Even Google Chrome includes a built-in ad blocker (which only blocks ads on sites that display non-Google ads), so Google would have no moral standing to claim that Piped is unethical:
That is a disclaimer saying that I am not speaking on behalf of my employer.
May be it is their lobbying and marketing that has you convinced?
> Apple doesn't personalize ads, but they are instead working hard to kill open computing which is way worse than personalizing ads in my opinion.
Both these companies want to protect their core businesses and attempt to commodotize each others advantages all the time. It seems you are comfortable with personalised ads and that may be has skewed your opinion.
"I want to say that Google is unethical and ads are evil, but I've never actually worked on ads and actually don't know what data means in this context"
Also, would you morally expect your doctor to disclose that they're on the payroll of the company that develops the medications you've been prescribed to take? Regardless of the answer, disclosure here isn't about whether or not a doctor is capable of their own opinion, or whether or not they are speaking in any official capacity for other companies.
Ethical appearance is part of professional ethics.
Similarly, it doesn't matter if a judge is capable of independent opinion while having financial interests tied to the cases they preside over. The mere appearance of financial entanglement can stink up professional credibility. It would also be quite silly for a judge to respond with, "But I've only recently been receiving paychecks. I hardly know anyone at the company."
Is it really so hard to believe that some people don't agree with you on this point because they've seen different evidence than you have?
I'm just pointing out that we all have our biases. As somebody who understands how targeted advertising works from the "inside" I see a lot of commentary that is factually inaccurate and conceptually off base.
Do you think the fact that no one on the "outside" knows how it works may be the reason for that? Also, do you think that if we did know how it works from the inside that we would agree with you?
Any evidence for this claim, besides for your gut?
How do you explain all of the googlers who have resigned over Project X/Y/Z, or how Google handles sexual allegations, or who they do business with?
I don't work on ads or Youtube, and you have cause and effect reversed actually. It's not that I'm okay with ads because I work at Google. I was ok with ads long before I worked there.
I work at Google because I'm ok with ads. :)
So Google asks that people pay $12 a month to not see ads, but still uses watching behavior to build a user profile to advertise to in all other mediums.
Do I have this correct? How does google explain the value proposition? Is the real cost of YouTube (sans tracking) greater than $12 a month?
> Also use your activity and information from Google services to personalise ads on websites and apps that partner with Google to show ads. This stores data from websites and apps that partner with Google in your Google Account.
Unchecking this means (as I understand it) that, among other things, your YouTube watching behaviour will not be used for ad targeting on non-Google websites.
(That's about non-Google websites, but as I type the above, I just realized that maybe by "all other mediums" you meant other Google sites, like Google Search etc. But those already covered under "Ad personalisation" (the main toggle at https://adssettings.google.com/) so I'm not quite sure the premise of the question is correct.)
However, it's important to distinguish this completely reasonable point, that the product may be overpriced or provide less value than it should, vs an argument that Google is "unethical" for offering it.
I would speculate that the average and 95th percentile customer experience with tracking is so astronomically better on average, across nearly all dimensions, that even after paying, fewer than 5% of users would prefer the no-tracking/personalization product experience.
Personalized ads isn't just about getting you to click more. It's also about showing you fewer irrelevant ads. In fact on many sites that's way more important.
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/05/96-of-us-users-opt-o...
https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/united-sta...
https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide
Based on this data, it seems extremely unlikely that 95% of users would prefer the "customer experience with tracking" on YouTube or any other mainstream social media site.
From where I'm standing, Apple masterfully manipulated their users into adopting a worldview that transfers future cash flows from other tech giants to Apple.
It's great for me as an Apple shareholder, but just another punch in a bout amongst the titans.
I am not really sure they manipulated me into switching to the iPhone, as much as they produced a product that advertised the things I want, and that I can get nowhere else.
That is, if you run a randomized AB test where some users lose personalization, then ask everyone "are you enjoying Facebook", the responses are much better for the users who have personalization.
Because the number 96 is large, it's not the case that some ads-averse subpopulation made an individually optimal choice.
You either have to reject my empirical claim about surveys, or you have to agree that these users made a choice that is worse for them on timescales of 1-2 months. (There's room for an argument that they're worse off in the short term by opting out but everyone will be better off in the long term, but then we're no longer debating individual preferences)
The people who are being presented with rage inducing topics that they feel their circle of friends are fighting agaisnt from personalization of their feed from a mix of old and new content is likely to say they enjoy Facebook over the old feed where a friend of a friend from high school is posting baby pictures again and people are actually just living normal lives not being shaped by a desire for clout.
