News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:29PM (#28768072)
The person who mentions the banality of evil, dannykwells, has an excellent point.

But there's more at play here. I briefly worked on Twitter's anti-abuse engineering. Many of the people on that team cared a lot about protecting people. I sure did. But we didn't have the necessary power to actually solve the problem.

The people who did have that power were senior execs. They might say that they cared. In their heart of hearts, perhaps they even did. But their behavior demonstrated that they cared about other things much more.

My boss's boss, for example, was an engineering leader who had a climber's resume: quickly advancing through positions of more and more power. In my view, he cared about that a great deal, and did not give a shit about the actual harm to users. As soon as he got the chance, he pushed out my boss, laid off the team's managers, me included, and scattered the people to the wind.

I presume the same was true about the senior execs. They were aware Twitter was causing harm to people. If they wanted to know the details, we had plenty of research and they could have ordered more. Did they care? Impossible to know. But what they focused on was growth and revenue. Abuse was a big deal internally only as long as it was a big deal in the press.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by whakim on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:24AM (#28769505)
I think this hits the nail on the head. It's not that Facebook or the many people who work there don't care about kids or a deleterious political climate. They do care. It's just about what happens when those concerns conflict with other concerns, such as maximizing user engagement. In my opinion Haugen's testimony and Zuckerberg's response simply confirm this: Haugen talks a lot about the research that was done and how that research was ignored; Zuckerberg points out a lot of (somewhat lacking in context) facts about the size of Facebook's investments in trust and integrity or openness to regulation.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by rhaksw on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:14AM (#28769784)
Fair to say it's about incentives? I think it's possible to run a profitable social media company that does care. We're just stuck with too few options. I'm unaware of any that make transparency a core value by, say, openly publishing moderator actions.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by onion2k on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:47AM (#28769979)
I think it's possible to run a profitable social media company that does care.

That's probably true but not at Facebook's scale. If the employees are willing to accept the argument "We could have increased profit but chose not to in the interests of users.", because everyone's bonuses and stock value is based on profit, you'd need to hire a lot of people who are happy to trade some amount of personal gain for user wellbeing. That would be difficult when you have tens of thousands of people.

Alternatively, maybe it'd be possible to run Facebook without giving the staff equity or bonuses. That would take a huge shift in the way tech renumeration works though.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by MakersF on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:33AM (#28770236)
This comment consider employees (people) as if they were algorithms to maximize personal revenue.

That is not necessarily true. If FB where a place where people could feel proud of the good it does, a lot would be ok taking a pay cut.

Sure, maybe the ones that care the most about compensation wouldn't join, but that might be ok.

I worked previously for a for-profit company which was devolving a massive amount of their profits to charity. It was something I was proud of, and a part of my evaluation of how much I liked working there.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by yissp on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @07:50AM (#28771951)
It seems increasingly likely that if FB keeps ignoring these concerns they're going to get hit with some sort of government regulation. So I still think it's in their long-term self-interest to try and avoid that happening, even if we assume profit is really all they care about.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by popcube on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:15AM (#28770137)
if they can do this, let everyone trust they do this, rheir company will beyond all organizations in human history. you can let them take care your kids!
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by trhway on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:29AM (#28769867)
>I think it's possible to run a profitable social media company that does care.

No. Due to network effect successful company must be large, and the large company lives by different rules. FB for example is a trillion dollar company. It is like a TeV energy level in physics. Different behavior of matter. At those energy levels chemistry for example just doesn't exist, and matter itself changes as protons break apart. Ethics in big business is like chemistry in high energy physics - it just doesn't exist at those levels of money. At these levels they can be affected only by comparable level of money or power, like the government power.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by jamiek88 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:36AM (#28769906)
Then they are too big and must be broken up.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by sofixa on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @04:01AM (#28770402)
I can't see it working. Instagram and WhatsApp should be spun off, absolutely no question about it. But Instagram and Facebook still remain way too big.

And how do you break them up? By geographic area? People would be pissed because they have contacts with, or maybe want to watch vacation videos from people from different areas.

IMHO the only options would be:

* non-profit run by the UN or similar

* forced to open all data and APIs to make it a platform, with rules to make it an even playing field

In both cases with much less, and why not zero, "engagement" focus ( just show the latest stuff chronologically from the things you've liked/subscribed to). Could either work? No idea, but seems to me that they have better chance than a Facebook per country or region.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by nonameiguess on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:49AM (#28771495)
It's probably too late for any specific publicly traded company that already exists, but social media as a protocol, with forced interoperability if necessary, is the way to solve this. Many regional phone carriers doesn't prevent people from communicating across regions.

