News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by danuker on Friday October 15, 2021 @01:39PM (#28880557)
> there was never more than $61.5 million backing Tether, even as more 442 million coins were circulating at one point.

Ah, pulling the classic "fractional reserve" I see.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by pfisherman on Friday October 15, 2021 @01:53PM (#28880766)
<insert crypto rant> fiat <more crypto rant > debasing the currency.

What I find ironic is that the crypto ecosystem still ended up with something like central banks, only in this case their mandate is make money for its owners, and they have no accountability or obligation to serve the general public.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by bko on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:29PM (#28882788)
The difference is I can choose not to hold Tether. Removing my exposure to dollars as a US citizen is a lot harder. Not to mention people that are on a fixed income like my parents. So debasing fiat is a lot worse
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by itsoktocry on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:31PM (#28883894)
>The difference is I can choose not to hold Tether. Removing my exposure to dollars as a US citizen is a lot harder.

Did you miss the part about them lying?

"I have a right to choose to buy something" for whom the value is deceptively obfuscated is quite the argument.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by roenxi on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:19PM (#28884237)
If the US Fed lies, do they get fined?

Pretty sure the answer is no, because they have so much power they don't need to lie. They do what they like then change the rules so they can do the same thing legally.

The argument here isn't that what Tether is going is good (it isn't). It is that if the government did it, it would come with "and all you plebs have to join in because bankers making money is good for us all".

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by spywaregorilla on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:39PM (#28882894)
That is part of being part of the society, yes.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by anm89 on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:09PM (#28883163)
So is having the right to hold other currencies and assets.

Tell that to an Argentinian who has had their life ruined because of the lack of foresight from the the people who run their society.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by floatingatoll on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:12PM (#28883188)
Incorrect, no such right is necessarily guaranteed by societies. For example, during much of the 1900s you were required to sell gold to the US government for USD rather than keep it under your mattress, and if you refused they had the right to seize it with force. For another example, negative savings interest rates in certain European countries.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by waterhouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:34PM (#28883368)
> during much of the 1900s you were required to sell gold to the US government for USD rather than keep it under your mattress, and if you refused they had the right to seize it with force

Many considered this a violation of their rights. Justly so. I would say that "no such right is necessarily guaranteed" is only true in the sense that no rights at all are necessarily guaranteed.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by floatingatoll on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:45PM (#28884673)
That's nice, but regardless, the law stood for forty years, even surviving the Supreme Court^.

Society abrogates individual rights by its very existence, and anarchic utopias that exclude all abrogation tend to fail comically^^ and/or catastrophically^^^. It turns out that compromise is a necessary factor of coexistence with other human beings, especially those we disagree with. If you don't feel that your rights are being abrogated by society in some regard, then you either are unfamiliar with the unconscious rights we all take for granted, and/or your circumstances align with the corruption that rich and well-connected people benefit from.

In the US, the Constitution guarantees you specific and inalienable rights, and lays out clear terms that the government is not permitted to violate without consequence. While corruption exists, and no constitution is ever written or enforced perfectly, your declaration that no rights are guaranteed is incorrect for US citizens in the US. Other countries have similar guarantees of rights, such as the EU and GDPR, not to mention many older ones as well, so that statement is incorrect in various ways for those as well. Societies vary wildly in who is granted rights and what rights those are and when they may be abrogated without consequence. Corruption is endemic to virtually all modern societies, small and large. Regardless, rights are granted in most of them.

I respect those that feel that their rights are violated by the laws of the society they are members of, but that is no excuse to declare provably false statements ("no rights at all") as if they're facts. You'll need to invest more effort in your arguments to make headway with that declaration, or define what "rights" means to you that lets you declare that you have none, or declare that the society you are a member of does not guarantee you personally any rights whatsoever.

^ For example: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/294/330

^^ For example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28441794

^^^ A popular counterexample is an Icelandic system of government from a thousand years ago, frequently held up as an example of libertarian utopia that lasted for centuries. However, the governmental laws that implemented the godord specifically abrogated the rights of the citizens of Iceland, binding them without individual consent to the societal system of godords, laws, courts, judgments, and enforcements. If you ignored the judgment of the courts, you were stripped of your societal right to live; anyone could kill you without being punished for doing so. Ironically, this meant that in this ancient system, societal outlaws were truly freed from all abrogations of their rights, as they were cast out from society as a whole. However, being marked for murder by those who do accept societal abrogations tends to diminish the enjoyment somewhat.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by waterhouse on Saturday October 16, 2021 @12:23AM (#28885530)
A relatively recent large-scale case from the U.S. that comes to mind is the internment of Japanese-Americans. I'm not sure if I can point to a specific Constitutional amendment that it violated (4th amendment on seizing a person without probable cause? Probably 9th amendment, that there are are additional rights not enumerated), but I think most declarations of rights cover a right to liberty unless one is charged with a crime or other strictly limited exceptions, and it seems clear that the Japanese internment violated that.

Interestingly enough, the Supreme Court of the time seems to have upheld part of what was done to the Japanese-Americans[1]. "In effect, the two rulings held that, while the eviction of American citizens in the name of military necessity was legal, the subsequent incarceration was not"[2]. About the first ruling, Wiki says: "Chief Justice John Roberts explicitly repudiated the Korematsu decision in his majority opinion in the 2018 case of Trump v. Hawaii. The case is often cited as one of the worst Supreme Court decisions of all time."