Facebooks personalization seems to just send me to more and more content that makes me angry. Some people may find some pleasure in that, I suppose, but rejecting the temptation is not a suboptimal choice, like rejecting the 3rd beer is not a bad idea, even if you want it right now.
And I don't think it is unrealistic that ~everybody is adverse to ads, but I think it is fairly likely that everybody who has seen apples privacy ads are going to think what Facebook and others do as creepy and opt out based on that.
Finally I nearly always say no or give a low rating for those popups, because I find the popups annoying.
Dupuit explained it all in four simple words. It's not out of vindictiveness, or even saving money Instead, it all boils down to this: "To scare the rich."
...
It is not because of the several thousand francs which they would have to spend to cover the third class wagons or to upholster the benches. ... [I]t would happily sacrifice this [expense] for the sake of its popularity.
Its goal is to stop the traveler who can pay for the second class trip from going third class. It hurts the poor not because it wants them to personally suffer, but to scare the rich.
https://www.inc.com/bill-murphy-jr/why-does-air-travel-suck-...
Jules Dupuit was a 19th century French engineer and economist.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jules_Dupuit
His insights on nonrivalrous public services and induced upselling apply across any number of goods and services. That would include informational and online ones.
This is before one considers the inherent bias of A/B testing and "market choice" mechanics generally to short-term highly-attractive options, and disregard of long-term value, long-term risks, and of less apparent or manifest value and benefits (see Robert K. Merton on manifest vs. latent functions).
ads are not unethical per se. what i find unethical is the on by default tracking apparatus/personalized ads following me around and trying to learn what i like/want. show me random ads like billboards first, and if i want tracking, i'll tell you.
This leads to a sign in page. Is it possible to opt out of ads personalisation without a Google account?
I don't think that they're straw-manning, I think that they're simply not trying to persuade. The tool is meant for those who are already sold on privacy, and they didn't want to waste time that could have been spent explaining the tool.
Viewers can opt out of ads personalisation but can uploaders opt out of "monetisation". Morever, can viewers and uploaders opt out of surveillance, data collection and how the collected data is used.
Even if you could be 100% certain the ads being pushed on people against their wishes were not harmful to them directly, (and there is plenty of evidence that ads have caused great harm to people and their health) the entire system that enables and sustains targeted advertising is downright abusive and dangerous. Only the most narrow view of the issue could support the idea that it wasn't an ethical mine field and google's implementation specifically is full of problems.
"The Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Web Search Engine" http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html
I think that when we weigh the harm against the good, we're likely to disagree about the balance. But I think I have more information about the good than people who have not worked at Google or Facebook, and I have just as much information about the potential and actual harm.
NSA getting caught pwning google would be a snowden-esque nightmare for them. Now some backroom deal between NSA and google for SOME data would be more believable, it never hurts to align incentives and have a three letter agency owe you a favor when senator so-and-so starts banging the break up & regulate big tech drum.
Substitute "creators" with "collaborators" and maybe it'll be more obvious to you why this is a flawed argument. Anyway, I don't think you can even opt out of Youtube inserting advertisements into your uploads anymore, but back when you could it would result in a discoverability penalty.
If you made a band and sold me a recording on the condition that I not resell it, it would be unethical for me to resell it. I think it would be undesirable and annoying of you to resort to DRM to prevent me from reselling, but I'm still the one violating our agreement. I have no special "human right" to listen to your music (or watch your Youtube videos), but you should have the right to enforce agreements whose nonenforcement would harm only you.
> I still think it's unethical to serve monetized content without paying the original "collaborator".
So you're not even going to seek the refuge of "their payment is the free bandwidth" argument and admit that Youtube is screwing a lot of people over?
> ...but you should have the right to enforce agreements whose nonenforcement would harm only you.
lol, "harm". Sure, you have a legal right to argue over the definition of "harm" - but you know you've retreated from "ethical" to "legal", right?
I agree that under your moral system, it's not wrong to deny the creators value, but that's sort of just a restatement of the fact that we disagree on the acceptability of ads in the first place.
In general I don't assign the label "unethical" to something unless I'm aware of a convincing case that the thing causes more harm than good, harm without appropriate equity, violates some other axiomatic principal that I agree to, etc. I just haven't heard a convincing case that ads meets any of those criteria.
You can add the use of "retreat" in the context of a value judgement to the list of disagreements, but the reframe into a legal argument makes our exchange largely pointless.
