If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29090845.
What implication am I supposed to take from this? Everyone has must contribute meaningfully to society or they're shit?
> Anyone arguing against this has either a dog in the race, or loose screws in the head
So if I don't already agree with you, I'm either lying for finical gain, or insane? Rough options... :(
Getting paid for a service is not rent seeking in the way people are using it here.
> Pretending that, just owning property and having them gall to dare to not rent it at or below cost is what's immoral or unethical is harmful to persuading anyone currently undecided[...]
This is not what people are critiquing. No one else is talking about the thing you are. They are expressing their own moral judgements about a certain category of economic activity. That's why I linked you to a definition of "rent seeking." Economics does not make a moral judgement about rent seeking - it just says systems of exchange are more efficient w/o it.
Not everyone agrees on where to draw the line between productive business and rent seeking - but when someone speaks about businesses or owners "seeking rents" they are specifically talking about a proportion of their business that is past the point of making things worthwhile for them and into the range of excess. The definition of a "rent" in this context is that the business owner would make a reasonable profit without it. If they need to charge as much as they do to break even, it is not a rent (with some exceptions[1]).
There is another conversation all together that happens outside economics about how we should organize our society. The 'left' side of that conversation often includes the ideas that all landlords are bad or that profiting from property you own w/o labor is bad. Those are all ideas we could also talk about but they are orthogonal to the economic discussion. Economics cannot tell you what system of ownership is moral and morality cannot tell you what economic systems are stable.
[1] If an owner makes a bad investment and, say, buys a building at the peak of valuation, and then tries to pass on their bad investment to their tenants an an unethical way, that could be considered a "rent" in the economic sense as they are tying to get income on an unfair value of the building.
I think that is a little myopic.
Older buyers that are downsizing can make an excess profit in that situation. Although perhaps if excess numbers are downsizing to the same retirement homes, then maybe the retirement home owners win instead.
Also if you have a second investment property, you are definitely winning.
Finally, as house prices go up, you do end up with more equity (perhaps way more equity because a mortgage is geared lending). More equity can make a huge difference if you have any economic shocks, or if you care about passing on your equity to your children. Let’s say you have 10% equity in a $500k home, which then appreciates to $1M. If you die, you now have 550k equity, which is 11% house deposits for 5 children, or 27% deposits for each of two children. Not a bad trick.
I think a better way to think about it is that you need to own 1 house. If you don’t own a house, then you are shorting the housing market. If you own 2 then you are long the housing market. If you are a couple with kids, then you need to consider the chance of divorce (owning 1 home each is conservative, owning 1 home together is risky), and consider how much you want to give to your kids. Due to moral hazard I can’t see how you could insure against the risk of divorce.
You are born short housing.
Relevant: https://thezikomoletter.wordpress.com/2012/12/10/you-are-nat...
If they outbid everyone who actually wanted to live there, who were they planning to sell to? :P
Buying things you think are underpriced and reselling them is not frontrunning. (Ever since GME, a lot of people learned the word frontrunning and started using it in every possible situation.)
Zillow's plan was to act as a market maker. Market makers make a profit by buying things and then reselling them for slightly more. The difference is called the spread, and it's how market makers make money. Another example of a market makers is used car dealerships. Despite maybe seeming like a useless middleman, the reason market makers can exist is because they provide a valuable service to the buyer and the seller. They provide liquidity: you can go to a used car dealership and buy or sell a car today, instead of having to find someone to trade with directly. (If finding someone without a middleman were just as easy, the buyer and the seller would both benefit from just trading with each other directly. But they don't, which indicates that used car dealerships are actually providing a useful service.)
Zillow wanted to be a market maker for homes. They have a lot of data and thought they could use it to find homes that were underpriced, make a cash offer (benefiting the purchaser by giving them more liquidity via the faster sale), then quickly resell it. Their pricing algorithm didn't work, though, and they lost money. C'est la vie.
When a lower middle class guy in your town does this, he’s called a scalper and seen as a villain.
When rich elites do this with life essentials, they’re market makers doing a useful service.
