Several scans, and a few hours later, my SO was discharged.
I then got to spend something like 30 hours on the phone over the course of a couple of months fighting a bill for around $100k because of a typo during the admissions to the hospital.
That's bad enough on the face of it, but there were real Kafkaesque moments. Like where I was explaining to the insurance company that this was not an automobile incident just because there were cars nearby, not once, not twice, but five times, once with a form that asked for pictures of the intersection and made me describe why cars would be stopped at a red light.
Up here in Canada I have not gotten a bill yet (including when my daughter had to get brain scans), but one thing is it’s very hard to get the actual scans. I had to no joke steal my own chest xrays to get a copy.
unacceptable. In Asia, you have the personal email and cellphone of your dedicated administrative assistant (you won't ever have to talk to another one) who takes care of things like that. You just tell her to obtain your CT and fedex it to your doctor, and they call you back when it's done.
US is $3k-$4k?
Medical transcribing has a high error rate.
The US healthcare system is immoral.
Unraveled messes not to be fixed lest the profits disappear
In this case, though, the error was a transcription error in the birthdate. That caused a mess.
Several hours and CT scans later, I was informed my brain was fine and I just have a strange retina, and will need annual follow up.
I've been sent a letter every year since, inviting me back to the hospital, and every year they tell me it's still fine.
So far I've paid £25 for the eye test (which I completed at a later date!) as I do not get my eye-tests subsidied by the NHS. However my employer reimbursed me for that too...
Goldman Sachs asks in biotech research report: ‘Is curing patients a sustainable business model?’
<https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/11/goldman-asks-is-curing-patie...>
this is some quote...
what's next: "people, what is their true ROI.."
When I work, I get paid. I expect pharmaceutical companies feel the same way.
And if you look at how the world dealt with the hep c cure, it was pretty much trying as hard as possible to pay as little for a cure because the cost was front loaded.
Unless that one time cost is huge.
There simply isn't a "cure for pain" to replace painkillers, but statins and co could be avoided if we taught people actual good diet advice.
The worst problem with statins is the personality changes: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200108-the-medications-... …which doctors wouldn't admit existed because they aren't taught that "evidence of absence is not absence of evidence".
Imagine how many cheap cures we would “suddenly discover”.
Capitalism makes this a really difficult problem, even if we’re just doing hypothetical scenarios.
I mean that any system that has money or power as it’s underlying motivation probably cannot reach the kind of level that is possible since there will be people who are gaming and manipulating it to take extra for themselves.
My actual point is that we (human beings) have the technology, the knowledge, and the capacity for compassion required to live beautifully vibrant lives free of most of the health problems that we see in our societies. And we can have all that when we get out of our own way.
Nobody wants to spend 100% of their income on healthcare, which means saying no has to become a habit.
I'm not talking about Healthcare provision, or the complexity of the current service industry (the whole industrial complex around healthcare is
I'm saying: pretend we could sweep everything 'off the table' and start over. Not just the industries and the political systems, not just fiscal structures, not just the concept of money itself, but the mindsets of every human being.
And let me be clear: I do not think that this is realistically possible in any sort of reasonable time frame (I'm not even going to argue that it's possible at all).
But, now that we've hypothetically swept everything off the table, my point is that we have the building blocks to build a society where the majority of people are effortlessly healthy.
With a clean starting point, there's no reason to build in a way that companies gain by keeping people sick.
We as a planet know how to be healthy.
We as a planet know how to keep the environment healthy.
We as a planet know how to be emotionally, physically, and spiritually vibrant.
We as a planet know how to treat many diseases cheaply and effectively. (Not all. There's definitely still a need for medical R&D so don't @ me on that)
Yes, we could argue all day about how these ideas are not profitable or realistic or 'how things are done' in our current societies, but none of those arguments matter against the fact that we have more varied understanding and capabilities now than we ever have in the past.
From decades of observing the system, it seems extremely unlikely to me that it was deliberately engineered to be this way. Rather, different parts of it grew and changed organically and the parts and changes that benefitted moneyed interests in power stayed, while those that did not were discarded.
It does not take a deliberate will behind something for it to be pulled toward this sort of inequality, and presenting it as if that's what's happened suggests that if we could only defeat the Evil People who "engineered" it this way, we could make it better. It's a very compelling idea, and it makes for a nice dramatic narrative, and humans love good stories.
