News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by mthoms on Sunday September 26, 2021 @01:31PM (#28662744)
Mini’s statement only highlights the absurdity (emphasis mine):

>With regard to the turn indicator light pattern, there should be no trouble at all for a driver to understand, when seeing the full rear of the car, which direction is being indicated

So what about when you can only see half of the car? Like when it’s changing lanes or pulling out of a parking spot? You know, like those times when a signal is MOST useful?

Absolute idiocy.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by cratermoon on Sunday September 26, 2021 @05:13PM (#28664720)
Or when it's dark. I'm imagining a cyclist or pedestrian seeing only the blinking light and maybe a vague outline of the vehicle at best, seeing the <- blinking and thinking, "that car is turning left". Then the cyclist wakes up in the hospital after being flattened by a right hook[1]

1 https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2019/04/08/whats-a-right-...

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bagels on Sunday September 26, 2021 @07:26PM (#28665560)
If it's dark, I would assume it is likely that the taillights are also on.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by Reason077 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @07:41PM (#28665643)
Usually yes. But in urban areas (where there are lots of street lights, and lots of cyclists), people often forget to turn their lights on. I guess it's becoming less of a problem now that most cars have auto lights, but I still see cars driving around without lights pretty regularly.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by fho on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:30AM (#28670408)
Story time!

Last year saw a revival of drive-in cinemas in my area (for ... obvious reasons).

Apparently drivers are getting so used to the automation, that the staff was doing rounds telling the audience to turn off their automatic lights.

Then, on the way out, at least the driver in front of us completely forgot to turn on the lights again. This was not in a well lit area, but on cross country roads. I honestly have no idea how the driver did not notice that she couldn't see the road well.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by cratermoon on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:49PM (#28675211)
Same here! I went to a drive-in just a couple of weeks ago, for the first time in .. decades? .. and that happened. The other thing was all the people in big SUVs parking backwards and opening up their tailgates, thus blocking the view of people behind them. The house rules said that open tailgates should not extend higher than the vehicle itself, meaning some folk had them tied partly closed, but I think enforcement was mostly complaint-based.

If the drive-in theater became a real thing again, I imagine it would have to adapt to these realities.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by dwighttk on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:53PM (#28666330)
Yeah I’m astonished at how often people drive with headlights off. Why is it even an option for lights to be off when in drive? I can understand wanting to turn them off sometimes, but not while moving.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by culturestate on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:50PM (#28666610)
I think the proliferation of daytime running lights is partly to blame here, because you still get some light out of the front even without headlights on.

The thing that always gets me is switching between (rental) cars that have automatic headlight sensors and those that don't.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by prehistoricdog on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:30AM (#28680501)
A fun thing I've noticed, those driving with no headlights in nighttime often lean towards windshield to, presumably, see better)
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by useruser1234 on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:01AM (#28667883)
No lights on shouldn’t even be an option. Even with older cars I’ve always turned them on. My current car won’t even allow you to turn them off.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bagels on Monday September 27, 2021 @12:20AM (#28667055)
Right, but that's a bigger problem than confusing turn signals. Doesn't matter what shape they are in that case.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by floatingatoll on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:55PM (#28666628)
That is not a safe assumption if you're a bicyclist or pedestrian at night, especially if the area is well-lit with cool light (such as white LEDs) that share a general color with headlights.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bluGill on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:47PM (#28665965)
Good enough for now, but in 10 years those cars will be worn with the typical problems of any other 10 year old car. At least a few will have non-functioning tail lights until the owner realized the problem and gets around to fixing it. (I suspect in my past I drove with non-functional taillights for many months before someone told me - it isn't the type of thing you check often)
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by waste_monk on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:58PM (#28666360)
I make a point of checking at least once a week - I have to get out of my car when leaving the house to close a set of gates, so I grab a big rock from the yard to wedge down the brake pedal and walk around the vehicle doing a brief inspection.

It's annoying at first, but quickly becomes habit.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by u801e on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:43PM (#28666580)
My 2000 Audi has an indicator light that comes on if one of the stop lamps is not working.

It would be nice if this was a standard feature in every car. Trying to determine whether the lights in the tail lamp cluster are all working without some assistance is difficult at best.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by cratermoon on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:46PM (#28675168)
Are those two lights a car or two motorcycles? Or a motorcycle and a car with one taillight out?
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by noneeeed on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:44PM (#28663981)
Even if I could see the full back of the car I think I'd still risk a brain-fart. It's like a driving Stroop Test (where words like "blue" are shown but you have to say what colour they are shown in, not what colour they say).
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by nextos on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:47PM (#28665964)
The designers screwed up many obvious things, not just these signals.

