News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by azinman2 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:31PM (#29222585)
That’s been the mentality in SF for years — “we don’t want to become nyc”. And so what happens? Prices skyrocket, the people who made the city interesting and serve its needs are pushed out, and only the rich enjoy it. The young generation as a whole has little hope of home ownership, while the top who work in well paid jobs reap all the rewards. Those well paid jobs are where it’s expensive to live, so it’s a catch 22. It doesn’t create a balanced society, and in fact just further stresses the differences between the haves versus the have nots. At it’s worst the wealth inequality turns into tinder for moving beyond culture wars into actual war or revolution.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by theluketaylor on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:42PM (#29223037)
The really frustrating part being they don't need to become Manhattan to keep prices under control. If the areas zoned for single family in the Bay had been raised to 3-4 stories and multi-unit 30 years ago you could have tripled or quadrupled the number of people living in San Francisco without the need for any high rises. Human-scale neighbourhoods would still dominate the city. All the growth of the city could have been easily absorbed without high rises if mixed use mid rise development was allowed.

The best time to plant a tree is 20 years ago, but the next best time is now and California is finally deciding to plant some trees.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by selectodude on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:05PM (#29223182)
San Francisco would have a population of 1.8 million if it merely had the density of Brooklyn.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:13AM (#29224315)
But the hilarious part about "Manhattanization" is that these people actually think they'll become the cultural, financial, media, and entertainment capital of the world by accident.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by la6471 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:37PM (#29222628)
Why do someone need to move to SFO in the first place? Jobs are plentiful nowadays everywhere. So it’s not that for tech jobs one need to move to SFO. Yes one may want to live in Hong Kong , Singapore , Dubai , Mumbai , Paris or SFO but like all over the world certain places have higher per square foot cost than other places.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by justahuman74 on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:46AM (#29224163)
Many people move half-way across the world to live in SF, and it's _only_ for the jobs. There is no other reason.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by azinman2 on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:13AM (#29224317)
I think you’ve spent too much time in the tech scene. There are other types in SF, which is a city that has a lot to offer.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by daniel-cussen on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:52AM (#29224543)
I'm not so sure. I used to party in SF and it was indeed vibrant, but that was more than seven years ago. The tech scene has pushed all the eclectic, weird-haircut, artsy, broke-but-beautiful, etc, scene to places where it is actually able to function economically, with some people telling me about Brooklyn being a better place for that.

Certainly the last few times I've been there, before the pandemic, it was like entering the matrix, you get on a ferry and you show up at the Ferry Building, and boom, you're inside the internet, you went through the monitor of your computer. Ads for ad platforms everywhere, startup credit cards, everything targeting startup founders, and you know what that means? Fucking crazy abusive inescapable prices. Even at the MacDonald's, my best recollection is $8.30 for a quarter-pounder. No wonder you would get assistance from the City if you made less than $120,000.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by daniel-cussen on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:50PM (#29234596)
I'll add that this pushing-out has made the scene lose critical mass.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by throwaway6734 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:54PM (#29223110)
That's where a lot of very high paying jobs are
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by CincinnatiMan on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:03PM (#29223539)
Are the people with very high paying jobs the same people that need help from rezoning?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:15AM (#29224327)
Yes. Because if you don't build housing at every scale the bottom level becomes Sao Paulo slums
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by daniel-cussen on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:55AM (#29224565)
Those slums are actually remarkably better than "poblaciones callampa" (shroom villages) that popped up in the middle of nowhere in the rest of South America. Those favelas have water, electricity, and solid brick construction. And they're painted pretty colors, what's not to like? The real slums of the world where people who have nowhere to go come together and squat are really much less comfortable than that.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rcpt on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:47AM (#29224866)
Are the shroom villages in the middle of booming economic growth?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by daniel-cussen on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:46PM (#29230959)
Ah...no, more along the dumps and untilled land.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by epicureanideal on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:49AM (#29224522)
Housing currently costs so much that it's nearly unaffordable even for tech workers.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by azinman2 on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:14AM (#29224321)
No the people who need help were here before the techies came to the city.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by rank0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:38PM (#29222632)
The youngsters are free to live elsewhere no? I just purchased my first home earlier this year. Obviously I had no choice but to purchase a home in a city/neighborhood I could afford. Why can’t others do the same?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by tcmart14 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:30PM (#29223346)
A number of different factors that vary for people depending on circumstances. My wife is in nursing school. Sure, we could move to some rural town in Montana when she finishes, but its not reasonable if the closest hospital is 4 hours away. Some of the more affordable places just don't have good access to jobs people want or are qualified for.

