News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by cehrlich on Sunday March 28, 2021 @05:55AM (#26609132)
I agree with the premise of the article. I started going to International school (all classes in English) at age 9. Got two University degrees in England. Have several academic papers published. There are still moments where I'm made aware that I'm not a native English speaker - for example I sometimes translate German figures of speech into English, where they don't exist.

However I'd disagree that the article's premise is unique to English. I've been learning Japanese for the past few years, and while it's definitely more difficult to learn than English for someone who's coming from another European language, I think the long tail of being native-like is equally infinite. It's just based on different things. Examples would be は vs が (this is a beginner-level topic as well, but comes back in a different way much later), sentence-level pitch accent, the fact that writing in formal language is basically the world's most elaborate game of madlibs, etc.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by kh1 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:15AM (#26609384)
As a Japanese, I agree with you. When friends who are learning the language ask me questions, I sometimes can't even answer them. So I end up saying "that's just how we say/use it".

And much respect from me. I wouldn't learn Japanese if my mother tongue is European language.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by robotmay on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:58AM (#26609582)
I've tried twice to learn Japanese and I consistently get stuck on kanji. The spoken language is actually really intuitive in a lot of ways, and hiragana/katakana fit easily into my brain, but kanji, with the multiple and inconsistent readings, is just mind-blowingly hard for me. And it's a shame that I keep getting stuck there as it really is a beautiful language.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by kh1 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @09:37AM (#26610286)
I think you should start with easy ones. IIRC kids take small tests in class every semester at elementary school (like 50-150 kanjis per test). Those kanjis are the easy ones and then you can build up. So learning kanjis you find on a newspaper or a novel might be too hard. Understanding those words in real life context requires you to have higher language skills anyway (e.g. understand economy news or whatever in Japanese).

On a slight side note, kids can't even write their own names in kanji. You can imagine how happy we got when we were taught kanjis that were part of our name. So you shouldn't feel bad about it, taking small steps serve you well in the long term.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by eternalban on Sunday March 28, 2021 @10:42AM (#26610764)
> On a slight side note, kids can't even write their own names in kanji. You can imagine how happy we got when we were taught kanjis that were part of our name.

Do you have any thoughts on the implications (social, mainly) of logographic writing systems?

Also would be interested in having a sense of the historic patterns of literacy in Japan in context of Tokugawa caste system.

/tia

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by matt-attack on Sunday March 28, 2021 @10:42AM (#26610759)
How do you look one up you don’t recognize? Like there must be dictionaries but what is your “alphabetical order”??
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by kleton on Sunday March 28, 2021 @10:49AM (#26610813)
Nowadays you draw it in your phone/computer. In the old days you looked up by "radical" and number of strokes in large tables.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by kh1 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:10AM (#26610977)
When you finish middle school, you're supposed to learn most of kanjis used in real life.[0] At that point it's pretty rare to encounter kanjis that are completely foreign to you.

But there's electronic dictionary on which you can draw to search for kanji.[1] I used one of these in high school.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J%C5%8Dy%C5%8D_kanji [1] https://www.casio.com/content/dam/casio/product-info/locales...

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by charcircuit on Sunday March 28, 2021 @04:51PM (#26614415)
The easiest way is just using OCR which for example the Google Translate app lets you do. After that you can search by drawing it or search by the radicals that you recognize in it.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by charcircuit on Sunday March 28, 2021 @04:57PM (#26614479)
>Those kanjis are the easy ones

One thing to note is that the order they are learned is not from easiest to hard. The order is more based off the complexity of the meaning of the kanji.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by charcircuit on Sunday March 28, 2021 @08:15AM (#26609679)
Learning kanji is a skill. The more you practice it, the easier it will get. Also what's a few thousand kanji if you also have to learn 10s of thousands of vocabulary.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by aasasd on Sunday March 28, 2021 @08:06PM (#26616195)
Perhaps ‘spaced repetition’ tools like Anki might come in handy in organising the memorization. You still need to come up with a system, but the app will then help with putting kanji into the brain. Spaced repetition is suited precisely for things that don't have a prominent internal structure which would lend itself to learning.

Afaik Anki is popular for learning Japanese, iirc even the author did exactly that, so there's probably plenty of readymade material. Though it may be mostly for vocabulary.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by cehrlich on Monday March 29, 2021 @03:37AM (#26618622)
Yes, IMO the easiest way to 'learn' the kanji is Heisig's book "Remembering the Kanji", along with an Anki deck to review daily. I 'learned' 2000 kanji this way in 3 months, with a daily time investment of about 1 hour. There are plenty of pre-made RTK Anki decks.

