News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:35PM (#31400781)
You said what happened to Luna can't happen to BTC because the BTC supply is capped. It's not. The inability to mine new BTC doesn't actually matter. The pseudobanks we call exchanges are still able to introduce numberless BTC into circulation through loans. The result is inflation and possibly market crashes in case of defaults. Really no different from what Tether and every other bank is doing.

I've written more detailed posts about this:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31375366

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:46PM (#31400953)
> BTC supply is capped. It's not.

Yes, it is. They are not introducing BTC into circulation. This is verifiable via the blockchain.

Banks creating IOU's or derivatives or whatever other abstraction they can come up with never generates new BTC. You'd hope that people foolish enough to work with such financial institutions would know the risk of possessing nothing but an instrument created by the bank. If you're unwilling to take custody of your own bitcoin, you better damn well do some good research on third party custodians.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:57PM (#31401107)
How much BTC exists in the blockchain is ultimately irrelevant. What matters is the amount of BTC actively circulating.

If you deposit 1 BTC on Binance, then I can get your BTC in the form of a loan. I can even withdraw your BTC. Meanwhile, Binance records still say you have 1 BTC, they even allow you to trade with it. So there's really 2 BTC in circulation. That BTC is duplicated, it's in multiple places simultaneously.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by warkdarrior on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:36PM (#31402853)
That is correct. And, fundamentally, this is possible because the Bitcoin chain is not the only ledger out there tracking BTC. Each (centralized) exchange has its own internal ledger, tracking how much BTC its customers have.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by snovv_crash on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:33PM (#31401536)
And of course, the music keeps playing as long as Binance has liquidity.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by codehalo on Monday May 16, 2022 @04:12PM (#31402631)
Still doesn't have anything to do with Bitcoin, or the bitcoin supply.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Firmwarrior on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:31PM (#31405430)
They're explaining that your algorithmic science money is susceptible to the same forces that Crypto Faithful say turn USD into Fiat Clown Coins
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:29PM (#31404274)
In the non-blockchain space this is called "credit creation" and it absolutely is something that happens there.

But this doesn't happen with Bitcoin.

It's true that there are a number of DeFi apps that will loan BTC.

However if you look at the loan mechanism it is different to how it is done in traditional finance.

A BTC loan is done in one of two ways:

1) The original owner of the BTC is given an IOU in the form of a different token (lets call it "Wrapped BTC" or wBTC) and the original BTC token is given to the person taking the loan, OR

2) The person taking the loan is given another token ("wBTC"). This is more common.

In both these cases no new BTC is actually created. It's possible to create more of this other token though. In the specific case of wBTC[1] they say it is 1:1 backed with BTC, but other tokens might not have the same backing.

I don't have a strong opinion on the utility of BTC, but I think it is worth being accurate in our discussion.

[1] https://wbtc.network/

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Nursie on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:31AM (#31406056)
> But this doesn't happen with Bitcoin.

It doesn't happen on the bitcoin blockchain. Exchanges are black boxes though, we don't always know what's going on in there.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:06PM (#31416855)
No, that makes no difference.

If you think otherwise explain the mechanism you think is happening.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Nursie on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @09:50PM (#31418403)
Exchange has all customer deposits intermingled. Exchange offers crypto loans. Exchange shows positive balances across all users that exceed deposits (though may or may not balance out with negative balances).

Everything keeps functioning because the exchange is a black box and not everyone wants to move their BTC at the same time. More people can 'own' BTC on paper than there is BTC in existence on the blockchain.

In the same way that most BTC transactions don't involve the blockchain either, they take place entirely within exchanges.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @06:15AM (#31420992)
It's true this is how it would work if you are treating BTC as a traditional asset and creating dollars by loaning the same deposits out multiple times.

But for BTC you can't do this. If they have 100 BTC deposited from all their users and then try to loan out 101 that 101st transaction is impossible because the bitcoin isn't there.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Nursie on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @09:30PM (#31429669)
I'm sorry this is just nonsense, as has been pointed out many times, exchanges are not constrained by the blockchain of any particular cryptocurrency, most of their transactions don't take place on a blockchain and their customer balances are not stored on the various blockchains.

