News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by lbj on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:17PM (#29421874)
"open everything up despite it being relatively clear it was way too early"

It probably wasn't. There have been 2 major studies on the effects of covid-lockdown measures, they show a small increase in total mortality. So we should have done as the Swedes and kept everything open from beginning to end.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by GVIrish on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:52PM (#29422368)
Sweden did worse than the other Scandinavian countries that enacted stricter Covid restrictions, including lockdowns. Sweden had roughly 5-7x as many deaths per capita as its immediate neighbors of Norway and Finland. Germany had less deaths per capita as well:

https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by tomp on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:00PM (#29424786)
This is often repeated fake news.

Take a look at this graph - cumulative deaths since, I don't know, start of 2021 or something.

https://ourworldindata.org/explorers/coronavirus-data-explor...

Sweden is just barely worse than other Scandinavian countries (definitely not 5-7x). Germany is 50-100% worse than Sweden.

So while you might use "total deaths" as an argument that the Swedish "no lockdowns" strategy was worse at the beginning of the pandemic, it's clearly superior now.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by thisiszilff on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:27PM (#29425045)
The linked graph shows Sweden at 7x norway's rate, 5x finland's rate and 3x denmarks rate. Am I reading that right? How are you concluding that Sweden's strategy was clearly superior?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by MagnumOpus on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:29AM (#29429771)
To paraphrase you: it was great to have all those vulnerable people in care homes die immediately from Covid in 2020 since it avoids a few of them dying in 2021.

You realise how nonsensical (and callous) that sounds?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:17PM (#29422722)
A lot of that can be attributed to a relatively huge early spike in deaths at nursing homes.

Rightly, Sweden decided it was a bad idea to do go about business as usual at nursing homes. After this, their relative difference to other Scandinavian countries is much smaller.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:24PM (#29422825)
And are those spikes in deaths at nursing homes not normal? Is that not how things always and usually work? Do people at nursing homes not die mostly in the winter and flu season, since forever? What are the statistics of excess mortality, is it higher than usual or not. Old people die. I read headlines in the papers "10 people have died since moving into a nursing home" That's what nursing homes are for. Everyone who moves into a nursing home dies...
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:47PM (#29423142)
The average death rate for people in nursing homes for an entire year wasn't even as high as the death rate was for just a few week period: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-sweden...

Almost ~3200 people died in nursing homes in a couple of months at the beginning of the pandemic. There's ~95k people in nursing homes. That's 3.3%...

These deaths still account for ~1/5th of all Sweden's covid deaths.

Hence, when people say 5x as many people died in Sweden - a full 1x of that is from the early nursing home no-strategy.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:06PM (#29423407)
Doesn't say anything, death rates are not constant, it always varies a lot ever year by year. Did 2020 have excessive mortality per capita compared to other years or not? No it didn't. It doesn't matter if you find some anecdote.

Everyone knows death rate was high in peak covid. As it always is in peak flu season, so what, the year was well within standard deviation

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Swenrekcah on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:14PM (#29423499)
This is false, you have been misinformed. See here, and compare for instance Sweden with their neighbours Norway and Finland.

https://www.euronews.com/2021/02/17/eu-excess-deaths-in-2020...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:36PM (#29423772)
It doesn't make any sense to compare it to neighboring countries, you need to compare the same country to previous years. That's the real interesting statistic, and the one that nobody is showing you. Because it's not dramatic enough..
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Swenrekcah on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:38PM (#29423802)
The graph is exactly that. Each country’s excess mortality compared to that countries previous years.

The comparison with neighbours is to gleam the effects of their differing mitigation strategies.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:26PM (#29424419)
I looked at it again, it's only comparing to the average, without knowing the standard deviation it doesn't really say much. "2020 was above average" yeah we know that, but was it higher than a "usual" year? No it wasn't, and you can't draw that conclusion by comparing it to the average.

Also it looks like they are doing the comparison month by month which doesn't make much sense since this will vary a lot of course...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Swenrekcah on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:58PM (#29424767)
This data is compiled by professional statisticians.

Deaths aren't evenly distributed throughout the year. High-traffic seasons will cause a spike, very cold or hot weather, etc. So month-by-month comparison is reasonable. Doing that also shows in the graphs when the waves hit various countries.

I agree, it's missing the standard deviation though. (But again, look at the graphs, you'll see a difference of 10, perhaps 20% fluctuating around zero, and then suddenly a wave of 60,80,100% more deaths. It's unlikely a coincidence.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:59AM (#29428030)
month-by-month doesn't make sense because the flu doesn't happen at the same month each year, and yes without at least also the standard deviation, it doesn't say anything.

Just seeing that the temperature is below average outside doesn't say anything about the question: do we have abnormal weather? Is there a crisis? And even if this years winter is colder than the last three years, still doesn't mean that it's abnormal.

It needs to be a statistical outlier to be abnormal, it needs to be statistically significant. Why are they not showing previous years? Why are sample sizes deliberately small when we have more data? Why don't we see basic required numbers such as standard deviation, median, percentiles? It's all clickbait bullshit

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Swenrekcah on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:55AM (#29428327)
This is all public data. If you think there’s some big conspiracy you can look it up yourself, calculate how the data show COVID is no big deal and then share the results.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @06:38AM (#29428887)
Yeah I already looked at the public data and did the calculations, and I am sharing the results as I've said in other comments, and I challenge anyone to disprove me with another opinion that holds up to normal basic statistical scrutiny, and not some misleading clickbait bullshit
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Swenrekcah on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:43AM (#29429356)
I looked through your comments but can't find the link to your calculations. Would you mind sharing it again here?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:21AM (#29429683)
Here's the source data I used (only Sweden): https://www.scb.se/en/finding-statistics/statistics-by-subje...

You don't even need to make any calculations really, just take a quick look at the table to see that the death rate was unusually low 2019 and only slightly high in 2020 (Edit: sorry, almost compensated by 2019's low numbers, not completely). And if you go back in time, you can see that in fact every single year between 1999-2012 had a higher mortality rate than 2020.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Swenrekcah on Friday December 03, 2021 @02:30PM (#29434177)
Thanks for the link!

Yes, I see that. I calculated the mortality rate for all years, then the average and standard deviation for the last 10 years preceding 2020.

The average is 0.92%, standard deviation is 0.03%. The mortality rate in 2020 was 0.95% or exactly one standard deviation above the average for the last 10 years.

There is also another clear trend from the data which is slowly but steadily declining mortality rates. Obviously since 1749, but this trend is especially noteworthy during this century (since 2000). Then only one year has increased mortality (by more than one least significant digit) which is 2020.

2020 saw 10% higher mortality than 2019.

So to conclude: I'm by no means a statistician but I'd say this is probably not a random fluke.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by crooked-v on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:15PM (#29423509)
> Did 2020 have excessive mortality per capita compared to other years or not? No it didn't.

