News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @07:58PM (#27400556)
The submitted title was "Y Combinator kicks out Paul Biggar over a tweet". That is inaccurate, so in keeping with the HN guidelines ("Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), I've replaced the title with the tweet text. That's the standard thing we do with titles, when people post Twitter links.

Much as I'd love to, it's not my place to say why the original title was inaccurate, so I'll just remind you all that there are two or more sides to every story and not everything on Twitter is true.

In keeping with the rule that we moderate HN less, not more, when YC or a YC startup is involved (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...), I'm not doing anything else to the submission. Normally, of course, we'd downweight this sort of petty drama.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by bebop on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:42PM (#27401164)
I think your post could have not included:

“Much as I'd love to, it's not my place to say why the original title was inaccurate, so I'll just remind you all that there are two or more sides to every story and not everything on Twitter is true.”

And “Normally, of course, we would downweight this sort of petty drama.” And could have avoided unhelpful conflict in the threads below. You sort of threw your opinion out without expressing it outright.

For what it is worth I have no opinion either way and generally agree this sort of post should be downweighted.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:56PM (#27401234)
I hear you, but both of those sentences are there for a reason. Without the first I'd be getting lots of "how is it inaccurate?" responses, and without the second I'd be getting protests about moderation practices. My intention was to give enough information (I'm not saying it's a lot) to preempt avalanches of predictable objections. I'm sure I could have done it better, though, because this was far from what Scott and I used to call a "splash-free dive".
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by bebop on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:01PM (#27401268)
I appreciate that this is probably a no win situation. Thanks as always for doing your best and keeping this community healthy.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by roenxi on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:12PM (#27401333)
There isn't a loss. There is nothing wrong with adding some sass to the comment if the moderator hat comes off. It'd be unreasonable to expect him to turn a blind eye to a situation where he has more at stake and better information than 80% of the comments.

Dan's opinion is only different from the average HN commentor because it leads to people being banned. As long as there is a careful separation of personal opinion from an official moderator view there isn't anything to take note of from one personal opinion.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by bebop on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:18PM (#27401377)
I meant more that no matter what was said, someone would take offense.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by garmaine on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:23PM (#27401425)
You could just say “As there is a conflict of interest, I will not comment on the substance of this tweet.”
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:01AM (#27402868)
But that's not the reason and wouldn't be true.

There's another aspect too: I try to avoid being a bloodless ghoul in communicating with this community. People here don't want stiff corporate pantomimes, and that suits me fine, because I would hate to do that; or rather I can't because my body would reject it. That's an old Willie Brown line btw.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by hutrdvnj on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:15AM (#27402936)
I would like to hear the other side of the story. I understand that dang is not the best person to tell us, but maybe there's someone else?
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by garmaine on Saturday June 05, 2021 @06:34AM (#27403800)
As a moderator of YC’s forum, you have a conflict of interest. That’s an objective fact.

Saying there is a conflict of interest is not saying that you actually feel conflicting motives. I’m not casting any doubt on that. The mere appearance of a conflict is sufficient, in typical circumstances where legal definitions are required.

Recognizing that the (appearance of) a conflict of interest exists and respecting it would go a heck of a lot further in garnering trust, IMHO.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:36PM (#27407908)
I think we may have crossed signals somehow because I'm certainly not denying any of that—it's obvious and the community is well aware of it. Respect for the delicate conditions under which the HN community, the HN moderators, and YC interface with each other informs everything about how we moderate HN, as anyone who reads my comment history will find. You can look at https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... and https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... for examples if you (or anyone) cares.

What I don't respect so much is Twitter drama and misleading rhetoric. To the extent that readers care about this at all, they should get to hear both sides of the story so they could make up their minds for themselves. But it's not my call, so I don't get to go there this time.

More interestingly perhaps, I think it would be a big mistake, for community relations, to hide behind bureaucratic language about this stuff (e.g. "as there is a conflict of interest, I will not comment"). HN readers aren't used to that. They're used to getting the inside story and to feeling personally connected to the people who run HN and to some extent YC. To flip a switch and suddenly turn that off when something like this happens would send all the wrong signals. My commitment to people here is to tell them as much as I can about whatever they're curious to know, and to interact with them as a human, not as a corporate role. That's what I meant by "bloodless ghoul" - I apologize if that wasn't clear - my language maybe gets more colorful late at night.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by user-the-name on Saturday June 05, 2021 @05:58AM (#27403657)
Are you claiming you do not have a conflict of interest here?
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:34PM (#27407898)
No not at all. I'm saying that it's not the reason why I couldn't comment further.

The conflict of interest (I'm not sure that's the most precise term here, but I'll go with it) is obvious, everyone's aware of it, and it doesn't normally (nor should it) stop me from sharing information with the community. HN readers are curious, generally like more information rather than less, and are smart enough to make up their own minds. And although you can call it a conflict, actually just sharing what's happening is a way to build trust with readers.

The difference in this case was not any of that—it's just that it's not my call what YC does or doesn't publish about its internal affairs, so I don't get to share information like I normally would. I don't like that; my comfort zone is, like I said, to tell HN readers whatever relevant information I can and let them decide for themselves. That has worked well over the years and continues to. But other people have different jobs and need to make decisions from different perspectives.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by CRConrad on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:01AM (#27460879)
The actual difference between the bloodless "conflict of interest" and the line you did use to explain the title change is of course that the latter implies that this was not why Biggar was expelled, i.e. that there was some other reason -- "he had it coming anyway, it's just that I can't say precisely why."