Of course, it does cost more, so the question becomes who is willing and able to pay for a socially less harmful means of networking individuals without having to put them all on a single data hoovering ad platform? Whether it's direct charge to consumers or subsidized by government, the money still ultimately has to come from people.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by SheikhSalman on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:12AM (#28927696)
Thanks for the Great Content Sir. I will share with my friends & once again thanks a lot. https://beingkurt.com/
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by prirun on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @10:42AM (#28773744)
> social media as a protocol, with forced interoperability if necessary, is the way to solve this

Hey, if they get that implemented for Facebook, maybe they can try to make it work with health care records too. Good luck with that...

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by riffic on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:01PM (#28776175)
here's a business model for it:

Implement ActivityPub (an existing protocol recommended by the W3C), and offer their underlying social networking services as hosted and managed software for big orgs to operate on their own domain. With interoperability, they'll work across domains. Target customer is anyone with at least 100K followers (so gov, institutions, media, et cetera).

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by mensetmanusman on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:38PM (#28780756)
If the United Nations ran Instagram, they would ban any discussion of human rights in Hong Kong, because China is a veto member.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by sofixa on Thursday October 07, 2021 @03:22AM (#28783252)
And the US would ban any discussion on Guantanamo and CIA torture. What's your point?

It should be run independently, like the WHO, not directly under the power of the security council. And before you say Taiwan, the Republic of China is not a UN member, and there's nothing the UN or WHO can do about it, it's between China and them.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by mensetmanusman on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:07AM (#28785173)
I am unfamiliar with cases where the US prevented CNN (or others) from discussing Guantanamo.

I am familiar with the extreme lengths China would go through to prevent discussion on topics it hates though (e.g. if HN was based in China both of our comments would have been deleted immediately)

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by fsflover on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:58AM (#28771554)
> And how do you break them up? By geographic area?

Did you hear about federation and inter-compatibility between different network? Have a look at how Mastodon works.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by trhway on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:52AM (#28770009)
And who is going to break up TikTok or whatever comes next/instead?

The social media is like tobacco, and FB increasing the engagement at all costs is like when Big Tobacco were increasing addictiveness of the cigarettes. Like with tobacco, the way to deal with the issue is to wean the population off by in particular educating the population about the damage it does to them .

Btw, "Statement from Mark Zuckerberg" - that reminded that foundational tenet of Facebook :

Zuck: yea so if you ever need info about anyone at harvard

Zuck: just ask

Zuck: i have over 4000 emails, pictures, addresses, sns

Friend: what!? how’d you manage that one?

Zuck: people just submitted it

Zuck: i don’t know why

Zuck: they “trust me”

Zuck: dumb fucks

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:37AM (#28771414)
To be fair to the guy, he was 19 then. Who amongst us hasn't said something (many things, in my case at least) stupid at 19?
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by solveit on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @04:04PM (#28777712)
Also, he was right. People shouldn't have sent Zuck their private info even if Zuck were a saint, because there was no way they could have known Zuckerberg was a saint.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by trhway on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:56PM (#28776123)
how many stupid things you said at 19 made you $100B? I'm pretty sure that if a stupid thing you said at 19 had made you a $100B by the age of 30 and continued to made many billions after that you'd pretty much continue to believe and follow that stupid thing.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:50AM (#28785541)
This wasn't about Facebook, it was about a different, non-commercial project (as far as I know, anyway).
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by richardfey on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:03PM (#28781353)
That is a beautiful simile, thank you!
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by whakim on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:04AM (#28770077)
I honestly don't know if it's possible. Common sense seems to suggest that social networks become more harmful as they becomes bigger and more profitable. That's just my surface-level take though. I guess the meta-question is what to do about highly-profitable lines of business that cause demonstrable social harm. Clearly regulation and government intervention are one answer, as are reforms to corporate governance structures (e.g. German and Nordic rules around worker representation on corporate boards.)
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by the_other on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @04:27AM (#28770557)
> Common sense seems to suggest that social networks become more harmful as they becomes bigger and more profitable.