The reason I'm putting learn in quotation marks is because afterwards you need to reinforce them in context, ie by learning vocab and doing tons of reading (there's a term called 多読 which means it's not the quality of the material or even your level of comprehension, but just the sheer amount of pages you read).

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by presentation on Sunday March 28, 2021 @06:22AM (#26609208)
Im learning Japanese too and both agree and disagree. There are way fewer idiosyncrasies in the language IMO, the rules tend to hold and depending on how you’re explained concepts they make more sense (は described as the “topic” particle, が described as the “identifier” particle, which most resources don’t explain properly but makes the choice much easier to understand). Sounding things out is super straightforward due to the direct mapping from sounds to kana.

But some things are pretty elusive or just require a great deal of memorization to sound natural, like which counter words are the correct counter for the given noun, or the proper pitch accent patterns and intonation to apply to words and phrases, and speaking with the different levels of formality. Plus the huge hurdle of learning a ton of Kanji.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by EE84M3i on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:13AM (#26611022)
>Sounding things out is super straightforward due to the direct mapping from sounds to kana.

Sounding out, e.g. place/people names, in Japanese is difficult and sometimes impossible if they use a one-off reading of the kanji.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by cehrlich on Sunday March 28, 2021 @06:47AM (#26609289)
Kanji (at least the first 3-4000), counters, word-level pitch accent, etc are all totally learnable and I wouldn't consider them "advanced" topics. That's not to say it doesn't take a couple thousand hours to get there, just that with enough time spent studying and consuming native content learning these things is inevitable.

Likewise understanding something like は vs が to the level of a fairly advanced non-native speaker is not that difficult. Especially now that there are actual good grammar resources that don't explain things in the bizarre way that the traditional textbooks do. At that point you can _understand_ everything, and explain yourself in a way that you will always be understood.

However once you know all those things there's a whole different category of issues that separate you from native speakers. Case in point: this 331-page book [1], written in Japanese, only about は vs が. Clearly if knowing that が is always the topic etc was enough to pass for a native, this book would not exist.

As I said, this is in no way unique to Japanese. There's a difference between speaking correctly and speaking at a native level. Most are happy with the first, and that's ok - it's mostly an academic exercise once you go beyond that.

[1] https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/product/487424128X

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by EE84M3i on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:02PM (#26617277)
>Kanji (at least the first 3-4000), counters, word-level pitch accent, etc are all totally learnable and I wouldn't consider them "advanced" topics.

For reference, the Kanji Kentei test[1] has 12 levels.

> Level 2 is as high as many Japanese, even those with higher education degrees, tend to go. Passing level 2 can be used as leverage when applying for jobs, etc. Passing levels pre-1 and 1 is especially rare even among native speakers.

Level 2 has 2136 daily use kanji. Pre-level 1 has 2965 kanji, Level 1 (the highest) has 6355.

Learning 3000 kanji is definitely "advanced".

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kanji_Kentei

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by cehrlich on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:35PM (#26743443)
The Kanji Kentei tests production. I probably couldn't even produce 500 kanji without a computer/phone), and I don't think I will ever make it much further than that, because why bother? When would I ever need to handwrite kanji without access to a digital dictionary?

Recognition, however, is an entirely different story. To be able to recognize 98% of words, which is approximately the amount you need to be able to deduct the meaning of the remaining words from context, in the average novel you need something like 3000-3500 kanji.

The good news is recognition is much easier to achieve than production. With Heisig you can learn the first 2000 kanji (recognition only) in about 3 months, the next 1000 are more difficult because they're less common, but still it's nothing compared to passing even the lower levels of the Kentei.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by tasogare on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:24AM (#26609429)
Japanese is hard for different reasons but some of them are self-inflicted. Bothering with pitch accent is one: no second of effort towards it will be ever relevant in comparison to learning new vocabulary or collocation. An other big issue is indeed in manuals, which teach sentences construction with the English logic instead of the Japanese one (eg starting with 私は学生です already poses 3-4 pedagogical problems). I’m working on a conversation guide (in French for now) to avoid those issue but that’s a lot of work...
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by presentation on Sunday March 28, 2021 @09:34AM (#26610251)
Disagree re pitch accent being unimportant - it depends what your goals are and what your experience level is. If you’re competent enough with grammar but screw accent up constantly Japanese people get tired of listening to you, when you nail it people are more at ease talking to you in my experience. Like someone messing up stress in English all the time.

If your goal is to get over that then it’s absolutely worth studying, and arguably it’s worth studying early before you pick up bad habits in the first place.