Since you're not stupid we have to assume you knew very well that this was what you were saying, so we have to conclude you said exactly that because exactly that was what you wanted to say.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by arolihas on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:47PM (#27401589)
But then he couldn't subtly minimize or delegitimize it.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by s5300 on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:12AM (#27402411)
Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

Any HN user should most definitely be applying this rule on Dang of all people. He deals with a lot of shit on here.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by arolihas on Sunday June 06, 2021 @06:39AM (#27412152)
Well he basically admitted it. But if y’all want to suck him off, fine. This place is overrated anyway.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:07AM (#27402898)
I didn't think I was being particularly subtle, though it seems I may have buried the lede.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by anonytrary on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:59PM (#27401685)
> Much as I'd love to, it's not my place to say why the original title was inaccurate, so I'll just remind you all that there are two or more sides to every story and not everything on Twitter is true.

You've always been a fantastic moderator, dang. To be honest, it's not your place to say anything on the matter publicly, especially not an insinuating comment such as that. The conditions of separation are private. A company can create pretext and other excuses as to why they separate with someone. The only conclusive answer is that there is no conclusive answer here, and there probably never will be unless OP takes legal action.

I think this won't be the first time that a techie underdog goes up against the YC crowd and is shut down by ridicule, legalese, and other platitudes. It's important to not censor those folks, and also important to not try and publicly denounce them in the way that you have. It will only work against YC. The underdog will always have something more interesting to say than the company. They will bide their time and come together. It's best for the company and its constituents to not comment on the matter at all, or post provocative content that encourages uncivil discourse.

I've seen a lot of YC companies doing this to their employees. I think it's going to backfire in a really ugly way in a few years.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by magicalist on Friday June 04, 2021 @08:59PM (#27400938)
> Much as I'd love to, it's not my place to say why the original title was inaccurate, so I'll just remind you all that there are two or more sides to every story and not everything on Twitter is true.

This reads a bit like "not to be that guy, but...". You won't say why for some reason, but clearly it's not to stay out of it because you're letting innuendo do the job.

Alternative suggestion: "That is inaccurate but it's not my place to elaborate." It would still express the point but avoid reinforcing the circle the wagons/"blue wall of silence"ness of this situation.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:10PM (#27400992)
I don't see that alternative formulation as so different really?

I'm sure you have a good point, I'm just not sure how to do it better. I needed to give enough of an explanation to satisfy people's curiosity at least a little bit even though I can't satisfy it for real. I also needed to make sure that my comment had enough information in it to answer (let's say) the top 10 obvious objections, or it would have brought a flood of them down on my head.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by serf on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:25PM (#27401079)
>not everything on Twitter is true

>I'm sure you have a good point. I'm just not sure how to do it better.

Probably without the allusion that the tweeter isn't telling the truth, to be blunt.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:53PM (#27401222)
To say that the submitted title was inaccurate is already to say that.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by geekone on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:01PM (#27401697)
I don't think the inaccurate title has much to do with the added color that the tweet could be a lie
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by alisonkisk on Saturday June 05, 2021 @02:00AM (#27402611)
You can't satisfy the people who don't want to be satisfied.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by Judgmentality on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:14PM (#27401778)
I think you are unwittingly coloring your words, likely because you are frustrated by this post (it's petty drama you want to downvote but policy says you can't, and you have inside information you can't share). This is like subtle apophasis, where you're implying that the tweeter (wow that sounds so weird) is on the wrong side.

I'm not taking sides here, despite being a YC alum (alternate account) I stopped looking at the forum forever ago and had not even heard about this nor do I care, honestly I just thought it'd be fun to read some drama on HN since it's so rare here.

I think enough other people are commenting on this to suggest it's not just me. I think you mean well, but none of us are unbiased. It seems like a no-win situation though. So it goes.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:16AM (#27402948)
Unwittingly? That's fightin words.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by random314 on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:48AM (#27403100)
Please adhere to hacker news guidelines https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:33PM (#27407887)
Sorry! I meant it in a nice way, though of course that may not have come across.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by austincheney on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:11PM (#27400997)
This is all petty personal drama that shouldn’t be a thread in the first place. Being concerned due to unspecified assumptions is less than wonderful.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by FemmeAndroid on Friday June 04, 2021 @08:10PM (#27400630)
Honest question, since I’ve seen the situation come up before: Would you be willing to modify the title of any post to be ‘accurate’ based on non-public information, without making that information public?

If so, how does one make that request, and what would the process look like?

There have been a few titles I knew to be extremely misleading or false, but never thought there was a way to rectify it without publicly providing information I wasn’t able to share openly.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @08:17PM (#27400687)
It would depend on the specific circumstances, but I can imagine doing that, or perhaps there would be something else we could do that was better; it's hard to say in general, because cases like that are always very specific. We'd want to explain as much to the community as we could without harmful side-effects, but if someone's safety or privacy is at risk, I'm comfortable telling the community so, and I'm confident that the bulk of this community would respect that.

In such situations the thing to do is email [email protected].

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by eyelidlessness on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:34AM (#27402217)
This is a really disappointing answer. I know, I know discussing moderation here is frowned upon... but come on. You’re basically saying there’s a secondary set of rules that are decided and disclosed arbitrarily.