But FB isn’t a social network. It’s an engagement farm and advertising platform that abuses a social network to drive its business aims.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by whakim on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @04:40AM (#28770620)
While I'm sympathetic to your anti-FB bias, I think it's pretty clear that by any reasonable definition Facebook is indeed a social network (which also happens to make gobs of money through advertising, and covets engagement because that increases ad revenue as well as a general sense of "platform health"). The question posed was whether "being bad for society" is an emergent property of social networks as they grow.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by the_other on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @05:14PM (#28778519)
I guess you’re still on FB?

It’s quite hard to see how it’s just a business that doesn’t give one shit about you no matter now many followers you have or how many likes you got when you’re still using it.

An actual social network would care how you feel today.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by whakim on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @08:26PM (#28780224)
A social network is just a kind of business, like a chain of supermarkets or a steel mill. You could, of course, have a non-profit social network (or a business with a different corporate structure - as I allude to in a parent post), but that's not what Facebook is or what its peers are. In the United States, businesses are beholden first and foremost to their shareholders, which means that there's an inherent tension when "giving a shit about you" and "making money" come into conflict. What makes you think that a social network with a normal corporate structure and in the absence of countervailing regulation would have more empathy than any other business?

As an aside, I'd like to make the broader point that boiling everything down to "Facebook=evil" doesn't seem like a productive way to get the changes that I think both of us would like to see. It walks right into the strawman arguments that Zuckerberg is responding to in his post ("Why would we invest so much in trust and research if we didn't care?"). And it doesn't capture the fact that Facebook is a huge entity comprised of a lot of people, many of whom have different incentives and some of whom are even trying to do the right thing (see: Anna Haugen).

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by the_other on Friday October 15, 2021 @09:05AM (#28877259)
You’re trying to appeal to “my better nature”, to help me believe that FB can be changed. It wont work.

In 2007 or 2008 I promoted the idea amongst my friends to “poison the well”, to feed bad data into FB’s algorithms. If they enjoy Coke, talk about Pepsi, I said. If they vote Green, share far right news. I called it Falsebook.

It didn’t work, because the problems inherent in the advertising auctions are not very visible to users. They mesh with the echo chambers of our friend circles and fizzle into the background. We seek out echo chambers in order to feel safe and validated. It’s mostly fine when it’s just humans relaxing with friends. But when that echo is robotically generated from an accurate model of all individuals involved, it can be leveraged for all sorts of big scale shady crap. Advertising is the village idiot of this town and corportate-backed political propaganda is the warring gang lord.

And Zuck does what any market owner does.. sits back and rakes in profit, cleaning up the mess when it suits him. And mostly it doesn’t.

I’ve never felt it could be fixed from the inside. I’ve never thought it was a good idea to begin with but I let peer pressure and my magpie nature suck me in. I regret signing up for FB and GMail back in the day because corporate surveillance has fucked our society hard and let sociopaths run rampant.

You will not change my mind. I wasn’t contributing to the conversation in good faith. I shall assume you were. My original glib comment about FB abusing social networks wasn’t an invitation to learn a new perspective, it was a war cry, a flag raise, a call for comrades. I was hoping someone would respond with links to a new Scuttlebutt implementation or tell me about a cool Masto instance. Or try to explain why I should bother with Matrix. Or something more interesting than all of those.

The web is sick. Personalised advertising has made it ill. We need to fix it and I don’t believe FB or GOOG are interested in trying.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by mensetmanusman on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:37PM (#28780744)
An actual social network would let you choose how you feel, which is why you can choose your friends who might all be downers and feel horrible, and the social network will let them share their despair with you.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by rhaksw on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @04:21AM (#28770514)
> Common sense seems to suggest that social networks become more harmful as they becomes bigger and more profitable.

Yeah I don't know that anyone could have predicted these networks would become too massive to displace. Intervention should be on the table, no doubt about it. I hope they bring up net neutrality and Facebook's violation of it via internet.org. I thought "Free Basics" had died but apparently it's still going.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet.org

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by lr1970 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:38AM (#28771423)
> It's just about what happens when those concerns conflict with other concerns, such as maximizing user engagement.

They care about their own kids more than they care about abstract faceless millions of other kids on FB. Moral bankruptcy starts when they harm other kids in order to put food on a table for their own children. I would not be surprised if some of the FB's employees ban their kids from using it.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by kbenson on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @10:44PM (#28768581)
I don't necessarily subscribe to the Gervais Principle[1] other than thinking it's an interesting lens through which to reexamine motives and motivations of coworkers, but sometimes the terminology is damn apt (at least for one group...).

