News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by iambateman on Thursday August 12, 2021 @08:49AM (#28155579)
I often ask people: “if you could be 20-years old in 1991 or 2021, which would you pick?”

An incredible number of people pick ‘91. Some people even ask to go back to the seventies.

This article explains why I would much rather be young now rather than before.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:28AM (#28156026)
I'll take 91. I get to experience all the exciting personal computing technology again before it all becomes web appliances and dark patterns. Back when the internet, if you could get it, was a place of wonder instead of terror.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by pessimizer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:18PM (#28158936)
In '91 nothing followed you around. You could go to prison in Tennessee and Arkansas wouldn't be able to find out without a cop or two putting in a days work and making phone calls. People would get arrested, give a fake name, plead and do time, and be released without their identity ever being verified.

Young adults in 2021 are hopelessly trying to outrun that time they tweeted a slur when they were 12.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by lostlogin on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:04AM (#28156510)
If you are going back Marty, there are a few timelines I’d like altered.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by version_five on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:16AM (#28156649)
Fun fact is that the alternate 1985 in Back to the Future II where Biff ran Hill Valley was actually based on what it would be like with Donald Trump (as the sleazy casino developer) in charge.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by Jeff_Brown on Thursday August 12, 2021 @02:12PM (#28159553)
If 1991 why not 1919? You'd want the world transition from the horse age to the space age. It might be a good while yet beforw we see any new changes as profound as that one.

Okay I guess I'd rank crispr as highly. But the list of changes that profound is short.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by the_only_law on Thursday August 12, 2021 @02:13PM (#28159570)
1991 still feels modern enough to have a decent chance at participating in that transition I suppose.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by HaloZero on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:27PM (#28164213)
1919 for any non-white person (or woman) would be a terrible idea. 1991 at least you don't have to worry about segregation.

Assuming you're talking about staying in an industrialized nation.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by unnouinceput on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:20PM (#28158953)
Do you have kids? Sounds like you don't. All people would go back in time until they become parents. After that, faced with the harsh reality that going back in time would alter your decisions hence not getting the same kids, they, admittedly begrudgingly, back off.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by jasode on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:20AM (#28155933)
>I often ask people: “if you could be 20-years old in 1991 or 2021, which would you pick?” An incredible number of people pick ‘91. Some people even ask to go back to the seventies.

There's a podcast by Jason Feifer (was called Pessimists Archive) where the repeated theme across many episodes is the recurring fallacy of the "good ole days": https://www.jasonfeifer.com/build-for-tomorrow/

E.g. you ask today's generation and they say the "good old days" was 1991; but if you ask those in 1991 what the good old days were, they wouldn't say "right now!" ... they'd say 1970s. And if you ask those in 1970s... they'd say... (you get the point).

So the conclusion is either...

- the true good old days after connecting the survey across centuries was actually the prehistoric cave man days of hunting & gathering

... or ...

- every generation repeats the rose-colored glasses narrative because we bias the past with positive memories and the bias the present with negative current events

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by wazoox on Thursday August 12, 2021 @12:37PM (#28158436)
I was 20 in 1991 in Europe. I was flying regularly without any flygskam. The USSR was just falling and we were all sure it was an unmitigated good (we still didn't know that the Russians will die by scores and see their life expectancy drop like a rock); Germany was just reunited and we thought the EU was a great project, not a bureaucratic monster working for the oligarchy; Hell, I even believed there were nice guys and bad guys in the Yugoslavian wars. I probably even believed that voting counted. Future was bright, and open. Year 2000 was still ahead, with its wonders.

My mother was 20 in 1968, and it was the good old days. They believed the revolution was around the corner. Present was somewhat grim, but future was bright; in her years of political activity she saw the pill come, abortion rights, women rights enhanced, the end of dictatorships in Spain and Portugal, the end (in civilised countries) of death penalty, the crumbling of USSR.

My children are in their 20s; my son refuses to learn to drive because cars are evil and he doesn't want to own one, ever, because they're bad; he's hell-bent of enjoying the now because he's pretty sure that there is no future, except climate catastrophe, incessant wars, and electronically-enhanced surveillance; he thinks that democracy is a complete scam and he forgets to vote if I don't nag him weeks in advance. He's just as disillusioned as I am, but 27 years younger.

So I think the picture is more complex. The global direction of evolution is much more important than the objective starting point.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by z77dj3kl on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:31PM (#28159090)
I'm extremely interest the general feeling and views societies had in the past: how they perceived the present and the future, as a whole.

Objectively life has become better and more comfortable for the vast majority of humans since then (Hans Rosling does a beautiful job of exploring this).

But I do think that perceptions and feelings matter, and even though material wellbeing is a prerequisite to that, so is also the general feeling and view that those around you hold, and in many ways I feel we've gone backwards in that.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by aqsalose on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:05AM (#28156525)
> but if you ask those in 1991 what the good old days were, they wouldn't say "right now!"

