News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by greggman3 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @12:52PM (#30857766)
I think when it really works it will be more like the transition from feature phones to smart phones. very very quick. If they actually work it's just too compelling.

Further, I expect the number of cars on the road to go way up because suddenly so many more people can use a car. For example, every one without a license. Kids, elderly, disabled. I also suspect it means there will be lots more long distance drives as suddenly it becomes "hey, wanna go to this place 3 hours away, we can play games and drink while the car drives us"

I'd certainly consider visiting my family 9hrs drive away more often if Friday at say 12am I could just climb in the backseat and go to sleep and arrive at 8am vs having to drive myself (usually 7am to 4pm)

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by wiremine on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:09PM (#30859535)
> I think when it really works it will be more like the transition from feature phones to smart phones. very very quick. If they actually work it's just too compelling.

The definition of "very very quick" is important here. The smart phone adoption took over a decade. to get to 80+%. [1]

Cars are much more expensive than phones, and last longer. The average age for a car in the US is 11.5 years [2] and people replace their cars between 5 and 7 years. [3] And my guess is self-driving technology will be used at the top-end of the market, and slowly trickle down. This is similar to pretty much any consumer technology: the technology starts off as a premium and becomes a commodity over a longer period if time.

So, if we use cell phones as a benchmark, it will take 10 years at a minimum. It likely will take 20 years given the duty cycle of vehicles. (Assuming we all still own a vehicle. If we all move to subscriptions, that might be a different story.)

Fleets will be replaced sooner, because the commercial ROI will be compelling. But it still takes a ton of capital to replace a fleet, and they need to get the ROI out of their _existing_ fleet before they invest in new ones. So even that won't be immediate.

But it might be uneven. I 100% agree with your example of sleeping through the night. If I can do that with a rental, and that's cheaper than flying, I might consider it.

[1] https://www.comscore.com/Insights/Blog/US-Smartphone-Penetra...

[2] https://www.carchex.com/research-center/auto-warranties/how-...

[3] https://www.quora.com/How-often-do-people-replace-their-cars

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by bredren on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:20PM (#30863184)
Adoption of smartphones was also learning to adopt to a major technology change.

Adoption was also spread unevenly. Some parts of the country moved past flip phones long before others. There are still holdouts!

Cars will be an entirely different matter. People are trained to accept internet enabled devices and ridesharing already.

Once insurance rates for manual navigation clear those of an autonomous fleet vehicle, people won’t want the oil can Henry’s experience anymore.

You can already tell most people don’t want to drive anyway. They are looking at their smartphones as they idle down the street.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by woojoo666 on Friday April 01, 2022 @08:12PM (#30884656)
The bureaucracy is probably the larger hurdle. Snartphones don't really risk lives the same way cars do. And there are still a lot of people wary of the safety and capability of self driving cars. It could be hard to convince a city to agree to having them, and convincing every city in the US may take a long while.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by glenneroo on Friday April 01, 2022 @08:31PM (#30884763)
When they are proven to be considerably safer (a question of "when" and not "if" IMO), I highly doubt many politicians will want to stand in the way of allowing them on their streets... nevermind if Apple ever comes out with a car, it could quickly become a highly sought after experience.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by woojoo666 on Friday April 01, 2022 @08:34PM (#30884782)
I thought they have already been proven safer than human drivers. And yet people are still wary.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by deegles on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:29PM (#30859754)
Not if existing fleets can be retrofitted to be self driving. At $15/hr, if you can keep a car or truck driving 100 hours per week that's $6,000 month of labor costs saved. It's reasonable to expect insurance costs will be lower as well. Fuel economy would be better too, since a self driving car would be happy to drive at 60mph or less to get more MPG.

Even if the system + retrofit costs $50,000 that's an ROI of ~8 months. These numbers are made up but even with the most pessimistic of assumptions I believe widespread adoption will happen much faster than 10 years.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by Retric on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @09:20PM (#30862814)
Even retrofits still run into many issues. Delivering gasoline to gas stations for example requires hooking up hoses etc. Training people on site to do it is possible, but it’s a huge shift for an industry and unlikely to finish very quickly. The same applies to delivering cement or wide loads etc which require different behavior while driving.

On top of this retrofits for every existing model is a non trivial problem on it’s own.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by SturgeonsLaw on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:22PM (#30863198)
> Delivering gasoline to gas stations for example requires hooking up hoses etc

However delivering electrons to a powerpoint doesn't :)

I get your point though. The last mile stuff is tricky and fiddly, and will be done manually long after the long haul stuff has been automated.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by balaji1 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:17AM (#30864352)
Is there a simpler way to make long-haul more efficient by investing in trains along the major arteries of trucking traffic (which would include ports, big production and consumption cities/regions)? And then more intense and automated load transfer between ports to trains and trains to last-mile-trucking.

