News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chowned on Thursday October 29, 2020 @01:47PM (#24933081)
Denial is the only way to cope with how impossible it feels to make any meaningful progress. I mean, the alternative is to sit white-knuckled until I die in a food riot. I am well aware of the changes that are coming, and it's one of many reasons why I'm not having kids: I don't believe progress will continue like it has (which was always unsustainable, even without deleterious effects on the climate), and I think the future earth will be much harder for humans in the short term. Sure, humanity will probably adapt, but millions of people might die in the process.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hluska on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:01PM (#24935831)
You know friend, I understand how you feel. When I look out at the world, I see so much garbage that I can’t even believe it.

Then I hang out with my four year old. She doesn’t understand racism, politics or climate. But she knows that she really likes everyone, respects others pronouns and likes sharing what she has.

There’s hope. As cynical as I am, there is hope. And the fact that you feel so strongly fills me with as much hope as watching my little one learn about the fucked up planet she’s inheriting.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by bamboozled on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:38PM (#24936304)
What happens to grow up to suck so hard?

Why can't we just look at each other and imagine the child that person once was, then maybe we'd care more about others like your 4 year old does.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lotsofpulp on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:06PM (#24937627)
Because allocating limited resources isn’t in the purview of a 4 year old. As you grow up, you begin to learn who wields the power and resources and how it’s allocated and what the consequences are for those who forgo it or can’t get it.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by bamboozled on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:23PM (#24938150)
I actually do wonder though if in the end, it really matters?

Everyone with power ends up losing it, or acquiring some strife, maybe if we cared less we'd find out it wasn't that much of a concern anyway.

I mean, do people chose power or does power choose them? Would you appreciate it if you had it?

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kortilla on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:38AM (#24939967)
The entire lifestyle of the west is mostly unsustainable if everything started getting allocated equally. So it matters to a lot of people.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hluska on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:43PM (#24936388)
This is beautiful writing and it deserves a reply, but for now I’m just going to read your words and wonder along with you.

I’ll edit this comment at some point but for now, thank you friend. This is beautiful and poignant. :)

Edit - I notice you edited your reply but I’m happy I got to read the original. You’re a beautiful writer.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by notabee on Friday October 30, 2020 @02:17PM (#24945268)
On a positive note, doing this is a very good way to understand people. Even their bad actions make a lot more sense if you delve into some developmental psychology along with just engaging your intuition about what their inner 4 year old wants out of life.

On a negative note, I think most people convince themselves of being much more grown up than they actually are. Really it's far easier to just get meaner and more calloused to survive while suffocating the core self. Maturity is more like a deliberate and careful edifice built with a lot of work, self-reflection, and self-forgiveness. It's not a given that just getting older does that, other than the inhibitory part of the brain getting better at restraining the emotional part after adolescence. (Usually, unless trauma happens that's sufficient to get stuck in a particular development stage.)

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by redvenom on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:25PM (#24936844)
We are taught in Western and most other societies of today to numb pain. The problem is that we have knowledge of the problems of this world. I think if we allow ourselves to feel the pain of our knowledge and understand our existence through it, we can return to a childlike state and realize the pain is not something wrong with us, but our natural inclination and love for the world telling us that we are doing something wrong.

We may not be able to solve the problems created by our species, but if we learn to live with respect for the planet then we can at least know we are doing as much as we can with our own existence.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by oconnor663 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:55PM (#24937093)
> Why can't we just look at each other and imagine the child that person once was

As hard as it is to generalize, I'd say it's because sometimes our needs aren't getting met, particularly our need for safety. When we feel like we're in danger, it's very hard to appreciate wonderful things. ("This person feels like they're in danger" is also a decent way to broadly sympathize with other folks, along the same lines as "imagine the child that person once was.")

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by fsloth on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:42PM (#24936986)
Thank you, this is beautiful and deep. I think I will try to imagine people as children and imagine them growing up more. Much easier to project loving-kindness that way.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by katbyte on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:09PM (#24937189)
Because the adult that person is now often is the source of so much pain and anguish to others?
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by xupybd on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:30PM (#24938861)
It's a lie that kids are naturally good. Leave them alone long enough and it'll go Lord of the flies real quick.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by DeRock on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:47AM (#24939273)
The lord of the flies was made up. Here’s an actual anecdote of what happens (spoiler, they work together): https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-...
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by konart on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:47AM (#24940008)
>Here’s an actual anecdote of what happens

Sometimes this happens, sometimes not.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by LarvaFX on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:15AM (#24941409)
Or it does always and not the other way around.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tappio on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:28AM (#24939935)
Have you considered that you might also be living in denial? As far as I know your brains are full of chemical reactions that make your little princess seem perfect. I'm a father as well and it is sometimes hard to distinguish "I love my kid and she's perfect" from "my kid is actually very kind". I hope the latter is true for you!
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hluska on Friday October 30, 2020 @10:16AM (#24942417)
This is an interesting comment and I’ll reply with two points:

First, my kid can be a real little shit. :)

Second, I think about that a lot. My Dad and I have a close relationship and sometimes I wonder if that’s because we are personally compatible or whether there’s something biological that’s just beyond our consciousness. In terms of my kid, I wonder the same thing (particularly when she’s being a little shit).

I hope the truth is somewhere in the middle. I’m her dad so I’m very biased in her favour. There is an entire biological side that I don’t think my conscious brain has direct read access to. But I still hope that my little girl is perfect and stays this wonderful kind little angel.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by globular-toast on Friday October 30, 2020 @06:18AM (#24940803)
> There’s hope.

There's hope because 4 year olds aren't racist and "respect pronouns"? I hate to break it to you, but no children are born racist and they will believe and copy whatever you tell them whether it's religion, racism or alternative pronouns. None of this puts food on the table, though, does it?

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by glaugh on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:13AM (#24939087)
My boomer parents were raised by parents who were taught not to tell their kids they loved them.

My (privileged) five-year-old has emotional tools that I didn’t have until I was 25.

I do think we’re generally getting better at raising empathetic kids. It’s not uniform, but it’s better.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ricardo81 on Friday October 30, 2020 @02:47AM (#24939790)
I think you're too hard on the older generations.

They lived in a time where kitchen appliances were a new thing, most work involved manual labour and lots of time. Getting used to hardship and not whining about it was their way of getting through it. Tired? Tough!

There is a balance to be had which I usually sort by "needs" and "wants". There aren't many needs and the rest is a luxury.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tommica on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:45AM (#24939527)
I'm curious, why do you think having emotional tools is a "privilege"? I might be wrong in my understanding of the term, but isn't it more of a right than a privilege?
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by xenocratus on Friday October 30, 2020 @07:23AM (#24941110)
Nothing is either a right or a privilege, objectively speaking, so it can be a right in one historical/social context and a privilege in another.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kazagistar on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:21AM (#24941458)
Privilege is something good, unequally (and/or unjustly) distributed. Rights are something good that should be afforded to everyone. So there is a lot of overlap but also distinction.

