too much of it and the exchange remains operational, the ecosystem functions as if those balances are correct.

> Quadriga CX didn't produce any more BTC - they just lost their customer's BTC.

While they were still solvent it behaved as if there were more BTC present. Sure, they didn't create more on the blockchain, but they were able to operate as if there was more.

Until they weren't.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:42AM (#31444459)
> While they were still solvent it behaved as if there were more BTC present. Sure, they didn't create more on the blockchain, but they were able to operate as if there was more.

So as I said - they can't lend more than 100% of the BTC they have. They can make up anything want within their own exchange of course.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @10:21AM (#31423124)
> that 101st transaction is impossible because the bitcoin isn't there.

The exchange's BTC reserves only matter when customers try to withdraw their coins. Until then, the coins are nothing but digits in their database. They can inflate that number as much as they want.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @05:56PM (#31428149)
This might work inside the exchange, but doesn't work if you do a loan outside of the exchange.

In DeFi apps you need an actual token to use. If you don't have a the token you can't do a transaction, and apps choose which tokens they support.

So an exchange can create its own token, say it is backed 1:1 by BTC and lend that. But it isn't BTC so apps have to specifically opt into it.

If they loan out the actual BTC they have in the exchange they can only loan out 100% of what they have (not more) because control and use of each BTC token is dictated by the public ledger which is out of their control.

You can do other things (eg use the BTC as collateral for a dollar loan), but again you aren't lending BTC.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by MadcapJake on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:25PM (#31403309)
Laymen here: How can they introduce numberless BTC? I thought that was the crux of what makes this different from fiat: you can only transact from one address to another, no institution in between.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:53PM (#31404435)
I've written more detailed posts here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31375366

Accounting tricks, basically. They say you have BTC in your account when in fact your deposit is tied up in investments, loans.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by tasuki on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:21PM (#31412927)
This still doesn't change how many BTC are in circulation. When the fractional-reserve imaginary bitcoin implodes, it might even increase the price of actual bitcoin?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @10:17AM (#31423079)
> This still doesn't change how many BTC are in circulation.

It absolutely does. I can get a loan at an exchange while the original owners of those BTC still have it listed under their accounts. So multiple people can trade with the same coins, as if they had been copied.

> When the fractional-reserve imaginary bitcoin implodes, it might even increase the price of actual bitcoin?

Unknown. Perhaps.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:28PM (#31400678)
You'll have to explain how that's usefully different from the fiat context.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Karunamon on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:38PM (#31400842)
Because there's no such thing as unbacked BTC. You either have the UTXOs pointing at an address you hold the keys for, or you do not.

If someone loans you BTC, the supply of BTC has not increased.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:45PM (#31400942)
All bitcoin is "unbacked". There's no intrinsically useful asset behind bitcoin. Your private key is just a bundle of bits. Bits are so abundant as to be worthless.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:49PM (#31400989)
Same with paper fiat currency.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:55PM (#31401073)
I know? The point is: neither bitcoin nor fiat currencies are asset-backed. In both cases, there are commercial entities that offer accounts where you can deposit the "thing", and the "thing" is then loaned to someone else, and this is done for some kind of valuable inducement.

The question is: why is one called fractional reserve banking, a behavior that is acknowledged to increase the money supply, and the other one called "oh no this is definitely not increase of the money supply, it's just you relinquishing custody of your bitcoin and why would you do that, there's no reason you'd ever do that".

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:11PM (#31401256)
Actually paper fiat currency is accepted by a government to pay property tax. In this way you need it to keep possession of land, so the entire land value of the linked country, and all the infrastructure built on it, is the backing for 'fiat' currency.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by datadata on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:24PM (#31403298)
Accepting some form of unbacked currency does not give the currency intrinsic value and therefore make it backed. El Salvador made bitcoin legal tender, which means that USD or Bitcoin could be used to pay property taxes there, that doesn't mean that suddenly Bitcoin is backed by El Salvador property.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by el-salvador on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:38PM (#31405469)
> Bitcoin could be used to pay property taxes there

There are no annual property taxes in El Salvador :)

But this may be a technicality, based on the Salvadoran legal definition of the term. So it really depends on what is understood as tax in each jurisdiction.

El Salvador law differentiates between taxes and fees. Taxes are born from an "generating action", like selling a computer generates sales tax. While Fees are born from a "service provided" .