If the spread is a large percentage of the assets value then it doesn't work as well and public perception is more negative. The housing market is much more difficult to properly become a market maker in because the transaction costs are high. The seller's realtor is going to want their >=3% commission. There's other costs like title transfer fee/cost, inspections, etc.
Also scalping is typically more of product's that are impossible to otherwise obtain and are sold at a huge premium.
I think Zillow frequently tried to make the seller cover these costs (whether directly or via a lower offer amount) but it seems they didn't do this successfully. It's also possible that the seller's who accepted Zillow's offer tended to have some X factor that would make their house more difficult to sell but properly handling every possible X factor is very difficult.
If Alice has season tickets to a basketball team, and Bob buys some of them to scalp later, isn’t he adding liquidity?
I know nothing.
But the whole point is that the entertainer doesn't want liquidity, they want illiquidity, for two reasons:
1. The marketing value of a ticket being impossible to obtain. The best way to do this is to sell the ticket below the market clearing price. Then you get rows of people sleeping before the day they go on sale, etc. A lot of people want that image as they believe long term the marketing will generate more revenue.
2. They want fanatical fans rather than rich fans. They may feed off the worship or cheering and want those who go through a lot of hoops to get the tickets, rather than a salesman using the company expense account to wine some client who might not throw their bras on the stage or paint their face green and scream for their team. In this sense, you can think of the money the entertainer gives up by selling below market as the purchase price of audience enthusiasm.
Now if the scalper steps in, and instead of having the underwear tosser you get the businessman, then many entertainers/performers would be pretty upset as the scalper took for themselves the enthusiasm payment and left the entertainer with the market-rate fans.
Scalpers always buy stuff where there is already high organic demand from actual end users, because scalping only works if demand outstrips supply. This demand is the liquidity the producer of the stuff needs, and it's already sufficient for them to sell all their inventory quickly, so the scalper obviously does not provide any useful service to the producer.
For the buyers, they act as a seller, but for each item they offer, the original producer has one less to offer, as the scalper has bought it from the original producer. Therefore, they provide exactly no additional liquidity for the end user.
The only thing they do is ratchet up prices and reduce customer service levels (the original producer or an actual, professional reseller will most likely offer better customer services than some random guy on eBay), which are both net negatives for everyone but the scalper.
The same set of people who would move their price points up after a few months and get larger mortgages. This worked for all of 2020 and most of 2021 and only the past quarter did it fail as a strategy.
>Buying things you think are underpriced and reselling them is not frontrunning. (Ever since GME, a lot of people learned the word frontrunning and started using it in every possible situation.)
You're missing that this is Zillow, not a neutral market actor. They have unique information about demand for houses and even get to influence prices upward through Zestimates.
And that's the same shit booking.com tried to pull, that got them in trouble with the EU market authority. (If I remember correctly.)
The trading department should be separate from the affiliate department. Otherwise it's LIBOR scandal all over again. :|
> The same set of people who would move their price points up after a few months and get larger mortgages. This worked for all of 2020 and most of 2021 and only the past quarter did it fail as a strategy.
If they have a few months. Sitting on empty houses is not free.
Though the whole problem with Zillow seems to be that they disrupt the local markets, because due to their sheer volume they effectively corner each local market where they operate, which makes them able to set prices.
(But then why have they stopped? Probably they realized they'd need more money to do that effectively, or that they'd get a huge asswhoop eventually. Or that they were unable to hedge their risks.)
I mean, exactly - they lost $550 million. Didn't stop them from burning massive capital reserves to outbid tons of people and fuck up the market a bit for them on a bad bet.
DMMs operate on exchanges with membership licenses and a galaxy of exchange regulations, especially around price moves. Zillow and the open real estate market has none of that. Similarly, a DMM would not outbid and market capture the way Zillow does. Another one you wouldn’t see on an exchange with DMMs is the army of debt financing behind Zillow vs what’s behind retail purchasers. Explaining beyond that how framing Zillow as a DMM is a cherrypicked approach with no basis in real estate market reality is not worth the time. It’s really a nothingburger of an approach that comes off as a quote from a Rand book.
At its core, a DMM provides liquidity. Zillow buying real estate, taking it off the market for a month to renovate and flip at a higher price, is not that.