It’s your choice how to moderate, I don’t have any expectation or illusion of a right to use this platform. But can you understand how this creates ambiguity for people who don’t know what the rules ultimately are, and how it creates huge openings for people to cry foul when there’s nothing unusual?

Wouldn’t it be better to refine the rules and disclosure when gaps arise, so everyone is participating in the same system?

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:19AM (#27402959)
If you think that moderating a system as complex as HN can be reduced to a single set of unambiguous formal rules, you're profoundly mistaken. I can understand how that could be disappointing, but what's disappointing you is reality, because that's impossible.

Also: discussing moderation is frowned upon? Where'd you get that idea? I've posted 50,000 comments discussing moderation with HN users (not to mention...checking...24,000 emails, apparently). I'm not saying it's my favorite thing to do, but nobody's frowning upon it. Perhaps you were thinking of the guideline asking people not to go on about getting downvoted?

There's simply no way to avoid judgment calls, interpretation, and general messes, and I'm not into pretending otherwise. The best we can offer is to answer any questions people have, and that I'm pretty diligent about.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by eyelidlessness on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:38AM (#27403051)
> If you think that moderating a system as complex as HN can be reduced to a single set of unambiguous formal rules, you're profoundly mistaken.

I’m not saying it can be reduced to that. I’m saying it’s disappointing that the resolution to that is a side channel where decisions are made privately and have no way to resolve generally. This is especially a problem for you, as you field tens of thousands of things that may be similar but might not be equally convincing in private. It’s also a problem for you as people are understandably going to wonder what those private decisions entail.

> Also: discussing moderation is frowned upon? Where'd you get that idea? I've posted 50,000 comments discussing moderation with HN users (not to mention...checking...24,000 emails, apparently). I'm not saying it's my favorite thing to do, but nobody's frowning upon it. Perhaps you were thinking of the guideline asking people not to go on about getting downvoted?

I’m thinking of several instances seeing people who were concerned about moderation decisions being directed to email rather than the discussion in public.

> There's simply no way to avoid judgment calls, interpretation, and general messes, and I'm not into pretending otherwise. The best we can offer is to answer any questions people have, and that I'm pretty diligent about.

You are! You’re beyond diligent and I don’t know you but sometimes I see your attention to HN threads and hope you’re not burning out. My disappointment isn’t about you making a judgment call. My disappointment is that you made a side channel available for private judgment calls that might not be disclosed, both because that creates separate rules for people who do or don’t have access to it, and because it creates an opportunity for people to imagine things that might be private and create alternative narratives.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by yakshaving_jgt on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:49AM (#27402567)
> Wouldn’t it be better to refine the rules and disclosure when gaps arise, so everyone is participating in the same system?

I don’t agree with this. I think this idea works in computing systems and thus at least programmers are inclined to think in this fashion, however I don’t believe this is how every other framework functions, e.g., the UK legal system which is largely down to interpretation (and IANAL).

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by eyelidlessness on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:09AM (#27402904)
I’m not looking at this from the perspective of law, I’m looking at it from the perspective of judgment that’s partly secret and unknowable.

HN already has a reputation for skewed moderation (certain sites are pre-banned, posting them pre-flags subsequent posts). Making it explicitly something exceptional without any way for people to know what the exception is... again creates a separate set of rules and a basis for people to air unfounded objections.

If HN wants to be Fight Club fine but I’m happy to be on record opposing that so long as I can.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by Firehawke on Saturday June 05, 2021 @02:20AM (#27402694)
Any kind of working moderation system is going to have a certain level of "we have to play it by ear" or else it gets overrun by rules lawyers playing to the word and not the spirit of imposed rules.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by eyelidlessness on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:11AM (#27402914)
I wasn’t objecting to playing it by ear. I was objecting to committing to doing so and keeping it arbitrary.

Edit so I can hopefully make the spirit of my own complaint more clear: my puppy is defiant and stubborn and clever and a big doofus. Rules are a living document and they get revised all the time. If I communicate them and my expectations we grow together and move on to the next misunderstanding with some grace and patience. If I just decide that the rules change without saying what they are, I’m setting my pup up for failure and myself up for her resentment and an inclination to impose more strictness that she won’t understand.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:27AM (#27402989)
In that case I don't think we're so far apart. I wasn't "just deciding" to arbitrarily change things. Someone asked me how we'd handle a particular kind of rare situation and I answered based on established practice.

In fact, if you read my comment closely, it's not hard to discern what the principles are: (1) being transparent with the community, (2) protecting people's safety and privacy, (3) if there's a conflict between (1) and (2), then (2) wins.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by eyelidlessness on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:44AM (#27403086)
This comment came while I was writing my last response but I want to say, thank you this is clarifying and helps a lot.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by tshaddox on Friday June 04, 2021 @08:59PM (#27400936)
If so, wouldn't that be vulnerable to an attack where we make submissions enumerating claims and observe which ones get modified? :)
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by rrauenza on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:14PM (#27401351)
My main confusion from the title was trying to figure out who "Lol" was and why "Lol" got kicked out.

