The really complicated and intricate bits are the web of Tax Treaties, Tax Treaty Protocols, Revenue Procedures, and memos that redefine how a foreign concept maps on to US tax code.
All of this complexity (and the accounting cost that goes with it) is because the United States is the only developed country in the world that taxes nonresident citizens. You end up with so many situations where it's hundreds to thousands of dollars to compliantly report foreign income, even though the total tax owed is $0.
That being said, de facto you are correct. The CRA will chase you if they think you owe them money, but is happy never receiving your returns if they owe you money.
Agreed, most taxes are protection money masquerading as necessary evil that supposedly benefit the citizens.
40% of GDP seems like a pretty large subscription charge. 40% of the avg person's salary would be over 20K per year.
I could see this model working better if all the states were individual countries that can tax and spend the way they want. but the system as set up in the US just doesn't seem to make anyone happy because there's way too many diverse opinions on what to spend it on and how much to tax.
40% is a lot, but also the vast majority of federal spending goes to the safety net: unemployment insurance, social security, Medicare, health services — these categories are each more than spending on defense.
Personally, though I’ve never had to rely on unemployment insurance, I’m definitely glad it exists!
The political arguments about spending are basically noise at the margins by comparison.
Social security (20%), medicare and medicaide (20%). unemployment is a very small part as far as i know.
Out of $4.4 trillion:
Social security - $1 trillion - 23%
Medicare - $644 billion - 15%
Medicaid - $409 billion - 9%
SNAP, EITC, Unemployment, SSI and other Income Security Programs - $303 billion mandatory spending + $73 billion - 8%
That's about 55% of the total on various parts of the safety net.
(correct me if i'm wrong) if you had a family to support, with the truely enormous financial costs that SF brings, I think you might change your opinion on this matter.
A small fraction is spent on infrastructure.
Not sure why you're being downvoted.
What might be valuable would be for someone to whip up an app that allows you to input the taxes you paid and breaks it down by the federal budget. Kinda like a receipt, but for government.
I did it with a few odd items, once, and it was pretty interesting.
For example, I found that I paid $7/mo for each of our aircraft carriers and $0.02/mo for the president's salary and secret service protection.
It might help people gain better perspective where their money goes. I'm not quite sure why this kind of thing isn't mandatory, frankly. An itemized "bill" may change people's opinions on taxes, especially the most favorable.
Click through to finer and finer granularity. Searchable.
It's just ("just") a data vis problem. I'd work on it but too busy.
Maybe for the future. Could be fun.
I assume you're talking -- primarily -- about the Senate and the filibuster? If so, you'll be pleased to hear the UK has managed OK for the last 400-500 years in having a parliament that can do _literally anything_ it wants with a majority of 1 person[0] including deciding to pick on a single person individually without trial and subject them to whatever it pleases[1].
It might work for the UK, but the UK is quite different from the US. For one, the house of lords was supposed to represent the wealthy whereas the Senate is supposed to represent the states.
Secondly, there are far greater geographic distances and differences between the members of the country. This usually means there are great differences in needs and priorities. This was kind of the point of reserving most rights for the states. If using simple majority, the smaller and more rural states will eventually get tired of things being crammed down their throats. We are starting to see this already with an increasing number of sanctuary city/states and multiple topics.
Lastly, does it actually work well? It seems that almost 2/3rds of people in the UK think the rural areas are neglected.
http://www.thecommentator.com/article/7587/government_neglec...
As soon as you get over that sort of hyperbolic cynicism, you may recognize that communities, through democracy, provide for such services as are necessary for a functioning society using taxes.
No, there’s no opt-out, as it’s impossible to stop you from ever using any of the amenities that come with the package that is “living in society”. If you are American, there are dozens of countries that will allow you to immigrate with relative ease if you believe they provide a better deal or have limited government in the way you envision.
If there are none to your liking, that’s maybe a clue that yours isn’t all that bad. There are many comparisons, across industries and countries, that allow you us to come up with a reasonable floor for the costs of providing some specific service. And western democratic governments, contrary to popular and tired complaints, do rather well.
You appear to have a high view of government spending, and that also seems to be because you're unaware of how it's spent and how it's wasted.