This could be developed along-side trucking automation. Thus developing 2 networks meaning more resilience.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by adrianN on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:26AM (#30865979)
Infrastructure for trains is unfortunately very expensive. It's easier to spread the costs over thousands of trucks than to muster the political will to spend a couple of billions for a rail track.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by trainsarebetter on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:24AM (#30866366)
And road infrastructure isn’t? It takes up more land and needs more maintenance than rail
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by adrianN on Thursday March 31, 2022 @10:48AM (#30867809)
Roads are usually a bit cheaper, yes. And we also have them already.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by trainsarebetter on Friday April 01, 2022 @09:17AM (#30877786)
what? They definitely are not cheaper, they are just subsidized.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by adrianN on Friday April 01, 2022 @10:44AM (#30878535)
Roads are just asphalt. Train tracks need all kinds of supporting equipment installed for safety. If you want to electrify the track I'd guess that just installing that is more expensive than building a road. I'd be happy to be proven wrong though, do you have any sources about the average cost per kilometer of roads vs tracks?
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by trainsarebetter on Saturday April 02, 2022 @09:41PM (#30893415)
No they are not, there’s all the signage, barriers, and drainage. Roads wear out very quickly, they are the fastest degrading forum of infrastructure.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by namibj on Thursday March 31, 2022 @09:33AM (#30866972)
Technically, yeah. In Europe we finally started to test fully-automatic couplings[0] for freight trains last year (as in, run a production train on the system, making sure to collaborate with freight customers that won't complain).

These couplings are a massive upgrade over the common hook&chain freight coupling, which requires substantial manual labor for (un-)hooking. The new ones theoretically allow for fully automatic freight shunting/train re-assembly.

Now we "just" need to up the speed limit for freight trains to at least the 140/160 km/h most commuter rail uses for max cruise speed, and retrofit the digital part as needed to the already-used mechanical coupling to some electric multiple units that operate on congested links with demand for intra-day freight. A few (1-4) box/container/"swap body (truck/rail only deriviates of ISO 20ft containers)" cars should typically be no problem for these EMUs (especially the longer ones), and would allow to realistically compete with trucks on interstates (Autobahn). Just needs some very small shunting engines, probably ideally remote-controlled (from the rail yard's tower), to add/remove freight cars from the tail while the passenger doors are open. Timings is tight, but some automation for fairly aggressive acceleration/deceleration profiles during that shunting should suffice. Maybe later even add a low tier electric car's drive train hardware-wise to some such container carrier wagons, to let them do the shunting and possibly last-mile trip simply on battery power, as that'd greatly speed up the shunting (low speed acceleration is friction limited, and a separate locomotive can't use the freight weight on the freight axles for traction. They're only outfitted with brakes on typical freight cars.)

For example, these "swap bodies" which are like ISO containers with fold-out legs, should IIUC be able to get put on their legs coming from a freight car (just by folding them out and maybe using some small lifting jack style hydraulics to get an inch or two clearance), followed by that freight car (if it has a battery pack and some small motors) driving away under remote control, and the truck trailer driving under it. This would only need a switch and non-electrified streetcar-style concrete pavement integrated track long enough for one or multiple of these, on the side of an existing railway station. Some $50-100k plus whatever the concrete truck yard pavement itself costs. Adding the battery drive system thing should probably be around $20-30k on top of what the freight car (with the digital automatic coupling) would cost normally, at least if it's only manually operated with sight contact. (It'd recharge via the train's electric heating bus that was originally designed to replace the steam heating for passenger carriages. The coupling that was/is used with hook&chain is 600A@1000V 16.7 Hz AC (in Germany), with one coupling either side of the coupling. This should leave ample recharging power for a small battery pack on the attached freight.)

This obviously only works where trains and existing road infrastructure are level, but on cursory inspection, many train stations here in Germany already have that. On many commuter links there's hourly or even twice-hourly service here, so even fairly short trips could realistically make use of this shifting of traffic from street to rail.

[0]: https://www.dac4.eu/en/

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by xyzzyz on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:26AM (#30863810)
> Training people on site to do it is possible, but it’s a huge shift for an industry and unlikely to finish very quickly.

Training people to pump gas is possible but slow and a huge shift? Are you from Oregon or New Jersey, by any chance?

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by dmicah on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:45AM (#30863902)
I believe they are referring delivering the gas to the station via tanker truck, not filling a passenger vehicle with gas.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by batguano on Saturday April 02, 2022 @09:57PM (#30893564)
Doesn’t seem much more complicated to pump gas from the tanker truck into the gas station tanks. Just bigger hoses and a bit longer.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by xyzzyz on Thursday March 31, 2022 @10:21AM (#30867524)
Ah, I see.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by sokoloff on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @07:46PM (#30862212)
If the ROI was in 8 months, I’d think the seller of the tech would be charging too little. Why give it away for that price, when an ROI of 24 months would still be compelling, would give far greater margins and a more balanced split between the consumer and producer of the tech?
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by wiremine on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:32PM (#30859791)
Good point. That extends the ROI of the original investment, so it feels like a no brainer.

The big assumption is the retrofit market. Is that something anyone is talking about? Is that something Waymo and the like will be offering?

My point is: it makes sense, but is it the low hanging fruit someone will be going after right way? Or will this happen down the road?

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by gpt5 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:09PM (#30860809)
In a way, Waymo is already in that business - as all the cars they use are retrofitted.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by Retric on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @09:23PM (#30862843)
Waymo is solving this for a handful of specific models, they would need to do significant work to adapt their system to say a 2010 Corolla let alone more exotic stuff.

