The biggest trick is the banks. When using fiat and opening a bank account for an incorporated business, the bankers often ask for information on the company like website presence of marketing materials.
For the past few years I've been able to point to articles about commerce in Asia being chat app based, to get past that. Bankers don't actually care, but you do need to know how to make them not begin to care.
It's not too long ago they would ask for information faxed using company letterhead, as a form of legitimization.
The signals they use to vet customers are, again, a decade or two behind what's technologically relevant.
To which my boss replied "Wtf is letterhead?"
Personally, i'd be more comfortable with the modern approach being something more along the lines of:
You should put the token that we'll provide you with under your corporate website's page: https://<YOUR_DOMAIN>/.well-known/identity-challenge/<TOKEN>
A bit like what is done by Let's Encrypt for providing HTTPS (though there could be additional technical details).Of course, this does almost nothing for the website being compromised, but still feels less nonsensical than using fax and using letterheads and such.
Owning a website (or a printer, or a truck, or lots of money) doesn't mean you have a business. It's about the nature and purpose of your activities with those assets (or skills).
I can add an identity token to my personal website, but that doesn't make it a business any more than putting a saddle on a zebra makes it a horse.
This ruling from the Australian Tax Office lays out pretty clearly the defining characteristics of a business [1]. It's probably a bit different in the USA, but I'm sure it's not too dissimilar.
[1] https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?docid=TXR/TR20191/N...
I had PayPal ask me for exactly this (emailed rather than faxed) recently for my PayPal business account!
The incorporated entity is just for limiting liability, having properties in its name instead of yours, and more easily convincing tax authorities that the universe of tax deductible expenses is so great.
You can be paid for goods and services immediately, these days.
A minor feedback for the marketing page.
I’m an English speaker currently in Mexico City. The webpage first opened in Spanish based on my location.
It only took a few seconds to figure that I could change the language just above the footer, but my UI recommendation would be to put the location/language switcher next to the upper right sandwich (I’m on mobile) in a circle with the flag of my default country/language.
That would be much faster to find and have the added benefit of displaying how many countries and languages Stripe works in.
I'm building this myself with a product currently only in English in a Spanish speaking country, for speakers of both, so it's top of mind.
IMHO, the automatic detection being wrong is less of an issue with a greater ease of language selection.
Only 38% people of India has Hindi as their mother-tongue.
There is strong anti-Hindi-imposition sentiment in many places of India.
Just because someone's geolocation is set to India, don't automatically translate it to Hindi. It irks many.
It is frustrating to no end to visit sport sites in europe (for example, soccer) to have them default to MLS news or mexico news because of my IP
When i specifically go to a EU website to get EU sports news, why is does website forcing me to eat news about my home country sports???
It has gotten so bad that I've just dropped a few sites as a result.
Worse, it is never intuitive or easy to switch the content to the "default"
I never switch to another language other than English.
It is highly advisable that companies translate to eight most common Indian languages. Or even the top five [0].
People speaking all major languages of India are huge potential markets for companies. Google offers search in nine Indian languages. Amazon provides customer services in five languages.
For some services, you should not even want to translate to languages other than English. India has one of the largest English speaking populace of the world- 2nd only after the US [1].
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_number_of....
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_English-s...
> Translate to 8 Indian languages
That is not a compromise at all, that's a full solution
Especially where people willfully get arrested to wipe down Hindi marks from metro stations [0] and people who have fasted to death to not have Hindi as the national language [1].
[0]: https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kannada-pride-wins-day...
English
עִברִית
العربية
हिंदी
ไทย
etc
In that case, I'd suggest the first two letters of the language, an "En" for English, an "Es" for Spanish, a "De" for German, etc.
How does uber default the language for you? They've got the advantage of your registration so probably easier...
The most useful addition would be another text box (or full form) in the payment link setup to specify sending some custom text to the payer upon payment (by email or on-page or both).
For example a "Thank You", but also a "here's the private link to the thing you bought, here are the details, here is the password, here is the timeframe for shipping, here's what to do next", etc.
I'm curious if you have analytics collection on the first use case since it seems like a pretty risky privacy violation in terms of user tracking but honestly not far beyond shenanigans that bigger players pull (Facebook/Amazon).
But I'm really curious about the second use case - the no code approach is really nice and flexible for sending payment requests over alternative media (i.e. discord) but it feels like this might open the door a bit more to phishing users via redirection - do you happen to have any security ruminations on that topic that you've made public or be willing to share?
Here's an example of a payment link: https://buy.stripe.com/dR6cOd9RJ8KS8nufYZ. It's a single link that can be shared with anybody (not unique to one customer).
