News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by zuminator on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:55AM (#30150216)
I've had YouTube Premium since its inception. Whenever I'm around someone else who puts on a free-tier version of YouTube its rather shocking how frequent and intrusive the commercial ads are.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by hateful on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:11PM (#30150496)
I ran ad blocking on Youtube for years, and I've been a Premium member since it came out (as Red back then). I can't stand ads and avoid them like the plague.

Some ads still sneak into my world though. My current peeve is when going to a restaurant and they have "the game" on full blast. I'm perfectly fine with people watching/listening to the game - and half the time the restaurant is considered a "sports bar", so I get it. But what ends up happening is that those major games are mostly ads. And the ads are twice as loud as the game. So here I am, paying to eat at a place and I'm listening to ads. I've been tempted to ask the server if we'll be receiving a discount for listening to each ad like a mobile game!

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by spikej on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:32PM (#30150876)
dude... go to a different restaurant. You might even find it's less crowded, and you get better service because there's no game on!
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by munificent on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:01PM (#30151450)
Depends on where you live. Here in the Pacific Northwest, there are plenty of TV-free restaurant choices. Back when I lived in the South, it was a lot harder to find.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by teddyh on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:20PM (#30151811)
> My current peeve is when going to a restaurant and they have "the game" on full blast.

Get a TV-B-Gone.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by lapetitejort on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:00PM (#30153427)
I've bought the standalone keychain and the DIY TV-B-Gone. They're great but clunky. I bought a USB C IR blaster keychain hoping there'd be a TV-B-Gone app that could utilize it. No such luck.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by teddyh on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @09:47AM (#30163124)
There was an app for the Nokia N900 (I.e. the Maemo platform): https://www.my-maemo.com/software/applications_name_TV-B-Gon...
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by judge2020 on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:31PM (#30151970)
AirPods Pro also work well.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by judge2020 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:28PM (#30150789)
Regarding this, sports bars in particular pay a pretty hefty fee to have public-view television service, especially regarding access to all pro-league games. I'm sure they'd be paying more in general if they opted to mute or turn off the screen during ads (since the network expects x% of the restaurant's viewers to see and hear the ad, so they get the advertiser to pay more for access to those viewers, subsidizing the restaurant's actual monthly bill).
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by avgcorrection on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:42PM (#30152171)
The gym that I go to (and pay for) have ads on most of the displays (some are running TV programs). Ads for local businesses and “upgrade your membership TODAY”. It irks me. I don’t want to be distracted by these flashing screens.

But I guess there is no law that says that patrons should be shielded from ads. And I don’t think they would listen if I gave them a complaint (why would they give up a source of revenue?). So I don’t know what can be done about it short of a concerted effort by many members. And they (and myself) would probably not be motivated enough to go to that level of effort just to get rid of some irksome ads.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Vrondi on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:40PM (#30153966)
If there is another gym in the area with fewer ads, cancel your current membership, let them know the reason why, and go to the other gym. Let the new gym also know why you are switching to them.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by avgcorrection on Friday February 04, 2022 @12:16PM (#30209606)
I already said that it is too inconvenient for me to do some kind of protest move which won’t make a difference. All that will accomplish is that I will have to travel longer to and fro.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by jerf on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:02PM (#30151463)
Another alternative is ask them to turn it down and turn on CC.

I wish more of these places would have CC on. Especially if multiple programs are on, you can't have the audio. There's a solution right there, built right in, just waiting.... page in the conversation about how accessibility can be useful to more than just the immediately disabled.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by LeifCarrotson on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:00PM (#30155164)
Maybe your sensorium is different than mine, but the motion, flashing, and colors of advertisements are just as irritating as the audio to me. This is especially true in an environment where there are lots of other conversations and sounds to compete with the TV noise.

Unless the volume is turned up annoyingly loud, I find the visuals to be the annoyingly loud part: The subdued hues of the painted walls, tile floors, and wood trim reflecting back to my eyes from the ambient lighting are invisible compared to the 500 nits of flourescent colors jump cutting back and forth.

