News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Communitivity on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:55AM (#24754951)
We should be careful to draw a causal relationship here. It might not be that getting the military equipment causes police to be more aggressive and therefore have more killings.

It might instead be that the more aggressive police departments are the ones that more seek to purchase military equipment, and the more aggressive police are the ones with more killings. I tend to think that's the case.

Regardless, there is no need, ever, for police to have the automatic weapons, APCs, and "non-lethal" weapons they are buying from the military. If they are facing an opponent like that then call in the FBI, who generally have much better training, or ATF (no idea about their training).

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tomschlick on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:20PM (#24756040)
> Regardless, there is no need, ever, for police to have the automatic weapons, APCs, and "non-lethal" weapons they are buying from the military.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Hollywood_shootout is the catalyst for all of this. Police were heavily outgunned. The FBI would take hours to get there as FBI tactical teams are not in most cities and are not on call like normal SWAT teams are. APCs are purely defensive. Its effectively a Brinks armored money truck, but instead of money it carries people to/from gunfire safely.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by slg on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:25PM (#24756862)
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Hollywood_shootout is the catalyst for all of this. Police were heavily outgunned.

And yet the only two people who died were the two bank robbers. It sounds like the police were able to eventually take control of the situation even while heavily outgunned. So does adding more firepower on the side of police actually provide more safety when this is an example of the worst case scenario?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by alisonkisk on Monday October 12, 2020 @08:21PM (#24761042)
Seems unlikely, since 1033 started 7 years earlier, in tandem with the military buildup for Operation Desert Storm.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by erik_seaberg on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:52PM (#24757235)
That was two guys on foot whose objective was only to escape. There are many worse scenarios than that.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ceejayoz on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:21PM (#24757623)
> There are many worse scenarios than that.

Then why aren't they the "here's why we need an APC" argument? Or are they largely theoretical?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:27PM (#24757696)
I think most are a third option; not theoretical, but neither occurring in America. Consider something like the 2008 Mumbai attacks in which 10 men with rifles and explosives terrorized an entire city causing hundreds of casualties. Is there any particular reason to think such a thing couldn't happen in America, where rifles and explosives aren't hard to get?

Against that sort of threat, I think the police having a few armored vehicles makes sense.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by BelleOfTheBall on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:02PM (#24758108)
> Is there any particular reason to think such a thing couldn't happen in America, where rifles and explosives aren't hard to get?

Is there any particular reason why a clear edge-case scenario should be our basis for arming police departments, which spend most of their time solving mundane domestic disputes, pulling apart drunken fights and responding to break-ins where someone's Playstation was stolen? We should orient policing towards deescalation based on what they usually face. If their most common problem is a drug addict high on PCP, they don't need a gun, they need proper training and, perhaps, a taser.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:29PM (#24758434)
I think the biggest problem with these vehicles is the aesthetics and the mindset they attract. But in this regard, those armoured vehicles are only a small part of the problem. Their dark uniforms should be replaced with light uniforms. Replace black and dark blue uniforms with baby blue, white or 'day-glo' neons. Do the same to their guns (white plastic 'furniture' where possible), cars, and armoured vehicles. It doesn't particularly bother me that they own armored vehicles (given the armed nature of the American public), but those vehicles should be repainted to look uncool to the sort of person who fetishizes military hardware and edgy 'punisher'/'tacticool' aesthetics.

Basically, make the cops look less like the US Marines and more like UN peacekeepers (specifically their white vehicles.)

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by btgeekboy on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:51PM (#24759301)
In other words, you want more WA State Patrol (white cars, light blue uniforms) than Seattle PD (navy blue for both), it seems. Though I recall the move to the navy blue uniforms in Seattle was for cost reasons - their old baby blue uniforms were custom, so they cost more.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:44PM (#24760337)
Yes basically, though I would like to see these sort of aesthetic changes across the board, not just to uniforms. The uniforms and the rest of their equipment should convey peaceful professionalism, not macho militarism.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:54PM (#24761517)
Some of the black on the metal hardware comes from coatings to prevent rust and other corrosion, not to look cool. Custom colored coatings (cerakote I guess if you want light blue) would be much more expensive. It’s not just simply painted black. The other hardware that is painted is done for camouflage, and I’m betting the vehicles were sand colored when they got them as a black APC is gonna stand out real well in the desert.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:07PM (#24771348)
I'm aware that black metal components often have a protective black oxide layer. In another post in this thread I mention that the plastic 'furniture' could be made white at least. And in common police firearms, namely glocks, that's most of the gun that could be recovered. I don't think the Glock company offers such guns presently, but if there were widespread police aesthetic reforms I don't think supply would necessarily be a problem.

As for camouflage, I think police should be forbidden from using it. If a bank robber needs to be ambushed from the bushes in some sort of 'Bonnie and Clyde' scenario, let the beat police call in specialists. These armoured vehicles don't need camo in the likely scenarios in which they'd ever be used, particularly since the entire premise of such vehicles in a police role is that they'd be impervious to the small arm fire they might encounter. In a military role they might get hit by an RPG, but such anti-armour weapons are exceedingly unlikely to be relevant to police.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:39AM (#24775429)
I’m still failing to see how this will solve anything, as you’ve yet to explain why you’re scared of the color black. GLOCKS come in a few different colors of frames, but not white and the frames are made from nylon, not plastic, and you’ve still increased the cost of manufacture because of fear of a color.

SWAT teams need camouflage so they can park vehicles and stage raids at night or early dawn without announcing their presence.

Why did you decide all cops are bad and start a war against them?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by brigandish on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:03PM (#24759964)
You protect yourself from edge cases all the time, ever put on a seatbelt?

Risk is the chance of something happening coupled with the effect it would have. Perhaps the police should not be the ones protecting the public from a Mumbai style attack - possibly it should be the military - but it should be someone because of the grave consequences.

That does not have any link to whether police should routinely use de-escalation techniques (which they should).

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ceejayoz on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:32PM (#24760224)
There are hundreds of thousands of car accidents in the USA annually.

There has never been a Mumbai-style terror attack, and the National Guard could be activated for such a thing.

Some edge cases deserve more addressing than others.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by brigandish on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:10PM (#24761590)
> Some edge cases deserve more addressing than others.

Not only is no one arguing different, the "hundreds of thousands of car accidents in the USA annually" has been addressed (in several ways). Perhaps other problems may also be addressed?

> There has never been a Mumbai-style terror attack

No, only in most (if not all) of the other G8 countries, but have they had a Pulse nightclub attack or planes flown into buildings? How many have had a Bataclan or a London Bridge style attack?

Let's not split hairs.

> the National Guard could be activated for such a thing

Well, I did suggest “possibly it should be the military” so the National Guard, being part of the military, would fit.

In short, an edge case being rare does not imply that it should not be prepared for. What's the response time for the National Guard if terrorists start attacking people in the street?

Edit: typo

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:12PM (#24771393)
> What's the response time for the National Guard if terrorists start attacking people in the street?