Yes, it did. The statistics are pretty obvious: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:36PM (#29423783)
I'm saying compared to other years. That link does not compare to other years, it only compared 2020 to itself.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by crooked-v on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:56PM (#29424014)
> Counts of deaths in the most recent weeks were compared with historical trends (from 2013 to present) to determine whether the number of deaths in recent weeks was significantly higher than expected, using Farrington surveillance algorithms (1).
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:29PM (#29424457)
I just want to know year by year death rate per capita, and average, and standard deviation. That's the only way I can draw the conclusion "is there anything abnormal going on"
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by daddylongstroke on Thursday December 02, 2021 @11:12PM (#29426542)
All cause mortality in Sweden is flat and significantly lower than the last 20 years or so.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mythrwy on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:00PM (#29422479)
I'll be curious to know what these numbers are in 5 years.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by tomohawk on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:16PM (#29422708)
What is this obsession with limiting comparison of Sweden with "other scandanavian countries"? Is there some sort of special risk factor that only applies to scandanavia? Does COVID know what people look like? Why not compare stats of major metro areas with other similar metro areas in the world?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:27PM (#29422878)
Yeah and avoiding looking at the statistics for mortality to see if it's actually higher than usual, which it isn't. I looked at the statistics of mortality for sweden, 2020 was high but well within standard deviation, and there were several more deadly years in recent history, 2008 and much more deadly years in the 1990s, without this ever even making headlines.

What stood out the most in the statistics, actually, was that 2019 had an unusually low death rates, if you add up 2020 and 2019 they basically even out to an average death rate.

I bet mortality has been abnormally low during 2021 so now we have a bunch of dry tinder again which will cause another "crisis" and lockdown as soon as weather is cold and viruses making the rounds again. Never ending cycle of panicking when old people die.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by mijamo on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:19PM (#29422755)
Because the density of the metro areas are similar. Stockholm is not comparable to Paris or London when it comes to density for instance.

Culture is also very similar between Scandinavian countries and much different from western Europe, with people much more isolated (which is tough to adjust to for immigrants there actually).

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by vcdimension on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:27PM (#29423667)
Sweden has much higher ethnic & cultural diversity than Norway & Finland, and hence more people passing through it's borders potentially bringing in new infections from abroad. It also has fewer hospital beds per population, and higher population density. All these factors and more need to be taken into account when doing country comparisons. We won't really know how much effect the difference in policies had until someone has done a proper causal analysis using some regression model or other econometric technique.

I got the stats from here: https://www.indexmundi.com/factbook/compare/norway.sweden/de...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by pigeonhole123 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:49PM (#29423182)
People work in offices and go to shops in Scandinavia too. Maybe compare to the dozens of US states with lower population density than Sweden?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by notahacker on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:22PM (#29422787)
Because they have similar risk factors, which are much, much lower than the other countries people are noting Sweden appeared to have fared better than. The UK, which imported a lot more cases, has more crowded commuter trains and bars and probably a less sensible population tried the Swedish strategy for a few weeks, but gave up because the deaths were mounting.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:10PM (#29423462)
It's always cherry picking to deliberately misinterpret statistics to make the most dramatic headline, it has been during the whole pandemic. Nobody is even trying to make accurate and relevant conclusions with the numbers, quite the opposite it's like a sport now who can lie the most with statistics.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:21PM (#29422774)
For the same reason that their vaccination rates and wealth and gini coefficients and all types of other metrics closely resemble each other more than some random country like Ethiopia or Peru.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by pigeonhole123 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:48PM (#29423159)
We’re talking about Germany and France. Right across the water. Sweden had lower deaths in earlier years than their neighboring countries and this was a reversion to the mean. Speaking as a Norwegian people in this country like to look smart but they’re not getting the last laugh this time.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:22PM (#29422793)
And what is expected deaths per capita? That relative measure is irrelevant unless you compare it to some kind of normal death rate in the past. Are you expecting deaths per capita to drastically drop and be kept much lower from 2020 and forward, compared to the past?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by zibzab on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:22PM (#29421944)
Sweden did not keep _everything_ open.

We found a sweet spot between "business as usual" and "everybody stays at home". For example, big gatherings and sport events were not allowed. Schools were open only for younger kids.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by matsemann on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:51PM (#29422359)
Sweet spot being 3-5x as many deaths as Norway/Denmark/Finland?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by yodsanklai on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:32PM (#29422955)
Every country had to find some balance between freedom and health. I don't think Sweden is to blame more than anyone else. They had less death than most European countries.

Following you reasoning, how many more death did the US have compared to China? would you advocate to lock up people like China did?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:20PM (#29423577)
And not just freedom, but more important things such as a functioning society in general with regards to childrens education, babies being born, the economy doing well etc etc. It's not like lockdowns are only affecting some dude's ability to go and drink beer. And they are actively harmful to people's health too, so actually it's about finding a balance between everyone and everything, and the immune compromised people at risk from cold viruses.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by savingsPossible on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:20PM (#29423573)
Did china get less freedom because of covid lockdowns? That is, surely people faced absurd restrictions, but given the length of the restrictions, which is better for people?

I know that I would prefer 1 month hard lockdown than 1 year soft. But idk how it actually went there (curious to know!)

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by yibg on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:12PM (#29425410)
Talking to friends in China, they've been mostly open since the initial lockdowns. Every once in a while there are hard localized lockdowns, but majority of people majority of the time is life as normal.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by SergeAx on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:31PM (#29422939)
Please check out this data, section "z-score by country": https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps

Sweden indeed has a worse z-score compared to Norway or Denmark, but better compared to France, Netherlands or Belgium (or Germany, for that matter). And much better than Italy or Spain. I say they indeed found a sweet spot and escaped lockdowns.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:38PM (#29423028)
People in scandinavia live in warm houses, in continental europe people live in cold and damp houses in the winter. I think that has a big impact on how sick people get
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by SergeAx on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:48PM (#29423161)
Denmark, Belgium, Netherlands, north of France and Germany had a closer climate (and more accustomed to heating), that's why I looked up their z-score first.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by namdnay on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:48PM (#29423158)
> People in scandinavia live in warm houses, in continental europe people live in cold and damp houses in the winter

huh?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by pmontra on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:55PM (#29424004)
> [People] in continental europe people live in cold and damp houses in the winter.

Really?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by dnh44 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:46PM (#29424659)
I live in the UK and have spent some time in Sweden and I would agree with this. Swedish homes are amazingly warm and cozy in the winter.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @02:53AM (#29427666)
Yeah, and in germany using the heating in your home is basically considered an unnecessary luxury, while in Sweden it's always included in the rent, and always on.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by danans on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:05PM (#29422553)
The death rate in Sweden is more like 2x higher (1.3% vs 0.6% for the other countries) [1], since its population is double the other countries. Still signficantly worse than its Nordic neighbors, though.

1. https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/mortality

EDIT: I stand corrected - I confused the case-fatality-rate number with the mortality rate, which is much worse for Sweden than its neighbors.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ajross on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:11PM (#29422629)
That's a CFR study, it reports how likely a detected infection is to result in death. It's intended to measure how effectively a nation's health care system treated infections.