Turning on CC but leaving the visual assault in place doesn't help my eyes much. I would feel less abused if they'd turn the screen off but leave the game audio over the radio.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by jerf on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @12:20PM (#30165836)
It depends on what I'm there for, certainly. Recently I went to a piano bar with friends, and also happened to catch a particular football game. In this environment, you surrendered peace and quiet the moment you selected the restaurant. Fortunately for a football game, the audio is optional anyhow.

If I'm just there to eat, one TV is no big deal to me, but the TV Wall is definitely a distraction.

But at least don't try to have the audio on. As technically nifty as some of the restaurants are that try to have per-table speakers or a streaming option are, CC is still less obtrusive to me.

But of course everyone's mileage will vary.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by xfz on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:31PM (#30150851)
I would eat elsewhere if at all possible. You might not have many options though, or maybe you're with a group of people who love advertising.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by KeepFlying on Monday January 31, 2022 @09:39PM (#30157953)
I think it's more that you're with a group of people who don't hate advertising enough to take any action against it.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by cercatrova on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:47PM (#30152257)
Get a phone with an IR blaster and turn off their TV
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by sgjohnson on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:35PM (#30152034)
I have an ethical dilemma about YouTube. I hate ads, I hate Google, and I want to support the creators.

For those reasons adblock is a must, and paying for YouTube Premium is not an option (I’m not going to voluntarily give a single penny of my money to Google)

Sure, I’ve got CuriosityStream and Nebula subs, but not all content creators use those platforms.

It is what it is.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by judge2020 on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:03PM (#30152550)
Nebula seems to split profit 50/50[0] while YouTube splits it 55/45 to the channel[1], and Youtube Premium views are regarded as being sometimes 10-20x the payout of an ad-supported view[2].

0: https://nebula.app/faq#:~:text=How%20do%20the%20creators%20g...

1: https://variety.com/2021/digital/news/youtube-partner-progra....

2: https://twitter.com/LinusTech/status/1486935690315112455?s=2... and https://www.dailydot.com/upstream/totalbiscuit-youtube-red-p...

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by solarmist on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:36PM (#30153092)
re: [2] I did not know that. This thread has convinced me to seriously look at paying for YouTube.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by somerando7 on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:46PM (#30152247)
The creators that are decently big (100k+) make enough money whether or not you ad-block. Don't worry about it.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by elwell on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:08PM (#30154370)
They make enough money precisely because not everyone ad blocks. This seems like a fallacious argument.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by xboxnolifes on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:57PM (#30155975)
A lot of big creators take sponsorship deals and have in-video ads. I know most of the ones I watch do, and I actually don't even mind them. They're personalized to the content creator's content, and are usually as entertaining as the video's contents because of it.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by ratww on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @07:13AM (#30161511)
GP is talking about Patreon and sponsorships. A lot of videos get demonitized too, so some creators stand to see no money from ads in some videos.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by baud147258 on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:03PM (#30154310)
To support the creators whose videos I'm watching on YT, I use a whitelist add-on that disable the adblocker on those channels. Though the add-on still allows me to skip the ad, which I'm doing when it's an ad I've already seen.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by cercatrova on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:48PM (#30152278)
You can pay for their Patreon as well if you want
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by aero-glide2 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:01PM (#30150310)
I feel the same when I accidently open the stock app instead of Vanced.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by idatum on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:06PM (#30150398)
How far does YouTube Premium go as far as privacy? I never took a look at it carefully.

My fear is I would pay the fee for no ads, but Google would still collect data on what I view and monetize that by selling me ads somewhere else.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Macha on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:09PM (#30150448)
YouTube Premium does nothing to stop Google using your youtube history to profile you and letting advertisers target ads at you on other sites using Google's data which is partially built on the youtube profiling.

By not loading the ads at all, it may stymie non-Google ad networks attempts to profile you.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by judge2020 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:23PM (#30150710)
YouTube ads are based on your watch history, not some tracking pixel, so even a regular ad blocker on YouTube.com only blocks ads and doesn't help with privacy.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by onemoresoop on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:19PM (#30150642)
I suspect that since you're a paying user, a more valuable customer, they'd want to mine your data more thoroughly to derive more profits in other ways.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Workaccount2 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:26PM (#30150765)
I would suspect the opposite, once you start paying you go from being a product to being a customer.