'Hours' would probably be quick, since you'd probably need to get the governor's approval first.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:55PM (#24761523)
What about SWAT teams?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by BelleOfTheBall on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:57AM (#24763951)
This is a false equivalency. Putting on a seatbelt poses no danger and requires no effort. Giving police military-grade vehicles and weapons, on the other hand, costs money and isn't safe, considering their track record.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by brigandish on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:59AM (#24765586)
That you find a property or trait that is different between them does not make them a false equivalence. The comparison is about:

a) whether they are edge cases, which they are in terms of occurrence b) risk, which are comparable on a personal level

Additionally, when seat belt laws were introduced there were arguments about whether it was a moral hazard. Their requiring some effort (try strapping in a small child) and considerable danger to some (again, children, and pregnant women) was not relevant to that (ultimately wrong) argument and it's not relevant here either.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by slg on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:58PM (#24758063)
>Is there any particular reason to think such a thing couldn't happen in America

I don't think this is the right question to ask. There are a lot of things that one can reasonably think could happen in America. Do we need to prepare every police department in the country for all those situations regardless of the odds of the worst happening? Do the costs, both literal monetary costs and the harder to measure societal costs, of militarizing our police departments outweigh the potential that an increase in police firepower will allow them to save lives in this extremely remote possibility actually happens? Maybe we are just better off leaving some of these extreme outliers as something to be dealt with by the military if it ever happens here.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by CydeWeys on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:12PM (#24758927)
It's a good point. Our largest and most targeted cities (e.g. NYC, DC) absolutely should have dedicated heavy weapons troops on call to respond in real time to a terrorist attack. Their equipment and training should be separate from workaday policing.

Then most of the rest of the country just needs normal policing, because realistically, they're so unlikely to be a target. Look at all the big terrorist attacks that have happened in the past several decades. They've targeted huge international cities: DC, NYC, London, Paris, Mumbai. These are the kinds of targets (and the only kinds of targets) that plausibly need military-level policing on stand-by 24/7.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by kelnos on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:24PM (#24759057)
> Our largest and most targeted cities (e.g. NYC, DC) absolutely should have dedicated heavy weapons troops on call to respond in real time to a terrorist attack.

Absolutely not. The military does not handle issues like this on US soil. (If you meant something else by "troops", please choose your words more carefully.)

I have zero confidence that, with such a force on standby all the time, departments will resist using that force for more mundane matters until it becomes routine.

> They've targeted huge international cities: DC, NYC, London, Paris, Mumbai. These are the kinds of targets (and the only kinds of targets) that plausibly need military-level policing on stand-by 24/7.

Would "military-level policing" have actually helped in any of these terrorist attacks? I fail to see how a tricked-out army would have stopped 9/11. I did a quick search for "terrorist attacks in washington dc", and nothing really came up, except for some theoretical worries and a few foiled plots, which clearly did not need "military-level policing" to deal with.

I'm really tired of how "oh my, terrorists!" is used as an excuse for domestic militarization and draconian domestic policy. The threat of terrorism in the US is hugely overblown, and traditional policing at the local and federal level is what we need to handle these sorts of things, by catching them during the planning phases. And with most terrorist attacks, if you get to a point where there's an active attack, it's too late to do all that much that's meaningful, and bringing in militarized units has just as much potential to make the situation worse. Sure, there are exceptions, but not enough to warrant militarized police on call 24/7.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by CydeWeys on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:56PM (#24759348)
Yes, I meant militarized police by "troops", exactly what the article is talking about. Though here in NYC I do routinely see heavily armed actual troops (they might be National Guard? not sure), at Penn Station, Grand Central, and airports.

No, I'm not referring to 9/11. However, over the past several decades, there have been several attempted/successful terrorist attacks by people on the ground. At some point you do need someone heavily armed enough to take out an active ongoing attack, like what we saw in Mumbai or Paris. The odds of it happening again within the next decade are not that small. Do you really do nothing to even try to be ready to respond to it? I just don't think most voters are going to be willing to accept it.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by thaumasiotes on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:51PM (#24759305)
> Absolutely not. The military does not handle issues like this on US soil.

In what sense are the police not military?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:56PM (#24760456)
In the literal sense. Police like to blur the line by calling everybody else 'civilians', but they are civilians too.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:55AM (#24764642)
Just like military are also civilians? Your comment makes no sense, what should they call themselves?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by CydeWeys on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:56AM (#24765559)
There is no definition of the word "civilian" under which members of the military qualify.

> Under international humanitarian law, civilians are "persons who are not members of the armed forces" and are not "combatants if they [don't] carry arms openly and respect the laws and customs of war".

(from Wikipedia)

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @12:37PM (#24767192)
Sure, now next step is to determine if a military member in civilian clothes is considered military or civilian. Speaking from first hand experience we call ourselves civilians then.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:10PM (#24771379)
Soldiers are not civilians.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:23AM (#24775350)
Read my reply literally above yours.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ceejayoz on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:53PM (#24759876)
Police exist (in theory) to enforce law. The military does not.

Edge cases like MPs and the Coast Guard exist, and some countries blur the line more than others. The Paris fire department, for example, is a military branch for historical reasons.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by thaumasiotes on Monday October 12, 2020 @07:29PM (#24760704)
The military also exists to enforce law.

The police are in exactly the same business as the military, enforcing compliance through violence. Using a different word doesn't make them a different thing.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tomnipotent on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:25PM (#24761376)
> The military also exists to enforce law.

No it doesn't. It exists to protect national interests. The rare exemption is when a state decides to deploy the Army National Guard or Coast Guard. The Posse Comitatus Act is very specific about this, and the U.S. Army Military Police Corps were slapped with administrative actions for violating the act when they intervened in murder spree in Alabama.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by thaumasiotes on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:16PM (#24761905)
> No it doesn't. It exists to protect national interests.

This is meaningless, and to the degree that it has meaning, ridiculously overbroad. Almost all activities that "protect national interests" are not military. The definition you purport to provide here does not distinguish the military from anything else.

What actually defines the military is that it achieves its goals through the use of violence. And the police belong in this category too; there isn't a difference. Saying the police are not military purely because they wear a label saying "the third amendment doesn't apply to us, for reasons that will make sense if we beat you enough" would be the same error as saying that a newspaper didn't enjoy freedom of "the press" if it published online (and therefore didn't use a printing press).

Actually, it would be more like saying that the New York Times didn't enjoy freedom of "the press" because they're "the Times", not "the press".

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:54AM (#24764635)
Except the police lack a lot of the training that would be useless in urban environments. Your average cop is also trained with a handgun as their primary, instead of a rifle as primary and handgun as secondary. Your average military personnel is more fit than your average cop as well. Not to mention the military doesn’t have jurisdiction inside the US to enforce laws. If you believe they are the same then how come military cannot arrest you (ignoring MPs near or on bases)?

Using your logic I can prove many different things that are pretty silly. For instance, since a gun can be used to kill people, and so can a pillow, the pillow must be an “assault weapon”.

I have a question for you, have you ever needed the police for anything?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by CydeWeys on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:55AM (#24765553)
> Your average cop is also trained with a handgun as their primary, instead of a rifle as primary and handgun as secondary.