1: https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-...

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by craigyk on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:08AM (#28769416)
Reminds me a bit of one of my favorite books to chuckle over: systemantics
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by swiftcoder on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:44AM (#28770301)
Bingo. I never interacted with a person on the FB integrity teams who didn't care deeply about these problems - but their solutions never seemed to make it into production. Whether that was because of the unintentional friction of bureaucracy, or the explicit wishes of execs, is somewhat immaterial in the final analysis.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:12PM (#28768737)
Were you ever really meant to solve the problem or just be a Potemkin village in case anyone accuses the execs of not caring.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:36PM (#28768893)
Meant to by whom? I was very serious about it. So was my boss and most of the people on my team. Beyond that, I don't have direct data.

My guess is that execs would have been very happy if we could have quickly solved the problem in a way where revenue and growth were not harmed and nobody important had to go out of their way.

But online abuse isn't like that. It's a hard problem. So I think execs were satisfied to say they were making a big effort, celebrate some modest gains, and then stop thinking about the problem once it wasn't a giant PR/regulatory issue for them.

So it's more like how a lot of people mean to get fit or lose weight. If it's New Year's Day or their doctor scares them enough, they'll get real serious for a while. They probably do mean it, but they mean a lot of other things too, and those win out.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by tablespoon on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:59PM (#28769043)
I think you're exactly describing a "Potemkin village in case anyone accuses the execs of not caring." The people in power weren't serious about solving the problem (because the only things they'd accept were rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic or an easy magic solution that could never actually exist), and the main benefit your team provided was PR/regulatory cover for the organization.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by jmchuster on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:11AM (#28769767)
I would posit that no company "actually" cares. The premise of twitter isn't "the social platform that has no abuse". If that were the main goal, i'd imagined they'd be another nothing startup that ran out of money and died years ago. So then if only companies that don't have social good as their primary goals are the ones that would ever exist in the first place, then it feels that trying to judge companies for doing so seems not particularly useful.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by xg15 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:43AM (#28769953)
> So then if only companies that don't have social good as their primary goals are the ones that would ever exist in the first place

Or alternatively, we could try to view this as the root problem and try to fix it.

Edit: Note there is also a difference between "not having social good as their primary goal" and working effectively against the social good, whether intentional or not.

Edit2: Explanation of the downvote would be nice.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:58AM (#28769689)
no, a Potemkin village is never meant to be real, the parent commenter suggested it was like New Year's resolutions that are meant to be real but in the end people fail because they like their New York cheesecake too much to change.

Then the doctor tells them again you need to go on a diet or you will have a heart attack, and they go on the diet for a couple months.

having a heart attack may solve the issue.

Of course there are clear eyed people who see the situation for what it is, those that stay on don't care and consider the efforts to fight abuse as a Potemkin village.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:39AM (#28774448)
Exactly. To me a Potemkin village is one or two steps further away from reality. The Potemkin village is unoccupied and has no potential for occupation. All involved in its construction know it's fake.

My team was sincere, worked hard, and definitely got some good stuff done. Just not nearly as much as we wanted.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by psb217 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @12:19PM (#28774917)
In this metaphor you're the buildings, not the builders.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @07:34PM (#28779841)
Same thing then. In the metaphor, the buildings' only purpose and only outcome is to fool. One of our purposes was to get things done. And we definitely had some impact. If the public/regulatory pressure stayed constant, we would have gotten some more done. We would also have gotten more done if executives had taken it more seriously, of course.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by 0xBABAD00C on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:59AM (#28770394)
So here's a much more general statement: your identity and your sense of self, your consciousness, your "choices" that build your life's narrative, are all actually a "Potemkin village in case anyone accuses the execs of not caring". The "anyone" in this scenario being other social agents you interact with (see [1] for further thoughts on this).

> the main benefit your team provided was PR/regulatory cover for the organization

This sort of reasoning seems to be applicable on many levels of social organization, from brains to countries. Most of the stuff your brain does is for show / self-delusion, most of the stuff any community or global organization does is also for show / self-delusion. It's "Potemkin villages" all the way down.