On the Stripe side, nothing is collected from the customer til they click.
We've thought a lot about the security side of things—one of the reasons why Payment Links has its own subdomain and the payment page is hosted by Stripe.
It would be very cool if it would either (1) redirect to the company website or (2) a “store” or directory showing other available Payment Links.
Excellent work!
Really nice and clean process though.
The one feedback I'd give is that it's hard for a user to know they can adjust the quantity on mobile. You have to click the "Details" link in the top right, and it's not really obvious to a user this is where they should go do this. (i.e. they may well think that they can't update the quantity).
That’s an additional service to find and connect if you use stripe, sadly. That’s why when we launched Lab Surprise [0], with 19 apps from developers in several different countries, selling worldwide our bundles, we ended up using Paddle: they are the merchant of record, collect and remit the correct taxes in each country. Yes, it’s 5%+0.5cts but for us it was worth it.
I’m pretty sure many sellers using Stripe paylinks will just never do the proper remittances in countries that are not their country of origin, but that might end up bitting them hard.
Making tax remittance invisible is what can unleash instant worldwide micro-stores without hidden task risk
About a year ago I was toying with the idea of creating a SaaS/product that worked completely without JS, and the only hurdle was that there currently is no way to simply answer redirect a client directly to the Checkout page after creating a Checkout Session in the backend. Currently, you have to create the Checkout Session, send this to the client, load StripeJS, and _then_ you can redirect to the Checkout page.
Seeing that the Payment Link is basically the same thing, only that instead of a backend, the seller can create the Payment Link ("Checkout Session") in a dashboard, it doesn't really seem like the StripeJS-step I mentioned above is strictly necessary.
I hope you'll add a way to get the URL when creating a Checkout Session in the backend, so that the dream of a fully-functioning noscript SaaS might one day come true :)
If I'm going to go through all that trouble, I might as well just use a Wordpress electronic delivery solution or Woocommerce, in which case, what's the point of this website-less payment solution?
If I'm gonna go website-less, then it needs to do what the website would otherwise do.
Warning: shameless plug.
It's a no-code shopping cart that works with Stripe. We offer digital downloads that work as you describe.
You could check it out - https://trolley.link
(you can email me direct at [email protected] if you want to know anything more)
It really does make me want to consider working with stripe for my next project (or, consider working for stripe for my next job)
As to your reflections, I'm wondering how Stripe ingests these various emerging patterns around the world (especially as you expand to unfamiliar territory) and prioritize bringing them into your products?
IOW: if N trends at various stages of the adoption cycle are happening 7K miles away, how do you think about placing different bets on each, especially when the cultural moments may be wildly different than, as yet, Stripe understands?
Cheers! SM
When you launched Atlas I've considered it, but the accounting and taxes are complicated and expensive. I believe one even needs to charge state sales taxes in some states.
I can't wait to be wrong about that!
Keep in mind the Panama papers you probably are thinking of had little to do with Panama. The law firm was located in Panama, but the corporations and shady financial things were happening in the usual handful of island nations. If the law firm was located in New York it would have been the Manhattan papers - it didn't have much to do with Panama at all.
I formerly lived in Sri Lanka, and the country lacks a payment provider worth their salt, let alone an innovative one like Stripe. Perhaps extending the countries that Stripe supports can have the biggest impact.
Also, there's no good way to share the original link. The one after you click (and page you end up on after purchase) is crufty: https://checkout.stripe.com/pay/cs_live_n1WDYJkCi1wp32H4Zlh8...
Obviously, Stripe is the gold standard and I think we have a hard time, but we're hoping to improve the developer experience even more this year.
For example, when I implemented the PRODUCT_CHANGE event I expected it would notify me of the new product, but that is not the case on Android which led to bugs with some customers. It turns out that only iOS sends the new_product_id, so it is impossible to know from this event what the new product should be to display it in the app. Since upgrades/downgrades are immediate on Android, it turns out that the solution was just to not handle that event on Android since the renewal event would override the product anyways. (but sometimes the events came out of order, which is what led to bugs when PRODUCT_CHANGE was after RENEWAL).
There are a lot of cases where events in the dashboard are totally out of order and don't make sense, like showing a customer purchasing the lesser plan, then renewing for the upgraded plan, and then switching from the lesser to the upgraded plan 10 days later. How could that be possible? The switch should have been between the renewals, so it's very confusing to debug.
