News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by ehsankia on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @01:59PM (#26878197)
As pointed out above, this is already the status quo (replacable battery, 1 year life, etc). Tile has had it for years.

I'm curious if it would've been technically feasible to have wireless charging on these instead of replaceable battery. Or would that greatly increase the price?

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by dijit on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:26PM (#26880100)
> Tile has had it for years.

I had a tile and it most assuredly did not have a replacable battery, I had to mill the thing open: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrhM5ujSU6w

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by kstrauser on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:56PM (#26880611)
I've had a Tile with a replaceable battery since 2018 (according to the app just now). It replaced the previous single-use model.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Me1000 on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:31PM (#26880178)
Yeah, I had to check their website... it looks like some of the their models have replaceable batteries now, but they certainly didn't start that way (and not all of their products have a replaceable battery today).
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by ehsankia on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:36PM (#26885159)
Never claimed it started this way, but they've had replaceable models for ~3 years now, if not longer.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by spoonjim on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:53PM (#26880562)
Tile has products with replaceable and with non replaceable batteries.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by natch on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:23PM (#26885088)
Yes now they do. For years they had only non-user-replaceable ones but they were happy to charge a large fee for a swap.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by quangv on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:51AM (#26885538)
Tile sends me free replaceable batteries.

Hopefully AirTag opens up their API so Tile can integrate. I’m just assuming AirTag would be slightly more integrated than Tile.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by FabHK on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:02AM (#26887029)
Here is Gruber's take (from Daring Fireball):

> Conspicuously absent from the list [of third-party products using the Find My network], of course, is Tile. Given their membership in Epic’s Coalition for App Fairness, I wouldn’t hold my breath waiting for Apple to promote Tile’s products. And it’s unclear to me whether Tile even wants to be in the Find My app — their spat with Apple is more about their own app competing with Find My, and their accusations that Apple unfairly advantages Find My by not holding it to the same rules as third-party apps that ask for always-on location access. Apple’s solution is this third-party accessory program; Tile’s preferred solution would be Apple allowing Tile’s own app to do everything Find My can do.

https://daringfireball.net/linked/2021/04/07/find-my-third-p...

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by mrunkel on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:19AM (#26885690)
The “find my” app is open to third party devices, but they have to get certified.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by dexterdog on Friday April 23, 2021 @05:22PM (#26919347)
That's a funny way of saying they have to pay for the license.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by sbuk on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @03:05AM (#26886285)
They do? They charge me an annual subscription for that.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by natch on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:36PM (#26907162)
Free? How did you swing that without the subscription payment?
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by KingOfCoders on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:32AM (#26885437)
"Now" like in the last 3+ years.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by pfranz on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:46PM (#26879294)
Tile didn't start with replaceable batteries--they still don't use them in all their products. I don't know how AirTags will be in practice, but user-replaceable batteries haven't been great. I don't know if it's a technical restriction or not, but "low-battery" seems to be a time based warning and not based on battery charge. So I either get an alert when 1 year has passed on all of my devices at the same time, or they just suddenly die without warning. I could see why Apple might avoid this user experience. Hopefully, their implementation is better.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by habibur on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @04:01PM (#26880703)
> I don't know if it's a technical restriction or not

More likely because CR batteries don't drop voltage significantly as it discharges. And at full discharge it suddenly drops dead. Which is why it's harder to measure "remaining charge", as that's generally calculated on battery voltage.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by rkangel on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:40AM (#26887725)
It's equally hard to get any useful information about Li-On or Li-Po based just on battery voltage which is why any actually useful battery indicator involves a charge counter (informally known as a 'gas gauge'). The actual coulombs of charge are counted in and out and that gives a much better estimate.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by yardie on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @06:52PM (#26883000)
Lithium batteries are high output until they're not. Like the CR2032 battery in my car keyfob it's working until it's not. The drop from 3V to 1V is precipitously fast. Also, 1 year is extremely conservative. I normally get 3 years out of these batteries. An Airtag that's constantly being interrogated may run out faster than say a keyfob used 5x a day
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by culturestate on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:10AM (#26885340)
Yeah, I'd expect these to last notably longer than a year for most people. The AirTags marketing page gives the measurement spec:

> Battery life based on an everyday use of four play sound events and one Precision Finding event per day.

