News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:23PM (#29222520)
One thing I don’t understand about the housing debate is why any specific area needs to be “affordable”

If I can’t afford to live in an area, it seems to me the solution is to live somewhere else.

Maybe I’m missing something. I’m open to new ideas here but I really don’t get it.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by ZoomerCretin on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:46AM (#29224161)
Because these restrictions are a net-negative on the entire economy of the United States. If no metro areas blocked housing between 1964 and 2009, GDP would be 50% higher than it is today. (https://www.nber.org/papers/w21154?utm_campaign=ntw&utm_medi...)

"The authors estimate that if New York, San Francisco, and San Jose had housing regulations—rules about where you can build, how tall you can build, how much parking you need, and so on—that didn’t protect cute houses and instead were equivalent to the median US city in the period between 1964 and 2009, the US economy would be 9.5% bigger right now, or grow 0.21% more annually. That’s would be a big deal for wages, for the public debt, and for prosperity in general." (https://qz.com/402763/new-york-and-san-fransiscos-insane-hou...)

The average worker's income would increase by $9,000 per year if the Bay Area and New York City relaxed their zoning laws. (https://www.theregreview.org/2018/06/14/somogyi-zoning-codes...)

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by makomk on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:54AM (#29225234)
The problem with this is that no matter how much you tell people that they need to live in tiny concrete boxes and like it because it'll make more money for Bezos and co, they're not going to like it, which is why attempts to push it anyway have to be so anti-democratic. Sure, people are all for economic growth if it improves their actual quality of life, but a huge part of that is actually having a decent home and the anti-NIMBY campaigns involve abandoning trying to give that to people in favour of "the economy" and more money for housing developers.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by adrianN on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:06AM (#29225695)
Rent prices in cities where building small apartments is legal indicate that a large number of people want to live in small apartments if it is in a desirable location. For example I share 55m^2 with my wife and we like it. Commutes are short, super markets, cinemas, etc are close by. We don't have a car.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by clairity on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:53PM (#29233302)
that's actually not small (~600 ft²), being plenty for 2 people (having done this myself), and even a third if they were a child.

without even going tiny home crazy, for a single person in an urban neighborhood, a well-optimized 250 ft² (~23m²) apartment is plenty (i've done this too). if stores are plentiful and close, you don't need much storage, which is how all the excess square footage is eaten up in most homes.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by adrianN on Monday November 15, 2021 @11:39PM (#29236927)
It is small for people buying 200m^2 plus a yard and a garage in suburbia. While I was single I lived on 25m^2 too. I once spent half a year in Tokyo on 5m^2. That was fine too.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:00AM (#29225266)
That's a false dichotomy. The solution to "housing crisis in low/medium-density area" need not be "dystopian nightmare".
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by luckydata on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:37PM (#29234460)
That is a stupid (as in based on lack of information and wrong assumptions) take. You can have denser, more vertical housing that is pleasant to live in and very beautiful. Think Paris, or any large Italian city. We have multi story tall buildings with commercial space at the street level, the buildings are usually very nice to look at (better than any single family home I've owned or seen in the Bay Area) and are more conducive to meeting your neighbors and generating a lively community.

They are also better for the environment as they are more energy efficient, produce neighborhood that don't require cars for every errand and reduce the need for expanding the city footprint which lead to public transport being more effective.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Eric_WVGG on Monday November 15, 2021 @11:03PM (#29236651)
Oh cool. Go tell everyone in NYC with a chic loft that they don’t like their homes so it’ll free up some for me and everyone I know.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by azinman2 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:31PM (#29222585)
That’s been the mentality in SF for years — “we don’t want to become nyc”. And so what happens? Prices skyrocket, the people who made the city interesting and serve its needs are pushed out, and only the rich enjoy it. The young generation as a whole has little hope of home ownership, while the top who work in well paid jobs reap all the rewards. Those well paid jobs are where it’s expensive to live, so it’s a catch 22. It doesn’t create a balanced society, and in fact just further stresses the differences between the haves versus the have nots. At it’s worst the wealth inequality turns into tinder for moving beyond culture wars into actual war or revolution.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by theluketaylor on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:42PM (#29223037)
The really frustrating part being they don't need to become Manhattan to keep prices under control. If the areas zoned for single family in the Bay had been raised to 3-4 stories and multi-unit 30 years ago you could have tripled or quadrupled the number of people living in San Francisco without the need for any high rises. Human-scale neighbourhoods would still dominate the city. All the growth of the city could have been easily absorbed without high rises if mixed use mid rise development was allowed.

The best time to plant a tree is 20 years ago, but the next best time is now and California is finally deciding to plant some trees.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by selectodude on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:05PM (#29223182)
San Francisco would have a population of 1.8 million if it merely had the density of Brooklyn.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:13AM (#29224315)
But the hilarious part about "Manhattanization" is that these people actually think they'll become the cultural, financial, media, and entertainment capital of the world by accident.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by la6471 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:37PM (#29222628)
Why do someone need to move to SFO in the first place? Jobs are plentiful nowadays everywhere. So it’s not that for tech jobs one need to move to SFO. Yes one may want to live in Hong Kong , Singapore , Dubai , Mumbai , Paris or SFO but like all over the world certain places have higher per square foot cost than other places.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by justahuman74 on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:46AM (#29224163)
Many people move half-way across the world to live in SF, and it's _only_ for the jobs. There is no other reason.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by azinman2 on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:13AM (#29224317)
I think you’ve spent too much time in the tech scene. There are other types in SF, which is a city that has a lot to offer.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by daniel-cussen on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:52AM (#29224543)
I'm not so sure. I used to party in SF and it was indeed vibrant, but that was more than seven years ago. The tech scene has pushed all the eclectic, weird-haircut, artsy, broke-but-beautiful, etc, scene to places where it is actually able to function economically, with some people telling me about Brooklyn being a better place for that.

