News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by JCM9 on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:04PM (#30961207)
Expecting a lot of armchair NTSB investigators to rock up here, but honestly not much indication on what happened until the appropriate authorities can pull the data recorders out of the aircraft and see what was going on.

Looking forward to reading what happened but until then…

Interesting observation that the controllers and pilots were speaking French to each other. They’re really not supposed to do that (English is the standard for ATC, in part so other aircraft can maintain situational awareness) but that happens a lot in France.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by radicaldreamer on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:18PM (#30961365)
Korean Air had crash after crash until they forbid crew from speaking in Korean. Turns out cultural norms (highly hierarchical power structure) and honorifics were causing copilots to refrain from pointing out issues or pointing them out in an unclear way.

A Colombian airline crashed in New York after running out of fuel due to similar deference to air traffic control.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by The5thElephant on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:59PM (#30961820)
That was a Malcolm Gladwell theory that has been debunked, particularly here: http://askakorean.blogspot.com/2013/07/culturalism-gladwell-...

In general I tend to question much of Gladwell's ideas these days seeing how many of them have been demonstrated to be wrong.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by yongjik on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:53PM (#30962373)
Malcolm Gladwell may have overstated his theory, but askakorean is itself a biased source, and IMHO shouldn't be trusted too much. It is a fact that (1) Korean Air had a string of preventable accidents during that time, (2) pilot hierarchy in communication was believed to be a major factor that led to the Guam disaster, and (3) later Korean Air mandated everybody to speak English in the cockpit.

How much (3) contributed to the improved safety record is anyone's guess.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by bakashi on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:53PM (#30963475)
The following are direct quotes from the blog post:

> So, out of the seven KAL crashes that happened in the 20 year span between 1978 and 1997, three were a result of a military or paramilitary attack. Those three crashes clearly have little to do with pilot skills. […] that Gladwell would use incidents of terrorist attacks to pad the stats is darn near offensive. It is as if New York is being described as extra-dangerous in the early 2000s by including the number of deaths from the 9/11 attacks. > Take a look at p. 204 of the report, which shows the point at which the pilots initiate their landing check sequence, thinking that they must be near the airport. For the next five pages--which ends with the moment of the crash--the pilots are communicating almost entirely in English. […] Gladwell explains that the new COO of Korean Air, David Greenberg (a former Delta Air Lines executive,) solved all the difficulties caused by the ambiguous Korean language by requiring the pilots to speak only in English. Gladwell writes: "In English, [the pilots] would be free of the sharply defined gradients of Korean hierarchy . . . Instead, the pilots could participate in a culture and language with a very different legacy." But Gladwell never reveals that Korean Air pilots were already speaking mostly in English, although that fact was absolutely plain from the transcript.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by yongjik on Friday April 08, 2022 @11:22PM (#30965030)
As I said, the blog makes weak arguments. This wikipedia page in Korean [1] shows seven KAL accidents in 1990s, with three of them causing deaths (one being the crash at Guam). If you went back in time and asked an average Korean "What do you think about KAL's safety records?" most of them would've said "This is unacceptable and something must be done!" Overall, Korea in the 90s was not a nice place, if your goal was staying alive.

Also, even the blog acknowledges that among the three incidents attributed to military/terrorist attacks, two of them started with pilot errors. KAL 902 was flying from Paris to Anchorage, but somehow made an almost 180 degree turn over the arctic, and ended up in Soviet airspace. It was shot at and forced to land on a lake: two died. The much more tragic KAL 007 also made a similar mistake, and was shot down, killing everyone.

I don't know about aviation, but among all the things a pilot should never do in the 70s-80s, I'd assume "fly into Soviet airspace unannounced" was pretty high in the list.

Also, if you look at the transcript of the Guam crash [2], it's hard to claim that pilots were communicating in 90% English. There's a lot of English, but they are technical words, like when you read off a checklist or verify readings. Everything that is unusual or requires a decision is spoken in Korean, like [all in Korean]:

> check the glide slope if working?

> why is it working?