That seems like exceptionally heavy usage to me.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by floatingatoll on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:51PM (#26883551)
If the airtag dies without warning, wouldn’t it alert the user that the tag is out of range, and so then they could replace the battery? (Presumably Apple has a UI flow for this.)
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Kye on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:35PM (#26880240)
Your choice is a reasonable timer or extra circuitry and logic for monitoring battery power that cuts the battery life.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by idiotsecant on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:57PM (#26880631)
low-cost, low-power battery monitoring is like pretty much the most solved problem ever.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by zsmi on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:28PM (#26881975)
you forgot something, low-cost, low-power, low-accuracy battery monitoring is like pretty much the most solved problem ever.

low-cost & low-power & high accuracy, not so much

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by idiotsecant on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:16AM (#26885368)
What do you mean? It's literally just a 2-axis lookup table with voltage on one axis and SOC on the other.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by xondono on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:39AM (#26885472)
Except it isn’t, not with modern lithium based batteries.

Now most devices use direct voltage, coloumb counting and battery impedance to keep track, and that’s with known batteries.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:11AM (#26885956)
Even for lithium ion batteries, notoriously hard to track, that's only true for the middle 70-80% of the charging range. It's very easy to check it a lithium ion battery is almost empty, just wait for the voltage to drop below 3.6 or 3.5 and maybe adjust for temperature.

For a CR2032 specifically, you get a nice smooth drop over at least the last third to quarter of its charge. There's no difficulty in detecting that.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by rkangel on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:43AM (#26887750)
It sometimes looks like that in the lab, but in real life it doesn't work. Here are two of the MANY situations that result in incredibly misleading voltage readouts:

My battery is 80% charged, and then I go outside where it is 10 degC colder. Suddenly my battery voltage drops by 200mV and my battery looks 20% charged

My battery is 80% charged and then I start playing a video. The increased load drops the battery voltage and suddenly my battery looks 20% charged.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by kbos87 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @07:09AM (#26887958)
The fact that the Nest motion sensors / path lights in my home have been functioning for almost 2 years (their stated lifespan) without me needing to replace their tiny batteries boggles my mind.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by dghlsakjg on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:35PM (#26883418)
A CR2032 (disposable) has 2x-4x (200 mah under ideal conditions, compared to 40 mah) the capacity of the same sized LR2032 (rechargeable), and is more stable over a long period of time. In addition there is the necessity of additional charging circuitry, and I'm not sure how small they can physically make the charging antenna.

Lithium rechargeable would mean higher price, larger size for equivalent specs, with an added risk of fire!

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by sydd on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @03:04AM (#26886277)
Instead now we get millions of CR2032 batteries thrown into the garbage each day :/

Anything with non-chargeable batteries is a no go from sustainability perspective

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by mensetmanusman on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @08:17AM (#26888599)
That’s not true, it depends on the types of materials, how it is disposed, and what the alternatives are.

Recall that everything is made out of rearranged earth atoms. So long as you put them back properly, it can be sustainable.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by ostenning on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:05PM (#26934962)
Yeah but is that practically the case? Most people just chuck things in the trash. Most are too busy to even think about disposing of their waste properly.. This is the reality of our society
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by chid on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @04:37AM (#26886853)
you could get them as a re-chargeable (though it would likely be more waste to buy a recharger) - but I mean even rechargeable batteries are also consumables
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by dghlsakjg on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @11:58AM (#26891365)
Rechargeable batteries in the 2032 (20mm wide, 3.2mm deep) package are generally lithium ion chemistry.

