News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @06:37AM (#29564581)
I don't care. I already switched my business to Linux Boxes. The last Mac OS in use is Catalina. All of my critical software runs under Linux. Figma is in the browser. Affinity Designer is running perfectly under Isolated Windows VM. If I ever use Apple computer again it will be with Linux. After 20+ years of using Apple computers I don't find them interesting enough to risk my data and be scanned, categorized and processed by third party criteria. Think different. Use Linux.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by aunty_helen on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:20PM (#29572339)
Hey I just want to let you know that you're not alone and there are other sane people out there that aren't just grumbling but keeping on with the boiling frog.

Even though the new mbps look really nice, I've got a Framework laptop sitting at home that I'm in the process of migrating to (that's $4k of MBP max that apple have missed out on).

And early next year, I'm moving off the iphone platform onto probably a pixel and switching the OS to something like Graphine. It's going to be fun and experimental.

I'm also looking to hire some developers next year, provided laptops will be Linux too.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Thursday December 16, 2021 @01:57AM (#29575764)
My business operation is small. I wisely postponed buying new computers for the office. I admit that M1 chips were the primary target. Apple lost from my business north of 80k euros, now redirected towards Lenovo ThinkPad X1's and custom build PC's.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by theplumber on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @06:55AM (#29564734)
What about the mobile OS?
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by bigyellow on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:58AM (#29567761)
Not OP, but check out LineageOS without Play Services.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Silhouette on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:22AM (#29567118)
Affinity Designer is running perfectly under Isolated Windows VM.

Share more details about how you set that up please? Good graphics software, or the relative lack of it, is one of the few things still holding us back from shifting several daily use machines to Linux. Affinity would be OK for that but the only reports we found suggested it wasn't happy running virtually and performance was poor.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:53PM (#29570777)
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:02AM (#29566832)
Did you switch because of the proposed CSAM detector?
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Syonyk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:11AM (#29566980)
I can't speak to the person you're asking, but I very much have eliminated Apple products from my daily use as a result of CSAM - though it was on top of a range of other things (mostly China related) that told me I can no longer really trust Apple.

I've scrapped out a perfectly good (and exceedingly nice to use) M1 Mini, I no longer use a 2015 MBP, I've shut down my iPhone (not quite for good, I still have to figure out how to move my Signal root of identity off it), and I no longer use an iPad for work reference PDFs.

I've replaced these with far less functional "But I'm making them work" sort of devices. An AT&T Flip IV for phone stuff (KaiOS, handles basic calls and texts, and not much else, though it does have GPS and maps, and can do email if you let it), a Kobo Elipsa + KOReader for PDF support, and I've spent a good bit of time tweaking a PineBook Pro into my daily driver laptop.

The general view I have of Apple at this point is, "Oh, we know what kind of company you are, now we're just haggling over details."[0]

To whine about Apple doing stuff and continue to use them says, "Yes, it's important enough to complain about online, but not important enough to alter how I use their products - therefore, not really important at all."

[0]: https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/03/07/haggling/

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by hef19898 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:31AM (#29567252)
It's funny, the Apple CSAM issue got me to de-google and de-MS as much as possible. I didn't use Apple, but I figured the others won't be any better. That worked very well in private life, professionally it is Windows and will be for the foreseeable future. That leaves Windows machines for the kids to run MS Office and Teams for school.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:04AM (#29567864)
> I've scrapped out a perfectly good (and exceedingly nice to use) M1 Mini

Given that the CSAM issue turns out to be moot, I assume you feel regret at doing this.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Syonyk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:46AM (#29568367)
Not really. It's forced me to evaluate what I actually need (not much) vs what I'd prefer (fancy, nice, expensive systems because... well, why, of course I need them!).

I'd love an ODroid N2+ with 8GB RAM, though. Twice the CPU performance of a Pi4 but it's pretty RAM choked with only 4GB.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:03PM (#29568635)
I see, so you felt regret for buying a computer you didn’t need and claimed it was because of CSAM but that was actually a lie.

