News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by martinald on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @01:55AM (#29990764)
It's interesting to see just how slow faster ethernet standards have been. Feels like I've had gigabit ethernet at a pretty low cost for nearly 20 years now, but faster than that has been pretty esoteric outside of the datacentre.

I guess there really isn't much demand for faster than gigabit speeds even now (outside of servers?)

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by buro9 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:13AM (#29991135)
Lots of reasons:

1. Consumer broadband speeds rarely exceed 1Gbps

2. 1Gbps Local network transfers are seldom slowed by the network (as large file work typically involves HDD still)

3. Where local network transfers are impeded by the network speed the transferring itself isn't a frequent enough and blocking thing that people feel they need to fix it... they just go make a cup of tea once or twice a day

4. There are a lot of old network devices and cables out there, some built into the fabric of buildings (wall network sockets and cable runs)

5. WiFi is very very convenient, so much so that 250Mbps is good enough for almost anything and most people would rather be wireless at that speed than wired at a much higher speed (gamers and video professionals being an exception)

And ultimately, the cost and effort of investing in it doesn't produce an overwhelming benefit to people.

Even in quite large offices, it's hard to argue that this is worth it when the vast majority of people are just using web applications and very lossy audio and video meetings across the internet.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by erik on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:40AM (#29992011)
Another factor: data centres moved to fiber. And fiber is less physically robust and not great for desktop connections or plugging in to a laptop.

10GBASE-T exists, but it turns out pushing 10gbit/s over 100m of twisted pair requires chips that are hot and power hungry. Again, not great for desktops or laptops. And because it’s not used in data centres, there are no economies of scale or trickle down effects.

Gigabit Ethernet and wifi being “good enough” combined with 10gig over twisted pair being expensive and power hungry means that the consumer space has been stuck for a long time.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by DannyBee on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @08:39AM (#29993471)
This is, IMHO, completely right, though I think at this point the physical robust issue is moot.

It's easy enough to get G.657.B3/G.657.A3 cables, and you can wrap them repeatedly around a pencil and they are fine.

Also, most consumers would not notice the bend attenuation anymore becuase they aren't trying to get 10km out of them :)

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by salamandersauce on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:39AM (#29992407)
2.5Gb ethernet seems to be starting to trickle out at least. It's becoming a more common thing on desktop motherboards. Doesn't seem like there is a lot of 2.5Gb routers yet though.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by zinekeller on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:58AM (#29992554)
Thank Intel for single-handedly changing the 2.5Gbps landscape by integrating 2.5Gb Ethernet on their chipsets, allowing no-brainer OEM integration. Unfortunately, unless ISP router OEMs (Nokia, Zyxel, Huawei et al.) do their part (the reason being that very few people actually bothers to buy a separate router), we will not see the economies of scale necessary to fully finish 2.5Gb Ethernet.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ksec on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:43PM (#29998922)
But is kind of sad they skip 5Gbps. I thought it was the best compromise for consumer between 1 and 10 Gbps Ethernet.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by zinekeller on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:45AM (#30021305)
> But is kind of sad they skip 5Gbps. I thought it was the best compromise for consumer between 1 and 10 Gbps Ethernet.

I suppose forwards compatibility is good, but unfortunatel unlike 2.5Gbps, 5Gbps is practically unusable on existing CAT5e cables.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by wmf on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:19PM (#30000288)
5 Gbps will probably come to the consumer market around 2030.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by NavinF on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:07AM (#29992209)
> fiber is less physically robust

Maybe this used to be the case long ago, but I don’t think it’s true today. Personally I’m pretty rough with fiber (having slammed cabinet doors on fiber, looped fiber around posts with a low bend radius, left the ends exposed to dust, etc) and had no issues within a data center. Can’t say the same for copper. Even the cheapest 10km optics have more margin when your link is only 50m.