Unfortunately, it's not the case. In order to make it better, we need to take a good, comprehensive look at many aspects of our systems of economics and government, and redesign them deliberately and with a strong intention to inhibit the flow of money upward from the 99% to the 1%. It's hard, it will take a long time, the people with the most wealth and power will fight us every step of the way, and there's no silver bullet, but there's also very little that's more worth doing.
I get they need to make money, but many times it seems like hospitals/doctors sent out bills just hoping people will pay.
Me, and my father used to have great union insurance (Cadillac plans). For years their were no problems. That started to change in the late 90’s.
1. I once got a $900 lab test from a hospital. They knew I had insurance. I called multiple times, and told don’t worry about it, but I still got the bills. Lather I saw what the the hospital charged my insurance company, and it was $90 for the test. I paid $9 for my premium. Isn’t in the hospitals interest to send out bills just hoping I might pay $900?
2. My mom is sent so many bills even though she has the same plan.
My point is there are no laws against sending out bills. Hospitals/doctors might not have it written down anywhere, but just send out a bill, and let the patient clean up the mess with their insurance company seems like a good strategy—for the heathens?
My mom had a bad tooth a few years ago. Went to her dentist, and he demanded cash upfront—conveniently on a Friday, and he knew she had great insurance. She paid because of the pain. She called up a few weeks later, and asked for a refund. She gave $2500, and insurance (Delta Dental) paid 90% of the bill. She kept calling the dr’s office, but always was told we need to contact the insurance company. I finally got on to a Delta Dental worker, and started to explain the situation. The work seemed to know exactly what I was trying to say. In thirty minutes, after Delta called the doctor, a highly apologetic money manger said we are sending off your check today. (I won’t publicly saw what the representative implied here of the doctor here.)
3. My father once went to Marin General for a routine hernia surgery. My father was beyond a hardened man. I saw him close to crying once, and it over taxes. Well he woke up after the surgery, and their was a Teddy Bear, and bouquet of flowers waiting for him. It wasn’t me, I told him. Anyways it was a mystery until he got his bill. Beyond the typical $12 Tylenol’s, there was a $330 psychological enrichment fee. Yes—that was the hospital charging my father, and insurance for the unasked for gift.
So it is it seems like it’s in their best financial interest to overcharge, do unethical things, and hope people just pay?
Is that engineered—-in my book yes.
Our medical system is no different. Insurers developed byzantine claims departments and custom plans as a way to make medical coding complicated and error prone for the purpose of denying claims due to error. They setup private panels and doctors to reviews claims and treatment plans with the explicit purpose of denying claims as not medically necessary.
The system is designed to intimidate, overwhelm, and confuse and it's stacked against both the customer and the medical provider.
You've covered the evil tactics of insurers, but providers absolutely engage in intentional opaqueness, overbilling, and as much screwball behavior as the market will bear. No, the insurance company did not force them to charge $500 for an aspirin and "accidentally" bill in full for a procedure that was discussed as a hypothetical but never actually happened. "Look over there!" isn't going to cut it as an excuse forever.
Is it fair or honest? No but if they suddenly became fair and honest it would solve nothing because they're a symptom of the problem, not a source.
I'm sure the overbilling and weaponized opaqueness are plausibly deniable, but I'm just as sure that providers don't mind one bit when they work, just as an insurance company doesn't mind when they discover an excuse to deny coverage. Providers are not "making ends meet," they are testing the limits of how far they can exploit the blank checks they have been written. They are not solely responsible for this mess, but they have a full share of moral and systemic culpability.
For example insurance pays for procedures not the process of doctors filling out insurance forms. That’s by design and ends up having horrifying implications for the healthcare system as doctors often spend more time dealing with insurance than the patient actually needing treatment.
It's literally a preposterous thing to believe, deeply revealing.
> It does not take a deliberate will behind something for it to be pulled toward this sort of inequality, and presenting it as if that's what's happened suggests that if we could only defeat the Evil People who "engineered" it this way, we could make it better.
...but then also this:
> ...to inhibit the flow of money upward from the 99% to the 1%. It's hard, it will take a long time, the people with the most wealth and power will fight us every step of the way...
So maybe there are "evil" people and deliberation at work, and it's not just emergent complexity?
Non for profit is a nice smokescreen. Nonprofit status is a nice little windfall fir the permanent bureaucrat class at payors and hospitals.
Starting from cancer children's hospitals that do all kinds of tricks to energize fundraisers and draw donations.. which amount to a paltry 30% of their CEO's salary....
