Attempts to refuel will be completely unneeded.
Edit:
This seems to be a controversial opinion (based on down votes). To clarify, my expectation is that if launch costs have come down as much as people suggest, launching a new and improved (potentially significantly larger) space telescope would be a better use of funds than a complicated and risky refuelling mission. There will be many lessons learnt from JWST that by then there will be an appetite for something new.
My hope also is that if the cost to launch has come down so would the development costs of any new satellites, leading to reduced costs for science missions.
It's fair to say that over two decades, additional capabilities will exist.
Given the advances in launch systems, both in situ assembly (large structures w/o complex packaging and deployments), and planned servicing and replaceability could mean that both arguments are true:
- We'll have bigger, more capable, and/or simply more observatories.
- Those themselves will be capable of being serviced and upgraded over their own lifetimes.
Keep in mind that one element of science that's advanced by such projects is engineering systems for space environments themselves. Vacuum, radiation, micrometeorites, station-keeping, gravitational flux and variance, materials handling (cold-welding, lubrcation, moving parts, etc.), thermal management, and design-for-servicing itself, all factor in to considerations.
It seems highly probable to me that any such servicing itself will all but certainly be robotic. At L2, speed-of-light issues are a factor as there is a one-way signal time of five seconds, long enough that direct control of physical manipulators is no longer feasible, or very slow. (Imagine that you reach for a wrench, and ten seconds later, see that your hand has actually extended and contacted it.) And putting humans in such a location, only reachable over many days or weeks, well out of Earth's magnetosphere radiation projection, would be fantastically expensive.
The LUVOIR is the next generation - https://asd.gsfc.nasa.gov/luvoir/ and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_Ultraviolet_Optical_Infr...
The design for it is really impressive.
> LUVOIR Architecture A (LUVOIR-A) features a 15-m diameter primary telescope aperture and four serviceable instruments
JWST has a 6.5 meter mirror.
The larger the aperture, the smaller the resolved object that we can look at. For example, looking at the central black hole of M87 which is on the order of "diameter of the solar system" ( https://xkcd.com/2135/ ).
However, the only reason we are able to resolve it is that it is so bright.
But if you want to look at dim objects, then the area of the light gathering is the important value. That is why Arecibo was so important ( https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2005AAS...207.2907D/abstra... )
For the HSA - it used the largest of the radio dishes available - https://science.nrao.edu/facilities/vlba/HSA
The Green Bank Telescope 100m and the Effelsberg 100m telescopes are much more sensitive than the VLA... but the VLA can resolve 0.2 and 0.04 overall.
So yes, we could send up a bunch of 3m space telescopes out to the L2 point - but how many individual miniature instruments are we going to need to make for each, how much propellant will be needed for each, how will you keep the cold side cold (size matters)?
While I'm not a rocket scientist, I'm not sure that those are easy problems to solve... and I feel like they're much harder problems to solve than ones that the JWST and the current line of telescope proposals have.
>It's fair to say that over two decades, additional capabilities will exist.
Capability doesn't create need, in either a technical or economic/resources sense.
Too many people are interpreting "unneeded" as: "a satisfactory amount of fuel for a long-enough lifespan, but more would be better"...
When it really means: "fuel is no longer the most likely controlling/ limiting factor as to what ultimately triggers the end of webb's usable/useful lifespan".
Even if fuel ends up being the actual limiting factor, no ability to extend the (likely) lifespan of ALL the other critical components makes refueling a high-risk, high-cost, low-return venture.
Of course it does! Today we have all kinds of needs that people 20, 100, 1000 years did not have. That's because the capability to do something created the need for it.
For an obvious example, people need iphones. Nobody had one 20 years ago.
For another, deodorant wasn't needed 100 years ago. The need for it was totally created by the ability to manufacture it.
Capability allows the market to exist and creates potential for demand.
For certain levels of actual demand and saturation, social/cultural normalcy and expectations might lead to "need" as you describe it.
But in this case, I meant specifically that Webb, given 20 yrs of remaining fuel, won't suddenly "need" refueling if the experimental technology suddenly becomes avaliable in 19 years, as the remaining system also approaches end of life.
