Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by cbfrench on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:48AM
(#29022810)
My new life goal is to write an action film in which a rag-tag band of meteorologists takes on an arch-villain who seeks to change the weather to enrich himself and control the world. These meteorologists initially realize something is up because the villain has hijacked the GFS to distract from his plot. The climactic (or climatic?) scene will involve using a Hurricane Hunter to parachute into the villain’s lair to put a stop to the scheme using the full force of the NOAA, which will probably involve weaponized weather balloons. At some point the villain will ask: “How many divisions does the NOAA have?”
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by bryanrasmussen on Thursday October 28, 2021 @05:26AM
(#29024033)
I think Shane Black should write, then we will get some quality Christmas action scenes, the weather the bad guy is doing the trial run on is obviously going to be snow in Christmas.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by shantnutiwari on Thursday October 28, 2021 @04:52AM
(#29023867)
The terrible 90s movie "The Avengers" starring Sean Connery had a similar plot. Connery wants to ruin the world's climate, and some rather boring superheros (The Avengers, no not those ones) stop them.
Yeah, I remember the Avengers from before they were cool
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by themodelplumber on Thursday October 28, 2021 @12:45AM
(#29022468)
Fun fact, NOAA (operator of linked website above) has its own federal law enforcement division with guns. Among other things, they enforce the Weather Modification Reporting Act.
If you try to modify the weather without permission, there is a chance that you will have to surrender to a gun-wielding federal officer wearing a NOAA patch.
So, unless your weather modification activities are also violating laws or treaties regarding the use of and access to fisheries, you probably won’t be encountering any NOAA fuzz.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by cbfrench on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:18AM
(#29022634)
Now I really want to imagine that at NOAA OLE HQ, there is a big bulletin board with a bunch of strings and newspaper clippings that demonstrates precisely how everything somehow interacts with the fisheries. They’re just waiting for their moment to act on that. (Although they might have to borrow Amtrak’s SWAT team…)
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by systemvoltage on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:50AM
(#29022822)
I’ll get in trouble here but there is something totally badass about this. Gun wielding people that are trained to eliminate the threat and protect us from all evil. NASA needs a special unit to protect astronauts from billionaires.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by cbfrench on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:26AM
(#29022686)
As it turns out, USPS doesn’t fall under the statutory definition of a uniformed service: “ (5) The term “uniformed services” means—
(A) the armed forces;
(B) the commissioned corps of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration; and
(C) the commissioned corps of the Public Health Service” (10 USC §101(a)(5)).
Apparently this has to do with the fact that both NOAA and PHS commissioned officers operate according to military rules (but are not generally subject to the UCMJ), while USPS employees (even in the Postal Inspection Service) do not.
(https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniformed_services_of_the_Un...)
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by dragonwriter on Thursday October 28, 2021 @08:09PM
(#29033697)
> Apparently this has to do with the fact that both NOAA and PHS commissioned officers operate according to military rules
Specifically, the NOAA Commissioned Corps has its antecedent in Army (never returned after the Civil War) and Navy commissioned officers that worked with its predecessor civilian workers until 1900. There was a couple decades with no uniformed component, but a new and separate uniformed component was created in WWI, because part of the agencies work was battlefield survey, and under the law of war non-uniformed personnel captured doing that job would not be entitled to treatment as POWs, and would likely be executed as spies.
The PHS Commissioned Corps seems to have come about originally because the PHS had an ex-military leader who thought military discipline was a good idea, but it does (among other functions) supply medical officers to serve with both the Coast Guard and the NOAA Commissioned Corps, neither of which (unlike the other uniformed services) have their own, so, I guess that provides some nexus.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by dragonwriter on Thursday October 28, 2021 @08:12PM
(#29033725)
There are law enforcement officers with uniforms in many federal agencies, but they aren't legally “uniformed services” which are basically the armed forces plus two services that have auxiliary military roles as part of their scope.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by themodelplumber on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:19AM
(#29022640)
I had a neighbor who was a postal inspector. You actually got me wondering too, because he definitely carried a firearm but I never saw that guy in a uniform.