It’s not just physical instillation their models would have to be adapted for different camera placement, vehicle weight, etc.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by jfoster on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @09:35PM (#30862924)
But not to the point where they are selling kits. They retrofit a specific vehicle for use in their service.

I think CommaAI is the closest to a kit, but it probably will never quite reach "no-human-required" autonomous driving; I don't think they're even aiming for that.

https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/blob/master/docs/CARS.m...

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by acd10j on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:30AM (#30863831)
I don’t think retrofit will work at scale, as maintaining a retrofit for so many models for software as well as hardware will work, building a new model in keeping self driving in mind will be much more cheaper in long run.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by 14 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @09:24PM (#30862848)
What do you suppose all those officers will do when cars no longer break the rules?
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by ceejayoz on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @09:32PM (#30862902)
They'll claim to smell drugs.

https://abovethelaw.com/2021/07/court-calls-bullst-on-cop-wh...

> The Court agrees with Gray that it is incredible that Officer Hiser—who self-admittedly does not have a heightened olfactory system—could smell the scent of two resealable sandwich sized plastic baggies of unburnt marijuana coming from a moving vehicle when patrolling in his cruiser. This occurrence is not only contrary to any common experiences, but is “implausible” and seemingly “contrary to the laws of nature.“

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by xbmcuser on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @11:49PM (#30863645)
The replacement cycle for taxi ie commercial vehicles is lot shorter. Taxi fleets will move to self driving cars a lot faster. 2 biggest running costs for commercial vehicle are driver and fuel. So driver being replaced by ai and ice cars being replaced by electric happening almost at the same time means the transitions will be a lot faster.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by aardvarkr on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:05PM (#30857913)
The phone -> smartphone transition stretched out over the course of a decade. It’s fast relative to the adoption of the automobile for example but nowhere near as quickly as you make it sound.

Even in modern times we still have a surprising amount of Americans still use feature phones. The Pew Research Center found in 2018 that 17% of Americans still use feature phones. https://www.fool.com/investing/2018/02/19/a-foolish-take-17-...

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by Kye on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:47PM (#30858466)
I didn't get a smartphone until 2014. It was frustrating how so many people in the tech bubble acted like everyone had one long before most people did and just didn't bother with web sites anymore, leaving me out of so many new things. The failure to peek outside one's own experience is a continuing problem among the people deciding what the world will look like tomorrow.

See also: the internet. People still discussed seriously whether or not it had staying power as recently as 2008. It didn't really take off until the 2008 election pushed so many people to participate in new mediums. 2004 was kind of a prelude with Howard Dean's campaign, but he mostly reached the already online set. I was already on in the 1990s, and it still surprises me when I meet people my own age who didn't get on until the 2000s or 2010s even though it's the more common experience.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by frutiger on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:07PM (#30858700)
> It didn't really take off until the 2008 election pushed so many people to participate in new mediums. 2004 was kind of a prelude with Howard Dean's campaign, but he mostly reached the already online set.

I find the idea that the Internet’s adoption was related to US presidential election cycles a little bizarre. I know they dominate the mainstream media for a few months every four years but surely the utility of the internet vastly exceeds that?

What about online shopping or even email displacing paper communications?

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by benatkin on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @07:00PM (#30861913)
Thinking about it more...I think texting, especially group texting, was much bigger during the 2008 campaigns than it was during the 2004 campaigns, and for some, rudimentary web browsing. And they did it on the pre-iPhone concept of a smartphone, that we've since thrown out.

What they used to call feature phones back then (which I think are practically discontinued now - most current feature phones would be considered smartphones in 2006) supported texting but it was used less than on the 2006 concept of smartphones.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by Kye on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @07:29PM (#30862116)
I still remember Helio's "don't call it a phone" ads. They almost beat the iPhone launch.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helio_Ocean

When they said social network, they meant SMS Twitter. It was a very interesting time with lots of companies vying to be the next evolution of mobile.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by Kye on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:38PM (#30863285)
If you double check context, you'll see the US was the subject of comment I replied to and it's reasonable to see an implicit constraint even without me qualifying it. HN's guideline on charitable reads applies to everyone regardless of geography as far as I know. It's only bizarre if you read it in a way that would be bizarre if it was a fair reading.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by benatkin on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:45PM (#30859219)
Obama famously used a Blackberry. That isn't a smartphone in the current use of the term IMO, but I think it was called that back then.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by SturgeonsLaw on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:30PM (#30863238)
> I find the idea that the Internet’s adoption was related to US presidential election cycles a little bizarre. I know they dominate the mainstream media for a few months every four years but surely the utility of the internet vastly exceeds that?

Not to mention the rest of the planet. I'd like to take this opportunity to remind everyone that the majority of the world is not-America, and views American presidential elections as a newsworthy diversion for a few weeks every four years, and not much more than that. Those elections don't really drive any changes in behaviour. Hell, my own country's elections don't really drive any changes in behaviour.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by slyall on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @11:55PM (#30863664)
I put the very late 1990s as hen the Internet took off. It went from being a weird techie thing to something a good proportion of the population was using.