Yes, parent was being hyperbolic when they suggested 50% is wasted and 50% to kill people abroad. But I think you're serious that you believe the US government apparatus is somehow responsible with all of our money.
Sure, the government may waste "only" $500 of my dollars a year on asinine programs (like seeing if zebra fish get addicted to nicotine), but there is tremendous waste in how money is allocated, budgeted for, paid out to contractors, and used for assistance.
If you think we run a tight ship (we don't) or have no room for very serious improvement (we do), then I think maybe you're not aware of what's going on.
Please study this more.
Understanding the physiology of addiction in animal models is a step towards curing it in humans. It's anything but asinine.
On a different note, something like "Please study this more" as an ending statement adds nothing constructive to a comment. It just comes off as smug and passive aggressive.
That sort of response smells of totalitarianism. If you find my suggestion that parent try to understand the flaws in our government's structure passive aggressive, but don't find their suggestion that their parent move to another country anything short of actively aggressive... I'm not sure how to respond.
There's nothing smug or passive about my statement. I do absolutely implore them to understand their government more thoroughly.
I'm sorry we can't see eye to eye on this. (And no, I'm not being passive aggressive or smug with this statement, either... or this one lol)
Get humble.
Tax is optional, you just don't want to give up it's benefits.
Also, crucially, if you have not obtained citizenship elsewhere first, you will be a stateless person with no rights anywhere. So you can't just renounce your citizen and then move.
Also, it's irrevocable — if you change your mind, you can't get citizenship back except by immigrating the hard way (visa/green card track).
You may also owe an exit tax, depending on your recent income and current wealth. Oh, and it costs $2,350.
The argument is not for no taxes, the argument is that taxes are too high. Reducing taxes is definitely achievable.
Florida, on the other hand, does not tax its residents, while still having roads, schools and police.
Yes, it does.
It doesn’t happen to use a personal income tax, but it absolutely does tax it's population.
The roads in Florida are generally better (and cheaper), schools are good [1] and Florida State University is ranked higher than SUNY [2].
[1] https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings/education
[2] https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/florida-state-universit...
Watch how fast they start radioing for the coast guard when the pirates start showing up.
It is not what it has become in the last 200 years. Modern society is very hard to revolt like this country was founded, but there are sprouts of it in the crypto community.
But imagine the market for patent snake-oil medicines that would create! The business opportunities boggle the mind.
Your mistake is in assuming the tax is necessary for the benefits.
If we want to close this loophole (if it's not closed elsewhere in the code) - I feel like the logical way to handle it would be to treat it as if they stole the imputed interest as well. I don't think § 7872 applies, but this would be in the spirit of that section to balance things out.
So, you'd treat the transaction as though they stole the item plus the interest required to "borrow" it, and then only returned the item without returning the interest. They'd need to report the imputed interest as income (since they stole it!), and you could report it as a loss (since they stole it from you!).
And you provided that service for free!
I love the irony.
Simpler loophole: you gift it to them, then they gift it back at the end of the term. Or perhaps sue the IRS because Islam and Judaism prohibit lending money with interest, sounds like a case of discrimination (Christianity prohibits it as well, but basically no one follows nowadays).
only monetary profit counts? i shouldn't borrow to buy something that makes my household more efficient, like a dishwasher?
If "efficiency" in and of itself is sufficient to justify making a purchase with debt, you will quickly find all of your financial resources going to paying off debt service. Then you find that instead of your tools serving you, that you are instead spending your time serving your tools.
The way out is to only spend cash (or cash equivalent, i.e. to commit to paying your credit card bill in full each month) on items which cannot generate a measurable financial profit for you.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Oven_of_Akhnai
which underscores the idea that (in rabbinic Judaism—clearly other currents divided over this very issue!) human institutions were given responsibility for interpreting the law, including in ways that create leniencies or apparent loopholes. Although there is probably a better story or example about loopholes in particular.
Baked goods that many people are eating this week for Passover might be a good example, because a fair amount of food chemistry has gone into making some of them fluffy and bread-like, while still not technically being chametz. The mainstream interpretation is that the criteria for being "leavened bread" were authoritatively identified and fixed by rabbinic tradition, and that, if you stay within those criteria, you're fine, even if you produce foods that are subjectively reminiscent of leavened bread.
https://www.allrecipes.com/gallery/passover-bread-recipes/
https://www.allrecipes.com/gallery/passover-cookies/
https://www.allrecipes.com/gallery/passover-cake-recipes/
Fun fact: the oven in question is referred to as תנור (tanur). I wondered if this is cognate with "tandoor", and it is, as both terms were borrowed from Persian.