This means that, depending on the circuitry they are not always drop in compatible since the voltages and discharge curves differ

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Nextgrid on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:06PM (#26878372)
To be fair, replaceable batteries in laptops and phones also used to be the status quo and Apple successfully changed that. Just because it’s the status quo wouldn’t prevent Apple from “thinking different”.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by llbeansandrice on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:19PM (#26878678)
> Apple successfully changed that

I feel like this gives far too much credit to Apple. Any one company can "think differently" but Apple shouldn't get the blame for all of the other companies following suit.

Remember the ads Samsung ran before axing the headphone jack a year later?

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by serial_dev on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:02PM (#26879653)
I do think it couldn't have happened without Apple doing it first from the big manufacturers.

Apple had (and still have) the status and prestige to do anything and make that a standard. If Huawei/Samsung/etc didn't include chargers, didn't use USB or USB C, changed from 3.5 to some proprietary audio jack first, they would have been ridiculed.

But once Apple changed these things (except luckily the USB), these companies could point out that "Apple does this, so it must be an acceptable idea".

The most annoying thing about this is that they are trying to spin these changes as innovation or something for the environment.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by addicted on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:27PM (#26880121)
Apple has an ability to drive change that other computer manufacturers don’t.

The simple reason is that Apple is the only manufacturer in a specific market. The market for MacOS (or in the case of iDevices, iOS) users.

What that means is that Apple can introduce a pretty shitty change and not lose too many customers to other manufacturers because switching from Apple to another manufacturer is much harder than from Dell to HP.

So, for example, if Dell were to introduce those shitty butterfly keyboards, that were nearly unusable and got spoilt so easily, they would have to change back to their old keyboards within months, unlike Apple, which managed to stick to that design for years and generations of devices without suffering too much.

I use that example because it was an unambiguously worse option, so it nicely illustrates how Apple has a lock-in that others don’t. But Apple can use that lock in to then introduce what are potentially more useful changes (USB2) and/or changes that are not fully baked yet (USB-C), and not suffer the consequences other manufacturers would.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by bredren on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:05PM (#26881675)
As a customer, my buy-in is built on the trust that the majority of the time the company is going to make the right call.

If they make the wrong call, they’ll handle it. Or they won’t and you’ll get burned a little bit.

When Apple makes an obvious error, like with the keyboard, or something external is holding back the quality of the product (recent pre-Apple silicon laptops) you do have to sort of pay attention and if possible steer around the problem.

As an example I largely sidelined the weak 2018 MacBook Air and instead invested in maxing out a Mac Mini. That turned out really well for me.

Sometimes, like with the butterfly keyboard, it feels like Apple does not take enough responsibility for screw ups and take greater measures to make customers whole.

This happened recently for me with the iPhone 12 Magsafe Silicon case, which is a good product but flawed in the context of the iPhone upgrade program.

In that way, I think Apple could and should be much more generous about returning value to its customers instead of to shareholders.

If there were any existential threat to Apple, I’d say it’s the need to reward shareholders instead of customers.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by jen20 on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @10:15PM (#26884684)
> it was an unambiguously worse option

Speak for yourself. The butterfly keyboard is the only laptop keyboard I have ever encountered which I can type on for a full day without flaring RSI. Despite having a fully-loaded 16" with the replacement keyboard, I still use the 4.5-year-old butterfly model for almost everything.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by fiddlerwoaroof on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:31AM (#26885753)
Yeah, I personally prefer the typing feel of the butterfly keyboard: I'm just a bit hesitant about its reliability.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by tshaddox on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:37PM (#26883437)
> What that means is that Apple can introduce a pretty shitty change and not lose too many customers to other manufacturers because switching from Apple to another manufacturer is much harder than from Dell to HP.

I totally get this interpretation, but I genuinely cannot work out how to tell the difference between this explanation and the alternative explanation that this actually just is what the smartphone market prefers and when given the choice they will choose it.