The main graph on the top of this page shows Internet Users as proportion of population in Developed countries went from 11% in 1997 to 31% in 2000.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Internet_usage

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by bsder on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:15AM (#30863762)
I mark the transition as Y2K exactly.

It was basically right at 1999->2000 that you had internet stores completely melt down on Valentine's Day and Mother's Day.

This was the point where the Internet was escaping being some weird techie thing to being something that non-technical people were using.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by lhorie on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @09:29PM (#30862880)
Honestly, I doubt it. If you're gonna make predictions, you kinda gotta look at what already exists. People that buy cars to ferry their kids around will look at things like safety ratings. Safety reports for robocars are super hush hush, which just doesn't inspire confidence. The stats aren't there either. People that over-rely on Tesla FSD already get a bad rep.

Price is another really big factor. Car buyers are generally not willing to spend even $3k on optional bells and whistles. My understanding is a lidar system costs like $20k. You can buy an entire car for that price tag.

Sleeper buses and the like also already exist and demand isn't really that high. Greyhound shut down a bunch of lines during the pandemic. I.e. if demand drops, an operator can go out of business. What makes a SDV fleet operator any less prone to the same sort of risk profile?

Another factor that seems suspiciously absent from Waymo discussions is Google's abysmal track record wrt customer support. Comms from Waymo always come out as carefully written press releases, but people actually using the service have to sign NDAs. Seems... kinda fishy?

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by geodel on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:08PM (#30863117)
> Further, I expect the number of cars on the road to go way up because suddenly so many more people can use a car.

That's just assuming rides will be dirt cheap. I don't expect that. With billions invested in R&D, costly hardware for self-driving car and tax starved governments to make money, these rides will be nowhere cheap where anyone could take ride anything between 10 min and 10 hours without second thought.

With all said and done I believe pricing will be in range of cab rides not bus rides.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by merely-unlikely on Thursday March 31, 2022 @08:06AM (#30866253)
Also (local) government imposed monopolies/supply caps will keep prices up in many areas.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by bigtones on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:14PM (#30858056)
Smart phones when launched cost less than $1200 which a majority of people could afford. Cars that have this technology onboard would cost upwards of $65000 which almost no one can afford comparatively.

This is not going to be a fast rollout.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by gibolt on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:33PM (#30858292)
The economics of a robotaxi are insane. Main cost now are the driver, and then fuel, and then vehicle wear/tear/depreciation. An autonomous EV taxi makes all three of those comparatively negligible. Profit per year per vehicle could be $25k+, meaning it is in their best interest to produce as many cars as possible.

In addition, each taxi will be replacing at least 10 cars, if it is sufficiently cheap and convenient.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by mdoms on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:13PM (#30858767)
I am convinced people who believe "wear and tear" on electric cars is "negligible" have never owned a vehicle. I worked as a mechanic at a bunch of small mum and pop businesses. Other than oil changes and brake pads (which will be less of a concern with electrics) nothing changes. The bulk of work in shops like that is suspension and steering (bushings, shocks, hydraulics), running gear (wheel bearings, hubs), AC problems (pumps and clutches mainly) and failing electrical parts (bulbs, starter motors, coil packs, wiring gremlins).

Electric cars are heavy, so expect more suspension failures. Running gear doesn't really change. AC is identical but with electric motors (prone to failure). Electrics will be worse if anything.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by gibolt on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:50PM (#30859281)
Suspension failures are not particularly common, EVs aren't that much heavier, and maintenance can still be done. While EVs are somewhat heavier, there are plenty of crazy heavy ICE vehicles that work without issue.

Tire wear may increase, but a robotaxi can also optimize driving style to reduce it.

None of those costs matter, compared to ICE. EVs just have less things that can break, and even less things that result in EOL or catastrophic failure. The more miles a taxi runs for, the more money it makes. Even if costs increased, the profit would easily make up for it.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by mdoms on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:03PM (#30859457)
> Suspension failures are not particularly common

Only because we regularly service them by replacing bushings, CV joints and ball joints regularly. And shock absorber failures are still commonplace.

> EVs aren't that much heavier

They're much heavier. It's obviously hard to make a direct comparison because there's no such thing as "equivalent but with an ICE engine" but a Golf E weighs about 250kg more than a Golf GTI.

> there are plenty of crazy heavy ICE vehicles that work without issue

And they have heavier duty components which require more servicing and are more expensive to replace.

> None of those costs matter, compared to ICE.

Can you show me some evidence for this? I am not making the claim that EVs are more expensive to maintain than ICE cars, but you made the claim that wear and tear costs (aka maintenance costs) on EVs are "negligible". You will need to show some receipts for a claim like that.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by fragmede on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @06:10PM (#30861446)
There are undoubtedly other changes involved, but BMW makes an ICE and electric version of their current 3-series. The 330i is 3,582 lbs vs the electric 330e's 4,039 lbs. Roughly 10%'s difference; quite a bit heavier!

For an apples to oranges comparison, a Tesla Model 3 is 3,648 to 4,250 lbs; a Honda Accord is 3,150 to 3,430 lbs. Totally difference cars, but same-ish external size class. Those battery packs are heavy!

