Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by doublepg23 on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:03AM
(#29990796)
Maybe once gigabit internet service becomes more widely available, but even for something like a consumer NAS you’re probably bottlenecked by something else no?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by adwn on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:26AM
(#29990899)
My hunch is that for most consumers, there's just no point in getting anything above 1 GbE today, even for their central switch. 1 Gbit/s is more than enough for 5x 4K video streams from their NAS, plus a very fast Internet connection at burst speed. What more do most people need on a regular basis?
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by pkulak on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:43AM
(#29990989)
Working with files on a network share? Though, I do all my photo editing that way and it feels local over 1gbe. I could see video editing benefiting from it. Pretty niche though.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by glogla on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:10AM
(#29990835)
NAS with SSD can go way faster than the ~ 120 MB/s 1GbE can offer. For NAS with HDD, the benefit is not as big but still there.
Also, the main competition is WiFi which is significantly slower than 1GbE in most cases.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by fulafel on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:42AM
(#29990981)
Spinning HDDs are faster than this as well, 250-300 MB/s sequential read seems common per drive, and in a home setup you might have a couple of those in a RAID-1 giving 500-600 MB/s read BW.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by justsomehnguy on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:08PM
(#30001001)
> couple of those in a RAID-1 giving 500-600 MB/s
If you are talking about only two drives than no. Multiple drives can give you more throughput, but at that point it is RAID-10.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by fulafel on Thursday January 20, 2022 @12:50AM
(#30005232)
Right, for 2x single stream sequential read throughput + redundancy I guess you need somehing like Linux f2 RAID10 mode. Otherwise reading every other stripe per disk would kill you due to seeks or 50% wasted readahead.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by vladvasiliu on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:36AM
(#29990949)
Well, seeing how large SSDs are still very expensive (in my mind it's €100 / TB), my hunch would be that if it makes sense for you to spend that much money on the drives, you probably won't really notice the price of a couple of 10 Gb network cards. They seem quite cheap on eBay if you're OK with used.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by k8sToGo on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:34AM
(#29991612)
It is not the cards that are that expensive. It is also the switches etc.
Also SSD are not 100 EUR / TB. A 4 TB SSD is like 300 EUR.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by ericd on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:28AM
(#29991930)
The Mikrotiks are pretty reasonably priced (though you need adapters to go to RJ45, and you can only populate every other port due to heat). But you're right, the low end of switches are generally 10-20x more expensive IME.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by vidarh on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:57AM
(#29991733)
Having a NAS is a niche thing.
People who notice mine in the corner mostly don't even know what it is.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by 64bittechie on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:52AM
(#29991029)
NAS with HDD and a boat load of RAM can easily saturate 10GbE NIC if you're using it as a media server. Most content on my NAS is cached and rarely touches the disk.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by doublepg23 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @12:44AM
(#30082216)
I’m curious how your media content is being cached? Running a PLEX server very rarely would I get ZFS ARC hits even when a blockbuster came out.
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by k8sToGo on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:15AM
(#29990860)
I have gigabit fiber Internet and internally I use 2.5Gbit
Re:Add 10 GbE to your system with an M.2 2280 module
by rocqua on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:47AM
(#30006415)
I checked performance on my server locally vs accessing the server as a NAS.
The simple spinning hard-drive was already faster than gigabit ethernet, and the NAS access speed was 90-95% of ethernet. So I am prerty sure that NAS is the bottleneck here. And this is on a WD-red 5400RPM harddrive, nothing special.