Is this sourced? In Europe, 1991 was when the Soviet union fell. Sure, in many now-ex-USSR countries 1991 wasn't the best of times because the collapse wasn't very well managed. But in West, suddenly the impeding doom of nuclear war near disappeared overnight.

2021 has ... exciting climate events and Covid.

edit. What is the soundtrack of 2021? In 1991 it supposedly was https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4RjJKxsamQ . TIL the year ended with band donating bunch of royalties from the single to Gorbachev 10 days before he resigned and the USSR disappeared. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_of_Change_(Scorpions_song...

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nostrademons on Thursday August 12, 2021 @12:21PM (#28158207)
I'm old enough to remember 1991, even if I wasn't in the workforce then, and IIRC the mood then was kinda depressed. We were in the midst of a recession. We'd just come off the hangover of the first Gulf War. Nobody really knew what the fall of the Soviet Union would mean for America, and there were real fears about nukes falling into the wrong hands. Grunge was the hot new music, and pop culture was all about Gen-X alienation.

If you asked then what the good old days were, they'd probably say 1988. There's a reason Bush 1 was the only 1-term president between 1980 and 2020. Things didn't start perking up until around 93-95 with the WWW.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:33AM (#28156102)
A 3rd option is society (or parts of society) can go through rough patches where 30 years before year X was better than year X + 30. Trajectories for different populations within the society can differ themselves and so individuals will have varying answers.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by __s on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:36AM (#28156132)
Alternatively, it's a bit of Future Shock

I grew up in the 90s, & maybe I'd do better as a 20 year old in 1991 rather than 2031 (too young to say 20 in 2021; I've succeeded already close enough to there), but I'd rather grow up in the 2000s than grow up in the 80s

There's a kind of arbitrage, where if I could take my technical abilities from 2010 back to 1990, I'd probably do pretty well. I'm not so sure about taking those abilities to 2030. So you need to frame your question more clearly: at what age does the time travel occur? For simplicity I assume the only age you've given: 20. If it's about when we're born, then that's a completely different human being

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by 1123581321 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @08:51PM (#28163892)
The most charitable option is that it’s simply a great pleasure to imagine retreading familiar years. Due to human limitations, those years are the ones we grew up in.

That explanation has the benefit that it doesn’t need to counter-assert against daydreamers that things are getting better, worse, or staying the same.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by ghaff on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:28AM (#28156032)
That's one of the themes in the film Midnight in Paris. (Yes, it's a Woody Allen film.)
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by thundergolfer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:16AM (#28155880)
Going to be another person commenting that they'd seriously consider 1991 (as long as I had the smarts to still go into software). Jump back to 1991 as a 20yr old and head to the recruitment fair stalls of Sun Microsystems / DEC / Apple / Adobe / Microsoft.

Google search and showers that stay hot are pretty nice, but the relative difficulty of accessing quality education, jobs, and housing probably turn out to be much more significant as you exit your 20s in 2031 and think about starting a family.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by bcantrill on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:47AM (#28156998)
You may want to reconsider before you step into the time machine. First of all, 1991 in particular is a tough year -- it was a crushing recession in the US, and young people were having a really hard time finding jobs. So you wouldn't be "heading to the recruitment stalls" for any of those companies except potentially Microsoft. And this is absolutely the "why-are-manhole-covers-round" era of Microsoft, and it's the DOS era as well -- so not only is the company smarmy, its products are buggy, demoralizing piles of death-marched junk. Read the (excellent) Showstopper! for a hint of what awaits you at Microsoft.

There's a big difference between 1991 and just a few years later of course, but even when I graduated from college (1996), Microsoft was absolutely suffocating. I had decided that I wanted to work for a computer company and that I had zero interest in working on Windows NT(or Copland). This left one company, Sun Microsystems, which even in 1996 was not really recruiting at universities. I got a job there by cold e-mailing a Sun engineer (Jeff Bonwick) based on a Usenet post in comp.unix.solaris. (Cold e-mailing to get a job was so unusual that a friend of mine who was a reporter for the AP wrote a story about my job search -- and it was broadly picked up nationally![0]) At Sun, I was the youngest person in OS development by a decade, and the industry broadly thought Sun to be foolish for insisting on innovating in the operating system. Conventional wisdom was wrong, of course, and I had a great 14-year run at Sun that I wouldn't trade for anything -- but it would be a mistake to overly romanticize what was honestly a pretty crappy era.

[0] I talked about this briefly in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IznEq2Uf2xk, including an (embarrassing) photo of me ca. 1996 that ran as the front page of many business sections around the US

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by thundergolfer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @08:09PM (#28163523)
It's great to get this extra perspective from you Bryan, because you're probably the person whose talks have most made me interested in seeing 1990s Sun Microsystems et al. Point taken about 1991's struggles. I was vaguely aware that it was a troubled time, but took the premise as is. Which particular part of the 90s was best seems an awkward question. Were things generally getting better through the 90s until dot-com bust turned everything to shit?