Mini Mk 1 (2000) was a beautiful minimal design by Frank Stephenson. Things started going downhill with Mk 2 (2006) and further models. He left, and I guess designers suffered from non-invented here syndrome.

I own a Mk 1 and I've leased or driven all other models. Aside from being uglier, many subtle things in the dashboard were tweaked making it a lot less intuitive. It makes me angry every time I see how they ruined a great design. Engines, on the other hand, have improved very significantly with each generation.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by noneeeed on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:16PM (#28674836)
That makes me sad. I learnt to drive in the Mk 1, it was a really nice car. The current crop are just plain fugly.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by nextos on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:19PM (#28677331)
Yes, they morphed classic shapes into something odd.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by misnome on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:44PM (#28663435)
This is what I _hate_ about the Audi striping indicators. Yes, they are actually useful when you see them when they are indicating.

However, when they have the hazard lights on, they still stripe. So if it's still and you can't see the left indicator, it feels like a very strong statement that they are trying to move out.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by Schlaefer on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:14PM (#28663692)
I'm still confused how they made it through regulation. Image you're a security-engineer and read "On average the indicator light runs at only 50% because we think it looks cool."
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by growt on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:27PM (#28664350)
The average regular indicator is also only on for 50% of the time. You know the joke: works, doesn't work, works, doesn't work
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by stavros on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:32PM (#28665889)
Yes, but this one is 50% of that 50%.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by growt on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:36AM (#28669457)
You're right. I imagined that the light would start to fill up immediately after turning off but it looks like thats not how it works, it really is completely off for some time.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by Goz3rr on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:26PM (#28664344)
Besides the fact that they're blinking lights so only on 50% of the time by design, consider the fact that regulations specify the minimum luminous output which these cars obviously pass. Add to that the fact that you're using modern high power LED lights and that the human eye perceives light in a logarithmic manner, it wouldn't surprise me if these indicators will be more noticeable on their "minimum" output than their old incandescent bulb counterparts.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by CRConrad on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:57AM (#28668529)
Have you measeured their area? Betcha they're at least twice as big as the smallest ones on the market -- whichever vehicle those are on -- so 50% of these is still more visible lit-up area than 100% of those.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by majormajor on Sunday September 26, 2021 @05:09PM (#28664682)
I don't have a problem with those. If you can only see half the car, hazards that blink normally still look like a turn signal blinking too. Yeah, the motion calls extra attention, but paying extra attention to a car with its hazards on seems fine.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by mccorrinall on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:21PM (#28664305)
Do you mean this indicator? https://youtu.be/r9Fin7pyzDc

Honestly, seems pretty good to me compared to the Mini one (which for some reason is RED instead of amber?! Plus an arrow in the opposite direction!)

Is there no law which makes amber coloured turn lights mandatory on cars (in the US)?

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by lozenge on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:41PM (#28664489)
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by tyingq on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:27PM (#28664356)
These types of laws aren't set at a Federal level in the US, but rather, state-by-state. As far as I know, they all allow red or amber. Most US cars have red turn signals.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by userbinator on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:46PM (#28664525)
The red comes from the fact that combined red turn signal+brake lights with white reverse was the standard for a very long time, from at least the 1940s.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by u801e on Sunday September 26, 2021 @06:04PM (#28665082)
Any state vehicle law pertaining to vehicle lighting has been superceded by FMVSS (Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard) 108.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by mccorrinall on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:35AM (#28682025)
Interesting, thank you. Since I've never been to NA I just took the yellow turn lights for granted. I just looked it up for Germany, and apparently turn light have to be yellow for every newly registered car after 1970.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bombcar on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:46PM (#28664528)
Federal law can override and has done so in cases like seatbelts. But they’ve not bothered for turn signals.

If it were to happen CA would likely be the first and then the rest of the country could follow.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by u801e on Sunday September 26, 2021 @06:09PM (#28665113)
Federal law (FMVSS 108) permits red rear turn signals, either combined with the brake lamp or a separate turn signal lamp. Interestingly enough, they require amber color front turn signals because the white ones were difficult to see when the headlamps were illuminated. It's too bad they didn't use the same reasoning for the rear turn signals compared to the stop lamps.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bluGill on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:15PM (#28666127)
There would be a huge backlash if they tried. Standard trailer connectors combine the brake light with the turn signal. (the brake like turns on both turn signals 100%) Many trucks just send enough wires (which are expensive these days) to run the trailer and tie the taillights off of those.