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by Dylan16807 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @11:38PM (#30863594)
> Roughly 10%'s difference; quite a bit heavier!

Personally I'd call 10% tiny.

Also you save a third of that when you remove the driver.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by mdoms on Thursday March 31, 2022 @03:53AM (#30864862)
You'd call 10 bags of concrete in the car a "tiny" amount of weight?
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:21PM (#30870545)
When the car weighs 100 bags of concrete, and the entire thing is designed and tuned around the extra weight, then yeah it's a pretty tiny difference.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by fomine3 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @08:45PM (#30862595)
330e is PVEV, not BEV. We're talking for battery's weight so not good example. Tesla 3 is relatively lightweight compared to other BEVs. I wonder what's the difference.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by simonebrunozzi on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:42AM (#30866080)
Don't forget that brakes last 3-4 times more on an EV, compared to an ICE.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by at-fates-hands on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:08PM (#30858707)
Just looking at some data on Tesla's:

According to RepairPal, the average Tesla maintenance cost is $832 per year. That compares to an average of $652 per year for all car models sold in the United States. Depending on which services your Tesla needs, you may end up spending much more than the average car owner on yearly maintenance needs.

Also, Tesla's aren't known for their reliability:

Though not much information exists yet about the overall reliability of Tesla models, early results aren’t encouraging. In the J.D. Power 2021 U.S. Vehicle Dependability StudySM, Tesla ranked 30th of 33 car brands for overall reliability. That’s better than only Jaguar, Alfa Romeo, and Land Rover among all automakers across the country.

J.D. Power reported an average of 176 mechanical issues per 100 Tesla vehicles, compared to an industry average of 121 issues. The organization notes, though, that it doesn’t rank the electric car brand with other major automakers because it doesn’t meet the study’s criteria.

What can be known is that Tesla models break down relatively regularly and that Tesla maintenance costs are pretty steep.

https://jalopnik.com/advisor/tesla-maintenance-cost/

Unreliable cars and a pretty steep per year cost to maintain them, along with steep repair costs (a broken door handle will run you about 1K plus labor)? This doesn't sound like the pipedream you're selling me here.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by robocat on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:15PM (#30859617)
> Tesla maintenance cost is $832 per year. That compares to an average of $652 per year

I would be very careful before relying on those maintenance cost figures - they are very dependant upon the age of the vehicles and neither figure sounds realistic, if you look at the following information.

https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/the-most-and-least-expe...

The link shows the cheapest average cost to maintain a vehicle over 10 years was $550/annum for a Toyota in 2016, and the most expensive was $1780/annum for BMW.

More importantly, further down, the article shows the cost increase over time for maintenance is about +$150/annum. At age 10 years the average maintenance is $1500, and it plateaus at about $2000/annum (because people retire vehicles when they get too expensive to maintain).

A Tesla doesn’t have oil changes or combustion engine problems, so some maintenance costs are reduced. However the battery eventually needs replacing, which is a large expense, so you must know whether the battery replacement is included in average yearly maintenance costs or not, before the figure is useable over the long term.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by HWR_14 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:21AM (#30864062)
The numbers align with my anecdata. I'd say $832/year is probably around what people I know with a newish (0-3 years) Tesla pay. And people I know with an ICE car probably average $600 or less.

Your source seems to argue in favor of the numbers as well. If we just look at your Toyota and BMW numbers, the average holds true if there are 11 Toyotas to every BWM. That sounds plausible.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:21PM (#30860914)
>The link shows the cheapest average cost to maintain a vehicle over 10 years was $550/annum for a Toyota in 2016, and the most expensive was $1780/annum for BMW.

Gotta love how these numbers are both a decent sized integer multiple away from what you would think they are if you got your advice from the internet.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by sgerenser on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:12AM (#30865895)
Keep in mind that BMW number is probably including a yearly maintenance/tune up at the dealer that includes an oil change, new wipers, cabin air filter, and nitrogen in the tires all for one low price of $599.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by gibolt on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:52PM (#30859317)
Their reliability score does not take into account severity. Most things reported are super minor, and all are within the first year. Luxury cars are the 'worst' in these surveys, because owners are pickier.

True reliability metrics are average years on the road and miles driven.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by unregistereddev on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:23PM (#30859706)
Tesla ranks behind Lexus, Acura, BMW, Cadillac, Lincoln, and many other luxury cars in the same reliability studies. Even if most things are minor, they still have significantly more problems than the established automakers.

I wonder whether the average amount spent on non-warranty repairs would be a good metric to add to "average years on the road and miles driven". That would hopefully remove initial defects from the first few years and also remove defects that are so minor that most people won't pay to have them fixed.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by wolverine876 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:54AM (#30864233)
> Their reliability score does not take into account severity.