We haven't gotten as far as large-scale violations in the U.S. of a right to not be killed by official government policy (death penalty notwithstanding). (Also notwithstanding the FDA delaying the introduction of lifesaving drugs.) It has certainly happened in other countries, though. In the small scale, the U.S. government does sometimes assassinate individuals, and seems not too squeamish about killing whoever else is in the blast radius (some may protest that those people aren't citizens). I would admit it's pretty unlikely they'll go that far on this particular right (in the absence of a revolution), but for the majority of rights, it seems there will be circumstances where politicians will plead "emergency" as a reason to violate them, and often enough will get their way.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korematsu_v._United_States

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America...

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dragonwriter on Saturday October 16, 2021 @06:10AM (#28886773)
> We haven’t gotten as far as large-scale violations in the U.S. of a right to not be killed by official government policy

If you ignore the genocide of Native Americans, which in many cases did not stop once those Native Americans accepted US government jurisdiction, maybe.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by anm89 on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:18PM (#28883790)
And yet, I still hold those other things.

Many people told that society where to shove it when they came to repossess their assets by force.

If you are trying to explain why I owe some debt to society to support their currency you aren't making a very convincing argument.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by floatingatoll on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:56PM (#28884726)
It's up to you how to interpret the law, and it's up to the justice system and/or law enforcement and/or military to decide to punish you if it disagrees with your interpretation of the rules of society. I am not you, I am not your lawyer (this is not legal advice), and I am not a member of a societal authority such as those above; therefore, I have no viewpoint on whether you specifically owe some debt to society or not. You'll need to resolve that yourself or with the cooperation of your lawyer.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by 8note on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:23PM (#28884252)
The government however has the right to demand you pay taxes in a certain currency, regardless of which currency or assets you're holding
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by frankbreetz on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:24PM (#28883278)
I believe a tether collapse would have a significant effect on the entire cryptocurrency ecosystem
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by headmelted on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:59PM (#28883612)
This is the big question mark, and why I sigh when people shrug it off.

How much of the demand for these tokens is being driven by money that never really existed? 100%? 50%? 0.02%?

There’s no way of knowing until it crashes - then what? e.g. if the price dives by 50%, and that really equates to 200% of the actual capital ever invested, what happens then?

I was listening to Darknet Diaries episode 102 today about the Canadian money printer, and I was thinking the entire way through it that it was basically describing tether but with paper and ink.

It got especially eye-opening when he talked about having to manage how it was released into circulation slowly so as no-one could track where it was coming from.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by kaashif on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:46PM (#28883512)
It would at least open the door to more regulation, not to mention prudence on the parts of investors. I can't escape the feeling some of these risks aren't being priced in properly.

I don't think very many average people are invested in crypto significantly, if at all, despite the hype, so hopefully the harm would be limited.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by fancifalmanima on Saturday October 16, 2021 @12:32AM (#28885573)
^ This is the reason why more folks in crypto should be worried about and enraged by tether. Inevitably, there will be a market condition that leads to tether being insolvent. And when that day comes the people that get hurt will be every day crypto holders. The people running tether will run off with many, many millions of dollars and many will wonder how the heck this happened. And it'll lead to regulation. And centralization.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by creepto on Saturday October 16, 2021 @01:22AM (#28885754)
It would be a crash of epic proportions.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by tmcw on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:23PM (#28884255)
Most people didn't own money market accounts or buy collateralized debt obligations in 2008, but the collapse of those things, ahem, affected them.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by 8note on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:21PM (#28884244)
You only need to change citizenships to get off the dollar. It's a package deal
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dragonwriter on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:10PM (#28882574)
> What I find ironic is that the crypto ecosystem still ended up with something like central banks, only in this case their mandate is make money for its owners, and they have no accountability or obligation to serve the general public

So, like private currency-printing banks before government monopolies (and like private banks, which subject to central regulation still create money though they don't print currency), not like central banks.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by majormajor on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:43PM (#28883992)
> So, like private currency-printing banks before government monopolies (and like private banks, which subject to central regulation still create money though they don't print currency), not like central banks.

Yes, nothing prevents a crypto bank from "creating money" (aka lending) in the same way that a fiat bank does. Loan out your deposits. It's that easy.

Not having it blow up on you in a run-on-the-bank scenario is the harder part than "creating the money". ;)

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by jayd16 on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:31PM (#28883350)
But the point of the article is that they essentially did print currency, no?
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dragonwriter on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:36PM (#28883403)
The point of the article is rather that they violated the rules on creation of “money” [0] by means other than issuing legal-tender currency, and are being punished for that violation.

[0] viewed broadly, but I won't quibble about that.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by DennisP on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:04PM (#28880908)
Play centralized games, win centralized prizes.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by rgrieselhuber on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:54PM (#28884072)
Exactly.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by OneLeggedCat on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:53PM (#28881575)
> crypto ecosystem still ended up

It's decades from its final form.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by rzwitserloot on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:26PM (#28882004)
Perhaps. But we're, what? 10 years in and so far crypto has enabled 'I encrypted your data!' scams, caused political instability, been a vehicle for highly volatile investment (but the world wasn't hurting for such opportunities...), and served as a fine buzzword for dev teams around the world to get a sack of cash to update some systems.