That would also explain why essentially all competitors copy the change one product cycle after the first company makes the change. Unless you’re suggesting that Apple’s competitors are actually colluding with Apple to remove the headphone jack despite strong market opposition, I really don’t see how you can definitively say that Apple and its competitors aren’t simply making products that most people prefer.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Nursie on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:17AM (#26887545)
As someone who has mostly had android phones (but not now), I watched the wireless charging thing unfold in a hilarious way.

A bunch of android phones had wireless charging years ago, including one of the nexus devices IIRC. Great! I'll buy a couple of wireless charging pucks and use them. No more flakey USB ports that give up before the phone does.

Apple didn't pick it up.

Android phones all dropped the feature.

Apple picked it up, hyped it, rolled it out.

Android phones started appearing with it again.

It's like Apple has to lead the way, and even useful features can't survive in the android ecosystem without Apple's blessing.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by myspy on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @09:57AM (#26889762)
Afaik Samsung phones had wireless charging since 2016 and kept that, didn't they? I'm an iPhone guy, but my colleagues were using wireless chargers around that time.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Nursie on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @11:45AM (#26891169)
Interesting ... looking up the specs the site I use tells me that was "market dependent", I wonder if that has impacted my experience.

The motorola Nexus 6 had Qi charging in 2014, then that manufacturer seemed to back away from it. Huawei only picked the feature up in 2019 AFAICT, my P20 pro didn't have it.

But yes, it does look like the galaxy phones have had it all along. I wonder why I discounted those?

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by valuearb on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @10:17PM (#26884692)
It wasn’t status or prestige. It was developing battery conditioning software and integrating it in the OS so the batteries could last years before replacement.

And when Apple did this, they were able to pack more wattage on their MacBooks, making them last substantially longer on a charge than competitors. Competitors had to do same to eventually catch up.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by llbeansandrice on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:07PM (#26883168)
> these companies could point out that "Apple does this, so it must be an acceptable idea".

Friends and jumping off bridges and all that.

I get that Apple has immense sway in these marketplaces but I've never gotten a good explanation for why it's Apple's fault when another company makes that same anti-consumer decision. Headphone jacks being the most prominent example.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by serial_dev on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:59PM (#26885283)
I didn't blame anyone, I was just saying it couldn't have happened without Apple doing things first.

And not even all the things I listed really annoy me, I have listed examples for things where Apple had to be the first from the established manufacturers. For example the audio jack, I basically never used wired headphones in the last 6 (?) years (since the first time I bought Beats with Bluetooth), so I don't even care.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by boublepop on Thursday April 22, 2021 @01:20PM (#26905294)
> I do think it couldn't have happened without Apple doing it first from the big manufacturers.

Well sure nothing “could have happened” without the first company doing it and then the rest of the companies also doing it. But you can’t blame just Apple for an industry wide change. Sure they where the first major company to push a single button mouse, but you can’t blame them for there being no two or three button mice on the market today. That’s not something they made happen, that was an entire industry adopting their practice, and the consumers backing that decision.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by capableweb on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:38PM (#26879080)
We can just blame all the companies for doing X, we don't have to be so selective. Apple and Samsung both removes user replaceable batteries? Well, screw both of them then.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:53PM (#26879447)
Amen. I'm tired of HN discussions trying to find a single cause/blame when you can often spread the blame pretty well around.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Larrikin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:06AM (#26885618)
Thankfully saner heads have prevailed at companies like Sony.

They solved the waterproof phone with a headphone jack many years ago, went with with the craziness of removing it for no reason reason like Samsung and apple, and have since put it back in all of their phones as there hasn't been any noticable improvement in phones that have removed it, but now you have to make sure your headphones are charged.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by r00fus on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @04:46PM (#26881416)
> Apple shouldn't get the blame for all of the other companies following suit

It's not about blame - Apple has repeatedly changed the landscape of computing for decades. Mac, modern laptops, iPhone. Downplay their influence if you will, but they have been the harbinger so often before...