I myself work full time and am going to school for Software Engineering. Right now job prospects in where I would like move don't look great since the last job fair I attended, I got the feeling most companies are planning to axe remote work ASAP. Which then limits my ability to move in the market place for jobs.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by idreyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:51PM (#29222727)
Others are free to do the same, except that they have to continue to commute to where the jobs are. If they're lucky they might live on the fringes of BART but increasingly people are just condemned to hours-long gridlocked freeway commutes to get to their $17/hr job in SF. To recover any kind of decent quality of life you're talking about moving to a different region/state.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by briffle on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:21AM (#29224721)
Firefighters typically work 24 on, 72 off. My family members in firefighting tell me it’s shocking how many of them live in Reno, where they can afford a house. If there is another huge earthquake, they won’t be able to drive in to help.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kcplate on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:05PM (#29222810)
$17/hr is essentially an unskilled labor rate in 2021. Why not make a move? $15-17/hour jobs are pretty plentiful in other places with a far lower COL than SFO.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by idreyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:14PM (#29222867)
Many people have deep ties to a place — as caregivers to aging parents, as members of diaspora enclaves, or as young people willing to struggle through a few years of hardship for the chance of success. Many others have seen the writing on the wall and moved elsewhere, and more power to them. It's a question of whether individual solutions (people can just move somewhere else) compose into societal solutions (we need lots of "unskilled" labor or our cities will collapse into chaos within days).
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kcplate on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:58PM (#29223137)
Understood, but to your point, if a city needs unskilled labor to survive it shouldn’t work directly against it.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by oh_sigh on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:09AM (#29223944)
Why? Won't the unskilled laborers be free to choose if they want a big commute and more money, or a smaller commute and less money?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by ddingus on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:22AM (#29224723)
Maybe.

Often, the "more money" part is not enough to actually fund living and showing up for work, commute or not.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:04AM (#29225289)
If you're making $17/hr in an unskilled job in SF, and move to somewhere cheap, you're probably now making $12/hr. Maybe that change is worth it, maybe not.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by bluGill on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:26AM (#29226179)
i live in des monies iowa. the local burger king is starting at 15/hr. if you can live on 17 in SF, then 15 here will seem like riches) i know of plenty of other jobs that pay more as well with little experience needed.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:21PM (#29235429)
That's great to hear that people are able to earn a living wage where you are.

You cannot live on $17/hr in SF. Your post-tax income wouldn't even cover the the rent of a studio apartment. Not sure how you'd pay for food and transportation on top of that. Let alone actually doing anything fun that would make it worth living here.

That's 40 hrs/wk, of course. Many people end up working twice that, or more, across several jobs, in order to make ends meet here. And at that point I wonder why they stay.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:46PM (#29233938)
You're a youngster that purchased your first home?

The question is not why others can't; the question is how did you do it.

Please elaborate about your background, education, geography, occupation, whether you have a partner, children, medical issues, and what kind of home you purchased (is this a tent you set up in the woods, or a single-family house), how far it is from work, and how you get there.

Also please include any assistance you got from your family before getting to that point, including contributions to the downpayment, owning property where you could live without paying rent (or allowing you to live comfortably rent-free at their place), co-signing on the mortgage and/or student loans, paying for your education, buying your first car, etc.

Usually, the answer to your question is "because not everyone's parents are well off"; but let's hear your success story.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by EricDeb on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:49AM (#29225919)
Yes we're all free to live by market forces. We're also all free to decide if we want regulations. That's the discussion here.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Aspos on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:48PM (#29222695)
Can you elaborate and explain this further to a curious non-american? So, sounds like the problem is in transportation: if train ride from a low-cost area to a high cost area would take minutes and cost almost nothing, then the problems you mentioned would not be an issue, right? So, why try to fight the laws of economics? Why not let the rich where they want, and let the poor commute to high-job areas by solving the transportation problem? Why there is so much ado and drama? What am I missing here?
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by idreyn on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:04PM (#29222805)
- The basic geography of the Bay Area: it's big, it's polycentric, it's hilly, there's a huge body of water on the direct route between many origin/destination pairs. The train ride can take hours and can actually cost quite a bit.