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%D7%AA%D7%A0%D7%95%D7%A8 https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tandoor
Plus, this doesn't have anything to do with the original topic.
them: "these are not loopholes. these other people say so."
all divine authority is mediated by men.
ref: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/taxes/gift-tax-rate#:~:te....
Unless you have a net worth way above $10 million dollars you don't need to worry about the gift tax. If you accidentally forgot to report a $30,000 "loan" that turns into a gift to a friend, the IRS isn't going to care. You might have to go back and fix it if they notice but it isn't going to be a problem.
The gift tax exists to prevent extremely rich people from cheating the estate tax. If you've never heard of the gift tax before you don't need to worry about.
Germany allows a few 100k tax free every 10 years depending on the exact relationship.
+ "Usual" Christmas / birthday / marriage gifts etc which can be substantial
This is a terrible "loophole"; it eats into your estate tax allowance.
I feel this same way about two rules at my college that prohibited (1) building an igloo and sleeping in it, and (2) rappelling from the windows of residence halls.
I don’t think this is unique to taxes at all, I don’t have a Twitter account or really use it but there’s one account I check regularly: https://nitter.cc/crimeaday (random example https://nitter.cc/CrimeADay/status/1091488611269332993#m).
Property crimes typically have a 10-20% clearance rate. Police are too preoccupied writing traffic tickets and/or harassing poor people. If anything, reported property crimes track against unemployment/economic prosperity-- probably much stronger than police payroll.
The FBI's UCR is even more accessible at https://crime-data-explorer.app.cloud.gov/ -- where you can look at crime rates, clearance rates, types of crime all the way down to the municipality level.
What were the biggest line items on those municipalities' budgets? Police salaries, benefits, pensions and the purchasing and maintenance of law enforcement equipment and assets.
If you visit the police departments' Facebook pages, they frequently celebrate months long investigations on literal children who sell pot to their friends. There's apparently no time to solve potentially difficult-to-investigate crime when there are easy targets out there like kids smoking pot and people speeding.
You might as well have declared your location to be San Francisco Bay Area.
Had my wallet stolen at a community rec center in the Northgate area (a few miles north of downtown Seattle for those unfamiliar). There was video of the thief taking it. I was able to find out from regulars his name + phone number + address, from which I found his facebook account with several public pictures of him that made it clear he was the same man from the security video. Also was able to find some public police reports of prior arrests of the same man on various counts of theft/larceny, although no convictions that I could find. Gave all of that information to the "detective" assigned to my case. Nothing ever came of it. As best I can tell, nobody did anything beyond write down some of the information I gave them.
Someone did eventually take it seriously when the thief stole thousands of dollars from a series of banks with my wife's checkbook. I guess cash is king.
But that's a pretty big if ;)
Is that a common practice?
You can't prove they did anything illegal to profit, but the IRS can audit them and prove they have not paid taxes on all their assets.
And on the bad side, it is a very big barrier for a legit commerce, and foreign business entrants.
You never know how many tax laws you break every day even if you run a lemonade stand.
Why do they have a wash sale rule for stock sale losses but not for gains?
Maybe this isn’t a major issue so the IRS hasn’t clamped down?
That's not true at all... It depends on the crime, it depends on the state, and it depends on the firearm.
"Stolen property. If you steal property, you must report its fair market value in your income in the year you steal it unless you return it to its rightful owner in the same year."
When I read these rules, I thought of a potentially amusing tax loophole with regards to the stolen property section:
>Stolen property. If you steal property, you must report its fair market value in your income in the year you steal it unless in the same year, you return it to its rightful owner.
There's another rule[0] on the books that says interest-free loans to friends and family can have tax implications, but if your friend/family _steals_ the money from you and repays it later that year, they could potentially get a short-term, interest-free loan without incurring the tax implications. I'd have to dig into the details to see if this would actually work out, but it's an entertaining thought exercise nonetheless.
[0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/7872