"Only once the second price is being paid do you see any return on the first one."
So he agrees with you: you start getting the benefits as soon as the "second price" is being paid.
And I don't think it's quite right to say that the sixteen hours are the actual reward. They're the space in which some of the actual reward occurs, so to speak. You pay the price of using 16 hours of your time to read Moby-Dick. You get the reward of 16 enjoyably-spent hours, and also the reward of having your brain reshaped in whatever way reading Moby-Dick does for you -- deepening your ideas about friendship or obsession or sailing or whales, etc.
The 16 hours you have to spend are still a price, even though you enjoy spending those hours. (Some people enjoy spending money. They're still paying when they do.) The 16 hours you spend reading Moby-Dick are 16 hours you aren't spending reading The Brothers Karamazov or sleeping or doing lucrative consultancy or talking with your friends.
I think, in addition, there is an 'unpleasant' quality about needing concentration for reading that the author feels more than you do. But that unpleasantness is not the core of the piece. The limited budget is.
Consider someone who reads 10 hours a week and buys 5 books a week. They will be buying books they will probably never read. They are paying the first price but never the second.
It is not something that costs me anything other than time, however that's not the "price" he's talking about. Otherwise "low price pleasures" wouldn't be a category, if you enjoy that time it's not marginally better than nothing.
1) money
2) time
It costs money to get access to the good you are consuming, and hours to unlock the value. Whether or not you enjoyed reading Moby Dick, you have 16 less hours in the time bank.
If you do enjoy it (I did not), you have paid 16 hours out of the time bank and reaped the reward of 16 hours of pleasurable reading.
There are “cheaper” thrills. I am told you can spend 5 minutes on TickTock and receive some quick gratification. The up front cost is low. The cumulative payoff of spending 16 hours watching cat videos may not be as ultimately rewarding to you as plowing through some classic literature.
All original content. It has its own twist to it. All in 5 to 10 minutes. Everything just flows, I never use any browsing. Just swipe.
EDIT: I also need to mention that TikTok is host to many, not just one, many emergent properties. Trends take off, people from around the world do the weirdest things which become super popular. Such as ASMR videos, example: whispering secretary
The time spend by purely relaxing activities like reading or watching is on itself a reward. You do it instead of doing something less pleasant- staring bored at the wall.
And the idea that you could have spent all that time doing something super useful is wrong if it is about opportunity cost. I tried multiple times to cut off all "time wasters" like reading fiction or videos. It ended in low productivity and depression each time.
When you're young and poor, the sticker price seems very close to the actual value, but as you get older and richer, you come to see the time spent as by far the most significant scalar quantity.
I don’t think it’s just time but also, as you allude to a bit, the extra effort, mental or physical.
So I wouldn't cross out "staring at a wall" as inarguably invaluable. It's what's going on in your head when you do it. Same as when reading that book.
However, this is basically just the idea of opportunity costs, and pointing out that they apply to more than just the money spent, but also the time.
The article's point is that there's a particular relationship between these costs and benefits. Namely, that the first cost only enables you to gain the benefit, but that you can't actually receive the benefit until you pay into the second, time cost. This is interesting because it's easy to forget or miscalculate that second cost, and because the second cost gates the benefit that means you may not be getting the full benefit from paying the first cost.
But yeah, many things require time and once you paid for something, often using isn't instant.
I speed read War and Peace for the first time in ~4 hours for the school test (I refused to read assigned literature). It went into one ear and into another.
I then re-read it while recovering from the surgery over a leisurely week and enjoyed it tremendously as I think would anyone who gives it time.
My mother told me she read just the Peace parts, while my father admitted to reading only the War parts (they are pretty much alternate chapters).
It's too bad we can't structure assigned reading and coursework in terms of choice, I distinctly remember choosing to work on harder assignments when given choices back in the grade school era.
There was a time I wanted to learn Russian to read Tolstoy and Dostoevsky.
You can read those masterworks at a superficial level and they’re usually somewhat rewarding. Or you can read Dostoyevsky while deep diving on Russian history and get a notably different experience. But it takes a lot longer.