[1] https://www.elephantinthebrain.com/

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by SheikhSalman on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:12AM (#28927699)
Thanks for the Great Content Sir. I will share with my friends & once again thanks a lot. https://beingkurt.com/
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by spoonjim on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @10:21PM (#28768444)
This is a place where the founder-CEO-demigod like Zuck should able to make better decisions than a professional team like Twitter. The long term profit maximization strategy was to maximize profits only up to the point where you risk getting regulated by government. With all the fawning praise of him as a kid I don’t think Zuck envisioned that one day both Democrats and Republicans would be united in their desire to fuck him over.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by nonfamous on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:29PM (#28768853)
Zuck is desperate to be regulated: he asks for Congress to step in every time he’s asked.

Regulation would be awesome for Facebook: not only would it be a fig leaf for all their social problems (“hey, it’s not our problem anymore”), it would also stifle any potential competitors out of their market. The costs of regulation are regressive: much more easily absorbed by BigCos than any startup.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:40PM (#28768915)
Could be. Some of the proposed regulation I've seen for this specifically exempts companies under, say, $100m/year in annual revenues. So legislators aren't unaware of the problem.

Another possibility is that Facebook knows that asking Congress to do something is either a) not going to increase the odds of them doing anything, b) actually decrease the odds by sounding contrite, or c) puts it in a place where Facebook's army of lobbyists and otherwise connected individuals make sure nothing meaningful will get passed into law.

It's not a bad bet given how polarized Congress and the American electorate are. And gosh, who is a big enabler of that polarization?

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by intended on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:55AM (#28769670)
The base problem isn’t really solveable, and its as much of a public discussion on what we want to do with speech first, before its a question of how we want Social Media firms to act.

In the end, there is no algorithm which can match the scale of bad content, no robust definition of bad content which can work without creating a flood of false positives.

Every false positive is now someone who had something valid to say who is silenced.

How are we going to decide which grey area speech is unwelcome (leaving out obvious things that are illegal).

———— The popular idea is increased human centric moderation, but thats still going to be 2k email escalations for one region per day, at a 10% escalation ratio from a base of 20k.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:55AM (#28774660)
It only appears unsolvable because you've presumed that social media should exist in its current form. Yes, algorithms can't match the scale of the bad content before we hit AGI. But that problem only exists because we have for-profit companies hosting way more content than they can afford to police on the thin margins ads provide. (Twitter, for example, makes about $1 per user per month.)

Prior to the late 2000s, this problem didn't exist. In alternate universes, it surely doesn't; there are many ways this could have gone.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by throwaway2048 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:07AM (#28769745)
its hard to say the problem isn't really solveable when nobody has really tried to begin with.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by Yoric on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @04:13PM (#28777836)
There are academic researchers and private teams all over the planet attempting to find solutions to disinformation, bullying and even spam.

Of course, it's pretty clear by now that there isn't going to be a magic bullet that is going to make everybody happy.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by intended on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:42AM (#28769941)
People are trying, what are you referring to?
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by zo1 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @11:36AM (#28787696)
Not OP. My impression is that a lot of the focus is around safety and specifically privacy. Both play right into social media giants' hands.

Instead we need to target Ads. Almost all problems can be eventually traced back to ads. At the very least traced back to the money incentive that ads create, on any platform.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by intended on Friday October 08, 2021 @04:19AM (#28796891)
Thanks, thats actually a great answer.

I would go one step further and suggest that ads are an issue for certain types of Economic games or Markets.

Any industry that depends on Ads tends to consolidate, and has an issue of incentives - the more people on the network, the more likely the network is able to survive.

On a tech forum people assume that challengers have better tech - but I would argue that challengers actually allow for more salacious/engaging content.

This is what creates the race to the bottom.

If the race to the bottom can be stopped - i.e. an incentive structure created that stops engagement being the primary metric, then the rest of the downstream problems are largely prevented.

Thats my root cause assessment of the situation. However once I get to this point, any solution seems to be a mess of intersecting fields ranging from morality, legal constraints, issues with press freedoms, free speech etc. etc.

So... I guess how do we set up incentives to not allow the most "engaging" content to dominate?

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by native_samples on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @05:57AM (#28771117)
Or

d) He realizes that there are opposing factions with different ideas of what needs to happen, and it's impossible for his company to please them all, so pushing the decision to some semblence of a vote that claims to represent everyone is the only way to put an end to the endless arguing.

or

e) He believes what he wrote and doesn't think these social issues should be decided by corporations.