Thanks for the book recommendation. I've added it to my Goodreads list. I'll checkout the talk too. I haven't seen that one of yours, because I saw the title and figured it was heavy on memory-management and pretty out of my wheelhouse.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by bcantrill on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:09PM (#28164077)
It's hard to know -- but something that definitely struck me was that we at Sun did much better technical work in the bust (2001-2005) than the boom (1997-2001). (It's hard to say anything definitive about this as there is so much there that's specific to Sun and the group of technologists I was working with, but it certainly didn't make me long for the boom!)

As for the progression of software development, this may be trite to say, but in my opinion the single most important revolution in software is the rise of open source. I don't think that there was a single event here per se but rather a multi-decade long progression across many different domains that has changed just about every single aspect of software development. (Cloud computing too, certainly -- but I don't think that cloud computing is economically viable without open source.) So software development from the 1990s is unrecognizable in large part because it is just so damned proprietary -- which, as it turns out, was in fact a relatively short blip in the fullness of history.[0]

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zpnncakrelk, in which I expand a bit on the history of open source, among other things

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by thundergolfer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:29PM (#28164225)
I'm early enough my career to not at all find it trite. Open-source has certainly been the most exciting and fulfilling aspect of my software work so far. If I was thrown back to the 90s with knowledge of 2020s open-source culture, I'd be frustrated as hell.

I didn't fully appreciate how important open-source is as a 21st century movement until I read The Cathedral and the Bazaar this year. Hearing the open-source development story of SQLite also blew my mind a little.

I can see why you're so energized by open-source firmware.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by bcantrill on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:13PM (#28164528)
Yes! The final two frontiers (or, among the final two frontiers, anyway) of proprietary software are firmware and EDA software. I am (as you noted!) very bullish about both, and I think that open firmware + open EDA will lead to a new golden age of HW/SW co-design -- it's a great time to be a software engineer, and it's only going to get better!
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by jjav on Thursday August 12, 2021 @07:01PM (#28162761)
> So you wouldn't be "heading to the recruitment stalls" for any of those companies except potentially Microsoft.

Late '91 I was graduating soon and I did go to the university recruiting stalls of Sun and IBM and Motorola. DEC was a presence but I loved SunOS and didn't like VMS so didn't talk to them. Never considered Microsoft since I hated them so much already back then.

Ended going in a different direction due to a graduate degree scholarship but thinking back maybe should've joined Sun directly back then. I did later end up at Sun a few years later, roughly same timeframe as you.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by namdnay on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:30AM (#28156056)
Now I could understand this as a blue collar worker, but you’re saying you’d prefer to be a software engineer in 91 than 2021? Come on, of pretty much all the professions were the ones who have reaped the most benefits of the past 30 years
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by ghaff on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:42AM (#28156226)
Arguably in 1991, you're getting in on the ground floor but it's a mixed bag. Your new grad salary is probably going to be around $40K or so in the US. And dot-bomb is 10 years in the future.

And that list of companies is sort of a mixed bag.

Adobe has mostly done pretty well through the years.

Sun Microsystems did have a very good decade through the dot-com years but then didn't.

Apple was really struggling at that time.

DEC was on the way down and would be bought by HP a few years later.

Microsoft was about to launch Windows NT so that was a pretty good place to hop on but obviously went on to have a long period of stagnation.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by cmrdporcupine on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:09AM (#28156572)
Indeed it predates my entrance to the industry by a half-decade but one thing that's notable about this period is the technology stacks being built during it would in large part be heavily de-emphasized later when the web exploded.

If you were at Apple, you'd be working on a platform (Mac OS classic, or Copland, or Newton) that would be thrown away by the end of the decade.

If you were working at DEC, likewise. (VMS, VAX, even Alpha)

Sun is more complicated, as they pivoted better and took longer to die. That would be a good place to be maybe.

1991 is an awkward year since it's about 2-3 years before the HTTP/browser revolution.

One thing though is that to my eye when I look at what these companies were working on then, it all seems more interesting to me now. The actual employment of a programmer (who wasn't stuck in finance or insurance etc. doing COBOL) had the potential to do some stuff that we at least thought Was going to be groundbreaking back then. NewtonOS and Alpha and Copland, CORBA, PowerPC/PREP, OS/2, research projects like Sun's "Self", etc. it was all exciting stuff. Just very little of it went on to be used later.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by ghaff on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:18AM (#28156670)
For me, Sun definitely looks like the most attractive company on that list. (Though Microsoft might well have been a perfectly good job.)

For one thing, you'd have been much more plugged into the coming internet revolution broadly than any of the others. You'd also have been at least connected to the open source world although Sun resisted aspects of it in many ways.

They were also primarily in Silicon Valley unlike the others.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by bluedino on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:35AM (#28156847)
The 90's had all kinds of tech companies starting. Many of them didn't last, but there was a lot of exciting stuff going on.