> glide slope is incorrect

> since today's glide slope condition is not good, we need to maintain one thousand four hundred forty.

> not in sight

> let's make a missed approach [six seconds before impact]

From the transcript, it's clear that there was no way one could have said something like "The weather is too bad, let's go around" in English. Anything other than completely mechanical steps were decided in Korean.

Now, of course, that doesn't mean that Korean is inferior for communication or the culture is inherently flawed or whatever. But it seems reasonable to say that KAL had a company-wide culture of putting schedule over safety, and the hierarchy over pilots contributed to it. Because they were all Korean, the communication problem itself manifested in the Korean language.

Was it a stupid decision to ban Korean in the cockpit? Maybe, but if something is stupid and it works, then it's not stupid.

[1] https://ko.wikipedia.org/wiki/%EB%8C%80%ED%95%9C%ED%95%AD%EA...

[2] https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/...

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by jrockway on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:11PM (#30963988)
CRM is a hard skill to learn. It sounds easy on paper, but it goes against everything you've ever learned for how to have polite social interactions. Imagine you're an intern watching someone like Jeff Dean give a live demo, and you think the presentation is proceeding in a way that is going to cause a major outage. What do you do? I'm guessing that 99% of the time, you're not going to say anything. "He knows what he's doing" "It's not appropriate for me to interrupt a senior engineer's demo". Defeating that intuition is what CRM training aims to eliminate, and it takes a lot of work to override that hardcoded human behavior. (Even for Americans. I imagine it's even harder for Koreans.)

I'd really like to see # of hours of CRM training (and total training!) company wide vs. fatal accidents, and dig in even deeper to see if the training was even any good. (You could give every pilot 10 hours of bad training, and it wouldn't help the accident rate.)

Anyway, I'm sure someone has these numbers. My guess is that much more work was done than saying "just speak English" and the problem was magically fixed.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by khuey on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:50PM (#30964241)
> Imagine you're an intern watching someone like Jeff Dean give a live demo, and you think the presentation is proceeding in a way that is going to cause a major outage.

It's more like you're Guido van Rossum watching Jeff Dean give a live demo, and the presentation is proceeding in a way that is going to kill you, Dean, and 200 random people from the audience.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by markdown on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:05AM (#30965207)
> and the presentation is proceeding in a way that is going to kill you, Dean, and 200 random people from the audience.

Skipping a step here and there is rarely ever going to seem like it'll end in deaths of your and everyone else in the flight.

"We've flown this same route 2000 times before and never had an issue. My Captain is as old as my father and has been flying all his life. The weather is great, we're a little late, and he's probably right, skipping this pre-flight checklist this time isn't going to do any harm."

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by vishnugupta on Saturday April 09, 2022 @01:54AM (#30965557)
I'm unable to follow your assertion so please help me understand this.

> skipping this pre-flight checklist

Does this happen? My only knowledge about piloting is checklists are considered sacrosanct. Wouldn't skipping a checklist raise a red-flag?

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by markdown on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:44AM (#30966550)
Yes, considered sacrosanct. However, my point was that if you skipped one, it's not a certainty that it would result in death. So if a captain said they should skip a checklist, the first officer might defer to their judgement and not oppose that decision.