Total per-capita covid deaths in Sweden covid are indeed about 3x those in Denmark, and closer to 5-6x those in Norwan & Finland. Sweden did a little bit better than the USA (about 50% higher still), but not relative to its neighbors:

https://91-divoc.com/pages/covid-visualization/?chart=countr...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by pigeonhole123 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:02PM (#29423363)
Where do you think these deaths come from? Do you think the health services in Sweden were overwhelmed?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ajross on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:27PM (#29425041)
At times, yeah. The closer you get to capacity the more the staff are overworked, the more likely you are to be attached to the old/cranky/unreliable ventilator, the more likely you are to be seen by fill-in staff pulled from other departments, the more likely it is that your hospital will run out of some medication and have to substitute, etc...

So all other things being equal, you'd expect CFRs to rise with case load. Probably not linearly, but measurably.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by danans on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:24PM (#29422820)
You're absolutely right. I should have looked at the deaths per 100k population column.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by op00to on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:10PM (#29422621)
Why would the rate be higher in higher population countries?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by danans on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:18PM (#29422743)
That's not what I said. I just said that the rate more like 2x higher in Sweden when considering population - but I was incorrectly reading the case-fatality rate. The actual mortality rate is much worse in Sweden.

The GP was comparing raw mortality counts, which isn't meaningful without dividing by population.

The difference in mortality rates is complex, but public policy around masking and gathering in groups has a significant effect. Sweden's relatively lax restrictions probably play a big role in their higher mortality rates and case fatality rates

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by kgwgk on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:54PM (#29422388)
With "big gatherings" being defined as 50 people.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by PicassoCTs on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:32PM (#29422950)
A sweet spot, were the elderly first were not properly protected, and then euthanized instead of given at least a treatment effort? Not even C-Pap, just panic-relieve and pain-medication. Not even given a choice, just scratched out of the book by politics.

https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN2841CG

It was a reckless betrayal of the elderly population of sweden.

I'm all for the freedom of self-euthanization, if a person longs for that and no, this can not be compared with what went down.

Which can be best described as a remnant from a horrific pre-worldwar 2 "survival of the fittest" mindset being dragged into the light.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jollybean on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:49PM (#29422327)
And by 'Sweet Spot' we mean a materially higher death rate than immediate peers ...

The lockdowns were imminently effective.

In Canada, when we had big waves, we shut things down, the wave faded, we opened up gradually, if another wave hit we cloistered again and the numbers came down.

If you look at 'Our World in Data' graphs you can see any number of 'spikes' for various countries, most of which were handled with lock-downs, which brought numbers down drastically.

Here you go [1]

In almost every case when there is a spike up, there are serious measures put in place, and the spike comes down.

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/covid-cases

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by annexrichmond on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:56PM (#29422420)
Lockdowns in Canada were ridiculous, particularly in Ontario. People weren't even allowed to go to parks or hikes. My parents couldn't drive to their cabin up north in fear of being ticketed.

My mom was telling me a story of her colleague's husband who resented her for going to work because he thought she was going to get him killed.

Are unreasonably strict lockdowns a good idea? Does it drive unnecessary fear? What if it causes more people to disregard rules later on?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by throw10920 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:08PM (#29422602)
> People weren't even allowed to go to parks or hikes.

If this is true, it's some pretty impressive science denialism - it's pretty obvious that there's an extremely low chance of transmission outdoors (assuming that you're not, you know, breathing right into someone's face, or next to 20k people in a stadium).

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by annexrichmond on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:14PM (#29422676)
https://globalnews.ca/news/7757913/cherry-blossoms-high-park...

> During a news conference at Toronto city hall Wednesday afternoon, Mayor John Tory said the three main concentrations of cherry blossoms at High Park would be fenced off to “discourage” people from gathering.

to be fair the park closures might not have been as general as I made it sound in my original comment but there were definitely some degree of closure of parks in addition to general sentiment of people being afraid to even go outside

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/horseshoe-resort-ski-...

> Ontario ski resorts were closed for seven weeks from Christmas Day 2020 through to February of this year. Ontario was the only jurisdiction in North America to close its slopes, according to the Canadian Ski Council. The province had said the closures were needed out of an abundance of caution and at a time when cases were soaring and vaccines were new.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jollybean on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:30PM (#29422932)
It's a tiny bit glib to lament 'science denialism' in a pandemic for which we do not have any living memory of dealing with, a new kind of disease for which there are many unknowns, serious concerns with equipment and personnel shortages, high mortality, time constraints, a state of emergency, and most evidently the very low social cost of 'not gathering in groups' outdoors.

In hindsight, they probably didn't need to go that far, but that's hindsight.

Along with the vaccine denialism, the other thing that has surprised me among the concerns of the plebes, is how they have difficulty grasping what an emergency implies.

There is a term called 'Fog of War' that military people are aware of, hinted at in the term 'No Plan Survives Contact With The Enemy'.

Running government is like running a company - it's operational. But governing in an Emergency is more like running a startup but where all your personnel are 9-to-5 functionaries not used to such situations. It's managed chaos at best, nothing will be optimized.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:30PM (#29422920)
It isn't. Closing off certain places isn't done just because those particular places have an increased risk of infection but also to stop people from traveling to and from those places.

I live in western Germany. Home office mandates in my country were for a large part to stop people from commuting in crowded trains every day, even if their actual workplace might not have had a high infection risk.

I live near a busy shopping street. Back in march 20, there was a blanket order to close everything in that street - cafes, malls, mom&pop shops, etc. The street consequently was deserted for a few months. Later, restrictions got more targeted, with an overall goal to keep untested and unvaccinated persons out. And this may lower the infection risks for individual stores, but I can just observe that the street itself is as busy again as before the pandemic.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by CamperBob2 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:46PM (#29423132)
So shut down the trains. If someone is driving to their cabin, there is no reason to stop them. It was always completely irrational to prohibit solitary or family-oriented outdoor activities. They did that around here for a while, in a largely rural state in the US Pacific Northwest region.

Senseless "do something!" edicts like that give a lot of rhetorical ammunition to the denialists and antivaxxers, while doing nothing to address the spread of COVID.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by gebruikersnaam on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:23PM (#29423614)
Another reason to keep people from traveling is to make sure they stay where there's available healthcare. If everyone traveled to their cabin and got sick, the local hospital wouldn't be able to handle all the cases.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by CamperBob2 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:50PM (#29423937)
Sorry, that's unconvincing at best.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:11PM (#29425408)
Not anymore, as the virus is already anywhere. But there absolutely was a reason to stop potentially infected from travelling large distances and carry the infection into other regions.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by CamperBob2 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:44PM (#29425627)
Where am I more likely to spread the infection? In a crowded city, or in a private cabin in the woods?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:16PM (#29425439)
> So shut down the trains.

Ok, so mandating work from home and closing down public parks is too heavy-handed but shutting down all public transport is fine?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by CamperBob2 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:45PM (#29425632)
Assuming you're trying to stop the spread of a communicable disease, yes. Do you disagree?