Early cell phones. PDA's like Palm. Printer market was hot. Businesses were networking their computers like crazy. The PC accessory market was hot. Video games like the Playstation were about to come out. Dial up online services and then ISP's. The web appeared.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by namdnay on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:09AM (#28156574)
I guess if you had hindsight it would be great, just live very frugally, choose the right company and above all buy as much real estate as possible in SV :)
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by pessimizer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:39PM (#28159198)
> Your new grad salary is probably going to be around $40K or so in the US.

Of course $40K then is $80K now, and you were working at 9-5 at BigCo, with a pension plan. Interest rates were 3-4x what they are now, the value of the house that you spent a couple of years salary on is probably going to quintuple, and the stock market runup over the next 30 years is going to be unreal.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by ghaff on Thursday August 12, 2021 @03:20PM (#28160343)
>the stock market runup over the next 30 years is going to be unreal

Not counting the stock market plunge especially in tech in the dot-bomb era when there's a good change you'll also lose your tech job and very possibly be very underemployed for a few years. Of course if you hold on through that (and 2008), you'll come out well on the other side.

And if you were 20 in 91, you probably don't have a house in ten years in pricey (just not eye-watteringly so) SV 9 years later when the bottom falls out of the market.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by mywittyname on Thursday August 12, 2021 @02:37PM (#28159850)
You might also be describing 2021-2051.

Well, except pension, which were largely gutted in the private sector by 1991 (it was the plot of the 1987 movie Wall Street).

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by mech422 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:19AM (#28156681)
I moved from Wall St. to the West coast in the 90s. Both paid above average programmer salaries for the time, but S.V. was the place to be for tech. So much going on, so much demand.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by thundergolfer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @07:54PM (#28163375)
I'm sure the day-to-day experience of building software is generally much better in 2021, but as others have noted there are other reasons to start in 1991.

- Particularly interesting point in history for software (pre-Netscape!) - Build lots of experience before Google, Netflix, and FB are even born. - Incredible compounded returns in software stocks (and great returns in housing)

2021 is a great time to be a 20yr old software dev, but it's also a great time to be a 50yr old software dev who has 30 yrs of experience, stock market returns, and housing investment.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by wolverine876 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:13AM (#28156615)
The political dangers are orders of magnitude worse now, plus there is climate change (a product of the same political problems). I'll take 1991, but without this future.

Also, IME, the culture has become hateful, poisonous, and based on trauma, despair, and survival rather than hope and dreams, freedom and self-actualization.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by devnull3 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:37AM (#28156869)
> I'll take 1991, but without this future.

May be with memory wipe of currently what you know and the way the world is

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nemo44x on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:29AM (#28156034)
2021 if only for the health improvements without trying: - You grew up in an era of not inhaling cancerous smoke everywhere you go - Even unhealthy foods are less unhealthy due to removing hydrogenated fats from foods (god were they tasty though) - Cars are safer than ever - The environment is cleaner than it has been in decades

The past always looks better. People still want to return to the 50's and most of them were not alive then.

However, I believe every generation has had it "better" generally speaking than the previous and that's how it should be. Certain era's had things that were probably better but this era has things that future generations will envy as well while also having it "better" generally speaking.

Today is this best time to be alive and I'm optimistic tomorrow will be even better.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by Clubber on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:42AM (#28156220)
>You grew up in an era of not inhaling cancerous smoke everywhere you go

A recent study (2013) suggests that the idea that second hand smoke has a direct link to cancer wasn't entirely accurate.

https://academic.oup.com/jnci/article/105/24/1844/2517805

>Even unhealthy foods are less unhealthy due to removing hydrogenated fats from foods

I would say food is far more unhealthy today than in 1991. There is sugar and bastardized sugar in everything. Sugar is addictive and food manufacturers use it to get people addicted to their food. Instead of eating for nutrition, people eat for that sugar hit, and you almost can't escape it. Try finding prepackaged foods in the grocery store without some form of sugar in it.

https://www.addictioncenter.com/drugs/sugar-addiction/

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by TigeriusKirk on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:21AM (#28156715)
I was in my early 20s in 1991, and I'd easily pick 2021. The 1990s were a great time to have as my formative period, and it was fun to ride the web from gopher to mobile.

But the 2020s are going to be a transformational decade too, with a lot to learn and experience, and a ton of opportunities. Far more chaotic than the 1990s, but honestly that suits me personally. I thrive on that.

I would pick the 90s over the 2000s or 2010s though.

Well, I'd go back to the 2010s and buy even more bitcoin than I did, but other than that, I could skip that decade.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by rufus_foreman on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:08AM (#28156556)
I'm trying to imagine being back in the late 80's living in the squat or in the animal house I lived in during the early 90's and having this guy time travel back to tell us about the future.

"You mean we don't all die in a nuclear war or from AIDS or global warming?"