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by wizzwizz4 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:29PM (#26892748)
Apple didn't actually invent the modern laptop; that's just Apple PR. The Xerox NoteTaker, Osbourne 1, Dulmont Magnum, Toshiba T1100 and Compaq SLT all get credit for the “first” in different ways – and all in the 80s, before Apple produced a single computer that could be called a “modern laptop”. (Except the NoteTaker, which was 70s.) I vote the Toshiba T1100 as the first modern laptop, btw.

Apple was the first to put a trackball in a laptop (though that laptop was, in the rest of its design, at least five years out of date – hardly modern), invented the laptop palm rest, and – much later – was the first to put an Ethernet port in.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by no_wizard on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:20AM (#26885380)
Turns out all the people up in arms about the headphone jack didn’t really amount to much more than media fervor.

I really like the look of this over the tile products personally and it’s “rightly sized” to me. I definitely will see myself owning a few of these air tags

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by adrr on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @04:29PM (#26881157)
They are replaceable just not user replaceable though user's can change it if they buy $10 worth of tools. Just like my car's battery isn't user replaceable unless i buy tools to be able pull the battery out of the battery compartment.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Nextgrid on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @04:59PM (#26881596)
Your car's battery isn't glued in place behind a cover held by screws with an intentionally obscure pattern. Not to mention, car manufacturers don't (yet?) use specialized batteries that only they can source legitimately nor use DRM to make the car reject a perfectly good battery just because it's not the original one that came with it.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by adrr on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @06:40PM (#26882872)
I've never changed the battery in my IPhone but my MBPr 15 it took an OEM battery fine. I cut the glue with some spectra fishing line and wasn't that hard. Took me about 15 minutes to replace it. The IFixit OEM battery came with the tools to change out the battery.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by throwanem on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @08:35PM (#26883928)
Older iPhones are much the same; I've done several battery and screen replacements on my 1st gen SEs. A heat gun comes in handy, but beyond a couple cheap screwdrivers most of what you need is just decent eyesight and steady hands. (I only have one of those, but can still fake the other for a few years yet before I need one of those magnifier visors.)

Newer ones, I don't know. It does look like Apple is starting to move in truth toward the hostility to DIY repair they've always been claimed, in the past often falsely, to display.

It's a shame. I really like the idea of that purple 12 mini - it'd go so well with my fountain pen! But if I can't fix it myself when it needs fixing, that's a much knottier problem.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Angostura on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:37PM (#26883438)
Let me just pop out and change the battery on my Tesla.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by ctdonath on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:21PM (#26883307)
My next car’s battery will be glued in place, permanently affixed to the frame. When it dies after a million+ miles, I’m sure both battery and steel body will be quite ready for recycling.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by throwawayboise on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:42PM (#26883471)
Assuming it doesn't incinerate you first, of course...
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by rconti on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:11PM (#26881747)
Standard tools or specialty tools?

I suppose if you can't lift 80lbs out of an awkward spot, it's also not user replaceable? The line has to be drawn somewhere.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by ehsankia on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:08PM (#26878428)
It wouldn't, but in this specific case they didn't. Did apple bring any actual innovation that I missed? That's why I was proposing wireless charging, that would've actually been a nice step forward.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by pfranz on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:45PM (#26879271)
> Did apple bring any actual innovation that I missed?

I guess it depends on what you think of as innovation. Their marketing pointed to "scalloped" batteries instead of square so they can take up more empty space (plus the space that would have been used by covering the battery and a fatter connector).

In my experience, their batteries went from 200 charge cycles, about ~4 of battery life, and often failing before reaching it's end of life to 1000 charge cycles, about 8-10hrs of battery life, and rarely getting "service" warnings suggesting replacement. At least last time I needed to swap batteries I just needed a small screwdriver.

I was very concerned when they ditched removable batteries because that was one part I constantly had problems with. Since those issues were address I'm very glad they went that way.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by ehsankia on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:57PM (#26879539)
> Their marketing pointed to "scalloped" batteries instead of square so they can take up more empty space

I'm confused, are these standard CR2032 batteries or not? Do I have to buy some special Apple battery?