Oh and bend insensitive fiber is dirt cheap and works just fine when it’s tied into knots.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by LargoLasskhyfv on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @12:29PM (#29996760)
Yes, even in my days with FDDI (pre-2000) you could wrap them around your finger, no matter if multi- or single mode. At least for 'demo'-purposes, to stop the hyperventilation of some people. Nonetheless I've seen horrible installations, where I've straightened out the gordic knots when I've seen them, just to be sure ;-)
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by aidenn0 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:41PM (#29998904)
The robustness gap has narrowed (not just with better fiber; some cat-6 STP is surprisingly fragile compared to old cat 5), but I think copper is still more robust for short runs where there will be many insertions and removals.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by sigstoat on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @12:32PM (#29996814)
> And fiber is less physically robust and not great for desktop connections

i buy armored multimode patch cables for, i dunno, 10 or 20% more per unit length, and they seem indestructible in my residential short-distance use cases.

> Gigabit Ethernet and wifi being “good enough”

i think this explains it all. when the average user prefers wireless to wired gigabit, we know how much bandwidth they actually need, and it isn't >=gigabit.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by liketochill on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @01:34PM (#29997959)
It takes special connectors to survive being disconnected and reconnected daily and cables left disconnected with out the risk of an accidental laser eye surgery
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by sigstoat on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:08PM (#29999277)
> It takes special connectors to survive being disconnected and reconnected daily

i don't know what you're using, but the LC/LC connectors i use seem pretty durable, and the springy bit that wears out can be replaced. the SFP+ modules are all metal; i am unwilling to believe they can wear out.

> and cables left disconnected with out the risk of an accidental laser eye surgery

single mode, which isn't human-visible, is of concern but the multimode (which i mentioned using) isn't any worse than a cheap laser pointer. it isn't strong, and you can see it.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by liketochill on Friday January 21, 2022 @01:26PM (#30027805)
I mostly deal with single mode and in industrial environments, on top of the safety hazard fibers left dangling tend not to work when plugged back in due to dust. There are special connectors for applications such as ship to shore that address these issues.

Maybe a laser in your eye is an acceptable risk in your home but I doubt it is an acceptable hazard in a work place.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ksec on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:40PM (#29998884)
>requires chips that are hot and power hungry.

That is finally improving. The technology improvement meant we get less than 5W per port on 10Gbps. Cost will need to come down though.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by AceJohnny2 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:22AM (#29991174)
All excellent points but I'd remove gamers from there:

> (gamers and video professionals being an exception)

I play Stadia, 4K HDR 60FPS, just fine on a gigabit ethernet connection and 150MBit internet connection. Any games not streaming the entire video are fine with just kilobits/s of data, as long as the latency is good.

So the case for home 10GE is even weaker ;)

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by buro9 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:26AM (#29991193)
Gamers aren't a strong answer :D but they're the audiophiles of home computing hardware and networks and the most likely to overspend in the belief that it's better :D
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by Ourgon on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:54AM (#29991369)
Hm, that's taking it a bit far given that I've yet to see any gamer who believes that e.g. taping plastic bags with gravel to their network cables [1] will lower their ping times (if it is not for weighing down a cruddy connector which only works when you press the damn thing down, that is). There does not seem to be a gamer-equivalent of $30000 speaker cables [2] (8 ft., add $1500 per additional ft.) or $10.000 power cables [3] either. No, audiophiles still hold the biscuit for being the most easily deluded moneyed demographic out there. If Hans Christian Andersen were alive today he'd write a story about it, "The Emperor's new Speaker Cable" [4] where a little boy is the only one who dares to comment on the piece of rusty barbed wire connecting the speakers to the amplifier.

[1] https://www.machinadynamica.com/machina31.htm

[2] https://www.synergisticresearch.com/cables/srx-cables/srx-sc...

[3] https://www.synergisticresearch.com/cables/srx-cables/srx-ac...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor%27s_New_Clothes

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by LargoLasskhyfv on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @12:38PM (#29996942)
Oh. Really?

Why not compare the insane prices of thermal paste and compounds per volume/weight with the stuff that is used industrially?