"No, the future is much better! Riding lawn mowers are cheaper, teddy bears are much more cuddly and silky, board games have been revolutionized and you can get goat cheese at Walmart!"

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:16AM (#28156643)
It might go a little something like this: https://sfdebris.com/videos/special/timewalker2020.php
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by inglor_cz on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:23AM (#28156735)
For a sexually active 20 y.o., 1971 was probably better than 1991. The threat of HIV had an enormous chilling effect on the casual dating scene.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by BuckRogers on Thursday August 12, 2021 @12:12PM (#28158074)
I'm going 91. I was there. I wasn't 20, but I was closer to 10. And 10 years old in decades past is about equal to 20 years old today, we experienced more. We had more freedom, we made more mistakes. More of us were likely beaten/raped/killed or otherwise died.. but we simply were less childlike, the generations that had analog childhoods. Less coddling. That was more true the further back you go, but there was a steep decline for children born around 1990 or after due to many factors. At least that's what I've observed.

Those quality of life improvements on that list are in reality pretty sad compared to the loss in social cohesion and quality of life in ways that matter more. You would think we didn't have indoor plumbing or antibiotics. We were in good shape. But the difference in pre and post 9/11 America is stark. This place was basically ruined on a social level, pure fear and panic, and it remains in different forms.

Now if you asked me if I'd rather be born in 1971 or 2021? I would say 2021. Because the last 20 years have been throwaway decades. Someone 20 years old in 2021 missed ALL of the good times, never saw America as it was, and has and will spend most of their life behind the 8 ball.

If you're born today, while there could definitely be more calamity, there's a good chance things turn up from the malaise of 2001-2021 in the next two decades. At least as it pertains to the working class. Which is most of us. Its been a great two decades for those that were running the show. But there's a reason why overall sentiment is and has been negative.

I'll take 20 in 1991, or 20 in 2041. But not 20 in 2021.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by icedchai on Thursday August 12, 2021 @07:20PM (#28162982)
I honestly feel this same way about the past 20 years. You captured it so well.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nivenkos on Thursday August 12, 2021 @08:56AM (#28155657)
'91 would be better though - better salaries in a lot of jobs, and lower house prices.

GPS on the phone is awesome, but I'd still prefer financial security.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by ghaff on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:26AM (#28155995)
>better salaries in a lot of jobs

Factory jobs that is probably true in general--though you're still into the period when a lot of traditional union manufacturing jobs were leaving (or had left) the country.

As an engineer/software developer, you're probably going to be paid about $40K for an entry-level position [ADDED: For the US at a "tech" company]. And there is basically no equivalent to routine FAANG SWE salaries.

Housing is cheaper (relatively) in some locations although the Bay Area was still relatively expensive. Manhattan was considered the high-priced place to live at the time.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by mech422 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:27AM (#28156768)
I was making $50K/year as a developer on Wall St. with 2-3 years professional experience...and it was awesome. And yes, the HFT guys got 'FAANG' salaries. HFT was in its infancy, and those guys were making bank!

While the absolute numbers may seem small by today's standards, it was more then enough for a single 20something to have the time of their lives. Even paying Manhattan rents, we were out 5-6 nights a week clubbing and partying

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nemo44x on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:14AM (#28156624)
There are many factory jobs today and companies have a difficult time filling them. They are not the monotonous, repetitive jobs of assembly line work (that has been outsourced) but rather involve some skill that you'll be taught. But it's hard to find people to fill these roles as qualified candidates in many cases think the jobs are below them (college educated but can't find work in their field) or they simply don't want to show up every day and work.

Many people today choose lifestyle centered work (gig economy, part time roles for short term, etc) rather than work that lets them build a life. I have multiple friends that have gone this route out of high school with no college and started at the bottom and have over the years acquired more skills and knowledge and some have moved into supervisory and management roles after their companies financed some additional skills like using spreadsheets, basic management, etc.

The endless stories of people that start, work a week and get a check, don't show for 2 weeks and then come back thinking they are still employed is amazing. The jobs exist and they pay well, but not enough people want them.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nivenkos on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:16AM (#28156647)
If people don't want them, then they don't pay enough (or have other issues - work safety, etc.). That's how the market works...
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nemo44x on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:38AM (#28156882)
It could be, but really I think it's more than that. These jobs pay really well and they offer a career ladder. You will be able to buy a home, have children, take vacations. But you need to show up every day and work. A lot of people who would be qualified for these types of jobs don't want to do that. They'd rather pick and choose and float around at places for less money and less financial security.

This isn't like fast food restaurants having trouble hiring people at minimum wage because stimmy checks pay more than working. People come in and they want the job and they work a week or 2 and then disappear after they get paid and then come back when they need money again. That type of work ethic just isn't compatible with this kind of career so they end up at an Amazon warehouse, driving Ubers, and delivering food instead since that does support their lifestyle choice.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 12, 2021 @11:50AM (#28157819)
> These jobs pay really well and they offer a career ladder. You will be able to buy a home, have children, take vacations. But you need to show up every day and work.