I was responding to a comment where it was implied that the decision was a definite life-and-death decision.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by radicaldreamer on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:01PM (#30961837)
Aw man, this is a real bummer. I thought I'd weaned myself off of Gladwell, but his fabulism is embedded in my memories from way back :( he's so good at it!
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by syntaxfree on Friday April 08, 2022 @11:02PM (#30964926)
The real L, as they say on Twitter now, is that we went so far on making scientific knowledge the only valid kind of knowing that fabulists must now come disguised as science (whereas in the past we all knew what Blavatsky, Gurdjieff, von Daniken etc were all about and could enjoy them for what they were).
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by jahnu on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:28PM (#30962146)
People really should be very wary of anything Gladwell says in recent years. The fisking The Bomber Mafia got should be evidence enough.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by jimmySixDOF on Friday April 08, 2022 @09:41PM (#30964538)
I didn't see a rebuttal which substantially affected his argument. Most of it was the typical bandwagoning against his pop-style storytelling method. Very few disputes of fact. If Gladwell is guilty of anything it is to place a finely tuned modernly biased reference frame onto past events that did not/could not exist at the time but do become increasingly visible with the benefit of hind sight in a way that helps readers connect today with lessons from the past. Call that inauthentic if you will, but I think there are valuable insights to be gained and am glad he reaches such a wide audience in spite of the intellectual backlashing.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by bigDinosaur on Friday April 08, 2022 @10:08PM (#30964660)
Well, the precise frustration people have with Gladwell (and his fans) is precisely this attitude. A very relaxed attitude towards rigorous evidence. I stopped paying a single bit of attention to him after the 10k hours claims, it was just mountains and mountains of poor or misleading evidence.

Believe in what he writes if you will, but I'm fairly certain that barely anything he writes is actually actionable.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by TedShiller on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:41AM (#30965310)
Malcolm Gladwell proved that he can make things look logical in hindsight, without the ability to have foresight. Which makes his conclusions entirely unimpressive.

I can tell you in very nice sounding, complex, and intelligent ways what yesterday's lotto numbers were, by the way.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by letitbeirie on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:56PM (#30964279)
It's not just Korean pilots though, deference to a KLM captain in the wrong was a critical link in the chain of events that led to the Tenerife disaster.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by mbubb on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:14AM (#30976695)
that is a very memorable incident - not least for the number of lives lost. I am not sure if it was deference as much as reverting to a native speech pattern in a critical moment.

"We are at takeoff" is what the pilot said and a native English speaker would have said something more like "We are taking off". A subtle difference - I grok what he was saying after the fact but in the moment the other's understanding was something like 'the KLM plane is currently at the starting point for takeoff'.

All these are just guesses on my part - I think of this incident often, particularly in terms of clarity and 'closed loop' comms under stress.

https://tailstrike.com/database/27-march-1977-klm-4805/

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by CamperBob2 on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:44PM (#30962868)
Wow, are all Koreans that bad at arguing? (/s) How do you even begin to compare a solitary sport like golf to the team effort involved in flying a passenger jet?

The influence of cultural imbalances on aviation safety is not a subject for debate, and hasn't been since the Tenerife disaster in which a junior officer hesitated to argue with a respected senior pilot. This blogger may be well-intentioned but they haven't bothered to do their homework. Point goes to Gladwell on this one, as flawed as his conclusions have been in other areas.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by aunty_helen on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:03AM (#30966090)
I think you should forward this on to the training departments of all major aerospace manufacturers.

I can distinctly remember being taught this during a human factors mandatory training during my time at one of the 3 engine manufacturers.

I’m sure they would like to update their FAA approved training schedules based on the new information from askakorean.blogspot.com

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by TedShiller on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:05PM (#30971526)
What Malcolm Gladwell is good at is telling you yesterday's lotto numbers in a way that sounds very sophisticated and intelligent.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by mbubb on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:57PM (#30961805)
some years back I worked on a project with Korean Air on exactly that topic, cockpit communication and honorifics... A compounding factor was that pilots and crew often came from military backgrounds.

I learned about a number of air disasters and PanAm/KLM crash[1] in Tenerife 1977 really stuck with me. In the transcript a Dutch pilot says something like "We are now at take off" when he was indicating that the plane was in the process of taking off. (an idiomatic way of expression)

There was already much stress on the situation as an incident at another airport caused massive traffic rearrangement across Europe. Under stress we revert to native ways of expression. I tried to keep this incident in the back of my mind throughout the project, and since...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenerife_airport_disaster

edit - include the transcrpt: https://tailstrike.com/database/27-march-1977-klm-4805/

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by tomatowurst on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:58PM (#30962428)
What is really maddening about Korean neo-confucian society is this automatic social hierarchy based on your age, as if to suggest someone who is older than you is automatically infallible and has authority over you. It was exported to Japan (Senpai and kōhai is a direct model of Korean sunbae, hoobae) but it doesn't seem to practice Confucianism this strictly, there really is no other countries that take it this extremely.