Not always, but often used for results which could be called statistic noise. Very diminishing returns.

All for pushing reviews with many bar graphs over two dozen pages, and so much more page impressions. Like the rest of gamermedia, too.

Woo!

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by Ourgon on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:50PM (#30001574)
Show me the diamond-dust cooling paste for $10000 per CPU and you'll be right - for a little while. Soon you'll find that paste in larger $50.000 thimble-sized containers to be rubbed under all equipment "to open up the sound stage". Raving reviews will come in, "as if the composer is standing next to you", "the lows were really clearing up, as if the sun broke through the clouds".
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by LargoLasskhyfv on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:29PM (#30001996)
Hm, k. BUT...everything counts in large amounts :)

So we have the very few audiophiles which totally ignore the thin copper layer on cheap PCBs, versus the whole market segment of twitchy gamers going for Bling, Bling, Bling without function on their RAM, coolers, vs. the equivalent stuff installed in laptops and servers which lacks that :-)

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by Tostino on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @12:22PM (#29996644)
I love how much more ridiculous this has gotten since I last looked at this space ~15 years ago.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by kodah on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:49AM (#29991331)
Gamers being hard wired has everything to do with consistent latency in twitch style FPS's. That said, consistent latency is pretty beneficial in most PVP games.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ericd on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:17AM (#29991857)
Seems like they're saying that gamers would prefer wired to wifi, which I think is reasonable - it's not so much a bandwidth issue as a latency issue - wifi has higher latency, and higher variance than wired ethernet, especially if you get a crappy client joining and filling up the airtime with retry attempts. But maybe that's dominated by ISP variance for most.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by m_eiman on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:38AM (#29991267)
> as long as the latency is good.

Which is what rules out wifi :)

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by aequitas on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:20AM (#29992703)
You probably even don't need gigabit. A Stadia stream ranges from 10Mbit to 50Mbit depending on the quality settings. Latency and other network users are far more influential on gameplay.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by xondono on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:52AM (#29991355)
I understood GPs point to be “everyone is pretty much on wifi except professionals and gamers anyway”.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by jcelerier on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:11AM (#29991467)
Weird, SteamLink on gigabit ethernet is barely useable here
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by globular-toast on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:05AM (#29991777)
Looks like SteamLink only has a 100mbit/s NIC? People do often vastly overestimate how much bandwidth things need. The latest 4K HDR Blu-rays are easily streamable over 100mbit/s with a big enough buffer. A big buffer is no good for real-time gaming, of course, so they probably cap the peak bitrate to <100mbit/s which would be fine I imagine.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by jcelerier on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:20AM (#29992295)
It's the steamlink app of a samsung tv which is from 2020, I doubt it's 100mbit
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by globular-toast on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:34AM (#29992377)
You might be surprised. There are still quite a few 100mbit/s NICs shipped in new things. It would save them a few pennies. Raspberry Pis only got gigabit NICs in 2018 and only usable at gigabit speeds in 2020. Pis are more capable than a lot of smart TVs I've seen.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by AceJohnny2 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:48PM (#30017127)
Perhaps more of an encoding performance issue on the host computer?
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by thfuran on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @08:20AM (#29993242)
I think 1gbps is more limiting now in consumer space than 100 Mbps was back when gigabit started becoming widespread.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by walrus01 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:17AM (#29991152)
10GbE and 100GbE on fiber is quite cheap and easy now - but 99% of consumers and people doing ordinary stuff have no capability or interest in doing fiber. You can terminate cat5e or cat6 with $25 in hand tools...