COVID spreads poorly outdoors. That was understood well before they reopened the public parks in my area.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by sdenton4 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:17PM (#29422725)
I think it actually took quite a while for outdoor safety to be firmly established. Canada was meanwhile having a very hard time sourcing medical supplies (and eventually also vaccines), meaning there was fear that a real blowup could be much worse than in the US.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by bduerst on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:30PM (#29422923)
People were allowed in parks. The hyperbole comes here in that the parks closed during certain seasonal events that tend to draw huge crowds.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by dmix on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:49PM (#29423173)
That's not true. I tried to go to provincial parks in Ontario and they were gated off and closed...
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by yonaguska on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:47PM (#29423144)
So those videos I watched of teens being arrested for skateboarding or playing hockey weren't real?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by TravHatesMe on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:15PM (#29423511)
Or the guy drinking coffee in a timmies parking lot
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jollybean on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:20PM (#29422763)
Nobody has ever dealt with these problems before in living memory there are far too many unknowns, and there are very serious consequences i.e. death, hospitals overflowing, staff shortages, it's a very real emergency.

If part of your job is to sit there and watch the numbers come in, and hear the reports fro the Health Officers, it's visceral.

It's managed chaos at best.

Personally, the 'no parks' thing was a bit much, and they should have encouraged 'strong distancing' at the same time encouraged people to 'get out'.

But lockdowns are ham-fisted and crude in every way but if we can bring a national emergency down to something more bearable, so be it.

If COVID strikes again this winter, hopefully we can be more nuanced about it (i.e. probably encourage people to get outdoors).

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jollybean on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:20PM (#29423568)
"Are unreasonably strict lockdowns a good idea? Does it drive unnecessary fear?"

???

If you look at the data fro Our World in Data you see exponential spikes, implying any group facing them is on the precipice of disaster.

The lockdowns decisively killed the spikes and prevented untold harm.

That for a few weeks 'you couldn't go to the park' is relevant, but not hugely material, neither is that they caused a bit of fear.

The 'no parks' bit is maybe an excessive feature taken in an emergency context but it's not a big deal.

Whatever we want to call them and whatever the mechanism, they were mostly useful.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by annexrichmond on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:47PM (#29423905)
I think it's material if people felt certain rules were invasive (which they were). And that was my point -- such people may be less inclined to follow certain guidelines in later phases of the pandemic.

> The lockdowns decisively killed the spikes and prevented untold harm.

I don't think that is definitively true. Florida hasn't been locked down at all with zero mandates since last June and while it's certainly not rainbows, it's not nearly "untold harm" either.

Did it "kill spikes" or just delay them to some degree?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jollybean on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:44PM (#29424641)
"I think it's material if people felt certain rules were invasive (which they were)"

'That you can't visit some parks' is not material in the face of the fact that you 1) cannot go to work 2) cannot gather with people 3) must wear a mask 4) cannot go to restaurants or cinemas 5) numerous other restrictions and especially 6) Must stay at home unless you have a reason to leave.

Most of those restrictions are legitimate in the fact of a drastic spike in COVID cases, which makes the 'Don't Go To A Park' a footnote in that context.

"The lockdowns decisively killed the spikes" -> "But Florida didn't have Lockdowns"

"Hey, I didn't wear a seatbelt, and I have never been hurt in an accident!"

Every situation is a bit different, and the data is not perfectly clear, but the evidence points to 'the total social changes due to lockdowns' do actually work, moreover, none of that was known in May 2020.

We had no examples but the crisis in China and Europe back then.

Given a state of emergency in the early stages of COVID, the close downs were within reason even if they erred a bit too much on the side of caution here and there. 'That we cold not go to parks' just isn't very relevant. If we have to do another lockdown, we will probably be able to go to the park.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by annexrichmond on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:08AM (#29427129)
> That you can't visit some parks' is not material

Disagree. Being in California I was grateful to comfortably meet with friends to go for a hike. The risk was trivial and I value social interaction. The fact that I cannot go to work or gather with people made things that you regard as immaterial in this context a lot more important to me.

> Given a state of emergency in the early stages of COVID, the close downs were within reason

Certainly, but it was clear within a few months (Jul 2020) that being outdoors was reasonably safe, especially if you are decently distanced. But you still had places restricting people from laying on a beach, or swimming in a beach. There was no scientific support for either of these stupid policies.

> "Hey, I didn't wear a seatbelt, and I have never been hurt in an accident!"

this is a silly analogy because health policies have multivariate outcomes, it's just about deaths, etc. and it's not something you can readily experiment on scientifically; these are people's livelihood, wellbeing, and prosperity. Optimizing for a single variable is foolish.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by FpUser on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:32PM (#29422952)
>" People weren't even allowed to go to parks or hikes"

This is total BS. I live in Toronto and I've never seen so many people in parks as I have during COVID lockdowns. What was discouraged is big companies having party in the parks.

I cycled every day in various Toronto's parks so speaking from experience.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:16PM (#29422717)
What exactly do those studies compare? How countries without lockdown coped in the same wave?

Lockdowns were called because hospitals were at capacity and immediate risk of failing to keep up service - as is currently again the case e.g in Germany.

Remember, the first lockdowns in Europe were mandated after hospitals in Italy were forced to conduct triage. (The "who do I have to let die" kind of triage)

Why did that not happen in whatever control groups the studies were looking at?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by standardUser on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:51PM (#29423195)
If Swedish hospitals exceeded capacity as has happened in other nations (like the US) then there would have been more severe restrictions. The name of the game is and always has been "don't let this very contagious virus collapse our healthcare systems".

The "we should have never shut anything down" contingent doesn't seem to understand this.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by howinteresting on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:19PM (#29421907)
Mortality isn't the only negative outcome.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by boringg on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:29PM (#29422054)
You should add Mortality + mortality in the following year. Studies coming out that people who survived severe covid had over twice the risk of dying within the next year.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by JoshuaDavid on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:05PM (#29422552)
> Studies coming out that people who survived severe covid had over twice the risk of dying within the next year.

I'm curious how those studies would disentangle the effect of "COVID damages your health, and severe COVID damages your health more so you're more likely to die in the next year" from the effect of "if you are in worse general health, a COVID infection is more likely to be severe, and also you are more likely to die in the next year". Even if you try to control for factors like age, sex, smoker vs nonsmoker, BMI, etc etc you're likely to miss something. But maybe they did something clever with their control group that serves as a good proxy for "people who would have had severe covid and survived, but didn't get infected".

I'm interested to see which study you're referring to.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by boringg on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:28PM (#29422891)
Agree there are disentangling challenges.

However if you think about it logically from a health perspective - if your respiratory system goes under severe stress that will likely exacerbate any respiratory issues that were in your system beforehand. It is surprising that the risk is so great for the following year, but not shocking considering how taxing this disease is on peoples health.

https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2021/12/severe-c...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by JoshuaDavid on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:55PM (#29423250)
Hm, I think that article references this paper[1]. It looks like their "control group" was patients who were tested for COVID-19 for any reason. They then checked whether the age distributions and distributions of Charleson Comorbidity Scores were the same for people who tested positive vs those who tested negative (of positive tests, 65.3% were under 65 vs 64.5% of negative tests, 53.5% had a comorbidity score of 0 or 1 among positives vs 49.4% among negatives). However, they then checked the age distributions between mild and severe cases, found very large differences (54.5% of severe cases were over age 65 vs 20.3% of mild cases, and 74.2% of severe cases had a comorbidity score of 2 or more vs 26.4% of mild cases)[2]. And then if I'm reading correctly, they just decided that was fine and they'd calculate the hazard ratios for mild vs severe COVID without adjusting for underlying confounders anyway?