Either interpretation is fine and a lot more generous than yours.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by somehnacct3757 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:53PM (#28768998)
He also wants the legislation to be toothless or misplaced so Facebook can pay lip service and not be fundamentally altered. Haugen just offered congress more surgical solutions than they were drafting as well as valid critiques of their drafts. That's why this particular post from Zuckerberg comes with such a large side of koolaid.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by davedx on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:34AM (#28769898)
That's an extremely pessimistic view of regulation. Somehow other industries manage to do fine despite it. In the EU, GDPR somehow hasn't snuffed out all small businesses.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by Hammershaft on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:15PM (#28777060)
I mean, the harmful effects of regulation are much less visible then the harmful effects of what is being regulated. We don't know to what degree the GDPR has snuffed out potential small businesses.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by pantalaimon on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:32AM (#28771375)
> In the EU, GDPR somehow hasn't snuffed out all small businesses.

Simply because there was enough regulation in place in that area that they didn't exist in the first place

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by zeruch on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:23PM (#28768807)
"The long term profit maximization strategy was to maximize profits only up to the point where you risk getting regulated by government." That is correct, but as with Wall ST, the addiction to the gamble has long been unhinged by an environment that has been lax on regulatory options...so when the blowback actually hits, it will not be just painful it will likely come on the tail end of a ragnarok-grade event that will likely shank the whole industry for a generation because current C-suites are so far up their own asses they can take direct inventory of the last few days of meal plans.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by surfingdino on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:24AM (#28770183)
Zuck started Facebook as Facemash, a site to judge attractiveness of students by other students. It was a creepy site then and has remained to this day. Sorry, but companies to take after their founders, because the founders set an example of what is OK, how to behave, what their values are, etc. While he may not be responsible for all of the actions of his employees, the buck stops with him.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by shrimpx on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @10:11PM (#28768396)
Your sentiment reflects what I see on teamblind.com. It's all TC and leveling up. A ton of people don't give much of a shit about the subject matter.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by seattle_spring on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:08PM (#28768710)
If we go by the content of teamblind, then every company's engineers only care about TC and leveling up.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by shrimpx on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:39PM (#28779372)
Are you saying that people on teamblind are only focusing on the TC aspect, and also care about many other things, or that only a subset of people only care about TC? If the latter, it’s still worrisome that so many of those people who hop around chasing only TC and not caring about subject matter, are highly valued at these companies like Facebook. Glib and shallow E6 and E7 don’t make for great tech leadership in a company that supposedly cares about ethics and safety.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by seattle_spring on Friday October 08, 2021 @03:32PM (#28803184)
Seems like very few engineers that make it to E6+ are the ones rabbling on about "TC or GTFO" on Blind. It's mostly more junior engineers or bad engineers that will never make it past the 2nd or 3rd rung of the career ladder.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @07:40PM (#28779874)
I get your point, but glib and shallow climbers are exactly what you want for a company that only supposedly cares. They're very good at supposedly caring!
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by electrondood on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:05AM (#28774021)
Blind is a toxic community, in my opinion.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by Dracophoenix on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @12:43AM (#28769287)
> I presume the same was true about the senior execs. They were aware Twitter was causing harm to people. If they wanted to know the details, we had plenty of research and they could have ordered more. Did they care? Impossible to know. But what they focused on was growth and revenue. Abuse was a big deal internally only as long as it was a big deal in the press.

Could this just be an issue of too many problems to care about and not enough time to solve them all or do you think the indifference was intentional?

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by luckydata on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:14AM (#28769454)
I worked at FB (not for very long) but you can trace everything back to the awful performance process they have (the infamous PSC). At the end of the day, hard to measure stuff doesn't get you promoted while tangibly moving metrics does. If you incentivize people that way, it doesn't take anyone WILLINGLY doing anything evil to end up with a pretty evil thing on your hand.

If you optimize for profits and only that, you always end up selling crack cause it's the best business in the world, and that's why it's illegal.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @07:38PM (#28779863)
I agree their incentive structure is at the root of this. But this is an incentive structure designed by one group of conscious actors and then followed by another group. A bunch of people choose this. And given the many years of public critique of Facebook, they can hardly be unaware of what they're choosing.

The truth is that almost anybody could sell crack. Most of us choose not to.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:45AM (#28774524)
Too many problems to care about and not enough time? That's the human condition. What defines us is the choices we make, the priorities they set.