Thus to require amber to the rear means the standard trailer connector needs to be replaced, then some sort of grade period for old trailers, and - well I doubt I could think of all the complex factors required. In 30 years we might be able to do it.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by u801e on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:13PM (#28666435)
If they did mandate it, then it would only apply to new vehicles and trailers.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bluGill on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:08AM (#28670188)
You still have to deal with people with old trailers and new trucks, or new trucks and old trailers.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by mccorrinall on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:35AM (#28682024)
Trucks and trailers are each their own entity with their own papers in Germany. Perhaps this would solve the problem in the US too? When you have a new truck but an old trailer, you'd just show both papers when being questioned about it => everything is fine.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bluGill on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:53AM (#28682166)
The paperwork isn't the problem, it is all the adapters needed.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bombcar on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:42PM (#28666573)
And a diode on the old trailers would let them work with new.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by jbuhbjlnjbn on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:24PM (#28664328)
Of course you are absolutely right, as is the author of the column.

These unfortunate design decisions violate the most basic principles of design and safety, 'common sense' and 'function over form'.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by FridayoLeary on Sunday September 26, 2021 @05:16PM (#28664749)
They look terrible IMO.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by riazrizvi on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:52PM (#28664576)
For a car branded for being small, that is now 3x heavier than the original sensational design I would not call this absolute idiocy. It is consistent idiocy.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by throwaway0a5e on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:20PM (#28666153)
Cost of compliance but in pounds instead of dollars.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by JustResign on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:29AM (#28670402)
Given Mini's British origins, this is brilliant
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by WaitWaitWha on Sunday September 26, 2021 @01:56PM (#28662967)
Or at night, in the dark, unlit two-lane roads of most of Europe?
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by bcraven on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:28PM (#28663290)
As the article states, the euro-models light up the middle bar of the lamp. This appears to be US-centric issue due to the fact turn signals are not required to be amber.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by wirthjason on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:03PM (#28663038)
At night both tail lamps are lit.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by ashtonkem on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:08PM (#28663093)
If they’re working, and if there isn’t something obstructing their view, like another vehicle or fog.

Generally it’s best to design vehicle signaling with an assumption that situations are not ideal, just in case.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by giardini on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:25PM (#28663255)
Result: night-time accidents, especially in fog. Drivers will see a single flashing taillight arrow and make incorrect assumptions. Very severe and fatal collisions and consequential lawsuits will ensue. Cooper will pay, pay, pay. They will issue recalls and beg for leniency. But there is no doubt they f*cked this design.

If one of the two tail lights and/or a brake light(s) is/are out then the situation will only be worse.

I'd short Cooper stock were I an investor. This will cost them a pretty penny.

Gawd, I can't imagine what a self-driving car would see when it is following a Mini down a foggy British roadway. Perhaps someone could model it?

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by u801e on Sunday September 26, 2021 @06:14PM (#28665152)
If I'm not mistaken, rear fog lamps are required by UNECE regulations and would mitigate this issue. Unfortunately, in the US rear fog lamps are not required.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by jen20 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:40PM (#28663936)
If it’s on a British road, said self-driving car will see normal yellow indicators, since red is not a permissible colour. As mentioned in the article.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by ashtonkem on Sunday September 26, 2021 @05:47PM (#28664967)
Yeah, I think the amber horizontal bar in the middle for EU cars is an acceptable design. Cutesy, but no risk to the health and safety of the driver and others.

It's the US spec that seems incredibly poorly thought out.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by jen20 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:27PM (#28666495)
Even though this is a particularly egregious example, poorly thought out indicators are not exactly new in the US though - it is unfathomable to me why people thing that making the turn signals the same colour as both tail and brake light is a good idea...
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by dboreham on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:27PM (#28666782)
It was almost certainly a grandfathered cost reducing measure.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by fishywang on Monday September 27, 2021 @01:26AM (#28667361)
As a cyclist I'm always annoyed at the scenario that a car parked to the right of the bike lane having their left turn signal on, and their right turn signal is blocked by the car behind them, so I don't know if they are actually trying to pull out or just having their blinkers on.

Designs like this could actually be a solution to that, if they have the whole <-> on both sides, so when it's blinker they blink -> <-, and when it's turn signal they turn on <- or ->, depending on which side. That would totally resolve cyclist's problem.