Certainly the last few times I've been there, before the pandemic, it was like entering the matrix, you get on a ferry and you show up at the Ferry Building, and boom, you're inside the internet, you went through the monitor of your computer. Ads for ad platforms everywhere, startup credit cards, everything targeting startup founders, and you know what that means? Fucking crazy abusive inescapable prices. Even at the MacDonald's, my best recollection is $8.30 for a quarter-pounder. No wonder you would get assistance from the City if you made less than $120,000.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by daniel-cussen on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:50PM (#29234596)
I'll add that this pushing-out has made the scene lose critical mass.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by throwaway6734 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:54PM (#29223110)
That's where a lot of very high paying jobs are
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by CincinnatiMan on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:03PM (#29223539)
Are the people with very high paying jobs the same people that need help from rezoning?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:15AM (#29224327)
Yes. Because if you don't build housing at every scale the bottom level becomes Sao Paulo slums
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by daniel-cussen on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:55AM (#29224565)
Those slums are actually remarkably better than "poblaciones callampa" (shroom villages) that popped up in the middle of nowhere in the rest of South America. Those favelas have water, electricity, and solid brick construction. And they're painted pretty colors, what's not to like? The real slums of the world where people who have nowhere to go come together and squat are really much less comfortable than that.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:47AM (#29224866)
Are the shroom villages in the middle of booming economic growth?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by daniel-cussen on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:46PM (#29230959)
Ah...no, more along the dumps and untilled land.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by epicureanideal on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:49AM (#29224522)
Housing currently costs so much that it's nearly unaffordable even for tech workers.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by azinman2 on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:14AM (#29224321)
No the people who need help were here before the techies came to the city.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:38PM (#29222632)
The youngsters are free to live elsewhere no? I just purchased my first home earlier this year. Obviously I had no choice but to purchase a home in a city/neighborhood I could afford. Why can’t others do the same?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by tcmart14 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:30PM (#29223346)
A number of different factors that vary for people depending on circumstances. My wife is in nursing school. Sure, we could move to some rural town in Montana when she finishes, but its not reasonable if the closest hospital is 4 hours away. Some of the more affordable places just don't have good access to jobs people want or are qualified for.

I myself work full time and am going to school for Software Engineering. Right now job prospects in where I would like move don't look great since the last job fair I attended, I got the feeling most companies are planning to axe remote work ASAP. Which then limits my ability to move in the market place for jobs.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by idreyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:51PM (#29222727)
Others are free to do the same, except that they have to continue to commute to where the jobs are. If they're lucky they might live on the fringes of BART but increasingly people are just condemned to hours-long gridlocked freeway commutes to get to their $17/hr job in SF. To recover any kind of decent quality of life you're talking about moving to a different region/state.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by briffle on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:21AM (#29224721)
Firefighters typically work 24 on, 72 off. My family members in firefighting tell me it’s shocking how many of them live in Reno, where they can afford a house. If there is another huge earthquake, they won’t be able to drive in to help.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kcplate on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:05PM (#29222810)
$17/hr is essentially an unskilled labor rate in 2021. Why not make a move? $15-17/hour jobs are pretty plentiful in other places with a far lower COL than SFO.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by idreyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:14PM (#29222867)
Many people have deep ties to a place — as caregivers to aging parents, as members of diaspora enclaves, or as young people willing to struggle through a few years of hardship for the chance of success. Many others have seen the writing on the wall and moved elsewhere, and more power to them. It's a question of whether individual solutions (people can just move somewhere else) compose into societal solutions (we need lots of "unskilled" labor or our cities will collapse into chaos within days).
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kcplate on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:58PM (#29223137)
Understood, but to your point, if a city needs unskilled labor to survive it shouldn’t work directly against it.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by oh_sigh on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:09AM (#29223944)
Why? Won't the unskilled laborers be free to choose if they want a big commute and more money, or a smaller commute and less money?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by ddingus on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:22AM (#29224723)
Maybe.

Often, the "more money" part is not enough to actually fund living and showing up for work, commute or not.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:04AM (#29225289)
If you're making $17/hr in an unskilled job in SF, and move to somewhere cheap, you're probably now making $12/hr. Maybe that change is worth it, maybe not.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by bluGill on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:26AM (#29226179)
i live in des monies iowa. the local burger king is starting at 15/hr. if you can live on 17 in SF, then 15 here will seem like riches) i know of plenty of other jobs that pay more as well with little experience needed.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:21PM (#29235429)
That's great to hear that people are able to earn a living wage where you are.

You cannot live on $17/hr in SF. Your post-tax income wouldn't even cover the the rent of a studio apartment. Not sure how you'd pay for food and transportation on top of that. Let alone actually doing anything fun that would make it worth living here.

That's 40 hrs/wk, of course. Many people end up working twice that, or more, across several jobs, in order to make ends meet here. And at that point I wonder why they stay.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:46PM (#29233938)
You're a youngster that purchased your first home?

The question is not why others can't; the question is how did you do it.

Please elaborate about your background, education, geography, occupation, whether you have a partner, children, medical issues, and what kind of home you purchased (is this a tent you set up in the woods, or a single-family house), how far it is from work, and how you get there.

Also please include any assistance you got from your family before getting to that point, including contributions to the downpayment, owning property where you could live without paying rent (or allowing you to live comfortably rent-free at their place), co-signing on the mortgage and/or student loans, paying for your education, buying your first car, etc.