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by applecrazy on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:06PM (#26879737)
Parent comment is referring to MacBook batteries
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Nextgrid on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:16PM (#26879903)
However, none of this justifies intentionally making the batteries extremely difficult to replace. It wouldn't make any noticeable difference to their bottom line (when you consider the margins on their products) to hold batteries with a screwed-in bracket (or even by compression with some foam) instead of hard-to-remove adhesive.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by giantrobot on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @04:56PM (#26881552)
Adhesive responds better to thermal expansion/contraction cycles than screws. Using foam to compress the battery to hold it in place can prevent safe thermal expansion and isn't necessarily going to hold everything in place with vibration or percussion.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by pharmakom on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:33PM (#26882046)
Phone batteries stopped being user replaceable once smart phones started improving at such a rapid pace that even if you could replace the battery in your 2 year old device you won’t want to because the UI would be dog slow and the camera a blurry mess compared to current model.

Funnily, the time for replaceable batteries in phones seems to have arrived, but users are now trained not to expect it.

Sending your phone in for a manufacturer battery replacement after 2 years of use to get a further 2 is a good compromise in my view. My last replacement was about $50.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by flatiron on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:05PM (#26883150)
I did like having two batteries and an external charger. 30 seconds I’m out the door with a freshy
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by katbyte on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @08:28PM (#26883873)
i guess with external battery packs being thrown at people every trade show there are alternatives now.

I have a small one on me always that can charge my phone twice over

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by xondono on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:45AM (#26885506)
Would you want it enough to pay 20% to 30% more and have the phone be ~5mm thicker?

Because the obvious issue is that most people won’t.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:20AM (#26886003)
Why is that the requirement? The extra layers of plastic to enable removable batteries cost close to zero dollars and don't have to cost more than a millimeter.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by tekknik on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @08:23AM (#26888658)
There’s also connectors that wouldn’t be there normally, those connectors also have to be large enough to support the current. Then there’s the plastic lined battery well, as well as the plastic battery case. It’s not as simple as throwing plastic around a battery and calling it a day.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @03:06PM (#26894078)
> There’s also connectors that wouldn’t be there normally, those connectors also have to be large enough to support the current.

Supporting 5-10 amps requires very small pins. It's a tiny percentage of the battery size.

> Then there’s the plastic lined battery well, as well as the plastic battery case. It’s not as simple as throwing plastic around a battery and calling it a day.

Yes, those are the layers of plastic I was talking about.

I didn't say you could slap something together in half an hour, I said it would cost close to zero dollars when talking about the per-phone price.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by tekknik on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @08:35PM (#26897234)
> Why is that the requirement? The extra layers of plastic to enable removable batteries cost close to zero dollars and don't have to cost more than a millimeter.

That very last phrase you said a millimeter. None of this will fit in one millimeter, which was my counter.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @10:58PM (#26898243)
The connector won't affect thickness, it will go at one end of the battery.

For the layers of plastic, the battery already has a wrapping, and the phone already has a back. You just have to reinforce the wrapping on the battery. How much thickness do you think that needs? It's definitely not five millimeters.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by xondono on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:37PM (#26891918)
“ The extra layers of plastic to enable removable batteries cost close to zero dollars and don't have to cost more than a millimeter.”

“It’s two lines of code, how hard can it be?”

More seriously, the cost of designing a battery pack goes way beyond that, just like in software there’s a world of difference between an internal and an external interface. Adding ESD protection for instance can be a headache.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:57PM (#26893977)
There's an enormous amount of design cost in a phone no matter what. Doing it differently from the start does not substantially increase the cost, and I'm not asking for a retrofit.

It's absolutely bonkers to suggest a 20-30% increase in total cost that would be driven by design costs; that's more than doubling the entire design budget!

