Ray tracing is good for rendering surfaces, reflection and refraction, but what we see is not limited to these things.
Volumetric stuff is all over the place: fire and other plasma, smoke and other aerosols, other forms of mixed-state matter. Also we have lots of liquid water on our planet, when it interacts with solids things and/or air, the visual complexity of the scene simply explodes. Look at boiling water, or streams of water, or shoreline. And to complicate things even more, some visuals depend on wave nature of the light: soap bubble, rainbow, or DVD disk.
Here’s some 15 years old tech.demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HsWh66MvqBg
Stuff like the brick wall with these shadows and reflections is awesome fit for RT. The final scene also good. However, close up scenes of the ground with water pouring all over the stuff, or that glass window with drippling water at 1:30-1:45 — RT won’t help a bit. And the rain / water / wet surfaces is about half of their shaders: https://developer.amd.com/wordpress/media/2012/10/ToyShop-Eu...
https://www.starwars.com/news/the-mandalorian-stagecraft-fea...
Backgrounds are, by definition, not what the viewer is going to focus on. Oftentimes they'll even be out of focus and therefore slightly blurred.
Don't get me wrong, Disney's interactive set technique is revolutionary and shows how far Unreal has come, but I still expect future Pixar movies to take hours of rendering for every single frame (because by now that's basically Pixar's selling point).
No I think they literally do photograph the LED screen on the stage with the actors and that is the final composite. Just like with traditional back- and front-projection.
I guess it’s graded etc, but so is a completely natural scene.
Is that to let them create something like a (say) 16K archival master that covers all the formats they might want for the foreseeable future without an expensive re-render?
It’s very common for film CG frames to take a few hours but not usually 12 hours. You need to be able to start rendering jobs at the end of the day and have them ready for dailies on the morning. Jobs that take more than 4 hours risk clogging the queue and taking 2 days per iteration rather than 1, so people are motivated to keep it reasonable.
Another important difference between games and film is antialiasing techniques. Much of the difference in render time between them is in using fancier texture sampling and using lots more samples than games are willing to use or even need for decent quality.
The original lion King worked because it was hand drawn graphics, the story , the dance and expressions on cat faces worked because graphics was limited.
The new one was a dull imitation with no understanding of what made it successful.
you should checkout the screen rant video on this https://youtu.be/sbx97kKHUHw
Art and games have been successful even if medium is limiting,ppl still read books watch plays and enjoy playing games like FNAF even if far superior tech is available.
If the limitations of medium wouldn’t matter, people and studios wouldn’t pay billions of dollars for VFX.
The new Beauty and Beast movie however was a whole lot worse than the cartoon. Lumiere, Cogsworth, Mrs Potts, etc all felt a lot more human and emotional in the cartoon than with the “realistic” CGI. They actually looked creepy in the new movie.
Way too slow for VR, try 5 ms just to be sure.
If they get it better and more relevant in the future we can check again!
[1] Few as in "not enough to matter much". There can still be millions of enthusiasts, but the market predictions and "disruption" didn't pan out.
"Disruption" means that you create a less qualitative, but cheaper product that would cannibalize the margins of the product of a company whose products are high-margin (think cutting-edge CPUs of Intel). This "cheap" product will for a long time ridiculed as toy (but nevertheless sell in huge amounts because it is cheap) - until it suddenly "lifts off", becomes an inconvenient competitor, and disrupts the market.
Does this description of disruption sound like any market prediction from the last 10 years how the market for VR glasses will develop? I don't think so.
That's because the limiting factor on VR hardware value to the consumer isn't resolution, or scene complexity as measured in polygons, or FPS, or any of the other metrics by which desktop games and game hardware are evaluated. It is latency. Latency in estimating and rendering the user's pose, movement, and viewport changes.
We would have had widespread adoption of immersive content by now if VR experience developers would be willing to sacrifice the 'traditional' metrics in favor of a ruthless focus on latency (and ideally push the hardware vendors in that direction too), but instead everyone keeps chasing "AAA graphics in a headset" , which, given that AAA graphics are (as the OP states) an ever-rising bar, can't ever really work except on whatever the current highest-end hardware is, and any experience that breaks people's willing suspension of disbelief on everything but the highest end hardware can't end up being a commercial success, any more than a multiplayer game with noticeable lag on anything under gigabit FTTH could (and for the same reason, except that the lag for VR starts with the single-player version, and only gets worse from there).
Not exclusively. That's disruption in the sense of "undercutting".
Disruption in the large also means:
"radical change to an existing industry or market due to technological innovation"
E.g. "things will change in how we do IT, entertainment, education etc due to VR".
But the fact is it brings an entirely new genre of games that can simply cannot be played on a keyboard/mouse/joystick & monitor.
However you seem like someone who enjoys pretending like VR is a little fad and doesn't offer anything new to the game space- so whatever.
Whether it's absurd, tons of pundits still did tout it to high heavens, big media outlets, tech startup sites, etc. The usual BS propping up they do, like they did for stuff ranging from fuel cells to grid computing and autonomous cars at different times.
"The VR revolution", "The next big thing", "How VR will disrupt everything", "revolutionize the economy", and so on. This started around 2012 and peaked around 2016 or so.