> ...unless I'm aware of a convincing case that the thing causes more harm than good...
Ah, yeah - we definitely won't agree on much of anything. I'm more of a first-principles/universality sort of guy... whereas it sounds like moral relativism is more your thing.
>> I think this is a case of straw-manning...
> I just haven't heard a convincing case that ads meets any of those criteria.
See what you did there? You created a strawman. There is a difference between "ads" and "Google using data to personalize ads". I've got no beef with the former, but you are arguing in defense of the latter.
To your last point, you can substitute one for the other, I stand by the original point in either case. I haven't heard a convincing case from first principles as to the wrongness of "Google using data to personalize ads". Generally the principle I hear in these cases is very close to "tracking or targeting is inherently wrong", which I reject.
Not as you've described it, as a real objective thing that is a social construct. I agree that it is a social construct, and I agree that it is "like language", because I'd describe morality as, at the very least, an internally coherent social construct. "more harm than good" has no logical constraint and easily permits the violation of every prior principal while affording no solid ground upon which to build, by design.
> To your last point, you can substitute one for the other...
Cool, so long as you're aware that there exists the possibility of data-hoard-free advertising - and that it was common prior to recent Internet centralization.
> I haven't heard a convincing case from first principles...
That is because, like ad-blockers, it isn't wrong. Good luck trying to construct on internally coherent system of morals that blesses the present state of data-broker panopticon while at the same time condemning ad-blockers. If you can do that with something beyond "might makes right" then I'll be impressed.
> Right to Monetize
> You grant to YouTube the right to monetize your Content on the Service (and such monetization may include displaying ads on or within Content or charging users a fee for access). This Agreement does not entitle you to any payments.
https://www.youtube.com/static?gl=CA&template=terms
They more clearly state what it means over here: https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/83733719/updates-t...
> For channels not yet in the YouTube Partner Program:
> We added this new section to let you know that, starting today we’ll begin slowly rolling out ads on a limited number of videos from channels not in YPP. This means as a creator that’s not in YPP, you may see ads on some of your videos. Since you’re not currently in YPP, you won’t receive a share of the revenue from these ads, though you’ll still have the opportunity to apply for YPP as you normally would...
1) No possibility of generating an objection from the most sensitive of current and potential advertisers.
2) Do not compete with legacy media presently on platform.
Makes you wonder about all those outrage mobs that targeted companies with adverts that had the bad luck of randomly appearing in videos that demonstrated wrong-think, and how they've ushered in network television 2.0 while sticking it to all the totally-real-and-definitely-a-threat-to-our-democracy-neo-nazis.
I mean really, “Further I think products like this are actually unethical”? Did you really just jump to the defence of a near 2 trillion dollar company whose business model overtly threatens some of our most fundamental human rights?
For example, in your comment you take for granted that Google "overtly threatens some of our most fundamental human rights". I could imagine reasonable arguments that Google does some harm in some cases, and it would even be defensible to claim that Google does more harm than good for some groups of people (although I disagree). But the position you take as a given seems extreme to me and conflicts strongly with my conception of "human rights" and "overt".
There are numerous current (and past) legal cases against Google, including numerous antitrust / anticompetitive cases. Several of those hinge on influence and manipulation through that chief organ of a democratic society, media.
Google's role, and YouTube's specifically, in radicalisation, is rather well documented.
"How YouTube Built a Radicalization Machine for the Far-Right" (2018)
It's a target-rich search: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=how+youtube+radicalizes&ia=web https://www.thedailybeast.com/how-youtube-pulled-these-men-d...
Why do you type like an AI then?
AdSense is typically a small portion of a channel's revenue (I've heard a few creators say it's around 30%), and all of the costs to produce a video are sunk.
When someone with an ad blocker watches a video, they're still consuming the sponsored content, clicking on the affiliate links and buying the merch. From a business standpoint, they're still 70% as valuable as a "regular" viewer.
I've never heard a YouTube creator complain about ad blocker or ask people to "like, comment, subscribe and whitelist". Linus Tech Tips even made a guide a while back on how to set up Pi Hole and only asked that people "buy a shirt".
If they're not complaining, and people with ad blockers are still making them plenty of money, I don't agree with you that it's wrong.
This product also attempts to remove the other things you listed, including sponsored content (via SponsorBlock), ability to click affiliate links, ability to like or comment on the video, etc.
