Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by tcmart14 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:36PM
(#29223380)
Its something that sucks it has to be done a state level. I mean, that is how most decisions are. It sucks any decision sometimes has to be made at the national level. But NIMBYism has a strong influence in municipalities. I would argue, the people who have the time and resources to go to city council meetings and voice their opinions, are the people who are NIMYBYs. Kind of hard to go to city council meetings or have influence if you don't live in the city (think of an outlying town/city of San Fran), or you have to commute 2-4 hours a day to and from work, or your holding down two jobs to keep your head above water.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by rank0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @08:53PM
(#29222737)
This is the best response I’ve gotten so far. It does seem a bit silly to me that I couldn’t build a duplex on my own property.
But then I wonder again if this is an issue that the state government should fix instead of the municipalities.
Re:California plans to turn the screws on NIMBY cities
by kelnos on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:43AM
(#29225161)
The problem is that the municipalities are beholden only to the people who live in them, and the people who live in them tend to be pretty selfish when it comes to housing policy. The state can take a bit of a broader view. If it were left up to the municipalities to fix, it wouldn't get fixed.
One could certainly argue that that's fine, and that property owners should get to decide every detail of housing policy for their municipality. I don't personally agree with that, but I can understand the argument.
Zoning should allow for variety and growth. Japan, for example, does a much better job of this than the U.S. Basic residential zoning allows for multi-unit and mixed use buildings. This is more flexible over time. Cities evolve as the decades pass, they need room to breathe. Single family single use zoning doesn't allow this.
It's a major fail when a society can't provide housing for its people. Seems that a lot of Millennials are concerned about this.