News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:50AM (#26487049)
Worth remembering that as good as it is that Google is reducing it's abusive taxation on third party developers, the primary reason they're doing this is to try to quiet the majority of developers asking for stronger government regulations against this taxation without actually reducing their profit much, since the large companies which bring in the majority of revenue still have to pay full price.

Basically, they're hoping that this will stop some app developers from demanding the right to use third party payment processors, which would likely be used many of the larger >$1 million revenue publishers.

The Android Police article about this cites an example from iOS, that "On Apple's App Store, the 98% of developers who qualified for a lower revenue share rate were responsible for less than 5% of Apple's total collected revenue"

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by enos_feedler on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:15AM (#26487873)
The primary reason they are doing it is because Apple did it. Same goes for every other rev share change that Apple has implemented.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by DeusExMachina on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:42AM (#26489130)
That still poses the question: why did Apple do it? I believe the reasons are the ones explained by the parent comment.

Also, I don't think Google mindlessly copies anything Apple does. Sure, part of it is pure competition. But I'm sure they also evaluated the reasons behind Apple's decision.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by londons_explore on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:35AM (#26489610)
Note that this is 4 months later. That's about as quick as things like this can be done in a big organisation like Google where the decision has to go via policy, legal, engineering, translation, etc.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by enos_feedler on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:13PM (#26493187)
I believe that Google's goal is to show regulators that Apple has market power. The easiest way to demonstrate that is to follow what they do and make it look like they are in control. The reason I believe this is that it is uncharacteristic of Google to blatantly copy something like this over the years, yet it is clear they are fast following all of Apple's decisions around the app store. I would expect Google to try and differentiate and come out with a new, competitive way to make the developer ecosystem happy.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:08PM (#26494831)
> I believe that Google's goal is to show regulators that Apple has market power.

Unlikely, since Google and Apple monopolize in the same way. Google and Apple are close allies in this fight, and if the Epic lawsuit or an antitrust investigation goes bad for one, it'll go bad for the other.

> The reason I believe this is that it is uncharacteristic of Google to blatantly copy something like this over the years,

This is comical. Google me-toos everything. Google Home's entire product line being a blatant Amazon Echo rip off. Google Cloud needing to launch a copy of every AWS service, etc.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by enos_feedler on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:21PM (#26497504)
Actually they don't. Apple makes a consumer product and exercises control between developers and users. On the other hand, Google has power over the rest of the smartphone ecosystem via Android (practically speaking) and the installation of Google Play store. It's important that Apple move first as the "leader" and Google, representing the rest of the ecosystem "follow"
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by londons_explore on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:19AM (#26489473)
Which is odd... Users of the Play store and App store are a disjoint set. Very few users will switch from Android to iOS or back because in-app purchases are cheaper. Developers are generally forced to support both stores.

There wouldn't seem to be any strong reason for both stores to pick identical fee structures - they aren't really in competition.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by inglor on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:36AM (#26489613)
Startups sometimes (initially) develop applications for only one platform. Reducing the cost for (new) developers makes platforms more appealing to target (presumably).
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by tyfon on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:47AM (#26490303)
Speaking of swapping, I switched from android to iphone last spring since my old android phone croaked on teams and I couldn't get a new xperia fast enough.

The switch was actually relatively painless when it comes to the apps themselves, the biggest problem I have is the phone itself. Iphone has inconsistent UI/shortcuts and lots of hidden gesture based inputs that you just got to know to be able to use. I'm really tempted to switch back but the google tracking keeps me away for now.

So there are some who are in the market for both :)

The developer cut/price of apps is really low on my list of reasons to switch from one to another though so you got a good point there. I'm actually trust an app that costs 100 NOK (€10) more than a 10 NOK one since they will have less incentives to do shady things.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by lordnacho on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:35AM (#26489595)
Users might not change phones but android users might have different behaviour to ios users in terms of how likely they are to spend. Which perhaps skews the developers towards starting on one platform or the other.

But generally yes I agree that it can't be all that big a difference.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by sokoloff on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:07AM (#26489907)
Low end Android phones/tablets are so cheap that some serve as dedicated displays/devices. I have one that I use as a OBD2 scanner, another sits as a DRO display on a desktop mill. My actual phone is iOS.

If those facts mean I’m counted as an iOS user once and Android user twice, the iOS me spends a lot more in the Apple App Store than the two Android mes put together.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by lordnacho on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:23AM (#26490057)
Very true, I have an old android tablet that's gotten too slow for normal use, but functions fine as a clock. Another shows my task list for household chores.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by salicideblock on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:34AM (#26489583)
The discourse is that Play store and App store are monopolies (arguably duopolies) facing the developers, not the users.