It reminds me of the Japanese invasion of Chosun dynasty, how the rigid military/confucian structure made communication impossible and largely allowed unopposed landings by Hideyoshi's army.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by yongjik on Friday April 08, 2022 @07:53PM (#30963893)
> It was exported to Japan (Senpai and kōhai is a direct model of Korean sunbae, hoobae) ...

Hmm I don't exactly know which way the terms were exported, but many people blame modern Korea's ageism on colonial Japan (at least partially), where the Japanese Empire tried to run itself as grandiose military barracks and trained everyone to be subject to the social hierarchy. Rigid hierarchy and hazing was a huge problem in the Imperial Japanese military.

The Joseon dynasty (1392-1910) had numerous issues but actually ageism wasn't as prevalent. Confucian scholars regularly made friends with each other over five or ten years of age difference. (You may think "so what?" but that pretty much never happens among students in modern Korea.)

Also, one reason that Joseon allowed Japanese landing at the start of the invasion of 1592 was that that division of the navy was led by Won Gyun, one of the worst admirals in Korea's history. Shortly after the war began he ordered his own fleet burned and ran away.

(Later, the legendary Yi Sunshin was imprisoned after being framed by Japanese espionage, and Won became the commander again. He then sailed the whole Korean fleet into a death trap at the battle of Chilcheonnyang, losing almost the entire fleet. Won ran away and likely died. We don't know exactly what happened to him.)

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by tomatowurst on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:55PM (#30964273)
Confucianism and ageism existed far before the 19th century, the fact is that Chosun dynasty was the result of a military coup when the general tasked with attacking a weakened the neighbor Yuan dynasty (China) struggled to maintain legitimacy and thus forced upon a new state religion called Confucianism that ousted Buddhism. It was under this system rigid hierarchies regarding one's class, education, ageism were enforced. You can see the difference from the earlier Korean kingdoms like Silla that imported and cultivated Buddhism leading to female rulers and greater tolerance for "LGBT".

Chosun was rife with corruption, rigid social hierarchy except through state examinations one could join the ranks based on skill and stability. It was very stable because of the oppressive social hierarchy based on neo-confucian ideals. The royalty were corrupt and immoral (with the exception of Sejong who created the Korean alphabet) and the last Chosun queen herself spent most of the state's treasury on luxury goods.

Not many missed the Chosun dynasty, well apart from North Korea which introduced many of its traditions (punishing 3 family generations of state designated criminals is from this era), ageism, caste, oppression of women, sexual minorities and male chauvinism. In fact Japan's colonialism brought more equality and ended caste system with meritocracy. Any modern claims of "collaborators" or such are moot, because it was a failed monarchy state and Korea simply was without any political direction.

Korea's success is economic success is largely owed to the Japan (the first capital investments and transfer of technology was from Japan to normalize relations) and its imperial economic system of zaibatsu (chaebol) and the 5-year economic plan that the strongman Park Chung Hee used was straight out of Manchukuo.

anyways just rambling on here as I eat pistachios about my understanding of korean history as an outsider on a friday evening.

y'all have a good weekend.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:03PM (#30963066)
It isn't based on individual age. I know Korean cousins with a 20 year age difference where the younger one gets the honorific because his lineage is older and he's an earlier generation. They never speak Korean with each other.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by tomatowurst on Friday April 08, 2022 @07:23PM (#30963701)
> It isn't based on individual age.

It is. you are using a special anecdotal case in a family situation (that same person would use honorifics towards their friends who are much older) to negate the rest of Korean society that uses one's age to decide who is above and below you, and the necessary honorifics. DK effect is quite laughable to see from a non-Korean.