That's a pretty poor result for 10 years of this much investment and focus. The internet was waaaaaaaaaaaaay more useful 10 years in.

I don't think crypto gets to claim the benefits of the oft touted protection against centralized bullies or scams. Quite the opposite: You need to go pretty deep into political dictatorships before crypto on net balance seems favourable. So far crypto coins are far more likely to be fleeced, and the vast majority of crypto holding folks are working with mostly centralized entities (such as Tether), which rate, as far as trustability and good shepherdship goes, not in a good place. Better than Pol Pot and Mugabe. Maybe.

Oof.

So if it's decades from its final form, when is it going to deliver on its first actually useful to humanity milestone? I'm still waiting.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:39PM (#28883436)
> I don't think crypto gets to claim the benefits of the oft touted protection against centralized bullies or scams.

The big problem here is that the core benefit of cryptocurrency is in removing the bank as a middle man. But the bank is the chokepoint where governments impose constraints.

When you're up against an authoritarian government imposing unreasonable constraints, that's what you need. But it works the same against any constraints. So if you want constraints on "money laundering" or processing transactions related to criminal activity, those constraints are gone too.

The constraints are already gone for anyone willing to break the law. You can't un-invent Bitcoin, so from here on drug dealers will be able to use it or something like it to transfer their drug money etc. That's happened, it's in the past, no regulations you put on law-abiding people will undo it because the people doing it are already the people breaking the law.

We still have all the regulations. They just don't work anymore. We're still paying the cost and the benefit has evaporated. But for all the honest people who are following the law, the regulations still apply. The overhead is still there. All the paperwork and the false positives.

So you can use Bitcoin to buy drugs but you can't use it to buy a sandwich, because to accept Bitcoin the sandwich shop would have to deal with filing fees and lawyers that the drug dealer is just ignoring. Regular people don't get the benefit until we have a regulatory system that makes it as easy to accept cryptocurrency as it is to accept cash.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by clusterfish on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:13PM (#28883741)
You can't uninvent Bitcoin but you can certainly make it illegal, making it all but useless for drug trade or money laundering. Nobody needs a currency that you can't exchange for, you know, real currency that you can buy real things with. So although the government doesn't have the power to eliminate Bitcoin, they do have the power to make it useless. I don't think they will though, because guess who is using it for bribes and money laundering?
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:28PM (#28883868)
Making it illegal doesn't affect its utility for illegal activity. Criminals already break the law. It would cause a one-time decline in value but that only matters to speculators. The value would still be non-zero because it's global and there exist places where it isn't illegal.

Even if it was somehow illegal everywhere, the value still wouldn't be zero because of black markets. The drug user uses it to buy drugs, the drug dealer uses it to buy guns, the gun runner uses it to buy stolen art, the fence uses it to buy stolen goods from petty thieves who use it to buy drugs.

Black markets would also exist to exchange it for cash or ordinary commodities so that someone else could get it to buy drugs/guns/art/whatever.

And it has utility over using physical cash or gemstones or bullion in that you can transfer it over the internet.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by Retric on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:19PM (#28884235)
Making it illegal makes it vastly less useful for illegal purposes. Legitimate transactions provide cover, it’s like the difference between a sniper in a forest or an empty parking lot. If your factory selling a truck full of AK-47’s you want to actually be able to buy steel to make more AK-47’s. If bitcoin’s illegal you now need to find a buyer for the guns and another buyer for the bitcoins.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:10PM (#28884513)
The steel mill was probably going to want dollars instead of Bitcoin regardless, so the only difference is that they do the trade for dollars on a black market exchange. This is likely to get folded into the money laundering process anyway -- the Bitcoin goes to unspecified offshore location to get turned into dollars that come back as a clean payment for "consulting services" or what have you.

There is no need for additional "cover" at that point because the illicit transaction is already illicit. If someone just took that Bitcoin and bought a house, the IRS would have questions. It would have to be laundered first. The output of the money laundering process is clean dollars regardless of whether the input is illegal because of the illegal source or illegal because of the illegal source and currency.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by Retric on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:23PM (#28884576)
Do you expect the guy laundering money to accept bitcoins without charging extra? Because if the guy selling bitcoins takes ~10% from the AK-47 buyer and the guy laundering money also takes his ~10% cut for using bitcoins on top of his X% cut for laundering money, suddenly it’s starting to look really unappealing.

The real appeal of bitcoin for illegal purposes is it’s effectively a poor but really cheap way to launder money. Try and deposit even 1 million in cold hard cash and the banking system throws up red flags, liquidate 1 million in bitcoin and that looks significantly more legit at least on the surface. It doesn’t help if you’re under investigation, but then again it’s cheap.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AnthonyMouse on Saturday October 16, 2021 @04:40PM (#28891287)
> Do you expect the guy laundering money to accept bitcoins without charging extra?

That's the entire purpose of using them.

Someone who has a million dollars in physical cash either needs to get someone local to launder it, which might be hard to find or require paying them a thick margin, or they have to find a way to ship a huge amount of physical cash to the place it's being laundered and risk it being seized at border crossings etc.