Therefore Tesla's reliability might be even worse.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by tintor on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:15PM (#30859612)
"each taxi will be replacing at least 10 cars" Two cars maybe, but not ten cars. Ten of us can't commute to work in the morning, and return back with the same taxi. Two round trips might fit during rush hour.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by Teever on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:35PM (#30859829)
One of the easy things that we could do to improve quality of life and reduce waste would be to increase WFH and also to simply stagger work place start times somthat were not all hammering infrastructure at the same time twice a day.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by SturgeonsLaw on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:32PM (#30863251)
Normalise starting at 10:00am! Night owls rise up!
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @04:16PM (#30860250)
There's reasons to do that already to avoid rush hour, but somehow many people still end up getting stuck in rush hour traffic twice a day.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by gibolt on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @06:06PM (#30861402)
Not all people commute. Rush hour isn't all at once, but distributed over several hours. Not all cars will be replaced right at the start, but those who use their cars the least will probably be the first to go taxi only.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by BurningFrog on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @04:37PM (#30860479)
Even assuming that rigid pattern, the cars can do other things between the rush hours. Like deliveries.

Also, if there is an unused resource for most of the day, capitalism will find a use for it!

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by native_samples on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @04:38PM (#30860487)
You appear to be ignoring development costs. Waymo has to be one of the most fantastically expensive projects in corporate history. Even if they ramped up massively tomorrow, they'd still be charging taxi-like prices and it will take a long, long time to break even on that initial investment. But of course, they aren't ramping up tomorrow.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by bushbaba on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:18AM (#30863777)
I often wonder how much higher googles stock price would be if they used that money to buy back shares.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by zepearl on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:22PM (#30858878)
> In addition, each taxi will be replacing at least 10 cars, if it is sufficiently cheap and convenient.

Maybe the demand would be even higher than that - I'm thinking of all people that cannot drive (e.g. because of age in a few years for my parents & other relatives), the ones that don't own a car (too costly, don't want it, whatever), introverted people that don't like driving in a taxi/uber (that's me! hehe), etc... .

Of course alternatives exist already now but often they lack something (e.g. bus to remote location X drives only once every few hours and/or only up to a certain time, taxi is very expensive and/or availability is unreliable) => a cheap robotaxi would be a game changer, there would be many indirect consequences (and in my opinion many would be positive, like less parking spaces needed, more mobility for old people, more flexibility about where-to-go-for-what, room in the trunk, etc...).

> Main cost now are the driver, and then fuel, and then vehicle wear/tear/depreciation

Especially thinking about an idle taxi vs. robotaxi (waiting for somebody wanting a ride): unbeatable, as the driver's cost not generating any revernue would not exist anymore (only vehicle deprecation based on time and cost of capital used to buy the vehicle, which are both very low) => the difference related to fixed costs would be incredible (but I assume that some additional/new cost will show up, e.g. some data-exchange-service to keep maps/routes extremely up-to-date, coverage for remote-assisted driver in the case that the car would get stuck, etc..., but that would probably still not increase costs a lot).

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by jfim on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @04:16PM (#30860252)
> Maybe the demand would be even higher than that - I'm thinking of all people that cannot drive (e.g. because of age in a few years for my parents & other relatives), the ones that don't own a car (too costly, don't want it, whatever), introverted people that don't like driving in a taxi/uber (that's me! hehe), etc... .

Another thing that would increase demand would be the cheaper cost of AI driven miles compared to human driven ones. Today, it's somewhat expensive to get anything delivered from local shops, due to how expensive it is to do local point to point delivery. But if the local bakery or restaurant could deliver for a dollar or two, that would change a lot of behaviors.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by wolverine876 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:53AM (#30864229)
> Main cost now are the driver, and then fuel, and then vehicle wear/tear/depreciation. An autonomous EV taxi makes all three of those comparatively negligible.

How does autonomy reduce fuel consumption and wear?

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by sgerenser on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:03AM (#30865841)
EV reduces fuel consumption compared to ICE. I don’t think it necessarily reduces depreciation, especially if the price is much higher than a regular taxi to start with. Notwithstanding the recent year or two where cars have actually appreciated due to inflation, in general more expensive cars with more tech depreciate faster than more basic cars.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by wolverine876 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:14PM (#30869742)
We can have EVs without AI, and we do.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by LandR on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:43AM (#30866087)
Less moving parts to wear out ?
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by tintor on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:11PM (#30859570)
"Majority of people can afford $1200 smart phone" What? Majority lives on <$8 a day.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by rejor121 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:07PM (#30863112)
Of course they mean that the majority of people (who) can afford ( a ) 1200 smart phone ( exist )
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by jatone on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:28PM (#30858221)
businesses can afford it though. 65K to replace a very large, yearly, expense of a driver? you bet your ass they are going to switch and fast. That is what is going to cause most of the fallout. the ROI is basically 1 year, 2 tops.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by copperx on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @09:09PM (#30862747)
> Cars that have this technology onboard would cost upwards of $65000 which almost no one can afford comparatively.