If youtube was 90% premium members, it would likely be an unrecognizably better platform, since users instead of advertisers would be the core profit center.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by onemoresoop on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:35PM (#30150927)
In a normal world that would make sense but we're dealing with businesses and MBAs who need to incessantly increase their revenue. As a paying customer they could squeeze more, you're willing to pay. Non-paying customers are used as a product themselves but it's extremely hard to extract more.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Workaccount2 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:46PM (#30151161)
That's just normal business though, and my statement is intrinsically correcting for that.

Netflix has the same MBAs and bean counters, but their product has no ads and orders of magnitude less clickbait. Its clear they make content geared for their users, not for their advertisers. Youtube is very heavy with advertiser friendly content, and both creators and users pay heavily for that (but its *quote* Free! *unquote*)

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by pvarangot on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:16PM (#30151718)
Netflix productions do content placement. It's pretty sneaky and they do use social media accounts for shenanigans like fake posts on subreddits asking "What was that jacket in TVShow S03E04?" and another account responding with a link. Big brands with recognizable logos also do product placement on those. For fantasy shows they aim to own the merchandise distribution, but for stuff that happens on the real world there's always product placement and webpage placement and stuff like that going on.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Workaccount2 on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:33PM (#30152013)
I hardly see product placement as being even remotely close to what YouTube is doing. Its probably one of the most innocuous forms of advertising. Imagine a YouTube where the worst you can come up with is a guy drinking a coke during his video.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by onemoresoop on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:33PM (#30153027)
Yes, because it's done in moderation. Imagine if that was ramped up and 90% content was turned into product placement..
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by tomjen3 on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @12:45AM (#30159035)
I was watching lost in space and one of those episodes had an entire subplot about Oreos. It was so blatant it ruined that episode.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by HWR_14 on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @10:05AM (#30163403)
Why wouldn't they mine the data of all their users super thoroughly (to their technical limits)? It only costs a bit of computer time.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Taylor_OD on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:09PM (#30150452)
I just upgraded after refusing. Mostly for mobile. On desktop my ad block works but on mobile it wouldnt. You can also shut off your screen on mobile and it continues to run with Premium. It kind of sucks that Youtube requires you to pay for this but I use Youtube enough to be okay with it.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by cma on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:19PM (#30151785)
Ad block on firefox works on YouTube on mobile (Android) and there is another mobile firefox extension to allow background play.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by exhilaration on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:22PM (#30152827)
The name of the Firefox Android extension that allows background play is "Video Background Play Fix": https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/video-backgro...

Just install that and uBlock Origin and you're set: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/ublock-origin...

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by eyeundersand on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:42PM (#30153179)
On Android, Youtube Vanced (https://vancedapp.com/) is the best solution, in my experience. Used it for multiple years, no complaints.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Taylor_OD on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:16PM (#30154495)
Oh nice. I'll check this out. Thanks.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by onemoresoop on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:16PM (#30150600)
I'm blocking youtube ads on my mobile quite okay and the experience is fine (IOS - AdGuard). There are some twitches here and there but it is very usable.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by kingcharles on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:14PM (#30151685)
> Whenever I'm around someone else who puts on a free-tier version of YouTube its rather shocking how frequent and intrusive the commercial ads are.

Also, when I accidentally open a video in a private browsing window where I'm not logged in. DAMN IT WHY IS ALL THESE ADS.

Although, I have to say that the ads on YouTube were some of the most targeted of any site, and I would often sit through them.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by asddubs on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @01:24AM (#30159254)
you can enable addons in private mode
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by titzer on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:59AM (#30150271)
I bet! I run an adblocker and it's a cat and mouse game with YouTube ads slipping through. Last breakage, before I reinstalled it, I was getting ad interruptions for the same two stupid adds literally every 45 seconds.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by BenjiWiebe on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:23PM (#30150700)
Which ad blocker? I use ublock origin and I never see YT ads.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by titzer on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:47PM (#30151180)
I agree uBlock origin is the best, but I am running Safari now, so I use both Adblock plus and Ghostery lite.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by tomp on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:48PM (#30153245)
I use AdGuard, I don't see YouTube ads.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by shadowgovt on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:09PM (#30150445)
Problem is once an ad blocker's in the loop, the ad architecture's dataflow is damaged and it'll have to run fallback content.