Someone who has a million dollars in Bitcoin can buy money laundering as a service over the internet from the lowest bidder who has a good reputation. The Bitcoin gets transferred to some place with favorable banking rules, gets liquidated there where it's either not illegal or the local authorities are corrupt, and it comes back as dollars. Since it's possible to do it over the internet, you have competition from all over the world including some favorable jurisdictions, so the margins get smaller than they would be if you had to find someone locally.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by Retric on Sunday October 17, 2021 @07:55AM (#28895811)
Money laundering can’t just be done in an arbitrary location. You need to transfer money back into your country’s banking system while looking legitimate to safely spend it.

Put another way, banks are already operating on digital money that’s the problem.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by mwint on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:31PM (#28883902)
If you can’t trade BTC for USD, you’ll trade it for Yen, and then trade for USD.

Some country will want to cash in on the demand for their currency, and will leave it legal to exchange.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by flipbrad on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:59PM (#28882421)
Don't forget the environmental catastrophe of all that wasted electricity generation, and driving up prices of GPUs.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by matheusmoreira on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:14PM (#28884530)
> when is it going to deliver on its first actually useful to humanity milestone

Technologically speaking, most cryptocurrencies are utterly useless. Bitcoin included. There are some good projects though.

Monero, for example. It allows people to transact without anybody knowing anything about the details of the transaction. Where the money came from, where it's going, how much money was moved. Everything is obfuscated. Block chain analysis is at the very least hard and inconclusive, if not impossible. So it essentially works like digital cash.

This is an invaluable achievement that allows people to reclaim their financial privacy in a world where governments think it's acceptable to surveil everyone.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by bonestamp2 on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:36PM (#28882134)
> so far crypto has enabled 'I encrypted your data!' scams

These scams existed long before crypto. But, crypto currencies are a better solution to international money transfers so of course they became the preferred currencies for these scams.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by lottin on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:00PM (#28884125)
If cryptocurrencies were a better solution, they would have been widely adopted. Instead, they have been adopted by people who can't use real money for one reason or another, e.g. criminals. Which tells us they are a poor substitute for real money.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by exdsq on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:15PM (#28884537)
Or those without decent banking access
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by lottin on Saturday October 16, 2021 @04:42AM (#28886440)
I don't know that one can use crypto without a bank account. Is there a black market where you can buy/sell crypto with/for cash?
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by exdsq on Saturday October 16, 2021 @10:58AM (#28888298)
In several African countries people use their phone credit as a currency to barter and there are trials to use crypto instead with on/off cash ramps in the same way as the phone credit works but with the additional benefit of things like financial records to start building credit scores
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by lottin on Saturday October 16, 2021 @12:46PM (#28889150)
Can you provide a link? None of this makes any sense. Why would anybody buy phone credit and then use that to barter instead of just buying whatever they need directly? How do you build a credit score from a record of transactions? Why do Africans that don't have access to banking are so worried about building a credit score? So many questions...
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by exdsq on Saturday October 16, 2021 @12:52PM (#28889210)
I can give a more complete answer later but here’s a link that looks relevant https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.economist.com/finance-and-e...

Credit scores help introduce micro loans which help with social mobility and is key to bringing communities out of poverty

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by varjag on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:54PM (#28883027)
It took crypto to make them Web scale.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by kbenson on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:24PM (#28883282)
If that's the trend, by the time it reaches it's final form we'll all be smoking husks left over from the great AI uprising wars, but don't judge those AIs too harshly, that new testnet that paid out for verified kills was just too good to pass up.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by tmcw on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:24PM (#28884264)
Give it a few decades, it'll still be early, somehow.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by ChainOfFools on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:40PM (#28882173)
decentralization is at best nothing more than a polite name for the transition period from one centralized regime to another.

like all mirages, it dissolves when you get too close.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by matheusmoreira on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:04PM (#28884479)
Yeah, it sucks. The problem is USD though. It taints everything it touches but people are still forced to use it. People use cryptocurrencies as an investment and convert to fiat in order to transact. They refuse to transact directly in cryptocurrencies.

They would work if some country was crazy enough to sell barrels of oil for cryptocurrency, indirectly setting the price of everything else. That will probably get them invaded and destroyed by the US military for threatening the hegemony of the petrodollar.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dylan604 on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:35PM (#28882116)
> their mandate is make money for its owners,

Isn't this pretty much the description of every company? I understand feduciary responsibilities blah blah, but if the company didn't think they could do both then they wouldn't be running the legitimate buisness. If it was started to intentionally dupe people that's an entirely different thing.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by pfisherman on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:59PM (#28882416)
Objectives and incentives are extremely powerful drivers of mass behavior in large organizations. Maximizing profit is a much different objective that contributing to the social good. That is why some functions are best fulfilled by non profits and government.

There world is full of cases where products or services are degraded in order to maximize profit. Has DRM ever made for a better gaming experience? Do clickbait articles result in a better informed public?

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dragonwriter on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:16PM (#28882633)
> Isn't this pretty much the description of every company?

Which is why we don't let private companies create currency willy-nilly anymore.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by heurisko on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:47PM (#28882974)
> Which is why we don't let private companies create currency willy-nilly anymore.