I don't understand this line of thought. Ownership will be relegated to ultra-luxury status if cars can drive themselves.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by HWR_14 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:22AM (#30864069)
If I wanted to pay uber-level fares instead of owning a car, that's already a possibility. Most people will continue to own an older ICE car.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by satronaut on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @04:35PM (#30860463)
i disagree with the 65,000 figure. A baseline tesla model 3 is 38000 dollars, which has a computer that can handle full self driving beta. I can see the price going down TBH
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by nrclark on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:26AM (#30864087)
Tesla's FSD is really far from actually being full self-driving. There's a lot of computer required to get from 85% perfect to 99%. Uber and Cruise also both have lidar which is spendy.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by dzhiurgis on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:32PM (#30861057)
Cheapest Tesla atm is 47k

"FSD" is another 12k IIRC

Total 59k

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by sgerenser on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:15AM (#30865917)
Tesla FSD isn’t what we’re talking about here, that’s a level 2 system. Robotaxis would have to be level 5, or at least level 4.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by FireBeyond on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:00AM (#30864260)
You cannot buy a TM3 for less than $47K. And you'll be waiting a long time for it if you don't pay $12K for FSD.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by russh on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:26PM (#30858200)
Think driverless Uber.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by remus on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:32PM (#30858275)
I think price is an important difference between phones and cars. When they started coming out smart phones were expensive, but within reach for a big slice of people. There's a lot of people who don't buy brand new cars because they're expensive and poor value so I suspect there'll be a natural transition where the tech takes ~10years or so to trickle down in to the second hand market.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by ISL on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:34PM (#30858312)
When liability insurance costs plummet, the total cost of ownership will drop, too.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by bduerst on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:45PM (#30858439)
>Further, I expect the number of cars on the road to go way up because suddenly so many more people can use a car.

You're assuming that the cost will be much less with self-driving than ride share or cabs. It likely won't be a significant reduction for a while.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by zepn on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:22PM (#30860928)
The upfront cost could remain the same while externalities like road deaths, insurance, and even pollution (via e.g. more efficient braking / speeds) goes down.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by bduerst on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:28PM (#30861013)
It sucks, but most consumers are rational actors that don't care about those externalized costs (hence why we have tragedy of the commons). It's especially so for the price-sensitive demographics that GP was describing above, who care about their direct cost, which likely won't change for a while.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by ghaff on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @04:33PM (#30860434)
It’s not just cost though. I’m a bit over an hour drive to the nearest major city. I find I’m even less inclined than I used to be to head in for evening social event. If I could be driven, I’d be far more inclined to do that sort of thing and a (reasonable) cost wouldn’t be a huge factor.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by bduerst on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:24PM (#30860959)
>If I could be driven, I’d be far more inclined to do that sort of thing

The same way a taxi or ride-share would drive you right now?

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by ghaff on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:57PM (#30861328)
The cost for me to get into the city with a human-driven car is close to $100 each way which is too high for pretty much anything other than going to the airport. Cut that in half and eliminate parking and it’s more thinkable for an evening event.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by bushbaba on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:23AM (#30863793)
You assume self driving will be any cheaper. I doubt it.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by ghaff on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:16AM (#30864035)
I don’t necessarily disagree. A lot of people seem to assume that self-driving will be super-cheap, hence my use of the term treasonable. In fact, some trike today’s IRS deductions are probably the floor especially for anyone who isn’t trying to use a clunker of some sort.

I actually agree that today’s Uber/taxi rates are probably a good estimate for many years even once self-driving is practical.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by dvirsky on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:36PM (#30859835)
> I expect the number of cars on the road to go way up

This could also play out totally opposite to that - think cheaper on demand rides, no need to park near your work if your car can just go do something else, etc. This might play out as actually less people owning a car, or families owning just one car instead of two, etc. I remember a prediction from a few years ago that it may reduce the number of cars by 80%, which I doubt, but I also don't think it will necessarily mean more people buying cars.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by hibikir on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:08PM (#30860806)
First, it's unlikely, as most trips happen in small windows of time, and in the same general directions in a city, leading to very little chance to reuse: Peak cars on the road at 8 am on a Tuesday is not really going to drop, and then very few trips will be happening at 2am. It's the same thing that happens in many US cities for commuter trains: A large fleet spends the night on depots far from the center, and then makes a single trip downtown, where they stay put all day, just to make a lone trip out later in the day: The demand is just too low in the other direction to not have most trains idle most of the day.

But let's ignore that fact, and instead look at a different definition of number of cars on the road: Instead of how many cars actually exist, count how many cars are on the road at any given time. It's not just that there might be more cars in the end, but even with fewer cars, each car will be doing more miles, because you don't need a driver. Children visiting each other while being less of a nuisance for parents mean more trips. Old people that are uncomfortable driving. People going further away in geneeral, because being driven would be less stressful when the technology is doing well. More visits to the bar, now that you don't have to call an uber, or risk a DUI on the way. And let's not forget letting the car go back home to park, instead of paying for expensive downtown parking: Same number of miles with a passenger, but bonus congestion for everyone else.

When driving is cheaper, the number of miles driven goes up, and therefore the number of cars that you actually find on the road goes up, even with fewer cars.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by ryukafalz on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:07PM (#30859503)
> I expect the number of cars on the road to go way up

This sounds horrific for those of us who live in cities that are already overrun with cars.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by copperx on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @09:31PM (#30862892)
The problem with the US transportation-wise is its low population density. One possible solution could be to have robotaxis take care of last mile transportation, and have reliable and punctual mass transport take care of the bulk of the commutes.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by ryukafalz on Thursday March 31, 2022 @05:29PM (#30872417)
Another possible solution is to increase population density, for example by eliminating bans on higher-density development.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by HWR_14 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:25AM (#30864083)
We don't need robotaxis for that. Just put giant parking lots at subway stations.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by HWR_14 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:05AM (#30863986)
> I'd certainly consider visiting my family 9hrs drive away more often if Friday at say 12am I could just climb in the backseat and go to sleep and arrive at 8am vs having to drive myself

Have you ever done it via the bus. Because that gets you exactly what you want and overnight buses exist almost everywhere.

