News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by sennight on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:23PM (#27870108)
> They are an unethical use of the data produced by Youtube creators, who miss out on ad revenue which they worked hard to earn.

Substitute "creators" with "collaborators" and maybe it'll be more obvious to you why this is a flawed argument. Anyway, I don't think you can even opt out of Youtube inserting advertisements into your uploads anymore, but back when you could it would result in a discoverability penalty.

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:50PM (#27870218)
I don't follow. I still think it's unethical to serve monetized content without paying the original "collaborator".

If you made a band and sold me a recording on the condition that I not resell it, it would be unethical for me to resell it. I think it would be undesirable and annoying of you to resort to DRM to prevent me from reselling, but I'm still the one violating our agreement. I have no special "human right" to listen to your music (or watch your Youtube videos), but you should have the right to enforce agreements whose nonenforcement would harm only you.

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by sennight on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:31PM (#27870394)
huh, guess I'll have to break it down Barny style: you are effectively trying to wave a bloody shirt with the "think of the creators" bit. If your system of morals allows you to deny Youtube advertisement revenue on the basis of an aversion to invasive spying, then the "creators" aren't victims - they're collaborators in the spying. Of course not all of them draw advertising revenue...

> I still think it's unethical to serve monetized content without paying the original "collaborator".

So you're not even going to seek the refuge of "their payment is the free bandwidth" argument and admit that Youtube is screwing a lot of people over?

> ...but you should have the right to enforce agreements whose nonenforcement would harm only you.

lol, "harm". Sure, you have a legal right to argue over the definition of "harm" - but you know you've retreated from "ethical" to "legal", right?

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:44PM (#27870442)
I don't see it as a retreat, I'm using a different conceptual framework because we don't agree on the meaning of "ethical".

I agree that under your moral system, it's not wrong to deny the creators value, but that's sort of just a restatement of the fact that we disagree on the acceptability of ads in the first place.

In general I don't assign the label "unethical" to something unless I'm aware of a convincing case that the thing causes more harm than good, harm without appropriate equity, violates some other axiomatic principal that I agree to, etc. I just haven't heard a convincing case that ads meets any of those criteria.

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by sennight on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:09PM (#27870523)
> I don't see it as a retreat...

You can add the use of "retreat" in the context of a value judgement to the list of disagreements, but the reframe into a legal argument makes our exchange largely pointless.

> ...unless I'm aware of a convincing case that the thing causes more harm than good...

Ah, yeah - we definitely won't agree on much of anything. I'm more of a first-principles/universality sort of guy... whereas it sounds like moral relativism is more your thing.

>> I think this is a case of straw-manning...

> I just haven't heard a convincing case that ads meets any of those criteria.

See what you did there? You created a strawman. There is a difference between "ads" and "Google using data to personalize ads". I've got no beef with the former, but you are arguing in defense of the latter.

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:14PM (#27870535)
I'm not a relativist, I believe morality is a real objective thing, but that it's socially constructed. Morality is more like language than it is like physics.

To your last point, you can substitute one for the other, I stand by the original point in either case. I haven't heard a convincing case from first principles as to the wrongness of "Google using data to personalize ads". Generally the principle I hear in these cases is very close to "tracking or targeting is inherently wrong", which I reject.

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by sennight on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:47PM (#27870641)
> Morality is more like language than it is like physics.

Not as you've described it, as a real objective thing that is a social construct. I agree that it is a social construct, and I agree that it is "like language", because I'd describe morality as, at the very least, an internally coherent social construct. "more harm than good" has no logical constraint and easily permits the violation of every prior principal while affording no solid ground upon which to build, by design.

> To your last point, you can substitute one for the other...

Cool, so long as you're aware that there exists the possibility of data-hoard-free advertising - and that it was common prior to recent Internet centralization.

> I haven't heard a convincing case from first principles...

That is because, like ad-blockers, it isn't wrong. Good luck trying to construct on internally coherent system of morals that blesses the present state of data-broker panopticon while at the same time condemning ad-blockers. If you can do that with something beyond "might makes right" then I'll be impressed.

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by lstamour on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:33PM (#27870148)
That's true, you can't opt out of YouTube ads on your own uploads. YouTube still has documentation on how to turn off monetization: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6332943?hl=en but since November 2020 they've updated their terms to now say:

> Right to Monetize

> You grant to YouTube the right to monetize your Content on the Service (and such monetization may include displaying ads on or within Content or charging users a fee for access). This Agreement does not entitle you to any payments.

https://www.youtube.com/static?gl=CA&template=terms

They more clearly state what it means over here: https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/83733719/updates-t...

> For channels not yet in the YouTube Partner Program:

> We added this new section to let you know that, starting today we’ll begin slowly rolling out ads on a limited number of videos from channels not in YPP. This means as a creator that’s not in YPP, you may see ads on some of your videos. Since you’re not currently in YPP, you won’t receive a share of the revenue from these ads, though you’ll still have the opportunity to apply for YPP as you normally would...

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by sennight on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:10PM (#27870305)
Kinda makes the inevitable conclusion obvious: non-fashion&beauty channels need not apply - non-legacy media will not be permitted much aside from topics that both have:

1) No possibility of generating an objection from the most sensitive of current and potential advertisers.

2) Do not compete with legacy media presently on platform.

Makes you wonder about all those outrage mobs that targeted companies with adverts that had the bad luck of randomly appearing in videos that demonstrated wrong-think, and how they've ushered in network television 2.0 while sticking it to all the totally-real-and-definitely-a-threat-to-our-democracy-neo-nazis.