For what it's worth, your average soldier isn't equipped with a handgun at all, and as such, handgun training is minimal to non-existent. Your average soldier is more likely to need to know how to operate the squad's crew-served machine gun, a grenade launcher, or a door-busting shotgun, so to the extent that there is cross-training, it'll focus more on that kinda stuff.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @12:51PM (#24767354)
You’re right there, my comment was more in line with the primary rather than secondaries.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:56PM (#24761527)
So then these centers will be known and avoided by terrorists.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by CydeWeys on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:56AM (#24765561)
Good?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @12:39PM (#24767215)
So then they divert to the less guarded areas. So no, bad.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by throwaway0a5e on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:28PM (#24758418)
In the time it takes for an APC to show up some beat cop the rampage will be over. They will either run out of ammo and detonate suicide vests or someone will have managed to shoot the threat. An APC is of no use except when you know where and when you want it and those situations tend to not be the kinds of situations we want civilian police engaging in.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:33PM (#24758492)
The 2008 attack in Mumbai lasted numerous days.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by kelnos on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:29PM (#24759101)
You are picking one particular attack and are attempting to use that single, outlying instance to argue for things that will not be necessary in the 99% case.

And the problem with military gear -- as we're currently seeing, plain as the day -- is that cops will not just save it for the truly dire situations; they'll use it more and more until it becomes a part of routine operations.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:52PM (#24760415)
There have been numerous attacks like that in other countries, some far more extreme. I chose a single example to illustrate my point, but that doesn't mean a single example is all that exists.

Anyway, the cops aren't using these armored vehicles to kill people, they primarily do that with guns. It isn't the use of these vehicles that concerns me, but rather the role these vehicles play in recruiting macho edgelords to be cops (the sort prone to shooting people with guns.) To address this, I would like all their vehicles to be repainted, uniforms redesigned, etc. Aesthetics matter, it influences the sort of person drawn to the job. A police force with a particularly militarized aesthetic will attract men who want to LARP as occupying forces in Baghdad.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:57AM (#24764663)
Or we can just do psych evals and stop this nonsense about things “looking” aggressive. You know what they DIDN’T do when designing the APC? Find ways to make it look more “tacticool”
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:15PM (#24771415)
Pysch evals are not mutually exclusive with repainting the vehicles. The aesthetic intent of the vehicle designers is irrelevant.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:23AM (#24775346)
But you’re running around saying it makes people crazy and militaristic by it’s looks alone, so it is relevant. Let’s discuss the looks of it because why are you scared of an inanimate object.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ceejayoz on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:57PM (#24758775)
Are you under the impression the Indian Army doesn't have APCs etc., then?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:00PM (#24758797)
I am not. I am refuting the assumption that a coordinated terrorist attack would play out quickly. Even if the responding police/military are well equipped it remains possible that a terrorist attack could last for several days.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:00PM (#24761538)
Do we really need to pull up instances of when police use APCs to insert SWAT teams? It’s very easy to find and pretty well common knowledge if you look.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by nitrogen on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:52PM (#24757987)
Is there any particular reason to think such a thing couldn't happen in America, where rifles and explosives aren't hard to get?

Mainly because gurs in general aren't hard to get in America. Any would-be shooter has to fear not only cops, but armed civilians. And if they are spanning an entire city and the police aren't able to keep up, you'd definitely get recreational hunters with their rifles trying to take them down.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by bigbubba on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:36PM (#24758528)
Maybe in a city like Dallas (I'm aware of the Charles Whitman case), but how many rifle-toting vigilantes could you really count on in San Francisco?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Steltek on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:26PM (#24756868)
APCs are not "purely defensive". They're an intimidating presence which is by itself, a type of force. On top of that, it's becoming "a thing" to use vehicles to run over people you disagree with.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by yeetawayhn on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:33PM (#24756950)
>APCs are not "purely defensive". They're an intimidating presence

In that case, they can paint them pink.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by darkerside on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:37PM (#24757017)
But they won't. Because they wouldn't look intimidating.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:02PM (#24761548)
Yet they paint them tan when in military use. Honest question, why do you think black = intimidating?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by darkerside on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:44PM (#24770670)
Is that a challenge or an honest question, I really can't tell?

If it's a question, probably because of its association with night and darkness, and it's contrast with bright colors.

If it's a challenge, give me a basis because you're fighting common sense. I'm not here to convince you that black is intimidating in a way that pink is not.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:25AM (#24775369)
It’s more of a wake up call, you’re calling a color intimidating. A color. Chase that mental rabbit whole for a minute to find out why.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by gravy on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:58AM (#24778111)
The only person doing this mental chase here is you. Why don't you just come out and say what you mean?

If you're really this confrontational about "the color" black being tied to darkness since pre-history (not much of a stretch there) and the significance of darkness being the physical manifestation of something like "evil" (also since pre-history) EDIT: and why "evil" is "intimidating", then nobody should take your contributions to this discussion seriously.

EDIT: I just don't understand how your response of "if black is intimidating, why do they paint them tan for military use" is in any way an honest argument. Did you simply not even think of camouflage? There are more important tactical advantages in warfare than intimidation. And now I feel like I did the job that darkserside was trying to avoid.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:59PM (#24783596)
Nope, you see I’ve been on the black isn’t evil argument for a while because I own various black colored guns. It’s a pretty common argument to say the black guns are scary yet nobody can explain why. So again, why do you think black makes it scary or intimidating?

I have, in fact if you see my replies to others you’ll see me point out that very thing. But people are going around saying the goal of painting it black is to be intimidating. If that were true then why doesn’t the military use the same tactic when they do want to look intimidating? This would imply it’s used for camo, like you said.

It’s not a race thing, don’t take it there because I most definitely am not.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by darkerside on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @09:52PM (#24783936)
Thank you, and I'm sorry!
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:59AM (#24787637)
No I’m sorry. We still don’t have a reason why grown adults are scared of a color and we can’t even talk about it without it becoming a race thing. What a world the democrats have made.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by darkerside on Thursday October 15, 2020 @01:47PM (#24791458)
I didn't make it a race thing. With all due respect, which is very little based on your comportment in this discussion, kindly find another community to flame.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Friday October 16, 2020 @07:25AM (#24799678)
what exactly are you talking about? Read. nobody but you two are making it a race thing. It’s a simple question, why does the color black make something look intimidating. You said it first and now you’re trying to make it a race thing to avoid explaining why the color black is scary on a gun. If you can answer a non racial question about a color then perhaps you should grow up?

Let’s make this real simple for you two what makes a black gun more scary or dangerous than one painted pastel? A rational human would say there’s no difference. A gun is a gun. But you have a certain class of people claiming very interesting and dangerous things about the looks of items. It has nothing to do with color, nobody is overtly calling you a racist, it’s a question to find out why you think the way you do because maybe public education on why guns are black is warranted.