I expect that developers for the Play store and App store are two sets with a big overlap

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by enos_feedler on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:38PM (#26493540)
This is the story that Google wants you to believe by fast following Apple with pricing changes. They want to demonstrate that Apple has pricing power to regulators (just my theory). The reality is that Apple and Google are in competition, and if Google actually innovated on business model the way they do with every other aspect of their business, it would actually drive the app store fees down for Apple. Microsoft has tried to do this [1] but they don't have enough market power to move the needle.

[1] https://www.windowscentral.com/microsoft-store-now-gives-app...

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by enos_feedler on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:22PM (#26493313)
I agree it is very odd. For other reasons too, including how Google tries to differentiate their smartphone ecosystem from Apple to try and compete. Innovating on a business model for developers would be a good differentiator.

This is why my theory for this blatant copying is for regulatory reasons. The app stores are under scrutiny right now and it is best for Android, which has very large market penetration with the Play Store, to make it look like Apple is in control of the market. Just my theory.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by cat_plus_plus on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:15AM (#26487224)
You know that Android is open source and you can just sideload apps, install a 3rd party app store or replace entire OS with your own ROM right? What, your app/game is not valuable enough to the user to bother with unless it's a single click install without having to enter credit card? Well...

Basically - Situation is not at all the same as with iOS - There is too much emphasis on friction-less low value installs and less on highly valuable things that users are willing to invest time and money on. Those apps would not survive without vendor-included single click app stores anyway.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by onion2k on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:05AM (#26487490)
Those apps would not survive without vendor-included single click app stores anyway.

I find this a little amusing because it's the exact reason why Microsoft lost their IE anti-trust case. Users were given IE by default, and because using something else required effort IE took a huge chunk of the market remarkably quickly. That was deemed to be violating their effective monopoly position on OSs to influence their position in a different market (browsers). Microsoft were made to add a screen in the Windows on-boarding process that gave users options about which browser they wanted.

Sometimes using user 'laziness' to maintain or gain market share doesn't work out so well for you.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by xmprt on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:53AM (#26487758)
I strongly believe that if the Microsoft anti-trust case happened today, Microsoft would easily win. The tech monopolies that we have today have a much bigger impact on society.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by joering2 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @10:29AM (#26491734)
Absolutely! First time I loaded Google Search and saw ad under search box, where nobody else can advertise, no matter how much they offer to pay, saying “not using Chrome? Click to install now”, I thought to myself “damn they gonna get huge ant-minopoly lawsuit that will cost then billions”. And what happened?? Nothing! Other than Chrome is number one browser now for decades to come.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by Karunamon on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:12AM (#26492325)
Microsoft's mere inclusion of a web browser (which is now a basic OS tool that is reasonably expected to come out of the box, but then was new) wasn't why they lost their case. They lost their case because they were demanding OEMs refuse to include any alternative browsers on pain of revoking their pricing agreements.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by krisgenre on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:03AM (#26487808)
What was really the outcome of Microsoft losing the anti-trust case? Windows still comes with a preinstalled browser and I don't remember ever seeing a version of Windows without one.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by input_sh on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:35AM (#26488001)
They've reached a settlement equal to a slap on the wrist. They've agreed to share their API with third parties and a couple of people to verify that for a couple of years (it expired in 2007).

So basically nothing.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by quelsolaar on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:42AM (#26488064)
In legal terms they got off easy, but it did change Microsoft and computing forever. Microsoft became terrified of been seen as monopolistic and that lead to them effectively saving Apple, not buying Google or Yahoo, embracing Linux and so on. It was very much worth it.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by lenkite on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:35AM (#26489606)
"So basically nothing"

Umm..no.

IE could now be un-installed on Windows.

After various settlement fines in the US with several parties, the EU took it further and also leveraged its largest anti-trust penalty of that era. (~1 billion)

Microsoft were forced to share ALL their earlier private computing API's as open specs. MS word, excel formats, SMB, etc. This was amazing and resulting in several OSS libraries.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by krisgenre on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:34AM (#26490158)
>>IE could now be un-installed on Windows.

Why is this important?

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:53AM (#26490384)
And I was never able to make it actually work. Like the whole system became much more unstable if you did uninstall IE.