Well, and also because it's illegal in some states to buy directly from a car manufacturer, so you're forced to go to a dealership whether they provide value or not.
Would eBay and Amazon be considered market makers, as they pair up buyers and sellers?
New car dealerships really don't many any sense and regulated into existence haha. I was referring to used car dealerships
Back in the early days of the auto industry car companies sometimes existed just long enough to sell some crappy cars and fold before angry customers with defective cars came calling.
That's why the laws around manufacturers having dealers exist, no matter what Elon Musk tells you.
Ever notice that bodywork, parts, and repairs for Teslas are very expensive and difficult to come by? Plenty of Teslas with relatively minor body damage end up in limbo for months or more even though the insurance company is ready to pay for repairs. Why? Tesla's bodyshops have long backlogs because there are no parts, because Musk is desperate to get as many cars out of his factory as he can.
Lots of Teslas also get totaled because Tesla charges outrageous pricing for replacement parts. Musk is exploiting the insurance industry.
Insult to injury is that Tesla can decide one day that your vehicle is too damaged for their tastes, and refuse to sell you parts. No other manufacturer does that, not even Ferrari, and that's really saying something.
(In case it's not clear, I'm legitimately curious and know basically nothing about dealerships.)
other investors. housing is only "underpriced" because it's become a commodity market that investors play in. the people who want to live in the houses have no hope of affording them when they have to compete with all the various capital funds that are buying houses and hoping to flip them to other capital funds using a slightly different algorithm to calculate value.
was that their goal? it's possible to be a market maker without cornering/manipulating the market. see: market makers on stock markets.
They were scalping housing.
"Scalping" makes zero sense in this context. Scalping exploits ticket mispricing and asymmetrical access to the market (waiting in line). Houses are bought at auction; you can't "scalp" at an auction. Try it at Christie's sometime.
They were literally scalping properties. And, like a scalper who has too much inventory, they’re now selling at a loss.
Granted plenty of mom and pop flippers are doing cheap flips in this market as well. Zillow was just jumping in on the action at a much larger scale. But if I was king for a day, I think I would pass a law that required inspection contingencies on all residential real estate transactions. And maybe some sort of escrow for undisclosed maintenance issues that occur in the first year or two after the sale.
Hell, just last weekend I read a home inspection that specifically cited inability to assess interior and exterior wall cracking due to recent paint.
artificially driving up the prices of basic human needs is literally Bond villain behaviour.
Yes, they're profiting off of a bad situation, but they're not the cause of it. Bev from the local council's planning department, as well as Michael Caton's horrific propaganda piece, has done more damage than every flipper combined.
What I'm trying to bring attention to is that our generation is frustrated, we are priced out of owning a home unless we have some massive help from our parents or inheritance, and being repeatedly told that we will own nothing and it is for our own good is demoralizing.
There might be a sizeable portion of people who do have help from their family of putting down massive six figure deposits or are up on their luck from investments, but I still think it's important to bring attention to the housing crisis for those of us who haven't had the same sort of luck.
I don't disagree with you, and I'm in the same boat personally (young family currently renting, looks like we'll be able to afford a house but only because one of our businesses has taken off in a massive way).
I just feel like we as a generation, when expressing our frustration, obsess over who has what rather than the systemic obsctacles getting in the way of us gaining a stake in society.
Screaming at people who have more than us is cathartic, but ultimately achieves nothing. We need to refocus our efforts towards solutions that are achievable and impactful.
I never advocated for a "pacifist approach", but if we want housing to be affordable we need to pick the right battles.
Advocating for things like tax reform, financial restrictions which limit the utility of residential property as an investment vehicle, incentives for empty nesters to downsize, less restrictions on property development, or even high-speed rail between metro areas and regional hubs will all put downwards pressure on property prices.
Misdirected frustration, unfortunately, will not.
What crisis are you referring to?
No matter how you slice it, they were speculating on housing inflation.
Matt Levine's Money Stuff column covered this in detail. Incompetence, not villainy.
That seems like it was the idea but amusingly, per this article, not exactly the right word for what they were doing
Zillow was literally scalping housing, a basic human need that all people must buy. That's generally considered very immoral by most reasonable people. And they didn't just do it once or twice, they did it at ridiculous scale (tens of thousands of homes sold last quarter, was a sale to a scalper to artificially drive up all housing prices).
