News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by humanistbot on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:09PM (#28960518)
From the article:

> The fight between the two companies centers on a 2019 agreement to allow YouTube TV on Roku. Roku said Google demanded special access to search data from Roku customers as a condition of allowing YouTube TV on Roku devices. Roku also said Google asked for prioritized search results for YouTube videos in Roku's search feature.

> Roku said it agreed to those terms, but also asked that Google not ask for any additional data. Google would not commit to that, according to Roku, and now both sides are at an impasse. Unless both companies come to an agreement before Dec. 9, YouTube's apps will disappear from Roku's app store.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by joemi on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:32PM (#28960804)
If that's all it is, it's pretty damning of Google.

It'd be nice if they thought of the users they'd be affecting, but I guess in a way they are, in that they're upset they can't mine those users.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by etempleton on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:04PM (#28962708)
Google denies that they made this request, but recently revealed emails indicate that they did make a request along those lines.

Regardless of this deal, Roku is almost certainly dead in the water. They have limited international penetration and their platform, if you can call it one, is extremely limited compared to Apple, Google, and even Amazon’s offerings and app stores.

I don’t see a path forward at this point for the company. They will continue to have a stream of ad revenue for awhile, but will slowly get squeezed out.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by tyingq on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:04PM (#28963331)
They seem to be doing well in North America: https://9to5google.com/2021/05/03/roku-global-streaming-mark...
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by fgonzag on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:29PM (#28963556)
They have limited international penetration and their platform

Most cheap smart tvs come with roku OS. I wouldn't call that limited penetration.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by etempleton on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:57PM (#28963774)
Most cheap smart TVs in North America.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by nsn90 on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:10PM (#28965349)
also Latin America, where their value offer is strong
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by wmf on Friday October 22, 2021 @07:34PM (#28964116)
Roku is a meta-platform that includes Apple and Amazon and may even be taking a 30% cut of those.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by commoner on Saturday October 23, 2021 @12:56AM (#28965857)
I don't see any evidence that Roku is taking 30% of anything. Roku does not require users to use its own payment system for subscriptions of streaming services, including subscriptions initiated from within the channel.

Roku help page for Apple TV channel: https://support.roku.com/article/360036652634

> If you subscribe to any Apple TV Channels, payment will be charged to your Apple ID account at purchase.

Apple TV channel listing on Roku: https://channelstore.roku.com/details/a20e3c294993147c6cda43...

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by wmf on Saturday October 23, 2021 @06:13PM (#28972884)
You pay Apple then Apple pays Roku.

"brand-specific buttons on its remote controls... $1 per customer for each button ... Roku doesn’t pay anything to the channels it distributes, yet it still takes a share of their ad revenue. ... Roku executives will threaten to cancel a channel if its owner doesn’t give Roku a larger cut of ad sales" https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-12-11/streaming...

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by EastOfTruth on Saturday October 23, 2021 @04:17AM (#28966636)
Do you work for Google, Apple or Amazon?
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by judge2020 on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:58PM (#28962648)
Both sides of the agreement are likely being deceptive in their statements. Google says they never asked for preferential treatment of search, nor access to user data[0], yet Roku says they did.

0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28945280

also see[]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28945250

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by black_puppydog on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:39PM (#28963087)
What you describe really only guarantees that at least one of the two is being deceptive.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by TwiceCubed on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:50PM (#28963196)
"Both sides" meaning "both sides of Google's lying mouth".
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by rnd0 on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:06PM (#28963342)
Most likely but that doesn't exclude the possibility that Roku is dissembling as well.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by jmondi on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:24PM (#28960689)
My solution? Jellyfin and yt-dlp with an easy to use web ui -- https://github.com/alexta69/metube
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by cdurth on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:03PM (#28962699)
Thanks for sharing this! Recently started using youtube-dl's built in channel scraping but it is clunky and slow. Few months ago ads on youtube app on Roku went from aprx 1 per 10 minutes to every 3 minutes. Had enough of that and started scraping my subscriptions to Plex
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by Fervicus on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:28PM (#28960748)
Switched from Plex to Jellyfin a couple of years ago and very happy with it!
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by ryanmcbride on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:26PM (#28962306)
I'm a really big plex fan but I've never heard of Jellyfin. What triggered your switch?
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by Ardon on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:54PM (#28962609)
I'm not that guy but I made the same switch.

