Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi...
by nohr on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:46PM
(#27870205)
No one said it's their only revenue. You're making up words no one said. It is unethical to consume content without accepting that ad revenue is how its covered. That's it.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi...
by hypertele-Xii on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:55PM
(#27870246)
> It is unethical to consume content without accepting [ads]
Well in my belief, ads are unethical. These two views don't reconcile. And since I'm in control of my computer, I get to decide if the ads play or not.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi...
by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:00PM
(#27870260)
See it's sort of a non-argument. Saying something is "unethical" is just an emotive way of saying "I disagree with this".
Because if "ads are unethical" under your definition of "unethical", then I think it's totally fine for people to do "unethical" things.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi...
by ekianjo on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:49PM
(#27870214)
You can make the case it's also "unethical" to track everything users are doing across the whole web with Google Analytics, and then using that data to sell ads to third parties. "Being ethical" cuts both ways.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi...
by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:57PM
(#27870251)
Stealing from a rich man may not harm the rich man, but I still believe it's unethical.
I'm saying that I think taking things without paying is unethical, while what Google does is not unethical (use user data to provide a service and sell ads).
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi...
by Ostrogodsky on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:47PM
(#27870446)
Google makes billions! every year putting ads on illegally copied copyrighted videos. Sure, they will take them down if the claim is made (especially by the big players) but for sure they are not going to return any money made. Some kid doing an small tool is wont to make 0.00000000001% at best. You are the juggler defending the rich baron stealing from everybody.
Re:Piped: A privacy-friendly YouTube front end which is effi...
by mgraczyk on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:50PM
(#27870454)
Two wrongs don't make a right.
Google should not do that. It's bad that Google does that. It's also bad when others do it.
However, Google is spending a lot of money trying to do that less. The difference in motivation and intention is important.
What? Who cares? They can have multiple revenue streams and they often do with Patreon and sponsored messages inside videos. That nonsense that they rely only on youtube ad money has to stop.
EDIT; oh you work for Google! That explains everything. Nice of you to mention that explicitly, by the way.