Fuel is no longer the most likely point of failure for determining lifespan. That might have been different if Webb had to use more fuel on its trajectory burn, had only a few years of fuel, and the technology was extant/eminent and cheap.
The risk-v-reward calculus would completely different, but unlikely to change at this point.
If my truck throws a rod on a roadtrip in Alaska and I limp upon a gas station as my 20yo dying truck burns the last of its gasoline... I don't "need" gasoline, I need a flight home and a new truck.
And that fuel itself, over 20 years, could prove not to be the limiting factor.
There remains the point that you've stated, and are again asserting, an absolute condition, that refueling is completely unneeded. Given that a now + 20 years JWST that is still functional except for fuel might exist, that categorical absolute remains unjustified, regardless of how probable it might be. And again, it's specifically how you're communicating this that seems to be raising objections.
None of us have a perfect view of the future. JWST itself offers only an improved view of the past, after all.
In what hypothetical scenario does fuel deplete at a greater than expected rate, in a way that wouldn't also call into question the reliability and expected lifespan of the remaining limiting factors?
Accidental commanded release? A leak? Station-keeping being more demanding than expected? Those would all move risk-v-reward in the wrong direction.
And it doesn't substantially decrease the cost or risks, other than what might be gained by an extended development period, which would need to be weighed against simultaneous advances better applied to and spent on a successor.
So maybe not an absolutism, but an already highly-unlikely proposition who's chances of implementation just decreased dramatically due to the new information at hand.
[0] By ending up with an older/ closer to failure but refueled satellite, and a decreased relative value of remaining potential science/observations, presuming highest value science is done first.
They are not the elements of your initial nor follow-up comments with which I've had issue. And you continue to not address those.
As for what might lead to low-fuel-but-serviceable observatory: reaction-wheel degreadation shy of failure (there are multiple redundant wheels for each axis of rotation), possibly some kind of solar-storm or solar-wind interaction which increases station-keeping requirements.
It's difficult to foresee what previously anticipated scenarios might emerge, for all the obvious reasons. But if I had a $10 billion low-on-fuel observatory on my hands, it was still turning in good science, and my capabilities to provide it with fuel had improved markedly, and there was nothing else obviously imminantly limiting lifetime ... I might opt for the top-up. Even at a cost of a few sheckles.
Keep in mind that the opportunity cost isn't the amortised value of the observatory, but its projected future life and the cost of replacing that functionality. I don't know what the associated values here are. I could envision a reality in which those turned favourable for a refueling mission.
Which, again, contradicts your original, and several-times-sustained, "completely unneeded" assertion.
The horse seems quiet well flogged, and in the interests of a peaceful death, I'm begging off further beating of it.
Yeah you might be able to get bigger and heavier but it still needs to contend with launch forces.
Now assembling it in space might change things… but I’m sure that has its own challenges. And even then you’d probably want a space elevator instead of rockets to get your people and equipment int local orbit.
The Arian 5 costs around $185M to launch, they therefore need to make sure it works first time.
Starship is estimated to be $2-10M.
Size constraints are particularly obvious. For instance, it's 6.5M diameter mirror needed to fold up for launch to fit inside the less than 5.4M diameter fairing. That would fit comfortably without folding in Starships 9M diameter. The sunshield wouldn't quite fit unfolded (14m x 29m), but you can almost guarantee that it would have had a simpler deployment mechanism.
Mass constraints are maybe more important, but less obvious. JWST weighs 6161 kg, Starship is aiming for a payload of more like 100,0000 kg, and by taking advantage of orbital refuelling the capability to put that anywhere instead of it being severely reduced past LEO. That means you can use heavier mirrors instead of optimizing them for weight, you can build your structures out of easy to work with materials light metal, instead of hard to work with ones like carbon fiber. You can oversize parts, and include redundant ones if you think they might be needed.
Even if you totally ignored the cost of the launch, the capabilities of a super heavy launcher would make a huge difference. The cost is the icing on the top. It means that as long as you can build a second version for substantially cheaper than the first, you don't have to design the first so that it never fails. For instance, you don't have to design your heatshield on earth and never test the design in 0G until it's on your 10 billion dollar satellite that has to work...