Are they only outputs, or could they be GPIO? What would happen with a giant prism above a cloud?
A very pretty cloud, for sure, Somewhere Over the Rainbow. I just wonder whether the ice crystals could be persuaded to melt quicker, and drop their rain. Cheaper than silver iodide for cloud seeding. I have no idea who to talk to about this, or any clue how to simulate it in a lab.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by Ginden on Thursday October 28, 2021 @04:02AM
(#29023564)
Obvious reason would be that hurricanes are large. Like 100km large. Force exerted by blast follows inverse-square law and it's quite negligible in 30km for thermonuclear bombs. 30km diameter disruption of wind affects only 9% of 100km diameter cyclone.
It's quite unlikely that it would disrupt cyclone, but someone with better fluid mechanics knowledge can probably do such calculation.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by SapporoChris on Thursday October 28, 2021 @03:07AM
(#29023262)
"They start forming off the coast of Africa, as they're moving across the Atlantic, we drop a bomb inside the eye of the hurricane and it disrupts it. Why can't we do that?," Trump reportedly asked aides during one hurricane briefing.
https://edition.cnn.com/2019/08/26/politics/nuke-hurricanes-...
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by mechanical_bear on Thursday October 28, 2021 @10:48AM
(#29026734)
It’s funny that he got so pilloried. We tell people that we value outside the box thinking, and a willingness to ask questions with no regard to looking stupid. But when these traits are actually displayed, the person will be mocked. Now…if he had followed through on it, after being told it’s dumb…
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by dotancohen on Thursday October 28, 2021 @03:15AM
(#29023315)
It sounds like a stupid question, but so was "Why can't we boost the first stage _back_ to CCAF then land it using legs and fuel that we carried up with us" just a few years ago.
So, what is the real answer? I'm not advocating the idea, but why is it not feasible?
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by ben_w on Thursday October 28, 2021 @04:25AM
(#29023692)
1. Hurricanes are powered by heat, so you just make it stronger
2. The heat energy used by a hurricane is roughly equivalent to one Hiroshima per second, which at least reduces the impact of 1., but tells you how large the scale difference is
3. Explosions produce shockwaves which only change instantaneous pressure, and are totally ineffective at changing barometric pressure, the one thing you want to increase, because barometric pressure is the weight of all the air above the ground
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by dotancohen on Thursday October 28, 2021 @04:37AM
(#29023767)
Terrific, thank you.
I was thinking that a powerful enough explosion may disrupt the winds. And it seemed to be that a disruption of the winds may dissipate a storm. I suppose that the concept of "what a storm is" may not be very clear to the layman, including myself. Until a few minutes ago it seemed to me that a hurricane is just winds going around in a circle.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by anigbrowl on Thursday October 28, 2021 @03:14AM
(#29023309)
You find out the hard way what HAARP can really do.
For real though, if there was a real problem like that the NOAA would get military backup. The American approach to an immediately urgent problem is to just hurl massive resources at it and (maybe) ask questions later.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by helloworld11 on Thursday October 28, 2021 @05:34AM
(#29024059)
hahaha. Loved the HAARP bit. Would make for a wonderful MIB-style movie, but with NOAA agents and their secret globe-spanning weather weapons against invading aliens.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by anigbrowl on Thursday October 28, 2021 @06:05AM
(#29024200)
One of the most annoying things about conspiracy theories is the lack of emotional payoff from a dramatic reveal. Maybe we should budget for $5 billion of non-fatal economic destruction annually, on condition that it be emotionally satisfying - build giant Tesla coils and have them bring down empty airliners, or derail trains full of extremely garish but glowing chemicals (that are environmentally harmless) in places where we wanted to build a new bridge anyway.
