> Also use your activity and information from Google services to personalise ads on websites and apps that partner with Google to show ads. This stores data from websites and apps that partner with Google in your Google Account.
Unchecking this means (as I understand it) that, among other things, your YouTube watching behaviour will not be used for ad targeting on non-Google websites.
(That's about non-Google websites, but as I type the above, I just realized that maybe by "all other mediums" you meant other Google sites, like Google Search etc. But those already covered under "Ad personalisation" (the main toggle at https://adssettings.google.com/) so I'm not quite sure the premise of the question is correct.)
However, it's important to distinguish this completely reasonable point, that the product may be overpriced or provide less value than it should, vs an argument that Google is "unethical" for offering it.
I would speculate that the average and 95th percentile customer experience with tracking is so astronomically better on average, across nearly all dimensions, that even after paying, fewer than 5% of users would prefer the no-tracking/personalization product experience.
Personalized ads isn't just about getting you to click more. It's also about showing you fewer irrelevant ads. In fact on many sites that's way more important.
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/05/96-of-us-users-opt-o...
https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/united-sta...
https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide
Based on this data, it seems extremely unlikely that 95% of users would prefer the "customer experience with tracking" on YouTube or any other mainstream social media site.
From where I'm standing, Apple masterfully manipulated their users into adopting a worldview that transfers future cash flows from other tech giants to Apple.
It's great for me as an Apple shareholder, but just another punch in a bout amongst the titans.
I am not really sure they manipulated me into switching to the iPhone, as much as they produced a product that advertised the things I want, and that I can get nowhere else.
That is, if you run a randomized AB test where some users lose personalization, then ask everyone "are you enjoying Facebook", the responses are much better for the users who have personalization.
Because the number 96 is large, it's not the case that some ads-averse subpopulation made an individually optimal choice.
You either have to reject my empirical claim about surveys, or you have to agree that these users made a choice that is worse for them on timescales of 1-2 months. (There's room for an argument that they're worse off in the short term by opting out but everyone will be better off in the long term, but then we're no longer debating individual preferences)
The people who are being presented with rage inducing topics that they feel their circle of friends are fighting agaisnt from personalization of their feed from a mix of old and new content is likely to say they enjoy Facebook over the old feed where a friend of a friend from high school is posting baby pictures again and people are actually just living normal lives not being shaped by a desire for clout.
Facebooks personalization seems to just send me to more and more content that makes me angry. Some people may find some pleasure in that, I suppose, but rejecting the temptation is not a suboptimal choice, like rejecting the 3rd beer is not a bad idea, even if you want it right now.
And I don't think it is unrealistic that ~everybody is adverse to ads, but I think it is fairly likely that everybody who has seen apples privacy ads are going to think what Facebook and others do as creepy and opt out based on that.
Finally I nearly always say no or give a low rating for those popups, because I find the popups annoying.
Dupuit explained it all in four simple words. It's not out of vindictiveness, or even saving money Instead, it all boils down to this: "To scare the rich."
...
It is not because of the several thousand francs which they would have to spend to cover the third class wagons or to upholster the benches. ... [I]t would happily sacrifice this [expense] for the sake of its popularity.
Its goal is to stop the traveler who can pay for the second class trip from going third class. It hurts the poor not because it wants them to personally suffer, but to scare the rich.
https://www.inc.com/bill-murphy-jr/why-does-air-travel-suck-...
Jules Dupuit was a 19th century French engineer and economist.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jules_Dupuit
His insights on nonrivalrous public services and induced upselling apply across any number of goods and services. That would include informational and online ones.
This is before one considers the inherent bias of A/B testing and "market choice" mechanics generally to short-term highly-attractive options, and disregard of long-term value, long-term risks, and of less apparent or manifest value and benefits (see Robert K. Merton on manifest vs. latent functions).
So Google asks that people pay $12 a month to not see ads, but still uses watching behavior to build a user profile to advertise to in all other mediums.
Do I have this correct? How does google explain the value proposition? Is the real cost of YouTube (sans tracking) greater than $12 a month?