Imagine instead launching components that could be docked together in orbit, tested, and then boosted to it's destination orbit.
Speculation is somewhere in the 70%-90% of original cost.
Doing it after the fact--- some design work would be saved, but how much of the tooling and supply chain still exists? Parts are going to need re-engineering, etc.
You can also remove large categories of risk by freely spending mass and volume.
> Starship is estimated to be $2-10M.
Don't believe the hype. If Starship works out, they can beat other paths to orbit by a fair margin, but it's not going to be a >10x reduction. Much likely much less than that, too.
There should never be such an expensive program again because hopefully we'd realize its easier to also build a massive 1-off rocket for it instead of years developing awesome folding things. Has all the money SpaceX have ever spent so far even come to 10 billion yet?
Instead of a huge sunshade, use a telescope tube and a huge amount of liquid helium (even the relatively small amount in Spitzer lasted many years, and this is one instance where mass directly translates into time). Instead of big unfolding mirror, use a monolithic one.
This would actually be technically superior to Webb (colder mirror and instruments than you can get with the typical Webb cryocooler, less starlight impacting the instruments as your telescope tube with baffles shields it better, less diffraction off the mirror segment interfaces) and ought to be potentially much simpler and cheaper. And you could afford to build more than one, allowing you to reduce risk aversion slightly and increase telescope time.
I grew up at Lick Observatory in the Bay Area, and really love ground-based stuff, but I'm somewhat familiar with their operations and I guarantee it's got nothing on space 'scopes.
You literally could have 1000 tons of liquid nitrogen delivered to your telescope if you needed to, if it saved $1 billion.
I think people still aren’t understanding the ambitions of Starship. We’re not talking about a 30% improvement in cost. But a 300000% improvement in part because you could even afford human technicians…
... not at the same wavelengths. The earth's atmosphere is largely opaque to IR, for instance.
There are some things you can only do beyond the atmosphere.
Not that space isn't also hard, but each environment has both affordances and limitations.
Propellant is often a key limitation to life of a satellite, especially for earth-observations sats in low earth orbit (the opposite of the JWT), and it's well worth refuelling a satellite in principle.
The JWT is a _lot_ of expensive hardware. It's not crazy at all to think about refuelling, especially if it's expending significant propellant to say in a stable orbit +/- maneuver for imaging operations.
All that having been said, refuelling is still a long way from reality, and despite a lot of companies marketing refuelling ports and similar things, it will be a long while time until it's a realistic solution. Over the lifetime of the JWT, it probably will become feasible, though.
I believe the GP is correct: wear and tear on existing components means that fuel won't be the only issue in 20 years. Hubble has been serviced 5 times [1] for example.
Part of the complexity (and thus cost) for JWST was all the issues introduced by trying to fit a 6.5m mirror on existing rockets. All those moving parts and points of failure have design costs.
What you may find in 20 years is that we'll want to launch an even larger mirror and/or use interferometry between multiple telescopes to improve effective resolution.
[1]: https://www.space.com/15892-hubble-space-telescope.html#:~:t....)
I wouldn't say he's a "pariah because of his wealth." If anything, he's probably a pariah for consistently, wildly over-promising (overshooting "optimist" to land in "liar" territory) and being a jerk (e.g. defaming that the cave diver, among other things).
Then add to that obnoxious fanboys who've made him a weird tech Jesus, and who defend him and bring up his brain farts at every opportunity. I, at least, wouldn't mind never hearing about him again. Lets hear about the cool people who actually did the cool stuff (and just happen to work for companies he's invested in) instead.
1. People like to hate on things and people just because they're popular when there's literally no other reason; and
2. A large number of people will let their personal opinion drive their behaviour. Elon is a dick, no question. Because of that some people will just downvote or speak ill of SpaceX or Tesla. Worse, this dislike can be used to rationalize pretty antisocial behaviour (eg doxxing, swatting).
What SpaceX has done is nothing short of astounding whether you like him or not. I'm not sure of the exact number but I believe SpaceX has raised <$20B and brought launch costs from >$50k/kg (Space Shuttle) to $1-2k/kg to LEO. It seems highly likely that Starship will drive that below $1k/kg, possibly by a lot.