As I understand, private banks extend loans, which while not being printing money, the loans being deposits (which can be withdrawn) the effect of creating currency is the same.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by simonh on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:07PM (#28883150)
Issuing tether was basically an unregulated bank loan system. With a regular loan the created money is destroyed when you repay it. In theory that would happen to the tether when you redeem it for dollars. The problem is really just that tether was lying about how they were operating.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by rsj_hn on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:56PM (#28883045)
Correct, for the non-financial sector, "money" is currency in circulation (created by the government) and then liabilities of the financial sector (created by the private sector). This is true regardless of whether they are checking accounts, savings accounts, certificates of deposit, money market mutual funds, etc. It's all private money and we not only allow it but we subsidize and encourage it.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by majormajor on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:52PM (#28884058)
Private banks can only extend loans so much as they have the money already.

Yes, it's a juggling act: Person A still has $1000 on the ledger in their deposit even if the bank lends $800 of that to Person B, so if the people with deposits want to cash out all at the same time, and the bank can't pull back what they've lended out fast enough, you have big problems!

But they aren't just adding numbers to a cell in a spreadsheet without having the money to back it - a loan that can't be used to pay someone or to be turned into cash is useless. You can't just start a bank and issue yourself a thousand dollars into your own account and expect to be able to use it for anything. This would be closer to the credit card model - short term credit without taking deposits, making money on the repayment - but again, good luck issuing yourself your own credit card to buy a bunch of stuff with to "create money."

And they also aren't doing anything that couldn't be done with crypto!

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by heurisko on Saturday October 16, 2021 @03:12AM (#28886142)
> Yes, it's a juggling act: Person A still has $1000 on the ledger in their deposit even if the bank lends $800 of that to Person B

Fractional reserve banking isn't up-to-date with the modern banking system, where in many cases, like in the UK, and in the US as of 2020, there are no reserve requirements. [1]

> But they aren't just adding numbers to a cell in a spreadsheet without having the money to back it

I disagree; this is the reality. Banks don't have to wait for deposits to extend loans. When creating a loan involves novel financial instruments to hide or offload the loan's risk, this has caused massive bubbles, as in the 2008 mortgage crisis.

This credit they extend to customers is "broad money" that, while not being created by the central bank, is effectively the same, as it is the deposit for someone else, which can be withdrawn.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_requirement

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by spiralx on Monday October 18, 2021 @07:00AM (#28904157)
No, banks do create money through loans, a bank with zero deposits could still loan out money.

https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-...

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dragonwriter on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:33PM (#28883364)
Lending, and the maintenance of the depository accounts where lent money not withdrawn in cash must end up, is much more tightly regulated than it was in the era of willy-nilly private currency issuance, as well as direct currency issuance itself being reserved for the State.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by lazaroclapp on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:58PM (#28882403)
> Isn't this pretty much the description of every company?

For the most part, sure. But that's the parent's point, I think. Central banks are not companies, they are part of the public financial infrastructure of a nation (or, in the EU case, group of nations).

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by jameshart on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:14PM (#28882607)
> Central banks are not companies

Actually... it's complicated. The Bank of England, for example, was nationalized only in 1946, and it remains technically a company which is owned by the state, not actually part of the government.

In the US, the Fed is... well, it's not a company, but it's also not not a company... or group of companies...

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Reserve_Bank

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by tialaramex on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:33PM (#28884617)
Yeah, the Bank of England even used to offer account services to employees after it was nationalized. Which would be scandalous if we found it in some dubious ex-Soviet republic today, albeit there maybe they're lending the Bank's President $10M with no real security and the Bank of England was offering employees mortgages and similar modest run-of-the-mill secured loans.

The UK owns a whole bunch of banks and entities that would need a banking license if they weren't owned by the government, of which only the Bank of England acts as a central bank, but there are also a bunch of commercial banks in (or at least operating in) the UK that are named after parts of the UK even though they're not owned by the government, including the Bank of Scotland.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dboreham on Friday October 15, 2021 @11:07PM (#28885221)
See also: Bank of America

But they can't issue banknotes, unlike BoS and RBoS.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by tialaramex on Saturday October 16, 2021 @10:36AM (#28888165)
To be fair, unlike Tether, the Bank of Scotland actually does hold actual cash worth the same as the notes they issue.

Also, although these banks have permission to issue notes (whereas if you went around issuing "bank notes" you'd likely get arrested) the notes aren't necessarily worth anything except in the sense that you can assume the Banks will give you Bank of England notes for them if it came to it since they're required to hold those.

They aren't legal tender (Scotland doesn't really bother having legal tender laws anyway) and retailers can choose not to accept them if they want. You won't have a problem exchanging them for tourist stuff in Edinburgh or buying a fish supper in Dundee, but good luck getting some random corner store owner down South in Cornwall or Essex to accept them - even though these notes are in some sense worth the same as Bank of England notes, there is no law requiring retailers to accept any notes and so they might just tell you to fuck off with your weird-looking money.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dragonwriter on Saturday October 16, 2021 @06:12AM (#28886790)
The decision-making body of the Federal Reserve System – the thing that sets monetary policy, among other things – is a government agency (the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve.)