1: https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2013/08/th...
Overanalysing it kills that pleasure and atmosphere. That is not reading, that is doing seminar.
People want 1.5 speed because that's what gets the narrator back to a normal speaking speed.
I think the broader point the author is making is that we are over-consuming — because we can. But without the fulfillment that comes from the time spent with the purchased thing we are finding our lives paradoxically empty.
The problem the author elucidates really resonated with me, but perhaps it was framed a little awkwardly.
We are living in an age when consuming is easy, while time has become so much more precious. Contrast that with days past when the opposite was true: purchases were precious while time was more plentiful.
When exactly was supposed that be?
People like pastoralists who watch over grazing flocks are relatively free too, it is not a constant work comparable to a factory floor.
Traditional female works were a bit different. A lot of spinning, for example, that was a major time eater, and independent of season.
Yeah no. That meme came from estimation of some economist that completely ignored what actually male (or female) peasants done. And conditions they actually lived in.
And they already knew how to make candles.
I have some first-hand knowledge from them, which I consider quite reliable. They are all dead now, but their conditions were quite alike.
The work in the height of the agricultural season was very hard and arduous. A huge problem was the weather: if it rained too much, or not at all, food would become very expensive.
But I stand by my claim that they had a lot of free or semi-free time. Their entire rhythm of living was different.
For example, every Sunday, there was a market in a town 20 kms away. My grandma walked there and back to sell some eggs and cheese and buy whatever the village did not produce (e.g. kerosene for the kerosene lamp). It was 4 hours each way, but the time spent walking there wasn't work. The villagers went in a group, talked, told stories, flirted, sung etc. on the way. So the journey was a mix of leisure, exercise and bonding.
Or another example. Girls would often knit or decorate clothing together. It was an important activity, but under no hard deadline or quality pressure (unlike in a factory), and they usually gathered together and had a good time talking, sewing, relaxing for a bit. Someone could actually read stories aloud to pass time etc.
These days, we have rather hard divisions between "work", "hobby" and "leisure". Only a few moments in the day (the watercooler chit-chat) are somewhere in between.
That wasn't the case in premodern rural society and my grandparents yet lived in such a world.
Decorating cloth is work. It just is and was. Nor something you can avoid and something you are judged on. I listen to music when coding and to podcast when doing repetitive work. Does not make it not work.
You know why we girls don't don't anymore? Because it is boring repetitive chore to large majority of us. And I actually did some embroidery - it is cool in small amounts. Emphasis on small.
And it was not all relaxing either. You are talking about period with huge pressures, periods of lack of food due to wars.
In generation in between, there are people who cant relax. They feel guilty and will badge you if you dare to sit and rest.
The 200 hours isn't quite the reward. A jog isn't rewarding. Reading a paragraph isn't rewarding. You need to read perhaps a chapter at least to get some reward.
I bought Dune. I read until the legendary "fear is the mind killer" scene. And then I put it down and haven't picked it up yet. I got some reward from it, probably not the full amount, but I just couldn't afford the hours to finish the book.
Honestly, I'm not sure if you can say that the money spent is truly a "cost" either.
Consumers love buying books (spending money) as much as they love reading books (spending time).
There is definitely a sense of reward in simply buying a book - even one you never read - just as there is for buying clothes you'll never wear or gadgets you'll never use.
Is there? Doesn't that just make you feel like an idiot for wasting your money? The only feeling I ever get after spending money is "this better not suck".
Feeling a sense of reward simply for spending money sounds unhealthy.
> Is there?
W-w-what? Of course there is reward in simply buy a book. Or, perhaps, one could say there is reward in the possessing of the book, and maybe not the purchasing. Or maybe that's a distinction with no distinction. In any case, it's certainly true that one can get reward from buying books without the necessity of reading them.
> Doesn't that just make you feel like an idiot for wasting your money?
Sorry, I'm not seeing where any "wasting" enters into it. If I buy a book I want, the reward is having it. There is no waste. I got what I wanted. What you're saying only makes sense if you make the rather odd assumption that the value of a book is exclusively in the reading of the book...