They obviously do not pay commensurate to the risks of job loss, lack of quality of life at a job, and/or to make up for the undesirability for the location they are in.

The proof is the data showing wages for factory type work stagnating for many decades now (until the recent few years). People incorporate that knowledge, and let their kids know that those jobs are not worth investing in. How many factory towns are there where the factory closes or downsizes and the whole town goes into economic decline? You need to pay a lot to offset that kind of risk.

The other proof is also that I bet they can get lots of qualified applicants that will “show up everyday and work”. Just offer $200k per year. Or $500k per year. Obviously the purchasers of that type of labor are not offering enough money.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nemo44x on Thursday August 12, 2021 @03:18PM (#28160311)
> They obviously do not pay commensurate to the risks of job loss, lack of quality of life at a job, and/or to make up for the undesirability for the location they are in.

I mean, there's a lot of alcoholism problems and drug issues too.

>People incorporate that knowledge, and let their kids know that those jobs are not worth investing in.

I'm not sure the wisdom of the crowds is a great example here. How many kids are in many thousands of debt and working at dead end jobs or as a barista, etc. because they got a useless degree from a third rate university?

> How many factory towns are there where the factory closes or downsizes and the whole town goes into economic decline? You need to pay a lot to offset that kind of risk.

I don't think I'm describing factory town style jobs of yesteryear. There are many solid jobs in tool and die, machining, etc that are mainly run by small to mid-sized shops. Literally thousands of these around the country.

There are a lot of people making a great living in these places, it's just that there's a shortage of qualified labor. Similar to software companies - there's a shortage of labor and it isn't because they aren't paying enough. Additionally, a lot of people think this kind of work is below them because they went to a university to study a field that they can't make it in.

> The other proof is also that I bet they can get lots of qualified applicants that will “show up everyday and work”. Just offer $200k per year. Or $500k per year. Obviously the purchasers of that type of labor are not offering enough money.

Yeah probably but I'm not sure that's economic. Also, the starting pay won't be the best but you rise fairly quickly through the ranks where the money improves. But like I said before, there are a lot of people making a good life for themselves with a home, a family, vacations, and a solid American life in these places. This life exists for people. But you would think it isn't even available - but it is.

Kids complain that they are 50k in debt from school, can't find a job that pays well and will never be able to afford a home or have kids. But that's not true. There's a career out there in modern manufacturing if they are willing to humble themselves.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 12, 2021 @04:30PM (#28161029)
> Additionally, a lot of people think this kind of work is below them because they went to a university to study a field that they can't make it in.

People think it is "below them" because they saw the people who went into white collar professions in their parents' generation come out ahead. Pay enough (and advertise the pay) and people's perception will change.

>But you would think it isn't even available - but it is.

Where are the job postings showing the pay and benefits? Why do the stats indicate the wages not increasing much?

>There's a career out there in modern manufacturing if they are willing to humble themselves.

The situation might have changed recently, but those jobs have definitely not paid sufficiently for the past few decades to make it a worthwhile investment. This is shown by definition, since they are complaining about lack of candidates for the job positions. If they paid appropriately and competitively, by definition people would have opted to work those jobs.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nemo44x on Thursday August 12, 2021 @05:44PM (#28161926)
I’m not sure and maybe the type of work I’m describing isn’t traditional manufacturing. Machining and welding for instance are skilled trades but a big part of modern manufacturing. Tool and dye press setup is another and one of many entry paths.

We hear the same things in other non-manufacturing trades though like plumbing and carpentry and HVAC, etc. companies struggle to find reliable people when the money is good and prospects are stable.

One contractor I had was a Ukrainian man with a math degree but went into tile work when he moved here because he found he could make more money doing it. Smart man in our conversations and humble but is massively in-demand in the general area because he’s so good at it and he’s paid like it.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nivenkos on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:38AM (#28156166)
My entry level software job was $35k in 2015 in London! Outside the US, jobs across the board paid a lot more before 2008.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by jjav on Thursday August 12, 2021 @07:14PM (#28162925)
> '91 would be better though - better salaries in a lot of jobs

Not in tech though. Engineering jobs paid middle-class level well, but nothing out of the ordinary for white-collar professionals. Starting salaries were in the 30Ks for top offers in rich companies but many people started in the 20Ks. You had to be Sr.Dir/VP level to start getting close to 100K.

The concept of engineers with a few years of experience making more salary than top-level surgeons was inconceivable. So purely on a financial sense, it's much better to be a new grad in software today than in '91.