The rest of the system is, as you note, complicated, but the rest of the system doesn’t set monetary policy.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by lmkg on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:21PM (#28881125)
On the initial headline I thought that $41 million would be negligible compared to the central role they have in the crypto ecosystem. But apparently that fine is 2/3 of their backing reserves.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by boole1854 on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:37PM (#28882141)
Correction: it is 2/3rds of what their reserves were back in 2017. The amount of Tether in circulation has increased over 150-fold since then, so presumably their reserves have increased as well.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by delecti on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:49PM (#28882285)
> The amount of Tether in circulation has increased over 150-fold since then, so presumably their reserves have increased as well.

They just got punished for not having actual reserves match their circulation. What basis is there to presume that their reserve is matching their circulation now?

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by jyrkesh on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:16PM (#28882643)
Even worse, they just took the opportunity to pay off the govt to avoid disclosing exactly to what extent they lied.

At this point, what basis is there to presume that their reserve is non-zero?

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by 35fbe7d3d5b9 on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:11PM (#28882585)
https://tether.to/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/tether_assuranc...

This all boils down to two questions in my mind:

1) Do you trust the unsigned report from the auditor, who appears to be a fairly unknown entity?

2) Do you trust the asserted quality of the commercial paper, which makes up 50% of the putative reserves?

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by FireBeyond on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:32PM (#28884614)
This is not an audit. That's why it says "Accountant's Report". Because a real accountancy firm/auditor would risk their ability to practice by calling it something it's not.

The last time Tether claimed to have something that was an "actual" audit, they claimed they couldn't release it to the public because ...

"... it is in Mandarin".

Here's the big problem with this attestation:

> Our opinion is limited solely to the CRR and the corresponding consolidated total assets and consolidated total liabilities as of 30 June 2021, at 11:59 PM UTC. Activity prior to and after this time and date was not considered when testing the balances and information described above.

They're very, and repeatedly clear that this is a snapshot. There is nothing stopping Tether taking a 72 hour loan before this attestation and then closing that loan after it.

They claim $6B in cash holdings, in an undisclosed bank, presumably Deltec, whose "deputy CEO" demonstrated in an interview (among other problems) that he did not know the names of the two banking licenses available to banks in that country, and he wasn't sure which one they had.

You can't get a mortgage with a simple attestation of funds - why should it be okay for these guys?

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by sgpl on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:50PM (#28883533)
While I wouldn't say that their reserve is matching now ( I do not know) there were a few threads on twitter that I read a while back that stated that the folks behind tether were increasing the supply (of tether) to artificially inflate the value of their bitcoin holdings - which is something that they could have liquidated in exchange for more fiat since then. Obviously this is all conjecture.

This is the best reference I could find in relation to what I've said above:

In newly published research, with Amin Shams of Ohio State University, he finds evidence that Bitcoin’s 2017–2018 bubble was inflated by a lesser-known digital currency called Tether. [0]

[0] https://medium.com/texas-mccombs/tether-connection-puts-bitc...

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by FireBeyond on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:07PM (#28881784)
Hah. At one point Tether was claiming, during the days where they were holding on to the "1:1 backing!" that they were banking $2 billion A WEEK.

And yet the cryptofans were telling us we were curmudgeons for not buying into the hype (or in this case, the bullshit).

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by zomglings on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:50PM (#28882308)
There has always been a healthy amount of skepticism about Tether in the crypto community. Your cryptofans narrative does not accurately reflect reality.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by chrononaut on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:55PM (#28884422)
Isn't the trouble that Tether substantially influences the solvency of all other stabletokens and the value of cryptocurrencies themselves (in relation to X fiat)?

For example (admittedly this is probably way off-base here), let's say there were only two stablecoins (USDT and USDC), and only one of which had true 1:1 buyback (USDC) where >=1 entity would exchange one USDC for 1 USD (I know the reality of USDC is muddle too). Let's also say the amount of USDT in circulation was $10b and the amount of USDC in circulation was $1b. If there's a well-established "distrust" of USDT, where people only "temporarily" keep it on hand or use it as an intermediary, they're still using it to acquire other cryptocurrency, and thus inflating prices, right? If everyone attempts to exit onto the USDC, the available supply will dry quickly, causing the <X Crypto>/USDC price to plummet (?).

Thus even if you thought Tether was intolerable I feel like it's an implossible belief to simultaneously think (1) that Tether is a scam, and (2) cryptocurrency can be seen a store of value. (I know there are others who recognize and highlight other utilities of cryptocurrencies).

(I am super interested in the flaws in this logic because as an aside, if there's any general reading material regarding these kind of economic thought experiments, doesn't have to even be crypto-related, I will certainly take any recommendations! I find them really fascinating. Someone mentioned a Darknet Diaries episode on counterfeit currency; Probably the first thing I have to look into.)

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by zomglings on Saturday October 16, 2021 @09:34AM (#28887764)
There are three very interesting threads in your comment, as I see them:

1. Tether influencing solvency of other stablecoins.

2. (Tightly related to point 1) Inflation of Tether as it becomes an intermediary.

3. That it is logically inconsistent to view Tether as a scam while also viewing cryptocurrency as a store of value.

Point 3: There is a difference between a store of value and a store of value that is stable with respect to some specific other value.