Their methodology doesn't look super sketchy when it comes to COVID vs no COVID, but I am not sure what they're trying to do by comparing mild with severe COVID without even controlling for counfounding factors.

[1] https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmed.2021.77843...

[2] https://www.frontiersin.org/files/Articles/778434/fmed-08-77...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by lbj on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:39PM (#29422183)
Interesting, I did not know. Have a source?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by user764743 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:04PM (#29422544)
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by latchkey on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:11PM (#29422632)
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:18PM (#29422744)
Yeah because people who get severe covid are immune compromised, and that means they get are at high risk for severe illness/death from any infection, not just covid. And remember that most people who "die from covid" are old and frail and more or less at end of life. Median age for covid deaths in germany is 85.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by boringg on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:24PM (#29422829)
You are missing point to the study.

Even if I use your position that people were to die without being infected due to their health already being somewhat compromised (which isn't the case here but I will suppose it for your trollish statements) - the point is that COVID-19 has serious and significant impacts on the cardiovascular system beyond your immediate infection and more so than we previously thought.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by spookthesunset on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:22PM (#29421948)
What about all the negative outcomes from continuing all the restrictions?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:14PM (#29422679)
Still less severe than long covid, sorry.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by adolph on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:27PM (#29422868)
Persistence of various symptoms in people who recovered from COVID-19 (collectively called Long COVID) is a major health issue worldwide. It could be due to various mechanisms such as post-intensive care syndrome, post-viral fatigue syndrome, permanent organ damage or others. Proper clinical evaluation will help identify the etiology, and to customize treatment. As the disease is new, it is too early to know the true long-term outlook.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8056514/

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by bduerst on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:34PM (#29422976)
That's saying long covid is bad but we don't know just how bad until more time passes.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:31PM (#29422938)
Your point being?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by adolph on Thursday December 02, 2021 @10:43PM (#29426396)
I was somewhat skeptical about long covid. The linked article summarizes the known facts well and outlines conjectures for causes.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by howinteresting on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:16PM (#29422710)
I think mask mandates and ratcheting up the pressure to get vaccinated is a far better use of the "restriction budget" than full lockdowns on the entire population, yes. Lockdowns on people who aren't yet vaccinated by choice seem pretty great to me.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ipaddr on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:12PM (#29424248)
Your living in delta but the vaccine doesn't help as much in this new variant era. That means lockdowns for all. Still sound great?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by howinteresting on Thursday December 02, 2021 @10:57PM (#29426460)
What is the evidence to suggest that? Seems like vaccinated people have had pretty mild cases so far.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by spookthesunset on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:54PM (#29423993)
Why should a vaccinated person wear a mask? Do vaccines not work? What is the point of getting one if I still have to wear a mask?

Naw. Masks need to go away.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by _djo_ on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:45AM (#29428284)
Because all of these things work at population level, not necessarily at an individual level.

Masks reduce the amount of aerosols a person emits, thereby reducing the distance and amount of viral particles an infected person can spread in any given situation.

As a side benefit some masks protect the wearer to an extent, particularly N95s, but the main purpose is to reduce spread from infected people in the first place.

Vaccines, similarly, are not a magic shield that protect you from even getting COVID. Instead, they dramatically reduce your likelihood of getting severely ill and being hospitalised and reduce the duration of disease therefore also reducing transmission. But that only works if enough people are vaccinated that the cumulative effect of that reduced transmission can meaningfully bring down the R0 value.

This pandemic has exposed how few people are able to consider issues or questions at a broader community level versus merely how it affects them directly.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by howinteresting on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:08PM (#29424858)
It's not binary.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by hogFeast on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:26PM (#29422012)
And lockdowns can cause mortality too. In England, the waiting list for operations (these are procedures that a doctor has determined are required medically, some are elective but England doesn't do many electives because of cost) is expected to hit 12m in a few years...the total adult population in England is 56m. Ignoring the economic turmoil that they cause, ignoring the social turmoil.

There are no very good choices. But the high cost of lockdowns should dictate that they only be used when the alternative is extremely large numbers of people dying (at least in the UK, this was probably met at some point last year but hasn't been met for the majority of the Covid period).

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by howinteresting on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:22PM (#29422801)
I agree that the NHS is fucked, but that's because of:

* COVID itself

* its funding and delivery model making it vulnerable to politicians acting in bad faith

far more than restrictions on gatherings.

By the way, an "elective" surgery is one that can be scheduled in advance. Most elective surgeries are not optional. https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/treatment-tests-and-t...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by hogFeast on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:54PM (#29423236)
Right, and how do you explain what has happened in Scotland then? The SNP gave ample rope to the NHS, and they promptly hung themselves with it. I agree there are structural issues but those aren't separable from the funding issues. A few months ago, the Tories said the NHS was getting £20bn in extra funding, and journalists were being briefed by NHS lobbyists/BMA that weekend that it wasn't enough...at some point, the public has to recognise that the resources problem isn't separable from the structural problems.

My comment about electives was for the US audience. The US does a huge amount of quality-of-life, elective surgeries that don't happen in the UK (i.e. giving an 85-year old a knee replacement). So when you write something like: the waiting list is long, people from the US might not understand that the mix of surgeries in the UK is very different from there, and it largely represents people who need prompt care (for example, I have a relative who is a high bowel cancer risk and needs a regular screen, in the US this would likely happen annually but hasn't happened for about three years now because they were overdue in early 2020 and then everything stopped).

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Pyramus on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:52PM (#29422363)
How many people is "extremely large" in your opinion? And who?

Or to put it another way: Would you be okay to go, while we keep everything open? How about your parent, or grand-parent?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:15PM (#29422695)
Isn't this exactly what measuring excess mortality is for? But it's not reported anymore since there is none, and media has instead shifted to infection rate.

If you were old and had little time left, and had a compromised immune system that made any slight infection possibly lethal, and you had the choice to close down society to lower your risk of infection, would you do it?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by _djo_ on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:49AM (#29428301)
What? There has been significant excess mortality, as summarised here: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-...

My own country alone has seen nearly 300 000 excess deaths compared to the annual average, with the waves of excess deaths neatly tracking those of known COVID infection waves.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @06:42AM (#29428912)
This is exactly the problem, you're using an absolute number without reference "look big number = scary" and you are simply comparing to an average, which doesn't say anything about whether or not this is an unusual or especially different situation.

"The temperature outside is 2 degrees higher than average". Ok what conclusions can you draw from that? Very little. Just because you make a big scary number without reference, doesn't allow you to jump to a conclusion out of fear, it's just manipulative misleading misinterpretation to make it look as scary as possible, to disable people's critical thinking and support a point that actually doesn't have any basis.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by _djo_ on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:07AM (#29429074)
No, I'm providing what you asked for: A measurement of excess deaths.