Then we can have new conspiracy theories about how real disasters are just being passed off as cool disasters and the rotating cast of supervillains are actually a puppet show from the real villains in the federal reserve.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by kaybe on Thursday October 28, 2021 @09:00AM
(#29025552)
I mean.. I just followed a seminar talk about methane emission detection from an aircraft in the US. For this you often fly in lines to cover an area fully.
The speaker finished up with a screenshot from a youtube video where an UFO enthusiast actually followed the aircraft by car and came to the airport to look at it. It didn't help that the aircraft was rented from a company that usually rents to military.
40k views on a video that claims they released radioactive insects on that flight. (It was a spectrometer onboard...) The video is gone now, and we can only speculate what the people behind it think about that. How does one deal with this in a satisfying manner?
40k views on a video about methane emission detection would be amazing! A fraction of those 40k people in the area with knowledge of the problem and the same enthusiasm could probably easily stop all these emissions as well.
(Apart from that.. if anyone wonders.. talk to us! (and please don't seem like a nutjob..) This is research paid by your taxes and on your behalf, and if you come with journalistic interest we might just open the doors and, y'know, let you have a very close look at things.)
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by themodelplumber on Thursday October 28, 2021 @12:49AM
(#29022493)
I believe they are heavy cooperators with other agencies including e.g. state and local agencies. They were only 200 strong last I checked, and that probably includes office staff.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by ARandomerDude on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:07AM
(#29022582)
Indeed. In fact, failure to work with other (local) law enforcement agencies was one of the reasons the FBI had such a bad day in the 1986 Miami shootout. This is taught as a textbook example of what not to do in the military and LEO communities today.
They like to portray local vs federal in Hollywood as a trope, but in reality, inter-agency cooperation is (supposed to be) the norm.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by themodelplumber on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:48AM
(#29022805)
Spoiler: 52 page PDF about military weather operations. Seems interesting if a bit of a different direction for the topic. Military ops are "allowed" but in a military context...though a NOAA buddy cop showdown against a rogue USAF weather ops team wouldn't exactly sound boring.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by sillysaurusx on Thursday October 28, 2021 @12:15AM
(#29022321)
Hmm. This assumes we know all the spies. But it could be true that spying has been wildly successful, and that most spies were never caught. In a scenario like that, a breakdown of percentages would sound a lot less convincing.
I suppose most spies are caught, but I've always wondered whether Feynman was a spy. Not based on anything in particular; it's just tantalizing to think that random famous people are actually traitors. We'd never know unless they were caught, after all.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by ncmncm on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:17AM
(#29022631)
Most people tried for espionage in the US in the last two decades were not spies at all. The people who should have been tried and executed, for participating in torture, and for destroying evidence that could have led to convictions for torture, are still in charge.
Probably the overwhelming majority of actual spies in the US are not caught, because hardly anybody is even looking. And, the stuff they spy out is in the end mostly inconsequential, except insofar as it causes trouble for other spies.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by baybal2 on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:26AM
(#29022690)
I think, on Russian side they never really had anything like functioning counterintelligence screening.
They instead had complete reliance on Hanses, or Ames like "super-spy" characters, with whom they went to any length to recruit as became known after USSR dissolved.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by hguant on Thursday October 28, 2021 @02:26AM
(#29023025)
Literally everything you've said is is just patently false, and betrays a such severe lack of any sort of knowledge or understanding about the subject matter that one can only assume bad faith, or else that you're an object lesson in the failure of the US education system.
The Western Regional Security Office is housed at the NOAA Western Regional Center.
On some level, NOAA is a national security asset, I would think, so it makes sense. Also, they appear to provide security services for other, smaller agencies within the DOC.