So there are monthly fees payable to the local city/town/village hall based on property size and location for services they provide in that area Some common ones are garbage collection, CCTV, city lighting, road maintenance and the contribution for each City/Town annual Festival. A monthly fee for each town's annual party :O Does that exist in other countries?

So once you get your city hall invoice, and wanted to pay in bitcoin, you'd have to visit the city hall to pay in their bitcoin terminal.

At least four city halls are connected to BitRefill which allows online invoice payments using Bitcoin/Lightning. BitRefill connects to a local payment network, then the user types or scans the Invoice barcode, and makes the bitcoin payment for the fees bill.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by peyton on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:49PM (#31402979)
I think I responded to your other comment, but I don’t think this is true. Do you have any further reading?

A currency is not backed by land value. It’s usually “backed” by a combination of sovereign debt obligations and its status as legal tender.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:02PM (#31403105)
I think that's right - fiat currency is not asset backed; in the case of the USD, it's backed by "the full faith and credit" of the U.S. government.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Karunamon on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:50PM (#31401010)
You know good and well what was meant, and that isn't it. Stop it.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:56PM (#31401098)
Actually, no, I literally have no idea what you meant - by all means, please amplify!
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by jacoblambda on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:01PM (#31405256)
Not OP but I figure I'll pitch in because nobody else explained it. When referring to backed vs unbacked Bitcoin (or any other UTxO accounting model based cryptocurrency), the "backing" isn't about whether the token is backed by another asset but rather whether your proxy holding of the token is backed by the actual cryptocurrency on the ledger.

If it's some wrapped Bitcoin that is backed, that means that there exists some UTxO which corresponds to the wrapped bitcoin tokens you hold. UTxO are atomic and unique so you can verify that your wrapped tokens have a 1:1 mapping to the tokens held within the UTxO on the native token's network. Non-backed bitcoin instead are just tokens that are handled through some minting mechanism where there is claimed to be a 1:1 equivalence without any actual tooling to prove that.

This concept of backing can actually even be further extended via Secure Multi-Party Computation where private keys can be collectively held in such a way that no user ever can see the private key but together they can coordinate to build and sign transactions with that private key without leaking it even to themselves. This can then be used to actually hold tokens from a foreign/incompatible network and interact with that network with little to any required trust.

Hopefully that helps answer what is meant.

---

Also since it's often a question asked I'll answer preemptively: "What is UTxO?"

I've mentioned the UTxO accounting model a few times here. Bitcoin doesn't have accounts but rather UTxO or Unspent(U) Transaction(Tx) Outputs(O). These are indivisible bundles of tokens that can only be created or consumed/destroyed atomically. There are no accounts but rather just private/public key pairs which can redeem/spend those UTxO. Additionally, all transactions are just a collection of input UTxO (that are consumed with the tx) and newly created UTxO. All Tx must uphold the rule that the sum of all inputs equal the sum of all outputs (or some equivalent of this rule as is the case for Monero's Zero Knowledge transaction proofs). A number of networks use UTxO or a UTxO extension (such as EUTxO or the cell model). Most famous is Bitcoin but Monero, Litecoin, Cardano, Ergo, Nervos, and a number of other networks also use this model.

This is opposed to Ethereum and co (Polkadot, Solana, Luna...) who use the balance-account accounting model. This model works like traditional ledgers where tokens are stored as some balance in an account and transactions are just transfers from one account to another.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:07PM (#31401223)
> If someone loans you BTC, the supply of BTC has not increased.

True when someone does it, false when a fractional reserve bank does it.

When someone loans money to someone else, money physically changes hands and there is no concept of a reserve. Banks are able to maintain the illusion of full reserves even though they operate in a state of perpetual insolvency.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:57PM (#31401806)
So is Binance a bank, when it offers 5% APY Bitcoin savings accounts? Or is it perhaps a shadow bank, which is to say an entity that creates money supply through credit without regulation?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Karunamon on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:19PM (#31401371)
Please explain the mechanism by which a "bank" is able to transfer to you an amount of BTC that they do not have wallet control over?

This is a critical difference. A bank can loan you fiat money that they do not physically have, with the almost always correct assumption that most people won't want to convert that database entry into cash at the same time.