Rights are an ideal, privileges are a material reality.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by golergka on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:07AM (#24939859)
Having your right realized and not tampered is a privilege.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rad_gruchalski on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:07PM (#24938372)
> Then I hang out with my four year old. She doesn’t understand racism, politics or climate.

To put this in perspective: Hitler was once a sweet 4 year old. Stalin was one too. Mao? Yup. Putin? Sure he was. Everyone on this planet was once that sweet 4 year old not grasping any of what you mention. And yet, look where we are.

[dead]
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by konart on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:58AM (#24940051)
I mean, yours is even worse. You behave like an angry kid in an online game.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by konart on Friday October 30, 2020 @06:24AM (#24940835)
Hopefully people do realize that above is the reply to a deleted comment by hluska
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rad_gruchalski on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:25AM (#24940232)
Wow, you are actually the person I replied to in the first place. There goes the hope.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hluska on Friday October 30, 2020 @10:19AM (#24942455)
And again, emotional intelligence would help out here.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:13PM (#24938097)
Pull yourselves together. The previous century had trench warfare, famines, WWII, The Khmer Rouge, the cultural revolution, the Spanish flu, polio, threat of a nuclear holocaust, threat of overpopulation, AIDS, Imperial Japan, Apartheid, lobotomies, etc. Most of that stuff is now under control and probably will be for your kid's entire life. There's no chance global warming will be anywhere near as bad as many of those things for anyone alive today. For even further in the future, we have no idea.

Your despair is probably a result of being fed emotionally manipulative stories from the news and social media for too long. The real world has never been better, and it hasn't stopped improving. Try looking at some of Bill Gates's writing for inspiration. That's somebody who's not afraid to see the bright side of life while not ignoring the dark.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by webmaven on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:14PM (#24938758)
> Pull yourselves together. [snip 20th century bad stuff]. Most of that stuff is now under control and probably will be for your kid's entire life. There's no chance global warming will be anywhere near as bad as many of those things for anyone alive today.*

Umm. I'm pretty sure that drought, mega storms, wildfires, famine, and mass migrations of refugee populations (just to start) will spawn horrors in the 21st century at least as bad.

I mean, consider that some of the worst events in the 20th were essentially triggered by the great depression. As a civilization, we're going to have to withstand stressors far more severe than that before the 21st century is out.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:03AM (#24939025)
You need to put some numbers to those disasters. We already have all of them without global warming. We're much better at coping with them than we used to as well.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by EdwardDiego on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:48AM (#24940344)
Except a large part of humanity is _more_ vulnerable to them now due to population growth in vulnerable areas.

There's sufficient evidence that our response to climate change in the past was migration, sometimes by force.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by notabee on Friday October 30, 2020 @02:41PM (#24945490)
People have put numbers to it. Climate scientists have been literally weeping in interviews because of what they know. These are things that you just have to read for yourself to get a sense of the scale of the problem. But here's some exercises if you actually want to learn about this and you're not just going to hand-wave away unpleasant notions:

1. Read about the Permian Triassic extinction event (The Great Dying). That involved somewhere between 1200 - 2000 ppm CO2. We're emitting CO2 at least an order of magnitude faster than what led to that event. We still have at least 800 ppm to go to get to that scale, but if the permafrost decides to start belching everything up, we'll be heading there very, very quickly. Feasibly by the end of the century.

2. Do the math on how much excess carbon is in the atmosphere right now compared to the ice core data from the past 800,000 years. That ranged from around 180 - 300 ppm that changed gradually on the scale of thousands of years. That range is what humans have lived in for the existence of our particular species. Now, take the extra 120+ ppm and determine just how much material that actually is. How much mass. Now, do the math on how much of that carbon an average forest can absorb. Or any of these direct air capture technologies.

There is so much data out there. It's easily available. It's far easier emotionally to just plaster over this with general skepticism and blind faith in technological progress though. You can sealion all you want, demanding other people produce things on a platter for you to digest, but you're not going to really understand until you look at it directly anyways. You don't have to be a climate scientist to crunch some of the numbers.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Friday October 30, 2020 @06:02PM (#24947302)
You should explicitly state the logic you're implying and the conclusions. That way, if there are any embarrassing mistakes, they'll be obvious. Are you saying that with 1200-2000ppm, we'll have another extinction event? That it will include humans? Also that we expect to reach that concentration in our childrens' lifetimes? Those claims together are certainly not what scientists predict, so I don't know if you're wrong or using some other logic that I didn't infer correctly from your words.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by cranekam on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:53AM (#24940368)
None of those will compare to climate change. All of those events, bad as they were, were over in the relatively short term. Climate change is going to be all of that, a hundred times worse, and whatever anyone does at the time isn't going to fix it.

Your optimism is the result of living through the era of apparently limitless [0] energy and resources and the resulting development it has enabled. But the books don't balance. We can't possibly go on on this trajectory without the house falling down around us.

[0] not actually limitless

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by girvo on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:26PM (#24938833)
None of that will compare to the catastrophe that is climate change, if our understandings of the consequences are correct.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by SamReidHughes on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:54AM (#24939558)
A 7.22% reduction in GDP compared to where it would be in 2100? [1]

That's 2-3 years worth of GDP growth right now.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/08/20/climate-change-to-slow-globa...

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tsimionescu on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:52AM (#24940028)
This only factors in economic damage from the higher temperature. It's not looking at floods, extreme weather, and definitely not looking at second-order effects - mass migrations, increased risk of war etc.

It is an absurd fantasy to imagine that the only effects of global warming in the next hundred years will be economic contraction (though note that economic contraction YoY itself is almost unheard of in the US and Europe, and will bring dire consequences).

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by SamReidHughes on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:46PM (#24948161)
It's also an absurd fantasy that you can predict the future in technological advancements on a 100-year scale either. Not to mention the intractibility of climate modeling over that time period.

Considering a few years ago people were worried about the problems of jobs being automated away, you might imagine a little climate change creating extra work for people would be good for social cohesion.

But it's all just a bunch of bozos with PhD's and masters degrees.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dredmorbius on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:32AM (#24940546)
Nordhaus's Nobel is a fraud.

Steve Keen's done some excellent debinking.

Starting point:

https://evonomics.com/steve-keen-nordhaus-climate-change-eco...

TL;DR: Asssumming one can translate different lattitudes' GDPs to that of a planet undergone global climate disruption is ... an exceedingly dubious proposition.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:58PM (#24938999)
What are those understandings? The only quantitative predictions I've seen are utterly tame compared to those 20th century problems.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tsimionescu on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:02AM (#24940073)
[0] shows estimates of sea level rise from ~0.5m up to 2.5m by 2100. This alone will induce catastrophic flooding in some of the world's most populous cities and regions.