Advertising does not simply make people aware about some goods and services, it often works by manipulating peoples desires and fears. And to manipulate effectively, ad companies need to collect as much information as possible about every person. Google collects and manipulates at scale when it becomes a threat to society and culture.
For example, there was this one time when I had come across an ad on Facebook for a competition that I had found interesting. I applied, got selected, and eventually won a fully sponsored trip to NYC (worth about $4000).
Now, would I want my data to be leaked *outside* FB/Google datacenters out into the public? No. Would I want to be constantly interrupted while I am watching a video? No. But would I want ads that benefit me and help me? Yes, sign me up.
Also, regarding tracking, I believe tracking should be entirely optional (by law). Tracking certainly helps understand user preferences, and I personally always leave them on, because I want to help developers improve my experience. However, I do understand people wanting to turn them off, particularly on suspicious sites.
YouTubers share a percentage of the revenue with Google because it has a strangle-hold on online streaming. Platforms building frontends are chipping away at YouTube's moat within means which net neutrality and interoperability make it possible.
> I think that Google using data to personalize ads and recommend videos is ethically ok.
If viewers want nothing to do with YouTube, it is in creator's best interest then to engage with businesses building alternatives. If this niche service becomes any popular, then perhaps, the creators would do well to listen to their viewers, and a new model around revenue can be developed.
But I can paint a more specific picture. I don't think any of that tracking harms the user, and on the contrary it makes ads and products better. Unlike Google and most of the world, I also don't believe the data "belongs" to the user.
If you go to a website, the website owner should be allowed to tell anyone that you went there. I believe this should be protected speech, just as it would be protected speech if I saw you walk into my physical store and I sold that information to a third party.
I believe this because I think the world would be worse without personalized ads, and because banning it violates my moral principles regarding speech.
YouTube is a middle-man that has inserted itself between content creators and content consumers so they can collect rent, and they've happily fucked over content creators every single time it has served their bottom line to do so. Viewing YouTube ads supports YouTube more than it does content creators--you can make some argument that maybe the opaque monetization somehow benefits creators more than YouTube, but there can be no question that the power is firmly in YouTube's hands. It's bad for content creators, who have to constantly worry about frivolous copyright claims, demonetization, and the mysterious algorithm causing them to lose views and subscribers. And it's bad for consumers, who end up with a watered down and censored version of content, with the ubiquitious "like and subscribe!" and "this episode sponsored by" constantly being rammed down their throat even when using an adblocker.
If you want to support content creators, support content creators, not YouTube. I make recurring donations to a few different YouTube artists and they get more money from me than they would if I didn't use an adblocker.
That's not correct. The YT ad revenue split is 55% to the creator, 45% to YouTube. If it's the case that creators are getting a pittance, it's only because YT is getting even less.
> I make recurring donations to a few different YouTube artists and they get more money from me than they would if I didn't use an adblocker.
And the creators whose YT content you watch, but don't donate to? Would they perhaps be making less money?
There are many creators who don't only rely on unethical privacy invasive ads and support more ethical donations based support systems.
Just because a creator refuses to support a more ethical payment system, doesn't make it unethical to bypass participating in a system (the ad network) that actively harms you (by unethically violating your privacy).
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”
Either way, I joined recently and I'll leave at some point. My comings and goings from Google will have nothing to do with this, because it's not very important to me and I have always thought personalized ads were ethically ok.
Given that 80% of Google's revenue comes from ads[1], it would be incorrect to assume this.
Disclosure: Xoogler here.
[1]: https://abc.xyz/investor/static/pdf/2021Q1_alphabet_earnings...
I was pointing out that my salary does not depend on my beliefs about ads. My evidence is that many with opposite beliefs receive the same salary.
https://www.thoughtco.com/corn-pone-opinions-by-mark-twain-1...
What are you defining as "use of the data", in this case? Viewing their content? If so, that seems like a skewed way of phrasing it.
If I were a YouTuber, I would personally either be okay with or even actively encourage ad blocking/skipping. (Easy for one to say, I know, but, as light evidence, I have some popular open source projects and have run popular websites without ever displaying any sort of ads or sponsored content when I easily could have. And I've strongly considered the idea of trying to make YouTube videos regularly.)
I think I have a slightly different take on the issue compared to most people who dislike ads. I don't actually care much about the personalization or the data collection, as long as there isn't a way for an employee to easily drill down into specific people and track their individual activity by their real identity (i.e. a human manually stalking individuals personally, like a few Google and Facebook and NSA employees have occasionally been caught doing; I understand only a tiny percentage of them would ever do this).