Now you are promoting the ODroid N2+ which is completely irrelevant to this thread.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Syonyk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:28PM (#29568971)
I've had Mac desktops in my office for about 20 years at this point, to include a mirror door G4, a G5, a sunflower iMac, a 27" iMac, a 2018 Mac Mini (what an absolute turd for anything more complex than a static desktop, the GPU was horrid), and the M1 Mini. At no point did I really evaluate that my needs over time have changed, I just always had a Mac desktop, and, through most of that time, a Mac laptop. It was my default computing base, plus a range of Linux boxes.

The CSAM thing was the final straw for me with Apple, and as it turns out, my needs have rather significantly decreased over time, as the lower power hardware has increased in capability, though... sadly not as much RAM as I'd find useful.

It turns out that I don't actually need Apple hardware to do that which I now care to do with computers. And one of those replacements was a N2+, which, while a bit sharp around some edges, is actually a tolerably usable little Linux desktop.

You can call it what you want, I'm just describing what I've done in response to the changes in how Apple has chosen to treat their users.

The nature of the computing ecosystems have changed around me, such that I chose to make changes. I don't particularly regret the decision any more than I would selling a vehicle that no longer suits my needs when I move.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:42PM (#29569134)
> The CSAM thing was the final straw for me with Apple.

A final straw which never actually happened. They in fact listened to users saying how unpopular this would be, and changed course.

> I'm just describing what I've done in response to the changes in how Apple has chosen to treat their users.

No, you are describing what you’ve done in response to a demonstrably false belief about how Apple has chosen to treat their users.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by smoldesu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:54PM (#29569282)
> “Update: Apple spokesperson Shane Bauer told The Verge that though the CSAM detection feature is no longer mentioned on its website, plans for CSAM detection have not changed since September, which means CSAM detection is still coming in the future.”

It's still coming.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:50PM (#29570077)
Is it? What makes you think that?

Edit:

Please don’t retroactively edit your comment to make the comment that follows it look misplaced.

It is a dishonest tactic that makes you look like a bad faith commenter. Who can trust that anything you have written hasn’t been altered after the fact?

There is no reason you couldn’t have included that quote as a reply to my question instead of silently editing it in to make it look as if it has always been there.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by smoldesu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:35PM (#29570585)
I'm not sure why you're flying off the handle when I'm quite obviously not the poster above. I have no intentions of re-formatting my comments here, just informing you of the status quo right now.

> Is it? What makes you think that?

The Verge reached out to Apple[0] and Apple confirmed that their CSAM scanning feature is still coming.

> When reached for comment, Apple spokesperson Shane Bauer said that the company’s position hasn’t changed since September, when it first announced it would be delaying the launch of the CSAM detection. “Based on feedback from customers, advocacy groups, researchers, and others, we have decided to take additional time over the coming months to collect input and make improvements before releasing these critically important child safety features,” the company’s September statement read.

So yes, they still fully intend to push the update. You should probably take this less personally too, your arguments are only suffering by attacking people who are just trying to chip in their two cents.

[0] https://www.theverge.com/2021/12/15/22837631/apple-csam-dete...

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:54PM (#29570792)
> I'm quite obviously not the poster above.

You are in fact the one who dishonestly edited your comment. That’s what I was pointing out, and it was you and not the commenter before that I was replying to. We can see your name.

Trying to pretend otherwise is either delusion, or more dishonesty.

I agree that the update provided by the verge suggests that apple has not abandoned this plan yet.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by smoldesu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:16PM (#29571067)
What are you even talking about? Can you provide me a link to the specific comment that I had modified here? I'm genuinely lost.

In any case, that's not a refutation or response to the link I sent.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:03PM (#29572171)
Here is the comment you edited after I asked the question in the comment that follows it. When you first posted it you didn’t provide a quote.

> https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29569282

I don’t need to refute your response. In fact after seeing the update I agree that CSAM is not yet defeated.

