News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by AussieWog93 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:04PM (#29089313)
In defense of Zillow, they weren't looking to buy a "portfolio" of houses - they bought as many as they sold, and didn't have any net negative effect on housing supply.

Yes, they're profiting off of a bad situation, but they're not the cause of it. Bev from the local council's planning department, as well as Michael Caton's horrific propaganda piece, has done more damage than every flipper combined.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by enlyth on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:34PM (#29089578)
I'm not saying Z is the cause of the crisis, it's more like them trying to capitalize on it. How bad you view this is based on your political quadrant, so fair enough to those who don't think it's a problem.

What I'm trying to bring attention to is that our generation is frustrated, we are priced out of owning a home unless we have some massive help from our parents or inheritance, and being repeatedly told that we will own nothing and it is for our own good is demoralizing.

There might be a sizeable portion of people who do have help from their family of putting down massive six figure deposits or are up on their luck from investments, but I still think it's important to bring attention to the housing crisis for those of us who haven't had the same sort of luck.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by AussieWog93 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @09:00PM (#29089815)
>What I'm trying to bring attention to is that our generation is frustrated, we are priced out of owning a home unless we have some massive help from our parents or inheritance, and being repeatedly told that we will own nothing and it is for our own good is demoralizing.

I don't disagree with you, and I'm in the same boat personally (young family currently renting, looks like we'll be able to afford a house but only because one of our businesses has taken off in a massive way).

I just feel like we as a generation, when expressing our frustration, obsess over who has what rather than the systemic obsctacles getting in the way of us gaining a stake in society.

Screaming at people who have more than us is cathartic, but ultimately achieves nothing. We need to refocus our efforts towards solutions that are achievable and impactful.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by mistrial9 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @09:30PM (#29090050)
the reward for your pacifist approach is that you now rent, with a young family.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by AussieWog93 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @11:07PM (#29090689)
Please re-read my comment.

I never advocated for a "pacifist approach", but if we want housing to be affordable we need to pick the right battles.

Advocating for things like tax reform, financial restrictions which limit the utility of residential property as an investment vehicle, incentives for empty nesters to downsize, less restrictions on property development, or even high-speed rail between metro areas and regional hubs will all put downwards pressure on property prices.

Misdirected frustration, unfortunately, will not.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by miked85 on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @05:45AM (#29092614)
> I'm not saying Z is the cause of the crisis

What crisis are you referring to?

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by Pxtl on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @10:53PM (#29090605)
The "own nothing" wouldn't be so bad if there were massive reasonably priced rental units being built, but that's not a thing either. NIMBYism is killing rental too.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by kavalg on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @06:17AM (#29092780)
"own nothing" may be good in a competitive market with lots of small players that can't feasibly fix prices and engage in cartels. Reality has not been like that. At least where my sight reaches, every commodity our days is engaged in cartels and (somewhat) regulated.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by engineer_22 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:41PM (#29089653)
Sounds like they have a couple billion in inventory.

No matter how you slice it, they were speculating on housing inflation.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by stickfigure on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @12:44AM (#29091182)
No, not at all. They were trying to set themselves up as a market maker. They did not want to hold a position. They screwed up and got behind, which incurred the risk of the market moving against them (it did).

Matt Levine's Money Stuff column covered this in detail. Incompetence, not villainy.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by arcticfox on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:51PM (#29089736)
> Yes, they're profiting off of a bad situation

That seems like it was the idea but amusingly, per this article, not exactly the right word for what they were doing

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by lokar on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:10PM (#29089373)
They were trying to act as a market maker, providing liquidity for a price. Nothing wrong with that.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by maxsilver on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @09:10PM (#29089895)
> Nothing wrong with that.

Zillow was literally scalping housing, a basic human need that all people must buy. That's generally considered very immoral by most reasonable people. And they didn't just do it once or twice, they did it at ridiculous scale (tens of thousands of homes sold last quarter, was a sale to a scalper to artificially drive up all housing prices).

Most reasonable people would consider this behaviour to be evil (like, comic-book-villain level evil). Even scalping a optional-only luxury item like concert tickets or whatever is already considered unethical by most folks.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by pcwalton on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @09:31PM (#29090058)
I don't consider it evil. When you buy a house, fix it up, and resell it, you're essentially providing a renovation service to whoever will buy it next. There's no meaningful difference between you renovating a house and selling it and an owner-occupant buying the house and renovating it themselves.