I just inherently don't like advertisements and advertising. I don't want to see ads, anywhere, ever. I pay for YouTube Premium - I'd pay for Twitter Premium / etc., if I actually liked Twitter.
If that didn't exist: mine cryptocurrency in my browser if you want (as long as consent is requested) and give some of that to them. Or use something like Brave's attention token thing. Or anything else. Don't shove advertisements and sponsored segments in my face. Or, at least, ask if I want to see the ads, first, and let me choose "no".
I know it's difficult for content creators to make a living, and I know it's difficult to offer a service like YouTube or Twitter or Facebook for free. But I don't like this world of advertising. I want out. I hope there will be people like yourself who instead work towards building systems that let us slowly transition away from advertising models, like what Brave's trying to do.
1. To turn it on/off means they're still tracking it somehow regardless. I'm not logged into any google service on my machine right now, and yet disabling the features on the link above returned that it was turned off for this browser and device.
2. This was on by default
3. So it would seem that Google was tracking me even though I wasn't logged in as well as any other number of users; I wasn't using their services, yet I was generating data for Google without my consent at all.
4. I find your use of ethics here semantically deceptive; it's distracting the above actions of Google performing unauthorized collection of data on person(s) by discussing an action regarding the relationship of content creators and viewers.
5. Google's collection of data to personalize ads is unethical in that my data and my information, as well as the information of many others, without their explicit consent. In countries where GDPR is enforced, Google creates a full screen modal which does not allow you to advance without either blocking the element or agreeing to data collection, which is in direct violation of the letter and spirit of GDPR.
6. The discussion is not about whether ads are okay or not okay, it is about the system by which ads and data collected to sustain the ad system is generate is okay or not, which it is not for the above reasons and many more.
I cannot agree with any of your points as I see them as dismissive of the core issues and a justification of shady business practices that seek to simply gobble up information on all users regardless of whether they use Google's services or not.
These points you've raised do not address the behavior of Google nor the purposes of the application at all, and are only tangentially related to the comment on the ethics of modern advertising. The discussion about the content creators and the viewers is not Google's discussion -- Google is part of the system that hosts and pays the content creators, but the discussion about revenue streams for creators is one for the creators and their audience. Google trying to shoehorn themselves into such a discussion when alternate revenue streams exist that can be used. How creators want to handle that is their business. Arguably, Google has made this situation even worse for creators by:
- Reducing ad revenue for creators year after year
- Not providing contemporary features that other fast growing and dominant platforms have given their creators (see: Instagram, TikTok, and other contemporaries)
- By treating more substantial revenue streams for content creators aggressive until only very recently (previously it used to actively cut-off patreon links for small time channels that weren't part of the Partner system)
- By by providing the same level of tooling and control over works that other platforms do
- By aggressively demonetizing content creators that have any DCMA claim raised against them regardless of the validity of the claim
Google/Youtube and all of their partner items are aggressive towards consumers and abusive towards the content creators using its platforms. The actual good actors on these platforms suffer for minor clerical mistakes or because of aggressive automated systems that cannot be contested while bad actors continue to abuse the system and profit from it.
Users and content creators may have benefited from Google/Youtube and still have a dependency on its ad revenue, but it comes with extreme risk to rely on it now and with very sketchy behavior in order to support the system, all while Google and bad actors profit.
For the reasons above, I find your post extremely disingenuous, and your opinion on advertisements far too lackadaisical.
I also think your points about creator revenue with Google are valid and (some) are good criticisms of their business model. Where I disagree is believing any of these are "ethical" issues or that I should feel any worse working at Google vs working at a gas station that raises the price on potato chips.
We could dig down and try to find the more fundamental thing we disagree about. Currently from these comments, it seems like the crux of it is that many people believe that it's wrong for Google to use information Google collects about them to show personalized ads, while I disagree and do not think there's anything wrong with that.
The next step for my understanding would be to figure out why it is wrong for Google to collect and use this information. It doesn't bother me at all and I don't have any moral principles that this violates. What do you think?
Which one is it? Am I stupid or corrupt?
The actual explanation is very simple. I have more information available to me than you do, so I formed a different opinion about Google and targeted advertising. If you'd like I'd be happy to address more specific issues, my contact info is in my bio
Either your identity has to be kept separate (i.e. working there can't be something you're proud of) or you have to challenge or downplay the accusations, because they reflect upon you.
A great deal of googlers are proud of working there.