That doesn’t change the fact that your commenting tactics are dishonest. That is the problem here. You cannot be trusted not to edit upthread comments.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by smoldesu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:13PM (#29572260)
At no point did I ever edit that comment. It's contents were, since the time of posting, a quote and simply "It's still coming."

I legitimately have no idea what you're talking about. This is either an extremely confusing attempt to gaslight me or you're mistaking me for someone else. In any case, I don't really know what else to add here. Do you remember what was supposedly the original contents of this comment? We're really getting nowhere here pointing fingers.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @11:55AM (#29639269)
This isn’t true.

You posted “it’s still coming”, and only added the quote later after my reply.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by baby-yoda on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:38PM (#29571327)
[dead]
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by hu3 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:36AM (#29565121)
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by coldtea on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:07PM (#29570272)
How is not the parent comment a shallow reaction to the post, which was my point? It was the usual empty response that gets the top comment post and sets the tone for the thread.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:06PM (#29570949)
I beg you pardon, my responses can be categorized as provocative sometimes, but they are never empty. I always state clearly my point and give factual data.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by arbitrage on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:21AM (#29565518)
Be kind. Don't be snarky.

Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive.

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names.

Eschew flamebait.

Please don't complain about tangential annoyances.

Please don't post shallow dismissals.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#comments

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by DonHopkins on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:49AM (#29565860)
Beautiful is better than ugly.

Explicit is better than implicit.

Simple is better than complex.

Complex is better than complicated.

Flat is better than nested.

Sparse is better than dense.

Readability counts.

Special cases aren't special enough to break the rules.

Although practicality beats purity.

Errors should never pass silently.

Unless explicitly silenced.

In the face of ambiguity, refuse the temptation to guess.

There should be one-- and preferably only one --obvious way to do it.

Although that way may not be obvious at first unless you're Dutch.

Now is better than never.

Although never is often better than right now.

If the implementation is hard to explain, it's a bad idea.

If the implementation is easy to explain, it may be a good idea.

Namespaces are one honking great idea -- let's do more of those!

https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0020/

Take heart in the bedeepening gloom

That your dog is finally getting enough cheese.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ey6ugTmCYMk

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by kf6nux on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:38AM (#29568262)
> I don't care. I [switched to Linux]

That's short-sighted and self-centered.

You don't care about whether or not other people's rights are violated?

You don't see how normalizing rights violations could lead to downstream effects on you?

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by matheusmoreira on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:39PM (#29570631)
We do care. However, what can we do about it? Can we somehow make the billion dollar corporation do what we want? Unlikely. Better to use systems that we actually control so that we don't have to suffer their tyranny.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:33PM (#29570562)
Please, don't insult me and judge me so quickly. Read all my responses. You can check my posts back in time (If you wish).

The whole reason for my HN post activity (reading in the shadows from 2008-10) is CSAM. In the beginning of this issue nobody cared and tons of Apple fanboys down-voted every possible negative reaction.

Apple is industry leader. Everyone will copy what they create. You can read "I don't care" as an emotional reaction of an individual who had invested tons of money in Apple, used Apple products and evangelized thousands of friends and customers. Only to realize that The Beauty is actually The Beast.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zarzavat on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:01PM (#29568596)
The truth is that nobody has a right to use Apple products. It's good that Apple listens to criticism but if they had decided to steamroller this through, they would have been within their rights to do so.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by donohoe on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @06:55AM (#29564732)
And your phone is what?

If it’s an Android it’s probable got something similar in place.

On an iPhone all you must to use disable iCloud sync to avoid CSAM

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by bubblethink on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:35AM (#29565114)
This is such a silly strawman. First, it is not related to the parent's point at all. Second, it is perfectly possible to run AOSP based OSes not tied to google.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by donohoe on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:45AM (#29565796)
I disagree.

>> First, it is not related to the parent's point at all

The post was about switching away computers. My (badly implied) point was, a lot of the effort is wasted unless if you still use an Apple iPhone...

If you skip using an iPhone, then fine, but the other options out there are likely worse.