Still, I'd rather be paid 35K doing ground-breaking UNIX kernel or networking work than be paid 500K building yet another adware/spyware social app.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by technothrasher on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:23AM (#28155961)
I was 20-years old in 1991. It was good.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by mech422 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:23AM (#28156727)
yeah - I enjoyed it...
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by hiddencache on Thursday August 12, 2021 @08:52AM (#28155622)
Nevermind came out in 91, and it did feel like the beginning of something...
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by creaturemachine on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:54AM (#28157090)
This was the first thing that came to mind. Rock & Roll may have died in this decade but the innovation of the 90's made it worth it. I fear for 2031 once the tik tok-ification of music has run its course.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by RegBarclay on Thursday August 12, 2021 @11:27AM (#28157523)
I was 23 in 1991. It was OK, but just yesterday I was talking with a twentysomething guy who was playing for me a song he'd written using GarageBand on his phone. I told him, man, I wish I'd had YouTube and GarageBand when I was his age. It's really hard to say what I'd do. I'd probably not change anything. I've noticed that computer technology isn't really anything special to my kids. I'm not sure I would have taken up an interest in programming as a youth in 2021 as I did in the 80s and 90s.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by titzer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @03:04PM (#28160150)
The more I think about this, the more I realize that you pick almost any time in history and if you were wealthy and powerful, it was freaking awesome. Can you imagine what the life of a Roman Caesar was like? Or a Rockefeller or Windsor?

Similarly for life at the bottom. In almost any period in history, life at the bottom sucked hard.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by ghaff on Thursday August 12, 2021 @08:55AM (#28155642)
There are a lot of things that younger people in particular take for granted today that were basically not available in 1990. I occasionally think that if I had to go back to 1990 and do my job as a product manager, I'd probably quit in frustration over just not having the information I needed to do my job.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by everdrive on Thursday August 12, 2021 @08:59AM (#28155685)
But you'd only be competing against other similarly hampered project managers. Depending on how well you worked without the modern internet, you'd simply find your same place in the bell curve.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by ghaff on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:02AM (#28155719)
Well, sure. It would just be incredibly frustrating. As would lack of information generally.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by seanc on Thursday August 12, 2021 @04:33PM (#28161071)
I was in my 20's in the 90's. It's tough to say. On the one hand I feel like I was the last generation to take a mid-level software salary and pay off a degree and a "short commute" detached house before I was 40.

On the other hand, since I was in my 20's in the 90's I was a young child in the 70's and 80's when nerds were to be bullied, gay people were to be beaten, and God help you if you were Trans. That's still the case in much of the world, but looking at how my kids grew up, vastly improved since then.

So as a nerd, yes, the 90's were probably better for 20 year old me, but the 10's were definitely better for the 10 year old me.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by jjav on Thursday August 12, 2021 @06:51PM (#28162645)
> An incredible number of people pick ‘91.

Not so incredible I guess. I was 20 in '91 so can relate.

Computers and the internet were seriously exciting at the time, uncommercialized and pure hacker culture of exploration. We were building technology because it was exciting. The concept of building adware or spyware didn't exist. Today a startup going to "make the world a better place" is a sitcom joke, back then it was truly the feeling.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by icedchai on Thursday August 12, 2021 @07:12PM (#28162899)
Yes, I feel the same way. I was only 15 back in 1991, but was involved with BBSes, Usenet, early ISPs, etc. The "early commercial Internet" years (1991 - 1996 or so) were so much fun.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by bennyp101 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:24AM (#28155970)
I was 7 then, and just getting into computers - playing with BASIC on the CPC464) so being 20 then would have been awesome, although I’d be proper old now ;)
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by mech422 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:20AM (#28156706)
sigh So I'm 'proper old' now ? :-P

When can I be 'improper old' ?? :-D

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by jrsj on Thursday August 12, 2021 @03:10PM (#28160219)
I’d just like to go just far enough back to not be around for WW2 so I have to spend the least amount of time in the 21st century as possible. So I guess stick me in 1946.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by bambataa on Thursday August 12, 2021 @02:07PM (#28159490)
I’d pick 20 in 1991 just to be there for the original rave scene!
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by BrianOnHN on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:05AM (#28155754)
I don't work for tech companies, but I've never been "discriminated against" as a white guy.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by hncurious on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:30AM (#28156045)
That misdirection is convenient for the upper class, not so convenient for the rest of us.
[dead]
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by hncurious on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:34AM (#28156113)
You're clearly not familiar with hiring in tech. It's 2% because the available pool is tiny. It's not for lack of trying to hire non-white, non-asians in tech. Tech minorities are in fact prioritized in hiring AND there are countless programs to increase the pool. Aimed at girls and tech minorities, not white and asian boys.
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by dang on Thursday August 12, 2021 @02:57PM (#28160074)
If you post flamewar comments again we will ban you. We've had to warn you before.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[dead]
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by dang on Thursday August 12, 2021 @02:58PM (#28160079)
If you post flamewar comments again we will ban you. We've had to warn you before.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by LightG on Friday August 13, 2021 @07:28AM (#28167683)
Understood. I apologise though the aggrecious level was off the scale.

I thought it was quite a poetic and appropriate response at the time rather than flamewar'ish, but you're right.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by nivenkos on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:43AM (#28156232)
I'm not American, yet almost all Tech companies have inherited this Identity Politics culture.