I think what's new is the prevalence now of 2.5 and 5GBaseT ethernet chips that are cheap enough companies are starting to build them into any $125+ ATX motherboard. At short lengths even old crappy cat5e has a good chance of working at 2.5 or 5.0 speeds.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by gjulianm on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:16AM (#29991496)
Even 100GbE is hardly seen on company datacenters. Yes, it's cheaper than before, but still more expensive than 10G, and that's extra cost multiplied by all the devices that need to have the improved hardware to take advantage. Plus, most servers won't saturate a 10G link without tweaks on the setup. For 100G it's even worse, I think it will take a long time to see them on datacenters outside of core links or for companies with heavy bandwidth use (storage, video).
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by bradfa on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @09:03AM (#29993705)
I think the common knowledge that most servers can't saturate a 10Gb Ethernet link is no longer true. In my experience even saturating 25Gb links is rather easy to do when using 9000 byte MTU on mid-tier server hardware.

100Gb links do take some thought and work to saturate, but that's improving at a good rate lately so I expect it'll become more common rather soon.

The main downside to 25Gb and 100Gb links still seems to be hardware pricing. At these speeds, PCIe network adapters and switches get rather expensive rather quick and will make you really evaluate if your situation really demands those speeds. 10Gb SFP+ and copper network adapters and switches are quite inexpensive now in 2022.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by gjulianm on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @10:30AM (#29994865)
> In my experience even saturating 25Gb links is rather easy to do when using 9000 byte MTU on mid-tier server hardware.

But that's tweaking the setup already, it requires changes, testing and verification, and can cause problems in downstream equipment. And for a lot of applications, a 9K MTU will not be enough to saturate the link because they'll need NUMA awareness, or the NIC queues will need tweaking to avoid imbalances, or the application is not ready to send at that speed...

I'm not saying it can't be done, of course it can. But it isn't "plug a bigger card and it'll go faster".

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by toast0 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @11:11AM (#29995530)
> Plus, most servers won't saturate a 10G link without tweaks on the setup.

That doesn't seem right. When I got my first 10G server, it was running dual Xeon E5-2690 (either v1 or v2), and I don't recall needing to tweak much of anything. That was mostly a single large file downloaded over http, so not super hard to tweak anyway, but server chips are a lot better now than sandy/ivy bridge. It could only get 9gbps out with https, but the 2690v4 could do 2x10G with https because aes acceleration.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by gjulianm on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @11:40AM (#29995995)
> That was mostly a single large file downloaded over http, so not super hard to tweak anyway

Well, my point is that most servers don't just download single large files over HTTP. Even if you only look at storage servers, going into multiple files and connections you can easily find issues and have downgraded performance if you don't prepare the system for the workload.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by walrus01 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:35PM (#30002042)
I can saturate a 10G link on a $600 desktop PC with a consumer grade NVME SSD... serious servers are capable of far more than that.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by thedougd on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:43AM (#29992428)
I'm seeing 2.5 and 5 popping up all over the place. My WiFi App has 2.5 with POE. The aggregate bandwidth of the AP exceeds 1G. Spectrum cable modems have 2.5G ports now and AT&T Fiber is shipping their garbage gateway with a 5G port.

Unfortunately, I'm finding switches with 2.5 to still be overpriced.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by wolrah on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @09:52AM (#29994292)
As I understand it 2.5 and 5G modes were originally primarily aimed at WiFi APs as real-world capacities started to scale past gigabit speeds but replacing existing wiring for an entire building worth of APs to support 10G or completely redesigning the power infrastructure to support fiber would have been impractical.

Instead we run 10G signaling at half or quarter clock rates and get something that works on the majority of existing wiring.

AFAIK the IEEE was initially resisting supporting this, but enough vendors were just doing it anyways that it was better to standardize.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by zrail on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:57AM (#29992534)
I wanted to upgrade portions of my home network to multigig because Comcast is giving us 1.4Gbps and I wanted to use it. At least for me, 2.5 switches were way to expensive so I ended up with used Intel 10G cards connected with DACs to a cheap 5 port Mikrotik 10G switch. One 10GBase-T RJ45 SFP+ hooks into the modem.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by walrus01 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @09:24PM (#30003603)
"1.4Gbps" and probably 16Mbps upstream on DOCSIS3.1 channel bonding

I'd rather have a 100Mbps home DIA circuit that was symmetric and seriously reliable, than the typical Comcast circuit.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by zrail on Thursday January 20, 2022 @08:35AM (#30008676)
It's generally around 35-40Mbps upstream and between 600 and 1.2Gbps observed downstream, depending on the time of day.