So you'll get whatever's in the B-list of ads and that may be just two.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Macha on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:10PM (#30150480)
Yeah, google can circumvent the ad blocker's attempts to block the ad playback from beginning, but if the first thing the ad does is have double verify check if you're a bot, and double verify's domain is in your adblocker's list, then the ad is going to fail and Google will try load some other ad once it errors out.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by tasha0663 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:34PM (#30150921)
> double verify check if you're a bot

I hate when they do this. I just leave and go somewhere else. I'm not submitting to Voight-Kampff just to see a LinkedIn profile.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Macha on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:36PM (#30152064)
To be clear, advertising bot detection is different to website bot detection. The website bot detection is because they're worried about spambots filling comments or DDOS attacks. This is where you get the captchas. The advertiser bot detection is more for the case where the website owner is in on it and trying to boost their metrics to get more revenue from advertisers, and is more likely to be expressed via blank ad slots and demands for refunds from the website owner.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by shadowgovt on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:06PM (#30151534)
That's win-win for the server. Servers start doing this because automated traffic is cutting into their ability to provide service to humans. If you're freeing up their traffic to serve other humans you're doing them a favor.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Tenoke on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:14PM (#30150555)
In all fairness, if the rest of us didn't run adblockers, they probably wouldn't need to be so aggressive with the ads for those that currently don't.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by argomo on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:07PM (#30151544)
What's this mythical world where industry execs leave profit on the table because they aren't being squeezed by ad blockers? Have you tried watching cable TV? You know, the service that was originally billed as a way to watch tv without ads?
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by ravar on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:21PM (#30150680)
This strikes me as wishful thinking, adblockers are such a small minority. They are just following the incentives they would always follow, adblockers or no.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Tenoke on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:38PM (#30150986)
Adblockers are at 27% just in the US looking at statista and other random sources, and the number is much higher if you look at the more relevant younger demographic.

0. https://www.statista.com/statistics/804008/ad-blocking-reach...

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by throwaway744678 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:36PM (#30150946)
From the article, 27% of users; this is higher than I thought, and not negligible anymore.

Note: I tried a few google search to find accurate data, but it goes all over the place; is there an accurate estimation somewhere?

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by MomoXenosaga on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:57PM (#30151396)
Finding out if someone is running an ad blocker is not easy. After all a good ad blocker tries to be stealthy about it.

(anti ad blocker leads to anti anti ad blocker)

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by mileza on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:41PM (#30153985)
There are plenty of websites that detect that I'm using an adblocker. It's mildly annoying, but then I get to decide if what I was about to read was worth it.

Most of the time it's journaldemontreal.com (and other Quebecor-related websites) that prevents me from reading their articles with my adblocker. Which is a blessing in a way, because it's basically a glorified tabloid with a lot of articles of dubious quality.

I'm on Firefox with both AdBlockPlus and uBlock Origin.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by redml on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:40PM (#30151029)
There was a time back in the IE6 era where firefox didn't really have any market share and adblockers weren't really a thing.

The advertising industry was really aggressive even then. Some publishers put as many popups and banner ads as they could. I'm not saying all publishers would do this, but I have to admit the worst actors are the ones I strongly remember.

Only difference now is that there's a lot more tracking and ads are more insidious where they blend in with content now.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by ratww on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @07:17AM (#30161534)
Yep, the first punch was thrown by the ad industry. Popups, pop-unders and even full window advertisements were rampant before popup blockers became commonplace, to the point of being added directly to browsers.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by demindiro on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:45PM (#30151138)
I doubt that. Even if adblockers weren't a thing they'd push more ads since it generates more revenue. It's probably also effective at annoying users into buying a subscription to avoid (most) ads.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by tasha0663 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:31PM (#30150859)
You've put the cart ahead of the horse. Ad-blockers took off once they started throwing animated banners at us. Punch the monkey, win an ipod.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Tenoke on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:34PM (#30150918)
That's not really true. Youtube ads specifically were way way milder and rarer years ago when way less people used Adblock.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by sundarurfriend on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:53PM (#30151297)
And global warming was much milder when we had more pirates in the world [1]. Correlation is not causation. In the same period, YouTube's management style and public-facing attitude have changed dramatically, Google's general attempt at being the "good guys" has pretty much vanished, and beancounting has taken over as the guiding principle in many respects. I have zero reason to believe that had Adblocking not been a thing, there would have been any significant difference in the frequency or intrusiveness of the ads YouTube shows.