That is, not just the number of people who died, but the number calculated to have died over and above the normal seasonal average.

If those excess death calculations are perfectly acceptable to calculate the effect of bad flu seasons and other mortality-affecting events, why are they suddenly not okay now?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:15AM (#29429123)
Yeah like every other article they use a formula to calculate what is "excessive" which is not explained at all, and is used as the whole basis of the article. I took a peak in the github repo and I can't really read R well enough to make anything of it, but from a quick look and reading the article "take the number of people who die from any cause in a given region and period, and then compare it with a historical baseline from recent years" it could be a well defined prediction, or it could just be an average. It's unclear as the method section here is completely unknown, and I'm sceptical how you could ever calculate a fixed number prediction without obscuring the standard deviation.

Why not just show standard deviation, median, average, percentile. Show the standard deviation in the graph.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by _djo_ on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:21AM (#29429182)
You know that's just an article providing an overview, right? It's not the official source of excess mortality statistics.

For that, each country maintains an official group that has access to death certificates and other records when preparing statistics. The figure I quoted, for instance, is from the South African Medical Research Council, who publish their methodology. There's also EuroMOMO and many others.

Did you really think that statisticians and scientists have just magically forgotten about how to do basic statistics, for decades, when preparing these reports?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:30AM (#29429255)
Why should I put any weight to statistical results that are made with some unknown "formula" and is not presented in a standard way.

Instead of using the normal measures of mean, average, standard deviation and percentiles, we just used "formula" and voila, here is answer. Ok I'm going to continue to be sceptical of such results..

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by _djo_ on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:37AM (#29429327)
It's not unknown, all the groups publish their methodology in the open.

I'm now convinced you just want to be a contrarian, rather than learning about a system you don't understand.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @06:43AM (#29428917)
You need at least to include the standard deviation for that to be of any importance, and at least for 10 years in the past
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by _djo_ on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:11AM (#29429094)
Now you're just shifting the goal posts.

Excess death tracking is hardly a new thing, most countries have been doing it for decades to measure the effect of things like flu outbreaks. Therefore when those same statistics being done using the same approach suddenly show huge climbs in 2020 and 2021 it means something.

Stop trying to minimise the pandemic. If your arguments about how to deal with it are rational they should stand up to the reality of how serious it really is, rather than a pretend reality where people haven't been dying in large numbers and filling up hospitals for two years.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:19AM (#29429161)
I'm not trying to minimise the pandemic, I'm pointing out obvious ways that it is exaggerated, such as lacking basic statistical scrutiny and throwing around huge scary numbers with no comparison or explanation.

Another example from the media (now I am shifting goal posts, but defending my point of proving that it's exaggerated and manipulative): Why are they reporting running totals of number of deahts? And making big headlines of when they reach "new grim milestones"? How is that not a completely irrelevant manipulative misinterpretation? A running total of deaths, really? When will that ever go down? And using that to support a case that "things are getting worse" somehow.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by _djo_ on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:23AM (#29429201)
Nope. You may think you are, but in reality you're ignorant of how these statistics are calculated and you that's why you think you're smart for finding what you think are mistakes. This has, actually, all been taken into account, and more, for excess mortality statistics.

I'd recommend you spend some more time learning how the scientists and statisticians calculating these figures actually work, and maybe speak to a few, before commenting further.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:33AM (#29429286)
It's not my job to find out how they made their secret calculations, it's up to them to show it if they want to present credible results, otherwise it should be ignored.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by dragonwriter on Friday December 03, 2021 @05:05AM (#29428375)
> Isn't this exactly what measuring excess mortality is for? But it's not reported anymore since there is none

It isn't reported because it takes more explanation than the media likes to give, and direct COVID-19 death counts are less complicated, not because “there is none” which is just false:

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm

https://www.destatis.de/EN/Press/2021/10/PE21_481_12.html

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @06:46AM (#29428934)
Direct covid-19 deaths are irrelevant in relation to deciding about lockdowns, that's deliberately making an issue more complex than it is, in order to obscure it. If covid deaths are simply a proportion of expected death, which are not higher than usual, then there is no need for any measures at all.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by dragonwriter on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:20AM (#29431002)
> expected death, which are not higher than usual

Again, as stated in GP (with supporting data) in neither Germany (the context of the article) nor the US (the context and source of much of the political debate in the thread) is it true that actual deaths are not higher than expected from pre-pandemic experience.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by hogFeast on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:45PM (#29423121)
I don't think you need to outline a number in advance (if you are familiar with the UK's response, one very big problem has been that forecasts of deaths has consistently undershot estimates even when England wasn't in lockdown and had no mask mandate). We had excess mortality around 10k/week in April, that probably did require a lockdown (to be clear though, if the govt had handled the care home situation better than maybe not necessary) but the bump in December last year was very minor. I am not sure what you mean by who...whoever gets Covid.

Yes, no issues at all. I support lockdowns and have had relatives who became very ill because of lockdowns (delayed/ineffective hospital treatment, I am actually not well myself either for the same reason). I think trying to argue that someone should only support/oppose something because they have something to gain personally is the reason why politics in some countries is totally fucked (the UK is probably the worst for this, somewhere around 2017/18 most of the media became tabloids and every politics story contained some hyperbolic bullshit from some random person claiming their life would be destroyed by X minor policy change...it is just a waste of time and energy for all involved).

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by sdenton4 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:22PM (#29422797)
Replying to sibling: There's PLENTY of excess mortality: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm

Summer of this year was close to normal again, though it is of course easy to imagine it wouldn't have been in a zero-restrictions scenario.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:47PM (#29423145)
That doesn't say anything, it only counts death during one single year: 2020. And concludes that the death rate is excessive during the flu season, compared to not in the flu season.

It expects death rate to be constant over the year, which is wrong.

You need to take the total number of deaths per capita, for 2020, and compare that to the same number for 2019, 2018, 2017 etc. And look at the standard deviation.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by sdenton4 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:59PM (#29424059)
What on earth are you looking at? The default view is US weekly excess deaths for 2018 through October 2021, and uses historical estimates from 2013 to present to estimate per-week thresholds: it's most certainly NOT using a single threshold per year. Go read the methodology section, please!

You can clearly see bumps due to flu season in previous years, but because flu season happens every year since before 2013, this becomes a regular seasonal effect and don't show up as 'excess' except in late 2018. We also happen to know that flu was greatly suppressed by anti-Covid measures these last two years.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:16PM (#29424293)
You are correct, I looked at it again, it's actually using historical data.

But I'm still not sure what I'm looking at, overlaying a single year over an average is always going to look "excessive". I want to see previous years as well, why not just extend the graph? That's the one single most important number that you never get so see. Here they have buried it in a complex algorithm which looks honestly suspicious at first glance, upper bound for excessive death is basically the same as average. Is standard deviation really that low?