I invite you to address your professor or sunbae or the elderly without honorifics and see their reaction. You wouldn't be able to use your race card very long.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by bmitc on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:09AM (#30965217)
From my vast expertise (sarcasm) from watching Kpop, Korean variety shows, and Korean movies, the whole age thing is pretty rampant and adhered to, at least from those lenses. I mean, they have literal discussions while shooting regarding asking direct ages in order to speak "familiar" or not. It is pretty weird and arbitrary, especially with the way Koreans measure age.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by tomatowurst on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:00PM (#30970936)
those media you consume are a reflection of society. koreans use honorifics with strangers until they signal they wish to communicate casually and usually its completely subjective. somebody will only differ by mere months and demand you use honorifics (bullying). somebody will differ by few years and do not enforce it. its completely subjective and adds to the stress of interaction between strangers.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by robocat on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:20PM (#30963218)
As a low-ranking middle aged average white guy from a small 1st world country: if I go to Korea can I get a status boost?

I have seen low-rank white dudes get status upgrades in other Asian countries for a variety of reasons. One architect told me how he was hanging with high status Indonesians, and how he could name-drop NZ politicians (for example, the minister of finance) because our culture means low-rank citizens can personally know people in high-rank positions. Perhaps I can manipulate the Korean status game in my favour because my background is somewhat unmeasurable.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by tomatowurst on Friday April 08, 2022 @07:24PM (#30963714)
No, they have a label for someone who tries to do what you described, they are called 루저벡홈 or literally "Losers back home", or typically a white person that uses their racial status exactly in the manner you described.

It might have worked in the 60s or in South East Asia but certainly will not work anymore in East Asia, especially in a hyper connected world. In fact many foreigners who achieved celebrity status by lying were quickly cancelled.

By large, a non-asian person in East Asia is largely limited to an exotic animal at the zoo. Somewhat of a novelty for kids and adults to point and laugh "wow! we have foreigners in our country speaking our language".

You would see the same response towards a monkey suddenly speaking Korean or Japanese.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by X6S1x6Okd1st on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:41PM (#30963385)
You'd exist largely outside of the neo confucianist status structure. You'd be a foreigner in a way that is hard to understand if you've spent all your life in the heterogeneous melting pots.

I'm many cases this would apply even if you are Korean but grew up outside the hierarchy (i.e. grew up in the US)

You'd have some status as a us citizen as a white person, but it's complicated and a double edged sword

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by abraae on Friday April 08, 2022 @09:05PM (#30964329)
A better place to get a status upgrade could be the UK. A New Zillund accent doesnt really slot in anywhere in particular in the Brit class system so you are granted a kind of free pass while they work out your abilities. (Experience from last century - may have changed!).
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by numpad0 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:09AM (#30965617)
If it's same as senpai/kouhai system I'm familiar with, it only works in an organization, and either you'll carry your batch number/generation ID/year joined in that org, or you're out of the system as an age-free subject matter expert.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by spacemanmatt on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:09PM (#30979869)
Heck of an admission, there.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by sbierwagen on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:06PM (#30961898)
>A Colombian airline crashed in New York after running out of fuel due to similar deference to air traffic control.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avianca_Flight_52

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by smachiz on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:38PM (#30962225)
Not just deference. They crashed without ever declaring an emergency. Ultimately, ATC could have been better - but that was a pilot CRM issue.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by GekkePrutser on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:05PM (#30973584)
The problem was that they didn't know the right phrases to declare an emergency. They kept saying "we're running out of fuel, sir". But meant they had not enough to go around.

Though I do agree that good airmanship would have been to tell ATC no and land the plane. A pilot may do that if lives are at risk.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by anonu on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:52PM (#30961742)
The Colombian airline crash: they were speaking English though. NYC ATC is going to be brusque and quick... The new Yorker way. Not many cultures understand that...
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by giraffe_lady on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:05PM (#30961884)
ATC needs to be effective for all cultures that fly into that airport. If the new york one so deviates from the norm that it can cause crashes that is a very serious problem that needs to be addressed.

That said I don't have any reason to think it actually does and you didn't supply one either. Are air traffic controllers even normally from the area where they work? Don't they get assigned?