To payors colluding with hospitals to raise "gross" prices in order to get more government payments for medicare disproportionate share funding (DCH) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disproportionate_share_hospita...
THe profits go to the permanent administration.
Is it any surprise that admins then balk at putting prices online, with an argument that can be summed up as "OMG, you make us put online the price from 2000 contracts!! Its too hard! "
Here is a little nugget. Nonprofit designation for hospital is a recent development. It didn't exist before 1900. The designation was effectively "compensation" by the government to hospitals, so the latter would agree to admit patients regardless of ability to pay. Quid pro quo.
Dont feel bad for hospitals and their "curse" of nonpaying patients. They got their pound of flesh.
Nonprofit status its not just federal exemption.. its ALL Taxes (state, local, real estate, commercial, etc).
Imagine your life if you didn't have to pay sale tax? Property tax? State tax ? FICA, FUTA SDI?
That is the life nonprofit hospitals enjoy.
There is no other industry like it except, perhaps, the mafia.
I was unemployed for our second daughters birth (I started a new job a week after she was born) and her birth and subsequent care was all covered by Medicaid. So I guess the best financial decision is to time job changes for births, which really shows how messed up the system is.
When my wife takes our baby in for a visit, we wait 2-4 hours and get a $200 bill for a routine visit. We get charged if we cancel an appointment with notice or late.
They are always fumbling around with bills. Pay $150 at the visit and get a $80 bill in the mail, and then they bring up a $60 charge from last time.
I have the money, but am thinking of fighting it even though it’s such a small sum.
Either their accounting is incompetent or fraudulent, but either way, I’m annoyed enough to push back. I suspect they are trying to fleece as many people as possible to make up for the 2020 budget hit they took.
There were literally made up charges they admitted to billing everybody for, but can waive if somebody's insurance doesn't cover it.
No idea how they get away with this stuff. Every hospital in America must have some very good lawyers on staff.
It’s time consuming, and confusing, and people will fob you off. But it’s necessary unless you want to get taken for a ride.
I'm not trying to justify the system overall, but please don't take a $150k bill at face value, if you can't reasonably afford to pay it.
It's true you can negotiate, but it's also true their bar for "reasonably afford to pay it" absolutely can include emptying your savings and other assets.
But they will often vastly reduce and/or over 0% interest long term payment plans.
I asked the hospital who the anesthesiologist would be and they said they had no way of knowing because you use whoever is on duty when you give birth.
So there was literally no way to figure out if all of the birth would be covered. And it turns out, the anesthesiologist that happened to be working that day was not accepted on our plan. They billed us for $4k (even though he botched the epidural, causing us to need an emergency c section.)
We had to decline to pay it a few times before they said they would work it out and accept the lower amount from our insurance.
That's why I got hospitalization-only insurance as soon as Trump allowed it... Obama-care was a joke... except for the pre-existing condition clause, maybe.
The whole point of requiring everyone to get insurance is so that you don't have just the sickliest and oldest people getting insurance. Insurance is meant to spread the risk amongst everyone who pays premiums.
Additionally, not having insurance for primary and non-emergency care will make it much less likely that people will even end up in the emergency room. (No checkups, no outpatient)
Even worse, having emergency room coverage only encourages people to use the emergency room more often than they should.
Though I wouldn't expect our last president to have much of a handle on economics and business, considering his track record. Either that, or he was purposely trying to destroy the program (he was, but it was probably both reasons).
So why did it make the insurance costs skyrocket?
We had a child 10 months ago, billing was screwed up by the hospital, then by insurance and we are still in process of getting it resolved. I have now spent at least 8 hours on the phone.
I had a surgery, called insurance and verified it was pre-approved and in-network. After procedure I receive $22k bill. I was young and did not care about my credit back then and never paid. 5 years later I received a new bill, for $300 as the provider sued the insurance company.
I hate going to the hospital and AWAITING a shower of bills. This grinds my gears SO hard. Every hospital stay and bills just keep coming for a few months.
As someone who likes to budget and plant expenses, I just cannot stand the US medical system. I never know how much a simple wart removal my cost. $100 or $2000? I'm happy to have good insurance, don't require to use the medical system a lot and have enough money. However, if you are extremely ill you seriously need to move to a "FIRST" world nation or have a good insurance with low max out of pocket. However, you still are going to deal with bills like its your full time job.