[1] covers some estimates of how prevalent wet bulb temperatures of >35C (the upper limit for a healthy adult to survive outside in the shade) will become. Any heatwave in this area will kill many vulnerable people and will stop almost any outdoor economic activity.

These are just 2 easily quantifiable numbers that will directly make life much harder in the next century (and the problems won't stop in the century after that). The second order effects can also be imagined.

[0] https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/... [1] https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/6/19/eaaw1838

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:14AM (#24940168)
Thank you, but that doesn't quantify catastrophe. I mean numbers of dead, cost in dollars, etc. Maybe we can cope with those 35 degree events by staying in air conditioned buildings like people already do in SE Asia. Maybe cities can move. The world's biggest(?) (Shenzhen) didn't really exist at all 80 years ago, or even 40 years ago.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tsimionescu on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:49AM (#24940648)
Here [0] is a study that found that, with the current trend, climate-related deaths per year in 2100 will be near the total infectious-disease related deaths per year today.

Also, Shenzen is only ~20th biggest city in the world [1], and its age is the exception, not the rule. The majority of the world's most populated cities are older than the countries they are located in, many of them being continuously inhabited since prehistoric times. Also, while creating a new city and populating it is possible with somewhat limited human harm (though rural->urban migration has its human impact, to be sure), deopopulating and moving a city of tens of millions (say, New York City, which sits at 10m elevation) is an entirely different scale of human displacement.

[0] https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w27599/w275...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_cities

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Friday October 30, 2020 @02:11PM (#24945192)
I assume you're using that 85 deaths / 100000 annually which is for the worst case scenario of RCP8.5. With the more reasonable RCP4.5, it's only 14/100000, less than road deaths today. Road death rates have already plummeted by a factor of several over the past few decades. So we've already suffered far worse than the effects of 2100 climate change just from the direct danger of cars.

Since we'll probably continue to have improvements in safety, diseases, etc. between now and 2100, the world should be a safer place for humans by then. So it doesn't make sense for people to worry their kids will suffer a bad world due to climate change. They'll most likely enjoy a better world than us despite climate change.

Did you mention preshistoric occupation to suggest that continuous occupation is necessary for a city? That surely helps but if an area has to be vacated, people will obviously go somewhere else, probably another place that was already occupied. Cities renew themselves anyway within the climate change kind of time frame. Buildings usually aren't designed to last more than 50 or 100 years. People obviously don't last longer than that either. So cities of 2100 will likely contain mostly new buildings and people that don't exist today, while today's ones will be gone. They'll effectively be whole new cities. I don't see why that renewal can't coexist with a gradual move inland. Not starting from scratch, just putting new development slightly more on the landward side of the city than before.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tsimionescu on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:47PM (#24946744)
> Since we'll probably continue to have improvements in safety, diseases, etc. between now and 2100, the world should be a safer place for humans by then. So it doesn't make sense for people to worry their kids will suffer a bad world due to climate change. They'll most likely enjoy a better world than us despite climate change.

I am sorry, but this is just delusional. Perhaps the biggest catastrophes will be averted, but only with great effort that our children and grandchildren will have to endure.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:59PM (#24947276)
Quantify these catastrophes and the effort that will be needed to avert them.

Bear in mind that civilization will collapse without the great effort of people doing their jobs and keeping everything working, climate change or not. So great effort is going to happen regardless. It's not a tragedy that people work.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tsimionescu on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:48AM (#24940013)
Droughts followed by famines will become the order of the day in most of the world, wars will be fought for access to water, refugee crises the likes of which haven't been seen since for maybe 2000 years, greatly increasing the risk of nuclear holocaust (which is already at an all-time high, with the USA unilaterally withdrawing from its treaty with Russia, and exploring low-yield nuclear weapons), the rise of surveillance states now becoming possible to a degree that was barely even dreamed of before our time, a (mild) global pandemic showing how brittle our systems are and how much our leaders are willing to put economic benefit ahead of human life, the new rise of fascism in the US and Europe - we are well on the way to the worse centuries in recent human history.

Make no mistake: there is absolutely no doubt that climate change, on its current unchecked path, will end human civilization as we know it. That is not to say that there won't be a human civilization in 100 years, but there is no way for the current system to resist flooding of some of the world's largest cities and other densely populated areas, probably physically displacing more than 500 Million people, heat waves that will kill a healthy adult in the shade in much of the warmer regions, extreme weather events becoming increasingly common and more severe, and all of the consequences of these items - drought, famine, wars over land and drinking water, massacres to contain the migration of the hundreds of millions of people that will be displaced.

And of course, essentially every dollar of GDP growth that we currently make is only increasing the problems above, and will continue to do so on the current path.

The only way to avert the catastrophe is to drastically change our civilization today - to stop burning any fossil fuel or methane gas today, literally (yesterday would have been better), and take on all of the major economic overhaul that entails. Every day we continue to burn fossil fuels, to raise livestock in industrial numbers, to burn down forests etc is increasing the magnitude of the catastrophes to come (it is too late to completely avoid catastrophe, we can only hope to make them milder).

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by esarbe on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:51AM (#24941681)
Downvote all you like.

It won't change the facts.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by sedachv on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:08PM (#24938731)
> The real world has never been better

Better for whom? And why do you think Bill Gates is any kind of authority on this subject? Read some of Derrick Jensen's writing instead.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ImprobableTruth on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:04AM (#24940087)
... you might want to add why Derrick Jensen is an authority instead. From a quick google search he just appears to be some random anprim guy that wrote some environmentalist books. Bill Gates has his foundation that is working to mitigate climate change, so I'd say he at least has some qualification since he is presumably in contact with scientific authorities. What does your guy have?
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kazagistar on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:30AM (#24941528)
Not that I am in any way a fan of anprim thinking, but anyone with massive vested interest in the perpetuation of present day power dynamics (eg massive wealth) has negative starting authority when it comes to evaluating the quality of that world and the value of its preservation.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by sedachv on Friday October 30, 2020 @10:33PM (#24948694)
Jensen, in addition to being a prolific author, is one of today's leading environmental and social philosophers. The only reason you know or care about who Gates is, is because he became very wealthy from predatory business practices. Kind of a stupid reason to pay attention to someone.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ImprobableTruth on Saturday October 31, 2020 @04:02AM (#24949821)
I care about what Gates says because he's founded one of the world's largest charity organizations and has done a great deal to reduce human suffering as well as specifically a lot of work in regard to climate change. Being rich alone doesn't matter to me, I don't give a damn what e.g. Jeff Bezos has to say about the matter.