Consider Bitcoin and Ethereum. The rules by which these blockchains operate are quite transparent. The software is free (as in freedom). Anybody in the world with the means can run a node and participate in these blockchains. Thousands of people are doing so right now. These currencies are open in a sense that no other currency has been open in the entire history of the human race.

Tether on the other hand is completely opaque about its operations. In fact, the people at Tether actively spread misinformation about how Tether operates. It has repeatedly dodged and attempted to fabricates audits of its reserves.

Given all of this, I do not see any logical inconsistency between thinking of Bitcoin and Ethereum as stores of value which is largely orthogonal to the value of the fiat that you hold while simultaneously thinking of Tether as a scam stablecoin whose value is pegged to that of a fiat currency.

Point 1: I agree with you that the existence of Tether improves the solvency of other stablecoins. It reduces the pressure on anyone backing another stablecoin by offering an alternative means of a holder of that stablecoin to realize the dollar value of their stablecoin holdings (albeit with a slight overhead in transaction costs).

I think this is more significant of a factor for centralized stablecoins like USDC than it is for decentralized stablecoins like DAI, although I suspect the existence of USDT puts less pressure on collateralized DAI positions as well.

This is not a compelling reason to encourage or even tolerate the existence of Tether. A true stable coin would not experience any significant difficulties even if Tether became insolvent. I believe that decentralized stablecoins like DAI would only experience negligible effects from Tether's insolvency.

Point 2: This is a very good point and I don't understand it well enough theoretically to confidently make predictions about how it would play out on the market.

My intuition tells me that the most powerful factor against inflating prices of USDC in your scenario is that Coinbase (and the USDC consortium) will stick to their position and always offer $1 in exchange for 1 USDC.

The other factor is that there are many more legitimate stablecoins that could partly fill in the vacuum that Tether would create if it imploded. So not all attention would be focused on USDC. If people really needed a stablecoin, then they would not want to purchase an asset whose value was increasing.

There are a lot of parameters involved, though, and I find this very hard to reason about. Would love any input here.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by SkyPuncher on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:46PM (#28882964)
Yea, I'm on the edge of crypto and I knew that Tether has always been viewed is questionnable.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by bonestamp2 on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:37PM (#28882143)
Some of us who like crypto also knew it was bullshit.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by Kiro on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:55PM (#28882373)
I've never seen a cryptofan defend Tether.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by leppr on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:02PM (#28883634)
Most of the big Bitcoin talking heads did.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by lottin on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:02PM (#28884142)
And still do.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by tastyfreeze on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:20PM (#28883248)
From their website: "Every Tether token is always 100% backed by our reserves, which include traditional currency and cash equivalents and, from time to time, may include other assets and receivables from loans made by Tether to third parties, which may include affiliated entities (collectively, “reserves”)."

They don't claim 1:1 USD backing. They claim that every tether is backed by 1 USD of value. So, when their crypto holdings go up in value, TADA!, more reserves to print tether against. The problem here is they never explain what happens when the value of their backing assets goes down.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by loeg on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:31PM (#28883351)
Their website's claim has changed. Historically, they claimed USD backing: 2015[1] 2016[2] 2017[3] 2018[4]. By 2019, they had abandoned that claim[5].

[1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20150814185145/https://tether.to... "Every tether is always backed 1-to-1, by traditional currency held in our reserves."

[2]: https://web.archive.org/web/20160417000232/https://tether.to... "Every tether is always backed 1-to-1, by traditional currency held in our reserves."

[3]: https://web.archive.org/web/20171201230600/https://tether.to... "Every tether is always backed 1-to-1, by traditional currency held in our reserves."

[4]: https://web.archive.org/web/20180809053152/https://tether.to... "Every tether is always backed 1-to-1, by traditional currency held in our reserves."

[5]: https://web.archive.org/web/20190426055956/https://tether.to... (current language)

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:41PM (#28883455)
Don't worry - like Stonks - Crypto only goes up
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by sneak on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:49PM (#28882986)
I'm sure that the 68.5 billion-with-a-b tethers they have out there now must be backed, though, right?

Surely they learned their lesson when they only had 442 million tethers issued and only 61.5 million dollars in the bank.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by SandB0x on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:30PM (#28881254)
This is simply insolvency, not fractional reserve.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AlexandrB on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:35PM (#28881325)
And yet, they're still operating. This is the kind of thing that makes me think the whole cryptocurrency ecosystem is a house of cards. Cryptocurrency advocates seem to be really bad at spotting and punishing incompetent and malicious actors in their markets.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by TameAntelope on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:06PM (#28881768)
I think if you got a few beers in even the most adamant crypto advocate, you'd discover their thinking is more along the lines of, "The house of cards is out in the open with crypto, vs. hidden behind bureaucracy and obfuscation in traditional banking".

With crypto, the "average" person gets to feel "in on it" in a way usually reserved for coked up Goldman associates. That is possibly not a good thing, as you're pointing out.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by toofy on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:29PM (#28884294)
Sure, but anything which is open about crypto is also open in the financial system. It isn’t “hidden” away, people just don’t do the necessary studying to learn the underlying incredible complexity necessary for an actual world scale financial system.

It’s only hidden in the sense that the definition of “decathect” is hidden. The definition isn’t “hidden”, I just haven’t looked into and learned its definition and i havent considered all the implications of its material interactions with the world yet.