You may as well talk about this being impossible with paper money, the bank can't give out more than it has! There are only so many notes! But it doesn't need to. People can trade within the bank and between banks so long as the reserves cover the activities.

Quadriga CX worked this way, until it didn't and everyone discovered their cryptocurrency was fictional.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:11AM (#31431018)
> I'm sorry this is just nonsense, as has been pointed out many times, exchanges are not constrained by the blockchain of any particular cryptocurrency, most of their transactions don't take place on a blockchain and their customer balances are not stored on the various blockchains.

Sure, within the exchange that's true. The instance the BTC leaves the exchange as a loan or withdrawl it is no longer possible for that BTC.

> Quadriga CX worked this way, until it didn't and everyone discovered their cryptocurrency was fictional.

I don't think this was the case, unless you can show me otherwise.

In particular, they had "BTC ATMs" where people could withdraw cash. Note that this is not loaning BTC.

And when the CEO died, the BTC could not be retrieved. There was no magic second exchange-issued BTC around - it was gone because there is only one copy.

Notably there is a precise accounting of the BTC that was lost because there is a public ledger of it. Quadriga CX didn't produce any more BTC - they just lost their customer's BTC.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Nursie on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:20AM (#31443315)
> I don't think this was the case, unless you can show me otherwise.

Quadriga CX showed their users having BTC in their accounts.

In reality, the guy running the show had already gambled those away on other exchanges.

It all held together, ish, until he died and the music stopped.

> In particular, they had "BTC ATMs" where people could withdraw cash.

This is news to me and hasn't featured in any write-up of QCX I've ever seen.

> And when the CEO died, the BTC could not be retrieved. There was no magic second exchange-issued BTC around - it was gone because there is only one copy.

Yes, this is exactly what we're talking about - we have no real idea how much BTC is in peoples accounts on exchanges, because they are a black box and may be creating it out of thin air. While they don't try to move too much of it and the exchange remains operational, the ecosystem functions as if those balances are correct.

> Quadriga CX didn't produce any more BTC - they just lost their customer's BTC.

While they were still solvent it behaved as if there were more BTC present. Sure, they didn't create more on the blockchain, but they were able to operate as if there was more.

Until they weren't.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Friday May 20, 2022 @03:42AM (#31444459)
> While they were still solvent it behaved as if there were more BTC present. Sure, they didn't create more on the blockchain, but they were able to operate as if there was more.

So as I said - they can't lend more than 100% of the BTC they have. They can make up anything want within their own exchange of course.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @10:21AM (#31423124)
> that 101st transaction is impossible because the bitcoin isn't there.

The exchange's BTC reserves only matter when customers try to withdraw their coins. Until then, the coins are nothing but digits in their database. They can inflate that number as much as they want.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by nl on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @05:56PM (#31428149)
This might work inside the exchange, but doesn't work if you do a loan outside of the exchange.

In DeFi apps you need an actual token to use. If you don't have a the token you can't do a transaction, and apps choose which tokens they support.

So an exchange can create its own token, say it is backed 1:1 by BTC and lend that. But it isn't BTC so apps have to specifically opt into it.

If they loan out the actual BTC they have in the exchange they can only loan out 100% of what they have (not more) because control and use of each BTC token is dictated by the public ledger which is out of their control.

You can do other things (eg use the BTC as collateral for a dollar loan), but again you aren't lending BTC.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by MadcapJake on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:25PM (#31403309)
Laymen here: How can they introduce numberless BTC? I thought that was the crux of what makes this different from fiat: you can only transact from one address to another, no institution in between.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:53PM (#31404435)
I've written more detailed posts here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31375366

Accounting tricks, basically. They say you have BTC in your account when in fact your deposit is tied up in investments, loans.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by tasuki on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @12:21PM (#31412927)
This still doesn't change how many BTC are in circulation. When the fractional-reserve imaginary bitcoin implodes, it might even increase the price of actual bitcoin?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @10:17AM (#31423079)
> This still doesn't change how many BTC are in circulation.

It absolutely does. I can get a loan at an exchange while the original owners of those BTC still have it listed under their accounts. So multiple people can trade with the same coins, as if they had been copied.

> When the fractional-reserve imaginary bitcoin implodes, it might even increase the price of actual bitcoin?

Unknown. Perhaps.