But no. Mini completely ruined that. I have so many questions to the designer on how, in any scenario, this is a good idea.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by leokennis on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:22AM (#28670325)
People can complain about overbearing EU bureaucracy all they want - I love it. Please give me 500 pages of regulations about indicator lights if the end result is sane indicator lights.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by avemg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:08PM (#28663635)
The design is dumb but you’re really stretching. I don’t need to see the entire rear of the car to know which way the blinker is indicating. If I did then that would mean 99% of the cars on the road, which have no arrow at all, would suffer from this ambiguity.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by Retric on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:07PM (#28664186)
The issue is if you only see 1/2 the car people are going to make the wrong assumption rather than not knowing. You really don’t want confusion when driving multi ton vehicles at highway speeds.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by fsckboy on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:22PM (#28663769)
then why did the Mini representative say "when you can see full rear of the car"?
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by mthoms on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:58PM (#28664609)
It's dark/foggy and you're cycling along a bank of parked cars. Up ahead you see a flashing arrow pointing right but can't make out the car itself.

Is your first, gut instinct "up ahead there is a car pulling out to the left from the parking lane"? Or is it... "WTF is that?"

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by hellbannedguy on Sunday September 26, 2021 @05:17PM (#28664761)
I could care less about this tiny problem.

Is there a Mini owner satisfied with the mechanical part of their vechicle after 70k?

They have such a low oil pan, you don't dare not check it.

And every owner complains of things breaking down. A few days ago I was talking to a Mini owner.

Age friend has to go to England for a year, and gave the car to this guy, with the caviet of taking care of maintance.

The car had 50k--so it was new? First week a new Serpintine Belt.

Then faulty sensors, and a list of problems he was listing off.

They are cute though. I'm looking for a salvaged one to electrify.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by philsnow on Sunday September 26, 2021 @01:52PM (#28662934)
or when the back of the car is covered in snow or a million other reasons
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by diarrhea on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:31PM (#28663310)
> So what about when you can only see half of the car? Like when it’s changing lanes or pulling out of a parking spot? You know, like those times when a signal is MOST useful?

I don't understand how this is different with any other indicators.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by p49k on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:35PM (#28663343)
With other indicators, if you lack context your brain is aware that you don’t have enough info to deduce what’s happening. With the MINI, they are providing additional (incorrect) context to reassure you of the (wrong) result.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by thiht on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:20PM (#28663218)
> So what about when you can only see half of the car? Like when it’s changing lanes or pulling out of a parking spot? You know, like those times when a signal is MOST useful?

You either see which side of the car you're seeing, or you don't and the shape of the light doesn't matter. When you drive, you don't interpret the light of the turn signal, you interpret where it is.

For me that's one thing that looks stupid on paper but that doesn't matter in real life with all the context we have when driving.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by SkeuomorphicBee on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:52PM (#28663483)
> When you drive, you don't interpret the light of the turn signal, you interpret where it is.

That is not true, you only interpret "where it is" because there is no other information encoded in the light itself, when seeing a regular car with a plain signal you do interpret where it is. But in service cars (police car, ambulances, road maintenance trucks), large truck, or static light signaling, we frequently have special purpose lights with a meaning encoded in the light itself, and in those cases the position is irrelevant, the meaning is 100% in the icon used, so all drivers are already primed to interpret an arrow shaped light as an arrow. Now, those service vehicles don't have those special purpose lights in places were they could be ambiguously interpreted as a turn signal, so there is no problem there, but that Mini turn signal is quite unsettling, it sends two conflicting messages (position vs iconography), and that is BAD in traffic.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by p1necone on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:56PM (#28666013)
These lights are in the shape of an arrow pointing the wrong way, if it's nighttime it's going to confuse the hell out of you.

Even if it's daytime it's probably going to be confusing for a few hundred milliseconds too, and that's enough to cause accidents.

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by afavour on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:30PM (#28663309)
What about when it’s dark?
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by forgetfulness on Sunday September 26, 2021 @05:26PM (#28664804)
And say, you're a cyclist, going somewhat fast but not having headlights that would illuminate the rear of the car as to make out the relation of these arrows and the vehicle.
Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by CRConrad on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:06AM (#28668580)
> You either see which side of the car you're seeing, or you don't and the shape of the light doesn't matter.

Huh? I don't understand your reasoning. To everyone else, that seems to be precisely the situation where the shape of the light does matter, because it's the only context you have to go on. Care to explain your thinking?

Re:Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signal... by OneLeggedCat on Sunday September 26, 2021 @07:42PM (#28665649)
Have you ever driven in rural areas at night before?