I would also very much rather have a symmetric connection than what I have now. We are within range of a fiber tap for Comcast's 3Gbps symmetric ftth service but construction costs are too high right now for them to do it. I keep asking every six months regardless. There's no other game in town as far as I can tell.

Comcast Business will run a 100Mbps symmetric fiber for ~$750/mo, maybe that would be a thing to do to get fiber in the door and then switch back to residential after the contract earns out.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by yrro on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:39AM (#29992001)
2.5GBASE-T and 5GBASE-T are designed to work across 100 meters of Cat 5e. Nothing crappy about it! :)
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by yrro on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:35AM (#30007588)
That said...

https://www.cablinginstall.com/sponsored/berk-tek/article/16...

... points out that 5GBASE-T needs 200 MHz channel bandwidth which is past what Cat 5e is specified for. So perhaps for runs approaching 100 meters or in noisy environments, Cat 5e won't be reliable for 5GBASE-T after all.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by icelancer on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:14AM (#29992255)
2.5 and 5GBaseT is a great compromise, just wish UI would support it in their cheaper line of switches.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by vardump on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:20AM (#29990880)
Getting stuck to 1 Gbps is somewhat crazy, as even the slowest laptop and PC M.2 SSDs can do 10-20 Gbps easy. Fastest ones 50 Gbps+.

But I guess most people don't transfer files in their local networks anymore and use their network purely for internet access.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by vladvasiliu on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:33AM (#29990931)
> But I guess most people don't transfer files in their local networks anymore and use their network purely for internet access.

I think this is clearly the case. Most new laptops don't even bother with a wired network port. I've got a new "pro" HP laptop the other day, and it only comes with some cheap Wi-Fi card. And it's not an "entry-level" laptop, and it's thick enough for an RJ-45 plug to physically fit.

I also see more and more desktop motherboards come with integrated Wi-Fi. The desktops at Work (HP) also have had integrated Wi-Fi for a while, and it's not something we look for (they all use wired Ethernet).

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by Gigachad on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:38AM (#29992399)
It’s all usb c now. My iPad Pro has 10 gbit Ethernet support over the usb C port.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by rocqua on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @08:39AM (#29993484)
I am looking at wifi integrated motherboards, not for the wifi, but for the bluetooth support.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ThePadawan on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:01AM (#29991072)
I rent an apartment in a building that was erected around 2015. They laid an ethernet connection... with a 100Mbps bandwidth limit.

Some people just don't care.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by sjagoe on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:31AM (#29991594)
Are the ports in pairs at each location? Then it sounds like they did a Very Bad Thing and ran one cable per pair of ports; 100Mbps uses two pairs, so why use two cables when one cable has four pairs, right? :( I've seen that a lot in much older installations, but I'd expect better from 2015 construction.

I'm busy retrofitting Ethernet in my house by pulling cat6 through the walls and pulling out the old cat3 phone cabling. It's much harder work doing two cables (not least because none of the phone cables were in conduit, so it just starts off harder already) for each pair of ports, but it's very much worth the effort.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ThePadawan on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:38AM (#29991642)
I phrased this intentionally vaguely, because the details are more complicated, but also don't matter.

They didn't care, they just laid some sort of cable because that's all they had to.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by sigstoat on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @12:37PM (#29996919)
> Are the ports in pairs at each location?

there are a variety of ways to screw that up. i've seen a house that has a bunch of cat 5e run, but the installer stapled it down, and most of the cables have a staple through them somewhere along the run, killing a pair or two.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by social_quotient on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:42AM (#29991667)
Curious why did you go with cat 6 and not 6a or 7? Thinking about doing similar but want to make sure I’m not missing something.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by jabl on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:01AM (#29991752)
Cat7 is not a recognized standard by TIA/EIA, but there apparently is an ISO standard for it. Also, cat7 doesn't use RJ-45 connectors so it's not backwards compatible with older gear.