Usually, the answer to your question is "because not everyone's parents are well off"; but let's hear your success story.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by EricDeb on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:49AM (#29225919)
Yes we're all free to live by market forces. We're also all free to decide if we want regulations. That's the discussion here.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Aspos on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:48PM (#29222695)
Can you elaborate and explain this further to a curious non-american? So, sounds like the problem is in transportation: if train ride from a low-cost area to a high cost area would take minutes and cost almost nothing, then the problems you mentioned would not be an issue, right? So, why try to fight the laws of economics? Why not let the rich where they want, and let the poor commute to high-job areas by solving the transportation problem? Why there is so much ado and drama? What am I missing here?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by idreyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:04PM (#29222805)
- The basic geography of the Bay Area: it's big, it's polycentric, it's hilly, there's a huge body of water on the direct route between many origin/destination pairs. The train ride can take hours and can actually cost quite a bit.

- America's inability to build mass transit cost-effectively. At this point train rides along BART are mostly between high-cost areas, and discussions of expanding the system even a little more have price tags in the tens of billions, and timelines of a decade or more. Besides, the radius of BART is about as wide as it ought to be — it should be filling in, not sprawling out, and that requires upzoning the areas along the train to be effective.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by justahuman74 on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:47AM (#29224170)
I've often wondered what it would be like if we blocked off the southern part of the bay and drained it
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by nostrademons on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:10AM (#29225335)
Various people have proposed it. The most recent one I know of was Larry Page.

It'd never pass environmental muster, though. You've got multiple protected species of wildlife in the marshlands, shipping channels, salt flats, whole cities whose selling point is that every house is waterfront property, etc.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kjeetgill on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:18PM (#29231397)
That's basically what large parts of that area already are.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by tcmart14 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:27PM (#29223324)
Some of this is ancedotal from a coworker who has a friend who works in a "support role" in silicon valley. That being something like the guy who keeps the AC going, janitor or working in a FAANG coffee shop. While there is some transportation, the issue is, some of this friends in this role, have to take a 1-2 hour commute (using public transit) since they have been priced out that far.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by oh_sigh on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:08AM (#29223932)
Why don't they just get a job that is a 10 minute commute? Even poor businesses in America want their AC running sometimes.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Baeocystin on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:30AM (#29224072)
That's what a lot of them do. I live in Gilroy, and my neighbor is an HVAC guy that moved from San Jose to Gilroy, and only services as far north as Morgan Hill.

He has more work than he'd ever be able to fill, but now has the work/life balance to actually see his kids, too.

The neighbor one more house down is a welder, same deal.

The family at the end of the street, another trade, another SF/SJ escapee.

Hell, I work in tech directly, and am pleased to say that 90% of my clients are within a 20 minute drive. I don't earn a FAANG salary, but I don't need to, either, and I am 100% certain (and I say this non-judgmentally, just a statement of fact) that I actually enjoy my daily life more than many of my former compatriots.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:38PM (#29233850)
Because poor people often live together with our poor people and rely on each other, and the question of "why don't you, your partner, your parents who help you look after your children, and everyone else don't just get a job in the same area that won't pay much less than what all of you are getting now?" has many answers.

One is that minimum wage falling way, way below living wage ensures that the employers can always pay lower for even low-paying jobs.

Another is that perverse zoning laws often don't allow people to work where they live.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by stjohnswarts on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:38PM (#29223759)
Because of NIMBY. Basically the rich people at the city's center won't let regulations pass that would increase density and therefore more poor people living around them. They like the current status quo because "they got theirs". They limit what kind of housing can be built, how tall it can be, etc and price out all but the richest land developers who in turn charge ultra high rent for the limited housing. I don't even think they necessarily need to build "poor" housing as much as loosening regulations and allow other than historic buildings to exist.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:27PM (#29233707)
> Why not let the rich where they want, and let the poor commute to high-job areas by solving the transportation problem? Why there is so much ado and drama? What am I missing here?

You're missing racism and greed.

"We don't want those people in our neighborhood" has been the reason for not allowing fast, dense, efficient, usable public transit to exist in the US.

As for the basic laws of economics, they explain that the benefits of public transit are a positive externality; and therefore, public transit has to be subsidized by the government to actually serve the needs of the people. "Not on my tax dime!", says the US. "Who would even use this, poor people? Of color, even? Not in my backyard, and not with my taxes!"

In the same breath, we pay for the ever-expanding highway systems which don't solve the problem, but without which all the Teslas and Porsches would not be of much use.

On top of it, the higher-paid peons (tech workers) can get to feel superior to the people they depend on for living (service workers) by wasting fewer hours of their lives in traffic each day.

See comments in this discussion saying "I don't believe anyone is entitled to live within a short commute from work".

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by scythe on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:36PM (#29223384)
San Mateo County rejected BART expansion when it was initially constructed, which means that essentially all suburban rail traffic into San Francisco goes through the same tunnel under the Bay, and trains are regularly packed to the gills already.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by wetpaws on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:20AM (#29224364)
You are not missing much, it's a systemic issue of zero public transportation, constantly growing demand, broken housing market, zoning, and decades of scalability problems.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by WalterBright on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:40AM (#29224123)
> Prices skyrocket

The world desperately needs a new metaphor. How about "prices zoom to the moon!"

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by hypersoar on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:06PM (#29223188)
Every city relies on a bunch of cheap labor. Dishwashers, janitors, cashiers, cleaners, landscapers, baristas, gig workers, and on and on. Is it healthy for a city to need all of these people while denying them a place in it? We have this gross dynamic of essentially telling large swaths of people that they're around only to be the help and that they don't belong.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by supernova87a on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:24PM (#29223667)
There is a surplus of cheap labor in the United States (at least up until recently), for the amount of goods and services produced. You may not believe it, but it is true. We have people willing to take jobs at low wages (again, up until recently) because of the growth of automation, outsourcing of low wage jobs to countries with even more labor surplus, and immigration. All these things, I will say off the bat, being good things that are producing good for people. (aside from the question, how many people can our planet sustain)

"How can you tell people they are not welcome to live in the cities where they work" is a nice feel good thing to say, but those are feelings. Liberal city people seem to care a lot about feelings. But what matters, and how people actually behave, is what options and choices and reality people have to decide based on. And I might just point out, you probably don't care equally as much about the young families who are in the tech industry who "get told they can't afford to buy a house where they work". Anyway.

