The fact that it's the top post is the most questionable thing here, it seems pinned to the top.
The statement is seemingly fair and balanced but make no mistake it's not. A common technique among corporations and public relations experts is to try to seemingly be fair about things that are obviously wrong. A good example of this is educational creationism in the US. Many schools want to teach a fair and balanced view of biology by teaching both evolution and creationism. Like dang himself said, there are two sides to every story after all.
I never said Dang should be banned from commenting. It is a dictatorship after all. His opinion and comment and the fact that it's the top comment in this thread makes the whole thing sketchy. And that is all I am remarking on.
If I were him and my intentions were to be neutral I woulda just left the topic completely alone.
>Good moderation is too much undervalued from my POV. You only notice it when it's gone.
This is off topic. I'm not talking about moderation here as something to get rid of. My topic is the conflict of interest that has to do with this thread and dangs comment on it. That's it.
>If I'm free to give my opinion, you seem to frustrated because people don't agree with you. I understand, it's normal and human behavior. You are not above it.
You are, and I appreciate your opinion. I never said I was above it. But here you are again, after telling me to chill you tell me that I seem frustrated. Again it's your bias talking and inserting false emotions into places where none exists. I am simply explaining why I disagree with you.
>As an example your most recent comment, first line: >> Any post that challenges dang will likely get voted down. >It's snarky against a highly respected member that is part of the team that makes this forum HN.
It's not snarky dude. It's true. If I call someone who murdered 10 people a killer am I being snarky? No. I'm remarking on a fact. Now I admit I'm criticizing him but open and polite criticism is part of the spirit of HN.
Anyway this subthread has already degraded to uninteresting talk that's against the spirit of HN. I would say normally dang would probably kill this subthread if he saw it, but he may not in effort to appear fair and balanced. That's a good thing. But that doesn't mean you should just ignore the conflict of interest at play here. Either way, it's best not to continue this debate, I've made my point and you evidently disagree but neither of us can definitively prove whether censorship is happening or if it isn't so let's end it here.
>Full of human behavior ( as you like to mention), because it doesn't fit your endgoal. Downplaying that the post isn't deleted, while admitting that the moderation was fair.
And what is my endgoal? I have repeatedly said he could not be censoring things and that he also could Why didn't you bring those up? Are you CHERRYPICKING??? No you're not, you're simply not clear about what I am saying so I am clarifying the facts to you.
My end goal here is to remark that the actions dang took here are a conflict of interest and that makes his post highly sus. Does it mean dang doesn't do good things? No. Does it mean dang has never done no evil? No. It means that what he is doing here for this specific post is sketchy. THAT is my end goal.
>Useless content :)
See. This is rude and the smiley face is truly snark. This is actually against the rules of HN. A deliberate violation. I wonder how dang would react to this kind that kind of remark. Truly a test of his ability to stay centered and unbiased. Most likely he won't do anything given the context.
I thought he might have pinned it, but that isn't the case:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27401409
> "I certainly didn't intend it to be the top comment; that was entirely by upvotes."
If you're not willing to engage with him in good faith, I have a hard time understanding why you’re commenting in this thread. Have a good evening.
In essence you can say my faith in him is 50% not 100% as good faith seems to imply. So with 50% faith, engagement is still has value. I never met a person who never lied, so every single person I've ever talked to in my life I technically never had 100% good faith towards. I expect everyone to lie and be untrustworthy at some point. For some people it's big things, for other people it's minor white lies. For someone with a conflict of interest I'd be more careful.
Additionally even someone completely untrustworthy can still be communicated with. You can still glean information from such a person by observing his actions. For example if dang censors this thread by deleting the whole thing, that would say a lot. Him not deleting the thread also says a lot.
What I don't understand about you is how you can say you don't "understand" something and then suddenly say "good evening" as if you're leaving. Wouldn't the goal be for you to "stay" and "understand" Or is the goal simply to debate and win or leave if you can't win?
He didn't pin his comment as you claimed multiple times either.
It's not blind faith, but good faith based on Dang's > decade long track record on HN as moderator.
Also, what decade long track record? You have a record of posts that were deleted or censored? That would be a track record. But guess what? none exists. That's a fact.
All I'm saying is that a conflict of interest exists and because of this conflict of interest, dangs comment is pure sketch.
Am I going to let my neighbor borrow a million dollars just because he has good credit? No. It would be unwise to do so and you blindly trusting dang is highly, highly unwise.
All forms of faith are blindness.
I claimed multiple times that it looks like this was pinned. Whether it was actually pinned is open for debate. So you make a claim it wasn't pinned, why don't you prove it with something other than blind faith in dang saying he never pinned it.
You're constantly making accusations without any proof.
> This is off topic.
You are literally comparing things with ( in 1 post): China, covid, dictatorship, serial killers, censorship, educational creationism, biology in schools, ...
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
It's an upvoted comment by a moderator... Nothing more, nothing less.
As I said before: chill.
Ps. Still useless content :)
Those are called examples. Examples in service of helping to illustrate a point that is still on topic.
You on the other hand wanted to talk about things that were never remarked upon or even true. I never said anything about how dang should stop moderating anything. You brought that up out of nowhere. Hence. Off topic.
>As I said before: chill. >Ps. Still useless content :)
Then stop replying. Stop being rude. There's no point if it's useless for you.
No. It's whataboutism.
He also added ~"there's 2 sides of a story". I don't see why Dang wouldn't be allowed to add a comment regarding this topic.
Every post about a company has an employee/CEO stating an opinion and often even stating their side.
Even if you would think Dang's opinion is subjective ( which i didn't interpret as such). Why would that suddenly be a problem?
I said chill for example because of this:
> Down weight? So you guys internally pick and choose topics to weight down? I thought HN was purely community driven with only comments being moderated.
You seemed ignorant to the basic fact that every half decent forum is moderated. And you "attack" them on something that is known by ( almost appearantly) everyone and the very thing that makes+keeps this community interesting.
Good moderation is too much undervalued from my POV. You only notice it when it's gone.
If I'm free to give my opinion, you seem to frustrated because people don't agree with you. I understand, it's normal and human behavior. You are not above it.
As an example your most recent comment
(first line)
> Any post that challenges dang will likely get voted down.
Ugh.
(Last line)
> Still it's sorta good that this post wasn't outright deleted.
Full of human behavior ( as you like to mention), because it doesn't fit your endgoal. Downplaying that the post isn't deleted, while admitting that the moderation was fair.
To be honest. Dang could have just moderated this thread. Reactions such as ours are the reason why and don't have any meaningful content.
But he choose not to. Even though he probably knew it would lead to content as this.
Useless content :)