It's mostly that I despised the way that, fundamentally, plex was in control of what user saw when they first logged in. They kept adding bs and less technical users kept feeling like the rug was pulled out from under them when a bunch of stuff would change.

Jellyfin doesn't give me the control I'd like to have, but it does give me what I consider essential. This may improve when the team transitions to a from-scratch web client[1] rather than the forked-from-emby client.

[1] https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin-vue

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by handrous on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:01PM (#28962683)
Not a Plex user but I switched from Kodi because I've always hated Kodi's UI, and just suffered it for lack of anything better (no, alternative skins don't help, both because most of them are half-broken, and because most of what I dislike seems to be baked into the essential structure of their UI).

Gone back and forth between it and just running a simple desktop with VLC connected to a TV, for many years.

Happy Jellyfin user for... oh, two or three years now. I use it with the Roku app, and sometimes in a browser.

It's got some rough edges, but nothing like Kodi.

One thing I really like is that I can just run it directly on my file server. An absolute breeze to get it running in Docker. I'm a very lazy sysadmin when I'm on my own time, so I've even been relying on Docker to handle restarts and such—didn't touch Systemd at all. This isn't exactly best practice but I get it "for free" and it's yet to fail. If it does, well, it's not like it's a big deal. Kodi samba shares to play remote media have always sucked to set up, but this instead provides an API for clients to browse and then stream one video remotely—the clients don't need any form of actual access to the files (I think there are ways to set Kodi up like that, too, so you've got it two places and one's just playing media from the other, but the last thing I wanted was even more complexity in my Kodi set-up and config process)

Being able to hop on a browser anywhere and edit config and media metadata is so very much nicer than trying to do it on a TV. The in-browser UI's also pretty damn good for watching stuff.

I haven't tried it, but I understand there's a plugin for Kodi that lets you play your Jellyfin library through it. If I ever set up Kodi again, for some reason, that's exactly what I'll do. No "native" file access in Kodi, just a thin frontend for Jellyfin.

Somewhere on my long list of shit I'll never actually get around to doing is writing a Jellyfin browser & player "core" for Retroarch. Now that would be perfect.

[EDIT] Oh, I like its account management way better than Kodi's, too. Very easy to configure (through the browser, like nearly everything else). My kids have access to one set of content, my wife and I each have an account with access to everything, so our "watched" statuses don't interfere for stuff we watch on our own time. It's great.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by jmondi on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:21PM (#28963497)
Jellyfin is a completely open source and community driven fork of Emby, which was a rebrand of "Media Browser" way back in the day.

Plex is just creepy, doing things like requiring you to sign up and log in through their web portal instead of using the local plex server. Even before the [onslaught of money put into it recently](https://techcrunch.com/2021/04/14/plex-raises-50m-growth-rou...) Plex did weird things requiring you to ping their servers. I imagine this is going to increase tenfold over the next few years. Gotta hit those KPI's after all.

Overall, Jellyfin does not have the shine that Plex has. As a user of Jellyfin since day 1, it is getting better and better every day. At this point, the only platform that doesnt have a Jellyfin app that I really wish it did was PlayStation.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by hbcondo714 on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:51PM (#28962577)
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by Fervicus on Saturday October 23, 2021 @04:04AM (#28966585)
It's been a while, but I remember running into lots of weird playback and subtitle issues with Plex, like the media getting stuck when I would pause it etc. It felt very bloated. Jellyfin on the other hand has worked like a charm out of the box so far.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by ryanmcbride on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:05PM (#29006247)
Now that you mention it I tend to get the occasional buffering issue too. My main usecase for plex is sharing my library with my friends, does jellyfin have an easy way of doing that?
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by ZetaZero on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:33PM (#28960812)
How do I then watch downloaded videos on my Roku? Am I missing something?

EDIT: So there is a companion Jellyfin app for Roku

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by jmondi on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:24PM (#28963521)
Yep just watch the videos through the [Jellyfin Roku app](https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin-roku)
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by handrous on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:11PM (#28962782)
Jellyfin user, this looks very much like something I've wanted. How's Jellyfin do with finding metadata for these sorts of files? Getting the full title, date published, grouping by creator, anything like that? I'm pretty sure TVDB has listings for some long-running and fairly famous Youtube series, but it'd be nicer to have a general solution that worked for any Youtube video that Jellyfin finds. Plus getting it to find Youtube video metadata by TVDB entry would probably require some manual filename & folder structure editing.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by darknavi on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:45PM (#28963138)
Still a bit clunky but I self-host tubesync and it works pretty well:

https://github.com/meeb/tubesync

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by jmondi on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:23PM (#28963512)
I tried https://github.com/alexmerkel/archivetube but it was not a great experience.