I've been told that now the recommended approach is to ignore all the webhook data, and simply call the RevenueCat API to get the entitlement and subscription status - however I asked how to parse this into something meaningful and didn't get a good answer. I would like to know the users current entitlement, and the current subscription (which can be different than the entitlement). For example, if the user downgrades, their entitlement may still be the upgraded plan for a while, but the app should reflect that they are no longer subscribed, or that they are subscribed to a different plan. For the entitlement it is easy I think, just choose the highest entitlement level to use. For the subscription, maybe choosing the last renewed one would work? But there are so many complexities with downgrades, upgrades, crossgrades I don't know if that is true. The answer from support was basically that they didn't know, yet this is an absolute must for almost any app - there has to be a way to display what the user is currently paying (or not paying) for, linking out to the native UI is not an option as it's not user friendly and cannot be displayed cross platform (I want the website to also reflect what they are paying for). My big concern with this is also, why does the API supposedly return the correct data but the webhook doesn't? If I am calling the API 10ms after receiving the webhook, why can't the webhook just deliver correct data instead?
Another current issue I discovered the other day was that grace periods are no longer working. The RevenueCat dashboard shows that they are getting a 7 day grace period (the expiration date in the dashboard is correct), yet in the webhooks I am getting the wrong expiration, one that is only a day away. Apparently this is due to a change by Google and a fix is (maybe?) on the way? But it caused a lot of issues that I didn't expect.
Basically RevenueCat's promise is great, it has saved a ton of time but isn't quite there on fully abstracting all these native edge cases away, they crop up in the API occasionally, and the proposed fix to use the API instead of the webhook data is half baked when support has no idea how to actually parse it to get the current subscription that should be displayed to the user (in the case that they upgraded/downgraded and have more than one). I love the idea but I'm hesitant to recommend it to anyone because lately it's been causing a lot of headaches with customers having billing issues due to these inconsistencies.
Would you mind dropping me an email [email protected]? I think for our long term viability we need to have the trust of people who care about edge cases like this. I’d love to hear more.
Really they’d be smart to create an “External Payments” or “Off-platform payments” concept to support more than just Apple/Google. It could be a little odd to not get payouts on a portion of your invoices (like it could cause weird issues if you suck all the Stripe data into another tool/your platform, you’d have to take that into account) but it might be useful to enough people. It sets Stripe up to step in, with small code changes for the developer, if the walls weaken/come down around current IAP policies. Also, it provides only 1 API for a dev who wants to offer CC as well Apple Pay (not IAP) instead of 2 or just skipping CC (using only Apple Pay).
All that said, it will be a hard sell to Stripe execs who will probably see it as a large maintenance burden all to record stuff they don’t make money off of.
I do like the idea though!
https://stripe.com/blog/accessible-color-systems
https://videos.ctfassets.net/fzn2n1nzq965/7GDaCnGLsYrdVIwXIq...
First, the link that I was given to send to the other party was a tinyurl.com link. This concerns me because I don't think that Stripe or PayNowLink has control of tinyurl.com. If tinyurl.com is exploited then someone can reroute people to a totally different site.
Second, Privacy.com debit cards didn't work for me. I've reached out to support to see if that's something they can fix. Is that a known issue?
I would be super interested to know if there are any blockchain projects or related corollaries that Stripe is working on.
e.g. we're looking into how to pair payment links with Jam (https://jam.systems | https://jamshelf.com), basically stand-alone Clubhouse-style audio rooms.
Unbundling of the payment feature of superapps.
Link page: "Get an email after every successful payment by managing your settings."
Settings page: "Successful payments. Receive a notification for every successful payment."
While I love this, is there a way to also programmatically create these links?
With those additional fields it would mean we could post donation links all over the place, and then get donor details out of Stripe for the donations team. Thanks :)
Happy to chat more via email if helpful as you get started with Stripe — I'm [email protected]
So that a StripeLink buyer who is being charges can also later receive revenue ?
Is this all based on credit/debit cards? Are there any plans to incorporate mobile money payments?
While there are lots of antecedents (this is, after all, just a checkout page with a URL), and even though this was substantially inspired by the growth of the no-code ecosystem[0], the thing that's interesting to me about the payment link "space" is that it's a use case that really took off in other markets first -- Nigeria, India, Philippines, etc. I suspect that staying abreast of important new patterns emerging outside US/Europe will become more important for many businesses in the years ahead... there are a lot of legacy assumptions being questioned.
And feedback very welcome on our Payment Links product itself!
[0] We were excited to have Ben Tossell, one of the original no-coders, as one of our beta users: https://twitter.com/bentossell/status/1397246339898093568