This notion of “hidden” will not be solved by a coin were it to become ubiquitous. People would just have to learn a completely different set of complexities—many of which will actually be hidden by the grifters who take advantage of lack of regulations.

Much of (not all, but much) of this “hidden” argument rests on people who would just prefer simple barter/exchange—but they just don’t seem to understand the complexities that scale inevitably brings. Along with this is that they just don’t understand that crypto is not an answer to the scale complexity problems.

And if someone attempts to make a coin which addresses these complexities, oops, now we’re back to a complex, messy, and steep learning curve.

All of the grifts that we’ve seen throughout society’s history with finance will be repeated in the coin sphere and these people will sadly fall victim to these same grifts yet again.

Does our current financial system have problems? Absolutely. Does crypto solve them without reintroducing previously patched bugs? Nope. Not at all.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by pasabagi on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:08PM (#28883158)
It's a misunderstanding of what the house of cards is about, though.

One of the first empires to use fiat currency was the Yuan dynasty, and it worked, because if your currency is backed by the mongols, you're absolutely going to act as if it makes sense, even if it seems crazy to you. The backing of money is not precious metals, nor currency, but rather force - a state can demand tax in it, and exact retribution if their taxes are not paid. The state could demand taxes in cowries, and people would collect cowries, because you are going to get imprisoned if you don't pay your tax.

The fiat-currency house of cards collapses when people think the state isn't going to be able to pay their bills and collect their dues. Cryptocurrencies are more like tulips. There's nothing behind the curtain - it's just a weird social eddy that's grown out of all proportion.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by dboreham on Friday October 15, 2021 @11:27PM (#28885307)
I prefer beanie babies as an analogy vs tulips.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by chihuahua on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:51PM (#28881542)
In my opinion it's a house of cards (and Ponzi scheme), but combined with the John Maynard Keynes observation that the market can reman irrational longer than you can stay solvent (if you were to bet against it)
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:43PM (#28883466)
Why would they? If you're invested in Crypto - you don't want it to go down. It's better to look the other way while someone is pumping and hope they never start dumping.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by usrusr on Friday October 15, 2021 @04:29PM (#28882796)
While they are not completely divested, self-interest mandates that they still hype what they try to get out of. And after that, they simply don't care and pride discourages them from being vocal about their apparent change of heart. Some might be good at spotting, but they will be excellent at staying quiet about their conclusions.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by ikiris on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:42PM (#28882198)
It's hard to claim someone's specifically malicious / incompetent when the entire "market" is.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by wbsss4412 on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:43PM (#28881436)
It’s really an amazing case study in what happens when* you take libertarian ideology to its conclusion.

Edit: typo*

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by CryptoPunk on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:05PM (#28881752)
Libertarian ideology has resulted in Tether being replaced by USDC in Ethereum DeFi. Your claim is based on the bizarre premise that people are only intelligent when formulating mandates for otherd, while they can only exercis if formulating a course of action for themselves
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by wbsss4412 on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:24PM (#28881978)
> Your claim is based on the bizarre premise that people are only intelligent when formulating mandates for otherd, while they can only exercis if formulating a course of action for themselves

I’m not sure where my statement implied what you are assuming here. I think you may have your dogmatic blinders on.

Both tether, and crypto unrelated to tether are implicated in what I stated. That doesn’t make tether any less a result of libertarian ideology drawn to its conclusion.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by CryptoPunk on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:23PM (#28884257)
The last sentence of my last comment has a mistype. It should be "while they can only exercise naivety when formulating a course of action for themselves."

As for my point, it's pretty simple: the market moves away from tether on its own just as libertarian ideology suggests it would.

Those who use tether are aware of the risks and are choosing to use it anyway, and if they lose money no one will bail them out.

I suggest you reevaluate what you think a libertarian market, where adults are treated like adults and not like children who are subordinate to high up regulators, evolves into.

And really, that's what you're implying: that certain people, should control other people, for their own good, and I find it bizarre that any one would advocate for that when you can see the extreme inequality and dysfunction this approach has produced in traditional finance.

I think it's holding to your belief - not to the belief in a free society - that requires having ideological blinkers on.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by tom-thistime on Friday October 15, 2021 @02:44PM (#28881451)
Insolvency would be a better metaphor than fractional reserve. But I'm guessing* Tether doesn't actually offer to settle up in any reserve currency.

*I think it's a pretty good guess, based on the fact that Tether is still in business.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by SilasX on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:50PM (#28882301)
I think that would be illiquidity -- having only assets that need to be converted, rather than dollars themselves -- rather than insolvency, right?
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by SandB0x on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:35PM (#28883930)
Well that too
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by mortehu on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:30PM (#28883338)
If you read the order, it's clearly about cash reserves (in the financial sense) specifically, and not total underlying assets.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by ceph_ on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:56PM (#28884085)
> 442 million

Current market cap is up to 70 billion! 90% of which has been printed in the last 2 years, and wasn't even covered by the report. Looks like they're going on a last ditch printing spree

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by trident5000 on Friday October 15, 2021 @03:44PM (#28882210)
Depends what that means. Dollar reserve could be low because investment reserve is high. Would need to see the numbers.