> Protects the Department of Commerce and the U.S. Government by collaboration with key leaders, decision-makers, and stakeholders to effectively mitigate security risks.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by smcl on Thursday October 28, 2021 @04:36AM
(#29023757)
That first point is basically - you could do everything right on your end and there’s a good chance that a US agent within the foreign government will out you anyway. This is such an effective sounding deterrent I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s exaggerated, like “yeah maybe you’re smart but we are everywhere”
Either way it’d take something extreme to tempt me into this world - like if my country became a fascist dictatorship or something acting against it is at least the morally correct thing to do
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by smcl on Thursday October 28, 2021 @05:21AM
(#29024007)
That is true, but I think (or hope?) that if in the unlikely event my country was under an oppressive, fascist regime that I would do my best to resist and undermine it in any way possible. Who knows whether that would transpire.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by eru on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:24AM
(#29035432)
These two approaches are not necessarily incompatible.
Though I wonder why you would care so much about 'your' country? Once you save yourself and your family and friends, oppression and misery anywhere of any human seems about equally bad to me.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by smcl on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:05PM
(#29053317)
Well the country I grew up in contains not just my immediate and extended family who I care a lot about, but a pretty wide network of friends, colleagues and acquaintances. But let's leave that aside for a moment and think about whether I actually might want to live there in the future, rather than as a refugee elsewhere. There's more to it than this, but I think this is sufficient argument against "just move lol"
This is all going into a hypothetical future I'd rather not spend too much time thinking about. As I said it's fairly unlikely and if I'm honest this is normally the wheelhouse of people who are a bit unhinged so I'm a bit uneasy entertaining this fantasy even though I originally raised it :)
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by dzonga on Thursday October 28, 2021 @03:46AM
(#29023474)
they do. and linked article also mentions the us spies on their allies and reverse is true also.
which means spy-game is know your enemy, know your friend and treat them the same way, with suspicion.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by silisili on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:21AM
(#29022657)
> Most people who betray their country are not thinking rationally, or they would not be involved in such a self-destructive activity. They are driven, in large part, by irrational emotional needs to feel important, successful, powerful or to get even or to take risks. These emotional needs are out of control, so the same emotional needs that lead them to betray also cause them to flaunt their sudden affluence or to brag about their involvement in some mysterious activity. Because they are so mixed up psychologically, they make mistakes that get them caught.
This makes me rather sad. The punishment for espionage is rather severe. That it's explained as essentially a mental illness and lapse of judgement makes me wish we had a better mental health support system and rehab.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by tehjoker on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:24AM
(#29022668)
This is propaganda directed at the public and at the other members of the agencies. Often people have good reasons for doing what they do. For example, Chelsea Manning was accused of espionage for revealing war crimes.
The US has a long history of starting wars on fictional grounds (it's hard to think of one that wasn't after the Civil War, with a possible exception for WW2) and this can lead people that come to realize they were conned to try to get justice.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by silisili on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:49AM
(#29022817)
This aligns with my own ideas, though not directly. Even without a lying, quasi evil govt, society is still to blame.
Designing and forcing folks to live in a society that so idolizes power and money, while seemingly purposefully alienating people from each other and forcing down wages, what would one expect to happen?
In both our examples, the government has failed its people, and they act like it's so egregious that people would do such a thing.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by rand846633 on Thursday October 28, 2021 @12:30AM
(#29022401)
Looked for the publishing date when I read the line with the signal site. I’m sure it’s harder today to find the communication methods of spies when they can use any website.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by boomboomsubban on Thursday October 28, 2021 @04:59AM
(#29023903)
That can also make it easier to find the communication method, as the CIA has a history of leaving their random website communication unencrypted and indexed by Google.
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by rand846633 on Thursday October 28, 2021 @03:02AM
(#29023236)
Every keystroke on every device of every employee with access to sensitive data? Not sure how that would be implemented, do you think all their phones and private devices have some government Spyware running hidden in the background? Could be, but who knows…
Re:How spies are caught (2001)
by rand846633 on Thursday October 28, 2021 @06:08AM
(#29024222)
Sure, you are right. The article basically says: “don’t do it cause we will catch you for sure” & “only people with character flaw as would consider doing it anyways”.
My point was mostly about the mention of catching spies when the approach signal stations.