Took me a few minutes to realize it was LOL.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:19PM (#27401389)
Well that nuance certainly escaped me. I suppose we can safely capitalize LOL in accordance with the site guidelines :)
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by DonHopkins on Saturday June 05, 2021 @06:41AM (#27403826)
It's only ethical that anyone who writes LOL should also actually Laugh Out Loud, otherwise it would be deceptive. Same thing for ROFL.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by ModernMech on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:57PM (#27402028)
I read it and thought somehow League of Legends was part of YC.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by kjs3 on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:11PM (#27401327)
There is an 'in' crowd, for which the rules protect but don't constrain, and an 'out' crowd for which the rules constrain but do not protect.

I'm paraphrasing.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by verelo on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:57PM (#27401237)
Literally you’re the top comment, and it’s not a short one, and it expresses personal thoughts. Good job doing less not more.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by Wowfunhappy on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:14PM (#27401347)
I thought it was perfectly reasonable. "Less" doesn't mean "zero", and in the normal case this story would be downweighted way off the front page.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:21PM (#27401409)
I certainly didn't intend it to be the top comment; that was entirely by upvotes.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by verelo on Saturday June 05, 2021 @08:05PM (#27409480)
You know what they say about the road to hell and it’s paving material.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dqpb on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:00AM (#27402042)
Getting kicked out of ycombinator is petty drama?
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:34AM (#27403034)
That twitter fest is, as is telegraphed by the "LOL" in the title. Also, to be fair, the puerile GIF that the other side responded with, and ought not to have.
[dead]
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:28PM (#27401099)
FWIW, I think that was probably because your comment was unsubstantive enough that it was unclear what you meant, which probably put it in a worst-case situation. Also, unsubstantiveness attracts downvotes in its own right, especially when it contains traces of snark. Also, your account has quite a history of posting unsubstantive comments—could you please not do that? We're trying for something different here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by slumpt_ on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:45PM (#27401177)
We can set aside my history and focus on the simple point being made: labeling this issue as "petty drama" speaks volumes. It speaks volumes about you and the values you are espousing for this site and community, and reflects poorly upon YCombinator as an establishment in general.

In early March we were at a point in a global pandemic where vaccines were hard to come by in the US and real lives were at risk and changed by receipt of the vaccine.

That it is simply "petty drama" that someone is calling out the community for ejecting him over being repulsed by behavior that seeks to sidestep a good-faith system intent on helping those most at risk first is disgusting.

How's that. Is that substantive? I figured it was between the lines.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by edanm on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:11AM (#27402407)
I don't think it's "petty" (to use dang's wording) because the underlying issue ("cheating" to get a vaccine) is petty. You're right - the underlying issue is serious.

It's "petty" because the discussion isn't about the underlying issue, the discussions is about someone claiming that they were kicked out of YC for posting to Twitter about someone else posting about skipping the line to a separate internal forum. That's very far removed from the underlying issue of vaccines, and brings in so many other topics into play, many of which are just not best reasoned about in this kind of forum (e.g. is the tweeter telling the truth? If they are, was it ok that they publicly tweeted about something from an internal forum? Did they first approach the original posted? etc.)

Much as you or I might like the discussion to be "Does YC condone lying/cheating to get the vaccine early", that's just not the topic we can actually answer here, since we have no access to the real underlying facts (and probably only one side speaking).

That is what to my mind makes this issue "petty", not the seriousness of the subject matter.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:04PM (#27401283)
By the time something goes through this many twitterfilters, whatever non-petty quality it may have had to begin with has long been boiled away. It has become a self-licking ice cream cone of internet drama—something that certainly deserves the word 'petty'. Moreover, there was a long history of pettiness preceding this.

We can't set aside your history because (a) you've been breaking the site guidelines repeatedly and (b) we've asked you repeatedly not to do that in the past. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by slumpt_ on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:35PM (#27401510)
Yeah, I understand you don't want to set it aside in general which is fine. I was only requesting you set it aside to entertain what I was saying in the above comment.

And sure, happy to review the guidelines, all prior points aside.

Though to be clear, the problems of this community go deep when a moderator is dismissing this kind of serious issue as petty drama.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:08PM (#27401741)
Ah ok—I get your first point now and I respect that you disagree on the second. Thanks for the kind reply.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by etxm on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:38PM (#27401526)
> “petty drama” speaks volumes

Big time agree here. The comment was substantive and succinct. Saying it was “petty drama” in the top comment sets a tone for the convo.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by Nicksil on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:45PM (#27401575)
>Saying it was “petty drama” in the top comment sets a tone for the convo.

Top comment is the top comment because it was voted to the top. One doesn't say anything in a top comment; one says something in a comment which may become the top comment.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by grzm on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:49PM (#27401607)
'dang may have pinned the comment to the top to make clear that he had changed the submitted title to the tweet and be open that he had done so. From what I've observed, pinning comments in this case isn't uncommon.

Edit to add: as 'Nicksil kindly pointed out, 'dang made clear he didn't do this in this case.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by Nicksil on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:52PM (#27401630)
>'dang may have pinned the comment to the top to make clear that he had changed the submitted title to the tweet and be open that he had done so.

But he hadn't as was said in this very thread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27401409

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by grzm on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:52PM (#27401637)
Ah, cheers! I stand corrected.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:12PM (#27401334)
Any post that challenges dang will likely get voted down. This is normal given his position and it's the price of admission (see my other reply to his post). People also rarely vote on how substantive your post is but on whether they agree with it or not. It's not in the spirit of HN to do this but you really can't control human behavior and people do this without being fully aware of it.