This is not possible with bitcoin. Either the bank has the coins in wallets they control to send to a wallet you control, or they do not and can't.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:54PM (#31401770)
>Please explain the mechanism by which a "bank" is able to transfer to you an amount of BTC that they do not have wallet control over?

BTC that's in an offline wallet is like cash under the bed; and you're right that no-one is lending money that they have under the bed.

However, a significant number of BTC owners don't keep their money in their own wallets - they keep it at an exchange, which almost certainly commingles it with other owners in shared wallets.

You can certainly take a maximalist position here and assert that the exchange is the real owner, because they have the private keys. The fact of the matter is that the real world includes a difference between legal and beneficial ownership; and has done since well before the existence of fiat currencies - because it's useful.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Karunamon on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:39AM (#31406415)
That still is not the same thing. Coins in an exchange can only be traded for other coins in the same exchange - it's effectively KrakenBTC or BinanceBTC or [...]. Unlike fiat money in a bank, these exchange balances exist only in their walled gardens and cannot be exchanged for goods or services, effectively decoupling them from the total supply.

The total supply of bitcoin is the sum of all unspent transaction outputs on the Blockchain. Not what a bunch of exchanges tell their users they have.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @08:03AM (#31409219)
>Unlike fiat money in a bank, these exchange balances exist only in their walled gardens and cannot be exchanged for goods or services, effectively decoupling them from the total supply.

These are demand deposits with the exchanges/shadow-banks. You can (at least with some products; others look more like time deposits) withdraw your deposit at any time. This seems basically the same as a bank account where you can withdraw money at any time to buy goods or services.

I visit my "bank". I deposit my "currency" in a demand deposit account. I receive regular interest payments. My "bank" lends my "currency" to other people, in exchange for interest; presumably making a profit on the net interest margin. I can return to my "bank" at any time to withdraw my "currency".

How is this not credit creation? How is, e.g., Binance not operating as an unregulated shadow-bank without any kind of deposit insurance?

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by lottin on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @11:28AM (#31412143)
Note that the money supply increases simply as a result of banks not holding full reserves against deposits. Whether the bank lends or not is not important, as far as the money supply is concerned. The same applies to crypto-currency exchanges, of course, which can inflate the circulating supply of bitcoins by lowering the reserve ratio, regardless of whether they engage in lending.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Karunamon on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:04AM (#31431272)
You have to convert your Exchange!BTC into BTC to spend it on goods or services. In other words, it has to hit the blockchain. If it is not on the blockchain, then what is being transacted is BTC in name only.

You need not convert your bank balance into cash to spend it on goods or services. The balance itself can be used directly.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by lottin on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @11:06AM (#31411805)
If the bitcoins can be withdrawn at any time (i.e. without a notice of withdrawal), then these deposits are just like a current account, which means they are considered a component of the circulating supply of bitcoins (what we would call M1, if bitcoin was a currency).
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:48PM (#31404403)
> Please explain the mechanism by which a "bank" is able to transfer to you an amount of BTC that they do not have wallet control over?

They change a number in their database. All they have to do is edit the entry that records how many BTC you have in your account.

Whether you can actually withdraw those funds is a completely different matter. They're totally available for trading though.

> the almost always correct assumption that most people won't want to convert that database entry into cash at the same time

> This is not possible with bitcoin

It is. Most people do not withdraw bitcoin either.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:33PM (#31400753)
First you'll have to explain to me why you would give somebody your bitcoin and allow them to give it to somebody else!
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by TomSwirly on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:59PM (#31401133)
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:42PM (#31400887)
Interest. Right now Binance is offering 5% APY for BTC savings. If you give them your BTC, you'll stack sats automatically.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by alecbz on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:46PM (#31400944)
You really don't need to explain why; it's enough to observe that people do it.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:36PM (#31400808)
... because they promise to give you back one BTC plus something else of value?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by TomSwirly on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:59PM (#31401123)
> There is still 1 BTC in this scenerio.

You simply do not understand finance. Consider Eurodollars as another example: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/eurodollar.asp

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by gardenhedge on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:38PM (#31402876)
> You deposit 1 BTC, they loan it out to someone else. Boom, 2 BTC.