Cat6a is probably the sweet spot for home/office/etc structural cabling. It's not much more expensive than Cat6 (or Cat5e in case people are still putting that up), and has more than enough legroom.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by philjohn on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @08:16AM (#29993187)
Cat Cat6a is a pain to retrofit as it's stiffer and thicker than Cat6 in most cases. It's also more expensive (less so than before, but the delta is still there)

If each run is <55m then Cat6 can still do 10Gbps.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by tblt on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:06AM (#29991789)
They may have done this to run a single cable to supply both data and telephony/door intercom etc on the other pairs. I agree it's not ideal.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by xondono on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:55AM (#29991371)
> But I guess most people don't transfer files in their local networks anymore and use their network purely for internet access.

Most people don’t have anywhere in their local network to transfer things to. I still laugh when people see my home server and assume that’s “your work thing”. I do use it for work, but 99.99% of what’s contained in there are family pictures and photos.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ipdashc on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:18AM (#29991155)
I don't transfer files super often in my local network, but even when I do, gigabit is... honestly fast enough. Like it's never really bugged me.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by fulafel on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:40AM (#29990975)
People have been using faster ethernet in workstations for a long time, in data intensive jobs. But indeed the commodization has been going much slower than previous gens. My pet theory is that it goes back to the stall in internet connecitivity speeds, which in turn is caused by people jumping en masse to slow and flaky wifi and cellular connectivity. This then causes popular apps to adapt aggressively to low bandwidth and keeps apps requiring high bandwidth out of the mainstream.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:22AM (#29990888)
It's kind of chicken and egg. It's not worth buying a 10G switch when all or nearly all of your devices are gigabit and it's not worth buying 10G cards for any device when you have a gigabit switch.

What you need for the transition is for premium brands to start pushing 10G ports as a feature, e.g. Apple needs to add it to Macbooks and the Mini and start using it to bludgeon competitors who don't have it. Then once their customers have several 10G devices around, they buy a 10G switch and start demanding that every new device have it. At which point the volume gets high enough for the price to come down.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by dtech on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:37AM (#29991633)
I've noticed 2.5 becoming a bit more common on enthusiast hardware, so it'll be a while yet before 10G becomes mainstream, but 2.5 and 5 might be the standard for new hardware a decade from now.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by Jaruzel on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:54AM (#29991717)
The nice thing about 2.5gb/s is that you can still use existing CAT5e/6 cable runs (albeit at shorter distances).

I really want to start seeing 2.5gb/s becoming standard on Desktop motherboards asap.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by tomohawk on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:13AM (#29991830)
2.5 and 5 can use existing cat5e or better cabling. There is no solution for 10GigE that uses that cabling.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by jabl on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @09:05AM (#29993715)
10Gbase-T does 55m with Cat6, or the full 100m with Cat6A, both of which are ubiquitous and cheap. It's probably more to do with the expense and power consumption of 10Gbase-T PHY's.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by eatbitseveryday on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:46AM (#29991004)
> for premium brands to start pushing 10G ports as a feature, e.g. Apple needs to add it to Macbooks and the Mini

https://www.apple.com/mac-mini/specs/

> Gigabit Ethernet port (configurable to 10Gb Ethernet)

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ericd on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:24AM (#29991908)
I'd say it's worth it as soon as you have a home NAS, it lets you treat it almost as a local drive for any computer that also has 10G.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by Hamuko on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:56AM (#29992141)
I have a home NAS, but I think I need at least two, maybe three 10G switches in order to get everything hooked up properly. And then I need gear to actually get 10G on my computers. Sounds a bit expensive especially since the NAS is unfortunately limited to 2x1GbE.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ericd on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @09:24AM (#29993913)
Yeah, I’ve been a bit surprised at how few of the home tier NASes can get 10G. A bit of a chicken and egg, I guess.