Due to how human voting behavior sort of deviates from the spirit of HN, it's a good excuse to have some people moderate the site as having an emotional mob control everything could have the entire site turn into reddit. The problem is the people moderating the site are also human and also victims of their own biases and business interests so you get hella sketchy stuff like this pinned post.

Still it's sorta good that this post wasn't outright deleted.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by grzm on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:46PM (#27401587)
> "Any post that challenges dang will likely get voted down."

While this may be the case, the comment you reply to is a particularly poor example on which to hang this comment. It's a snarky, insubstantive insinuation, regardless of whom it's in response to, and was edited to complain about downvotes.

> "Still it's sorta good that this post wasn't outright deleted."

It's likely it wasn't flagged and removed because it was in response to 'dang, as he is generally leaves responses to his comments in place even when they're quite bad, even if he doesn't follow-up with a reply in what I take to be added transparency.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by slumpt_ on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:13PM (#27401766)
Oh don't worry, not complaining about downvotes. Just baffled that the community stands by that characterization of the issue at hand. Plays into crummy stereotypes about the tech community and their general naivety regarding social issues / norms (or perhaps worse, apathy?).

It's neither snarky nor insubstantive. It gets straight to the heart of the issue in few words. It does speak volumes. Few words can given context and choice.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by pydry on Saturday June 05, 2021 @08:38AM (#27404416)
The thread is a shitshow of bluster, vague accusations, mob down voting and carefully selected facts on both sides but it's interesting that it is still possible to piece together what actually happened by reading a selection of the comments from both sides.

My impression is that one side is slightly more keen on obscuring the full facts than the other without outright giving the impression that that is what they are doing.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by slumpt_ on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:46PM (#27401585)
It's good it wasn't deleted, but disappointing that he winds up editorializing it with his quip.

I've come to not expect much more from HackerNews. Sometimes http://n-gate.com/ is the best summary one can ask for.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by CRConrad on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:19AM (#27461081)
Wow, that's certainly a faster way to read HN! :-D

Thanks!

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:14PM (#27401018)
> Normally, of course, we'd downweight this sort of petty drama.

Down weight? So you guys internally pick and choose topics to weight down? I thought HN was purely community driven with only comments being moderated.

Of course on the surface you guys say you only downweight petty drama but I truly wonder if that's actually true. The fact that you guys downweight anything without trusting the community makes me question how fair, balanced and unbiased things are on HN.

Additionally the person who this tweet was about posted here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27400221 and it doesn't seem like drama. It seems like injustice and misinterpretation and stubborn refusal. His only option is to appeal to the public but of course YC has to color it with their bias.

It really looks like he was kicked out over a tweet from his perspective. Getting kicked out of YC may seem petty to YC but it is not petty to the person who was kicked out. Even Dang calling this kind of thing "petty drama" does unparalleled damage to his reputation.

The right way to deal with this is not to touch this post and let paul make blog post or something and see if the community votes it up on HN.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:16PM (#27401026)
> I thought HN was purely community driven with only comments being moderated

I'm not sure I buy that, given how long you've been around HN and how much of the last 8 years I've spent explaining how HN is moderated. But FWIW, HN is a curated site, and always has been; there has never been any claim otherwise.

HN's system is a complex interaction between three subsystems: community, software, and moderators. All three are necessary. If you or anyone would like to know more, here are some links to past explanations to start with. If there are still questions after familiarizing yourself with that material, I'd be happy to answer them.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

> Of course on the surface you guys say you only downweight petty drama

That is obviously not at all what I said.

[dead]
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:58PM (#27401245)
You changed what I said into "Of course on the surface you guys say you only downweight petty drama". That was (a) a massive distortion—you can trivially see from https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... that there are many other kinds of downweighting. On top of that, (b) you added snark ("of course") and insinuation ("on the surface") in a way that strikes me as particularly uncharitable.

You've done it again with "Seems reasonable to say, don't trust news about YC on HN", implying that we somehow intervene to distort that, when the truth is that we do exactly the opposite—as I'd just explained in the comment you were replying, as well as on many previous occasions: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu....

[dead]
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by ggm on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:12PM (#27401758)
Can you address the semantic intent of your use of the word only and what Dan said please: the substantive point to me is you implied only == specific == evidence of bias and as Dan said it is well established they down weight for more than one reason which implies != only which I think, personally you haven't adequately addressed. You're basically wrong.
[dead]
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by ggm on Saturday June 05, 2021 @02:43AM (#27402787)
You're not addressing the point. You said he only downweights for one reason. Plainly, he has declared consistency in downweighting for many reasons. No amount of self justification changes the fact you said he ONLY downweights for one reason, and that's factually incorrect.

What he did in this specific case? Different matter. What he does as a matter of both stated policy and declared intent and I would suggest, evidence is different. He downweights for a range of reasons.

Why can't you just accept that and say so? What's blocking you from acknowledging your own words are just incorrect?

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Saturday June 05, 2021 @04:30AM (#27403280)
>Why can't you just accept that and say so? What's blocking you from acknowledging your own words are just incorrect?

Very simple logic. He's in a position where he can lie. Conflict of interest. He's paid by the company who sponsors this news site. Why can't you get this simple logic through your head?

>You said he only downweights for one reason.

Please read my post. I said what I meant WAS THIS: The only thing Dang can say is that when he downweights posts he can only SAY that he does so in the interest of the HN community. That's it. Mainly the point is because this is ONLY what he can SAY (keyword) you can't trust what he says, because of a CONFLICT of INTEREST. Get it? Take note I capitalized some words for emphasis to help you understand exactly what I'm saying. The language I use is specific and exact.