I can't know what they felt when they made those choices. But I can see the choices and the outcomes. I get there's some theoretical difference between willfully fucking people over to get rich and being so blinded by eagerness to get rich that you fuck people over as a side effect. But either way they worked very hard to get positions of power that affected millions and then were indifferent to the harm they caused, so it's not like this happened by accident.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by ikr678 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:28AM (#28769526)
Depends if not causing harm to users was an executive KPI or not.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by Dracophoenix on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:28AM (#28770211)
How would "harming users" be defined for an executive KPI?
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:48AM (#28774575)
Abuse is measurable in all sorts of ways. The most clear one is having experts take a look at a random sample of users and see if they're being abused. You can back that up with interviews to look for both their take on what's happening and a variety of trauma markers. And there are all sorts of other measures that correlate.

But if there somehow weren't ways to measure it? Then they would have created a product where they couldn't even tell that they were harming people. That right there is something that shouldn't exist.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wahnfrieden on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:04AM (#28769400)
Follow the money
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by throwaway2048 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:06AM (#28769730)
Yep, ask yourself how much identifiable return "preventing abuse" has, and then you have your answer for exactly how much these companies actually care about it.

Even worse, preventing abuse and other social media ills often lessens engagement, and you know what that means.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by garbagetime on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @10:30AM (#28773608)
>Yep, ask yourself how much identifiable return "preventing abuse" has, and then you have your answer for exactly how much these companies actually care about it.

Quite a bit, then?

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by mise_en_place on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:49PM (#28768256)
There is a phenomenon I have witnessed working both in high growth startups and traditional Fortune 500s. At some point, the company starts attracting Dark Triad personality types that cement themselves in upper management positions, usually starting at Director level. These people are extremely dangerous, one of them had access to my corporate laptop (as was standard policy for that company) and would torment me by screwing with me on a daily basis.

When an organization becomes too large or bureaucratic, these Dark Triad types hide and typically exert their influence and power and will behind the scenes. This is why these companies seem “evil”, but it’s usually not the founders’ fault, a lot of times they’re unaware of it, or one of the founders is also a sociopath and will protect the evil cabal. That’s my two cents about it anyway.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by subsubzero on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:07PM (#28768703)
Extremely insightful, I have had the same experience and I agree. I somehow have the ability to "sniff" out these types pretty quickly, something about their conversations give them away.

Here's an real life example: I worked for a small startup years ago and the founder invited the engineering team to lunch at a restraunt. The founder proceeded to berate the waiter for no reason and yell at him, it seemed like completely psychopathic behavior and then I caught the smallest of smiles from him after the waiter walked away beaten up(metaphorically speaking) by the barrage. I knew right then this person was not someone I wanted to work for and put in my notice shortly after.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by cvhashim on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:10AM (#28772695)
You can tell a lot about a person by the way they treat service workers.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by throwaway-19283 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @10:16PM (#28768418)
This happened at a company I was at. Hyper-growth startup, huge aura around it.

A few high-level folks arrived whose perfection in smooth talking was rivaled only by their enjoyment of wreaking havoc on teams & relationships. They brought in their friends, paranoia and rumors spread, culture went off a cliff, CEO was confused what happened. Mass exodus followed.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by mc32 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @10:59PM (#28768667)
How do you filter against hiring these types given their talking and schmoozing get them over the HR guard as well as director and above interviewers?
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by devwastaken on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:46PM (#28768955)
You don't just filter to hire, you also unfilter employee concerns. Most people think that CEO's, founders, owners, "management" are not going to back them, and they're generally right. Therefore most problems never skip the chain, and end up being suppressed by their own supervisors.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by 88913527 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:15AM (#28769460)
Assess for technical skill and raw tactical ability. This would have the downside of filtering genuinely good leaders who've been too far removed from technology (and thus are pure people leaders) for too long. People that were once technologists, but no longer are, have a way of speaking that's easily clear to pick out. Also, some people move up but keep their technical chops along the way. An executive that can microscope on parts of the org, as needed, with a technical mindset, can provide material value.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by Cd00d on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @12:55AM (#28769347)
I don't like letting people bring their own teams with them. It's a shortcut to a discontinuation of culture and a form of second-order nepotism.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:43PM (#28768934)
I do it via interviews oriented on doing the actual work. The more an interview tests the ability to talk about work and be charming and persuasive, the more it advantages awful people.