As the parent mentioned, it’s all dependent on your goals.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by jhanschoo on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:16AM (#26617653)
> There are way fewer idiosyncrasies in the language IMO, the rules tend to hold and depending on how you’re explained concepts they make more sense (は described as the “topic” particle, が described as the “identifier” particle, which most resources don’t explain properly but makes the choice much easier to understand).

In my opinion this perspective more likely reflects your comparative lack of exposure to Japanese than to English. For example, you mentioned wa and ga as an example of an actually clear concept (albeit foreign), but in speech these particles may be dropped, and choosing what to drop also adds subtle meaning to what is communicated.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by andi999 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @06:46AM (#26609286)
Well the English 'counter words' for animals are also tough aren't they? Ok, a flock of birds everybody knows as well as a murder of crows. But what about an exaltation of larks? And is it a school of dolphins or rather a pod?
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by mkl on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:06AM (#26609350)
Most of those collective nouns are just made up and are not used in the real world: "In the course of the 14th century, it became a courtly fashion to extend the vocabulary, and by the 15th century, the tendency had reached exaggerated and even satirical proportions." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_noun

I read an interesting article about it a few weeks ago, b̶u̶t̶ ̶I̶ ̶c̶a̶n̶'̶t̶ ̶f̶i̶n̶d̶ ̶i̶t̶. (Edit: wccrawford linked it: https://www.audubon.org/news/no-its-not-actually-murder-crow...) There's a quote from a biologist who studies wombats about the supposedly-correct collective noun for a group of wombats: "Wombats do not form groups in the wild."

And it is a pod of dolphins: https://www.dolphins-world.com/what-is-a-dolphin-pod/

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by wccrawford on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:00AM (#26609328)
There's a few well known ones that everyone uses.

And then there's ridiculous ones, like "a murder of crows", that many people know because they're ridiculous, but people still don't use them.

And then there's a ton that almost nobody knows, and nobody uses.

In the end, it's not a big deal. Unlikely Japanese, where they really do use counters for those kinds of object. Flat things like paper, cylindrical things like beer bottles, etc etc.

https://www.audubon.org/news/no-its-not-actually-murder-crow...

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by laurieg on Sunday March 28, 2021 @09:43AM (#26610336)
English "counters" are in some way worse because they aren't consistent. Slice of bread, slice of cheese but not slice paper.

To be fair, Japanese has "everday use" counters and "trivia TV show" counters.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by pja on Sunday March 28, 2021 @10:37AM (#26610725)
Not going to defend the consistency of English for a second but for that particular example: paper isn’t sliced, so it wouldn’t make sense to refer to “a slice of paper”.

Obviously the standard usage of a “piece of paper” is pretty arbitrary, but slice is clearly wrong.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by wccrawford on Sunday March 28, 2021 @04:10PM (#26613977)
On the other hand, all 3 of those can be used with "piece of". Slice describes something that was done to it, and sheet describes its form. (As opposed to scrap or some such term.)
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by cowboysauce on Sunday March 28, 2021 @10:32AM (#26610694)
I don't see how that's inconsistent. Slice is used to describe things that are cut from a larger whole, particularly for food, while paper is manufactured as sheets.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by ghaff on Sunday March 28, 2021 @09:35AM (#26610257)
English uses those also to some degree: a case of beer, a carton of eggs.

But, yeah, if you told me to pick up some eggs and a a carton/box of beer, I'd know what you probably wanted. (In the latter case, I might ask if you wanted a 6-pack, 12-pack, or 24.)

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by mkl on Sunday March 28, 2021 @09:41AM (#26610315)
Carton and case aren't collective nouns though. They describe the packaging. You can buy a tray of eggs or a keg or six-pack of beer.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by AndrewDucker on Sunday March 28, 2021 @06:52AM (#26609303)
It's "some dolphins" and "some larks"

Because nobody in the UK bothers with group nouns except for a very few (herd of cows, for instance).

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by inkyoto on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:35AM (#26609472)
Pandemoniums of cockatoos are still rather common in Australia, especially considering the ruckus they bring along, and the occasional damage they cause.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by andi999 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:04AM (#26609342)
Ok, so that was a bad example. What about order of adjectives, do people in the UK bother about that? Like a red metal big ball, or a big red metal ball?
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by kwhitefoot on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:17AM (#26609396)
> What about order of adjectives, do people in the UK bother

Yes.

Usually size comes first: big red metal ball.

red big metal ball sounds wrong to me and so do metal red ball and red metal big ball.

