News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by ekianjo on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:45PM (#27870203)
Being paid good sums of money by Google will certainly drive a positive bias towards whatever the company does. In publications you typically describe conflicts of interests you know, you might as well do it here too whenever you give an opinion if you have a stake in the company people are commenting about.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:54PM (#27870235)
Should people who have never worked on ads or with user data in any significant capacity have to disclose that too?

"I want to say that Google is unethical and ads are evil, but I've never actually worked on ads and actually don't know what data means in this context"

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by threatofrain on Sunday July 18, 2021 @12:45AM (#27870819)
Not working on ads isn't a conflict of interest — there's no metaphorical paycheck for dodging Google. As you point out, it could predict more ignorance, but it doesn't predict financial incentives flowing to their direction.

Also, would you morally expect your doctor to disclose that they're on the payroll of the company that develops the medications you've been prescribed to take? Regardless of the answer, disclosure here isn't about whether or not a doctor is capable of their own opinion, or whether or not they are speaking in any official capacity for other companies.

Ethical appearance is part of professional ethics.

Similarly, it doesn't matter if a judge is capable of independent opinion while having financial interests tied to the cases they preside over. The mere appearance of financial entanglement can stink up professional credibility. It would also be quite silly for a judge to respond with, "But I've only recently been receiving paychecks. I hardly know anyone at the company."

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by ekianjo on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:14PM (#27870328)
It does not matter whether you worked on ads or not. The fact that you have many friends at Google and spent years there has already shaped you as an employee to believe that whatever Google does is "probably not evil". This is not specific to working at Google, by the way, we all rationalize what our workplace(s) does.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:24PM (#27870568)
I've been at Google for ~5 months and can comfortably say I have no friends here who I didn't know before joining.

Is it really so hard to believe that some people don't agree with you on this point because they've seen different evidence than you have?

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by ekianjo on Friday July 23, 2021 @01:19AM (#27927485)
5 months? your resume is saying you also worked there between 2014 and 2016.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by killingtime74 on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:16PM (#27870336)
Only engineers can think about ethics? What about philosophers, ethicists and lawyers? How about law makers?
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:30PM (#27870584)
I'm okay with anyone thinking about ethics, as long as they don't call themselves an "ethicist" :P

I'm just pointing out that we all have our biases. As somebody who understands how targeted advertising works from the "inside" I see a lot of commentary that is factually inaccurate and conceptually off base.

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by ds206 on Sunday July 18, 2021 @01:22AM (#27870935)
Go on... I'm listening ;)

Do you think the fact that no one on the "outside" knows how it works may be the reason for that? Also, do you think that if we did know how it works from the inside that we would agree with you?

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by oh_sigh on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:20PM (#27870354)
> Being paid good sums of money by Google will certainly drive a positive bias towards whatever the company does

Any evidence for this claim, besides for your gut?

How do you explain all of the googlers who have resigned over Project X/Y/Z, or how Google handles sexual allegations, or who they do business with?

Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi... by ekianjo on Friday July 23, 2021 @01:20AM (#27927496)
What do you mean ? You mean evidence taht someone giving you money influences your perception of them ? Are you seriously asking the question ?