I felt that keeping it in Jellyfin and grabbing metadata using https://github.com/ankenyr/jellyfin-youtube-metadata-plugin was nicer. Plus way more client support than just a web browser.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by a10c on Saturday October 23, 2021 @12:49AM (#28965817)
While we're on the topic, have a look at TubeArchivist

https://github.com/bbilly1/tubearchivist

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by meeby on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:24AM (#28986198)
It'll get less clunky in the future when I get some time to fix a few bits and bobs, honest!
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by mattl on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:10PM (#28965033)
How do you get this working on the Roku device?
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by mig39 on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:13PM (#28960573)
See also:

Roku tells customers it is unable to strike a deal with YouTube -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28943886

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by yumraj on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:27PM (#28962315)
Few years ago when YouTube app was removed from Fire TV, it had turned out to be a major blessing in disguise.

It basically cured my kid’s addiction to YT’s junk/addictive content for young kids.

I’m sure this so benefit at least some people in a similar fashion.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by vlunkr on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:11PM (#28962786)
I'm certainly looking forward to it. There's good content for kids on youtube, but it's drowning in a sea of low quality or downright creepy imitations, and I don't think the algorithm can tell the difference. And the ads aren't much better.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by Koshkin on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:57PM (#28963269)
OTOH because YT is an invaluable resource for learning, it’s also a big loss for the kid.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by drewg123 on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:55PM (#28961126)
Roku should do an official port of NewPipe(1) or SmartTubeNext (1) to its platform and install them by default.

(1) These are alternative YouTube clients that block youtube ads, and STN even has sponsorblock.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by judge2020 on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:29PM (#28962974)
Both of these generally break the TOS of YouTube[0], which means Roku distributing such software could be considered breaking the CFAA and/or helping their customers do so. Besides that, Roku isn't some small OSS project - their previous deal with YouTube likely means Google could revel in having real damages to bring against Roku for lost ad revenue during the entire time the YouTube app was removed and replaced with a version that doesn't show ads or shows less relevant ads.

0: https://www.youtube.com/static?template=terms#:~:text=circum... "Permissions and Restrictions" (2)

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by Pet_Ant on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:44PM (#28960946)
There needs to be ways ensuring that content remains a commodity and does not enable rent-seeking. Imagine where we would be today if each television station had it's own antenna and encoding just to seek more profit.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by Spivak on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:34PM (#28961611)
Wait what? Content has never been a commodity and copyright is by definition rent-seeking just without the negative connotations.

You might mean content distribution but that's really never been a commodity either. Even though it sorta kinda feels like you can buy "cable" from lots of companies that's only because each company independently negotiated contracts for all their channels. Physical distribution -- B&N/Blockbuster/Record Stores (and OG DVD Netflix) is the closest thing you could call commodity content distribution.

But we kinda ruined open internet distribution early early on with DRM and locked-down clients which put platform owners in a similar spot to cable companies and so here we are.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by xg15 on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:23PM (#28962906)
> copyright is by definition rent-seeking just without the negative connotations

> But we kinda ruined open internet distribution early early on with DRM and locked-down clients

DRM is nothing more than an enforcement mechanism for existing copyright though. So that's a bit like saying "copyright is a great thing as long as it only exists on paper".

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by colinmhayes on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:50PM (#28961819)
Facebook and Google have made content a commodity. That's the entire point of aggregators.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by arenaninja on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:21PM (#28961463)
I've been waiting for a device to smarten up my TVs so the kids can stream on it but without YouTube. If google goes through with this I will buy some Rokus :)
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by SllX on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:02PM (#28961994)
Just out of curiosity, and feel free to ignore this question if you’d rather not say, but why something specifically without YouTube, but presumably other streaming apps?
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by strombofulous on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:44PM (#28962513)
Search for a period (just ".") and pick any of the things youtube recommends (don't press enter on your "." query). These are the kinds of videos it tends to suggest to kids. Someone else posted a detailed explanation on why but tldr is that kids are curious about things that they don't understand and adults exploited this curiosity.

