But governments can be poorly run so I suppose “stable” is not the right word.
no, but the currency belonging to a particular gov't is as stable as the gov't itself, so your statement is still true; vis a vis the Zimbabwe currency vs the US dollar.
Want to own a house? Even if you buy it with bitcoin, you're going to need fiat to pay for the property tax bill.
Get paid wages? Even if you get paid in bitcoin, you still need fiat to pay the income tax bill.
Sell something? Even if you sold it for bitcoin, you still need fiat to pay the sales tax.
I'm confused. Countries manipulate their currency supply in various ways in order to make their money cheaper or more expensive, I get that. But I thought the main goal was to keep exports or imports to a good balance to avoid wrecking a real economy. Like, actual people's lifestyles and jobs and well-being, beyond just the value of an investment instrument
I'm not sure I see the metaphor holding up here, isn't the issue that came up an arbitrage opportunity caused by a peg that in the real world doesn't really exist or which is easy for actual human beings to intervene in?
Are you describing what Russia did? Did they "lose money" with the actions they actually took? It seemed more about adding rules and changing contracts than by spending money on anything in particular, I'm not sure how one would calculate how much money they lost doing it. Or if that's a useful way to think about it really even, nations just have so many other priorities and their money policy is not at all algorithmic...
So it sounds like this "ERM" is algorithmic enough that it broke things. It did get stopped due to human intervention though, so it feels like a weak metaphor.
I hope international currency markets aren't quite so fast... hopefully we won't find out.
If a national government can't maintain the value of their currency, they aren't backing it, and if they have so much gold that they can maintain the peg no matter what happens, it isn't fiat (the gold standard is where the government will sell and buy gold at a fixed price, printing or destroying currency in the process). So I would conclude that fiat currencies aren't backed by anything.
Any reasonable definition of stability precludes hyperinflation, we agree on that right?
You need dollars not because people have faith in them but because people have faith in the underlying institutions they represent. It's fine to claim you back bitcoin because you don't have faith in the traditional institutions but pretending that those institutions don't support dollars in a way that crypto/bitcoin isn't seems a little near-sighted.
The fact that inflation is the escape hatch for loss aversion psychology tells you that everyone on this planet is actively choosing for there to be inflation or even hyperinflation instead of a negative interest rate.
People will argue how immoral it is for a bank to tell you that your physical capital is slowly depreciating and thus even a 0% interest rate would be too high to offer to you. No, that would violate the principle of private property, private property of coupons that represent the time of other people, who are slowly aging and paying opportunity costs. People think they deserve to own the time of other people as if they were cattle or slaves. After all, their freedom to not be a debt slave violates your right to private property which is a far more pressing matter, after all the psychological bias of loss aversion justifies any hideous act (note how I didn't refer to immoral acts, as many hideous acts are considered moral).
This fully disproves your argument, as far as I can see.
No. It crashed because trillions of tokens were created rendering each token worthless.
Whatever fate lies ahead for Bitcoin, it doesn't have this particular weakness. It's not "leveraged" in the same way as Luna/UST.
People lost trust because they knew people losing trust would cause a death spiral, and they wanted to get out before everyone else.
It was a fire in a crowded theater. Bitcoin depends on trust, yes, but there's no Damoclean sword like there was for Luna. Some people losing confidence does not necessarily lead to others losing confidence.
Prices stay changed because the beliefs change.
If people had thought this was a sane and reasonable move that didn't really affect things the price would quickly return despite the quantity increasing.
The believed durability of the token changed
No matter what strategy is to be used to try to repeg it, it will only work if there's faith in the price.
Price isn't a thing it's a relationship between people about a thing
I would rather argue though that even government backed currencies are fully dependant on trust, not government usage of it. Just check out any government currency hyperinflation event.
A government backed currency means the government can issue that currency (for better or worse).
Bitcoin is legal tender in El Salvador, as is the US Dollar[1]. The US dollar is also legal tender in Zimbabwe and other countries.
We don't say the US dollar is backed by El Salvador or Zimbabwe. Instead it is backed by the "full faith and credit of the United States".
[1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/forex/040915/countries...
91% of El Salvadoreans prefer to use USD, and most stopped using Chivo (the privately-owned, government controlled wallet) after withdrawing their initial deposit.
https://www.elsalvador.com/noticias/negocios/el-salvador-bit...
At least for now, El Salvador has enough cash on hand to pay the $800 million bond payable in February 2023. Current cash foreign reserves are about $3000 million.
I'd like to clarify though, that I'm not an economist, and that the processes required and implications of using those funds to pay the upcoming bonds due are outside my scope of knowledge.
The one that is actually important when it comes to currencies, having something valuable (whether it is a resource, power, political influence, military, finances, etc.) to back the currency up with.
But on the most technical level, you are correct, El Salvador has the ability to back up BTC in the same capacity as a country like Zimbabwe can back up Z$.
The IMF (International Monetary Fund) which typically steps in to offer predatory financing terms, already outlined their demands: drop Bitcoin support.
So El Salvador really must have gone all into Bitcoin, right? Yes, somewhere between 25million to 73million dollars worth (in contrast to their 800million dollar bond or the ~6billion dollars they raise in taxes each year [1]).
Oh the horror. There is definitely no geopolitical maneuverings here. /s
[1] Government Revenues in El Salvador increased to 6037.70 USD Million in 2021 from 4894.30 USD Million in 2020 https://tradingeconomics.com/el-salvador/government-revenues....
1. Not being beholden to the whims of American banks and the American government
2. Less administrative overhead would mean being able to offer more competitive services with lower fees [1]
3. Being Bitcoin friendly would attract more crypto oriented industries to be based out of their country: offering a wider market to tap into (global remittances)
[1] "Last year, they collectively transferred nearly $6 billion, or roughly 23% of the country’s gross domestic product, and a chunk of that went to the middlemen facilitating these international transfers." https://www.cnbc.com/2021/09/09/el-salvador-bitcoin-move-cou...
What percentage of El Salvador's GDP does remittance processing represent?
Fiat currency has the backing of a government. The government demands certain payments of this currency in order to own land, and also for some extra rights like mineral extraction, fishing licenses etc. Thus, as long as the government is viable and can confiscate the land of those who don't pay, there will be demand for the currency, and it will be proportional to the value the government assigns to the property and the rate of tax.
Thus, the currency is stable, because you know at the end of the day, there will always be a buyer who needs to pay their taxes.