Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com...
by jimmySixDOF on Friday April 08, 2022 @09:41PM
(#30964538)
I didn't see a rebuttal which substantially affected his argument. Most of it was the typical bandwagoning against his pop-style storytelling method. Very few disputes of fact. If Gladwell is guilty of anything it is to place a finely tuned modernly biased reference frame onto past events that did not/could not exist at the time but do become increasingly visible with the benefit of hind sight in a way that helps readers connect today with lessons from the past. Call that inauthentic if you will, but I think there are valuable insights to be gained and am glad he reaches such a wide audience in spite of the intellectual backlashing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:B773 at Paris on Apr 5th, airplane did not respond to com...
by bigDinosaur on Friday April 08, 2022 @10:08PM
(#30964660)
Well, the precise frustration people have with Gladwell (and his fans) is precisely this attitude. A very relaxed attitude towards rigorous evidence. I stopped paying a single bit of attention to him after the 10k hours claims, it was just mountains and mountains of poor or misleading evidence.
Believe in what he writes if you will, but I'm fairly certain that barely anything he writes is actually actionable.