[1] https://swizec.com/blog/pirates-downfall-causes-global-warmi...

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Tenoke on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:22PM (#30152823)
Correlation is not causation but negative correlation is even more surely not causation and what I was replying to was

>Ad-blockers took off once they started throwing animated banners at us

which is still not true. When they took off the ads were still minimal.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by gifnamething on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:23PM (#30152851)
That was when it was still a growing business. Uber was cheaper when investors paid for it, too.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by ratww on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @07:23AM (#30161562)
I wouldn't call them "milder". They weren't static ads. They were video ads. Often loud and un-skippable for a certain small amount of time. This is definitely equivalent to a "punch the monkey" ad.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by judge2020 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:41PM (#30151051)
To be fair, if people stopped blocking ads I don't see them backing off on Ads any more; the increase in revenue and ad watch time would be kept as profit, since the current YouTube paradigm where they show 2 ads at the start and sometimes multiple mid-roll ads is so that they annoy you enough to sign up for Premium.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Workaccount2 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:23PM (#30150702)
This is exactly the case. Every time someone starts ad-blocking, someone else has to assume that ad watch for them.

Of course this isn't 1:1 parity in reality, but the ultimate manifestation of ad blocking is that.

Google had a good system a few years ago that I was probably the only sucker who paid them for it (and probably why they stopped it). You could pay a chosen amount monthly, and they would not show you ads as a result. It wasn't perfected, but the concept was good for those who understand the problem and want to work towards a solution.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by BoxOfRain on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:50PM (#30151258)
Aren't the people who use adblockers by definition those who are irritated by advertising enough that they wouldn't buy the products and services being advertised? If anything ad people should love things like uBlock Origin, it means they're not wasting their ad spend on people who aren't going to buy their products anyway.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by kzrdude on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:45PM (#30154044)
I think that's wishful thinking. I might even think this about myself, that I don't care about ads. But they still have some effect I think. Sure, I rarely buy stuff online or anywhere, I just don't shop much, but I still get affected by ads.

Some things about our brain we just can't change: we like things we've seen before. Both brands and people. Recognition makes a big difference, for example in arbitrary choices when shopping.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by hackerfromthefu on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:52PM (#30155044)
>> Every time someone starts ad-blocking, someone else has to assume that ad watch for them.

This is a completely unsubstantiated claim, and also false if you think about it.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by whoibrar on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:45PM (#30151140)
Which year was this ? Can you share more information regarding this ?
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by jsnell on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:50PM (#30151254)
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Workaccount2 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:52PM (#30151286)
Yeah thanks, that was it.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by whoibrar on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:11PM (#30151639)
Thank you (:
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by Workaccount2 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:50PM (#30151244)
I want to say they stopped it in 2018? I don't remember the name of the program, and searching "google paying for no ads" brings up a ton of unrelated adwords stuff.

I payed $5/mo and they would roll over unused funds. It worked pretty well, except that it would still show where the banners were, just blank whitespace instead of an ad.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by BenjiWiebe on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:21PM (#30150678)
I'm gonna guess that isn't the case, and that the percentage of people using ad blockers is still fairly low.
Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by xyst on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:28PM (#30150800)
instead of paying for premium and all of that money going to a megacorp. I spent some money on a simple browser plugin that forces YT to use the HTML5 video player.

Although every now and then an ad happens to pre-load before the video starts but I just refresh the video page and the ad goes away.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by judge2020 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:37PM (#30150970)
Premium views help a lot more than ad-supported views for creators, on the scale of 10-20x the payout per-view[0,1] (and it pays out regardless of the advertiser friendliness rating).

This has been a hot topic lately[2,3], but at what point is you watching YouTube for years without ads, without paying for Premium, ethically stealing or "piracy"? YouTube was buying petabytes of Hard Drive storage a day in 2012 to keep up with the demand[4], i'm sure it's nearly an Exabyte a day or more right now, so it doesn't cost $0 for YouTube to run the service, they just happen to have enough people on Mobile watching and clicking ads to make a profit[5] and subsidize the rest of us.