No public policy can escape the fundamental demographic truth that we have a surplus of labor, and as cruel as it may sound, as long as people are willing to take the job for less, people will be coming to work in the Bay Area and yet not be able to live there.

Liberal city policymakers believe that forcing cities to pay living wages or mandating housing will "make people feel welcome and that they belong" but there is no escaping these fundamental forces of wage depression due to labor surplus. Then trying to "fix it" by guaranteeing people housing or forcing affordable housing to be true through rent control etc. just creates more unintended side effects elsewhere. It creates housing shortages, sky high rents where not rent controlled, and protects the very NIMBYism that this article is about (where liberal people, believing their responsibility to be fulfilled through tampering with the market, now refuse to give on actual meaningful changes). And most of all, it makes those who had the good luck to get in, better off than those who weren't chosen to receive those benefits.

As much as good intentions are nice, they rarely lead to good outcomes when applied at that level of thinking.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by hypersoar on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:12AM (#29224664)
GP posed a question about why affordable housing in any particular place should be a goal. I offered an answer.

The market price of labor, or of anything else, does not come to us as if handed down by God. It is the result of a social calculation reflecting the things our society values and how much it values them. The fact that MANGA engineers are paid more than teachers is informed by how much we've decided teachers are worth. If everybody woke up tomorrow and decided teachers were more important than we thought today, then teachers would probably get paid more. Our societal values feed into our prices. In this way, we are morally culpable for the consequences of this calculation, and it is incumbent upon us to change things of the results are unjust. For example, by taking a bunch of money from rich people and giving it to poor people. Or by creating conditions for widely-available affordable housing. And I'm not just saying we "guarantee" the housing. We have the state go in and build it.

By the way, I live in Seattle, which raised it's minimum wage to $15 a few years ago to much doomsaying. Research after the fact found no effect on unemployment. It begins to seem to me like the style of laissez-faire economics that have dominated politics for decades (which I recognize may not have much to do with academic economics) is full of shit.

And, yeah, you better believe I care about feelings. Feelings are the filter through which all human experience flows. The economy exists for us, not us for it What good is strong growth if the system that brings it about makes us all miserable?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by imtringued on Monday November 15, 2021 @10:01AM (#29228169)
>By the way, I live in Seattle, which raised it's minimum wage to $15 a few years ago to much doomsaying. It begins to seem to me like the style of laissez-faire economics that have dominated politics for decades (which I recognize may not have much to do with academic economics) is full of shit.

Well, in theory if raising the minimum wage did not result in unemployment it means that the real wage that these people deserve is higher than the old minimum wage and that employers abused their powers to pay people less. The abstraction of a free market lets people pretend that violence and coercion do not exist. Safety from those things only exists to a limited degree and only because the rule of law made it possible.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by supernova87a on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:45AM (#29224848)
We live in a democratic system in which the rules say when a majority of people (through their representatives) believe that a change to some policy may make things better, the majority can implement those rules.

Now, you can go out and convince people that doing something like this will be in their best long term interests, and by all means do so. We have had campaigns in our history that convinced us in a phase change that, for example:

-- smoking was bad

-- food and drug regulation was effective

-- we should have traffic and road safety standards

-- the list goes on and on

And in many cases, after such laws were passed, everyone realized that yes, it was better and we wouldn't change it back. Let's campaign for higher teacher pay. Yes. Let's advocate and convince people that more housing is needed. Great, I agree. But let the democratic process back it.

Now another way is if you change the rules by which democracy operates to encode a general ability for "enlightened fiat" to enable some group that knows better to decide that the things it favors are positive and should be done even if many / most people disagree. This has not gone so well in the past. Just because you used it in a way that you agree with, who is to guarantee that others with not so good intentions (or even just competence) also pass different laws that aren't so good. As a certain unpleasant senator says, "you may come to regret it sooner than you realize."

What I dislike is when people believe they're right from a moralistic point of view — on a very particular and self-selected cause — take it upon themselves to experiment using other people's lives, and add layer upon layer of tinkering onto the systems by which many people have learned to live effectively, trying to solve certain emotionally-touching problems but creating more as they go because the depth of their solution never keeps up with the depth of reality and exceptions to the solution. Don't discount the fact that the system that we have today produced the greatest prosperity and increase in standards of living for many, many people, before you tinker with it.

I don't disagree that some of your goals may be good. In fact I think climate change may be such a problem that needs fiat to overcome popular will. Or public health crises, for example.

But I don't know all the side effects and unintended consequences. For that reason, I don't support you (for example) just being able to say, "I know this is for the greater good so we should put this exception into place against people's democratic choices desiring not to do that thing." Raising a minimum wage definitely does not rise to the level of governing by fiat. And I don’t know how you decided that one issue was the one to invoke this power on. For now, go out and convince people that they should adopt it by an overwhelming majority. Then I will have no criticism.

If they don’t wish to adopt it, maybe it is the fate of the US that democracy cannot survive into middle age and still make the right decisions when people get old, wealthy, and complacent. But let people decide that America has declined because of it and it’s in their best interest to do so.

People are still coming to the US to work for minimum wage. Why are you second guessing that they find it still worth it?

Finally, your example of Seattle minimum has been shown to be full of holes. Just because Seattle's bubble could do it (so far) and not show noticeable unemployment doesn't mean it holds in general. Just ask everyone whose jobs were outsourced to India whether a lower relative wage provides a large incentive to shift labor away from a place with high costs. It's patently apparent it does have effects.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:35AM (#29225115)
I don't think the parent was advocating for doing things against the democratic process. Quite the opposite, as statements such as (emphasis mine) "If everybody woke up tomorrow and decided teachers were more important than we thought today" would seem to suggest. Much of your post seems to be attacking a straw man.