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by kayodelycaon on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:14PM (#30961994)
Sadly, there was a compounding issue that the pilots didn’t declare an emergency or divert when they were running out of fuel. They thought asking for “priority” was sufficient, when the word has more urgency in their native language than it does in English. :(

New York controllers were more abrasive than they were used to and they had trouble speaking up. The controllers also didn’t communicate well amongst themselves and the pilots didn’t know their request for a sooner landing to due low fuel was not passed on.

Ultimately, the problem was the pilot’s failure to follow procedures. With the controllers being disorganized either due to lack of procedure or failure to follow it. Either of them could have prevented it.

Note: It is not sufficient to blame the pilots and move on. People make mistakes. Both sides need to be improved, because single points of failure kill people.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by avar on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:28PM (#30964095)
Two airlines pilots failing to use the specific word "emergency" isn't a single point of failure.

They then failed to tell passengers to brace before they crashed, which is thought to have contributed to injuries and even deaths.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by kayodelycaon on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:26AM (#30967878)
Not precisely, no. When it comes to pilot training or airline-wide problems, that becomes the point of failure.

The whole point is creating a defense in depth so one factor can’t take down a plane.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by FL410 on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:58PM (#30963015)
It’s not so much that they deviate from the norm (quite the opposite, there’s a manual that dictates exact phraseology), it’s just that there’s SO MUCH traffic that they don’t have time to hold hands, and they expect you to be competent. In other words, there’s very little time or room for error, and that can come off as rudeness.

It is always the pilot’s prerogative to overrule ATC (if there’s a legitimate reason) and/or declare an emergency. And I assure you NY ATC would take it seriously if you do. They just don’t have time to dance around.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by pininja on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:53PM (#30963476)
> Are air traffic controllers even normally from the area where they work? Don't they get assigned?

They are highly specialized on local facilities, weather, traffic flows, etc. The New York Metro area is one, if not the, most complicated airspace’s to control in the world. 4 major international airports (and tons of smaller airports/heliports) surrounding dense major cities with complicated weather, noise abatement procedures, and high congestion.

There are dozens of air traffic controllers of all different seats (supervisors, arrivals, ground, towers, helicopters) in the region. It’s a lot of coordinate.

This video gives a nice 3 minute overview: https://www.faa.gov/tv/?mediaId=1042

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by umanwizard on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:14PM (#30964015)
> 4 major international airports

JFK, LGA, EWR, what’s the fourth one?

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by rospaya on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:41PM (#30964185)
Just found out the other day that LaGuardia is limited in its international flights, just like Reagan National in DC.

It doesn't have US customs and border protection facilities.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by hansthehorse on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:46AM (#30969025)
Teterboro
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by cameldrv on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:48PM (#30962921)
In my experience the NY ATC can be brusque in a way that can border on the unprofessional, and they tend to have an accent that can be hard to understand if you're not from there and you're listening on your crappy AM aviation radio. I assume that would go double for a non-native speaker of English.

In the rest of the country that I've flown in, the controllers seem to be aiming for the voice of bored Apollo mission controllers.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by CPLX on Friday April 08, 2022 @07:32PM (#30963754)
I’m a private pilot that’s flown in NYC Class B repeatedly and trained here. I think the reputations are overblown and based mostly on the novelty of the accents and some amusing audio clips that have circulated for years.

Given the amazing volume they handle I’ve always found them nothing but crisp and professional.

If you’re also basing your opinion on those audio clips rather than actually asking for clearances or navigating the exclusions I think you might also have the wrong impression.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by andbberger on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:11PM (#30963135)
how high of a price are we willing to pay for kennedy steve
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by secondcoming on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:59PM (#30962433)
There are JFK ATC conversations on youtube. Even I, an native English speaker but not American, have difficulty understanding them sometimes. They also sometimes come across as being dicks, but obviously only the audience-worthy conversations get uploaded
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by mattr47 on Friday April 08, 2022 @10:43PM (#30964853)
All ATC should be brusque and quick, especially in high traffic environments.