>> Second, it is perfectly possible to run AOSP based OSes not tied to google

You can build your own Google-free etc version but again most people won't because of the effort and the need to redo for updates again and again. The Parent post author probably has the means to do it, but it's another endless task they have to stay on. All other options (to my limited knowledge - plz share if you know more) mean compromises in apps, and functionality - unless you're happy to spend hours each wee/month troubleshooting and setting up workaround and working with specific compatible hardware.

It can be done. But how much of your life will you want to spend on that? Reading other comments maybe it is a solved problem now - it hadn't been last time I tried.

If I assumed too much from the parent post then sorry.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by bubblethink on Thursday December 16, 2021 @07:26AM (#29577478)
I agree that most of this requires conscious effort. I think I was needlessly harsh too. My point was that if someone is making the conscious effort of changing their devices/OSes etc., then they have shown the interest and ability, and at least for them, there are reasonable options (i.e., not just theoretical ones).
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by bigyellow on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:59AM (#29567787)
LineageOS has near-nightly binary releases, you don't need to build or "redo" anything to keep up to date, other than a 5-10 minute update over adb about once a week.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:03AM (#29564799)
Basic phone and iPhone SE (the old version) for banking apps. Never used iCloud. All my backups are done locally. It is not only about CSAM.

CSAM was the last straw. Before this was that: echo 127.0.0.1 ocsp.apple.com | sudo tee -a /etc/hosts

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by threeseed on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:05AM (#29564817)
In your situation then CSAM scanning would never have been an issue.

It only applies when you have iCloud Photo Library enabled.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:10AM (#29564866)
It is not about the implementation either. It is about hostile attack towards user privacy after years of advertising: What Happens on your iPhone, stays on your iPhone. Privacy is King. Privacy. That's iPhone.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:14AM (#29565450)
>So we lost yet another feature which would have increased the privacy.

With all the respect, there is one small detail: The search criteria is provided by third party organisation (funded by DOD), without option of public oversight due to nature of "sensitive" data set. This data set would be defined by similar "organisations" per country bases.

In my humble opinion this "privacy related solution" is Stasi wet-dream on steroids.

Some governments liked it so much, that they wanted it to be extended.. https://9to5mac.com/2021/09/09/csam-scan-encrypted-messages/

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Retric on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:46AM (#29565820)
CSAM didn’t allow that, they only included hashes provided by multiple governments.

The backlash was obvious from the outside, but it’s clear someone spent a lot of time building something they felt was reasonable. Even if Apple presumably just implemented the same system in iCloud, at least people became aware governments have access to such systems.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by w1nk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:59AM (#29566787)
I'm not sure I can agree that it's clear someone spent a lot of time building something they felt was reasonable.

The entire technical underpinnings of this solution rely on essentially neural image embeddings, which are very well known to be susceptible to all sorts of clever attacks. Notice how within a day or two of the announcement of this whole system and it's symbols, people were already finding lots of 'hash' collisions.

In the space of people and places that can train and implement/serve such embeddings, these issues are pretty widely known, which makes it very non-obvious how this happened IMO. Someone that understood all of these issues seems to have directly ignored them.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Retric on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:02PM (#29572163)
The government image hashes are supposed to be secret information, any crypto system is vulnerable if you assume the secrets are suddenly public information. I am sure plenty of crypto currency people would object to saying the system is insecure because anyone can post a transaction with your private key.

More importantly hash collisions result in manual review by humans at Apple, hardly a major issue. This is also a safety measure protecting users from political images being tagged in these database.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by lttlrck on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:27AM (#29566358)
Reasonable and logical: it's a similar idea to a locally hosted virus scanner scanning all your documents...
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nicce on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:00AM (#29565330)
The most people have misunderstood how this system actually worked. I read every paper carefully, and this was very innovative system to protect your privacy IF we compare to existing CSAM solutions. Of course the best option is to not scan at all, but that is not really option.

Only those pictures which were about to be uploaded iCloud, would have been scanned, and Apple would get information about image contents only if it is flagged. The phone is blackbox and it scans your files anyway all the time, sending metadata to Apple e.g. because of the spotlight feature and photo albums, or simply syncing your data to cloud. There is massive AI behind that spotlight feature. Nothing would have changed, just the different kind of information would have been flagged, but this time encrypted.