Edit: And also this trick is known by a lot of kids according to a friend I have that works at a public school

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by croutonwagon on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:09PM (#28964701)
Yeah that was a lot crazier than I would have imagined snd I do a fair bit of YouTube. I cleared my search history after that though. Yeesh
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by dmitrygr on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:32PM (#28963014)
oh wow. Never tried this. Lots of very very weird things, like this (do not click): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xB910KU0myQ
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by SllX on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:22PM (#28981049)
That’s insane!
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by arenaninja on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:50PM (#28974183)
Like everybody else here said, YouTube is the wild west with zero content curation and shit moderation. My 4 year old loved this gaming channel on my one smart TV with a YouTube app, I saw a few episodes with him and it was all normal gamer stuff with reactions. Now I banned him from watching YouTube because that channel started doing reviews of games inspired by Squid Game (if you haven't watched it, it's essentially violence porn)

I had the same problem with my elder kid, YouTube is to kids what Facebook is to the aging population and Tiktok is to teens, an uncurated poison. But kids lack the ability to filter their own content, and YouTube makes no effort to curate. He complains he can't watch it anymore but when I stream kid-appropriate content from the other streaming platforms he'll watch it without further complaint

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by SllX on Sunday October 24, 2021 @03:19PM (#28981025)
Thanks! I am without kids so would have overlooked or never encountered this, but this is still solid intel for the future.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by op00to on Friday October 22, 2021 @07:02PM (#28963814)
YouTube is particularly addictive and damaging to children. There is very little content protection over whatever AI bullshit YouTube does.

My kids never cried for Netflix, Hulu, or Disney+, but when I banned YouTube they CRIED.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by hbn on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:34PM (#28962402)
It's pretty reasonable, and smart I'd say. The kids content on YouTube has been heavily gamed by content farms optimizing content for SEO, making absolutely bizarre and sometimes disgusting content.

Bit of a lengthy watch, but this video is pretty eye-opening:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LKp2gikIkD8

(It's a few years old at this point, but not a lot has changed, and possibly has gotten worse)

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by sgtfrankieboy on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:08PM (#28962095)
Not OP. My guess is because YouTube offers user uploaded content, unlike all the other streaming services like Netflix, Disney+
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by massysett on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:35PM (#28962407)
The crap that's on YouTube makes the cable TV networks targeted at kids look like educational television. Horrid stuff with kids shooting off their mouths.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by pixelbath on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:22PM (#28962257)
The article says this is "the latest battle between a Big Tech giant and a smaller technology firm." Roku is a technology spin-off of Netflix that went public on its own and last year reported revenue of nearly a billion dollars.

Sure, Roku is "smaller" than Google, but I disagree with the characterization of Roku as some poor upstart that's getting ground underfoot by Big Tech.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by chmod775 on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:24PM (#28962281)
Google at this point is just coasting along on its old reputation, while consistently behaving in a way one might expect from the Microsoft of old.

Doing a thing, getting called out, and then lying - only to get bitten by a leaked paper trail is such a Microsoft thing to do.

Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by throwawaysea on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:28PM (#28961534)
Roku could do the world a favor by featuring newer alternate video sharing platforms, particularly decentralized ones. It could also make it clear why they’re offering them and rally users to their support.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by Koshkin on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:04PM (#28963329)
Too bad - after the YouTube app had silently disappeared from my Apple TV, I had to dig up my ancient Roku so I could continue to enjoy it. A mini-PC to the rescue, I guess…
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by LocalH on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:32PM (#28963585)
Literally Cable 2.0. Fuck these assholes, both of them. Neither of them has clean hands
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by greatgib on Friday October 22, 2021 @07:00PM (#28963799)
Here people can see how Google is a sucker for your data...
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by sergiotapia on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:48PM (#28962549)
Roku should add Odysee to their platform, and dethrone youtube already. Time for decentralized solutions.
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by nimfan on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:43PM (#28963122)
Re:YouTube is about to pull its apps from Roku by tyingq on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:16PM (#28961398)
So Google will have to tell their users to side-load the app on the Roku. Just like anyone booted from the Android App store. (yes, the Roku does have sideloading, though you can sideload only one app at a time.).