Do you mean "they" purchase a second bitcoin with the second person's loan money? if not, where does the second bitcoin come from? (Hint: think about the blockchain)

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by kemotep on Monday May 16, 2022 @06:56PM (#31404063)
Bitcoin is fungible. That Bitcoin doesn’t have to be *exactly* yours but they update their ledger and loan 1 BTC to someone after you deposit your 1 BTC into the bank account. Based on the interest rate of that loan, the bank is giving you a cut in Satoshis. If you choose to withdraw the 1 BTC before the other person’s loan is pid back, they must provide you 1 BTC. They can choose to take that 1 BTC from someone else’s account or use the profits they make in loans and other financial transactions to provide you that 1 BTC.

On the blockchain, there only exists the 1 you deposited, the 1 that was loaned, and the 1 that was generated as profit by the bank. The blockchain tracks these transactions. The bank only has to settle these transactions when someone withdraws and when someone is depositing. Internally, there can be as many or as little transactions are as necessary.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by winkeltripel on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:50PM (#31401736)
If it is close enough for a real bank in USD, it's probably okay for an exchange in bitcoins, right? If the bank/exchange maintains a 5% reserve, every unit of currency can produce a multiplier/velocity of 20. Bank loans substantially increase the ability of businesses to fund activity.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by GaylordTuring on Monday May 16, 2022 @06:54PM (#31404047)
Nothing, but I guess I don’t have to tell you that, since your question seems rhetorical in Nature. However, what keeps BTC from crashing is the same psychological effect that keeps Twitter, Facebook, Nike, or Coca-Cola from crashing: Brand awareness.

Bitcoin sucks compared to many other cryptocurrencies, still it’s the most popular one because it was the first, because people know about it, and because people know that other people know about it.

Even if you could fork Twitter and put it behind a different domain name, for example , Twutter, and you would add some functionality that everybody would like to have (let’s say an edit button), most people would still go to Twitter.

If you could sell the rights to use the name Coca-Cola or Nike, even if you had to make it clear to the customer that the new product that you sold had nothing to do what so ever with old product, the names alone would be worth a couple of fortunes.

So what’s stopping Bitcoin from crashing is the brain virus (or meme if you want) that has infected hundreds of people around the globe and made them believe that other people will know about and believe that Bitcoin is valuable.

And since Bitcoin isn’t hooked up to a doomsday device like Luna and UST was, it can’t destroy itself.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Sebb767 on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:44PM (#31404367)
> And since Bitcoin isn’t hooked up to a doomsday device like Luna and UST was, it can’t destroy itself.

I think you undersell that point: Bitcoin has proven itself. A lot of currencies have come and crashed, had backdoors, hacks, hard forks etc.; Bitcoin is simple-ish and stable. It also the longest surviving crypto currency. So it wields a lot of trust and market power.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by thedudeabides5 on Monday May 16, 2022 @12:53PM (#31400171)
BTC is not pegged, that's the diff.

When you don't claim a value, you don't need a 'backstop.'

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:25PM (#31401444)
You always need a backstop, otherwise you only have scarcity and not intrinsic value. Scarcity gives value in a bull market when people want in, but only a backstop gives real intrinsic value in a bear market when people want out.

It isn't like you can reverse the mining process and get back the electricity which was used to mint your BTC or something.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:15PM (#31400480)
There were two pieces of this particular crypto asset framework. The first part was Luna, which was a generic coin with no pegging mechanism or backing assets. The second part was Terra, which was a USD-pegged stable coin.

The novelty was a guaranteed mint/burn mechanism across the two which was intended to maintain the peg on Terra.

As the prior poster correctly asserts, Luna was never pegged.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by paxys on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:25PM (#31403302)
Nothing is stopping BTC from crashing to zero, so why is it not crashing to zero?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by rednerrus on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:32PM (#31403385)
Because they continue to print Tether to prop the price up? Am I doing this right?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by chrismcb on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:21AM (#31405999)
Because there are enough people still buying it.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by postalrat on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:31PM (#31403379)
"Nothing is stopping BTC from crashing to zero" isn't true. Although it can still crash to zero.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by dmichulke on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:40AM (#31406118)
Let's make it clear that the dollar lost more often 99% of its value than bitcoin. And it never recovered.

I think this will hold in the future as well.

Or are you rather concerned with the volatility?

Because surely bitcoin crashed more often 80% than the dollar...

So pick your poison...