In this case, Zillow bought houses too high and sold them too low. As a result, the market punished that irrational behavior.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by 93po on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @10:01PM (#29090262)
If there's no difference then there'd be no profit for Zillow and they wouldn't be doing this to begin with. Clearly there's a difference and it's morally bankrupt
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by esyir on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @10:28PM (#29090428)
His argument is that Zillow was providing a valuable service in the renovation process. Value-add allows them to charge for it.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by 93po on Thursday November 04, 2021 @03:40PM (#29111626)
That would make sense if Zillow employees were literally the people painting the walls. As it is (or was), there's probably a project manager that managed hundreds of houses, spends all day on the phone call painting companies, and then just assumes they do a good job. I'm perfectly capable of calling a painting company myself and don't need to pay Zillow thousands of dollars extra to do it for me.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by esyir on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:50AM (#29115586)
The integration of renovation in the sales process is a differentiating factor in itself. That you're not the target market or, that it might not have been successful, doesn't change that.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by UncleEntity on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @03:05AM (#29091858)
Isn’t this whole issue based on the fact that there is no profit for Zillow and they are no longer going to be doing this?

Half a billion dollar loss seems like a pretty good indication that maybe…

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by gruez on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @11:29PM (#29090813)
>Zillow was literally scalping housing [...]. That's generally considered very immoral by most reasonable people.

sorry, what were they doing?

    Scalping may also refer to: 

    Scalping (trading), in trading securities and commodities either a fraudulent form of market manipulation or a legitimate form of arbitrage

    Ticket resale, the resale of tickets to a public event such as a concert or sporting event
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scalping_(disambiguation)

The arbitrage definition under "Scalping (trading)" (ie. making money off the bid/ask spread) doesn't seem very immoral to me. I don't think they were buying houses in an area, then recommending people to buy it, so it doesn't fall under the fraudulent definition. The "ticket resale" definition doesn't really fit, because zillow isn't really acquiring houses at below market value. They're buying houses from the same market as everyone else.

>a basic human need that all people must buy

you need to buy housing, not necessarily a house. They're not the same thing. You need to buy food to survive, but you don't necessarily to buy a farm.

>tens of thousands of homes sold last quarter, was a sale to a scalper to artificially drive up all housing prices

but the fact that they lost money suggests that they didn't drive up housing prices?

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by lordnacho on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @04:11AM (#29092177)
First of all, lots of people thinking something doesn't make it true. Verify yourself at your local church.

> Most reasonable people would consider this behaviour to be evil (like, comic-book-villain level evil).

This requires supporting evidence. Comic book villains do things like murdering half of all living things. Show me that study that says people think flipping houses is that bad.

I've met plenty of people who were flipping houses, and I'm pretty sure if most people thought it was on a par with comic book villainy, they would not just stand at a kids birthday party and talk about it.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by jnwatson on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @10:59PM (#29090651)
There are several TV shows that show house flippers. You think that's immoral?

For each property, they engage in two transactions for which all parties involved are willing participants. How is that immoral?

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by pas on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @08:26AM (#29093658)
Willingness is not necessarily, informed consent, and even that might be due to exogenous probabilistic predetermination.

So if we go by Rawlsian concepts: if it's not fair, it's immoral. If the market maker makes too much, then it's economic rent (due to rent-seeking behavior), which a lot of people consider immoral.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by jnwatson on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @10:06AM (#29094725)
I don’t understand how it is rent seeking. They are actually improving the supply of housing by fixing them up.

How is it possible for the market-maker to make “too much” in a free competitive market? They don’t have any special capability that the average home buyer doesn’t have.

I really don’t understand the angle. Capitalism is all about selling 5 cent pencils for 10 cents.

Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by iskander on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:27PM (#29089523)
It's more complicated than that since they also have a huge influence on prices through Zestimates. They undoubtably kept housing prices rising for the past few years, which was very profitable to them as large scale flippers.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by engineer_22 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @08:43PM (#29089669)
The market doesn't need any more liquidity. Banks will lend to anyone with a pulse.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by lokar on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @09:04PM (#29089842)
That is not the kind of liquidity I'm talking about. Look up what companies like citadel securities do in equities markets.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by mym1990 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @09:05PM (#29089851)
More so than providing liquidity they are providing increased velocity. I would love to know if there are properties that Z has bought and sold more than once...
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by Valakas_ on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @07:25AM (#29093205)
Would there be a bad situation if there was nobody profitting from it? Maybe there is a root cause, but Zillow is certainly one cause why this is so bad. Not the root one, but a cause still.
Re:Zillow to stop flipping homes, loses more than $550M, lay... by jnwatson on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @10:57PM (#29090633)
They actually improved the market by providing liquidity.