The tagline: “Justice is in the forecast.”
He has threatened the ice hotel with a heatwave in December - https://www.icehotel.com/
Yeah, I remember the Avengers from before they were cool
If you try to modify the weather without permission, there is a chance that you will have to surrender to a gun-wielding federal officer wearing a NOAA patch.
So, unless your weather modification activities are also violating laws or treaties regarding the use of and access to fisheries, you probably won’t be encountering any NOAA fuzz.
--Probably a career NOAA vet
Coming from a country where only the military and a few police are armed, the concept of armed meteorologists was quite something.
I thought this might have been in response to the Weathermen (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weather_Underground)
1) Army
2) Marine Corps
3) Navy
4) Air Force
5) Space Force
6) Coast Guard
7) Public Health Service Commissioned Corps (aka the Surgeon General)
8) NOAA Commissioned Officer Corps
Apparently this has to do with the fact that both NOAA and PHS commissioned officers operate according to military rules (but are not generally subject to the UCMJ), while USPS employees (even in the Postal Inspection Service) do not. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniformed_services_of_the_Un...)
Specifically, the NOAA Commissioned Corps has its antecedent in Army (never returned after the Civil War) and Navy commissioned officers that worked with its predecessor civilian workers until 1900. There was a couple decades with no uniformed component, but a new and separate uniformed component was created in WWI, because part of the agencies work was battlefield survey, and under the law of war non-uniformed personnel captured doing that job would not be entitled to treatment as POWs, and would likely be executed as spies.
The PHS Commissioned Corps seems to have come about originally because the PHS had an ex-military leader who thought military discipline was a good idea, but it does (among other functions) supply medical officers to serve with both the Coast Guard and the NOAA Commissioned Corps, neither of which (unlike the other uniformed services) have their own, so, I guess that provides some nexus.
https://youtu.be/0TVhxwmNIKQ
Somebody ought to make a film, serious or funny I don't care...
I had to laugh at your wording :) I am picturing someone with a drone carrying a sack of silver iodide suddenly having a very bad day.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28491494
Are they only outputs, or could they be GPIO? What would happen with a giant prism above a cloud?
A very pretty cloud, for sure, Somewhere Over the Rainbow. I just wonder whether the ice crystals could be persuaded to melt quicker, and drop their rain. Cheaper than silver iodide for cloud seeding. I have no idea who to talk to about this, or any clue how to simulate it in a lab.
It's quite unlikely that it would disrupt cyclone, but someone with better fluid mechanics knowledge can probably do such calculation.
So, what is the real answer? I'm not advocating the idea, but why is it not feasible?
2. The heat energy used by a hurricane is roughly equivalent to one Hiroshima per second, which at least reduces the impact of 1., but tells you how large the scale difference is
3. Explosions produce shockwaves which only change instantaneous pressure, and are totally ineffective at changing barometric pressure, the one thing you want to increase, because barometric pressure is the weight of all the air above the ground
4. The storm is now radioactive
I was thinking that a powerful enough explosion may disrupt the winds. And it seemed to be that a disruption of the winds may dissipate a storm. I suppose that the concept of "what a storm is" may not be very clear to the layman, including myself. Until a few minutes ago it seemed to me that a hurricane is just winds going around in a circle.
Ahh got it
For real though, if there was a real problem like that the NOAA would get military backup. The American approach to an immediately urgent problem is to just hurl massive resources at it and (maybe) ask questions later.
Then we can have new conspiracy theories about how real disasters are just being passed off as cool disasters and the rotating cast of supervillains are actually a puppet show from the real villains in the federal reserve.
The speaker finished up with a screenshot from a youtube video where an UFO enthusiast actually followed the aircraft by car and came to the airport to look at it. It didn't help that the aircraft was rented from a company that usually rents to military.
40k views on a video that claims they released radioactive insects on that flight. (It was a spectrometer onboard...) The video is gone now, and we can only speculate what the people behind it think about that. How does one deal with this in a satisfying manner?