By comparison, a single SLS/Artemis launch is likely to cost more than that.
And if you think it's just a question of throwing money at the problem, just look at the abject failure that is Blue Origin (fun fact: Blue Origin was founded 3-4 years before SpaceX).
I would bet big that most people on here have a fairly balanced opinion of him that roughly would look like:
- Almost single handedly accelerated the electrification of cars by a couple of decades
- Together with many amazing engineers, scientists and more, led to huge reductions in launch costs and increased frequency of launches
- He acts carelessly online with respect to the law around securities
- He acts carelessly online when he wants to insult someone
- He doesn't really care much about light pollution that affects astronomers
- Overhypes many of his ideas and doesn't recognise any criticism of his failures
- Has an implausible idea that we can colonise Mars this century
I am both impressed by the man and have a few misgivings. Like any human being he is multifaceted.
But like anyone he does idiotic things at times but I suppose they are amplified by his strange life.
cost of a new JWST without a foldable mirror and a static sunshield: $2B
why not do both?
I wouldn't worry about the junks, they're fake internet points that mean nothing.
also the irony here is that the only the only client this company has now is itself to launch his telecom satellite swarm, which in turn will have a negative effect on ground observations, both in VIS and RF bands. astronomers heavily rely on ground based observations, because on the contrary to space telescope the can modify their instruments easily.
you can do a lot with other technologies, for instance diffractive lenses, chronographs as a separate spaceship, etc, etc... the best for a telescope is not always to have the biggest single piece mirror.
i know i know, i'll get heavily downvoted for the above, i just don't like that the said company test their stuff in a middle of a natural reservation.
I guess you must really hate NASA then.
> Visitors to Kennedy Space Center Visitor Complex are often surprised to discover that they are just as likely to be greeted by an alligator or dolphin. This is because Kennedy Space Center sits in the middle of the Merritt Island National Wildlife Refuge adjacent to Canaveral National Seashore, one of the largest and most diverse wildlife preserves in Florida. In fact, the refuge supports one of the highest numbers of threatened and endangered species anywhere in the nation.
https://www.kennedyspacecenter.com/blog/07/the-wild-side-of-...
Much of it was built before the EPA existed, so routine was routine. But, it is still being expanded, lately on behalf of SpaceX. Scheduling in lots of studies and meetings just amount to delaying, if they can't actually affect whether the paving happens. No amount of public hand-wringing gives a turtle back the nesting site its ancestors have returned to for a million years, or a hundred million.
If they've built on 5% of the land in 50 years, then we should have another 950 years of expansion, at that extrapolation.
You are aware there is a conservation programme running too?
If the supposed conservation programme doesn't actually block paving, then it is what they call a formality. Business-as-usual is routine.
The US space program was practically moribund for those 50 years. The paving was done quickly at the start. With space activity ramping up, paving will too, as we see starting already. What are you demanding as a definition of "routine" beyond paving where they like, when they like?
You say they are routinely abusing the area and all I'm getting from that is that they've paved over areas, 5% of the area. How is this routinely abusing the area?
Could you post an journal article explaining how this has routinely abused the area and put the ecosystem at risk?
Also, sure you can have more complex methods to get to the stage where it's analogous to a single large mirror, but that's why it took 25 years to make JWST (amongst policical reasons too, but still).
If constellations are so bad to astronomy, why do ESA want one?
Finally, I think you'll find KSC in Florida is slap bang in the middle of a huge nature reserve, as it has been for the past 50+ years
I don't think they realistically stand a chance to outcompete SpaceX within the next ten years on any dimension, after all, SpaceX is a fast moving target itself. But that's just my opinion, so we'll have to wait to see how it plays out.
It would be great to have a real competitor to SpaceX, that can't come soon enough, I do give them better chances than Bezos and his toy factory.
Please, just watch the interview. It might change your opinion by listening to the plan, I know I felt much more optimistic about more serious players in the field.
I'm not aware of any reusable vehicles by ULA and all the current flights are fully booked, they're sold out of their current block. There were only a handful of launches last year, I think Electron actually flew more. For the new, they're waiting for engines from Blue Origin but they'll probably end up using RS as it doesn't look like BO will deliver.