>You're not addressing the point.

I am addressing the point. The point is I'm not wrong at all and I'm telling you why. That's really all you need to get through your head.

>What he did in this specific case? Different matter.

What he did in this specific case IS ENTIRELY the point. It is NOT a different matter. ANY thing off this point is off topic. My initial post is completely and only addressing the point. I think your mind is wandering from point to point not latching on the main topic.

>What he does as a matter of both stated policy and declared intent and I would suggest, evidence is different. He downweights for a range of reasons.

Your suggestion is noted. And I suggest there's a conflict of interest here. There.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by NicoJuicy on Saturday June 05, 2021 @06:43AM (#27403837)
> Why can't you get this simple logic through your head?

Everyone knows he's paid by YC and almost everyone is taking his decade long track record into consideration as an excellent moderator + that he literally didn't do anything wrong here. You're trying to defend your allegation and everyone else doesn't agree with you.

> That's really all you need to get through your head

Perhaps the problem isn't someone else :)

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by NicoJuicy on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:54PM (#27401225)
Please chill. If you've never moderated a forum, you should start realizing that moderation is key to having a good community.

Cherry-picking statements and acting like this is not appreciated.

Fyi: I've been banned once and thought it was justified. They've done an amazing job to keep the community healthy and that's really hard to do.

What Dang mentioned seems pretty clear: we won't moderate this because it involves us, but this isn't the place for gossip.

YC has > 150 companies per year. Not everything is perfect, not everything is known and people will always try to say their POV of the story. That's life, we'll see how this goes, but I'd rather see it on Reddit than here.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:47PM (#27401590)
I am chill. You're misinterpreting things.

It's perfectly reasonable things may never go perfect. However. Things become sketchy when Dang changes the title and pins his own opinion at the head of the comment section.

Gossip and news are literally the same thing. It feeds and lights up the same areas of the brain. It's hard to say whether this is gossip or news because from this guys post it looks like he got kicked out of YC for trivial reasons. It can potentially say as much about the reputation of YC as it does about the guy who got kicked out. That sounds like news to me.

>Cherry-picking statements and acting like this is not appreciated.

You know I make a huge effort not to cherry pick anything. But it's inevitable things are usually interpreted this way because of the medium of communication or my own trouble with articulating the meaning of what I say. My experience is that when you "think" someone is cherry picking words on HN, usually he's not doing it on purpose and that's how he actually interpreted what you said.

Look carefully at what I wrote. The only thing I am doing here is presenting a valid opinion that goes against the grain of public opinion. There's nothing else going on yet it's exploding into some kind of drama where you're telling me to "chill".

Consider the fact that the bias lies with you. You interpreted my comment as not "chill" when I'm literally just calmly typing my thoughts. I am calm, but why did you insert emotion into my words where none initially existed? Because you are biased. My guess is that you injected hostility into my words because my opinion is simply against your opinion.

It's normal human behavior to interpret a difference of opinion as an attack. I point this out to you so you can better understand yourself and to not classify a unique opinion as an attack. This is my interpretation of what's going on with you and I think it's pretty accurate.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by NicoJuicy on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:27PM (#27401857)
Dang changed according to the > decade old rules.

He also added ~"there's 2 sides of a story". I don't see why Dang wouldn't be allowed to add a comment regarding this topic.

Every post about a company has an employee/CEO stating an opinion and often even stating their side.

Even if you would think Dang's opinion is subjective ( which i didn't interpret as such). Why would that suddenly be a problem?

I said chill for example because of this:

> Down weight? So you guys internally pick and choose topics to weight down? I thought HN was purely community driven with only comments being moderated.

You seemed ignorant to the basic fact that every half decent forum is moderated. And you "attack" them on something that is known by ( almost appearantly) everyone and the very thing that makes+keeps this community interesting.

Good moderation is too much undervalued from my POV. You only notice it when it's gone.

If I'm free to give my opinion, you seem to frustrated because people don't agree with you. I understand, it's normal and human behavior. You are not above it.

As an example your most recent comment

(first line)

> Any post that challenges dang will likely get voted down.

Ugh.

(Last line)

> Still it's sorta good that this post wasn't outright deleted.

Full of human behavior ( as you like to mention), because it doesn't fit your endgoal. Downplaying that the post isn't deleted, while admitting that the moderation was fair.

To be honest. Dang could have just moderated this thread. Reactions such as ours are the reason why and don't have any meaningful content.

But he choose not to. Even though he probably knew it would lead to content as this.

Useless content :)

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:17AM (#27402142)
>He also added ~"there's 2 sides of a story". I don't see why Dang wouldn't be allowed to add a comment regarding this topic.

The fact that it's the top post is the most questionable thing here, it seems pinned to the top.

The statement is seemingly fair and balanced but make no mistake it's not. A common technique among corporations and public relations experts is to try to seemingly be fair about things that are obviously wrong. A good example of this is educational creationism in the US. Many schools want to teach a fair and balanced view of biology by teaching both evolution and creationism. Like dang himself said, there are two sides to every story after all.

I never said Dang should be banned from commenting. It is a dictatorship after all. His opinion and comment and the fact that it's the top comment in this thread makes the whole thing sketchy. And that is all I am remarking on.