That being said, I didn't know much about computers back then, so I probably messed up somewhere.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by lenkite on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:39PM (#26493555)
Avoiding security vulnerabilities.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by blihp on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:21AM (#26490791)
Look at how Apple, and to a degree Google, are controlling/constraining mobile apps today and imagine that Microsoft had done that (x10... they were much worse in their time) 20 years earlier on the desktop. They were pretty successful in choking off the growth of Netscape (the browser) and Java pre-DOJ action and would have likely used similar strategies against web companies (which were completely dependent on and at the mercy of the desktop OS back then) before they became large enough to be a competitive threat.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:14AM (#26489977)
Google exists, for one. Microsoft decided against early attempts to acquire Google or block their toolbar in IE because of the fear of further antitrust legislation.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by mrkramer on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @10:41AM (#26491912)
You think Google would sell to Microsoft? Larry and Sergey are one the smartest founders ever. They had clear vision and mission for Google.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:07AM (#26492241)
Microsoft was in a position to put Google entirely out of business at the time, and buy it for pennies on the dollar. Internet Explorer was THE dominant browser at the time with over 90 percent market share, and Microsoft was considering blocking the install of Google Toolbar (the vaguely malware-esque add-on Google paid Adobe to inject into Flash Player and Reader installers) and preventing Google from modifying the default search.

Google would not still exist without the antitrust lawsuit against Microsoft that scared them into playing it safe.

Also, Larry and Sergey's vision was an academic search engine that wasn't tainted by the mixed motivations of advertising[1]. Since they built the world's largest ad company, it's fair to say they sold out their vision and mission and the first opportunity for a lot of money.

[1] http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html appendix A

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by necovek on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @05:24PM (#26496965)
Well, they had a clear vision about "organizing the world's information", but ads did not enter the picture until year 2000.

In 1998 they were decidedly anti-ad, but after failing to monetize differently, I guess they caved in.

However, that anti-ad approach and an attempt to avoid the results being gamed with PageRank made hordes of "us" (geeks who were being called in to help others with their "computer problems") to get everybody to switch to Google Search.

But I doubt they planned all of that, especially not to turn their company into an advertising company.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by opencl on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:59AM (#26489835)
For a while copies of Windows sold in Europe let the user choose which browser would be installed by default during the setup process.

Microsoft's obligation to do this ended in 2014 and now we're back to them begging everyone to use Edge.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by freddie_mercury on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:12AM (#26487856)
Microsoft didn't lose the anti-trust case.

Go check Wikipedia.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by quelsolaar on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:39AM (#26488031)
They did loose, then they appealed and settled.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by oblio on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:58AM (#26490455)
Yeah, people should start treating, morally, settling just as losing a case. This doesn't apply for individuals, but companies settling for millions and millions are morally admitting defeat. Corporations can afford the drawn out court battles, so if they're not continuing them, it means that they're admitting they lost.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by leetcrew on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:48AM (#26491169)
no, people should consider settlements on a case-by-case basis depending on the actual terms. entities settle totally unfounded suits all the time just because it's cheaper than taking them to court. just because a giant corporation could afford to doesn't mean settling isn't a rational choice.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by heavyset_go on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:40PM (#26496516)
Settlements are a win because they don't set precedent, and are often much cheaper than going to trial, and much, much cheaper than losing. There are plenty of companies that skirt the law or civil agreements hoping that, in the worst case, they can just settle if they're brought to court.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by necovek on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @05:28PM (#26496998)
I think European court system is not based on precedents, so while someone can point at any particular ruling in another case, it shouldn't affect ruling in their own case.

IANAL though :)

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by heavyset_go on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:50PM (#26497770)
Applies in the UK, though, we got our case law system from them.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by guytv on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @05:21AM (#26488449)
> You know that Android is open source...

Technically Android is OpenSource.

De-facto - its not.

For many many years now Google is adding all non-os functionality into "support" libraries, "Google Services" - the name changes periodically - but the essence is the same: Making sure that any Android that is not "Google certified" won't be able to run Android apps - which all use these libraries - and won't have apps such as YouTube, Gmail, Photos come pre-installed..

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by londons_explore on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @05:59AM (#26488824)
But there is an opensource implementation of those support services (microg) which work for most apps.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by fsflover on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:46AM (#26489725)
Except the drivers are always closed, so you cannot run any OS that you like or have long-term support.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by guytv on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:04AM (#26489332)
oh, nice.

I didn't know about it.

It is a huge undertaking, google has services from "simple" things like location, to complex things like face recognition.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by londons_explore on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:14AM (#26489429)
I believe many of the microg services are mocked out in a way that makes apps 'work', but complex things like step counting in Google fit or face recognition will always return some bogus results.