The Russians (and Chinese) are basically copying anything SpaceX in terms of reusable heavy lift, which might be a good plan in the long-term but it's not that innovative.
I think long term if Ariane Space and ULA don't adapt that they'll die unless they keep being subsidized. But if SpaceX manages to reduce cost even further then that will make no sense, it is already very hard to justify.
I read Musk's statements regarding this towards his workforce as a pure power play to put pressure on them working even harder on ongoing issues like you mentioned.
That being said - if you can produce n amount of engines per time frame, I am positive that they manage to achieve n*x amount of engines per the same time frame as well.
Wasn't that a bit of over-inflation from dodgily-backed NIMBYs, especially in a state where petrochemical industries have abused a lot more natural environments?
A telescope that can see back to the beginning of the universe is never obsolete to astronomers. The Hubble is 'obsolete', but there are plenty of astronomers that would step over their own mothers to get time on it.
> but there are plenty of astronomers that would step over their own mothers to get time on it.
May I suggest "there are plenty of astronomers who would cut their left hands to get time on it". Similarly florid, but does not propagate the meme "people will often be evil for the right price" -- that meme is self reinforcing, the more we believe in it, the more true it becomes, and the worst the world becomes as a result
I believe the world becomes even worse when people are unable to speak candidly, frankly, and in their own way. Being able to extract and recognize the meaning behind someone's words, in spite of any perceived flaw in word choice or phrasing, is one of the hallmarks of a mature and intelligent individual.
This belief that controlling how people speak will somehow make the world a better place seems somewhat quixotic.
100% agree. The way we talk, I think, matters. The stories we tell ourselves help shape us. But so does it matter how we try to change it.
Forcing/controlling the way people speak is a remedy worse than the malady 97% of the time, and certainly in the present case.
(Also, it is reasonable that you would interpret my suggestion as an attempt to control, given some elements of the current political climate)
Another example of a poorly told story that worries me: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-...
My point it is, we have so few space telescopes that even having time on an "outdated" one is still pretty valuable.
EDIT: Maybe a better example, it's not much use for a first-world person to use a ten year old smartphone, since current smartphones are much more capable and they're comparatively cheap. Planes, on the other hand, are used for decades, since simply buying a new one is very expensive. This is despite it's tech being far superior.
It's the massive capital expenditure on the telescope and its infrastructure that is the significant limiting factor on the pace of putting newer and better telescopes in place.
Same thing in this case: instead of visiting Webb, they could build a new Webb without all the origami, and assemble it by hand in orbit for a tiny fraction of the cost, and end up with two of them. Then, maybe put different instruments on the second one.
best case you have two working mid-IR telescopes in space instead of one. i don't hear any astronomers complaining about that scenario!
But I also just wanted to point out as people discuss re-fueling that some of the concepts for this are not just open up the fuel tank and add more fuel but it might be operationally simpler to make a satellite that attaches like a jetpack [0]
There's still cause for optimism, NASA hardware has a reputation for outlasting its designed lifetime by quite a bit.
electronics on the voyager still work, 45 years after launch.
it is possible that things will break. it is also possible that they won't. we'll see in 20 years, but having an option on the table in case they do work is simply prudent engineering.
I don't think they can know for sure, however the bearings have been designed with this in mind using ceramics. Also I just realised with the JSWT going around the L2 point it won't be cutting through the Earth's magnetic field, mind you it will be exposed to the direct solar wind.
Lots of talk about refueling even with the 20 year lifespan, from what I've gathered having watched a lot of the NASA conferences and livestreams this past year, with this amount of operational fuel capacity the problem in 20 years will be on operational lifetime of wear components, not just the fuel.
The reaction wheels are _large_ moving parts on the JWST. The cryocooler for the MIRI is a very finely calibrated moving part. It's a closed system, but still relies on pumps and electronics. After 2 decades of operation it's very likely that these will be experiencing some issues.
While in 2 decades it might be feasible to refuel the JWST, it seems very unlikely it'd be worth it given the operational wear of every other component. Had we used too much fuel to correct the course to get where we are the math may have been very different. Seems to me that we're fortunate that we can instead dedicate resources to the next-gen observatories!