If I were him and my intentions were to be neutral I woulda just left the topic completely alone.

>Good moderation is too much undervalued from my POV. You only notice it when it's gone.

This is off topic. I'm not talking about moderation here as something to get rid of. My topic is the conflict of interest that has to do with this thread and dangs comment on it. That's it.

>If I'm free to give my opinion, you seem to frustrated because people don't agree with you. I understand, it's normal and human behavior. You are not above it.

You are, and I appreciate your opinion. I never said I was above it. But here you are again, after telling me to chill you tell me that I seem frustrated. Again it's your bias talking and inserting false emotions into places where none exists. I am simply explaining why I disagree with you.

>As an example your most recent comment, first line: >> Any post that challenges dang will likely get voted down. >It's snarky against a highly respected member that is part of the team that makes this forum HN.

It's not snarky dude. It's true. If I call someone who murdered 10 people a killer am I being snarky? No. I'm remarking on a fact. Now I admit I'm criticizing him but open and polite criticism is part of the spirit of HN.

Anyway this subthread has already degraded to uninteresting talk that's against the spirit of HN. I would say normally dang would probably kill this subthread if he saw it, but he may not in effort to appear fair and balanced. That's a good thing. But that doesn't mean you should just ignore the conflict of interest at play here. Either way, it's best not to continue this debate, I've made my point and you evidently disagree but neither of us can definitively prove whether censorship is happening or if it isn't so let's end it here.

>Full of human behavior ( as you like to mention), because it doesn't fit your endgoal. Downplaying that the post isn't deleted, while admitting that the moderation was fair.

And what is my endgoal? I have repeatedly said he could not be censoring things and that he also could Why didn't you bring those up? Are you CHERRYPICKING??? No you're not, you're simply not clear about what I am saying so I am clarifying the facts to you.

My end goal here is to remark that the actions dang took here are a conflict of interest and that makes his post highly sus. Does it mean dang doesn't do good things? No. Does it mean dang has never done no evil? No. It means that what he is doing here for this specific post is sketchy. THAT is my end goal.

>Useless content :)

See. This is rude and the smiley face is truly snark. This is actually against the rules of HN. A deliberate violation. I wonder how dang would react to this kind that kind of remark. Truly a test of his ability to stay centered and unbiased. Most likely he won't do anything given the context.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by grzm on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:23AM (#27402173)
> "The fact that it's the top post is the most questionable thing here, it seems pinned to the top."

I thought he might have pinned it, but that isn't the case:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27401409

> "I certainly didn't intend it to be the top comment; that was entirely by upvotes."

[dead]
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by grzm on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:41AM (#27402243)
> "I mean he can lie right?"

If you're not willing to engage with him in good faith, I have a hard time understanding why you’re commenting in this thread. Have a good evening.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:34AM (#27402512)
Giving someone with a conflict of interest good faith is extremely unwise. I advise even for you never to do it.

In essence you can say my faith in him is 50% not 100% as good faith seems to imply. So with 50% faith, engagement is still has value. I never met a person who never lied, so every single person I've ever talked to in my life I technically never had 100% good faith towards. I expect everyone to lie and be untrustworthy at some point. For some people it's big things, for other people it's minor white lies. For someone with a conflict of interest I'd be more careful.

Additionally even someone completely untrustworthy can still be communicated with. You can still glean information from such a person by observing his actions. For example if dang censors this thread by deleting the whole thing, that would say a lot. Him not deleting the thread also says a lot.

What I don't understand about you is how you can say you don't "understand" something and then suddenly say "good evening" as if you're leaving. Wouldn't the goal be for you to "stay" and "understand" Or is the goal simply to debate and win or leave if you can't win?

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by ohyeshedid on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:47AM (#27402282)
So instead of good faith conversation, you just opted for conspiracy babble?
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Saturday June 05, 2021 @04:31AM (#27403287)
No instead of blind faith I choose to not trust someone with a conflict of interest. You choose to give him your blind faith and call any form of doubt a conspiracy bubble.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by NicoJuicy on Saturday June 05, 2021 @06:18AM (#27403734)
You literally ignore the basic facts that this thread wasn't deleted/flagged.

He didn't pin his comment as you claimed multiple times either.

It's not blind faith, but good faith based on Dang's > decade long track record on HN as moderator.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:01PM (#27406128)
He's probably not deleting or flagging anything because he's aware it will make him look biased. This is a common strategy. Dang picking and choosing only to censor the most insidious things remains an open possibility.

Also, what decade long track record? You have a record of posts that were deleted or censored? That would be a track record. But guess what? none exists. That's a fact.

All I'm saying is that a conflict of interest exists and because of this conflict of interest, dangs comment is pure sketch.

Am I going to let my neighbor borrow a million dollars just because he has good credit? No. It would be unwise to do so and you blindly trusting dang is highly, highly unwise.

All forms of faith are blindness.

I claimed multiple times that it looks like this was pinned. Whether it was actually pinned is open for debate. So you make a claim it wasn't pinned, why don't you prove it with something other than blind faith in dang saying he never pinned it.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by NicoJuicy on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:32PM (#27407881)
You are making the accusations. In the court of law, it's up to you to prove it and you obviously can't.

You're constantly making accusations without any proof.