The major improvement was E2EE like system for Photos. Currently they are not E2E encrypted in Cloud. They are plaintext for Apple. iOS 15 beta had also encryption for backups, but it never reached public reach after CSAM was delayed. So we lost yet another feature which would have increased the privacy. "But it happens in my device", is not really valid argument since most people don't understand what happens in their devices in the first hand. Even AV engines sends all your data to cloud, and you can't opt out in most of the cases and it is for every file.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Copernicron on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:10PM (#29574723)
> I read every paper carefully, and this was very innovative system to protect your privacy IF we compare to existing CSAM solutions

I did the same and I agree with you with one small caveat. For someone like me, who does not use iCloud or any other cloud service, on device scanning seriously compromises my privacy. I want to be clear that I am not doing anything that is currently illegal in my home country, but that could change under a more oppressive government. I know my opinions would definitely get me in trouble in some countries if I happened to live there.

> Of course the best option is to not scan at all, but that is not really option.

Why isn't it an option? I know of no legal requirement anywhere that mandates Apple has to scan fro CSAM.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nicce on Thursday December 16, 2021 @07:28AM (#29577484)
> I did the same and I agree with you with one small caveat. For someone like me, who does not use iCloud or any other cloud service, on device scanning seriously compromises my privacy. I want to be clear that I am not doing anything that is currently illegal in my home country, but that could change under a more oppressive government. I know my opinions would definitely get me in trouble in some countries if I happened to live there.

At least in the current solution scanning was integrated part of the iCloud sync pipeline, and therefore this would not have affected you.

> Why isn't it an option? I know of no legal requirement anywhere that mandates Apple has to scan fro CSAM.

Apple is too big and they try to foresee politicians behavior. With "good will" solutions they can adjust the way how they scan or implement this. With regulation it would be more specific and might even restrict encryption in some cases totally. This is quite difficult topic at Apple's scale and I don't know if anybody really knows what exactly is already required and why

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by tjpnz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:29AM (#29566373)
An innovative solution to the wrong problem.

What exactly does one achieve in nailing the local pedo for old content? If he's stupid enough to be uploading it to iCloud he's stupid enough to get himself busted in all manner of other ways. The real problem is of course criminals who are currently engaged in the production of CSAM. Which Apple's scheme does nothing to address.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nicce on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:04AM (#29567866)
It is essential to stop sharing those files no matter what. It might not help on getting them caugh, but those who buy these pictures or find elsewhere, might try to share them as well. They might not be tech guys, so they might try to use some familiar service. And yes, there are many people like that. iCloud would be flooded if no action is taken against sharing.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by hulitu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:53AM (#29565911)
So you are saying that Apple has access to all your data ( = no privacy ) but this "app" will improve your privacy by scanning all your files.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nicce on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:58AM (#29567773)
It is not scanning all of your files, only those which will be send to iCloud. Scanning for part of pipeline in sync process, so it even can’t scan other files.

But yes, currently Apple can access all your images on the cloud, but with this change they would have been E2E encrypted, hence improving privacy.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Copernicron on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:11PM (#29574728)
> But yes, currently Apple can access all your images on the cloud, but with this change they would have been E2E encrypted, hence improving privacy.

Apple said nothing at all this would be the case. It's pure speculation from people on the internet.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nicce on Thursday December 16, 2021 @09:49PM (#29587089)
It was all over the spec, whole protocol was about encryption and ”Apple can’t access your images”. Otherwise whole flagging thing was pointless.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by ibigb on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:20AM (#29565512)
All cloud platform scan for CSAM. Apple was going to move the scanning task off their servers, where it is now, onto apple devices only as the devices upload to apple's cloud. If you use cloud services, info does not stay on your phone, does it?
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:39AM (#29565709)
After years of using Little Snitch to defend myself from Apple telemetry, it is not an option for me to "trust" any form of closed source software.