Being a prolific author doesn't mean much to me and neither does being an environmental philosopher in this context. Someone like Peter Singer definitely is an authority on environmental ethics, but on the effect of climate change/the ecological state of the world I don't see why anyone would consider him an authority.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by sedachv on Saturday October 31, 2020 @07:08AM (#24950477)
> I care about what Gates says because he's founded one of the world's largest charity organizations

So your criteria for who is and is not worth listening to is "rich man who gives a lot of money to charity." Wealth is not some kind of superior substitute for expertise or insightful ideas. Unfortunately this seems to be a popular delusion today; that does not make it any less stupid.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kortilla on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:42AM (#24939990)
Better for the vast majority of the planet. Extreme poverty has been on a constant decline.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tsimionescu on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:10AM (#24940132)
Extreme poverty has been on a constant decline only as defined by the world bank (by choosing an arbitrary dollar amount of 1.90 international dollars that could barely buy some food, but not medicine or shelter).

In real terms, it has been stagnant or increasing, especially as people who were living well off the land have been forced to participate in the monetary economy or die of starvation.

And even by the world bank standards [0], the only gains have been because of China (a planned economy that has ignored any american or european economic orthodoxy), and to a lesser extent, India, which has mostly advanced by freeing itself from the burdens of colonialism (before colonialism, it was one of the richer areas of the world). In sub-Saharan Africa, extreme poverty has actually been increasing.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extreme_poverty#/media/File:To...

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by sltkr on Friday October 30, 2020 @07:15AM (#24941088)
> In sub-Saharan Africa, extreme poverty has actually been increasing.

According to your source, only in absolute terms, not in relative terms. Ideally, both should go down of course, but it does mean a smaller percentage of Africans live in extreme poverty today than they did 25 years ago.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kortilla on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:44PM (#24948144)
> a planned economy that has ignored any american or european economic orthodoxy

I implore you to look up how China’s economy functions. It is successful because they threw away the majority of the “planned economy” bits of communism and have a capitalist economy. They have a stock market, citizens invest in companies they choose, starting a business doing whatever you want is easier there than many places in the US, businesses fail all of the time. None of those are features of a planned economy.

> and to a lesser extent, India, which has mostly advanced by freeing itself from the burdens of colonialism

It has little to do with that and more to do with making themselves globally competitive in many sectors (IT and outsourcing being obvious ones). They also operate under a capitalist economy that fosters these successful projects.

> In real terms, it has been stagnant or increasing, especially as people who were living well off the land have been forced to participate in the monetary economy or die of starvation.

Funny how people throw out actual concrete definitions and then say things like “In real terms” without providing any kind of definition. Maybe start by defining that.

Furthermore, the amount of people who were “living off of the land” are included in the 1.90 figure measured by the world bank. That’s not based on receipts at the grocery store or tax returns.

Finally, the number of people “living well off of the land” (who just were fucked if they got meaningfully suck btw) is vanishingly small compared to how many were “living malnourished off of the land”.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tsimionescu on Saturday October 31, 2020 @03:20AM (#24949671)
You are looking at how China's economy functions today in a few cities, and not how it functions in the vast majority of the rest of the country. More importantly, while China has mostly or entirely gotten rid of the planned economy, it's success has come in large part because of massive monetary interference by the state in the economy, protectionism, forcing western companies to give up some of their IP to do business there, and of course a good dose of slave labor, like every successful economy in history unfortunately (I am absolutely opposed to this last one, and it is one of the things we have profited most from in Chinas's growth).

Countries that moved from a planned economy to capitalism under the IMF and WB's guidance have generally rushed to privatize their industry, have accepted and dutifully implemented all international IP treaties, have opened up their arms to foreign investors and sold their industries to them, and are almost all in much worse situations than China, with no hope of regaining the lost ground for now.

For India, I will only say one thing - India would not have been an IT powerhouse if it had been under colonial rule. The British wanted cotton and spices and other raw or lightly processed materials from India, and that is what it would have been forced to do - same as the path the American colonies rebelled against. Industrializationa and high-technology was for the mother land, not the colonies, in the horrible economic principle of the 'competitive advantage'.

---

Related to poverty, you're right, I probably should have given a definition. Extreme poverty means not having access to one or more of the the basic necessities of life - water, enough food not be malnourished, enough shelter not to die of hypothermia or heat, and access to medical care to survive the most common diseases in your region. If you have only these basic necessities and nothing else, you are still poor, but not living in extreme poverty.

From what I understand, the monetary threshold for these should be somewhere around 15 dollars per day to get out of extreme poverty (note that this 'income' includes begging, access to communal resources etc). There are of course many opinions on this number. However, the 1.9 USD value is pitifully low, and you can easily check that yourself: please think about what you can buy for 3 USD in you region each day, without any kind of borrowing, begging, living off the land, sharing etc (as those are already included in the number). Would you consider yourself to not be in extreme poverty?

Note that if we look at malnourishent, the percentage and number of people who are malnourished has stayed roughly the same since we started collecting data (1981), after increasing steadily up to ~2000.

And about people living off the land, they are indeed included in the data since 1981, but not in the data since 1800, as often presented.

Edit: and yes, you are right that people living off the land were usually doomed if they got significantly sick. But this is also true of, for example, everyone living on minimum wage in the US today, so I fail to see what's improved.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kortilla on Saturday October 31, 2020 @06:06AM (#24950188)
> But this is also true of, for example, everyone living on minimum wage in the US today, so I fail to see what's improved.

No it’s not and it takes a shocking amount of willful ignorance to suggest otherwise. If you become very ill in the US you just show up to an ER and they fix the problem. The ER cannot refuse you because you are poor. You deal with bankruptcy/hospital negotiations after. This brings me to my next point.

If you are on minimum wage in the US, there is Medicaid (and additional government health coverage in some states like California) for low income households. Not only do you get health coverage at minimum wage, it doesn’t even bankrupt you if you’re making use of the resources available.

If you’re living off the land, you eat some contaminated fruit and you die. You get a bad infection, you die. You get a bad gash, you might bleed out or get an infection and die. Bad water, giardia, maybe dead. These are all trivial for anyone to get fixed in the US and they are effectively non-issues (for people who actually seek treatment).

Additionally, entire classes of problems that plagued nomads (contaminated water, hookworm, etc) are gone because of drinkable tap water (a few fucked up communities not-withstanding) and sewage systems.

Your equivocation between those living off the land and a minimum wage US worker indicates to me you’ve never experienced low income life nor realize how many benefits of society you can still enjoy. Public education, libraries, OTA TV, parks, heating assistance (in the north at least), food stamps, Medicaid, discounted housing, etc.

If you can’t see how that’s better than living off of the land, I suspect your beef is with the lifestyle of modern civilizations and no amount of income will satisfy your comparison.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tsimionescu on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:15AM (#24951188)
First of all, all of your examples just show that someone living for minimum wage in the US is actually making way more than 42 USD/day ((7.25 USD * 40h work week) / 7 days) by the WB standards, as all those additional protections are counted in the adjusted income. How would the poverty stats look if you took extreme poverty to be 40 USD/day?