Still, it makes 99% of apps work.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by im3w1l on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:28AM (#26487291)
A third party app store can not automaticly apply updates to apps. The user has to explictly approve every update. This puts the play store in a privileged position of lower ongoing friction.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by modeless on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:44AM (#26487366)
There was a recent Android blog post that said "we will be making changes in Android 12 (next year's Android release) to make it even easier for people to use other app stores on their devices". https://android-developers.googleblog.com/2020/09/listening-...
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by saurik on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:43AM (#26489137)
I bet they only announced that because Epic sued them on these grounds soon before that.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by curt15 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:25PM (#26493347)
"Android has always allowed people to get apps from multiple app stores. In fact, most Android devices ship with at least two app stores preinstalled, and consumers are able to install additional app stores. "

What is the most common preinstalled app store besides Google play?

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by modeless on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:34PM (#26493484)
I'm going to guess the Samsung one.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by pjmlp on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:05AM (#26487824)
90% of future Android 12 users will only get it when their phone dies and they buy a new one.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by oblio on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:00AM (#26490489)
It's actually getting better. New versions of Android are getting adopted faster: https://www.gsmarena.com/report_android_11_has_the_fastest_a...

It's not yet at iOS levels, but Google is actually getting there, I'm impressed. It's much easier to pull this off when you're a huge company making the hardware and the software and you can just boss OEMs and telecom companies around, it's much harder when you have a Microsoft Windows-like arrangement.

They're still at least 5 years from getting near iOS, but still... progress! :-)

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by pjmlp on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:26AM (#26490884)
IF one happens to own a flagship Android device from top brands, nothing changed for the devices that most people actually buy in large quantities for their pre-paid cards.

https://www.theverge.com/2019/9/4/20847758/google-android-up...

Google's own security reports marketing usually only focus on the devices where they can sell a nice Treble picture.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by oblio on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:31AM (#26490949)
It will trickle down. Even for those top brands it was a struggle.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by pjmlp on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @10:21AM (#26491599)
Nokia will gladly sell me a new device for Android 11, even though other devices from them of similar age as 7+ already got it, and they are one of the best update stories currently.

Meanwhile most shopping malls in Germany still sell pre-paid phones with Android 7 and above.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by square_usual on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:17AM (#26487569)
It will be ages before Android 12 is on a plurality of devices, not even a majority.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by valvar on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:14AM (#26487868)
That's assuming the feature even materializes. I don't it's cynical to assume that Google might shelve a "feature" that undermines their own business at the first opportunity.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by Bellamy on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:38AM (#26491025)
I bet they invest billions of resources to this feature.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by londons_explore on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:42AM (#26489683)
A lot of apps can do substantial changes to functionality with just serverside changes. App developers are already used to a good chunk of users having updates disabled. Those users update every 1 or 2 years whenever they get a new phone and reinstall your app.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by cute_boi on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:22AM (#26487259)
this opensource thing is not so straight as you have explained.

In Android these days I find lot of finance app using some proprietarytechnology like google safety net. And most app are using google play services which again is closed source.

Android is not true opensource software ...

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by bdcravens on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:45AM (#26487377)
Snaps in Ubuntu also has proprietary components.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by andrewshadura on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:49AM (#26489188)
Yes, the store. And advanced functionality is only available to paying users.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by curt15 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:57AM (#26489253)
"Advanced functionality" such as the ability to take full control of when apps get updated.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by e3bc54b2 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:08AM (#26487511)
And many on HN have reservations against snap for that and more.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by dleslie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:25AM (#26487276)
Many, _many_ Android phones cannot work with any known custom ROM.

Where's a custom rom for my Blackberry Priv, for instance?

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by m463 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:45AM (#26487705)
It is worthwhile to read the google anti-trust complaint:

https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1328941/downl...

It's clearly written, a short read and gets interesting each subsequent page.

The android stuff begins on page 19.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by heavyset_go on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:48PM (#26496612)
> You know that Android is open source and you can just sideload apps, install a 3rd party app store or replace entire OS with your own ROM right?

User installable 3rd party app stores are cannot compete with the Play Store on feature parity because 3rd party app stores cannot implement automatic upgrades, background installation of apps, or batch installs of apps like the Play Store can.

Manufacturers fight against users' abilities to root or replace their OS on the phones they sell. There are thousands of models of phones that will only ever run their OEM installed ROMs, and there are millions, if not billions, of Android devices that cannot be rooted or won't run custom ROMs, and more are produced every year.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by otabdeveloper4 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:34AM (#26490160)
> or replace entire OS with your own ROM right

For over 90% (rough guess) of devices this isn't true.