[dead]
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by mjayhn on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:24PM (#24757652)
> You people

Us citizens?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:04AM (#24764725)
Not all US citizens are complaining about them, just those who don’t understand what they are and what they’re used for.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by yeetawayhn on Friday October 16, 2020 @12:29PM (#24802382)
No, professional complainers.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tomschlick on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:44PM (#24757115)
You shouldn't get rid of a vital tool in a riot or active shooter situation because they look scary to you. And I have yet to see anyone use an MRAP/Bearcat to run over anyone (though I have seen quite a few patrol cars hit active shooters - quite justifiably)
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by justinclift on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:24PM (#24757658)
> APCs are purely defensive.

Many APC's seem to have significantly powerful weaponry, compared to civilian/infantry weapons anyway:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armoured_personnel_carrier

  In Western nations, APCs are frequently armed with the .50 
  calibre M2 Browning machine gun, 7.62mm FN MAG, or 40mm Mk 
  19 grenade launcher. In former Eastern bloc nations, the
  KPV, PKT and NSV machine guns are common options.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tomschlick on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:32PM (#24757764)
You're looking at actual APCs. OP was saying APC but police actually get the MRAP varients similar to the Lenco Bearcats that they buy. Those have no offensive weapons. Its just armor and bullet resistant glass on a heavy truck frame. Thats it.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by justinclift on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:33AM (#24764501)
Thanks, that does make a difference. :)
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ardy42 on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:14PM (#24759514)
> Police were heavily outgunned.

I believe the problem wasn't so much that they were "outgunned," but that they lacked longer range weapons of any kind. So that problem could be entirely solved by issuing some fraction of officers hunting rifles to carry in their patrol car's trunk. No need to kit them out like infantry or give them APCs.

The police's advantage in numbers and organization would take care of almost any other disadvantage WRT weaponry.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by pedalpete on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:05PM (#24761568)
The robbers were head-to-toe in kevlar and had armor piercing bullets, the police didn't.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ardy42 on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:18PM (#24761921)
> The robbers were head-to-toe in kevlar and had armor piercing bullets, the police didn't.

No, that's not true. They didn't have head to toe armor, but they were armored where the police where trained to shoot:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Hollywood_shootout#Death...:

> After retrieving [a pistol that had been shot out of his hand], [Phillips] placed the muzzle under his chin and fired; he was simultaneously shot by a bullet fired by Officer John Caprarelli that severed his spine.....

> Later reports showed that Mătăsăreanu was shot 29 times in the legs and died from trauma due to excessive blood loss coming from two gunshot wounds in his left thigh.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Hollywood_shootout#Weapo...:

> Following their training, the responding patrol officers directed their fire at the "center of mass", or torsos, of Mătăsăreanu and Phillips. However, aramid body armor worn by Phillips and Mătăsăreanu covered all of their vitals (except their heads), enabling them to absorb pistol bullets and shotgun pellets, while Mătăsăreanu's chest armor, thanks to a metal trauma plate, successfully withstood a hit from a SWAT officer's AR-15.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tekknik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:14AM (#24764814)
What are you asking for here? Take a headshot? You can disable someone with leg shots, it takes time as per your own evidence. Depending on how the armored perp is standing there may not be a gap. Then trying to hit such a small target with any kind of range will be very difficult for most. And you best believe if a SWAT officer had a lethal shot with an AR they would’ve taken it. So what makes you think the unarmored opportunity presented itself prior to the it did moment?

Also why are you questioning police owning an APC but it civilians owning body armor, which is most definitely legal.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Communitivity on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @10:59AM (#24766192)
Your point about the FBI taking time and not being on call is good. New procedures and Memorandums of Understanding (MOUs) would need to be put in place, i.e. politics. But there are more tactical teams than people realize. The FBI openly admits that the FBI maintains SWAT teams at each of its 56 field offices throughout the country[1]. The field offices are distributed ideally, so they'd probably need additional field offices. For example, there are two in VA and two in PA, but none in WV. The reason I am so for the FBI doing this is that they watch their people much more closely, and have a higher psych bar to entry.

Also, regarding distance for the North Hollywood incident, the FBI's LA Field Office is at 11000 Wilshire Blvd, along with our their office in Los Angeles, they have 10 satellite offices, known as resident agencies, in the area. The estimated travel time for the CIRG from the field office to incident site is 22 minutes by car. That doesn't count using sirens/lights, or using a helo. The problem was likely being asked to participate, and getting approval to participate. As with many things at scale, tactical or techie, politics is more often a root cause than a technical issue.

[1] "Critical Incident Response Group (CIRG)". Federal Bureau of Investigation. Retrieved 15 August 2020. https://www.fbi.gov/services/cirg

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by JKCalhoun on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:31PM (#24756928)
That sounds legit, but OP mentioned automatic weapons purchased from the military as well. Definitely not purely defensive of course.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by vorpalhex on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:32PM (#24759129)
No but a used beater M4 is a whole lot cheaper than a new Mk18 or a new M4 and it's probably been maintained by military armorers it's entire lifespan.

Though yes, the military firearms tend to be select fire. Probably not a useful feature for police but I can't imagine they use it with any frequency.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by e40 on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:28PM (#24759628)
is the catalyst for all of this

I think excuse is the word you're looking for. As someone else pointed out, the 2 people that died were the robbers.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by justinclift on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:35AM (#24764512)
Several civilians and police officers were also injured though. :(

It's not just deaths that count.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by dragonwriter on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:24PM (#24761958)
> APCs are purely defensive

Er, no, they aren't. They are mostly offensive, since the point of them is to allow infantry to more effectively conduct offensive maneuvering in the presence of automatic weapons fire rather than being pinned down in static defensive positions.

Military technology is almost never purely defensive.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Gibbon1 on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:26PM (#24757677)
Notable though your using as evidence a law enforcement action that rates it's own Wikipedia entry.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Symmetry on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:40AM (#24755555)
Yeah, I wouldn't bet on it being causal though I could make a plausible story that police departments that put dangerous looking military equipment in their recruitment videos tend to attract the wrong sort of people.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by 13415 on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:28PM (#24757711)
For a start, they should probably train police for two to four years like in other countries, instead of just a few months.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Symmetry on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:03PM (#24758127)
Unfortunately a lot of police training in the US is about lowering inhibitions about being the first to use violence, google "warrior training" for more details.

But I think that is a very real problem in regards to the sort of late night kinetic entries that result in the deaths of so many civilians and cops. I think that SWAT teams can have their place in large metros like LA where the sort of events that called for them happen every once in a while. But in third or fourth tier cities the local government can't afford the sort of intensive training required for a job like that but also those teams are always being sent on drug raids or things like that because there just aren't any incidents that would justify the existence of the teams otherwise. But sending a SWAT team into a situation that isn't already violent is just a terrible idea and US army forces, for instance, make an effort to avoid late night raids in a way that I wish our law enforcement community would follow.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ArnoVW on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:45PM (#24756379)
Or that police departments in dangerous areas have to resort to buying more lethal equipment. Thus ending up killing more no-good dangerous criminals.

