That deal was always time limited, and then was periodically extended for years and years until one day it wasn't. It was clearly never 'sold' as <i>forever</i> though.
The truth is that you miss the world in which google reader could exist. Free, unfettered, unabridged access to full length articles in a highly consumable format is not a thing that most publishers are behind now. They want your eyes on their ux and their ads.
It's a bit like saying you miss street fighter 2 cabinets. Ok but, there are no arcades left.
Excellent. But what Google took away was the culture of blog-RSSing.
It gave an enormous advantage to Facebook and Instagram. Which are competitors to Google. What a bad move from Google.
When they moved on, nobody else wanted to take on support in their free time, and no department wanted to pay someone full-time to work on it, so it was killed.
RSS still exists, you know!
I don’t think GReader led to a closing of feeds. It was simply a thing already happening. And even today the vast majority of sites still offer RSS feeds, I can’t even remember the last time I wanted to follow something, and it didn’t have a feed available.
But what you're not getting is that Google Reader helped make that world. Deleting the largest RSS reader app and replacing it with proprietary news feeds damaged the open web.
Huh? I use a self-hosted CommaFeed instance and it still works great.
We thought "Google is a big tech company, this should stick around." Got about 10 years out of it, which strikes me as pretty average for a tech product, but not great for a photo archive. Hell of a lot shorter than "4x6s in a shoebox."
At least that was a desktop app and they still have their data. Hopefully they were able to find a new way to organize them.
But I'm becoming more and more convinced that the only good way to store data is in an organized tree of folders, with any management software being a veiwer UI into that structure. App inevitably goes away? Replace it with the next one. Some things just need to have longer lifespans than software projects.
Point it at a folder, that’s your photo library. Dev could stop development tomorrow and your photos would be right where you left them.
I mean, if people really miss Picasa (and I personally know several) -- it's worthwhile to reimplement it and make money.
no it's not, because if you do (and look to be getting significant growth) Google will just start it up again and drive you out of business, run it for a year or two afterwards for free and then kill it.
As long as you don't use it to store music...
Basically same story, different file type:
The cloud is too... cloudy.
That said, play music was replaced by youtube music. My collection of 10k uploaded songs was moved into the new app without issue. Playlists and all.
We shouldn't tolerate this business from any megacorp.
The reason I used Google Photos was for one-click sharing. I could make a link, and viewers could pan and zoom and see all the details through a pleasant web interface. S3 doesn't do per-photo per-user access controls, and doesn't have a user interface for sharing or viewing. It's object storage, not photo sharing. As object storage, it's a lot more expensive than negatives in a binder, but about as useful.
We had to write a text editor in our first semester of our CS undergrad program. I'm not going to use my own text editor in favor of say MS word or Google doc.
Depending on contracts with an employer, there might be legal hassles as well.
It really is drop dead simple and you also don’t have to host it yourself. Every hosted provider supports external storages so you’re never locked in with them. And since you’re not actually using any of their storage you can stay in their free tier forever.
I self-host on DO and it works amazingly well.
Pray they don't alter it further.
I wish I had just gone with Apple.
All cloud storage should be treated as ephemeral (some more than others, particularly google). It will change terms or go away at some point.
Only local storage owned by you is actually, well, owned by you. If it is something that matters, keep it locally.
Following hard disk failure last week, I attempted to recover only about 1Gb of data from SpiderOak. Without going in to all the roadblocks, bugs and strange design decisions that exist when recovering data from them, I'm yet to recover anything worth having.
Been a customer for over 8 years. I guess the old maxim is true; an untested backup is worthless.
I managed to recover most data from various local backups I had lying around. That's the direction I'm going to go now, with a physical snapshot off-site every now and again. Not perfect, but much less hassle than what I've just been through, and also cheaper.
I only buy non-DRM content. Ideally, DVDs or CDs I'll rip myself (then the physical media is a second layer of backup).
Most of my storage volume is my own photography though. RAW files take a lot of space.
Didn't learn your lesson then, I see.
If you can’t see the actual JPG/MP4/FLAC files, you can’t be sure they’re actually there and eventually you’ll be burned.
Use cheap online storage for an offsite backup, and use any cloud (Apple, Google) in parallel for convenience.
When you drop a file into this drive, it will start "Uploading". Once it has uploaded, you will see "Remove Download" option which removes the local copy but keeps the copy in the cloud. If you click on such a file whose local copy is not present, it will "Download Now" (you can select and option-click and find this option as well).
Google offers both options, though? It used to offer free - unlimited "high quality" photos, which they have now stopped.
If you pay for storage, you can choose to store original quality images in the first place, and delete them from device
This is the sort of thing that really makes me regret getting a pixel
I wish I realized how anti-ergonomic Google's services were before I experienced it first hand.
You can choose to pay for storage and keep original quality uploads?
I got into this situation because I had a few terabytes of free storage that I accumulated while working at Google; there was some deal like "fill out this survey and we'll give your personal account unlimited free storage forever"... but they altered the deal and that storage went away.
I use iCloud now.