I can ditch my iPhone at any time, but Apple wanted CSAM to be part of Mac OS and this is unacceptable.

Anyway, I am glad that they tried. This was a wake up call with positive financial and technological outcome for me and my business.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nicce on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:54AM (#29567694)
> I can ditch my iPhone at any time, but Apple wanted CSAM to be part of Mac OS and this is unacceptable.

It is already on MacOS. It sends hashes from every unknown file on ”virus protection purposes”. Only name and hash database is different. How that changes your privacy?

And to be fair, they never said publicly that it would come to Mac OS.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nbzso on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:59PM (#29570847)
>These features are coming later this year in updates to iOS 15, iPadOS 15, watchOS 8, and macOS Monterey.*

http://web.archive.org/web/20210807010615/https://www.apple....

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by zepto on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:03AM (#29566856)
Except that you were just wrong and there was no attack. When people complained that this was over the line, Apple didn’t do it.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by mensetmanusman on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:38AM (#29565702)
No, the specific controversy was about on-device hash scanning which used child porn as cover, when in fact it is exactly the feature that China et al. wants in order to make sure people aren’t sharing any political memes etc.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by virtue3 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:24AM (#29565012)
for now? You can't really guarantee anything with companies when they start rolling things out like this.

The fact that they went so hard for the feature without really considering how people felt about the invasion is important.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by jeromegv on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:48AM (#29565847)
Without considering how people felt? They cancelled it! The whole process was about getting feedback on it.

We’re you consulted on how google implemented it server side with google photos? You likely didn’t know!

Only one company chose transparency here.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by pseudalopex on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:56AM (#29568513)
An Apple VP implied anyone who opposed it didn't understand it. And endorsed an NCMEC director calling them screeching voices of the minority.[1]

[1] https://9to5mac.com/2021/08/06/apple-internal-memo-icloud-ph...

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Copernicron on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:15PM (#29574761)
> They cancelled it!

No they didn't [0]

> When reached for comment, Apple spokesperson Shane Bauer said that the company’s position hasn’t changed since September

> Crucially, Apple’s statement does not say the feature has been canceled entirely.

[0] https://www.theverge.com/2021/12/15/22837631/apple-csam-dete...

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by boppo1 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:30AM (#29566387)
> They cancelled it!

I doubt it. It will be quietly implemented. If a techie digs in far enough with RE to prove it, general society will treat them like they wear a tinfoil hat.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by jaywalk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:13AM (#29566173)
> The whole process was about getting feedback on it.

What a load of BS. Apple told us it was going to happen, and then quietly canned it when there was backlash. There was no intention of "consultation" or "getting feedback" at all.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by threeseed on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:51AM (#29565263)
Why would they bother ? The PR from actually trying to help users has been negative.

So instead they will just continue to scan your photos server-side.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nicce on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @08:14AM (#29565443)
> So instead they will just continue to scan your photos server-side.

Yep, and because of that we are not getting E2E services (Photos, backup), which would have been possible with this new technology.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by jaywalk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:14AM (#29566182)
E2EE services are absolutely possible without this technology. What are you saying?
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by nicce on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:48AM (#29567575)
They are possible, but they will not be implemented on Apple’s scale without CSAM features. Politics already try to implement forced backdoors.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by Copernicron on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:58PM (#29574627)
> It only applies when you have iCloud Photo Library enabled.

For now. There are no technical limitations to Apple's proposed solution that preclude it from being always on. It's a policy decision only, and you can be sure there would be immediate pressure to force it to scan full time.

Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by SXX on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @06:59AM (#29564767)
Android have plenty of open source distributions without such features. They don't save you from baseband backdoor, but at least OS itself isn't your enemy.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by fsflover on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:23AM (#29564986)
How about GNU/Linux phones, Librem 5 and Pinephone? Not well polished yet but running desktop OS with all its possibilities.
Re:Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety w... by mattl on Saturday December 18, 2021 @12:48PM (#29606606)
Those phones are in no way usable as day to day phones.