News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:39PM (#28883436)
> I don't think crypto gets to claim the benefits of the oft touted protection against centralized bullies or scams.

The big problem here is that the core benefit of cryptocurrency is in removing the bank as a middle man. But the bank is the chokepoint where governments impose constraints.

When you're up against an authoritarian government imposing unreasonable constraints, that's what you need. But it works the same against any constraints. So if you want constraints on "money laundering" or processing transactions related to criminal activity, those constraints are gone too.

The constraints are already gone for anyone willing to break the law. You can't un-invent Bitcoin, so from here on drug dealers will be able to use it or something like it to transfer their drug money etc. That's happened, it's in the past, no regulations you put on law-abiding people will undo it because the people doing it are already the people breaking the law.

We still have all the regulations. They just don't work anymore. We're still paying the cost and the benefit has evaporated. But for all the honest people who are following the law, the regulations still apply. The overhead is still there. All the paperwork and the false positives.

So you can use Bitcoin to buy drugs but you can't use it to buy a sandwich, because to accept Bitcoin the sandwich shop would have to deal with filing fees and lawyers that the drug dealer is just ignoring. Regular people don't get the benefit until we have a regulatory system that makes it as easy to accept cryptocurrency as it is to accept cash.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by clusterfish on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:13PM (#28883741)
You can't uninvent Bitcoin but you can certainly make it illegal, making it all but useless for drug trade or money laundering. Nobody needs a currency that you can't exchange for, you know, real currency that you can buy real things with. So although the government doesn't have the power to eliminate Bitcoin, they do have the power to make it useless. I don't think they will though, because guess who is using it for bribes and money laundering?
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:28PM (#28883868)
Making it illegal doesn't affect its utility for illegal activity. Criminals already break the law. It would cause a one-time decline in value but that only matters to speculators. The value would still be non-zero because it's global and there exist places where it isn't illegal.

Even if it was somehow illegal everywhere, the value still wouldn't be zero because of black markets. The drug user uses it to buy drugs, the drug dealer uses it to buy guns, the gun runner uses it to buy stolen art, the fence uses it to buy stolen goods from petty thieves who use it to buy drugs.

Black markets would also exist to exchange it for cash or ordinary commodities so that someone else could get it to buy drugs/guns/art/whatever.

And it has utility over using physical cash or gemstones or bullion in that you can transfer it over the internet.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by Retric on Friday October 15, 2021 @07:19PM (#28884235)
Making it illegal makes it vastly less useful for illegal purposes. Legitimate transactions provide cover, it’s like the difference between a sniper in a forest or an empty parking lot. If your factory selling a truck full of AK-47’s you want to actually be able to buy steel to make more AK-47’s. If bitcoin’s illegal you now need to find a buyer for the guns and another buyer for the bitcoins.
Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:10PM (#28884513)
The steel mill was probably going to want dollars instead of Bitcoin regardless, so the only difference is that they do the trade for dollars on a black market exchange. This is likely to get folded into the money laundering process anyway -- the Bitcoin goes to unspecified offshore location to get turned into dollars that come back as a clean payment for "consulting services" or what have you.

There is no need for additional "cover" at that point because the illicit transaction is already illicit. If someone just took that Bitcoin and bought a house, the IRS would have questions. It would have to be laundered first. The output of the money laundering process is clean dollars regardless of whether the input is illegal because of the illegal source or illegal because of the illegal source and currency.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by Retric on Friday October 15, 2021 @08:23PM (#28884576)
Do you expect the guy laundering money to accept bitcoins without charging extra? Because if the guy selling bitcoins takes ~10% from the AK-47 buyer and the guy laundering money also takes his ~10% cut for using bitcoins on top of his X% cut for laundering money, suddenly it’s starting to look really unappealing.

The real appeal of bitcoin for illegal purposes is it’s effectively a poor but really cheap way to launder money. Try and deposit even 1 million in cold hard cash and the banking system throws up red flags, liquidate 1 million in bitcoin and that looks significantly more legit at least on the surface. It doesn’t help if you’re under investigation, but then again it’s cheap.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by AnthonyMouse on Saturday October 16, 2021 @04:40PM (#28891287)
> Do you expect the guy laundering money to accept bitcoins without charging extra?

That's the entire purpose of using them.

Someone who has a million dollars in physical cash either needs to get someone local to launder it, which might be hard to find or require paying them a thick margin, or they have to find a way to ship a huge amount of physical cash to the place it's being laundered and risk it being seized at border crossings etc.

Someone who has a million dollars in Bitcoin can buy money laundering as a service over the internet from the lowest bidder who has a good reputation. The Bitcoin gets transferred to some place with favorable banking rules, gets liquidated there where it's either not illegal or the local authorities are corrupt, and it comes back as dollars. Since it's possible to do it over the internet, you have competition from all over the world including some favorable jurisdictions, so the margins get smaller than they would be if you had to find someone locally.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by Retric on Sunday October 17, 2021 @07:55AM (#28895811)
Money laundering can’t just be done in an arbitrary location. You need to transfer money back into your country’s banking system while looking legitimate to safely spend it.

Put another way, banks are already operating on digital money that’s the problem.

Re:Tether Fined $41M for Lying About Reserves by mwint on Friday October 15, 2021 @06:31PM (#28883902)
If you can’t trade BTC for USD, you’ll trade it for Yen, and then trade for USD.

Some country will want to cash in on the demand for their currency, and will leave it legal to exchange.