I think it's pretty disgusting that we place the economy and capitalism above the emotional well-being of the people. As the parent said, the economy works for us, not the other way around. It exists only insofar as it provides people with prosperity. If it can't do that, then it's useless. Unfortunately the people in power tend to benefit from it the most (or are heavily influenced by people who it benefits most), and many others are taught to believe in the power of capitalism even when it's not in their best interests to do so.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by nemothekid on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:33AM (#29224089)
I can't understand how this diatribe is related to housing. The NY times article mentioned by GP shows clearly "liberal cities" don't give a shit about mandating housing anymore than "conservatives cities" do; it's a false choice, Americans as whole want to preserve housing as an investment asset class. Every decision flows downward from there, and any other division is simply a distraction from the actual issue.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:40AM (#29225145)
And that's the problem. People's basic needs should not be an investment asset class.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by paisawalla on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:24AM (#29226167)
Housing may be a basic need, but ample housing with a convenient commute is not. Proponents of change need to do a better job of filtering out their obvious sympathies towards wealth redistribution, and stating the problem more acutely. I'm not here to give every dishwasher and barista a 10-minute walking commute and a living room with a view of the city center.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by EricDeb on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:53AM (#29225943)
totally agree. the problem is people's morals on it change when their house is up 200k
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Quarrelsome on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:24AM (#29225786)
> "How can you tell people they are not welcome to live in the cities where they work" is a nice feel good thing to say, but those are feelings.

If you need it written in selfish then the issue is that eventually businesses will struggle to attract these sorts of workers and/or those workers will start living rough or sleeping in their car as a workaround. This causes hard to measure inefficiencies or other social problems and this all increases cost to business or other economic or social costs.

The wheels of the economy function much better if everybody has affordable, secure shelter with a reasonable commute. I don't see how its "feelings" state this, its just basic modelling.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by imtringued on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:56AM (#29228104)
>outsourcing of low wage jobs to countries with even more labor surplus,

I have to admit, globalization has winners and losers. The nation as a whole is winning but a small portion is losing out and the worst part is that we blame them for that.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by R0b0t1 on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:06AM (#29223918)
This is still something you need to let the market sort out. Otherwise how do you decide who gets to live in CA by the beach, job lotteries?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by mikem170 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:41PM (#29222655)
Personally I'd say the problem is if someone is telling you that you are not allowed to build additional housing units on your property.

Zoning should allow for variety and growth. Japan, for example, does a much better job of this than the U.S. Basic residential zoning allows for multi-unit and mixed use buildings. This is more flexible over time. Cities evolve as the decades pass, they need room to breathe. Single family single use zoning doesn't allow this.

It's a major fail when a society can't provide housing for its people. Seems that a lot of Millennials are concerned about this.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by tcmart14 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:36PM (#29223380)
Its something that sucks it has to be done a state level. I mean, that is how most decisions are. It sucks any decision sometimes has to be made at the national level. But NIMBYism has a strong influence in municipalities. I would argue, the people who have the time and resources to go to city council meetings and voice their opinions, are the people who are NIMYBYs. Kind of hard to go to city council meetings or have influence if you don't live in the city (think of an outlying town/city of San Fran), or you have to commute 2-4 hours a day to and from work, or your holding down two jobs to keep your head above water.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:53PM (#29222737)
This is the best response I’ve gotten so far. It does seem a bit silly to me that I couldn’t build a duplex on my own property.

But then I wonder again if this is an issue that the state government should fix instead of the municipalities.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:43AM (#29225161)
The problem is that the municipalities are beholden only to the people who live in them, and the people who live in them tend to be pretty selfish when it comes to housing policy. The state can take a bit of a broader view. If it were left up to the municipalities to fix, it wouldn't get fixed.

One could certainly argue that that's fine, and that property owners should get to decide every detail of housing policy for their municipality. I don't personally agree with that, but I can understand the argument.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by mikem170 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:56PM (#29222760)
I like the idea of the states doing something. Like the article mentions! Maybe that's what it takes to get past the local NIMBYs.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by throwaway34241 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:54PM (#29223112)
If the government was restricting the supply of cars / TVs / medicine, etc, causing the prices to be high, you could make a similar argument: why not buy the older car / smaller TV / medicine with more side-effects that you can afford?

That might not be bad advice at an individual level. But it still seems more optimal to allow people to produce more supply, so more people can get what they want and/or spend less of their income to do so.

For housing people generally want access to good jobs, shorter commutes, more space, and lower cost. Those all exist on a spectrum, but more supply would allow, overall, more people to get more of those things.

From a philosophical point of view, there's the question of who has a legitimate interest in what can be built... there's the property owner, the people who own houses in the neighborhood, and the people who work there but commute. There's the people who live in the general metro area, where the overall supply/demand will affect prices.

You could even consider the people left behind by "economic geography" - as fewer people are employed in agriculture etc, there are less jobs in rural areas, and as knowledge work becomes more important more jobs are created in large cities with liquid job markets (which can support greater labor specialization).

I think there's a case to be made that all these levels have some reasonable interest in the outcome and not just the local municipal level. And particularly at the local level there may be some bad incentives - approving more housing may generate local downsides like traffic, while not moving the needle too much on prices which may be determined more by the metro area as a whole.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:58AM (#29225258)
Housing policy doesn't just affect the people who live in a place, but also the people who work in a place.

Those people still have skin in the game, but they aren't allowed to vote on that place's housing policy. Consider that the cashier at your grocery store might not be able to afford to live in your city, and has to drive an hour each way to work every day. They have no say in that matter.

(And no, they can't just get a job closer to home. There isn't enough demand for grocery store cashiers there for every cashier-commuter, more or less by definition.)