Most reasonable people would consider this behaviour to be evil (like, comic-book-villain level evil). Even scalping a optional-only luxury item like concert tickets or whatever is already considered unethical by most folks.
In this case, Zillow bought houses too high and sold them too low. As a result, the market punished that irrational behavior.
Half a billion dollar loss seems like a pretty good indication that maybe…
sorry, what were they doing?
Scalping may also refer to:
Scalping (trading), in trading securities and commodities either a fraudulent form of market manipulation or a legitimate form of arbitrage
Ticket resale, the resale of tickets to a public event such as a concert or sporting event
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scalping_(disambiguation)The arbitrage definition under "Scalping (trading)" (ie. making money off the bid/ask spread) doesn't seem very immoral to me. I don't think they were buying houses in an area, then recommending people to buy it, so it doesn't fall under the fraudulent definition. The "ticket resale" definition doesn't really fit, because zillow isn't really acquiring houses at below market value. They're buying houses from the same market as everyone else.
>a basic human need that all people must buy
you need to buy housing, not necessarily a house. They're not the same thing. You need to buy food to survive, but you don't necessarily to buy a farm.
>tens of thousands of homes sold last quarter, was a sale to a scalper to artificially drive up all housing prices
but the fact that they lost money suggests that they didn't drive up housing prices?
> Most reasonable people would consider this behaviour to be evil (like, comic-book-villain level evil).
This requires supporting evidence. Comic book villains do things like murdering half of all living things. Show me that study that says people think flipping houses is that bad.
I've met plenty of people who were flipping houses, and I'm pretty sure if most people thought it was on a par with comic book villainy, they would not just stand at a kids birthday party and talk about it.
For each property, they engage in two transactions for which all parties involved are willing participants. How is that immoral?
So if we go by Rawlsian concepts: if it's not fair, it's immoral. If the market maker makes too much, then it's economic rent (due to rent-seeking behavior), which a lot of people consider immoral.
How is it possible for the market-maker to make “too much” in a free competitive market? They don’t have any special capability that the average home buyer doesn’t have.
I really don’t understand the angle. Capitalism is all about selling 5 cent pencils for 10 cents.
A lot of people want this. Its basic human nature ... take or construct the path of least resistance. Its just that most people cannot do this and only top 1% can.
The whole FIRE movement makes ppl aspire for the day when they can live on passive income from the savings/investments.
The advent of free money to cover the insolvent institutions caught making stupid decisions, but managing to be "too big to fail", stole a lot of money from local economies, and my parents.
People that I know that are already FIREd or plan to don't actually intend not to work. They want to, but on things they actually enjoy. If there was UBI the FIRE movement would go significantly down because one of it's main goals would be achieved by default. Right now the only way to get those goals is with passive income from investments.
We have this one life, and wasting it is not the way to go. FIRE people don't want the riches or hoarding insanes amount of money for power trips with their buddies. Most are very frugal in fact, that's the only way to achieve FIRE in the firs place. They just want the freedom from forced work. That is the essence of the FIRE movement.
I admire your strong conviction. Cheers.
It must be this then that leaks some questions in my thoughts.
What if the money you buy the properties with is a result of your contributions?
Is there a decent and accessible way to have funds to buy such properties while not having to contribute first?
Let's say I've spent 20 years working 12 hours a day contributing about 4x the average productivity - would it be ok to buy properties and continue not contributing or should I be forced to continue contributing?
What is the optimal path to reap rewards of my contributions? Having taxpayers pay that money to me in a form of retirement is one way, but what if I paid 10x more taxes as a result of my contributions should 10 other people pool their taxes to pay my retiremenet to make it fair? Or will I get the same as those who worked half what I did?
I remember my father told me that in communism there were two options as well, you either had to contribute how you were told or else you were a parasite and put to jail. Seemed fair to many.
In 1920s Russia they mostly genocided them - this is not considered fair these days.
I guess the reason it seemed fair to many is that there is truth to the simplistic formulation of your feelings.