Secondly, you can live off the land and still live in a country with a functional health system. I'm not discussing nomad hunter-gatherers here, just people who don't live off a wage, like traditional farmers and rural tribes (who still have money from trading their goods for example, and can live pretty wealthy lives, but contribute disproportionately little to GDP).

Overall the point was that people can and have been living outside of any standard of poverty for a long time in areas that nominally have very little GDP per capita, and are often getting counted as extreme poverty in stats older than 1981.

Related to medical coverage, I was thinking more along the lines of cancer or serious chronic diseases, not acute poisoning or broken limbs. The kind of diseases that not only cost serious money to overcome in a privatized health system, but also destroy your ability to work and earn money when you're whole livelihood is dependent on a wage - even if Medicaid can cove the direct medical expenses.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Saturday October 31, 2020 @07:07PM (#24955963)
> cancer or serious chronic diseases

Everybody must die from something so how could anybody possibly not be in poverty by this standard? Do you only count diseases which can be treated with enough money?

If a new cancer treatment was discovered but it was incredibly expensive, perhaps requiring a team of specialists to provide exclusive continuous care to the patient for the entire rest of their life, then almost nobody could afford it and suddenly the entire world would be plunged into extreme poverty through lack of access to it. So you obviously have to accept that not everybody can have access to all possible lifesaving medical care if the world doesn't have the resources to provide it. There are already some personalized cancer treatments that come close to that. These are a net improvement for healthcare but they look like a regression by making poverty relatively worse.

You're probably right that extreme poverty is increasing if you keep broadening the definition as people get wealthier.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hungryforcodes on Friday October 30, 2020 @07:25AM (#24941126)
Wow, so having kids is the only way to be a participating human being in life and climate change?
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rv-de on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:04PM (#24937157)
> As cynical as I am

okay ... are you ready?

> She doesn’t understand racism

give her and her friends blue t-shirts and an equal number of other kids red t-shirts. do this for several weeks. lo and behold the basis of racism unfold.

racism is an inherent human feature which can only be overcome by education. something adults have to provide for children.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by evan_ on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:59PM (#24938334)
This is a ridiculous claim disproven daily by thousands of daycares practicing color-coded stable groups.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rv-de on Friday October 30, 2020 @07:02AM (#24941023)
Last time I checked children bully each other over their clothes and form sub-groups based on them.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3513287/

It likely also depends on how prominent the color coding is. Just a marker would probably be too abstract for children to be factored in. But I'd question your claim if children are clad differently in an obvious fashion like different shirt colors f.x.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by evan_ on Friday October 30, 2020 @11:24PM (#24948922)
The programs I have knowledge of use bandannas.

The study you posted does not describe children bullying or forming subgroups based on wearing a color shirt.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by bonaldi on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:39PM (#24937414)
No, racism is not an inherent human feature. A claim like that needs better justification than ... none at all.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by jussij on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:15PM (#24938105)
Humans don't seem to require much in the way of a push before racist tendencies emerge:

https://exploringyourmind.com/blue-eyes-and-brown-eyes-the-j...

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by bonaldi on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:16PM (#24938435)
Suspect there’s more going on there than the naive explanation. Repeatability breaks down quite easily:

https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2009/oct/18/racism-psych...

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dd36 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:28PM (#24938846)
Racism is a lazy mental short cut. It reminds me of Robert Cialdini’s research.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by pfisch on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:51PM (#24937505)
ingroup and outgroup is an inherent feature of ALL social animals.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by 0_____0 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:00PM (#24937588)
ingroup/outgroup behavior ≠ racism
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by pfisch on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:24PM (#24937765)
racism is just a subgroup that is a type of ingroup/outgroup behavior.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by bonaldi on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:33PM (#24937822)
Spoken French is just a subgroup that is a type of communication behaviour, which is an inherent feature of all social animals.

Doesn't mean speaking French is innate or inherent.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by yholio on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:03AM (#24939841)
Nor does it mean that antisemitism, white supremacism, apartheid or nazism are anything but dialects of the same age-old social pattern.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rv-de on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:54AM (#24940680)
also kurds vs turks vs armenians. settlers vs natives. to some extent even stuff like car drivers vs bike riders. always two+ groups whose members identify with that group and act and feel like they are fundamentally better or more worthy than another group.

it's taboo to say that - but in fact it's essential to overcome racism which seems to be the psychological root of many social issues at the moment.

Why did these guys cut off those other guys' heads in Paris or in Nice? B/c they feel like they have to protect their group ideals against people deemed unworthy to live or even die in dignity. I wouldn't call this "racism" - but I firmly believe that the psychological thinking pattern is fundamentally related and entangled.

Also interesting unpopular food for thought is that not just Murcans keeping African slaves is very much racist but also the reason for why one African tribe kept slaves from another African tribe and then sold them to American slave traders who shipped them to the new world.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by globular-toast on Friday October 30, 2020 @06:23AM (#24940830)
Where do you think it comes from? Elephants? Of course it's an inherent human feature.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kazagistar on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:32AM (#24941548)
Christmas isn't an inherent human feature.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by globular-toast on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:57AM (#24941712)
No, but marking significant events and anniversaries seems to be. Speaking English isn't inherent, but speaking is. The specific kind of racism you're thinking about probably isn't, but people preferring and trusting people more like themselves is.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by flyinglizard on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:50PM (#24937945)
The argument that less advanced societies are more racist or acceptive of racism, strongly supports the claim you are dismissing.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by devin on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:34PM (#24938874)
I'm glad someone has all of the answers.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by erikerikson on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:12PM (#24933423)
> Denial is the only way to cope

I disagree. We can accept that we have a feeling of impossibility and still continue engaging in behaviors we predict to have a more positive outcome than any others. After all, have you ever been wrong? I have.

Occasionally the bulk of our actions create emergent shifts. It seems we will have to make adjustments and there may well be horrid consequences but the severity of those remains under our adjustment.

I'm surprised to read this on Hacker News, one of the homes of "impossible" successes.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by scythe on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:09PM (#24934326)
>I mean, the alternative is to sit white-knuckled until I die in a food riot.

You could try participating in politics! It's not exactly fun, but it's a lot better than dying.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by umanwizard on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:53PM (#24938975)
No mainstream politician has a realistic plan for addressing climate change.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by scythe on Sunday November 01, 2020 @11:05PM (#24964740)
The dynamic range of the elected government body is extremely low. As long as there are a significant proportion of people in office who deny the reality of climate change, it is unlikely that meaningful discussion of solutions will occur.

In response to a sister comment, realistically, to address climate change, we would need to:

- build roughly 300 GWh of grid storage worldwide, lithium iron phosphate seems a leading contender although sodium-[sulfur|nickel] has the obvious abundance advantage

- replace gas heating systems with heat pumps and district (waste) heating

- implement carbon capture at all steel/concrete production plants (or less likely use low-carbon processes)

- replace fueled vehicle use (most of which is personal cars) with electric

- build some amount of non-polluting power stations, I'm not sure what exactly but by now it's the easiest part

- I'm not sure exactly but maybe you can replace torch manufacturing with electric arcs and lasers or something?