But I'm not sure if it can be succinctly expressed as a general rule. It's just something that native speakers do without thinking, seeing it written in the wrong order or hearing it said in the wrong order just feels wrong to me. Perhaps a linguist could provide a rule, or at least a rule of thumb.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by ghaff on Sunday March 28, 2021 @08:47AM (#26609885)
Pinker's written about this I know. The order looks something like this https://www.hip-books.com/teachers/writing-about-reading/adj... (although there are exceptions, of course!)
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by kwhitefoot on Monday April 05, 2021 @06:00PM (#26705227)
Thank you!
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by mkl on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:10AM (#26609368)
Yes, the adjective order is definitely important (and native English speakers are not explicitly taught it, but we absolutely know it).
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by thaumasiotes on Sunday March 28, 2021 @07:48AM (#26609537)
"Important" is dramatically overstating it. I've only ever seen anyone remark on adjective order in an ESL class.

English is full of ordering constraints that matter. This isn't one of them; if you put your adjectives in a strange order, the worst thing that can happen is that people realize you're foreign. [1] And the odds are they knew that anyway, unless you managed to learn perfect pronunciation without absorbing common speech patterns.

[1] They may not even notice. ESL classes treat adjective order as a big deal, but native speakers will often violate the normal constraints if they have to string together several adjectives in a row. You're most likely to be noticed if you put exactly two adjectives in the unconventional order.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by bckr on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:57PM (#26611933)
This isn't even to take into account that we flub our speech (not to mention writing) all the time. It's easy to imagine someone saying "red... Metal... Big ball!" because that was the order that the features of the ball arrived in their mind.

So there's a difference between planned speech and rushed speech, and there's piecing together what someone means through their mistakes.

For another example, last night I was watching some Zoom comedy [0] and one of the comedians twice fumbled their joke, saying a word that was important to the punchline too early. So they abandoned the joke and moved on. Inferring what had happened was fairly natural, but you really had to have a robust (as in, fail-safe) grasp of English and, I suppose, culture, to roll with it.

[0] https://www.eventbrite.com/o/best-of-san-francisco-stand-up-...

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by thaumasiotes on Sunday March 28, 2021 @06:05PM (#26615119)
> This isn't even to take into account that we flub our speech (not to mention writing) all the time. It's easy to imagine someone saying "red... Metal... Big ball!" because that was the order that the features of the ball arrived in their mind.

Well, I meant to; this is what I had in mind when I said "native speakers will often violate the normal constraints if they have to string together several adjectives in a row".

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by laurieg on Sunday March 28, 2021 @09:34AM (#26610253)
A much closer analogue would be the words used in English together uncountable nouns:

A loaf of bread, a grain of rice, a slice of cheese.

These tend to be common everyday words but if you get them wrong things sound quite off.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by em-bee on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:00AM (#26610898)
i have a similar experience. i became mostly fluent after a year of living in the US during high school. (and then living in the US again and other english speaking countries for a few years)

i always explained to people that complained about learning german being hard, that i felt that german is hard at the beginning, but once you are over the hurdle, it gets a lot easier, whereas english is easy at the beginning, and it keeps getting harder.

learning german is like climbing up a steep road followed by a shallow incline, whereas learning english is a not so steep road that just keeps going up and up and up.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by MeinBlutIstBlau on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:28AM (#26611156)
I would describe your statement of german to be accurate in terms of how I've been learning it. I'd classify myself as a soft A1 but i have a decent vocabulary built up and can generally understand what a sentence is saying even if I don't know all the words. The foundation of the language is vital to learning it and as a native English stuck in SVO, the german sentence structure gets weird fast. But then it just clicked. Like oh I know where to put that now! The hard part i have is knowing which specific word to use because in context the meaning of it could change based off of how a native would use it. Honestly, the conjugations don't scare me so much as they used to. I'm not good at all with like accusative, genitive, etc but I don't think twice when altering verbs.
Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by amelius on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:03AM (#26610918)
> I sometimes translate German figures of speech into English, where they don't exist.

This is how language develops, so I wouldn't feel bad about it.

Re:English is relatively easy to learn, but not to master (2... by yigitcakar on Monday March 29, 2021 @03:02AM (#26618481)
I agree with both of your premises. I started going to International school when I was 10 and got all my education in English. I got two college and one masters degrees. I am fairly confident in my ability to use English yet my wife is American and every day she finds something to correct in my English.

My wife have been learning Turkish using Duolingo and a Turkish learning platform for the past couple months, and she can hold her end up in basic conversation. We have many expat friends who have been learning Turkish for a year or so and they can communicate pretty well.

Turkish syntax is wildly different than English syntax, and pronunciations are throat based rather than tongue based. There are lots of synonyms and parallel meanings in everyday use. Moreover there are not many resources to learn Turkish from. Yet, people start speaking broken Turkish enough to communicate complex ideas within a year.