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by closeparen on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:45PM (#29223435)
Cities are conducive to human flourishing. It is good for people to have access to them. They can't be made from whole cloth; only a few sites have the potential to grow as cities in the short or medium term. Many people prefer suburbia, and that's fine, but it's not fine that they insist on having their suburbia on the only possible city sites.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by bradleyjg on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:25PM (#29222533)
I could flip that question around. Almost the entire country is low density. Why does Palo Alto need to be?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:30PM (#29222577)
I mean it doesn’t NEED to be expensive it just is. The folks living there don’t want to change their local zoning laws. I don’t really feel like I should have a say if I don’t live there.

The burden of proof for an argument should come from the side which is trying to make a change.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by bradleyjg on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:34PM (#29222602)
I think we take hyperlocalism too far. If Americans shouldn’t have a say in California and Californians shouldn’t have a say in Palo Alto, then why not have each block be sovereign? Or maybe each house?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by throwaway9870 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:52PM (#29223101)
> If Americans shouldn’t have a say in California and Californians shouldn’t have a say in Palo Alto

"A say" in what subject? Currency used? Sales tax paid? Laws regarding civil rights? Laws regarding non-compete clauses in employment contracts?

We have a complicated legal and governing system that has worked out which subjects are covered at which levels of government. This is pretty much the same with all developed countries. Debating it in black and white terms as you present is not a very reasonable way to look at the issue.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:53AM (#29225220)
I feel like you're making a related mistake: just because we've worked out which subjects are covered at which levels of government[0], that doesn't mean we've done a good job of it, or that it's actually working.

[0] And I don't think we have! This seems to be a constant struggle, with municipalities suing states, the feds suing states, states suing municipalities...

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by throwaway9870 on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:51AM (#29227328)
Where did I say it should not be revisited?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:44PM (#29236107)
If you didn't mean to suggest that, then your comment doesn't seem to say anything at all. It reads like an objection.

What did you want to say?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:43PM (#29222671)
When it comes to local issues like zoning I think it makes sense that the people actually living there get to decide.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by JackFr on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:06PM (#29222819)
To take that to the extreme would be to eliminate zoning.

After all I own the property - why should anyone else tell me what I can do with it?

If you’re from much of the US, that sounds ludicrous — but then what is the optimal level to put zoning restrictions in?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by 72f988bf on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:28AM (#29224408)
This extreme of "no zoning" doesn't work because of the negative externalities you can create, affecting your neighbors

Simply put: if you get to build your perfect house, with a nice mountain view, the neighbor west of you could build a building the size of the empire state building, and so does your neighbor east of you. Now you don't have any sunlight. The neighbor south of you could build a smelly & noisy factory, and the one north of you could build a nightclub.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:49AM (#29225193)
But zoning itself also creates negative externalities.

I think some zoning does make sense. Totally agreed that we don't want a factory and a nightclub right next to everyone's homes.

But I don't believe that anyone is entitled to their view. The idea that you can buy a plot of land and somehow "own" the line-of-sight between that plot of land and a set of mountains that might be dozens of miles away is just unreasonable, and is not in the public interest.

In your extreme example, it would suck to lose that view, but consider that, after those skyscrapers get built, your property value would likely shoot through the roof. Take that windfall and build a new house on some other land with a great view, land that's less desirable for high-density housing.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:15PM (#29222868)
Honestly not a bad argument at all.

My knee jerk reaction says the lowest layer of government should get priority.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by theluketaylor on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:47PM (#29223067)
But since local landowners consistently choose the most restrictive zoning possible to the detriment of society with things like urban sprawl, car-centric development and locking the poor and youth out from economic opportunity local control simply can't continue. It's completely unsustainable both economically and environmentally. Local control means wealthy control.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by saltminer on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:23AM (#29224024)
Yep. Ask people who grew up in suburbia and who have only ever ridden public transit when on vacation what they want, and they'll probably tell you more low density neighborhoods, bigger roads, large shopping centers (but not malls since those became un-cool), etc.

When left to their own devices, these people will inevitably take the worst parts of north Jersey and Long Island and implement them wholesale because it's all they've ever known.

The affordable areas low-wage workers could previously live in just 15 minutes away have gentrified over the years, but local homeowners have no real reason to care that their cashier has a 2+ hour round-trip commute. As long as they can still get their groceries, it doesn't affect them. But, crucially, while the employees have to spend a shit ton of time and money getting to and from work every day and likely spend a fair amount of their paycheck in the city they work in (and pay a fair amount in taxes to it as a result), they have no say in its governance since they have to vote where they're registered to.

Local governance utterly fails in these situations, regional planning requires state involvement when municipalities repeatedly shoot themselves in the foot for decades.

And of course, as we hurtle towards a climate catastrophe, we must not forget that most people who commute long hours to and from work everyday drive cars - single occupant vehicles - because the only other way to get there involves an hour+ Greyhound ride (because they travel between multiple independent transit systems). Regional planning is needed to address these issues; the American worship of single-family zoning completely undermines any progress towards meaningfully addressing climate change.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by atweiden on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:09AM (#29224646)
> Local control means wealthy control

We’ve known for years US central planning is in fact a kleptocracy [1]. So, “no”. Locals can always throw a monkey wrench in any plan a far off bureaucrat makes for them, irrespective of wealth and power disparities. There are countless real world examples of this.

In addition, why should the wealthy be the only ones to object to high density housing as the one and only prescribed solution to housing affordability? Couldn’t the root of the housing affordability problem lie elsewhere, e.g. in investors who lack long-term residency parking their cash in inflation resistant assets? How about the lack of high speed rail networks, or human overpopulation in general?

[1]: http://www.princeton.edu/~mgilens/Gilens%20homepage%20materi...

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by tcmart14 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:40PM (#29223408)
My counter argument would be that the policies as they currently stand are policies that affect people who have less legal footing in committing change in that area. Someone who works in San Francisco as a janitor, but lives in San Jose, doesn't get a vote in San Francisco elections. The people who do get to vote are least affected. So now the local problem as external consequences, which kind of punches a hole in it is entirely a local problem. Depending on how far you want to go with considering something local.