- also some carbon capture unfortunately probably the crushed olivine thing I'd guess

Someone's probably made a projection for the cost of this but it's useless with any shift of this magnitude.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by NateEag on Friday October 30, 2020 @02:19AM (#24939670)
I would make a stronger claim (and no, I haven't done the research to back it up, just a hunch):

> Nobody has a realistic plan for addressing climate change.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kazagistar on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:35AM (#24941571)
There are plenty. They are only unrealistic when people belive them to be unrealistic.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by NateEag on Friday October 30, 2020 @10:15AM (#24942396)
The best ones I've seen so far involve massive engineering projects in orbit to let us control the amount of sunlight hitting the earth.

Those are technologically feasible, theoretically workable, and at least somewhat reversible.

However, they don't really take human nature into account. Megasatellites for solar gain control would be an intensely scarce, valuable resource, and a de facto superweapon - "agree to our terms or you'll never have good crop growing sunlight again."

Nobody would be willing to cede or share control of such a system to someone else. Wars would break out quickly, and no deployed system would go undestroyed for long.

The other plans I've seen seem problematic to me either morally ("first world gets to keep its tech but you guys who are bootstrapping with carbon can go DIAF"), technologically ("We think there will turn out to be some way to capture carbon super-efficiently that we haven't found yet"), or reversibility ("whoops, we put too much dust in the atmosphere - guess we're starving three billion people for the next year or four, folks").

I'm not saying there is no possible solution - just that I haven't seen a realistic one myself.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kazagistar on Saturday October 31, 2020 @11:54AM (#24952441)
I meant the plan of "stop emitting carbon, even if it hurts the economy".
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by NateEag on Monday November 02, 2020 @10:06AM (#24968842)
That's what I was referring to when I referenced hurting third-world economies badly.

My understanding is that a lot of developing regions are using their carbon stores to improve quality of life and lifespan for their inhabitants - bad as coal may be for your lungs, it's not as bad as having no reliable energy for things like sewers.

Hence my comment saying "...if you're bootstrapping with carbon you can go DIAF."

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kazagistar on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:34AM (#24941563)
Thats fine, you can work to support non mainstream ones, or failing that, there are riots to join,
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by Florin_Andrei on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:28PM (#24936870)
Well, "everyone is in denial" is too strongly worded.

A lot of us are aware that there are all sorts of self-reinforcing feedback loops that we have not found yet, and those will definitely influence the events. But models cannot account for hypotheticals.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kanox on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:08PM (#24936674)
> sit white-knuckled until I die in a food riot.

This is nonsense, food production on a per-capita basis is increasing and population is leveling off.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ahelwer on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:11PM (#24936710)
And this year's Thanksgiving turkey is reporting it continues to be fed more and more each day! The future is bright!
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by i_love_music on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:38AM (#24939220)
This gave me a chuckle. Thanks for that
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by palijer on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:20PM (#24937277)
I can't tell if this is sarcasm or not. This reply seems very similar to "global warming isn't happening, it still n degrees in winter".

Things are just starting to change now. Our food production levels are the result of previous efforts. Not future efforts dealing with future changes.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kanox on Friday October 30, 2020 @10:03PM (#24948576)
An average increase is supported by data, food production issues is really not.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by NortySpock on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:11PM (#24936712)
How does food production deal with crop destruction by droughts, freak storms, or flooding rains driven by climate change? How do the world's poorest deal with rising food prices caused by crop failure?

That's what we're worried about, not "the current steady state trend is currently going up, it's all fine!"

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by titzer on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:47PM (#24937026)
You forgot soil depletion, loss of pollinators, and system ecological collapse, but yeah.

Food production per acre has increased by ~4x over a century, but that's the only 4x we ever got and the only 4x we'll ever be getting. We've been at diminishing returns for decades but will soon peak and experience lots of bad effects from unsustainable practices.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by holoduke on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:27PM (#24937782)
It is not correct. Here in the Netherlands we have Avery efficient and sustainable food production (vegetables and fruits). The systems are getting so efficient that in 20 years from now it is expected to have almost fully automated production factories which can operate indefinitely (theoretically) And our export is big. When other countries adopt our technologies we can provide food for billions with just a tiny environmental footprint. So there is absolutely good progress made in that field.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by sjmulder on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:12AM (#24939370)
Efficient, but unfortunately not sustainable at this scale and intensity. E.g. our soils are in a bad state, see the recent report from Planbureau voor de leefomgeving.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by edgyquant on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:51PM (#24937062)
You underestimate humanities ability to adapt. I’d bet in 100 years a lot of food is grown in vertical farms and those can be made (mostly) immune to droughts and storms. It isn’t going to be easy but nor is society just going to throw in the towel when it gets hard.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kadoban on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:04PM (#24937149)
We won't throw in the towel, but there will be casualties. I'm not terribly worried about humanity, I'm concerned about quite a few humans though.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by edgyquant on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:16PM (#24937702)
For sure I’m not a denier just a (semi) optimist. I certainly hope we can figure out a way to get around it but I’d wager we’re looking at the next Bronze Age collapse except the people will be fleeing from the equator this time.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by fogihujy on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:13AM (#24940160)
We, as an international society, have been so focused on improvement in material conditions that we haven't really done a proper attempt at looking for a sustainable way forward. Your Bronze Age analogy is spot on; the ancients had global trade and rapidly improving conditions too, and things were looking extremely bright for them. Until it didn't.

As the grandparent stated, "there will be casualties". Sure, I'm quite certain humanity will recover, and probably end up better off than we are now, but that doesn't mean the chain of events leading up to that that won't be hell.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by pixl97 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:44PM (#24937449)
I dont think you have any idea how expensive that is. Completely possible, but the cost isn't going go make food more available.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by edgyquant on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:14PM (#24937684)
I do, but when the alternative is starve or come up with systems that exist outside it could be the cheaper option.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kanox on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:17PM (#24936768)
> crop destruction by droughts, freak storms, or flooding rains

Aggregate data is much more relevant than anecdotes.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chipotle_coyote on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:39PM (#24936951)
It's at least worth keeping in mind that this discussion thread is happening on a link to an article describing an occurrence -- the Laptev Sea not freezing by late October -- that aggregate data up through a couple of decades ago would not have predicted. Global warming itself is arguably a radical break from what aggregate data tells us about climate trends, and the (originally good faith) argument against it for decades was, essentially, that the "alarmists" were mistaking statistically insignificant temperature drifts for new statistically significant trends.

The theory that global warming is going to lead to food shortages in the relatively near future is not an out-of-the-blue flight of fancy on the part of random HN commenters; a UN panel in 2019 warned of this possibility, as did a 2020 IPCC report (pre-pandemic, no less), as did a 2016 study in the Lancet; this is just from a cursory examination of the Google results for "food shortage predictions global warming".