I'm more inclined to belief the first version, but it's good to keep in mind that this sort of interpretation has it's limits.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by NotSammyHagar on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:34PM (#24756963)
There is so much that is legal to own (but of course not legal to use violently). 50 caliber machine guns are legal to own, quora reports that it can take a year to get a permit. There are places you can go and fire mortars on private land. Should the police have tanks to counter these things? Because they are legally owned in the us. The answer is no, the police should not. They have shown through their actions (repeatedly during the past 6 months on top of historical actions) that they can't be trusted with weapons this powerful.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by nojokes on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:04AM (#24755089)
Or departments with more military gear are in more risky areas where the use of force is more likely.

I could not read the article because it is blocked for me.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jakelazaroff on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:39AM (#24755551)
The study controls for that variable:

> The newspaper’s analysis used the military’s database and paired it with a database of fatal police shootings from across the state, controlling for statistical variables like community income, rural-urban differences, racial makeup, and violent crime rates.

The article explicitly cautions against drawing conclusions about causality. My intuition is that there’s truth to both explanations: cosplaying as a military makes police more violent, and intrinsically violent departments are more likely to seek out military equipment.

And frankly, the second conclusion scares me more. If the causal relationship is “equipment —> violence”, we can solve it by simply banning the use of military equipment by police. If the relationship goes the other way, though, we still have to deal with violent cops who want to hurt civilians.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by regularfry on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:08PM (#24756657)
We would have to deal with violent cops who want to hurt civilians, but at least they'd have less efficient tools to do so. And maybe the violent people would be less drawn to a career in law enforcement if it wasn't associated with a militarised image.

If it's both effects at the same time, in a feedback loop, it's actually ok - you can stop the loop by cutting either effect.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by alisonkisk on Monday October 12, 2020 @08:27PM (#24761092)
When I think of the outrageous crimes committed by police, I see handguns and batons and knees, not military gear.

I suspect the tacticool gear is more about the culture and mindset (your second effect). As tech companies attract computer nerds with computer toys, LE attacks violence nerds with violence toys.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by stjohnswarts on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:51PM (#24761502)
I'm sorry a 38 caliber "old school" pistol will kill you just about as quickly as an AR15 and a shot gun with correct shells will be far more likely to end you. It's not about the style of gun, it's about who's using it and how aggressive they are.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by craftinator on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:08PM (#24756656)
Something I've long thought on is what types of people are attracted to the US police force. If you look at it economically, by what incentives are offered, it's a bit disturbing: 1) Power over others 2) Chance to stop violence 3) Little educational requirements 4) Access to cool gear 5) Immunity from law 6) Ability to help or hurt weaker people 7) Access to drugs, guns, etc...

The list goes on, but I really see two types of people drawn to these: those that seek to help, and those that seek power. The defenders, and the bullies. The saviors, and the criminals.

It's naive to expect that one type makes it through much more often than the other (the "a few bad apples" analogy). If I were in organized crime, or a gang, or a neo-nazi, or just someone who was a sociopath, what better possible job is there than being a cop? Would it be that hard to fake it through whatever screenings they use (which can be NONE in some PDs) to weed out the bad actors? No. We must expect some large minority or even a majority of cops to fall into the class of bad actors.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by leetcrew on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:55PM (#24758025)
one more thing to add to your list is that police tend to be pretty well paid for their level of education. in my area, starting salary for a police officer is not much lower than a typical salary for a junior dev. a rank-and-file cop with a few years of experience who pulls a lot of OT can make a surprising amount of money.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by anthony_romeo on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:10PM (#24755932)
> If the relationship goes the other way, though, we still have to deal with violent cops who want to hurt civilians.

If the problem is iterative, then I'd think in terms of adjusting probabilities in a Markov chain, and having the goal be to minimize instances of avoidable police violence over time. Anyway, it's not possible to eliminate violence from the police, unless we find a way to eliminate violence from human nature, so the goals should be about adjusting priorities, duties, and tone to minimize unnecessary violence.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by seretogis on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:35AM (#24755488)
"Risky areas" sounds like a dog whistle to me, much like "bad neighborhood"... When you think of these "risky areas", what do the people within them look like? Do they deserve to have militarized police literally rolling armored tank-like vehicles through their neighborhood, and what sort of impact do you think that has on them?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by nojokes on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:56PM (#24759343)
I honestly do not know about how they look like. What I meant was higher rate of crime against people and police.

But to give you an idea what might turn police force to want to have more serious weapons. Just few days ago there was a 2 hours long attack on the local police station in France. Attackers used fireworks. Police did not respond though and I do not have an idea why. Perhaps they were outnumbered and outgunned.

In such situation, where criminals do what they like, would you prefer your police force have some serious weapons or you would think that it would be an overreaction?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by alisonkisk on Monday October 12, 2020 @08:30PM (#24761115)
CNN: "Police said no one was injured and an investigation to identify the perpetrators is underway."

The police did a great job and I'm glad it didn't turn into a massacre that could have exploded into an outright civil war.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by baq on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:16AM (#24764047)
of course i'd rather the police sit and watch and maybe throw some tear gas around. why do think violence or even lethal force would work?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by WarOnPrivacy on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:54AM (#24755726)
I don't understand why this was downvoted.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ffggvv on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:45PM (#24759244)
i downvoted it because it’s not a dog whistle. people insist on seeing race everywhere. a risky area by common sense is an area with increased violence, regardless of the racial makeup. if you can’t see why somewhere with increased violence would possibly require police to have increased capabilities i’m not sure what to say. or how it’s magically a dog whistle
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by throwaway2048 on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:12PM (#24755957)
Because the down voters agree that "risky areas" aka communities full of minorities like black and hispanic people, deserve military style occupation and tactics.

If you think that's not true, ask yourself why analysis of that term is not welcome.

There is a long proud tradition of terrible anti-human bullshit being hidden behind neat euphemisms like that.

Because it sounds reasonable, and civil.

It isn't.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by malandrew on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:10PM (#24756684)
If you're using the term dog whistle to describe something, you're the dog in that situation.

That accusation is just a submarine form of kafkatrap.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by 8note on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:49PM (#24757959)
People can also hear dog whistles through technology. You don't have to be a dog to hear it, just get a microphone and a Fourier transform.

Similarly, people can figure out how to spot dog whistles without being a dog.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by matwood on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:39AM (#24755541)
> Or departments with more military gear are in more risky areas where the use of force is more likely.

Maybe. I know anecdotally where I live has very little violent crime, and the police department is fully militarized with mraps and the like.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by adwww on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:04PM (#24755847)
Plural? Like one could make sense, in a siege type situation or bank robbery in progress perhaps. The sort of event that might happen once a decade or so maybe.

But how many sieges or bank robberies are they expecting to need multiple of these?!

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by matwood on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:30PM (#24756912)
My city only has 1. I was mistaken because I saw a big police show and tell at an abandoned parking lot late last year, and saw multiples. The city next door has 2, and all the adjacent cities also have their own. Keep in mind these these cities are all basically considered the same large city. It's not like they separated by 100s of miles or anything.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by malandrew on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:13PM (#24756722)
Bank robberies used to be more common, but inflation basically took care of that

https://arstechnica.com/science/2012/06/economists-demonstra...