[dead]
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:20AM (#27430616)
You can't dox other users, or attack other users, on HN. I've banned this account. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27430579.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by NicoJuicy on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:29AM (#27402191)
You're response to my appreciation of moderation is ( while you are protesting against any moderation outside of the community ):

> This is off topic.

You are literally comparing things with ( in 1 post): China, covid, dictatorship, serial killers, censorship, educational creationism, biology in schools, ...

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

It's an upvoted comment by a moderator... Nothing more, nothing less.

As I said before: chill.

Ps. Still useless content :)

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by neonological on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:21AM (#27402447)
>You are literally comparing things with ( in 1 post): China, covid, dictatorship, serial killers, censorship, educational creationism, biology in schools, ...

Those are called examples. Examples in service of helping to illustrate a point that is still on topic.

You on the other hand wanted to talk about things that were never remarked upon or even true. I never said anything about how dang should stop moderating anything. You brought that up out of nowhere. Hence. Off topic.

>As I said before: chill. >Ps. Still useless content :)

Then stop replying. Stop being rude. There's no point if it's useless for you.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by NicoJuicy on Saturday June 05, 2021 @06:13AM (#27403717)
> Those are called examples.

No. It's whataboutism.

[dead]
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:21AM (#27430619)
Wtf? You can't dox other users, or attack other users, on HN. I've banned this account. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27430579.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by late2part on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:28PM (#27401461)
Don't you know how Reddit started?
[dead]
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by Nicksil on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:19PM (#27401394)
>Its not the first time you've been caught in a lie, dang.

>But folks, this is the secret hackernews site, called BookFace. This is the site that the event happened. Its also a nice site to conspire with other YC companies and YC itself as a cohesive market 'strategy'.

>https://bookface.ycombinator.com/

>Other secrets that HN/dang/pg don't want you to know is that founders can see each other with special flairs here. Of course, conspiring on BookFace also helps too.

None of that is secret much less anything anybody "don't want you to know."

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:24PM (#27401431)
What is this "lie" you speak of? Actually, can you please list the other ones too? It's not fair to readers to make a tantalizing claim like that and then not give them enough information to make up their own minds. It's practically dripping with duck fat.

Re Bookface: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

Re YC founder usernames- it can't be secret if it's in the FAQ, right? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html#yc.

None of these things are secret and to the extent you or anyone is curious about them, all you need to do is ask.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by duckfang on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:26PM (#27401452)
switch the letters of my username.

that's what I think of you.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:31PM (#27401485)
Oh yes that's clear, but it's also bloody clever and you get points for that. I'm sorry if my reference seemed like a swipe; I was just trying to speak duck with you.

When people say this kind of stuff to me, I try not to take it personally because the truth is that you don't know me and I don't know you; what you're saying is not what you think of me, it's what you think of the image that you've constructed from a name plus very little information. That's not a criticism. That's just how it is on the internet.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by doctor_eval on Friday June 04, 2021 @11:47PM (#27401969)
I don’t know how you do this, dang, but I certainly wish I had your level of chill.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by PhantomGremlin on Saturday June 05, 2021 @04:09AM (#27403201)
I think I could last about a week doing his job. Maybe a month.

I don't think $1,000,000 USD would be enough to entice me to do the job for a year. It would be too stressful.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by CRConrad on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:22AM (#27461112)
Yeah, dang: We need to know what you drink, smoke, or inject.

Particularly the more choleric among us coughwho, me?cough could use some tips.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by doctor_eval on Saturday June 05, 2021 @05:55AM (#27403642)
...also, thanks!
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by choppaface on Saturday June 05, 2021 @12:59AM (#27402355)
What?!! There are many, many posts with “inaccurate” titles. Would you like to change the John Carmack post to include his entire tweet as the title? YC moderation here on a YC-related post is not fair. It’s also unfair that this reply is placed above substantive discussion.
Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by dang on Saturday June 05, 2021 @03:35AM (#27403040)
If there are many posts with inaccurate titles, that's because we didn't see them. If you skim these 500 comments you'll see that we make a habit of editing inaccurate titles: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... - and that's just a small fraction of the cases. Also these 250: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que.... HN users are pretty adamant about title accuracy: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que....

> Would you like to change the John Carmack post to include his entire tweet as the title?

No, "John Carmack on JPEG" strikes me as an accurate title for that post, and in any case the entire tweet wouldn't fit HN's 80 char limit. When users think there's an inaccuracy or come up with a better (more accurate and neutral) title, we're usually happy to make a change.

> YC moderation here on a YC-related post is not fair

The principle, as I explained above, is that we moderate HN less when YC or a YC startup is involved (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...). Less, however, does not mean not at all - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que.... That would be a huge loophole. In this case I did the minimum to correct a false statement in the title and was hands off after that.

> It’s also unfair that this reply is placed above substantive discussion

That would be true if we had placed it there, but users upvoted it there.

Re:LOL just got kicked out of @ycombinator by choppaface on Saturday June 05, 2021 @01:19PM (#27406859)
As a past moderator for an unrelated forum, there’s a careful balance between “reducing confusion” and “fanning the flamewar using a moderator’s outsized leverage.” I really don’t see how the reply here strikes that balance. Moreover, my post here was +3 but is suddenly now -3 after Dang’s reply.

Dang, I’m sure you have a lot of work to do, but I recommend you take a critical look at how much of that “work” you’re actually creating for yourself. The behavior I’ve observed here really underscores the untrustworthiness of other things I’ve seen from YC founders and employees.