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by mr_toad on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:10PM (#24937199)
> Aggregate data is much more relevant than anecdotes.

Extrapolation of historic data trends isn’t always a good way to predict the future either.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by pixl97 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:45PM (#24937459)
Dinosaurs reigned for over 100 million years. Until they suddenly didn't.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:49AM (#24939285)
The world's poor are the victims of famines, yet the GP was worried about food riots for themselves personally. If they live in a developed country, that is ridiculous. If there's global famine, they'll simply use their money to buy food for themselves, pushing the price up so poor Africans can't afford it. That's what we did during the 2008 food price crisis.
[dead]
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ojnabieoot on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:15PM (#24934414)
> scared you into not fulfilling the genetic imperative, ending your own genetic line

> It's always a shame when an intelligent person chooses to ignore the sacrifice every one of their ancestors made to bring them to this point

Ok please don’t project your creepy literal-Darwinist ideology on other people. The parent comment literally said “one of many reasons.” I am not having kids because my “genetic imperative” is about the species itself, not my specific genes, and I sincerely don’t care about whether or not the Ojnabieoot Dynasty makes it to 2100. The idea that I’m “ignoring the sacrifices of my ancestors” is idiotic and unnecessarily insulting.

> to know that generations of people eked by just for you to play video games all day would be a truly disappointing conclusion.

Seriously what in the world is your problem? You don’t know anything about this person. This comment is pure toxicity, completely undermines the point I think you are trying to make, and adds nothing to the conversation.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by core-questions on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:58PM (#24934977)
> Ok please don’t project your creepy literal-Darwinist ideology on other people.

"Darwinism" is an "ideology" now? I thought believing in evolution was actually in-vogue! Do you actually not think intelligence is heritable, despite every study into the subject confirming that, as one of the most-reproducible pieces of social science research? Do you think we'll be better off if the smart people live lives of hedonism while only people who aren't as Climate Enlightened produce all the children?

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ojnabieoot on Thursday October 29, 2020 @04:07PM (#24935096)
No, the ideology is using an idiotic personification of Darwinism as a guideline for major life decisions like “do I want kids.”

I am not engaging with your blatant eugenics and ignorant Redditor’s understanding of intelligence and heritability. Needless to say, two commenters who don’t want kids does not mean that the unwashed hordes of dumb dumbs are going to take us over.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hluska on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:03PM (#24935856)
With all due respect, you long abandoned reason and now you’re just being an asshole. Someone decided not to reproduce - your opinions are of no value to their body.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chr1 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:56PM (#24937096)
From the evolutionary point of view, if some people are susceptible to believing in harmful ideologies that lead them to die off, maybe it's better to let them to die off instead of spreading their mind-virus further. There are many smart people who have many children like Elon Musk, Antony Davies or Kirk Sorenson.

Edit: some people interpret this as saying that not wanting children is a genetic trait, but what i was trying to say was that it's a counterproductive idea which will eventually burn itself out, and there are many smart people who are not suffering from it. So we won't run out of smart people.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ojnabieoot on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:16PM (#24937241)
The idea that susceptibility to dumb ideologies is a genetic weakness that “smarter” people are not susceptible to is completely at odds with current anthropological and sociological knowledge - ideology is part of the human condition, and being unable to determine whether or not your ideology is dangerous bullshit is part of the nature of ideology. Teichmuller, Nazi Germany’s greatest mathematician, was also an anti-Semitic loon.

Your comment about “smart people will have lots of kids who will save us” [paraphrasing] is ironically invalidated by Elon Musk himself, whose COVID tweeting and commentary is pure fact-free ideology (most infamously here: https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/12407546572631449... but he’s still going: https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-and-kids-wont-get-...) It is worth emphasizing that these comments are just straight-up indefensibly dumb.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chr1 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:57PM (#24937565)
I was not saying that the idea of not having children is genetically determined. (There might be some genetical component related to being susceptible to depressions, but that's not the point).

I was trying to say, that the idea itself is often passed to children, via non-genetic means, and it will burn out the part of population bearing it.

But that's not fatal for humanity because there are many smart people who have multiple children, so independently of exact percentage of heritability of intellect we are not doomed.

And regarding to the snide comment about Elon, independently of his opinions on any issues, he have done enough to prove that he is smarter and vastly more useful to humanity than average people.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ojnabieoot on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:25PM (#24938160)
My point was that smart people like Elon are fully capable of believing suicidally stupid things.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by CalRobert on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:03PM (#24934248)
If you knew their life would be misery and toil, would you have kids? I'm terrified for mine.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by bambataa on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:11PM (#24934357)
This is something I think about a lot. The most important is to keep things going. Our descendants might have terrible lives for a thousand generations and it would be worth it if it means humanity can get to better times on the other side. The only reason we’ve had all this wealth and ease to squander is because of those who went before us.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by petercooper on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:35PM (#24936245)
I am hugely optimistic about humanity and technology and believe we will get through this just fine. I say this to qualify my question here:

Our descendants might have terrible lives for a thousand generations and it would be worth it if it means humanity can get to better times on the other side.

Would it be worth it? There is likely no net loss for the universe if we or even the entire Earth disappeared overnight and that might be better than thousands of generations suffering painfully over thousands of years.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by bambataa on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:24PM (#24936826)
Are you happy to be alive, knowing that untold ancestors lived comparatively short and brutish lives
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by petercooper on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:50PM (#24937943)
I have sorrow and compassion for all humans who have had a hard life, but I don't feel any obligations either to or from my ancestors.

I was questioning your assertion that centuries of "terrible lives" (which, to me, seems a regression for most) would be an acceptable price to pay for "better times" later on. Compared to the past 1000 years where life has, in the main, improved gradually generation after generation, I feel this assertion at least deserves to be questioned.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lopmotr on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:48AM (#24939538)
Terrible life is always better than no life because the person living it has the choice to kill themselves. If it lasts 1000s of generations, then obviously they will have chosen life, so it's worth giving it to them.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by aesclepius on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:49PM (#24937493)
In the immortal words of the GOP, "Fuck you, got mine."*

*But no not necessarily, but at the same time I had a lack of autonomy in regards to those decision made.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chr1 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:43PM (#24936990)
Why do you think suffering is worse than not existing? If they find their suffering to be unbearable they can end their lives, But unlike us they will have more information to make such a decision. With suffering they have a chance to at least achieve something, so we should not be ones deciding to discard their lives.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by petercooper on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:00PM (#24938011)
If I have two children and do not wish to have a third, should I feel any guilt for the hypothetical "discarded" child's inability to experience life? I contend that as they will never exist, I have no obligation towards them.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chr1 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:37PM (#24938212)
If you have resources to support the third child, and you chose to not spend them on the child, you should feel some guilt for slowing down the progress of humanity. There is limited time until a meteorite hits the earth, or CO2 runs out, or some other life ending event happens on earth, and the more people live until that, the more possibilities we will be able to explore leading to higher likelihood that we discover new science and art increasing liveable space and improving everyone's life.