>However you seem like someone who enjoys pretending like VR is a little fad and doesn't offer anything new to the game space- so whatever.
"Offering something new to the game space" is a spectacularly low bar compared to the oversold promise of consumer adoption and applications of VR.
And even at that, VR thus far didn't even make a real dent in the gaming space, now that you've mentioned it. So much for all the 2012-2017 hype of the tech finally being "nailed".
It's doubly funny to me, because I have memories of the first VR fad, in the 90s. At least then besides the media hype, we've also got a few camp movies out of it ("Lawnmower man" and co).
They just don't have close ups of humans...
I deeply wish this were true. But it doesn't seem likely to me.
Games are real-time. And frame rate expectations are getting higher (60, 90, and even 120Hz) which means frame times are getting shorter (16ms, 11ms, 8ms). Rasterization is likely to always be faster than raytracing so the tradeoff will always be there.
Pixar movies look better and better ever year. The more compute they can throw at the problem the better pixels they can render. Their offline rendering only gets more complex and higher quality every year. It's so complex and expensive I'm genuinely afraid that small animation studios simply won't be able to compete soon.
Maybe raytracing will be "fast enough" that most gamedevs can use the default Unity/Unreal raytracer and call it a day. But imho the author is spot on that AAA will continue to deeply invest in highly complex, bespoke solutions to squeeze every last drop and provide competitive advantage.
There's an upper limit to what's useful - the real world. If our minds can't comprehend it, you've hit the upper limit of practical use. Once in game graphics become literally indistinguishable from real life then we'll start to plateau in terms of complexity of "tricks" and raw computing power will be able to catch up.
Maybe. Alternatively games won't actually want to render photorealistic and will want to render with varying types of stylized graphics. Is that easier or harder? Probably a little bit of both.
We actually are at a point where we can real-time render photorealistic scenes... for certain types of objects. Primarily static environments. Photogrammetry is basically cheating, but it is highly effective! Mandalorian is famously filmed on a virtual set and it's cool as fuck.
Graphics is moving rapidly into physics. We might be soon be able to render photorealistic scene descriptions. However simulating the virtual world we still have a long, long ways to go. By simulation I mean everything from the environment (ocean, snow, etc) to characters. We most definitely can not synthesize arbitrary virtual humans.
Will we someday see a movie that _looks_ like a live action movie but is completely virtual? Oof. Maybe? But even if we could, would we want to? I'm not sure.
https://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/cameras-vs-human...
It will take such a long time to get realistic VR, that we will have direct neural interfaces that are much simpler because they can skip the encoding/decoding.
\tanget And perhaps at higher semantic neurons, so we can just invoke the concept of "cool graphics" without actually having to simulate it...
In earlier headsets it was more narrow field of view and maybe that made it feel more obvious when my eyes were moving.
- [0] testufo.com
If testufo was randomized with multiple repeating patterns and random offsets, it could be a much better test. Here you can accidentally bias yourself.
The old 144hz goal was/is nice if you want to display 24fps (movies) content but games don't work like that. They display correctly without any judder/pulldown at whatever frame rate you want (as long as you have the hardware to run it at that rate)
Sounds like the beginning of a sales pitch for a 720 Hz display. :-)
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tV8P6T5tTYs - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OX31kZbAXsA
And here's how I can probably immediately convince you that I can as well: drag your cursor at a rapid speed across your screen back and forth (e.g. 2-3 times across the width per second). Focusing on one spot, do you see individual cursors with gaps of background in between? (I'm assuming yes.)
Now on 120 Hz the gaps will be half as big as on 60 Hz. On 240 Hz they are half as big once again, but they are nevertheless noticeable. The size of the gaps easily allows you to distinguish between 120 and 240 Hz.
Until I can drag my cursor across the screen and see nothing but a continuous moving object, we haven't hit diminishing returns on monitor refresh rate yet.
laughs in light fields
My point was that even if hardware gets 100x better we still have a difference between a AAA game that can render a giant open world and a AA game that will use smaller worlds like a space ships with loading screens for each room.
Text rendering used to involve complicated hinting and then subpixel rendering.
These days on Retina screens you don't need hinting or subpixel rendering.
You just render it like any set of curves, no longer any tricks about it being a font, because it's hi-res enough.
What rendering tricks are you suggesting are being added rather than being taken away, for fonts?
I think the author makes a good point at the high end, but Raytracing is going to simplify the crap out of whatever we have that's like Unity in a decade or two (hopefully not Unity).
So many issues like transparency sorting, AO & GI, depth of field, baked and real time shadows and reflections you basically don't have to deal with the complexities of as an end user.
But you'll be leaving a lot of performance on the table with a one size fits all solution.
But even though parallelism can be increased, the gains from them are limited as per Amdahl.
Amdahl basically does not apply to graphics tasks which are embarrassingly parallel. Raytracing will be no different.
And in fact you're getting rid of many preparation steps pre render that may be tricky to parallelize well, and replacing it with brute force.
Hybrid render pipelines and AI enhanced RT passes is the future.
And while true for now, I think the title is plain wrong in the longer term. There will come a time in which hardware is sufficiently powerful that one no longer needs these tricks to create top graphics. And physically based raytracing absolutely will simplify all of rendering to a couple core components when that time comes.