I worked for what many would call an unethical company for a while but I was never proud of it. When people talked about its behavior I would usually agree with them, but some of my coworkers were proud and they would defend it or try to downplay the accusations (e.g. we're not as bad as X).
Maybe consider the possibility that people disagree with you for reasons that have to do with their different evidence and experience rather than corruption?
>vast, clearly corrupt and abusive company
You assert much, and prove little. Adding up everything Google does, it seems to me that it comes up well into the positive side, though some of the things they do are bad.
You really should educate yourself on the harm these types of targeted ads and videos have caused before defending your employer.
https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/youtub...
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/jan/16/youtube-a...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/09/17/trumps-mo...
Your second link isn't even talking about bad ads or personalization. It's talking about bad content with good ads not wanting to be associated with the bad content.
> I think that Google using data to personalize ads and recommend videos is ethically ok.
Emphasis mine.
The videos and ads are hyper targeted to misinform people on some of the most important and dangerous topics of the day.
That one is easier for me to defend actually.
I've worked on video recommendation and misinformation integrity (tangentially) at Facebook. I promise as a disinterested ex employee that you are just factually wrong. Facebook and Google both spend 10s to 100s of millions per year specifically to reduce the spread of misinformation. It's a very difficult technical problem because of avoiding false positives (taking down acceptable content) and because there are state actors spending huge amounts of money trying to do the opposite.
There's no conspiracy here. You'd be right to say that Facebook has not done a perfect job, and that they didn't magically predict state actor election interference before 2016. But you'd be factually wrong to say that Facebook intentionally targets people with misinformation.
Any site as big as Facebook, Instagram, or Youtube would have the same problem.
In fact even though they can’t solve this problem, their entire business model is still built on the fact that anyone can target ads to a specific group to influence their behavior. And if they’re not showing ads then they are showing personalized content based on engagement and virality, which is not a measure of quality or truth, but one of shock and outrage. So no your employers’ behaviors are not ethical and I think you’d have to be delusional to think so.
That statement implies that "videos" are specifically shown to be with the intent to misinform people. In reality Facebook and Google do not do this intentionally, but by accident.
> their entire business model is still built on the fact that anyone can target ads to a specific group to influence their behavior
Not really, unless by "influence behavior" you mean "click on the ad". Ads just aren't that good, and neither Facebook nor Google want to make money off of misinformation.
> not a measure of quality or truth, but one of shock and outrage
No not really. Firstly Facebook shouldn't be the decider of quality and truth, so we can discard that as a goal. Content moderation is complicated, you can't just hide stuff that makes people emotional, or you'd have censored everything that happened in 2020.
Secondly, I don't think there's anything unethical about showing people the content that they want to see, even if it outrages them. There are many things going on that people should be outraged about.
Either way, I still don't consider it an ethical issue, and I don't think I'm delusional. I just know too much about how Facebook actually works to consider them evil.
Let me be clear, the content producers are the ones with intent to misinform. Google and FB just profit off of it.
> Either way, I still don't consider it an ethical issue
Yet you defended this behavior as “ethical” half a dozen times in this thread.
What? Who cares? They can have multiple revenue streams and they often do with Patreon and sponsored messages inside videos. That nonsense that they rely only on youtube ad money has to stop.
EDIT; oh you work for Google! That explains everything. Nice of you to mention that explicitly, by the way.
Well in my belief, ads are unethical. These two views don't reconcile. And since I'm in control of my computer, I get to decide if the ads play or not.
Because if "ads are unethical" under your definition of "unethical", then I think it's totally fine for people to do "unethical" things.
I'm saying that I think taking things without paying is unethical, while what Google does is not unethical (use user data to provide a service and sell ads).
Google should not do that. It's bad that Google does that. It's also bad when others do it.
However, Google is spending a lot of money trying to do that less. The difference in motivation and intention is important.
I just want to weigh in a counterpoint to make sure that this isn't the only voice people ever hear.
I think that Google using data to personalize ads and recommend videos is ethically ok. I think this is a case of straw-manning potentially legitimate complaints about Google's service by using the word "ethics" to skip the work of making an actual argument.
Further I think products like this are actually unethical. They are an unethical use of the data produced by Youtube creators, who miss out on ad revenue which they worked hard to earn.
And btw, you can opt out of ads personalization on https://adssettings.google.com/
EDIT: I work at Google (not on ads or Youtube) and have worked at other large ads companies in the past. I work at these companies _because_ I think ads are ok, not the other way around. My views are my own.