It feels like such a huge step backwards to have scholarships, fast track programmes, etc. rule out great applicants solely based on their skin colour.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by moron4hire on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:00AM (#28155700)
Being a white guy in 2021 is easy sailing.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by inglor_cz on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:27AM (#28156770)
In the USA, perhaps. Though I doubt it even there, a lot of the rural underperforming regions are mostly white.

In Belarus or Moldova, definitely not.

People somehow forget that being white is not the same as being white American. There is a lot of dirty poor whites living under dubious regimes elsewhere. Whiteness is not really a thing.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by dc-programmer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:59AM (#28157147)
Early 90s Eastern Europe would be a tough environment for a 18 year old. There was a lot of friction moving away from from the old system (not that Belarus living in 2021 is that much easier)
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by whitepaint on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:06AM (#28155770)
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by light_hue_1 on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:33AM (#28156088)
Oh my! Poor white people.

White people live on average 77 years white black people live 72 years on average. The HORROR! The white man's burden to have more money and live longer! Truly the catastrophe of the 21st century.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by BuckRogers on Thursday August 12, 2021 @11:59AM (#28157913)
Wow. You clearly are not connected with the broader white community, even if you're white yourself. Or just too young to see reality yet. I'm from the midwest, which removes a lot of the privilege on the coasts, normal people live here, not nearly as many silver spoons and generational wealth. Opioid and suicide death is through the roof compared to decades before. I knew many people personally that are now gone. If you hate white people, you should be very happy in 2021. Because as the backbone of America by default as the majority, they're under assault by corporate America to squeeze them for everything they're worth. Whether that's reducing their wages through offshore labor or effects of NAFTA, or by default as the majority group pushed pain pills by unscrupulous docs and big pharma.

Your generalization may be reality in your area, if you go outside at all and not just reading regurgitated politically motivated crap online. But I'm not seeing it on the ground, in the broad swaths of middle America.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by Clubber on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:17PM (#28158924)
To use your logic in another period, in 1300, the king was white, all the nobles were white, the clergy was white. White people in England in the 1300s must have had it pretty easy.

"Having it easy," is about class not race. Making it about race is a political motive to divide the lower and middle class to keep the status quo. You might thing what you are doing is virtuous, but it's just maintaining the status quo for all races in the middle and lower class.

Go visit Appalachia. Wanna see poor of all races, go visit just about anywhere outside a city / metropolitan area.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by BrianOnHN on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:03AM (#28155732)
I 100% agree. I was mostly referring to the fact that '91 was more difficult for other races, genders, and sexualities.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by seniorThrowaway on Thursday August 12, 2021 @11:01AM (#28157175)
That's almost an unfair comparison. I don't know how old you are but 1991 was an incredibly optimistic time in western history with the fall of communism in Europe. Maybe a closer comparison would be 2000 vs 2019, both years right before a big global event.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by saltcured on Thursday August 12, 2021 @12:50PM (#28158606)
Overly simplifying my memories as a west coast US teenager in that era, the very late 1980s were a time of cautious optimism with news such as the solidarity movement in Poland and the fall of the Berlin Wall. However, 1989 in many ways felt like the peak. Soon after, such global optimism was soured by the Gulf War, Serbian civil war, etc. We weren't as aware or focused on other positive changes that may have been happening elsewhere.

Edit to add: in many ways, the apparent close of the Cold War just removed that one bilateral threat from center attention. In its place, we gained a new awareness of much more fragmented conflict scattered all over the world...

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by anticodon on Thursday August 12, 2021 @10:54AM (#28157081)
Destruction of the USSR in 1991 gave a boost to the Western economies by eliminating a strong competitor and opening a new huge market.

While you enjoyed your life in 1991, people around me literally died of hunger, because Gorbachev and Yeltsin and their advisors from USA killed almost all the industry on the former USSR territory overnight. People lost jobs, people lost savings, people lost meaning of life overnight.

It's a biggest case of genocide since 1940s, that is silenced and undocumented.

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by CryptoPunk on Thursday August 12, 2021 @02:38PM (#28159854)
The USSR destroyed itself. It was bankrupt by 1989:

https://www.nytimes.com/1989/01/22/world/soviets-foresee-bud...

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by Clubber on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:05AM (#28155755)
1991. Less Orwellian. Back then, 1984 was a warning, not an instruction manual.
Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by ggreer on Thursday August 12, 2021 @05:24PM (#28161690)
In 1991, distributing encryption software was a violation of US munitions controls.[1] At the time, it was not at all clear whether encryption software would remain legal for individuals to own and use. The US government was considering mandating backdoors in all consumer encryption, culminating in the development of the Clipper chip.[2]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_th...

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip

Re:Life Improvements Since the 1990s by alexshendi on Thursday August 12, 2021 @09:58AM (#28156420)
Today, 1984 feels like an Utopia.