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by xondono on Thursday April 22, 2021 @07:06AM (#26901360)
I'm not talking about NRE costs, I'm talking about very real manufacturing costs that you are ignoring. Modern battery packs are one of these things that if you haven't designed one you tend to think they're simple, but have a lot of hidden complexity.

Just as an example, modern batteries require keeping track of a lot of parameters and metrics, and require keeping control of things like cell balancing. Making a battery removable means having to move all this into the pack, which then implies having exposed critical interfaces.

As an example check this device by Texas Instruments: BQ40Z50-R2. This gives you a lot of the functionality to the point that Apple keeps variants of them in current laptops, even if they're not removable anymore.

To make a software equivalent, imagine building an enterprise product that connects to a database, and then being asked to have this link exposed through public APIs. Now you need to consider delightful things like authentication, or being vulnerable to DDoS.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Dylan16807 on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:42PM (#26906432)
Okay, that's an actual cost. But:

1. That just moves from phone to battery, doesn't it? That's not a cost increase for the bundle.

2. You don't need fancy things like cell balancing for a phone battery.

3. Even with this chip it's $4 BoM for small batches and significantly less in bulk. So that could be a 1% cost increase. So we have that, a thin plastic shell, and a tiny connector. How are we hitting 20-30% increases, hundreds of dollars?

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by xondono on Friday April 23, 2021 @10:42AM (#26915235)
1. Except now you need a new PCB, a new subassembly, new procedures...

2. You need a lot of fancy things, just not cell balancing. That “battery health indicator” all iphones have, guess where that’s from.

You can take it from someone who has built several devices with replaceable batteries, or we can just keep debating until I’ve fully explain to you how you actually build one of these.

The thing is, I don’t want to waste more time on this, you can do your research on your own, or just keep your preconceptions, whatever floats your boat.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Dylan16807 on Friday April 23, 2021 @02:26PM (#26917610)
> 1. Except now you need a new PCB, a new subassembly, new procedures...

Every phone needs new subassemblies and procedures. For the PCB, you end up with an extra one that's tiny true.

> 2. You need a lot of fancy things, just not cell balancing. That “battery health indicator” all iphones have, guess where that’s from.

Sure, okay.

> You can take it from someone who has built several devices with replaceable batteries, or we can just keep debating until I’ve fully explain to you how you actually build one of these.

> The thing is, I don’t want to waste more time on this, you can do your research on your own, or just keep your preconceptions, whatever floats your boat.

Where would I look?

I'm trying to follow your logic. But you mostly keep naming things phones already have. They already have all this engineering work. They already have the battery chip, it just changes location. And that chip is less than $3.

Could you please give me a couple sentence explanation of how you arrived at 20-30% for a phone that's designed from the start to have a removable battery? You keep nitpicking me for not understanding an argument that you never explained!

My understanding goes something like this: Posit a $600 phone of which $50 is the battery pouch. Remove battery pouch and chip from phone, replace with a connector, phone now costs $550? Add plastic shell and $3 chip and connector and tiny PCB onto the battery pouch. For the total price to rise 20%, doing that has to cost more than $100 and leave you with a battery that costs more than $150. How?

And phones didn't get massively cheaper when they stopped letting you remove batteries...

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by oneeyedpigeon on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @07:31AM (#26888178)
On the cusp of the transition, I attended a music festival with a couple of friends. They both had modern smartphones, I had something closer to an old-school feature phone. At some point on what was probably the first day, we all went to the phone charging tent. They stayed there for an hour or two with their phones plugged in. I walked in and walked back out again immediately, with a fresh battery for my phone handed over to me for free.

I do like having a thin phone, but the utility of a replaceable battery has been sorely downplayed over the years.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Izkata on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:22PM (#26893505)
Hopefully MobileQubes [0] or similar competitors become more prevalent, there's a convention I go to where the hotel has had these kiosks since 2015. You pay ~$5 to rent a fully-charge external battery for 24 hours, with whatever connector your phone uses, after which you return it to the kiosk. If you fail to return it you're automatically charged the "buy" cost.