I mean... do you, or have you ever, collected anything simply for the sake of having that something? Stamps? Vinyl records? Magazines? Bicycles? Video game consoles? Something?? I mean, it's quite a common activity. I would think most anybody would be able to relate to this.
Then when I did read them, they greatly affected me, and were as worthwhile as I had originally hoped.
I could've died without ever reading them, but I still bought them to read at some undefined future date.
If I wanted to have books on a shelf for visual decoration, I believe that there are fake books available. But I have enough real ones.
Getting a signed first edition or something for the collector value seems reasonable to me, but I don't know why I would want it if I hadn't read some version of it.
I do. But only digitally nowadays. I hardly own any physical goods. Maybe $10-$15k taken together at most. I realize this puts me close to an extreme end.
As a kid I used to 'play' trading card games - but I hardly played them and mostly just spent a large portion of my meager allowance on buying painted cardboard. With the benefit of hindsight I could've spend that money on things that would have brought me considerably more joy, but I consider that a valuable lesson in itself.
I don't begrudge people their collections. There's still purpose in that. However buying something for your collection is different from buying for the sake of buying.
There are some uses of money which are primarily philanthropic or social messaging. In these cases, the utility of the good or service is ancillary to the purchase. As overall economic welfare continues to improve, the niche for these things increases. The split between purpose and utility varies, maybe 5/95 for that chocolate bar that says it is protecting the rainforest (doubtful) but 40/60 for Girl Scout cookies. It's hard to straddle anywhere near that 50/50 line, but again, as the niche expands, the markets will eventually figure out more products for the space.
"This NGO better be honest". It's not about the water bottle.
When I spend money, I expect something (to happen) in return. It doesn't have to benefit myself.
If you enjoy wasting money on books you are not going to read, I suggest you just set the money on fire instead. Or bury it and take the location to your grave. You'll do everyone else a favor by driving down the cost of goods, and nobody had to labor or waste resources on something you weren't planning to use. The economy will instead find something useful to do it with that labor and those resources.
Alternatively donate it as in your example - if you want to benefit someone specific. Maybe to the author whose book you weren't going to read?
If someone buys a collectible book with no intention of reading it, is it really a waste of resources?
Stuff is collectible because it's not being made any more and can't be. A signed first edition of something can't be sending an economic signal to produce more.
The money paid represents labor and resources forgone, and the more that the collectible costs, the more labor and resources is reserved for better purposes.
It is depriving someone else who would like to own it and possibly read it, but is that honestly a loss to society?
- You still need to manage / expose / dedicate space / maintain your collectibles to enjoy them
- It can be an investment so it’s really different than buying something to use it. It’s buying something hoping to resell it. Still, we could say you also pay with incertitude, maybe stress and responsibility if it’s something expensive.
This is true. A sense of proportion is always useful. Wouldn't you expect maintenance to be orders of magnitude smaller than creating things in the first place, very generally?
>It can be an investment so it’s really different than buying something to use it
I don't know what you are trying to say. Investment is inherently deferred consumption, and the higher the value, the more consumption is deferred. That leaves more resources for people who need them.
Imagine a stylized society with one rich person who has a billion dollars, and everybody else is poor.
If that person spends their billion dollars on a rare book, then the only thing that has been taken away from society is that book. And usually there is more than one copy of a book, so other people can still read the story, they just don't have the specific physical object.
But if they spend their billion dollars on, say, constructing a palace, then the resources could have been used to build thousands of homes for ordinary people.
Money is not a resource.
It seems healthier than having a sense of anxiety. Living in a moneyed society requires spending money, so why attach a sense of dread to it?
Also, if the experience of spending itself was valued at the amount being spent, this economy would break down in an instant.
If I was going to drive myself to destitution chasing good feeling like a rat in an experiment, there are far more effective hits I could get than just "the feeling of spending money on something I like, but may not actually use."
I already have to have the skills to not let good feelings completely drive my decision making, so what benefit is there to making an unavoidable process into a source of negative feelings? Would it be healthy to feel nausea every time I eat so that I don't overindulge?