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ArnoVW on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:53PM (#24757236)
Thanks for the interesting link. Ars at its best. Though my interpretation of the article is more that the risk / reward ratio simply has become too poor, nothing to do with inflation.

I suppose it is easier to rob a 150k watch from an unprotected person on the street, of hold up a Chinese tourist (who often have their holiday money in cash), if you're into that sort of thing.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by throwaway0a5e on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:25PM (#24757661)
Bored police departments spend their money on toys.

Busy police departments spend their money hiring more cops so that they aren't so over worked.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ryandrake on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:15AM (#24755226)
> Or departments with more military gear are in more risky areas where the use of force is more likely.

Which, itself deserves a different study to understand whether risky areas lead to more use of force, or whether excessive use of force leads to police distrust, making areas more risky for police.

There is probably no single causal path here. Use of force, aggressive police, police's fear of the public, the public's distrust of police, militarized training, military gear, socioeconomics, race, and crime are likely interrelated in complex ways, without an easy line to draw from one to the other.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:40AM (#24755558)
> controlling for statistical variables like community income, rural-urban differences, racial makeup, and violent crime rates.

So, they must have have data on low crime areas that also have similar military gear.

On a related note, do surplus statisticians cause lying journalists?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jakelazaroff on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:37PM (#24756263)
They do:

> A newly published article by a group of scholars with the Emory University Department of Political Science found no relationship between the presence of surplus military equipment and lower crime rates.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by burner831234 on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:02PM (#24755818)
check out archive.is
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by SquishyPanda23 on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:33AM (#24755461)
> there is no need, ever, for police to have the automatic weapons, APCs, and "non-lethal" weapons they are buying from the military.

I agree with the sentiment, but my impression (based on little evidence) is that the "need" here is to create a wider market for these weapons.

It takes money to develop new weapons, and a larger customer base helps defray those costs.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:17PM (#24756025)
Under the 1033 program, police departments pay for shipment and storage of the materials they request, but they do not pay for the equipment itself. While the military may purchase more equipment then it actually needs to lower per unit price, the acquisitions as a whole are not made any cheaper and the weapons developers make no more profit. In fact, given that this material is specifically diverted from what would be sold as surplus, the military would have more money to purchase weapons with if it didn't give these supplies to police forces. It's also worth noting that, while military vehicles like MRAPs are very visible, most of the requested property is more mundane: bulk ammunition is the most requested category, followed by office supplies.

It's pretty obviously just a way for the federal government to subsidize domestic police forces with money nominally intended for the defense budget.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by iguy on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:32PM (#24756191)
And perhaps a way to turn over the army's stockpile & keep its suppliers in business.

Quite a bit of the defense budget seems to have this goal, and it's not crazy -- if you skip a generation of tanks/planes/ships because your old ones are OK, the experience to build the next generation will have to be re-grown from scratch.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:44PM (#24756360)
Again though, selling the old equipment as surplus or just scrapping it achieves the same goal but also brings in some money.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by iguy on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:06PM (#24757434)
Sure, but maybe this has better PR than scrapping stuff. Or having it show up in Isis videos.

Mostly I don't think it's clear that "subsidize domestic police forces" need be the main goal.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:36PM (#24757826)
The simplest explanation that adequately explains the observation tends to be correct. There's really no need for any conspiracy here, support for "law and order" has been a winning political strategy for decades. Meanwhile, getting the department of defense to increase the number of MRAPs they order by a fraction of a percent seems like it could be achieved in other, easier ways. It's good to be skeptical, but at some point you need evidence.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by iguy on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:50PM (#24758689)
Conspiracy is quite a strong word!

My take on the neutral explanation would be is to assume that it's like every other policy -- about a dozen people with varying motivations had to support it, and then a few more motivations got added by PR people, and by whoever doesn't want it to stop. Policies "pretty obviously" driven by exactly one factor are extremely unusual.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:10PM (#24759488)
You are talking about a group of powerful politicians crafting legislation with a secret ulterior motive to transfer money to an unknown entity or entities in the military industrial complex. That's a pretty textbook conspiracy.

If you dig into the line items I'm sure there will be some compromises to get the maximum number of votes, but that's a far cry from an elaborate scheme to line the pockets of the military industrial complex.

It's not hard to imagine this bill passing on its own merits without heavy lobbying. No one in the 90s was going to want to be painted as anti-cop, pro-drug, pro-terrorist, and/or pro-government waste. Even if we now see the terrible consequences of police militarization, and many still don't, that's hindsight. At the height of the war on drugs, as children who grew up hearing about serial killers in the 70s were now worrying about their own young kids, taking the weapons that had been lying in warehouses since Nam and putting them to good use protecting the streets here at home had wide bipartisan support. It costs very little, makes people feel safe, and makes a lot of politicians look good.

Again it is good to question the official narrative, but your hypothesis needs to be falsifiable. You will always be able to go a layer deeper and say "oh well they did it this way to make it harder to see their real motive" but without evidence there is no reason to continue going down that rabbit hole.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by iguy on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:31PM (#24759657)
You're mis-reading me. Nowhere have I proposed any well-thought-out secret scheme. I'm pushing back against a story that says there's one precise purpose to this, which I thought was your claim above: "pretty obviously just a way for the federal government to subsidize domestic police forces".

I suggested one other motivation some people might have felt, of keeping the hardware moving. You've suggested some more, too, now, like looking tough on TV. Maybe that means we agree.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by monocasa on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:56PM (#24758759)
Don't they have to take over the fairly lucrative maintenance contracts as well?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jjk166 on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:15PM (#24759523)
Most 1033 materials are simple things like ammunition and office supplies, which wouldn't have any maintenance contracts. I'm sure if a police department got an APC they'd want it to be maintained, and I highly doubt you can just take an APC down to the local mechanic, but to my knowledge there's nothing in the 1033 program that forces them to continue a maintenance contract.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by jmcqk6 on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:36AM (#24755503)
Maybe those weapons should cost more instead.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ptero on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:04PM (#24755841)
I agree with your first part that there is not necessarily a causal relationship between military equipment and killings.

But your "no need, ever, for police to have automatic weapons" part is, to me, just wrong. In general, police should have enough kit to easily overpower the criminals they expect to face. We have been fortunate in many areas (e.g., most of the US, Europe and practically all urban areas) for the police to not need automatic weaponry. But this is not universal. In other parts of the world police may face a much better equipped adversaries and automatic weapons.

We should strive to make the world safer so the strongest weapon the police on the street has is a book for writing fines, but until we are there we should equip law enforcement to overcome threats they expect to face. My 2c.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by baron_harkonnen on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:32PM (#24756187)
The problem with your logic here is it makes the line between police and the military incredibly blurry to the point where police become just another type of military personnel.

Maybe if you have criminal activity at the level of needing automatic weapons, then you need military intervention and not police.

As many ex-military have pointed out in various forums, even in war situations rules of engagement for soldiers are very clear and strict, which is not true of most police. Soldiers are trained to deal with situations where lethal force and high power weaponry are assumed standard.