The US Army's ATC units had the motto of "Safe, Orderly, & Expeditious."

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by tapatio on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:03AM (#30965598)
"we request priority to land" vs. "we request emergency landing" is what led to the Colombian airlines disaster.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by belter on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:12PM (#30962585)
"Pursuant to requirements of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), ATC operations are conducted either in the English language or the language used by the station on the ground. In practice, the native language for a region is normally used"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_traffic_control

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by chris_va on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:02PM (#30962481)
Generally ATC will switch to English when an English speaker comes onto the frequency, but local language is fine otherwise... country dependent, though. I haven't flow in France, but I understand it's mostly in French until someone calls in with English.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by GuB-42 on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:55PM (#30962977)
I have flown in France and you are completely right.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by dehrmann on Saturday April 09, 2022 @12:32AM (#30965288)
At CDG, wouldn't you assume there's always assume there's an English/non-French speaker on the frequency?
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by cft on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:40PM (#30961576)
I just visited a traffic control room in Spain and an air traffic controller told me that Spanish and Latin American pilots speak Spanish to them (not only for landing flights, but also for transit flights say from Argentina to Germany while overflying Spain), and the same thing is practiced in France and Italy. So I am not sure you are right about "really not supposed to".
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by t0mas88 on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:38PM (#30962234)
English is one of the official ICAO languages and it's mandatory for all pilots at least in EASA and FAA rules to be English proficient. But as far as I know it's not forbidden to use any of the other languages if both controller and crew speak that language.

Even the other way around, some small French airports have a listing as "French mandatory" for their radio frequencies. Which is quite a challenge for me as a foreign pilot not speaking French.

But overall it would be safer if all ATC comms were done in English. Because it's better for situational awareness if you can understand what others in the same airspace are doing.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by m2fkxy on Friday April 08, 2022 @07:32PM (#30963761)
> it's mandatory for all pilots at least in EASA and FAA rules to be English proficient

I would really like to know where you got this from. Been flying in France privately for 7 years, and not a single time have I been requested to speak English nor my aeronautical English skills had to be assessed for me to enjoy flying privileges.

Been also flying abroad, in northern Europe, where the local native language very much is the norm, unless a non-native is exchanging with ATC of course.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by t0mas88 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:01AM (#30967680)
Source: I'm a flight instructor :-) the rule you're looking for is FCL.055

It specifies that you cannot use your license privileges unless you have a language endorsement on your license for English or the language used for RT for that flight. So if you have not passed an English test you are only allowed to fly in French airspace and speak French.

Maybe the French authorities will issue you a basic PPL without LPE, assuming you'll only fly in France. But many other CAAs will not issue licenses like that, and some won't renew a license without it even if you historically got it without LPE.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by m2fkxy on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:29AM (#30968866)
Again, being proficient in English or in the radiotelephony language used in the country of flight, as per FCL.055, does not equate to "[English being] mandatory for all pilots at least in EASA and FAA", as you said.

I could very well fly x-country from France to Germany if I am aeronautically proficient in both countries' languages, yet not being so in English.

> But many other CAAs will not issue licenses like that (...)

I know for a fact that they do in Spain, France, Germany, and Finland.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by NovemberWhiskey on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:05PM (#30963953)
Are you instrument-rated? I believe it's an EU legal requirement for you to demonstrate functional competency in English for an instrument rating now.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by m2fkxy on Friday April 08, 2022 @08:13PM (#30964000)
I am not IR. English proficiency is indeed a requirement for IR, but then it is only a subset of aeronautical activity. Flying in France comprises a minor yet significant share of non-commercial, non-IFR operations.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by Thaxll on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:26PM (#30961444)
Pilots speak their own language in their country, everywhere else is in english.

Why Im being downvoted?

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by United857 on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:35PM (#30963337)
I flew a lot of flights on United where they have a feature in the inflight entertainment system where you can listen in on the ATC comms (if the captain turns it on). I've found that:

* French pilots generally speak in French in France or Quebec

* Russian pilots speak in Russian in Russia

* Mainland Chinese pilots speak in Mandarin in mainland China (but not in Taiwan or HK where English seems to be universal)

* Spanish/Latin American pilots speak in Spanish in those places.