It might be healthier than becoming obese which comes with it's own negative feelings.
Despite obesity being a (if not the) leading cause of death, people are overindulging anyways.
It would appear that overwhelmingly people will act against their best interests if it just makes them feel good. At least when it comes to food.
I'm happy for you that you appear to be an exception.
Personally, I only think money is wasted when you don't get what you were trying to get when you spent the money. So if you decide to spend your money buying a delicious burrito, but it turns out to taste bad, then it was wasted money.
If you are trying to buy a book to bring you the joy you feel when buying a book, and you get that joy, then it isn't money wasted. If you buy it and then regret it after and don't feel the joy, then it was wasted.
It's still wasted. That person would just be an egocentric idiot. Even if they are a happy idiot.
A capitalist society cannot work properly if the experience of buying is valued at the cost of whatever is bought.
Neither can this world or society sustain widespread wastefulness. It hurts everyone (else).
Wasting money on things that are unused causes labor and resources to be diverted from more worthy endeavors. More directly it causes the price of those goods to increase, or even become unavailable.
Ultimately you need to trust that if someone spends, there's utility to the spend, otherwise they wouldn't have - even if the act of spending is the benefit itself.
It's not for 3rd parties to judge the usefulness of the spend. To illustrate this, think about the typical teenager who's mom says wastes all their time on "insert hobby mom doesn't like" and extrapolate that to the world's consumption habits. Everyone thinks others are wasteful.
Of course there is. Most books people buy can be borrowed from a library for free, but people still do it.
You pay literally for physical copy only in this case. You literally can get it for free.
There's definitely an alternative framing for entertainment. My friend gladly traded $60 for something that promised to take 100 hours. If it only took 50 hours, he would have found it less valuable.
I have this problem with games; there are lots of games. I can only find out if I enjoy one by spending time on it (and unfortunately the industry seems to like drawing things out such that the first hour or three aren't necessarily representative). Unfortunately, very often it is the case I go in hoping I would enjoy it, but after a while have to cut it short because it's not enjoyable. Not only have I not gotten much out of it, I've lost all the time I could have spent on something more enjoyable (or productive). And it's still true that I've lost the time, even if I enjoyed the activity. One tricky part with games that start out as fun (and addictive) is that it can take a while to realize it's not fun anymore and hasn't been for a while. And I've definitely had regrets with games that don't feel fun but after consulting opinions, "trust me it gets better." Ugh.
That sort of plays in to the value calculus on games.. a common mindset I see in reviews is that if a game offers hundreds of hours of gameplay, it is a high value game. For me, it rarely works out that way; I'm not a bored teenager desperate for entertainment, and in practice long games rarely seem to respect my time. They're long because they drag on and push you into running around, dull repetitive grind and fighting, mass produced shallow quests, boring errands, copypaste scenery spread over a large map... Quantity over quality. From my perspective, a game can definitely have negative value.
What I'm looking for in games today is definitely the opposite. Maximum quality that lasts a weekend at most and then I can move on in life. And I still don't want to waste most of my weekends playing games, even if I could find good ones.. Similarly, I have a bunch of books about which I've been wondering whether it's really worth my time reading them.
I'm sure I'd feel differently if I could somehow make more time available to me (e.g. work only three days a week oslt).
Try a board game! Seems like a great fit for what you want.
That said, I own several books and games that I haven’t put the effort into reading/playing yet. Reading and gaming aren’t effortless
Take the Moby Dick example... the author says you don't get the return on it until you have paid the 16 hour price of reading it... but isn't those sixteen hours the actual reward? You don't read a book to be finished with it, you read it because you like the reading process. The reward starts the first minute you start reading the book.
Not only that, but you don't have to finish the book to get something out of reading it. If you enjoyed the time you spent reading, that is enough.
This attitude seems very "completionist", where you only get value after you finish something. That isn't how I view things.
Also, why does he think mindless apps and games are the same as doing nothing? The idea is you enjoy the time spent playing the game. Sure, you don't end up with anything after, but you enjoyed the time.