Police, if they are really to protect and serve, and act as part of the community should be dealing with an entirely different set of tools and skills. A solider and a police officer should be completely different roles. The former should be an expert in using state sanctioned violence to deal with high level threats to public safety and the latter should be a member of the community with the ability to resolve local conflicts and enforce standards agreed upon by that community.

You can't reasonably mix these two responsibilities and expect good results.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Balgair on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:33PM (#24756943)
> The problem with your logic here is it makes the line between police and the military incredibly blurry to the point where police become just another type of military personnel.

Many other countries have Gendarmerie forces that bridge this gap in various ways. The most famous being the RCMP. Other countries mix these responsibilities with varying success, but they do it intentionally. Some have found good success with it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gendarmerie

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by cultus on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:10PM (#24758230)
The RCMP isn't a great example for why militarized police are a good idea.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_controversies_involvin...

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by freeone3000 on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:47PM (#24759274)
RCMP are regular police everywhere but Ontario and Quebec. RCMP are closer in remit to the US Marshals, but also have the investigatory powers of the FBI. "Gendamarie" isn't inaccurate, but they're not militarized any greater or lesser than the SPVM.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by ptero on Monday October 12, 2020 @08:58PM (#24761251)
To me, the military should not be a part of any law enforcement for the citizens. In practical terms, "never" is too harsh, but the bar should be very high. When military gets involved in local matters there is a risk that it takes power and holds it for a long time. Sometimes a military junta might be the least bad option, but this is not a path the country should risk taking lightly.

There were plenty of countries where gangs possessed and used automatic weapons, from Scandinavia to Germany, from Brazil to former Soviet Union. And that is not even touching Africa. A gang with machine guns is not a reason to ask military to take over law enforcement. My 2c.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by baq on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:29AM (#24764107)
what's the difference between military and police if both look the same and use the same weapons? what's stopping a rebel police chief from taking power in that case instead of some rebel general?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by mixedCase on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:42PM (#24757081)
How does "protect and serve" not include removing dangerous, violent criminals from society?. To do so you need efficient weaponry and tactics that differ from conventional warfare. Does every police officer need to be equipped with such firepower? No, but police forces around the world facing these threats tend to have an intermediate (or more) group for dealing with threats that fall between petty thievery and terrorist organizations/nation-state level actors.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by watwut on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:47PM (#24757162)
Are you taking about actual real need in cities or a fantasy? It sounds flippant, but other counties don't need such ammo.

The murder clearance rates are low, corruption seem to be persistent problem and actual police work does not actually seem to involve attacking actual super armed gangs.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by mixedCase on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:27PM (#24757704)
Of course I'm talking about an actual real need in cities, it's bewildering to me someone can't even see it as obvious.

What country do you live in where there's no need for SWAT-like teams or a straight-up Gendarmerie?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by watwut on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @02:24AM (#24762822)
SWAT-like teams are used rarely and they don't buy used arms from military. They are few in numbers.

The issue with catching organized criminality is in investigation and dealing with corruption - including police corruption. The whole need to shoot out with them thing does not happen unless the local police is spectacularly bad.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by mijamo on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:12PM (#24755956)
What parts of the world are you referring to? In general if you have people with automatic weapons attacking the police, you are basically in a civil war and the army takes over. The police is supposed to be a numerous local presence, not a fighting force.

When police has been equipped with automatic weapons, things usually end badly, particularly in those other parts of the world where police pay is nothing and alternative sources of revenue are very tempting when you are armed like a soldier. Having a corrupt cop is a thing, but a corrupt military armed cop is even worse.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by atoav on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:13PM (#24756720)
Yeah I agree that specialized police forces (e.g. those who are called when people are taken hostage) need modern weapons that can counter the weapons of criminals.

But when I say specialized I mean specialized. That means special training, special deployments, special oversight.

That is how it is done in most civilised nations and it works very well. Regular cops rarely even need their handarm in most western nations. The whole German police force fires roughly 35 bullets at people in an average year, with an average of 8 deadly ones. There are cops in the US who shoot more bullets at people in a week than the entire police force of a nation with 80 million people in an entire year.

This so obviously due to bad (and too short) training, a misguided police culture (rather than neutral enforcers many US cops seem to think they are the law) and of course a lack of hard consequences for the "bad apples".

Of course it has to do with weapons in general, but the Austrian village I grew up in has a Glock factory in it, every second family has rifles in their locked rifle cabinets etc — yet Austria and other Nations with a lot of guns (Canada, Finland) don't have comparable problems.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by btilly on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:13PM (#24756718)
My brother, who spend most of his life in the Marines, explained the difference between the military and the police to me many years ago.

The job of the military is to accomplish a set mission by any means necessary, including force. The job of the police is to ensure that law and order are kept. If you send the police to do the job of the military, the result will be dead police and and unaccomplished missions. If you send the military to do the job of the police the result will be dead civilians, and eventually civil disorder.

We have a lot of police who have forgotten this. And the results are obvious.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by UncleEntity on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:49PM (#24758680)
Case in point: when they sent the 82nd Airborne down to Haiti for peacekeeping things didn't go as well as they had hoped.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by baq on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:42PM (#24756337)
1. you're advocating providing people with milspec weaponry but without milspec training. there's a saying - with great power comes great responsibility - which seems to be forgotten about in some police departments.

2. you don't want to engage in an arms race with criminals.

3. law enforcement shouldn't be confused with urban warfare.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Munksgaard on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:11PM (#24755947)
I don't know of any developed country where the police can reasonably expect to face better equipped adversaries than they can in the US. This is interesting for two reasons: You may have a point that it is necessary in the US for the police to have automatic weapons, but the US is also the only western country that has put itself in such a situation. Take from that what you will...
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by leetcrew on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:15PM (#24756741)
"automatic weapons" is sort of a red herring. even in the military (US military at least), rifles are usually used in semi-auto mode. AFAIK, the main exception would be suppressive fire on a position, which is probably not an appropriate tactic for police in a residential area.

even in the US, you are much more likely to encounter criminals armed with pistols than rifles. it's a much more appropriate platform for the use case.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by withinboredom on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:34PM (#24756961)
That’s because with a m4, your job isn’t to push random rounds down range. Your job is to actually hit what you’re aiming at. Even with covering or suppressive fire, you’re not randomly shooting down range and your shots are calculated to keep whomever your shooting at either dead or where they are so they can be flanked. You might have some full automatic weapons in your team, but they can’t hit anything so they just lay down suppressive fire. Point is, you can’t hit what you’re aiming at in full auto.

Source: ex-military

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by mineirobr on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:44PM (#24756368)
There are plenty of places. Mexico for example where the narcos have capabilities similar to the mexican military and In brazil we have little kids with automatic rifles roaming the favelas.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by yeetawayhn on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:13PM (#24756704)
You missed the "developed countries" dogwhistle, which usually means rich and white nations.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by freeone3000 on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:52PM (#24759319)
It specifically does mean rich, but includes China and Japan and South Korea, which are not white. The description of economic development was specifically to exclude race and political affiliation from the equation while still capturing the relevant metrics -- poverty causes violent crime.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by throwaway0a5e on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:18PM (#24757572)
"Europe, but only the parts I like"
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by leetcrew on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:17PM (#24756770)
is there a better way of describing the group of countries where it is unlikely to encounter criminals with lmgs mounted to pickup trucks?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by throwaway0a5e on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:20PM (#24757595)
"first and second world" does a pretty good job covering it since there's plenty of nations that are formerly in the USSR's sphere of influence that aren't exactly rich but don't have to worry about cartel type violence.