- America's inability to build mass transit cost-effectively. At this point train rides along BART are mostly between high-cost areas, and discussions of expanding the system even a little more have price tags in the tens of billions, and timelines of a decade or more. Besides, the radius of BART is about as wide as it ought to be — it should be filling in, not sprawling out, and that requires upzoning the areas along the train to be effective.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by justahuman74 on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:47AM (#29224170)
I've often wondered what it would be like if we blocked off the southern part of the bay and drained it
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by nostrademons on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:10AM (#29225335)
Various people have proposed it. The most recent one I know of was Larry Page.

It'd never pass environmental muster, though. You've got multiple protected species of wildlife in the marshlands, shipping channels, salt flats, whole cities whose selling point is that every house is waterfront property, etc.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by kjeetgill on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:18PM (#29231397)
That's basically what large parts of that area already are.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by tcmart14 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:27PM (#29223324)
Some of this is ancedotal from a coworker who has a friend who works in a "support role" in silicon valley. That being something like the guy who keeps the AC going, janitor or working in a FAANG coffee shop. While there is some transportation, the issue is, some of this friends in this role, have to take a 1-2 hour commute (using public transit) since they have been priced out that far.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by oh_sigh on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:08AM (#29223932)
Why don't they just get a job that is a 10 minute commute? Even poor businesses in America want their AC running sometimes.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by Baeocystin on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:30AM (#29224072)
That's what a lot of them do. I live in Gilroy, and my neighbor is an HVAC guy that moved from San Jose to Gilroy, and only services as far north as Morgan Hill.

He has more work than he'd ever be able to fill, but now has the work/life balance to actually see his kids, too.

The neighbor one more house down is a welder, same deal.

The family at the end of the street, another trade, another SF/SJ escapee.

Hell, I work in tech directly, and am pleased to say that 90% of my clients are within a 20 minute drive. I don't earn a FAANG salary, but I don't need to, either, and I am 100% certain (and I say this non-judgmentally, just a statement of fact) that I actually enjoy my daily life more than many of my former compatriots.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:38PM (#29233850)
Because poor people often live together with our poor people and rely on each other, and the question of "why don't you, your partner, your parents who help you look after your children, and everyone else don't just get a job in the same area that won't pay much less than what all of you are getting now?" has many answers.

One is that minimum wage falling way, way below living wage ensures that the employers can always pay lower for even low-paying jobs.

Another is that perverse zoning laws often don't allow people to work where they live.

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by stjohnswarts on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:38PM (#29223759)
Because of NIMBY. Basically the rich people at the city's center won't let regulations pass that would increase density and therefore more poor people living around them. They like the current status quo because "they got theirs". They limit what kind of housing can be built, how tall it can be, etc and price out all but the richest land developers who in turn charge ultra high rent for the limited housing. I don't even think they necessarily need to build "poor" housing as much as loosening regulations and allow other than historic buildings to exist.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by romwell on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:27PM (#29233707)
> Why not let the rich where they want, and let the poor commute to high-job areas by solving the transportation problem? Why there is so much ado and drama? What am I missing here?

You're missing racism and greed.

"We don't want those people in our neighborhood" has been the reason for not allowing fast, dense, efficient, usable public transit to exist in the US.

As for the basic laws of economics, they explain that the benefits of public transit are a positive externality; and therefore, public transit has to be subsidized by the government to actually serve the needs of the people. "Not on my tax dime!", says the US. "Who would even use this, poor people? Of color, even? Not in my backyard, and not with my taxes!"

In the same breath, we pay for the ever-expanding highway systems which don't solve the problem, but without which all the Teslas and Porsches would not be of much use.

On top of it, the higher-paid peons (tech workers) can get to feel superior to the people they depend on for living (service workers) by wasting fewer hours of their lives in traffic each day.

See comments in this discussion saying "I don't believe anyone is entitled to live within a short commute from work".

Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by scythe on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:36PM (#29223384)
San Mateo County rejected BART expansion when it was initially constructed, which means that essentially all suburban rail traffic into San Francisco goes through the same tunnel under the Bay, and trains are regularly packed to the gills already.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by wetpaws on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:20AM (#29224364)
You are not missing much, it's a systemic issue of zero public transportation, constantly growing demand, broken housing market, zoning, and decades of scalability problems.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities by WalterBright on Monday November 15, 2021 @12:40AM (#29224123)
> Prices skyrocket

The world desperately needs a new metaphor. How about "prices zoom to the moon!"