You don’t need to go fully 10G, though, I mainly prioritized my workstation for example, and if you don’t want to splash out for switches, you can do a direct connection on 10G to a computer that needs it, and use the 1G links to the rest of the LAN.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by soneil on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:27AM (#29991921)
These are naive takes, accounting only for linespeed and nothing more, but give a useful rule of thumb:

- An 8x cdrom narrowly beats 10meg ethernet.

- 1x dvdrom narrowly beats 100meg ethernet.

- ATA133 narrowly beats 1gbit ethernet.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by sigstoat on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @12:47PM (#29997110)
> - 1x dvdrom narrowly beats 100meg ethernet.

that doesn't fit with my recollection of reading/transferring DVDs, or with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_storage_media_writing_...

> - ATA133 narrowly beats 1gbit ethernet.

the electrical interface/protocol, sure. i don't think any ATA133 drive made could actually saturate its interface, or a gigabit link.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by cosmotic on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:21AM (#29990886)
From my perspective the problem is availability and cost of 2.5, 5, and 10gbe switches.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by comboy on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:42AM (#29991292)
Mikrotik
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by Sebb767 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:25AM (#29991550)
It's still around 100$ and up (I know you can get it a bit cheaper, but not everyone searches). Gigabit switches, on the other hand, are basically free.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by panda88888 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:25AM (#29991554)
I have gigabit internet (downstream only... hoping for fiber one day for symmetric up/down), and I run wired gigabit ethernet for desktops and fixed devices to free up the wifi. For 99% everyday use it works just fine. Externally I hit 80+ MB/s on internet download (aggregate, very few sites saturate my downstream bandwidth), and internally I hit 90+ MB/s to and from my NAS. The only time I wish it was faster is when transferring really large files to/from the NAS, but only for 10GB+, so the extra cost of either SFP+ or copper 2.5/5/10G upgrade to the network is not really warranted. One day I might install a NVME cache on my NAS and run a straight 10G fiber from my workstation to the NAS, but that's more of a luxury (look I can transfer 10GB file in 10 sec instead of 100 sec!) than need.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by social_quotient on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:37AM (#29991632)
I’ve got google fiber 1 gig up and down. It’s plenty fast for external content but internally I’ve been annoyed at the network perf to my NAS so I got a secondary network card just to go from desktop to Nas at 10GbE speeds and it’s been great and it skips the need to overhaul the entire network stack.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by rocqua on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:43AM (#30006386)
Did that take any complicated setup to make the routing work?
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by tgtweak on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @12:29PM (#29996763)
It's not abysmal when you consider the standard (signaling, ECC) has to work over 80+km range in some cases. You'd be hard pressed to get a pci link to work over 10M.

That being said, I generally agree that it has been moving too slow in consumer electronics and 2.5G is a pretty long overdue step-up for a moore-adjacent technology. Another factor is the humble reality that infrastructure (physical cables installed in walls) is the (s)lowest common denominator in this advancement.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ezconnect on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:03AM (#29991084)
Because consumer found wifi more convenient and serves them well.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by digisign on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @12:25PM (#29996689)
Yep, though it isn't a problem I have any longer, using primarily wifi.

Flash drive writing speeds are my biggest bottleneck, wish someone would tackle that at a reasonable cost.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by doublepg23 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:03AM (#29990796)
Maybe once gigabit internet service becomes more widely available, but even for something like a consumer NAS you’re probably bottlenecked by something else no?
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by adwn on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:26AM (#29990899)
My hunch is that for most consumers, there's just no point in getting anything above 1 GbE today, even for their central switch. 1 Gbit/s is more than enough for 5x 4K video streams from their NAS, plus a very fast Internet connection at burst speed. What more do most people need on a regular basis?
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by pkulak on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:43AM (#29990989)
Working with files on a network share? Though, I do all my photo editing that way and it feels local over 1gbe. I could see video editing benefiting from it. Pretty niche though.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by glogla on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:10AM (#29990835)
NAS with SSD can go way faster than the ~ 120 MB/s 1GbE can offer. For NAS with HDD, the benefit is not as big but still there.