Pretty much nobody likes to think that way though because the majority of the time "developed nations" are brought up it's in the context of how the US should be more like western Europe and it's usually ideologically convenient to leave Eastern Europe out of those kinds of comparisons.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by leetcrew on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:41PM (#24757867)
"first and second world" describes more or less the same set of countries (perhaps modulo some eastern european countries like you said), but doesn't it have most of the same baggage as "developed nations"? as I understand it, the problem with "developed nations" is that it raises the question "developed compared to what?". in other words, it implicitly sets the west as the standard against which "developed" is measured. doesn't first/second/third world center the western perspective in pretty much the same way?
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by yeetawayhn on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:35PM (#24756984)
>is there a better way of describing the group of countries where it is unlikely to encounter criminals with lmgs mounted to pickup trucks?

The dogwhistle has now turned into a full on bullhorn.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by luckylion on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:17PM (#24756774)
Denmark and Sweden have increasing problems with drugs gangs using hand grenades, and they've had a lot of experience with the motorbike club gangs in the eighties and nineties, who raided army barracks for military weapons and waged war.

Should they use the military to patrol the streets?

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by 8note on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:54PM (#24758013)
I disagree; there's some range the police should be equipped to handle. When the danger escalates out of that range, they should step back and have a better equipped group step in like the national guard
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by throwaway0a5e on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:10PM (#24757481)
>If they are facing an opponent like that then call in the FBI, who generally have much better training, or ATF (no idea about their training).

The FBI doesn't answer the phone when the ATF calls anymore. They learned that lesson the hard way.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by malandrew on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:08PM (#24756649)
It may also be that the police departments that seek to purchase military equipment operate in cities/neighborhoods with a higher incident of violent crime.

Los Angeles PD for example was the poster boy for getting military style gear before most departments in the country, but at the time it also dealt with more serious violence than most police departments (such as drive-by shootings).

The per capita incidence of police shootings in the US compared to other developed nations seems high until you normalize it by the per capita rate of violent crimes committed by citizens.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tathougies on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:43PM (#24756348)
> If they are facing an opponent like that then call in the FBI, who generally have much better training, or ATF (no idea about their training).

Except those agencies aren't responsible for everday law enforcement, and some police departments are essentially fighting a war. For example, when I was a kid growing up in LA in the 90s, the gangs there were basically like warlords. Even recently, you can find examples of execution style gang murders in Los Angeles, and shootouts on the streets.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by me_me_me on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:03PM (#24755823)
I would guess that apart from 'super gear' making people feel more confident, it also would draw in even more people with power issues into police ranks.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by throwawaysea on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:31PM (#24756171)
There is no statistical evidence supporting the claims implied by this article or even the reversed claim that 'more aggressive' departments are seeking out military equipment.

> Regardless, there is no need, ever, for police to have the automatic weapons, APCs, and "non-lethal" weapons they are buying from the military. If they are facing an opponent like that then call in the FBI, who generally have much better training, or ATF (no idea about their training).

I disagree with this. The police should have automatic weapons so they are able to overpower criminals and protect themselves in dangerous situations. I want my police department to be effective and safe. It is also important that they have non-lethal equipment to de-escalate situations safely when possible.

As for APCs - if it is available as a surplus piece of equipment, why shouldn't they have it? It isn't something they use everyday. There aren't police departments using heavy gas guzzling APCs for daily patrol. They use it for rare situations like riots and shootouts.

Your statement about the FBI and ATF doesn't make sense to me and makes me think you aren't aware of what those agencies actually do.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by lmilcin on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:44AM (#24755601)
It might also be because military equipment is statistically more likely to be acquired by departments in more dangerous environments.

Though I still feel the explanation is a positive feedback, where being more aggressive causes more aggressive behavior to normalize faster, causing more aggressive equipment, causing police to feel more like an occupation force rather than civil servants, causing more aggresive behavior, and so on.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by giantg2 on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:58PM (#24757310)
ATF has a terrible track record with this type of stuff (and other things too).
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by SN76477 on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:50PM (#24757976)
When you train warriors, they start looking for a war.

We need to change the mindset that police are fighting everyday. They should be community servants that aid in settling disputes.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by stjohnswarts on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:49PM (#24761492)
This makes a lot more logical sense. The already had pistols and shotguns aplenty to shoot people, adding some armored carriers, camo, and some AR15s isn't going to really add much to that capability. I find your proposal a lot more likely, the police departments that get this stuff are much more aggressive and see it more as a War on Crime, rather than to Protect and to Serve.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by tehjoker on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:06PM (#24757429)
If the reverse is true, you are positing that American society, the most wealthy society in the history of Earth, is so dangerous that we need jackboots and APCs in the streets. I don't buy it for a second. I think cops should be unarmed, and if they are armed, they should at least pretend to be as brave as their propaganda portrays them as and resist shooting people even if it puts them in danger.

EDIT: To be even more clear, when you are not literally in a state of existential civil war, deploying militarized police is a political judgement not an evidence based one. It is a tool of para-military force used against the less powerful by the more powerful. I would argue that paramilitaries are never appropriate in civil society, even in a state of war.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Enginerrrd on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:28PM (#24756131)
FBI yes. ATF no. They're reputation is horrendous.
Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by diob on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:53PM (#24759325)
I think these statistics tell us everything we need to know: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_killings_by_law_enforc...

The right to a fair trial in the USA has been utterly destroyed by police who seek to be judge, jury, and executioner.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by Shivetya on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:16PM (#24757544)
Oh I want to give them the benefit of doubt but metropolitan Atlanta's Doraville Police department made headlines a decade ago with their tank video.

Frankly, as a Libertarian, I see zero reason that any police department have at its disposal any equipment the military has used or discarded that can lead to physical harm. This includes no vehicle that is not street legal; and no making exceptions to grant them legality does not count. As for automatic weapons, they should require a court order to unseal usage of if not by a committee which must be alerted to any request to use them.

If there is an excuse for heavy weapons or such, call in the national guard or local military to assist. The police still do not need this hardware.

Oh, the video is cringe heaven

https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2014/sep/30/help-crow...

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by squarefoot on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:04PM (#24759422)
"We should be careful to draw a causal relationship here. It might not be that getting the military equipment causes police to be more aggressive and therefore have more killings."

True. Still, when the only tool you have is a hammer, soon or later every problem will look like a nail.

Re:Police killings more likely in agencies that get military... by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:36PM (#24757002)
Its all fine to imagine the police are operating in a vacuum, where they can wait days for the FBI to respond when they encounter an emergency call with somebody with an automatic weapon.

Sure, they shouldn't have to have that kind of weaponry. But neither should they encounter them on the street. Are the police are some sort of ablative shield, that can be sacrificed to a political ideal?