EDIT: Another thought. And people the person works in SF, but lives elsewhere, who doesn't get to vote, but still have skin in the game for policy in SF.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by throwaway6734 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:56PM (#29223124)
If areas take federal or state funding than they input from both the federal and state levels should be considered
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by guerrilla on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:32PM (#29223361)
People have answered your question but I'll add another aspect: It creates positive feedback loops. The poor get poorer because they have to live where lower paying jobs are. The "rich" get richer because only they can live where the higher paying jobs are. This isn't a society we want.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by 01100011 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:14PM (#29223609)
There needs to be some sort of balance I think. There are limits to either extreme. Imagine if we forced, say, Hawaii to accommodate everyone who wanted to live there? There are limits on the carrying capacity of an area. I would love to let the market sort it out(sans all subsidies, property tax schemes(ahem, prop 13), etc), but I'm afraid the market will push things just to the south of being livable, and we'll build cities with poor quality of life.

That said, ecological concerns will drive more and more of us to the cities, and we need to accommodate those folks. I hope we figure out a way to do it while maximizing quality of life for everyone.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:14AM (#29225740)
>Maybe I’m missing something. I’m open to new ideas here but I really don’t get it.

Is the concept of "it would take 3 hours one way to commute to work which isn't done remotely" really that hard to grasp?

Or is the concept of relocation being difficult, costing a lot of money, and sometimes not feasible because it means other family members losing jobs too hard to get?

I'm not even getting into the completely ephemeral ideas, like being priced out of the city you grew up in and have family + social connections in. The two above would be a good place to start.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Monday November 15, 2021 @10:52AM (#29228790)
I still say relocate. There’s literally not another option and that’s what I would do.

The alternative is what? Struggle and live in your car for years hoping that state legislation will magically build enough affordable units?

You can’t always legislate every problem away. Life is hard and filled with struggle. I do not buy the idea that anyone is entitled to live anywhere and be able to afford rent and have a short commute. We may as well just ask for a utopia.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:06PM (#29233454)
>The alternative is what?

Sharing your living space with a dozen people. Either family or random roommates.

What kind of economic background do you have to be asking this kind of question?

> I do not buy the idea that anyone is entitled to live anywhere and be able to afford rent and have a short commute.

I don't buy the idea that anyone is entitled to enjoy the benefits of essential infrastructure (which includes groceries, deliveries, restaurants, stores, etc) if it requires the people that power it to spend hours each day in commute.

>We may as well just ask for a utopia.

High-density, mixed use walkable neighborhoods aren't "utopia", it's how the cities always have been. Suburban cars-first developments and residential-only zoning are not some sort of natural order.

Speaking of cars, without tax-funded highways, the suburban sprawl would not exist.

NYC is far from utopia, but you can rent a studio today within 8 miles of Wall Street for $1400, in a safe neighborhood, next to public transit that will get you there in under an hour, with groceries and restaurants and stores in walking distance.

>Life is hard and filled with struggle

And this is a justification for what exactly?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by chizhik-pyzhik on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:04AM (#29224260)
The issue really is about supply and demand, right? The US has artificially limited supply through restrictive zoning.

Better to fix the supply side than just say "move to texas".

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by chii on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:42AM (#29226286)
> Better to fix the supply side than just say "move to texas".

but "move to texas" is a solution. The "fixing supply" hasn't worked, for a long time, so why are people lamenting that instead of making "move to texas" easier?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by chizhik-pyzhik on Monday November 15, 2021 @10:49AM (#29228743)
It's not that increasing the supply "hasn't worked"- we straight up don't do it at all. It's been illegal to build anything besides single-family homes in most of the USA since the ~1950s. See SF, LA, Seattle... hugely popular metro areas where most of the city can only legally be a house.

Single family homes are inefficient! Compare us to Japan or China where density is legal, the difference is night and day.

In addition, it's very exclusionary to tell the less well-off to move away. Why embrace exclusivity when we can build more housing?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @10:39PM (#29236500)
"Move to Texas" is a solution in your head, not in real life.

Let's see what one needs to do to move:

You need to find a job in Texas. That means in-person interview for service workers. That means also losing current job, because you need to be away from your job for interviews, and those jobs don't have vacations.

So, to boot, you need:

* Enough money to keep your family afloat while you're looking for a job

* Money to pay for hotel while you're interviewing

* Money to pay for a deposit on a new lease in Texas

* Money to cover breaking the lease in your hometown

* Money to go back and forth and actually move your possessions and family (several thousand dollars to either move things or sell/buy everything)

Oh wait, your service job wasn't enough to provide for your family to begin with. Your spouse had to work too, and either or both of you had a "side gig", i.e. a second job to make ends meet.

New task:

* Have spouse find a job or two in the same area

* Find a second job for yourself in Texas that works with the hours and commute for your first job

* Have money to cover the deficit in the meantime

Oh wait, but you also have children. How do you have kids if you're both working?

* Have money to pay for childcare

Haha, of course not. You can't afford that; yours and your spouse's parents were helping out. New quest:

* Also move them to Texas, find places for them to live at, jobs to work at (retirement? Hahahaha), and so on.

But wait! Everyone in your family has health issues, because working those jobs isn't healthy. Your job was crappy, but at least it had health insurance.

* Have enough money to cover all medical expenses out of pocket while you were looking for jobs

Oh, and you're still paying out loans on your vehicle that you need to get to work (and maybe a degree that didn't pan out), plus credit card debt (because you never have enough money to pay it all off)

* Have enough money to cover all the debt that you have because you don't have the money to pay for things that you need to make money

Too bad though, it turns out that you took a risk looking for jobs in a different city that didn't work out. The jobs in Texas that you can find are available because they don't pay enough for the locals to take them. Go figure, minimum wage in Texas is half that of your home state.