The best definition of evil I've ever heard was - "all evil is perverted good, and it is that aspect of the good which it retains that makes it attractive to many people"
Anyway, writing this as someone "without a dog in the race" what about your dogs in the race - you mentioned you were looking at properties right now?
This isn't math. Prior "good" contributions to society don't even out "bad" contributions, no matter how we define them. To put an extreme example, you're not allowed to steal from anyone no matter how many people you helped recover their money from scams.
> What is the optimal path to reap rewards of my contributions?
It's very easy: do not speculate with human rights. When you buy a house for "investment", you are adding demand to the market, pushing prices up. Housing is inelastic, specially in the short term, so you're probably driving someone that needed a place to live out of the market, just for what? To sell it later for a higher price, driving prices further up? To rent it to people that need a place to leave, making it so that they lose wealth to you instead of owning it?
There's no need to delve into deep philosophical discussions of what is right and wrong, what is fair and isn't, and what did the communists do. The discussion is simple: don't speculate with housing.
It is, the GP said that renting is a leech and you said "but what if I buy the house with money from my contributions". If doing something is bad (however you define bad) for society, it is bad no matter how many good things you did before.
> buying a property to rent is not a bad contribution
A lot of people have already explained how it can be a bad contribution. People need houses to live, and that's not optional. By buying a house to rent you're taking it out of the market, maybe from a family that wanted it to live in it. That family might need to move to a different, cheaper place (possibly offsetting the housing discount with extra expenses in commuting and transport) or might need to rent and pay money to you instead of investing it in their house. If enough people do the same thing they'll drive prices up in an area, and because they need to recover the investment they'll also put high rent prices, because people need housing and will end up paying increasing rent prices when there's no other option.
> Human rights is a nice buzzword used very loosely and it tends to mean whatever the user considers useful to themself at that moment, I recommend reading some fundamental bills and know what's in it.
I'll just leave you with Article 25, Universal Declaration of Human Rights [1]: Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services.
1: https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma...
I do think there is a place for a service like this even in a less frothy market. Like a trade in for a car, there’s definitely some percentage of people willing to accept a deal that is not the top one if it means they can cash out faster and with less hassle.
Suppose house prices evolve from price p0 to price p. The market gains (or loses) p/p0 in that period. If you get a mortgage, you're borrowing money to buy at p0; at any point in time with a price p and total repaid r your total value is given by (deposit + r + p) - p0. You're in negative equity if (deposit + r + p) < p0. You're in the money if p > p0, but note that this isn't multiplying your investment by the market gain. Instead, it's exposing you to the absolute change in price. So suppose (deposit + r) = 40k ; p0 = 145k ; p = 190k. You're in the money for 40k + 190k - 145k = 85k, having invested 40k (roi=2.1). p1/p0 = 1.3 (<2.1), with your leverage (mortgage) having bought you more exposure to house prices. You can then liquify and re-lever back into the housing market, with a larger loan due to you larger deposit (and likely increased income). Historically this has worked very well for people as p has tended to be larger than p0. It does not work well if you end up in negative equity.
Real estate is going up in value for the following reasons:
- Almost 2 decades of QE and cheap loans
- More people working from home
- Boomers leaving the workforce and cashing in their retirement
- People leaving high cost of living areas
- Foreign investment
There is no conspiracy. As these things pull back, and they will in the next 5+ years, things will soften. What Zillow was trying to do is something a bit different but it doesn't matter because they ultimately failed.
The software developers working for this company knowingly tried to make algorithms to flip and profit off of something that should be a human right
Replacing carpets and painting walls, trying to flip for a 20% profit, the people running Z must be geniuses
As a millennial looking at 2 bedroom flats selling for £575k (780k usd, not far from a million dollars) in my area, I cannot help but have tears of joy when corporations who hope to profit off of our desperate housing situation get hit by reality straight in the face
Ask yourself who benefits from housing prices rising. If you lie to yourself that it's people who are trying to move up the housing ladder, remember that your flat appreciating 50% in 2 years means the house you want to move into by selling your flat also appreciates 50%, so you win nothing
It's the rent seeking leeches of society that think that by buying a "portfolio" of houses, they can live out their lives without contributing society in any way
Anyone arguing against this has either a dog in the race, or loose screws in the head