If you look at the history, every discovery was made due to very rare and specific combination of factors, and the only way to create such combinations is by trying many life paths in parallel.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by webmaven on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:25PM (#24938826)
> If you have resources to support the third child, and you chose to not spend them on the child, you should feel some guilt for slowing down the progress of humanity.

Perhaps concentrating attention on two children makes it that much more likely that they will have longer, fulfilling lives, and grace us with their eventual wisdom, rather than all three grubbing in the rubble of a collapsed civilization.

Sure, the odds of either path don't change much based on the single decision of whether to have another child, but every little bit helps, right?

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by everdrive on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:59AM (#24941730)
Some billions of sperm would like a word with you.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chr1 on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:40PM (#24944824)
Any cell can become a human if it is placed in a favorable environment. My argument is not about intrinsic value of sperm cell, fetus, or a newborn, my argument is about maximizing the amount of life in general. Every human alive by simply pursuing his own selfish goals, makes lives of everyone else better, by increasing the usefulness of research.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dogecoinbase on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:56PM (#24937542)
There is no other side. We've used all of the easily-accessible high-energy-density resources on the planet -- once technology drops below the critical level necessary to produce wind/solar/hydro/nuclear, we'll never be able to recover a high-energy society. We'll never get off the earth, let alone out of the solar system. And even if we waited millions of years, bacteria has learned to digest lignin, so there will never be another Carboniferous Period.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by saiya-jin on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:02PM (#24936626)
Imagine medieval peasant, which was most of the population ever. What they would give to live our lives! Toil? Are you kidding me? We have it better than some 120 billion human being before us. Concepts like basic freedom, education, healthcare were not a right that most ever had.

Watching half of your kids die before age of 5 from something a set of pills cures now? Your wife risking her life with every delivery? Dying of very minor wounds, when flu is killer that covid can only dream about?

I could go on like that for very long time... No, our life isn't a misery and toil in any western society, unless we make mistakes and chose such a path. My isn't for example, nor is most people I know.

Its kind of sad to see how weak we have become. 100 years ago a mutated flu killed 100 million people which was significant chunk of global population, right after the most horrible war mankind has ever experienced, and people got through. We can get through almost anything. Its properly sad what's happening. As a nature, travel and adventure lover my heart weeps, but I have no doubt mankind will get through this. There is still so much beauty out there. I am not naive anymore we will get much wiser while getting through this, but somehow we will manage. Till then, taking it day by day, enjoying the little things life so often gives us, enjoying friends and family... that's still a great life to live. Only few in the history had such a luck. I am definitely not terrified for my kids.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by sedachv on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:38PM (#24938898)
> Imagine medieval peasant, which was most of the population ever.

Maybe instead of using your imagination and whatever garbage you saw in a Hollywood movie, you can read accounts of how native people lived in places like North America up until a few hundred years ago.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by korantu on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:32AM (#24939464)
I think you missed the point where majority of people now having access to things that were not invented/widely awailable as recent as beginning of last century. It is not specific to a place
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by core-questions on Thursday October 29, 2020 @04:00PM (#24934991)
Everyone's life is some variety of misery and toil. I'm not especially worried for my children because spending time on worry is illogical and counterproductive - sure, things could go badly, but as long as I am always doing everything in my power to ensure my children do well, I can rest with an easy conscience no matter what happens.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by Johnjonjoan on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:18PM (#24936042)
>sure, things could go badly, but as long as I am always doing everything in my power to ensure my children do well, I can rest with an easy conscience no matter what happens.

Sad. Sorry to hear it. It's always a shame when an intelligent person chooses to ignore the sacrifice every one of their descendents will make, just so that they don't have to risk the potential of having any hardship themselves.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chipotle_coyote on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:42PM (#24936978)
[edited to note that I missed this was ironically reframing words back to the first commenter, which zaps my grump out of the water. Sorry!] Interpreting "I am always doing everything in my power to ensure my children do well" as "you won't risk having the potential of any hardship yourself" is startlingly ungenerous.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by Johnjonjoan on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:48PM (#24937037)
Did you read the previous comments?

I wrote two (I think) of the words in my comment, the rest were written by the person I was replying to about someone deciding not to have children.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by chipotle_coyote on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:57PM (#24937559)
Apparently I did not read back far enough! (And now can't, ironically, because I'm pretty sure the first comment that started it off is flagged.) Grumpy parent comment retracted.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by mpfundstein on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:07PM (#24936667)
when was the last time you experienced true joy?
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by Johnjonjoan on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:42PM (#24936981)
Ironically enough, when I was writing that comment. If you read the comment chain you'll realise why.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by jimbokun on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:24PM (#24938158)
A lot less misery and toil than almost everyone that came before them.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by tluyben2 on Friday October 30, 2020 @02:36AM (#24939731)
How do you know? We have 80 years to go in this century: there is no war yet but we have the covid pandemic, inequality, mental health issues ‘pandemic’, obesity/diabetes ‘pandemic’, rapid climate change.

We now close our eyes to stuff that does not bother us directly like devastating destruction of the amazon, attacks on armenia, several dictators using covid to assert unlimited powers etc, all of which would deserve global military intervention imho and thus wars, but do not, makes it a matter of who you ask if this is ‘worse or better’.

Agreed, over all it is better for ‘everyone’ but we have a solid 80 years to mess this up and turn the tables. Hope we do not but I for one do not think it looks good; this state is fragile, not robust.

We have the money and technology this time around to prevent things, but not sure if we will. Handling of Covid and the many dictators, racism, immigration issues etc are not good signs we learned much from 100 years ago. Covid being the most obvious (spanish flu followed the same curve); let’s see how the rightwing/populist will be handled in the coming 10 years to see if we even can learn.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by creata on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:22PM (#24934505)
It's nice that we have you to interpret the actions of our ancestors.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by raziel2701 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:14PM (#24934401)
Well he/she is not alone. Birth rates are falling because people don't feel secure in their future. I can't think of a single thing that makes me hopeful about the future. Stagnant salaries, stagnant economy, weak global leadership, rising nationalism and sectarianism, climate change, increasing wealth inequality, people don't agree on basic reality (masks, climate change) and no where in our political spectrum do we see glimmers of hope of someone having a vision for what is the right thing to do.

I think we are about to see a huge insolvency event in the next few years that will further destabilize the economy on top of everything. A huge demographic shift is coming with the boomers retiring, and damn, they're getting out at just the right moment as we inherit the problems they started and/or ignored for decades. If you are in your 30s or younger, we are the world's biggest suckers.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by catawbasam on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:16PM (#24936010)
I think you are too pessimistic. This year is bad, but most recent years have been much better. And in most places on Earth, the new generation will have a better life than the last one.