Yeah it's not free, but it's really nice if you underestimated your battery life since you're not tied to a single spot while charging it.

[0] https://mobilequbes.com/

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by tekknik on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @08:21AM (#26888640)
Meanwhile modern smart phones charge to 80% in 15-30 mins. If they were in there for hours they wanted it at 100%
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by oneeyedpigeon on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @08:35AM (#26888804)
Well, this was a good few years ago now, but I sure they DID want 100% charge anyway!
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by sjwright on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @09:01PM (#26884149)
Replaceable batteries were superseded by batteries of sufficient capacity for 99% of users. (And for the remaining 1% I'm sure the non-Apple marketplace has fantastic, no-compromise solutions.) Remember when it was impressive for a laptop to have three real hours of productive battery life? Back then, most laptop batteries were trivially hot-swappable. Now it's normal to get eight or more hours of productive use from a laptop battery.

I realise that capacity is theoretically orthogonal to swappability, but functionally it's relevant because battery casings, compartments, connectors and chassis strengthening elements all take up space that could otherwise go to a larger battery pack.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by banana_giraffe on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:24PM (#26878782)
Tile has user replaceable batteries on some of their products. Granted, it seems to be on their best sellers, but I somehow ended up with the thin ones, and I found out those don't have replaceable batteries after they died.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by bobthepanda on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @02:45PM (#26879252)
There was definitely a time when they had no product that had replaceable batteries in their line.

I swore Tile off when I found out the hard way that the battery gives out a year from time of sale, not from when you activate it.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Zircom on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:42PM (#26882165)
Do you have a source for that? My partner got a me some Tiles for my birthday 9 months ago and I still haven't gotten around to actually putting them on anything, would hate to find out they're only good for 3 more months
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by bobthepanda on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:47PM (#26882232)
Well, this is buried in their FAQ, emphasis mine: https://tileteam.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/200550678-ReT...

> What if my battery dies early?

> We do not control the lifespan of your Tile; the battery is guaranteed to last a full year (or 3 years for Sticker and Slim) from your purchase date. Your Tiles are covered for 12 months by our worry-free warranty! If your Tile’s battery dies before a year has passed from the time of purchase, we’ll replace it free of charge. Our Customer Care team would be happy to help you!

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by vel0city on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @07:23PM (#26883326)
The battery is slowly discharging and dying sitting in the box. I got one as some vendor swag a few years ago at an event. I stuck it in a drawer for a couple of years and forgot about it. When I went to move, I tried using it. It was dead.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by ryanfreeborn on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:07AM (#26885621)
You swore Tile off because because you don't like how batteries generally function?
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:23AM (#26886017)
They chose to set it up this way, and also that's not even close to the normal shelf life of an unused battery, so it must be actively draining it and not "how batteries generally function".
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by bobthepanda on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @11:08AM (#26890639)
I’m still going strong off a pack of non rechargeable AAs that have been in the cupboard for years.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by friendzis on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:29AM (#26885736)
> Or would that greatly increase the price?

Not only price, but size/weight too. It seems that currently the thing is 99% battery/case/PCB and is designed around the battery. While technically wireless charging is off-the-shelf, incorporating that may have been seen as "too expensive" and/or "too large".

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by butterisgood on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @08:59AM (#26889055)
I've never been able to replace the battery in a Tile. Is there some model I don't know about?

I've been using them for at least the last 2 years.

Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by cool-RR on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:46AM (#26885515)
Audio jacks were also the status quo...
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by tekknik on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @08:27AM (#26888707)
and so was 66Mhz 486 processors and RAM measured in KB and MB. things change.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by runawaybottle on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:01PM (#26879630)
If you are forgetting where your object is, you are probably forgetting to charge it too.
Re:Apple Introduces AirTag by jeffy90 on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @03:09PM (#26879790)
I lose my phone all the time but somehow I manage to charge it