There's a reason most people prefer to fly.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by autoexec on Thursday March 31, 2022 @04:38PM (#30871938)
Except with buses you're limited to their schedule, still have to drive to and then wait around in a terminal with all of your stuff, deal with tickets, and then you're crammed into a bus with a bunch of random strangers with all their noises and smells. It's a much more involved and stressful situation than climbing into your own private vehicle at a time of your own choosing and not seeing another soul until you're at your destination.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by nelsonic on Thursday March 31, 2022 @07:41AM (#30866070)
Firstly, the adoption of smartphones is ongoing there are still people with "feature" phones (for whatever reason). As technologists/early-adopters we have an observation bias that everyone adopted them overnight, it's simply not the case. Secondly, the adoption of tech in entrenched industries is much slower because the decision makers are older and more risk-averse. Next is the cost-benefit of the adoption. If it costs 5-10x to adopt a "driverless" truck that still requires a skilled driver for 2% of cases there is still very much a driver on-board, only now they have to be retrained in the new skill.
Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by season2episode3 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:38PM (#30859871)
> Further, I expect the number of cars on the road to go way up > I also suspect it means there will be lots more long distance drives

This is the wrong direction for the world to move in. We need to make our transportation efficient both to reduce emissions and not pillage the earth for rare minerals for these self driving electric cars.

MOST (not all) 3 hour drives can and should be done through train trips. Trains are efficient, they offer more equitable access to transportation, and they can be very fast. The American obsession with the automobile, and the way that obsession is pushed internationally through exported media, will ruin us all.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by babyshake on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:58PM (#30858591)
> I expect the number of cars on the road to go way up because suddenly so many more people can use a car.

With autonomous vehicle adoption, we may see the concept of blockchain "gas" (fees paid with rates based on real-time demand) come full circle as a real-time congestion tax.

Re:Waymo begins driverless rides in San Francisco by saltminer on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @11:36PM (#30863581)
> Further, I expect the number of cars on the road to go way up because suddenly so many more people can use a car. For example, every one without a license. Kids, elderly, disabled.

And in areas with already bad traffic, it will only get worse. Much worse. You thought LA or SF pre-COVID were bad? Those will be the "good old days." And that's not just traffic, that's also hunting for parking everywhere you go (those cars have to be stored somewhere, after all).

A comprehensive public transportation system means people unable to drive can still get around. People act like self-driving cars are the solution when we already had a solution but (at least in America) proceeded to tear it apart as soon as we heard "cars are the future, get with the plan" and derided public transit as "welfare".

Fundamentally, we cannot "fix traffic", self-driving cars or no, because a 15-foot car holding 1-6 people cannot hope to compete with a 30-foot bus holding up to 30 passengers (on top of the driver), and that still doesn't hold a candle to a single train car (an 85-foot Bombardier MultiLevel railcar, for example, holds 132 people...and has a bathroom).

Compounding this is the American obsession with single-family housing and large minimum lot sizes: it is a fundamentally inefficient and unsustainable use of land. There is not enough space to build in this manner in the areas most in need of housing (which are, not so coincidentally, the areas where most of the jobs are), and it is this same inefficient use of land which makes public transportation difficult to run frequently enough that people stop using their cars for most trips.

When you build densely, you can run comprehensive public transportation that alleviates the need to have a car every time you need to go to work, the doctor, the grocery store, the park, etc. This also means people who cannot drive are afforded far more freedom than if they were to live in your average American suburb where sidewalks and pedestrian infrastructure more generally are an afterthought.

Far from a utopia, the future self-driving car advocates proclaim would be a nightmare. A nightmare where people are more isolated [0], more municipalities are struggling with debt [1], and even worse climate change [2]. This is not the future we should be excited for, it should be the one we are attempting to prevent at all costs.

Self-driving cars are fine (not having to deal with the TSA would be wonderful), but the way people think they will reshape society is nothing but a net-negative - we shot ourselves in the foot, but the proposed treatment is just putting on a band-aid and calling it a day. A high-tech band-aid, but a band-aid nonetheless.

[0]: https://citymonitor.ai/environment/citymetric-advent-22-snap...

[1]: https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme

[2]: https://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/the-charac...

Edit: Another thing to consider - if self-driving cars enable way more people to get around, this isn't good for the environment because only 40% of US electricity is from renewable sources [3] (20% of that being nuclear, which we desperately need more of but which many environmentalists have an existential panic over due to envisioning them all as impending Chernobyls). Burning gas might be bad for the planet, but electric cars don't have a perfect footprint, either. In isolation, replacing all gas vehicles with electric (minus stuff like trucks) would likely reduce emissions, but adding a massive increase in trips would be far worse than if we had comprehensive public transportation in more cities and towns.

[3]: https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427&t=3