EDIT: I just want to see how many people died per capita in 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017 and so forth, why is that not shown anywhere?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Eelongate on Thursday December 02, 2021 @09:20PM (#29425895)
> EDIT: I just want to see how many people died per capita in 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017 and so forth, why is that not shown anywhere?

Because that statistic makes the whole thing seem very mellow. Same thing as average life expectancy by year; the change from 2019 to 2020/21 is very slight.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:09AM (#29427739)
Yeah but then the whole thing is very mellow, and showing that to people is the right thing to do, and not misinterpreting to blow something out of proportion to spread panic. But I guess it doesn't get enough clicks, and it's too late now to point out that the emperor is naked...
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by sdenton4 on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:05PM (#29438605)
Based on your earlier misreading of the data, please notice that you have a conclusion that you're projecting into the data. As they say, you can torture the data until it speaks. But it's very easy to look up yearly flu deaths (~40k, up to 60k in the exceptional 2017-18 season), and see that there's an order of magnitude difference between that and what we see here.

In other words, Is the emperor actually naked, or are you simply fishing for the conclusion you want to hear?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by bobthechef on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:22PM (#29421947)
Indeed, and the lockdown and other impositions have introduced numerous ills that don't necessarily register, at least not immediately, as deaths.
[dead]
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by airza on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:47PM (#29422288)
As far as I know, the latest research says that more than half (!) of people experience fatigue and other symptoms after 6 months. I don’t know if lockdowns are the right solution, but if the modal outcome is chronic fatigue than it seems a little flippant to call someone a hypochondriac.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by Eelongate on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:51PM (#29422354)
When people claiming to suffer from long covid are tested for antibodies, a substantial portion of them are revealed to have never had covid in the first place. And anecdotally, every last person I personally know that claims long covid is a person I already knew to be a hypochondriac.

I do believe some people will have lingering respiratory problems, as is the case for all viral respiratory illnesses. But I don't think there is much more to it than that, and I think most of the complaints come from the sort of people who always think they have the latest trendy affliction.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:17PM (#29422732)
> When people claiming to suffer from long covid are tested for antibodies, a substantial portion of them are revealed to have never had covid in the first place.

Source?

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by leesalminen on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:27PM (#29422877)
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:41PM (#29423075)
As a counterpoint, I can find this meta-study:

https://evidence.nihr.ac.uk/themedreview/living-with-covid19...

> There is a widespread perception that people either die, get admitted to hospital or recover after two weeks. It is increasingly clear that for some people there is a distinct pathway of ongoing effects. There is an urgent need to better understand the symptom journey and the clinical risks that underlie that. People, their families and healthcare professionals need realistic expectations about what to expect.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by leesalminen on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:24PM (#29424393)
It appears that this is from October 2020 with some links updated in January 2021. So, it's nearly a year old. My citation is from November 2021. Surely we've learned a significant amount about COVID in 2021.

Of course, these days, anyone can link to a "study" about anything that says anything you want it to say.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by xg15 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:28PM (#29425520)
I mean, i just took that study from the Wikipedia page on long covid.

What you linked may be valid, but so far has zero citations and various critical discussion going on in the comments. Is this already published at all or is it a preprint?

I don't have enough time or knowledge to assess the validity of the claims, but based on that, the study I found on Wikipedia seems more trustworthy to me.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by lambdaba on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:53PM (#29422382)
There was a study recently published that showed that long covid was correlated with personal belief of having had covid and not having actually had it (antibodies), in other words, vast majority is psychosomatic which is frankly what you'd expect in the current climate of hysteria.

Conversely another very real phenomenon is fear induced immunosupression, to which all of these overreactive measures and constant media bombardment are greatly contributing.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by MisterBastahrd on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:47PM (#29423150)
Parasmia, phantosmia, chronic fatigue, and narcolepsy (and I am an incredibly stubborn person when it comes go "keep on keeping on"). It's always an interesting new day when I'm sitting at my desk at the office and don't know whether I'm going to smell diesel fuel, dog shit, burnt toast, or one of another random smells. Also, tap water tastes like ditto paper used to smell, so that's fun.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by rytcio on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:56PM (#29422427)
I would like to know who in the world ISN'T fatigued. I'd go into work and everyone is tired and fatigued...
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by arsome on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:49PM (#29422330)
A vague symptom like "fatigue" is also one of the most commonly reported symptoms of placebos.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by oezi on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:21PM (#29423578)
No, we should have strived to get everyone vaccinated (by making it mandatory) and then this pandemic would be over in Europe.

"Opening up" would have killed more people than it killed in the UK.

The people driving this wave, who are getting seriously ill and dying are the unvaccinated.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ipaddr on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:08PM (#29424183)
How would you enforce this mandatory vaccine? Would you go as far as killing the unvaccinated?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by oezi on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:58AM (#29427379)
Like you enforce anything: by passing a law which makes it mandatory, by introducing a fine and by assigning somebody to monitor it.

It is not going to be a crime to be unvaccinated just a lot more inconvenient.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by user-the-name on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:23PM (#29421964)
Sweden had mortality rates nearly 10x those of their neighbours.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by throw20211202 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:41PM (#29422209)
Not really, though:

* Sweden: 1,485

* Denmark: 500

* Finland: 244

* Norway: 199

* Iceland (not really a neighbour, being a 1000 miles away, accross an ocean): 102

Some more random cherrypicking:

* USA: 2,414

* Italy: 2,221

* Belgium: 2,322

* UK: 2,124

* Russia: 1,901

* Peru: 5,984

Deaths per million capita, as of 2nd december 2021, from[1].

[1] All numbers from https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by vkou on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:13PM (#29423489)
The numbers in Russia cannot be believed. My entire extended family (in Moscow) caught what was almost certainly COVID (Most of them twice, my grandfather was at death's door over it), and not a single one of them got a positive diagnosis.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by user-the-name on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:42PM (#29422225)
Pretty sure 1485 is nearly 10x 199.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ch4s3 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:54PM (#29422398)
The VAST majority of deaths there are people over 70, and Sweden like the US warehouses old people in cramped retirement homes where the virus can spread rapidly regardless of the public health approach outside. Their deaths fell off precipitously once vaccines got to the old.

The lesson here seems to be that nursing homes probably cause some amount of excess mortality, and need special attention during epidemics/pandemics.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by user-the-name on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:02PM (#29422516)
You think that is different in any other country?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ch4s3 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:15PM (#29422689)
Yes, very different. Starting in the 90's Norway started transitioning from large crowded buildings with long corridors to more home based care and other approaches that seek to keep people out of settings that look like nursing homes. In southern Europe more people live with family when they're old. This is common in lots of Asia as well. In the US it varies a lot regionally and by income.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:54PM (#29423242)
What difference does it make, they all get the virus eventually anyway
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ch4s3 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:02PM (#29423358)
The crowding can cause a lot of morbidity before anyone knows what's going on or how to treat the new infection. This is what happened in New York, the pandemic ripped through nursing facilities killing thousands of seniors well before any treatment was available.

If things unfold more slowly, you have more time to develop treatments. A lot of the deaths in NYC occurred before we figured out that just laying people on their sides reduced the risk of dying significantly.