For software development, that's the opposite of what I want. Some of the best people I've worked with were terrible at interviewing. But once we got into actual code, they settled down and their skills shined through.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by subsubzero on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:15PM (#28768756)
How I find them is in their speech. They come across as extremely insincere and "out" themselves by how they talk to either the interviewer(focus alot on themselves) or someone they believe is beneath them(dismissive). If you are a gatekeeper for their employment or something they need expect flattery and overly kind words. If you are no longer that gatekeeper expect to never hear from them again or abuse. Also this type tends to lie alot, thats usually how they do get canned.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by Radim on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:50AM (#28769993)
"Just call BS! Geez, that was easy. Why are all these HR people so incompetent?"

This assumes you are more intelligent than them, and can see through their insincerity during an interview process.

But have you considered that these "smooth talkers" can be smarter than you? Or at least have been perfecting their BS craft (while you perfected yours, such as programming), so that you are absolutely no match?

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @07:42PM (#28779898)
For sure. Standard lines of BS don't work well on me because they're optimized for other people. But I firmly believe that for every person, there's a line of bullshit they're vulnerable to. And the people most vulnerable are the ones most sure they're too sharp to be BSed.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by gillytech on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:56PM (#28768305)
You're absolutely 100% correct. About 2.5% of people have have an inverted viewpoint of their own survival. Meaning, they think they need to squash others down in order to feel superior. As opposed to the logical path which is raise your team together and effectively lead to greater prosperity for all.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by 6510 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:10PM (#28768722)
I think the bug in most organizations is that performance is reviewed only by the people above with very little to no input from below.

edit: Took me down memory land to re-visit some truly incompetent and insanely unproductive bootlickers and fast talkers who would lose their job immediately after a 5 min confidential talk with any of their underlings.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by wpietri on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:22PM (#28768798)
For sure. A friend at Apple says that it was much better to work at when it was not as successful. Now that they have large piles of money, it attracts people who seek proximity to large piles of money.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by swalsh on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @10:07PM (#28768371)
Reminds me if Mao, he'd always say whatever it took to gain power. But when he had it, he used it solely for personal gain or for personal goals... regardless of how many people got hurt, or killed as a result.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by pphysch on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @10:25PM (#28768468)
Mao Zedong was a "founder" of a militant "startup" called the Communist Party of China during a vast civil war; his experience has virtually nothing in common with a non-founder career climber in 21st century SV.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by kyleee on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @12:24AM (#28769185)
Well, there could certainly be personality and technique overlap
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by itoocode on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @10:03PM (#28768350)
Totally agree with you, most of the time founders are not aware this is happening down the ladder. I have seen this scenario with the middle layer management protecting their jobs and gate keeping in most companies today.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by hef19898 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:41AM (#28769937)
Either the founder isn't aware, then they just get egulfed in the new culture until they have, at some point, no power left. Or they are among the worst of the pack and drive the new culture. Given that Zuck somehow managed to retain 50+% of voting rights until now, I would put him in the second group. Jeff would be the same.

And then you would have the truly exceptional people, that manage to combine the ruthless drive needed to grow a successful company, care about their people and have the capabilities to keep those bad actors out, or at least in check. I saw maybe 1.5 of these people in management functions, middle management that is. Not sure of those black swan unicorns exist as founders so.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by DoneWithAllThat on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:57AM (#28769682)
This is my life right now and it’s utter hell. The company is infested with these people and it’s astounding to me that nobody seems to care.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by coding123 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @11:11PM (#28768730)
Game of survivor played out in real life.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by atoav on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:19AM (#28770159)
> they might say that they cared. In their heart of hearts, perhaps they even did. But their behavior demonstrated that they cared about other things much more.

Isn't it just about that in the end? I think being good or not is about whether you give yourself the room to do the right thing even when other pressures exist – because they always exist.

Being good can be hard, because sometimes it means you have to abandon your usual priorities and stand up to the consequences which will emerge from that decision.

Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by cycomanic on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:18AM (#28771264)
I completely agree with you. The real judge if someone is doing something good, is when they do it despite the consequences. Otherwise it's meaningless, they simply are not being evil.
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by noslenwerdna on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:05PM (#28775513)
Just curious - given your boss's boss is so self-interested, what advantage could he gain from pushing out a subordinate and laying off all the people below?
Re:Statement from Mark Zuckerberg by akudha on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:55AM (#28771535)
Whenever I am having a hard time understanding a situation, someone's motives etc in the world of business/politics, I start with follow the money, and it helps. It might sound cliche, but it is also true in a majority of the cases