ARM isn't an open platform like Intel/PC.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by natex on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:02AM (#26487135)
Is your feeling on what Google's hopes speculation, or do you have some inside information?
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by elmomle on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:07AM (#26487165)
I imagine that it's speculation but it's reasonable speculation, since maximizing profits is pretty much the sole goal of a publicly traded corporation at the end of the day.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by natex on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:24AM (#26487269)
I don't think that supports the speculation since as the GP stated, Google is actually doing the opposite of maximizing profits in this case.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:27AM (#26487286)
The over $1 million crowd is 98% of their revenue. So in this case they're reducing revenue by about 1%... because they know if they don't, government regulations will take the other 98%.

It's still about maximizing profit, even when they appear to be reducing it.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by nindalf on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:07AM (#26487497)
It is exactly what you’d do if you maximise profits. The general argument against the Apple/Google tax is “think of the small businesses!” They use this argument because no politician wants to be against the small business owner.

Google and Apple understand this well. Since small businesses account for a small % of their revenue, they simply offer a better deal to those small businesses. Now Spotify/Epic Games/Candycrush people will have to argue “but think of the large businesses!” That doesn’t have the same ring to it somehow.

The majority of App/Play Store revenue is protected from government intervention, and profits are maximised. Make sense?

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by elwell on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:14AM (#26487869)
> Google is actually doing the opposite of maximizing profits in this case

You've chosen a difficult position to argue.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by elwell on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:20AM (#26487900)
> maximizing profits is pretty much the sole goal of a publicly traded corporation

Would that extend to for-profit private companies? Employees? Sub 1m revenue app developers?

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by aembleton on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:10AM (#26489392)
> they're hoping that this will stop some app developers from demanding the right to use third party payment processors

I thought you could do that for apps through the Play store. For example I pay for the Windy app through Paypal.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @06:15PM (#26497455)
This is actually somewhere Google has generally been more accepting than Apple. While Apple has been very harsh on both the app purchase and any in-app content or services being through them, Google has been more lenient, historically, on the latter.

Google has actually changed their minds on that, and will start being Apple-level strict in September of this year: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2020/09/google-announces-cra...

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by madeofpalk on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:16AM (#26489439)
I believe Games is the one exception - Games must use the Play Store for all in-app purchases.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by rsj_hn on Thursday March 18, 2021 @03:15AM (#26500306)
I don't think that developers, as a group, have much political power, or that Google is afraid of who developers will vote for.

To the degree that Google cares about developers, it is because of:

https://tenor.com/view/microsoft-windows-steve-ballmer-devel...

It's hard to retain Android developers already when there is less money to be had vs iOS, especially after Apple cut their take.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by heavyset_go on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:33PM (#26496436)
Apple and Google have held a duopoly in the mobile app distribution market for over a decade now. It's time for the market and consumers to enjoy the benefits that real competition in this space can bring and to rid them of the years of anti-competitive stagnation they've had to suffer through for benefit of Google and Apple's shareholders.

While Google's change is nice, it doesn't address the core issue at all.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by bjustin on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:36PM (#26494413)
I agree, and even with a selfish motive, this is still a positive move on their part (and Apple's). Companies changing their behavior to avoid regulation is a better outcome than regulation in some cases, including this one IMO.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by einpoklum on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @07:57AM (#26489826)
But can't Google avert this by paying off politicians? You know, with the legalized-bribe political contributions that are so popular?

Anyway, Google's hold on mobile ecosystems is really a menace. So much so that it's difficult to even tell apart Google Play the store, Google Play the service(s), Google Play the library(/ies), and whatever else they call by that name.

Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:17AM (#26490005)
Paying off politicians has worked well for Google since the Obama era, but it's not working anymore. Reason why was Trump's election. Politicians realized that Google's services, and how they're moderated, can do a lot more to affect an election than a donation ever could.
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by einpoklum on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:47AM (#26490307)
You have a point there... but even so - Google has been censoring non-mainstream political views, and artificially promoting mainstream news media (the big networks anyway). Isn't that enough to curry favor?
Re:Google Play service fee reduced to 15% for the first $1M/... by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:23AM (#26490825)
Not really. Perception is everything. Democrats believe Google allowed Trump to be elected by valuing profit on platforms like YouTube rather than intervening in extremism. Republicans believe Google and it's largely liberal-leaning employees are censoring conservative voices via algorithm updates and deplatforming.

The truth is probably both are right in certain respects, and so Google finds itself now without many friends in the political sphere.