Moreover, now that we have the ability to rapidly produce vaccines, it isn't a forgone conclusion that everyone will necessarily "get the virus eventually anyway."

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ajvs on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:46PM (#29422271)
You said "neighbours", when in reality you mean "one neighbouring country".
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by user-the-name on Friday December 03, 2021 @06:01AM (#29428672)
What useless nitpicking. How does that affect the actual argument in any way?
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by 1cvmask on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:54PM (#29422395)
Sweden has the highest density pockets of all of them. Meanwhile Norway has more fjords than people.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by santoshalper on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:22PM (#29421951)
The Swedes wore their masks and got vaccinated. What worked for them would not necessarily have worked for us.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by rightbyte on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:43PM (#29422248)
> The Swedes wore their masks

No such thing happened.

Cumulative death per 100k for Sweden in Covid is about 1500, compared to 1750 for France and 1200 for Germany. And far worse then the neighbouring countries.

I would not say anything "worked" but rather that the policies were not worse than other bad policies.

https://ourworldindata.org/explorers/coronavirus-data-explor...

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by arthur_sav on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:04PM (#29422540)
Such a relief to live in Sweden. No one is pretending to wear masks and we're doing just fine. If i wasn't reading the news i wouldn't even know there was a pandemic.

As opposed to the rest of EU where everyone is pretending to wear masks but only as chin diapers.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by 13415 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:23PM (#29422806)
You get used to wearing masks very fast and it's no big deal. They can be inconvenient. So what. Independently of the question whether masks are needed or not, it's bizarre and unreasonable that people still get heated about this topic. There are plenty of things worth discussing other than minor inconveniences like wearing masks or washing hands.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jeofken on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:21PM (#29424985)
Absolutely not. I’m Swedish and lived in NO and DK during the last 2 years. Every time I went home and could live life like normal was godsend.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by fvdessen on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:14PM (#29423498)
I personally don't think wearing masks are a minor inconvenience, and never got used to it. I like to see people's faces.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by 13415 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:43PM (#29423857)
Blessings to you, all that tells me is that you've never had a real inconvenience in your life.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by aakresearch on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:53PM (#29425696)
I wonder if someone dares to say the same thing to a victim of any crime.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by 13415 on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:14PM (#29433159)
I'll assume you replied to the wrong comment and didn't intend to insinuate that mandating the wearing of masks is a crime.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by spookthesunset on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:57PM (#29424036)
Wearing masks are huge deal. They are depressing as fuck and make everybody look ugly. We aren’t doing heart surgery… masks are silly rain dances.

I really hate mask religion. Especially the branch of it that likes to gaslight and minimize the idea that masks suck.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by aakresearch on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:37PM (#29425575)
Is tattooing a religious symbol on one's forehead "a minor inconvenience"? How about less visible part of a body? What if said symbol is a Hindu swastika? What if it's just a washable decal of a Hindu swastika? What if it is mandated under threat of a fine and imprisonment?

Maybe we have to agree to disagree on "inconvenience" of mask wearing. It is, clearly, an irrational but very powerful standoff. Masks have a marginal effect on protection (11% relative reduction in transmission, according to best recent study? So the abs risk reduced from, say, 20% to 18%) while having an enormous symbolic meaning, made even bigger by turning into political token. Washing hands is not even in the same league of religiousness. We'll see how it goes when it is made mandatory with govt-appointed "hygiene inspectors" at every workplace and fines up to a few grand...

Surely, fogging glasses and alike are minor things, but instinctive revulsion, panic, "brain shutting", "blood boiling" and suicidal tendencies aren't something to dismiss. I'm not particularly proud to be having such reaction, and I honestly tried to rationalize myself out of it, but to no success. At this point I also try to avoid seeing masked faces. I close articles or posts where author's photo is masked, blacklist YT channels and switch off TV when masked reporter or anybody pops up. That's the only thing I can do to keep some sanity before it overcomes me. And it will, because the mask mandates are looking to be with us for years...

The analogy you don't have to accept, but may help to illustrate how we (people, resisting "minor" inconvenience for "greater good") feel. Consensual physical intimacy is a great thing, very pleasant, absolutely harmless if practiced with proper care and contraception. People always sought it and it is still very much a driver of life, and will be forever. In wild nature our close relatives, bonobos, practice it widely and casually for stress relief, and it works great for the cohesion of their society! They known to have much less aggression than their bigger bros or humans. Surely the solid rational case can be made that adopting such practices could improve human society as well, maybe in major way. How would you feel if such "minor inconvenience" is mandated, with proper rules and protocols, of course? It must bizarre and unreasonable that the foolishness of "muh freedumb" standing in the way to "Greater Good"? How foolish it is of humans to make non-consensual intercourse a crime, sometimes worse than murder!

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by throw20211202 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:57PM (#29422441)
We certainly got vaccinated, but it could be better. But masks are few and far between. There was a recommendation to wear them on some public transport for a while (and might come back, due to Omicron), but my very unscientific anecdata I'd say less than 1% of people I see wear masks. Going through the central station in Stockholm in rush hour, seeing hundreds if not thousands of people, and you can probably count the number of mask wearers on your fingers.

I would follow any mask mandate, but the experience here (from my point of view) is that they don't seem to help that much. Otherwise we should have an absolute explosion of cases right now, compared to other European countries. My personal theory is that people don't use them properly; look at people on tv, constantly adjusting them, or wearing them under the chin, reusing single-use masks, etc.

There's been an uptick in cases during the last week or so[1], but compare it to eg. Germany[2] that have had a strong mask mandate for a long time. I don't understand it either.

[1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/sweden/ (do note that when looking at the chart for deaths, we have always been lagging a couple of weeks)

[2] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/germany/

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:50PM (#29423184)
And everyone always forgets those politicians who had to resign after making millions on the mask deals, and pretend that this corruption has nothing to do with why Germany has the mask mandates...
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by rory on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:54PM (#29422390)
I'm not sure who "us" is for you, but Swedes are not vaccinated at an especially high rate.

They're at about the EU average. 8-10% above the US average, 5-7% above California, but a few percent below New England, for example.

Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:51PM (#29423198)
Why would you get vaccinated for something that you're not in a risk group for anyway, it doesn't make any sense. And even double vaccines and boosters. If you did this pre-covid the doctor would have diagnosed you a hypochondric
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ahahahahah on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:35PM (#29423767)
Do you know that it's very normal for people not in a risk group for the flu to not only get double vaccines but to actually get a new one every single year? OMG, doctor's must be going crazy with all the hypochondriacs doing that.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by jseban on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:08PM (#29424177)
No I've never heard of anyone doing that, and I have never read anything about it or seen it in the media. The only thing I've ever heard is that elderly people over 70 has the option to take one dose of flu vaccine per year
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by kgwgk on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:07PM (#29424170)
It may be very normal in the US but it’s not the case in Europe.
Re:Germany locks down unvaccinated people, as leaders plan t... by ghaff on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:06PM (#29423405)
And two of those New England states have among the highest case rates in the country right now (which isn't the same as death rates of course).