Now you're out of money, out of work, without insurance, and with an employment gap what makes it harder to find work.

Having lost medical care, your health issues get worse, making it harder to find work.

So, what exactly should California do to make the above "move to Texas" easier?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by snidane on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:31AM (#29226582)
No, real estate suffers from inelastic supply per area. It's not a market for bananas going by basic supply/demand equalization.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by mtoner23 on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:18AM (#29227659)
One problem is these areas are adding jobs but not housing. SF added 10 jobs for every house they built in the last decade, that gaurantees people want to live there and there wont be enough houses, ergo price increases.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Igelau on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:20AM (#29224711)
Extreme example, but by pushing to the extreme we might illuminate something. Say you are born in Hawaii. One day you realize you can't afford to live in Hawaii. You're screwed.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by encryptluks2 on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:57AM (#29226374)
Well you see at one time in history colonials came to America, killed and genocided the original land dwellers, kidnapped, raped and enslaved people to work on land furthering their profits, passed on their stolen land and wealth through generations while segregating various groups impacted by their transgressions, and to this day ask questions like you. All the while, many of them own multiple properties, have a plethora of unused land, continually abuse their positions as landlords, drive up housing prices to prices that are not affordable, and try to ensure that land is no longer available to settle for those who are simply looking for the basic necessities of safe shelter in life without trying to find ways to continue to exploit those they consider weak.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Monday November 15, 2021 @10:33AM (#29228569)
> passed on their stolen land and wealth through generations while segregating various groups impacted by their transgressions, and to this day ask questions like you.

Im a first generation American and my mother was a refugee. Get off your fucking high horse and go virtue signal somewhere else.

People like you have no idea how the world works. You so desperately need to be seen as a “good person” it’s pathetic.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by encryptluks2 on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:35PM (#29230006)
> Im a first generation American and my mother was a refugee. Get off your fucking high horse and go virtue signal somewhere else

Im really glad it worked out for her, but that doesn't mean that problems don't exist nor that you or your family didn't contribute to the issue. Many people admire the same billionaires and are "happy" willful slaves. What seems to piss off the happy willful slave more than anything is truth.

> People like you have no idea how the world works.

Apparently you do? Care to explain it to me? Want to tell me that people don't get exploited and they should just change their attitude?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:12PM (#29230500)
> but that doesn't mean that problems don't exist nor that you or your family didn't contribute to the issue.

Wow that's some incredible mental gymnastics you're performing there. So despite the fact that my family has never "killed and genocided the original land dwellers, kidnapped, raped and enslaved people" somehow my family and I still contribute to the issue.

> Apparently you do? Care to explain it to me? Want to tell me that people don't get exploited and they those that are should just change their attitude?

Sure. Exploitation and market forces are a part of human society. Baselessly calling everybody evil without offering any sort of solution does nothing except help convince yourself that you're some kind of martyr.

People absolutely are exploited in every society that has ever existed. We're talking about the housing crisis in California cities here. People are not entitled to live in the most expensive, overcrowded cities in the world with low rent and short commutes. Somehow you've dumbed down a complicated issue into a blanket condemnation of the entire country.

There is an abundance of work available right now. Many jobs can be done remotely, especially the tech jobs in SV.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by encryptluks2 on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:51PM (#29233990)
> So despite the fact that my family has never "killed and genocided the original land dwellers, kidnapped, raped and enslaved people" somehow my family and I still contribute to the issue.

Yes, that is what I'm saying. Many people participate in this system of oppression without intentionally doing so. It is very difficult to avoid, but even many products that you use and purchase contribute to a system of oppression that in return helps increase profits for companies that were formed by the oppression that I mentioned and who actively lobby and persuade public opinion to continue the oppression.

> Sure. Exploitation and market forces are a part of human society. Baselessly calling everybody evil without offering any sort of solution does nothing except help convince yourself that you're some kind of martyr.

150 or so years ago people would have said, child labor is part of society. Marrying 12/13/14 year olds is just part of society. Blacks not being vote is just part of society.

Do you want to be in the group that excused the behavior, or the group that was opposed to and helped change it?

We're not talking about entitlement here. If you want to talk about entitlement, then look at people who feel entitled to oppress and make life difficult for the minority or those placed into a situation where economically they had a far less chance at being successful, and maybe that had to do with morals... yes, you have the opportunity to get rich in America, but often that comes with sacrificing your morals in order to do so. Are you suggesting somehow that people willing to commit immoral actions to gain wealth are more entitled?

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @08:30AM (#29240314)
You’re like the caricature of a woke college student. You’re never in a million years going to convince me that somehow I’m responsible for the housing crisis in California.

You have contributed precisely ZERO substance to the topic at hand. Instead of mentioning restrictive zoning and prop 13, you rant about genocide, rape, child labor, and black suffrage.

Do you have any point at all? I suspect you’re just a narcissist who thinks they’re saving the world.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by celloductor on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:55PM (#29223871)
well if you want to dine in a fancy restaurant and shop and hang around in a plush suburb, how can you expect the blue collar workers keeping everything running to have to commute 2 hours for your convenience?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by dehrmann on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:52PM (#29223846)
It's much less of a concern if there's good transit to work.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:23AM (#29225780)
> It's much less of a concern if there's good transit to work.

Even good transit easily creates a 1hr commute each way.

And no city in the US has good transit. NYC has barely adequate transit[1], and even then, the ridership of NYC rail systems exceeds that of the entire West Coast and Midwest combined.

[1]Have fun taking the subway from Bay Ridge to Kings Highway and Ocean Ave. A century ago, streetcars were running across Brooklyn; they were replaced with buses, which sucked then, and suck now.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by parineum on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:50PM (#29223086)
What even is "affordable" housing?

How many houses do you have to build in Palo Alto before you run out of rich people to pay insane prices?

You can build housing but the market decides if it's affordable.