Otherwise, it's generally English ATC including countries where it's otherwise not the native language, e.g. Japan, South Korea, Germany.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by Tuna-Fish on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:37PM (#30961548)
Because doing so is a terrible practice, and I'm saying this as someone who is not a native english speaker.

The communication between the tower and the plane is not just for their benefit. Everyone else is on the same frequency, listening in, and needs to be able to understand what is going on. Not everyone is going to be able to understand french, while everyone flying in controlled airspace is going to understand english.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by hef19898 on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:02PM (#30963055)
And France ain't a black hole like Africa when it comes to air traffic control. Also, using the language of the station is acceptable under official rules. French pilots speaking French in French air space are just fine.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by MobileVet on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:35PM (#30961534)
Because English is the official ATC language used world wide. You must know and speak in English to fly.

You may speak another language but English is first and relied upon.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by m2fkxy on Friday April 08, 2022 @07:37PM (#30963796)
> You must know and speak in English to fly.

This is absolutely incorrect! English proficiency is not a requirement if you are proficient in the official language of the country you are flying in. ATS provide services both in said-language and in English.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by GekkePrutser on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:10PM (#30973610)
At least in Europe you won't even get your PPL without an English proficiency test.

Unless you're born in the UK or Ireland that is. Because you're deemed native.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by m2fkxy on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:26PM (#30980769)
> At least in Europe you won't even get your PPL without an English proficiency test.

Yes, you will, in a number of EASA countries.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by DocTomoe on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:41PM (#30961593)
Point is, both of you are correct, and this argument is pointless. The native language is a common fallback during emergency situations, in situations where phraseology is insufficient, to expedite communication.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by physhster on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:21PM (#30962084)
In lots of countries, GA pilots don't speak English, but ATC does.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by bee_rider on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:49PM (#30962344)
Hey be nice, southern accents might be kind of weird, but technically people from Georgia (the state) speak English.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by mechanical_bear on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:30PM (#30962740)
GA = general aviation
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by coin on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:01PM (#30962457)
Because that’s not always the case. There are plenty of non-English countries that use English even for native flights, eg Japan and Taiwan.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by pc86 on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:36PM (#30961542)
Because you're wrong. The lingua franca of the air is English. I've heard ATC recordings in multiple countries and they're all in English, including ones between non-native English speakers. If you come on this frequency and you don't speak French, you have no context at all for what's going on. It's incredibly dangerous and it shouldn't ever happen.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by _moof on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:40PM (#30961574)
I'm afraid you're the one who is wrong. Yes, when a common language is needed, it is English, but native languages are explicitly allowed by EU law.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by smachiz on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:43PM (#30962281)
Common language is always needed - this is CDG, a large airport with many flights. It is important that all planes have situational awareness. If half are speaking French, how does the pilot coming from Seoul have situational awareness? What if he's sitting on the runway and doesn't know that the ATC just gave clearance to land in French to a pilot on the runway he's currently on?

ATC and pilots for commercial airlines should only be speaking English, regardless of their native tongue and where they are.

It's pretty important - and it is actually EU law: https://www.thinkspain.com/news-spain/29531/air-traffic-cont...

Unfortunately it only applies to airports with 50k international flights per year - the bar should be much lower than that. But of course, CDG qualifies.

Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by hef19898 on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:05PM (#30963080)
Situational awareness in controlled air space comes to a large degree from air traffic control. Not from listening to communicatiom between traffic control and other planes.
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com... by cameldrv on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:55PM (#30962979)
It's not consistent. I believe in some countries it's all English. In Germany, big airports are English, and small airports are German. In the couple of small airports I've flown out of in France, it's French.

I've heard of some countries where the controller will speak to you in whichever language you speak to them, which can lead to issues with situational awareness if you're the only one on the frequency speaking English and you don't know where all of the other planes are.