40k views on a video about methane emission detection would be amazing! A fraction of those 40k people in the area with knowledge of the problem and the same enthusiasm could probably easily stop all these emissions as well.
(Apart from that.. if anyone wonders.. talk to us! (and please don't seem like a nutjob..) This is research paid by your taxes and on your behalf, and if you come with journalistic interest we might just open the doors and, y'know, let you have a very close look at things.)
They like to portray local vs federal in Hollywood as a trope, but in reality, inter-agency cooperation is (supposed to be) the norm.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1986_FBI_Miami_shootout
BLAM! BLAM!
- I guess you could say he got...blown away ⌐■_■
I suppose most spies are caught, but I've always wondered whether Feynman was a spy. Not based on anything in particular; it's just tantalizing to think that random famous people are actually traitors. We'd never know unless they were caught, after all.
Probably the overwhelming majority of actual spies in the US are not caught, because hardly anybody is even looking. And, the stuff they spy out is in the end mostly inconsequential, except insofar as it causes trouble for other spies.
Because the NOAA has a Division of Security under the Dept. of Commerce umbrella: https://www.commerce.gov/osy/field-offices/national-oceanic-...
The Western Regional Security Office is housed at the NOAA Western Regional Center.
On some level, NOAA is a national security asset, I would think, so it makes sense. Also, they appear to provide security services for other, smaller agencies within the DOC.
It’s sort of like when you find out that both Amtrak and the NIH have tactical response teams: https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-20-710.pdf
(And that’s not even to mention the NOAA uniformed service, which was always a nerdy dream of mine to join… https://www.omao.noaa.gov/learn/noaa-commissioned-officer-co... )
You might even call them an umbrella agency.
1) there's the weather aspect
2) encompassing several responsibilities
3) ?
> Your short course in Treason is a series of articles on how spies are caught, the prevalence of espionage, and why people spy
https://www.wrc.noaa.gov/wrso/mission.htm
> Protects the Department of Commerce and the U.S. Government by collaboration with key leaders, decision-makers, and stakeholders to effectively mitigate security risks.
As a result, I found myself reading the entire page, all the way through to the end.
The parent URL https://www.wrc.noaa.gov/wrso/ Or their about page: https://www.wrc.noaa.gov/wrso/aboutwrso.htm
Seems it's part of the Department of Commerce? But they list one of their their clients as NOAA.
Either way it’d take something extreme to tempt me into this world - like if my country became a fascist dictatorship or something acting against it is at least the morally correct thing to do
Though I wonder why you would care so much about 'your' country? Once you save yourself and your family and friends, oppression and misery anywhere of any human seems about equally bad to me.
This is all going into a hypothetical future I'd rather not spend too much time thinking about. As I said it's fairly unlikely and if I'm honest this is normally the wheelhouse of people who are a bit unhinged so I'm a bit uneasy entertaining this fantasy even though I originally raised it :)
Note. If you are a spy: Don't cheat on your spouse.
"Thank you for applying for xyz spy agency we will get back to you after we processes your application"
I wouldn't be surprised if the USA knew most other governments spys.
This makes me rather sad. The punishment for espionage is rather severe. That it's explained as essentially a mental illness and lapse of judgement makes me wish we had a better mental health support system and rehab.
The US has a long history of starting wars on fictional grounds (it's hard to think of one that wasn't after the Civil War, with a possible exception for WW2) and this can lead people that come to realize they were conned to try to get justice.
Designing and forcing folks to live in a society that so idolizes power and money, while seemingly purposefully alienating people from each other and forcing down wages, what would one expect to happen?
In both our examples, the government has failed its people, and they act like it's so egregious that people would do such a thing.
"with a possible exception for WW2"
You can be as careful and as smart as you like, it won't help you.
Eventually they'll get a whiff of it from someone either close you or a foreign asset. There's statute of limitation, eventually they'll come for you.