0: https://www.dailydot.com/upstream/totalbiscuit-youtube-red-p...

1: https://twitter.com/LinusTech/status/1486935690315112455?s=2...

2: https://youtu.be/-znPFc-0VS8?t=149

3: https://youtu.be/6jUxOnoWsFU

4: https://sumanrs.wordpress.com/2012/04/14/youtube-yearly-cost...

5: https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/3/21121207/youtube-google-al...

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by xyst on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:25PM (#30153773)
It's insane to me that people are arguing in favor of the advertisement companies simply because they pay the content creators a sliver of what they accept from the companies that use their ad platform.

Here's my take. It's not "piracy" or "ethical piracy" (what the fuck?). The content creators put it out on YT with the expectation that it will get viewed. The little money they receive now is simply a bonus. It's only piracy if the content creator put it out on a platform for some dollar amount (ie, direct to consumer model) and then it is later re-uploaded for free by another channel or via other means..

In other words, you can't claim piracy when the "price" is $0 up front.

As for YT, I don't really care. They are subsidized by the data that is fed to them (ie, viewing history) and resold to advertisers. They get their nut.

If anything, this should really push the forefront on innovation for a decentralized video streaming platform. One organization or group should not have this much power over who gets the "top views" via a proprietary algorithm.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by judge2020 on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:56PM (#30154203)
The price of things don't have to be represented in dollar amounts. If I want to give you a free iPad for watching my 2 hour lecture, I don't expect you to put on some sunglasses and take a nap for 1 hour 55 minutes. If you do that, I don't have to give you that iPad even if you sued me for it.

Piracy in general is just 'unauthorized use'[0]. YouTube requires you watch ads to use their website, so not doing that is piracy. The only reason there's no consequences for adblock are because (A) it'd be bad optics and bad PR to sue regular viewers, and (B) YouTube sees the value of subsidizing those who block ads as a plus, since it means they can keep their tight grip on where 'everyone' goes to watch videos and thus where creators are required to upload if they want people to see their stuff. If they blocked ~37% [1] of viewers with adblock, different services more lenient to ad blockers (at first) would be able to actually attract viewers and perhaps get the content creators to start dual-uploading their content.

0: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/piracy

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30151590

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by commoner on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:33PM (#30155659)
> YouTube requires you watch ads to use their website, so not doing that is piracy.

Piracy is another word for copyright infringement. Blocking ads on YouTube is not piracy because you are not violating copyright law (in any country that I'm aware of) by viewing only a portion of the content that is delivered to you. DVRs do the same thing as ad blockers for TVs, but in the U.S., the courts have ruled that DVR services do not infringe the copyrights of media companies.[1]

YouTube and other Google services don't forbid ad blocking in their terms of service.[2] If they did, there would be an uproar because Google itself includes an ad blocker in Chrome, which of course does not block any YouTube or Google ads.[3]

[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/business-us-cablevision-cour...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/static?template=terms

[3] https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/7632919

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by judge2020 on Monday February 14, 2022 @03:03PM (#30337495)
> which of course does not block any YouTube or Google ads

I've seen it block Google ads a few times on this one website which cycles through them every minute. It says the ad 'used too many resources and Chrome has killed it'.

Re:Adblocking people and non-adblocking people experience a ... by hackerfromthefu on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:03PM (#30155221)
You're missing so much in this analysis - the big advertising companies do much more than show ads - they stalk you in excruciating detail, they resell your private life information to untold abusers who try to gain advantage from you.

Taking advantage of you, by manipulating your mind is one of the basic premises of ads.

In some ideal 'fair' world ads would just present information for you to make rational choices - but nope, the reality is the ads industry is based on emotional/psychological manipulation. If you seek to understand you can research about the evolution of the industry since the time of Freud where they co-opted psychological techniques to sell things by exacerbating people's psychoses.

Put another way, your arguments would only make sense if the advertisers played fair but they are abusive and try to trick you. You can't make a fair deal with conniving.

The reality of this is so bad that it is destroying our society - at what point is allowing massive scale psychological manipulation/abuse for profit destroying society?

My post here is a bit ranty but I get upset at the lack of fair context in the presuppositions of your argument.