Also, the main competition is WiFi which is significantly slower than 1GbE in most cases.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by fulafel on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:42AM (#29990981)
Spinning HDDs are faster than this as well, 250-300 MB/s sequential read seems common per drive, and in a home setup you might have a couple of those in a RAID-1 giving 500-600 MB/s read BW.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by justsomehnguy on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:08PM (#30001001)
> couple of those in a RAID-1 giving 500-600 MB/s

If you are talking about only two drives than no. Multiple drives can give you more throughput, but at that point it is RAID-10.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by fulafel on Thursday January 20, 2022 @12:50AM (#30005232)
Right, for 2x single stream sequential read throughput + redundancy I guess you need somehing like Linux f2 RAID10 mode. Otherwise reading every other stripe per disk would kill you due to seeks or 50% wasted readahead.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by vladvasiliu on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:36AM (#29990949)
Well, seeing how large SSDs are still very expensive (in my mind it's €100 / TB), my hunch would be that if it makes sense for you to spend that much money on the drives, you probably won't really notice the price of a couple of 10 Gb network cards. They seem quite cheap on eBay if you're OK with used.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by k8sToGo on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:34AM (#29991612)
It is not the cards that are that expensive. It is also the switches etc.

Also SSD are not 100 EUR / TB. A 4 TB SSD is like 300 EUR.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by ericd on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:28AM (#29991930)
The Mikrotiks are pretty reasonably priced (though you need adapters to go to RJ45, and you can only populate every other port due to heat). But you're right, the low end of switches are generally 10-20x more expensive IME.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by vidarh on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:57AM (#29991733)
Having a NAS is a niche thing.

People who notice mine in the corner mostly don't even know what it is.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by 64bittechie on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:52AM (#29991029)
NAS with HDD and a boat load of RAM can easily saturate 10GbE NIC if you're using it as a media server. Most content on my NAS is cached and rarely touches the disk.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by doublepg23 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @12:44AM (#30082216)
I’m curious how your media content is being cached? Running a PLEX server very rarely would I get ZFS ARC hits even when a blockbuster came out.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by k8sToGo on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:15AM (#29990860)
I have gigabit fiber Internet and internally I use 2.5Gbit
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by rocqua on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:47AM (#30006415)
I checked performance on my server locally vs accessing the server as a NAS.

The simple spinning hard-drive was already faster than gigabit ethernet, and the NAS access speed was 90-95% of ethernet. So I am prerty sure that NAS is the bottleneck here. And this is on a WD-red 5400RPM harddrive, nothing special.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by DannyBee on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @08:36AM (#29993443)
The main thing, i think, is that outside of DAC, most faster speeds are used over fiber.

The cabling starts to become an issue otherwise. It's also hot and power hungry over copper.

Having gotten into the home fiber side of it for various reasons, it's clear on the fiber side there is plenty of innovation/cost lowering/etc.

Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by jabl on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @09:02AM (#29993694)
I mostly agree, but optical transceivers are still expensive. Been waiting for dirt cheap silicon photonics for a couple of decades now. But it seems they are on track to be a thing, though initially for high-speed networking not home/office type stuff. Maybe one day, sigh.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module by DannyBee on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @11:23AM (#29995708)
I'm not sure how you define expensive. https://www.fs.com/c/10g-sfp-plus-63

20 bucks over MMF, 27 bucks over SMF doesn't seem expensive.

If you want to do it over single fiber rather than duplex, it's 40 bucks: https://www.fs.com/c/bidi-sfp-plus-64

25Gbps is 39 bucks over MMF, 59 bucks over SMF. 40Gbps is also 39 bucks on MMF (more expensive on SMF)

I don't think any of these are very expensive.

The cards are also ~same price between SFP+ and 10GBaseT from places like startech (outside of that, the 10gbaset ones are actually often much more expensive)